Skip to content
#157 Group exercise classes VERSUS personal training episode artwork

Jul 29, 2020 24 min

#157 Group exercise classes VERSUS personal training

from Find your model health! Hosted by Chemaine Linnie

In this podcast episode we are looking at the pro's and con's of group exercise classes and one-to-one personal training. Which is going to be better for you and your health goals. Which is more affordable in the short and long term, and which is best for accountability. I hope this episode helps you decide which route may be best for you. And if you have any questions at all, do not hesitate to reach out. It would also help me immensely if you could share this podcast with anyone you feel would benefit. Help me, help you to help others. :)

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

#157 Group exercise classes VERSUS personal training

0:00 24:24
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Good afternoon everybody and welcome to the Find Your Model Health Podcast for those looking to optimize their long-term health and weight goals and understand how their body works. I am your host, I am Shmaine Lenny, I am a fitness and nutrition expert, biohacker and certified aerodologist and I'm very happy to have you back with me for another episode where we learn how your body really works and we empower you to make the changes that you need to feel your best. I hope you're all keeping really well on this July afternoon. It is a sweltering 28 degrees here in Urgery, Alberta, even though my phone says it feels like 32, I can vouch for my phone, it does feel like 32.

I am sweating but I'm remembering to stay very hydrated, conscious of how much I'm sweating and I hope you all are too. So in this week's episode, I want to look at a question that keeps popping up over the last few weeks as all the different locations start to open back up and gyms start to open back up and people have a lot of questions of what is safe and what is right for them and what is not. So this question on whether personal training is for you or fitness group classes are for you pops up a lot lately for me through my clients and my followers. So I wanted to kind of just give you some direction in a podcast episode.

Before I go on, I must emphasize that the information in these podcasts is not to be taken as medical advice, but to be taken for informational purposes only, please consult your health practitioner before making any lifestyle changes. So basically what is better? Personal training or group classes? In my opinion, both are great.

They both serve their purposes. I have taught both. I teach both. I've attended both.

Let's kind of get down to the nitty-gritty. What are the differences and who might they suit? So right before in my opinion before COVID-19 and the pandemic hit, there was a huge popularity for group fitness classes. We saw here in aridry.

There was a big following for orange fitness, F45, cross-fit, even the group classes at Janice's place. I know we're very popular. And then of course they got hit severely once the pandemic kind of entered the scene. And then I suppose it got people thinking, well, if I can't go to my group classes anymore, maybe one to one personal training might be for me and safer as well, given the current environment.

So despite the popularity of either, both can provide great results, but let's compare the differences and why you might want to offer one over the other. So I started off many moons ago teaching group classes. I did step aerobics. I did aerobics.

I did boot camps. I did prenatal boot camps. I still do pilates group classes. Well, I haven't since the pandemic, but they're still on my agenda.

Now, when you're doing a group class, your instructor or your trainers main priority is to make sure that you are safe throughout the whole class, that the environment is safe, that your technique is being performed in a safe way, and that the risk of you hurting yourself is low. Unfortunately, this doesn't always happen in group classes and instructors attention is divided among the number of participants and this subjects students with reduced supervision to have minimal safety and questionable form and even alignment. By contrast, of course, a personal training session ensures that you get your instructor or your trainer's full attention. Now in saying that some instructors are awesome.

They're very aware of each of their students in their class. Many of them, including myself, will cath classes at a certain size depending on the class so that we can keep an eye on each individual and their form and their technique and any kind of safety issues that may be surrounding that individual. So there are a lot of great instructors out there that will keep an eye on this sort of stuff. And after that safety kind of awareness, a good instructor needs to look at form and proper alignment.

In many group classes, I saw before the pandemic, there were a lot of group classes that were packing out their classes. They weren't capping their numbers. They were squashing as many people as they could into classes. And then I felt like the instructor was more there to have fun than to keep an eye on everyone.

So this is something you want to be aware of. I feel that now that the pandemic is here and I've noticed group classes are starting up again. The numbers are going to be smaller, which this is reassuring because this could tell you, okay, well, if the numbers are smaller, then there's going to be more awareness from my instructor on my well-being and my performance and stuff like that. So that is reassuring.

So we just kind of have to wait and see how this kind of rolls out as group classes start to open up again. When we look at the financial aspect, group classes do come at a fraction of the cost of personal training. Personal training is like the top of the top tier when it comes to fitness. That's where you're going to spend that extra money for the extra mile.

But with group classes, we see that the amount of injuries that happen in a group class is staggering. So beyond the obvious cost of the class, then we kind of way up the cost of the injury and the setback to your fitness goals that that might cause as well. Now I'm not trying to say group classes are all negative, but I am kind of showing you both sides of the coin. So consider the cost of rehabbing from a torn muscle or a dislocation or herniated disc or one of the most common injuries in many classes is a sprained or twisted ankle, worst case scenario, it's going to be a fractured ankle and that can come from not, not monitoring the form of the client or understanding their fitness levels and people roll their ankles all the time.

