All Episodes

Amy Mihaljevic- Part 4, 30-Year Rewind

Amy Mihaljevic Part 3- 30 Year Rewind

Amy Mihaljevic 2: 30-year rewind

Amy Mihaljevic - 30 Year Rewind

Judy Martins with Nic from True Crime Garage

Evelyn Colon 1976

Sarah Pryor & Cathy Malcolmson

35th Anniversary of the Kirtland Cult Killings

Ted Bundy and Colorado's Unsolved Murders

Yogurt Shop 4 w/ Nic from TCG Pt 2

Breaking: Yogurt Shop Four w/ Nic of TCG Pt 1

Closure or Cowardice? The Fallout from Koberger's Plea Deal

Leah Ulbrich

Exclusive: CATCH LISK and Jesse Pollack

Kelly Ann Prosser

Gilgo Four Update: Peaches & Baby Doe

The Gilgo Four: A Deep Dive into Shannan Gilbert's Case Pt 2

The Gilgo Four: A Deep Dive into Shannan Gilbert's Case

Matt Mangino on the latest in the Idaho 4 & fingerprint analysis

Las Cruces Bowling Massacre

Brad Bellino: With Nic Edwards & Carolyn Beradino

Beth Bramlett

Charles Cullen: The Angel of Death

The Tylenol Murders

Nancy Grace

Richie "Dickie" Palmer

Louisiana's No Man's Land: An interview with author Scott DeBose

The Pike County Massacre Conclusion

The Pike County Massacre

Johnny Gosch

Unveiling the Process: Research and Storytelling in True Crime

17-Year-Old Maggie Long

Frank E. Thurber & Under-Sheriff Neil Marshall Pt 2

Grand Theft Auto: Inside the NYPD's Auto Crime Division with Vic Ferrari

Haunted San Pedro: An interview with author Brian Clune

WK Rewind: Nic from TCG on Molly Bish

Helene Pruszynski

Haunted Staten Island: An interview with author Marianna Biazzo Randazzo Pt 2

Frank E. Thurber & Under-Sheriff Neil Marshall

WK Rewind: Kelsi German Pt 1

WK Rewind: Kelsi German & Nic Edwards Pt 3

WK Rewind: Kelsi German Pt 2

The Trash Bag Killer – Patrick Kearney

Haunted Staten Island: An interview with author Marianna Biazzo Randazzo

Delphi Trial Update

Delphi & Kathy Halle Cold Case

Bruce Lindhall linked to another victim

The Scott Mausoleum: A Tale of Crime, Intrigue, and Investigation Pt 2

Amy Mihaljevic: New Evidence with Nic of True Crime Garage

Mary Davis: Presser of the Week

The Scott Mausoleum: A Tale of Crime, Intrigue, and Investigation Pt 1

Unraveling the Cold Case: The Lori Neeson Murder and Its Shocking Breakthrough

Sarah Ferris on True Crime and Advocacy

Bob Crane Follow-Up

WK Rewind: Israel Keyes with True Crime XS

Michael Furlong: An interview with Peter Hogan and Scott Rogan

Idaho 4 Update: Change of Venue and Legal Implications

Presser of the Week: Melissa Wolfenbarger

Sarah Ferris talks about Watching Two Detectives

Alicia Markovich: Missing 37 years

John Wayne Gacy 1

John Wayne Gacy 2

Murder & Mayhem in Southeast Kansas: An interview with author Larry Wood Pt 2

Murder & Mayhem in Southeast Kansas: An interview with author Larry Wood Pt 1

Bob Crane: Murder in Hollywood

Honey & Barry Sherman

Sherri Lynn Swalley

Molly Bish

Nancy Eagleson w/ Nic of TCG Pt 2

Nancy Eagleson w/ Nic of TCG Pt 1

Murder in Stark County, Ohio: An Interview with author Kim Kenney Pt 1

Southern Crime Stories and the Dixie Mafia: A Deep Dive with Benjamin Morris

Vacation Rewind 1: Amy Mihaljevic Suspects

The Good Hart Murders: A Northern Michigan Cold Case

Shenandoah, Colonial Parkway and RR Murders with Nic of TCG

LISK, Ethics & True Crime with Jesse Pollack Pt 2

LISK, Ethics & True Crime with Jesse Pollack

WK Rewind: The Shenandoah Murders with author Kathryn Miles

Presser of the Week: GILGO Beach MAJOR UPDATE

New Bedford Highway Killer

The women of New Bedford, Mass. Part 2 w/ Author Maureen Boyle

