Skip to content

“In exercising the discretion, the Court should be guided.…” — U.S. Supreme Court 2013 Term Arguments at 48:21

“In exercising the discretion, the Court should be guided. It's not just a freewheeling discretion that the Court is exercising under Article 12. We think it's guided by the purposes stated in the Convention. So, yes, first you look at whether the child is settled, and that could be enough to defeat the presumption…”