So we want to consider that the downtime and the loss of productivity and how that's going to affect not only your physical health and goals, but also your mental health if you can't work out and you have to pay the money for any health care associated with said injury. When we look at motivation and goals, group work out so defined usually by mantras and they've lots of music and enthusiastic cheerleading and shouting and lots of motivation. So in all that can be a terrific formula to keep you coming back for more. And this is where we see the social aspect come into group classes are working in big group gyms like CrossFit and group settings.

We see that social aspect the comradery happened. People motivating people basically and that can be great and that can be very enticing to someone who's looking for more of a social aspect to their exercise and maybe they don't have specific goals for their body composition or physique, but they do want to make sure they get exercise and also have say a laugh while they're at it. This is where the group classes can be great. The substance and the content again of the work out in a group setting will determine your actual results regardless of that motivation and the music and entertainment.

So bear that in mind. In personal training though you are motivated through each and every move by a trainer who is intimately familiar with your weaknesses, your strengths, your knees, your hands, your don'ts. When you're in personal training that trainer is looking just at you every second of the session. All focuses on you, your form, your safety, the goal at hand, even your facial expressions if you're struggling, maybe if you look a bit faint like there's a lot of attention given in personal training.

One of the selling points to personal training dare I say is that form is making sure that people have the correct form that's going to help them get to their physique or body composition goals a lot faster. Many people don't quite understand or dare I say know how to do specific exercises with proper form and this is where personal training comes in to make sure that everything is just pretty much perfect and on point. When you're doing personal training your results are constantly tracked and acknowledged and they provide powerful motivation or positive reinforcement to your progress regardless of the kind of music and camaraderie value. So this is more for those hard kind of goal seeking exercise who really want a specific physical composition, maybe some nice lat form or some beautiful shoulders or they want to tone their legs and this is where having personal training can come in handy with personal training.

It is again the top of the tear when it comes to cost them but with that cost you do get the specific value, you get the realistic goal setting which is constantly being adapted as you move towards your goals and keep making progress. You also then get adaptations to workouts, maybe your workout gets some sort of pyramid programming or you're switching up your workout so you're focusing on specific body parts or weaknesses whereas you won't get them with a group class and working with a specific dedicated coach will ensure your motivation remains consistent as long as you click well with the coach of course. If you don't vibe well with your coach, you're not going to get the results but if you vibe well and you have a good relationship with your trainer or your coach, then you will see that you'll continually progress and you'll continually be motivated. You'll enjoy the sessions.

The sessions, although they won't be a big social event like these group classes, they will be an event for you that you will look forward to and sometimes having just that personal trainer is the kick up the ask that many people need to sustain motivation along with that custom builds program that establishes your true starting point to help you get to your end point. When we look at the personal training, like I said, it's at the top of the exercise food chain in terms of expense. However, personal training sessions are also at the top of the food chain in terms of results. So you really have to weigh up the pros and the cons.

When it comes to your body, what price is too high to pay for an exercise program? What price is too much for something that you will do because you're being held accountable to when you have a personal trainer, they schedule you into their calendar. They message you or at least they shouldn't say, hey, am I seeing you tomorrow or hey, am I seeing you this evening? And then if you try to cancel, if it's not for a legitimate reason, that personal trainer is going to hold you accountable and say, hey, you better turn off.

You know this is for your own good. Whereas with group classes, we can convince ourselves to skip them because nobody's holding us accountable. It's very rare. We would see the fitness and structure message each individual attendee and say, hey, will I see you tomorrow night because they too much to stay on top of.

So and the value is just not there for that. If that makes sense, like the money is just not there for them to put in that much effort. So that is something that would be a selling point for me. If I sign up to personal training, I have to do it.

I have to do it. Whereas when you sign up to say 10 group classes, you go because you paid for them, but you can always talk yourself out of them and you can always convince yourself, oh, it won't matter if I missed one. It won't matter if I missed another one or sure, I only paid a hundred dollars for these 10 classes. It's not a lot of money.

I'm not going to stress over it. Whereas if you're paying a personal trainer, a hundred dollars for two sessions, you're going to make sure that you're there. So we see that one-to-one coaching provides a full service and not just the physical aspect and the mental aspect, but also that whole accountability aspect. But group classes, again, depending on the group class, can do that.

If you really enjoy the other members of the class and you really enjoyed that class, you, of course, will go because you enjoy it, not just because you paid for it or you signed up for it. So think about which is going to be the better investment for you, which is going to help you get your results better, but also keep you accountable. And what are the areas of your life might motivate you in? Maybe your nutrition, maybe your sleep, maybe just having a positive mindset that there's all this to think about.