CrimeCon Rewind: The Captain of True Crime Garage on Madeleine Mccann

CrimeCon Rewind: The Lewis-Clark Valley Murders with Victimology

CrimeCon Rewind: With Justin of Generation Why

CrimeCon Rewind: Maura Murray with Crawlspace

Tony Muncy Rewind w/ Nic of True Crime Garage

Josh Harmon Press Conference

Josh Harmon

Madeline Soto UPDATE

The Missing Paper Boys

PC: Veronica Butler & Jilian Kelley Murders

OJ & The Idaho 4 with attorney Matt Mangino

Delphi with attorney Matt Mangino

Michelle Martinko: December 19, 1979

Riley Strain Press Conference: UPDATE

The Lake Waco Murders: A Twisted Tragedy Unraveled Pt. 2

The Lake Waco Murders: A Twisted Tragedy Unraveled

Riley Strain Press Conference

UPDATE: 1974 murders of 16-year-old Donald Bartron and 18-year-old Peter Zito, Jr.

Presser of the Week: Portland Cold Case Unit, The Wheatley's

An interview with author Benjamin Morris about his show Crime Capsule

Tammy Zywicki

Angela Hicks

Presser of the Week: New Mexico Cold Case Unit

Ricky Kasso w/ author Jesse P. Pollack Pt. 2

Presser of the Week: Audrii Cunningham

Ricky Kasso w/ author Jesse P. Pollack

Yogurt Shop 4 w/ Nic from True Crime Garage Pt 3

The Yogurt Shop 4 Pt. 1

Yogurt Shop 4 w/ Nic of True Crime Garage Pt 2

NEW: Bill Thomas on Colonial Parkway Murders Update Pt 2

NEW: Bill Thomas on Colonial Parkway Murders Update

Virginia State Police PC: Colonial Parkway Murders Update

Colonial Parkway Murders w/ Bill Thomas & Nic of True Crime Garage 2019 Pt 2

Colonial Parkway Murders Part 4 w/ Bill Thomas & Nic Edwards

Colonial Parkway Murders: Bill Thomas 2022

Colonial Parkway Murders Part 3 w/ Bill Thomas

Colonial Parkway Murders Part 2 w/ Bill Thomas

Colonial Parkway Murders Part 1 w/ Bill Thomas

Savannah Soto & Matthew Guerra

Holiday Spree Killing

Angela Hammond

The Sodder Family Christmas Mystery

THROWBACK: JonBenet w/ The Captain of True Crime Garage Part 2

THROWBACK: JonBenet w/ the Captain of True Crime Garage Part 1

JonBenet Ramsey: The LATEST w/ Nic from True Crime Garage

Austin Spree Shooting: Presser of the Week

LISK w/ author Jesse P. Pollack Part 2

LISK w/ author Jesse P. Pollack Part 1

Yvonne Leroux Cold Case - York Regional Police

Sarah Pryor: 1985

Amy Mihaljevic & Chief Spaetzel

Amy Mihaljevic: True Crime Garage, Off the Record

Amy Mihaljevic

Vickie Lynn Belk: SOLVED

Ivan Milat- The Murderer from Down Under

Serial Killer: Bruce Everitt Lindahl

Presser of the Week: 6-Year-Old Noel Rodriguez Alvarez

NEW UPDATE: Delphi & Idaho 4 w/ Matt Mangino

Presser of the Week: Maine Police Dodge Questions About Missed Red Flags

Amy Mihaljevic 34 years unsolved w/ Nic & The Captain Pt 2

Amy Mihaljevic 34 years unsolved w/ Nic & The Captain Pt 1

Presser of the Week: Maine Mass Shooting

Holly Piiranien: 30 Years Unsolved...

Stranger Danger Cases

Presser of the Week: Natalee Holloway SOLVED

Presser of the Week: Gilgo Beach Murders UPDATE

Presser of the Week: Krista Martin Cold Case SOLVED

Brianna Maitland: An Interview w/ She Goes By Jane Co-Host Aimee Baker

The Bible Belt Strangler

Presser of the Week: Charlotte Sena, FOUND SAFE!

Andy Puopolo: An Interview with award winning author Jan Brogan Pt. 2

Andy Puopolo: An Interview with award winning author Jan Brogan Pt. 1

Presser of the Week: Debbie Lynn Randall Solved

The Evangelist Family

Marilyn Sheppard Press Coverage & F. Lee Bailey Interview

Marilyn Sheppard w/ Nic of TCG

Marilyn Sheppard, July 4, 1954

Who knew the KKK once ran Denver?

