Skip to content
#182 Understanding the Specific Carbohydrate Diet episode artwork

Apr 12, 2021 26 min

#182 Understanding the Specific Carbohydrate Diet

from Find your model health! Hosted by Chemaine Linnie

Over the last decade, the incidence of inflammatory bowel (IBD) and other inflammatory diseases, have increased worldwide. Symptoms of IBD are often painful and include diarrhea, bloating, bleeding ulcers and thus anemia. Elimination diets, such as the Specific Carbohydrate Diet(SCD), have gained traction as potential treatments for IBD and other inflammatory and autoimmune disorders. Check out this weeks podcast episode to understand more.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

#182 Understanding the Specific Carbohydrate Diet

0:00 26:20
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello everybody, welcome to episode 182 of the Find Your Model Health Podcast. For those looking to optimize their long-term health and weight goals and understand how their body really works, I am your host, I am Shmai Lini, I'm a fitness and nutrition expert, biohagger and certified eryodologist. I hope you're really well on this Sunday evening, so yes, I am recording this the evening before I release it, and to be honest I'm pretty tired, it's been a busy weekend, so hopefully I don't talk gibberish too much and I make some sort of sense or logic out of all the information I'm about to deliver. But I do hope you're very well and I thank you for joining me and giving me your time for another episode, I hope you find this really informational and helpful.

So in this week's episode we are looking at the specific carbohydrates diet over the last decade, the incidence of inflammatory bowel diseases and inflammation overall has increased worldwide. I put it down to, in my own opinion, I think it's poor quality food, I think it's pesticides and herbicides and other stuff being added to our food and sprayed on our food, I also do believe that we maybe are more stressed, like a lot more stressed than we used to be a decade ago, but also many people I've noticed don't prioritize their health anymore, they definitely don't prioritize sleep when they should and a lot of other things, but I think that those are the main driving factors behind this big increase in inflammatory diseases over the last 10 years or so. So before we go into this diet that may be helpful for you with any sort of inflammatory bowel disease or inflammation of the digestive system, I must remind you that the information in these podcast episodes is for informational purposes only and should not be taken as medical advice. Please consult your health care practitioner before making any lifestyle changes.

Okay, so in this episode we're looking at the specific carbohydrate diet which generally is used for inflammatory bowel diseases or inflammation of the digestive tract, symptoms associated with inflammatory bowel issues, usually spasms, diarrhea, cramping, bloating, gas, ulcers, and then anemia from bleeding ulcers, but elimination diets such as the specific carbohydrate diet have been gaining traction and have been making a difference. So the specific carbohydrate diet, it is a restrictive grain free diet plan designed to help people with conditions such as Crohn's disease, ulcerative colitis, C.E.A.c disease, diverticulitis, cystic fibrosis, chronic diarrhea, IVD, so irritable bowel disease and IBS, so irritable bowel symptoms. Some people claim it helps with pretty much all gastrointestinal problems including the gastrointestinal problems that some children have with autism and as the name suggests the diet allows some carbs but fans others based on how hard they are to digest and how much strain they cause the digestive system. You can have items including fresh fruit, most vegetables, meat that doesn't have additives, homemade fermented yogurt or really good yogurt, so it's not just homemade fermented yogurt, like a good quality store bought yogurt can fall into this diet, but not generally start to grains or processed or canned foods and that includes like dried processed fruits.