If what you constraints are too prohibitive for you, there are always other options. You can get boot camps that generally are a little cheaper, especially if they're doing outdoors and parks. And this, of course, helps with that whole social distancing aspect. You have a lot more room when you're outdoors and then you've got the fresh air, you've got less stuff that people are touching.

So that can be an option for some. I used to love teaching boot camps except when one, I got somberant or two, when it rained a lot. Otherwise I love teaching outdoor boot camps, the fresh air and the sunshine just do so much for the soul and not just giving people a good workout. But if you can commit to one or the other, you will see the results.

So in summary, both have their place. So group fitness classes or one to one personal training group fitness classes are going to be cheaper. They generally will have more entertainment and value to them. They can be more fun.

They have a lot more music. Well, most of them, they can be a bit more fast paced as well. You've got that social aspect to them, but then you have to consider the safety aspect is the instructor going to watch that you're in a safe environment. Your form is good.

How is your technique? Then hey, is there a chance I can convince myself out of going to a class so that accountability aspect? Then with personal training, yes, it can be more expensive. You may not have that entertainment value.

But if you vibe, like I said with your personal trainer, then you are going to enjoy the session. You're going to look forward to the session. You will build repertoire with your trainer and that can be very helpful because they can get to know your ins and outs on many levels, which can support you getting to your goals. Personal training can be more beneficial when one has injuries or past medical history.

You do get that 100% focus on your safety and your technique and your form and all that. But again, there is that investment cost to it. Personal trainers can range generally from $40 a session up to $150 a session. So you can shop around and maybe ask, can I try one personal training session with you before you jump into buying a package to see if you vibe well with the personal trainer, maybe do a meet and greet.

One thing that's important to know when you do group classes, not all instructors will do meet and greets or assessments or ask about your medical history or any old injuries. Every personal trainer will or show it to do that. So they understand where scar tissue might lie or where weaknesses or old injuries or maybe there's good stress, all these different things that can play apart. But again, because I really don't want this to sound one sided.

There are some great class group fitness instructors that will do assessments or maybe they'll email you an assessment form to fill out and they'll then go over it before you attend classes. I do always encourage my clients if they're going to a group class. I always say make sure you tell the instructor any issues you have or any weaknesses or if you've a bad knee or if your angles are weak or anything, always make sure if you've maybe diastes recti down your abdominals or literally anything. I always encourage my clients because I've clients all over the world.

So I don't teach all my clients face to face. So if I did, I would know their ins and outs, but otherwise I want to make sure that they're making their instructors aware of their issues because I don't need it adding to any health issues that I'm already helping the client deal with. Like we don't want to make things worse. We're trying to make things better.

So that's important to remember. So I think if you were deciding should I go group classes now that they're opening up or based on the pandemic and my goals, should I go personal training? So you get out of piece of paper, pros and cons of both, then way of what might work for you. You could even do say one group of sessions with a personal trainer and then go back to one group of sessions and group classes once everything is kind of relaxed a bit, not relaxed a bit in the sense of the safety measures.

But once they've had the time to kind of find their groove because I know most classes are only starting now over the next week or two group classes. So maybe you could try them in a few weeks. So do some time with a personal trainer then some time in group classes and then see which you liked, which kind of got you to your goals, which helped you stay on track, which kept you accountable, which you enjoyed, which you felt like you've got your money's work, like you've got a good workout as well. That's super important too.

So there's lots to kind of way up there. So take out a piece of paper pros and cons of both, then see which might be the best approach for you based on what your goals are for yourself. So I hope you found this podcast episode helpful. If you have any questions, watch, so ever reach out to me.

My email address is chimeine at findyourmodelhealth.info. You can contact me through my website. That's chimeine'smodelhealth.com. You can find me on Instagram and Facebook again, chimeine'smodelhealth.com.

You can PM me there on either of those platforms or you can even comment below here on your podcast player. So apart from that, I hope you guys enjoy this lovely weather, but don't get some burned to make sure you stay hydrated. And please, if you know anyone that this information will help, please do share with them. It helps me help you help others and the more we can do that, the more we can help the world be healthier, hopefully happier place.

So it would really mean a lot to me if you would recommend my podcast to anyone you feel would benefit from it. And if you wanted to go the extra mile, it would mean even more to me if you would leave a review only if you feel I deserve it and this was somewhat helpful for you. Okay, I will chat to you guys soon. Thank you for joining me.

I really appreciate it. I'm so grateful for all of you that. Follow me and listen to my podcast episodes regularly because I really do enjoy doing these. I'll chat to you guys soon.

Bye bye.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Find your model health!?

This episode is 24 minutes long.

When was this Find your model health! episode published?

This episode was published on July 29, 2020.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Find your model health! episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.