Presser of the Week: 16-year-old Stephen Lee Rodda

Presser of the Week: Taigur Taguri

Presser of the week: Jacksonville Race Murders

Ax Murders? More prevalent than you thought

Presser of the Week: Latin Kings Gang Member Killed in Shootout

Mary & Bill: An Ohio Cold Case, interview with host Justin Glanville

Cynthia Anderson: An interview with Naptime Nancy Drew

Nic From TCG & the Gilgo Beach Four Pt. 2

Nic From TCG & the Gilgo Beach Four

Gilgo Beach Latest & Maggie Freleng Part 2

Throwback: Maggie Freleng on Gilgo Beach Murders

Gilgo Beach Serial Killer: UPDATE

Alissa Turney Pt 3

Alissa Turney Pt 2

Delphi Court Docs Unsealed

Alissa Turney Pt 1

The Dixie Mafia

15-year-old Patty Desmond with author Maureen Boyle

Janette Roberson

Paige Renkoski

Presser of the Week: Alex Murdaugh & Gloria Satterfield

Lauria Bible and Ashley Freeman with Nic from True Crime Garage

Just Another Crazy Week in America

Encore Episode: Kristy Gibbons, 6/3/79- 5/1/23

Pt 1 Alexa Bartell. & Pt 2 Joe Michael Ervin

Marilee Burt

Brown's Chicken Massacre: Conclusion

Brown's Chicken Massacre Pt 2

Brown's Chicken Massacre

Robin Warder of the Trail Went Cold & the Furniture Store Murders

The Las Cruces Bowling Massacre

Stephen Smith & The Murdaugh Connection

Alfred Packer: America's First Hannibal the Cannibal?

Rita Shuler & the Murdaugh Murders

Alex Murdaugh GUILTY!!!

Jonelle Matthews: Solved!

The Cleveland State Murders

The Cleveland Torso Killings

The Kirtland Cult Killings: Part 1 & 2

Joseph Paul Franklin- America's Racist Serial Killer

An Interview with Carol Costello about her new podcast, Blind Rage

The Idaho Four w/ Nic Edwards of True Crime Garage

The Idaho 4 Latest with Attorney Matt Mangino

The Sodder Family Christmas Mystery

Eastbound Strangler Conclusion... for now

Jay Orbin w/ Author Kerrie Droban *BRAND NEW *

Eastbound Strangler 3 with Nic of TCG

Eastbound Strangler 2 with Nic of TCG

Eastbound Strangler

University of Idaho Murder's Remains Unsolved

The Golden State Killer With Mike Morford

University of Idaho Murder's Press Conference

UPDATE: Cory Barron's Death Now Ruled a Homicide

James Carroll: An Interview with Author David Domine

Conclusion of Unsealed: The Tylenol Murders w/ Hosts Christy Gutowski & Stacy St. Clair

Delphi Murder Arrest, ISP Update Press Conference 10/31/2022

An Interview with the Hosts of Unsealed: The Tylenol Murders

Lisa Leckie

Ross Ulbricht & The Silk Road: With Justin of Generation Why

EPISODE 200! Nancy Eagleson with Nic of True Crime Garage Pt. 2

Nancy Eagleson with Nic of True Crime Garage

The Sherri Papini Hoax

The Connecticut River Valley Killer with Survivor Jane Boroski

Serial Killer: Israel Keyes

ENCORE: Interview with Maureen Boyle, Author of The Ghost

Did Ottis Toole Kill Sylvia Quayle?

Interview with True Crime Queen Nancy Grace

Honey & Barry Sherman w/ Nic of TCG

Molly Bish w/ Nic of TCG

Larry DeWayne Hall & Black Bird

Johnny Gosch w/ True Crime IRL Host Kelli Brink

The 11 Women of New Bedford Mass.

Conclusion of Colonial Parkway Murders (NEW)

Bill Thomas Colonial Parkway Murders

Bill Thomas is BACK!

Colonial Parkway Murders: Pt 2

Colonial Parkway Murders: Cathy Thomas

Interview w/ Author Kathryn Miles of Trailed

Bombings on US Soil

Delphi Update & Patrick Kearney

Interview with Former D.A. Matt Mangino

Madeleine McCann & Girl Scout Murder Updates

Flashback, Amy Mihaljevic

Kidnapping & Murder of Adolph Coors III

Long Island Serial Killer w/ Maggie Freleng Part 2

Long Island Serial Killer w/ Maggie Freleng

John Wayne Gacy w/ Nic from True Crime Garage Part 2

John Wayne Gacy w/ Nic from True Crime Garage

Jeffrey Dahmer Part 2

Jeffrey Dahmer

Maura Murray: With Tim & Lance of Crawlspace

Stella Nickell & The Seattle Excedrin Murders

Chicago Tylenol Murders: Still UNSOLVED!

