PodParley PodParley
PodParley PodParley
Log in

E18 Afghanistan, Why We Failed with David Kilcullen (PhD)

Send us a text Guest David Kilcullen. The conversation explores the reasons behind America's failure in Afghanistan and the consequences of the Taliban retaking Kabul. It delves into the concept of counterinsurgency and its application in different contexts. The discussion highlights the mistakes made in Afghanistan, such as the failure to negotiate a peace settlement with the Taliban, the expansion of ISAF without understanding the local dynamics, and the attempt to replicate the surge strat...

Episode 18 of the At the Water's Edge podcast, hosted by WRKdefined Podcast Network, titled "E18 Afghanistan, Why We Failed with David Kilcullen (PhD)" was published on May 30, 2024 and runs 70 minutes.

May 30, 2024 ·70m · At the Water's Edge

0:00 / 0:00

Summary

Send us a text Guest David Kilcullen. The conversation explores the reasons behind America's failure in Afghanistan and the consequences of the Taliban retaking Kabul. It delves into the concept of counterinsurgency and its application in different contexts. The discussion highlights the mistakes made in Afghanistan, such as the failure to negotiate a peace settlement with the Taliban, the expansion of ISAF without understanding the local dynamics, and the attempt to replicate the surge strategy from Iraq. The disconnect between military leaders and civilian decision-makers, as well as the lack of accountability, are also discussed. The conversation with Dave Kilcullen explores the failures and lessons learned from the war in Afghanistan. Kilcullen highlights the lack of accountability within the institution and the inability to adapt to changing environments. He emphasizes the importance of a fighting force that can critique conventional wisdom and adapt when necessary. The collapse of the Afghan government and military is attributed to a focus on central government institutions rather than local governance systems. The relationship with Pakistan is discussed, with Kilcullen noting their fear of strategic encirclement and their desire to keep Afghanistan weak. He also emphasizes the need for better civilian-military coordination, political engagement, and a willingness to learn from past mistakes in future conflicts. Counterinsurgency by David Kilcullen The Ledger: Accounting for Failure in Afghanistan by David Kilcullen and Greg Millscontact the show: [email protected] Support the show

Episode Description

Send us a text Guest David Kilcullen. The conversation explores the reasons behind America's failure in Afghanistan and the consequences of the Taliban retaking Kabul. It delves into the concept of counterinsurgency and its application in different contexts. The discussion highlights the mistakes made in Afghanistan, such as the failure to negotiate a peace settlement with the Taliban, the expansion of ISAF without understanding the local dynamics, and the attempt to replicate the surge strategy from Iraq. The disconnect between military leaders and civilian decision-makers, as well as the lack of accountability, are also discussed. The conversation with Dave Kilcullen explores the failures and lessons learned from the war in Afghanistan. Kilcullen highlights the lack of accountability within the institution and the inability to adapt to changing environments. He emphasizes the importance of a fighting force that can critique conventional wisdom and adapt when necessary. The collapse of the Afghan government and military is attributed to a focus on central government institutions rather than local governance systems. The relationship with Pakistan is discussed, with Kilcullen noting their fear of strategic encirclement and their desire to keep Afghanistan weak. He also emphasizes the need for better civilian-military coordination, political engagement, and a willingness to learn from past mistakes in future conflicts. Counterinsurgency by David Kilcullen The Ledger: Accounting for Failure in Afghanistan by David Kilcullen and Greg Millscontact the show: [email protected] Support the show

Share this episode

Similar Episodes

No similar episodes found.

Similar Podcasts

The Water's Edge Marcus Osterhout, Certified Warrior Mindset Coach At the edge of the storm is a choice: sedate… or rise. Welcome to The Water’s Edge the podcast for high-performing men who look successful on the outside but are silently slipping on the inside.Hosted by Stretch, this show exposes the real conversations most men avoid about burnout, marriage, anger, faith, fatherhood, and fire. Each episode is a battle plan: part wake-up call, part system, all truth.No therapy. No fluff. Just raw insight and tactical power to help you go from stuck to savage. Whether you’re buried under the pressure to provide, drifting in your marriage, or done pretending Stories from the Water Shannon Keegan founder of Intrepid Water Where land meets water, an invitation lingers—not just between elements, but between versions of yourself. You could remain on shore—where it's safe, familiar, predictable. Or you could cross into the unknown.Stories from the Water is where we dive into the courage it takes to begin, the resilience that keeps us moving forward, and the wisdom that only emerges in the space between.If you have ever stood at the edge of a body of water and wondered what it would be like to swim to the other side, you're in good company. Whether you're a seasoned swimmer, aspiring adventurer, or just someone intrigued by the water's mysterious pull, allow these stories to reveal what lies beneath the surface—not just of the water, but of ourselves. How to Get Away with Shakespeare VEIGA ENTERTAINMENT Do pop culture classics and the latest Oscar-nominated films include significant references to the Bard of Avon? Are allusions to Shakespeare's plays in our favorite TV shows building upon his work, challenging it, or merely repeating it? Each episode of this podcast approaches a different production, from Guillermo Del Toro's award-winning The Shape of Water to Disney's animated epic The Lion King, looking for the things that will set your teeth on edge and the tidbits of information that will impress your friends at your next trivia night. Independently produced and edited by co-hosts Jane Fox and Gabriel Veiga, undergraduate students in English literature, 'How to Get Away with Shakespeare' explores the ways in which England's national poet influences modern TV and cinema. And be warned: though this be madness, yet there is method in it.We'll be back soon with more episodes. You Are Not A Frog Dr Rachel Morris The podcast for GPs, hospital doctors and other professionals in high-stakes, high-stress jobs who want to thrive rather than just survive.You studied for years, you’re really good at what you do but you’ve noticed that you’re starting to feel overwhelmed, overworked and under-resourced. You may be comparing yourself to a frog in boiling water - the heat has built up so slowly that you haven’t noticed the extra-long days becoming the norm. You may feel on the edge and trapped in the very job that you’ve spent years working towards.Here’s the problem, frogs only have two choices; stay and be boiled alive, or jump out of the pan. The good news is that you are not a frog. You have many more choices than you think you do. You don’t have to quit, and nor should stress and burnout be inevitable.It is possible to be master of your own destiny, to craft your work life and career so that you can thrive even in the most difficult of situations. There are simple changes you can make which will
URL copied to clipboard!