All episodes

202. MURDER: The End of Kim Wall’s Impressive Life

201. MURDER: When Juliet Met Pauline

200. MYSTERY: What is the Ohio Grassman?

199. MYSTERY: Where Did Granger Go?

198. MYSTERY: What Happened to Octavia?

197. MURDER: Amy Bishop’s Tenure was Denied

196. MURDER (adjacent): Is Charles Manson from Kentucky?

195. MYSTERY: Who was Kaspar Hauser?

194. MYSTERY: The Dancing Plague of 1518

193. MYSTERY: The Green Children of Woolpit

192. MYSTERY: What Happened to Bobby Dunbar?

191. MAGIC: Celebrating Samhain

190. MYSTERY: The Strange Death of Charles Bravo

189. (Honorary) WITCH: Sybil Ludington

188. MURDER: The Osage Reign of Terror

187. MURDER: The Disappearance and Death of Jessica Dishon (TRIGGER WARNING)

186. MYSTERY: Why Did Agatha Vanish?

185. MURDER: The Angel Makers of Nagyrèv

184. MYSTERY: Decoding the Basel Papyrus

183. MURDER: The Woman in the Well

182. MYSTERY: Who Was the Leatherman?

181. MYSTERY: What Was Life Like Inside The Source Family?

180. MYSTERY: What is the Ma’nene Festival?

179. MYSTERY: What Started the Satanic Panic of the 80s?

178. MYSTERY: The Outlaw Who Wouldn’t Die

177. MURDER: Dennis Nilsen, Serial Killer

176. MYSTERY: Haunted Charleston

175. MYSTERY: Where is Lars Mittank?

174. MYSTERY: What Causes Cotard’s Syndrome?

173. MURDER: Jerry Brudos, Serial Killer

172. MURDER: The Dissection of a Murderer

171. MURDER: Where Did All the Serial Killers Go?

170. MYSTERY: Where is Marvin Clark?

169. MURDER: The Horrific Death of Katarzyna Zowada

168. MURDER: Blanche, The Black Widow

167. MYSTERY: Three Puerto Rican Legends

166. MURDER: The Minister Who Loved the Choir Singer

165. WITCH: A Couple of Witches

164. MURDER: Bobbie Sue Dudley, Killer Nurse

163. MYSTERY: What, Exactly, is an Eelpig?

162. MEGAN’S FAVORITE: What Happened to Brooke Farthing?

161. MEGAN’S FAVORITE: Grace Sherwood, The Witch of Pungo

160. KARA’S FAVORITE: The Acid Bath Murders

159. KARA’S FAVORITE: The Legend of the Cora Tree

158. MYSTERY: Did Teresita Basa Catch Her Own Killer?

157. MYSTERY: The Witch Dance of Natchez Trace

156. MYSTERY/MURDER: The Imposter

155. MYSTERY: The Conspiracy Theories of the Denver International Airport

154. MYSTERY: What is Happening in the Bennington Triangle?!

153. WITCH: The Prophecies of Baba Vanga

152. SURVIVORS: Michelle, Amanda, and Gina

151. MYSTERY: Does the Congo’s Mokele-mbembe Exist?

150. WITCH: The Pendle Witches of Lancashire

149. MYSTERY: Who Created the Antikythera Device?

148. MYSTERY: Was Evalyn Walsh McLean Cursed?

147. MYSTERY: Who Was the Phantom Barber?

146. MURDER: When Jens Met Elizabeth, Part Two

145. MURDER: When Jens Met Elizabeth, Part One

144. MAGIC: What is Beltane?

143. MYSTERY: The Andean Ice Mummies

142. RANDOM BUT AWESOME: Operation Mincemeat

141. MYSTERY: Where is Fawn Marie Mountain?

140. WITCH: Kentucky’s Leah Smock

139. MURDER: When Bernie Met Margie

138. MYSTERY: The Tromp Family’s Road Trip

137. MURDER: The Unsolved Murder of Lisa McBride

136. MYSTERY: There’s Something About Mary

135. MYSTERY: The Hauntings of the Crescent Hotel

134. MYSTERY: What Happened to Cindy James?

133. MYSTERY: Nina’s Mausoleum

132. GODDESS: Olga of Kiev

131. WITCH: The Nissitissit Witch

130. MURDER: Joyce McKinney

129. MYSTERY: It’s Raining…Eels?!

128. MURDER: Adrienne Shelly, The Woman Who Wrote Waitress

127. MYSTERY: The Kentucky Meat Shower—Huh?!

126. MURDER: The Unsolved Murder of Betsy Aardsma

125. MURDER: The Death of Tonya Harding’s Skating Career

124. MURDER: Kim, Nancy, Amelda, Janice, Telacia, & Diane (Part 2)

123. MURDER: Crystal, Tishana, Leshanda, Tonia, & Michelle (Part 1)

122. MYSTERY: The Legend of the Slit-Mouthed Woman

121. MURDER: The Death of Marvin Gaye

120. (Honorary) WITCH: Edith Wilson, First Lady

119. MYSTERY: Was the Lemp Family Cursed?

118. MYSTERY: What’s Behind Sleep Paralysis?

117. MYSTERY: Who Did Norman Baker Think He Was?

116. MYSTERY: The Kecksburg UFO incident

115. MYSTERY: The Disappearance of Don Lewis

114. MYSTERY: Did Aliens Visit Ohio in 1966?

113. MURDER: The Decapitation of Pearl Bryan (Re-Release)

112. MYSTERY: The Devil of Devonshire

111. MAGIC: Setting Intentions for the New Year!

110. MYSTERY: The Strange Death of Thomas Hickman

109. HOLIDAY DOUBLE EPISODE: A Christmas Murder Spree & Austria’s Christmas Witch

108. MYSTERY: The Ghosts of Mammoth Cave

107. MURDER: Robert Durst is the Worst, Part Two

106. MURDER: Robert Durst is the Worst, Part One

105: WITCH: The Honest Courtesan

104. MURDER: The Murder of Helle Crafts

103. WITCH: The Legend of the Cora Tree