Wall Street Bombing of 1920

Corey Barron

Melanie "Suzy" Cooley & Ted Bundy?

Top 10 Cases I want Solved in 2022

Alicia Markovich: Missing 34 Years

Marshall/Boulder County Fire: Too Close for Comfort

JonBenet Ramsey: With Special Guest, The Captain of True Crime Garage (2/2)

JonBenet Ramsey: With Special Guest, The Captain of True Crime Garage

Dayton's Christmas Spree Killing- 1992

Delphi Murder Update: With Nic from True Crime Garage

Barry Seal and the Iran Contra Scandal

Interview w/ Crime Capsule host Benjamin Morris: "Those crazy southerners..."

The Kirtland Cult Killings: Part II

The Kirtland Cult Killings

Judy Martins: The Conclusion w/ Nic from True Crime Garage

Judy Martins is Missing; w/ Nic from True Crime Garage

Michelle Martinko: SOLVED!

Beth Bramlett, SOLVED!

Beth Doe... a Four Decade Mystery

Hope Remains for Amy Mihaljevic

Jonelle Matthews

Must Read Crime Books 2 of 2

My Favorite Crime Books

Bob Crane- A Hollywood Murder Mystery

Helene Pruszynski - SOLVED!

Joshua Harmon- SOLVED!

Lori Nesson- SOLVED w/ Nic from TCG

Julie Ann Hanson - SOLVED

Familial DNA: The Ultimate Crime Fighter

Are Eugene Martin & Johnny Gosch Still Missing?

Police Chief Mark Spaetzel & the Amy Mihaljevic Case

Pamela Maurer & Bruce Lindahl

Missing in Ohio: Kids of the early 80s

Tony Muncy UPDATE w/ Nic from True Crime Garage

Angel of Death

Molly Bish: UPDATE

Pike Co. Massacre Arrests

Pike County Massacre Part 2 w/ Nic from TCG

Pike County Massacre Part 1 w/ Nic from True Crime Garage

Police Chief Gregory Adams w/ Guest Author Maureen Boyle

Leah Ulbrich, 1994

The St. Aubin Street Massacre

Angela Hicks, 1990

Tammy Zywicki, August 23, 1992

Cynthia Anderson Missing since 1981 with Naptime Nancy Drew

Author Maureen Boyle on The Women of New Bedford, Mass.

New Bedford Highway Killer

Eastbound Strangler Part 4

Eastbound Strangler Part 3

Eastbound Strangler Part 2 w/ Nic

Eastbound Strangler

Delphi Anniversary

Amy Mihaljevic Update

Amy Mihaljevic Anniversary w/ Nic from True Crime Garage

Amy Mihaljevic - Chief Mark Spaetzel Part 2

Amy Mihaljevic - Chief Mark Spaetzel

Marilyn Sheppard Part 2, w/ Nic of True Crime Garage

Marilyn Reese Sheppard

Amy Mihaljevic-30 year part 1 - REDUX

The Sodder Family Christmas Fire

With Former NYPD Detective & Author Vic Ferrari

Angela Hammond

Billionaire's Barry & Honey Sherman? Part 2 w/ Nic

BONUS: Honey & Barry Sherman Press Conferences

Billionaire's Barry & Honey Sherman w/ Nic from True Crime Garage

Amy Mihaljevic- The Suspects w/ James Renner

The Redhead Murders

Amy Mihaljevic- Part 4 - Redux

Who Killed Amy Mihaljevic? Part 2 W/ True Crime Garage

Who Killed Amy Mihaljevic? Brand New W/ True Crime Garage

Who Killed Amy Mihaljevic? The Body; Redux

Who Killed Amy Mihaljevic? The Search; Redux

Who Killed Sherri Lynn Swalley? w/ guest Naptime Nancy Drew

Who Killed Libby & Abby? W/ Kelsi German & Nic from True Crime Garage

Who Killed Libby & Abby in Delphi? w/ Sister Kelsi German PT 3

Who Killed Libby & Abby in Delphi? w/ Sister Kelsi German PT 2

Who Killed Libby German & Abby in Delphi? w/ sister Kelsi German PT 1

Who Killed Christine Deifenbach? PSA

Who Killed Christine Diefenbach? w/ Attorney Michelle Kaszuba

Who Killed Lisa Leckie? w/ True Crime Files

Ivan Milat aka The Backpack Killer

Evidence Locker joins me to discuss Ivan Milat aka The Backpack Killer

Alissa Turney Part 4: with guest Sarah Turney

Alissa Turney Part 3: with guest Sarah Turney

Alissa Turney Part 2: with guest Sarah Turney

Brown's Chicken Massacre: The Conclusion

Who or What Killed Jaryd Atadero?

Palatine Massacre AKA Brown's Chicken Murders

The Lewis Clark Valley Serial Killer

Tony Muncy UPDATE with Nic from True Crime Garage

Sponsored Guest: True Crime XS & Israel Keyes

James Renner: Who was Joseph Newton Chandler?

Who Killed Janette Roberson?

Who Killed Paige Renkoski?

Robin Warder & The Furniture Store Murders

Wondery Introduces Joe Exotic: Tiger King

Mike Morford & The Golden State Killer

My Passion Case: The Captain- True Crime Garage -Madeleine McCann

The Lake Waco Murders Part 1

Wondery Introduces: The Dating Game Killer

My Passion Case: Maggie Freleng- The Long Island Serial Killer Part 2

Who Killed the Yogurt Shop 4? The Conclusion for Now...

Who Killed the Yogurt Shop 4? Pt. 3 W/ Nic from True Crime Garage

Who Killed the Yogurt Shop 4? Pt. 2 W/ Nic from True Crime Garage

Wondery Introduces Dying for Sex

Trailer- Episode 5 of The Captain's My Passion Case

Who Killed the Yogurt Shop 4?

Trailer: My Passion Case- Episode 4 with Mike Morford of Criminology

Who Killed the women of New Bedford, Mass.? Part 2 w/ Maureen Boyle

Who Killed the Women of New Bedford, Mass.?

My Passion Case: Maggie Freleng- The Long Island Serial Killer

Wondery Introduces The Sneak

My Passion Case: Justin Generation Why

Slo Burn Media Introduces My Passion Case

Who Killed the Atlantic City 4? Part 4

Who Killed the Atlantic City 4? Part 3

Wondery Introduces Blood Ties

Who Killed the Atlantic City 4? Part 2

Who Killed the Atlantic City 4?

Wondery Introduces Detective Trapp

NEW Interview with Amy's father, Mark Mihaljevic

Who Killed Amy Mihaljevic? PART 6 of 6, NEW Amy 30 Year Interview with Nic from @TrueCrimeGarage

Who Killed Amy Mihaljevic? PART 5 of 6, NEW Interview with Nic from True Crime Garage

Who Killed Amy Mihaljevic? PART 4 of 6, 30 Year Anniversary- Tracy Carloss Interview, News 5 Anchor

Wondery Introduces Bad Batch Trailer

Who Killed Amy Mihaljevic? PART 3 of 6, NEW Interview With Chief Spaetzel of Bay Village PD

Who Killed Amy Mihaljevic? PART 2 of 6, 30 Year Retrospective NEW Interview

Who Killed Amy Mihaljevic? 30 YEARS- PART 1 of 6

Introducing The Mysterious Mr. Epstein from Wondery

The Colonial Parkway Murders: Part Five

The Colonial Parkway Murders: Part Four

The Colonial Parkway Murders: Part Three

Introducing Imagined Life from Wondery

The Colonial Parkway Murders: Part Two

The Colonial Parkway Murders: Part One

Who Killed Holly Piiranien?

Who Killed Molly Bish?

Who Killed David Widlak?

Who Killed Shakira Johnson? Part 2

Introducing Room 20

Who Killed Shakira Johnson?

Who Killed the Robison Family?

Who Killed Alison Parrott? Part 2

Who Killed Carnell Sledge & Katherine Brown?

Who Killed Alison Parrott?

New Interview With Chief Spaetzel

The Lake Erie Murders: Who Killed Amy Mihaljevic? Round Table

Round Table Discussion on the Lake Erie Murders

The End... For Now

Mark Mihaljevic Interview

Margaret Mihaljevic

The Teacher?

Is this what we've been looking for?

Nic from True Crime Garage Interviews Me for Off the Record

Just the Beginning...

Who Do You Think Killed Amy?

More Suspects & More Nic & James

Where We Stand Today

Who was Amy?

The Suspects

The Investigation

Discovery of the Body

The Search Begins...

October 27, 1989

Who Killed Amy Mihaljevic? Season 1, Trailer 1

Who Killed Amy Mihaljevic? Season 1, Trailer 3

Who Killed Amy Mihaljevic? Season 1, Trailer 2