So how it all started was it was a pediatrician, Sidney Haas, who created the specific carbohydrate diet in the 1920s to treat celiac disease and that was kind of the end of what we heard from it after the early 20s and then years later it gained traction again where biochemists called Elaine Gotchall. She made the diet more widely known in 1987 when she published a book called Breaking the Vicious Cycle in Testinal Health Through Diets and she created this to help her daughter who had been diagnosed with severe ulcerative colitis and Gotchall reportedly used the diet as successful treatment for her daughter and then did further research on the nutrition and gastrointestinal health before writing the book and then the book became very popular and in the book it outlines the diet and the recipes she used if you would like to check it out so the book name again is Breaking the Vicious Cycle in Testinal Health Through Diets by Elaine Gotchall. But anyway, so how the diet works is the theory at least behind it is that when we eliminate certain foods that emphasize the removal of certain types of carbohydrates containing foods based on their chemical structure, basically the governing theory behind the simple carbohydrate diet or specific carbohydrate diet is that the complex carbs encourage and overgrowth of unhealthy bacteria and your intestines if you already have good issues that your microbiome and your gastrointestinal integrity is already not up to par so if you add in specific complex carbs that's going to exacerbate the problem and as these bacteria grow they produce byproducts that promote inflammation and that inflammation is not just trapped in the gut so it's not just in that zone that inflammation can then carry over to pretty much anywhere in the body because these bacteria can migrate basically and eventually this bacteria and the inflammation lead to reduced absorption of nutrients and then of course you get malnutrition and your hair falls out and lots of other health issues but basically the SED claims to inhibit the growth of these bacteria and restore digestive function by eliminating all carbohydrate food sources that have two or more linked sugar molecules so we'll be looking at our diet all ago and polysaccharides there so they'll both sugar types and through many carbs are prohibited the SED does not or does permit carb sources that have single unbound sugar molecules or mono saccharides as they're called as your digestive tract easily absorbs them but also it's less stressful it requires less energy as well to break down those sugars and this is a lot of in line with my teachings like if there's some foods I say yes to and no to but the basis of this not that I teach the specific carbohydrate diet like that's not my overall kind of approach but it's definitely implemented in a lot of my practices but I would then add in some other specific food types that do fall into this category but that are not kind of mentioned as much in the book or even in what most health practitioners will teach so I will add in some sort of foods I'll add in my biotics I'll add in what we call in my circle of clients very just certain foods that are designed to do certain things to optimize not only got help but also cellular help and stimulate positive DNA and genetic outcomes and there's a lot to it but this kind of is already implemented in what I normally teach but not specifically like I don't only teach this but anyway so on the SED foods to avoid generally based on their chemical structure the diet itself labels any food or food additive quote illegal so in my world when my clients ask me is this approved I say yes or no so in my world some of these diet labels would be considered quote no but basically in this diet they call something illegal if it contains two or more chemically linked sugar molecules and then that book that I mentioned breaking the vicious cycle collectively refers to these foods as complex carbs so in scientific terms any foods with disaccharides oligosaccharides or polysaccharides will appear on the list of quote illegal foods so I'm sure you can imagine that the list of banned foods is quite extensive but here's a few of the main groups that are quote illegal so potatoes grains pseudograins like rice we've got wheat corn quinoa melod pretty much all grains processed meats and meats with additives I mean you shouldn't be eating them anyway but dairy except some cheese butter and homemade yogurt that has been fermented for at least 24 hours now this is what the diet says but I believe there are there's going to be some exceptions based on what foods do mostly gooms this is where it lines off with the fadmak diet that I talked about in the last podcast episode because most legumes are very inflammatory as it is mainly because of their lectin content so in the s ed they will allow legumes or they're co permitted after soaking for 24 hours and washing and the same with some lentils because that process of preparation alone that reduces a lot of the lectins so yes then most processed sugar artificial sweeteners and sugar alcohols and then of course your processed foods so the general structure the overarching theme of the s ed is it's quite rigid most people won't follow it but it is intended to be followed exactly as outlines in let's say you got the book in the book and it doesn't leave too much room for flexibility in the book depending on the health practitioner your work with or the health coach of course they would have to have a very in-depth understanding of nutrition they can tweak this diet so that it's a little bit more flexible but still has all the benefits but shall I say a bit more enjoyable so some people can reintroduce certain illegal foods after symptoms subsized but this will depend on the individual's response to the diet kind of like the fadmak diet and then that whole reintroduction phase if you didn't listen to that podcast episode last week then you should go check it out even if you're not going to try it it just gives you an idea of the process of doing an elimination diet as we call them so the foods that you can eat that are approved on the s ed you can pay are also well of course they are called legal in my client circle if a food is approved it's a yes but most of the foods on the list are on process they're whole foods but again i'm apprehensive saying quote whole foods because not many people don't understand that not all whole foods are good for you so there's a bit of confusion there but anyway we're looking at the complex carbs and the molecular structure of the sugars so these quote legal carbs come from the monosaccharides so our glucose fructose and galactose which they're very easily digestible the body will kind of break them down absorb them really fast so some of your quote legal foods are going to be fruits fresh or frozen and juices but i would i would say no to juices if you're anybody that's just a bad idea but this is what the book says vegetables most vegetables except for the potatoes yams plantains and some other high starch vegetables so that would also include sweet potato but yeah i'll leave that um me so fresh meat as long as they don't contain any fillers or hormones or additives or chemicals or so preferably grass fed and organic or wild even then eggs are illegal food um some dairy like i said the homemade yogurt fermented for at least 24 hours and blessed with the holy waters running through lures in France anyway that was just my humor because i'm tired um then we mentioned some legumes as they are prepared properly now the scd also allows for nuts and nut butters as long as they're free from added starch or sugars but this one is always controversial i think because um some nuts and nut butters are very inflammatory for people that have gastric issues so if you were following the book and going with their approval of the legal nuts and nut butters and not seeing an improvement at all then this could be the problem so this is where if you are doing an elimination diet of any sort it's always good to have someone in your corner that you can bounce ideas off or that will have an understanding of certain foods and certain food groups and their nutritional properties and what they do in the body that's key understanding what a food does in the body and they can say well look you're not seeing any progress here and you're still getting these symptoms maybe will eliminate these nuts and nut butters um so that's just a side note then also our legal herbs and spices so most dried or fresh herbs and spices i would always get organic spice blends are typically discouraged because many of them harbor quote illegal additives or molecules like mst and vegetable proteins and stuff so it can be difficult to determine which foods are legal the scd book recommends eating only the explicitly legal foods to avoid inadvertently ingesting something illegal but like i mentioned that can be quite rigid and hard for a lot of people to um stick to it was originally designed like i mentioned to help people with ibd which is an umbrella term for ulcerative colitis cilia crumbs etc um at these types of diseases or health issues can hamper your ability to digest and absorb nutrients from foods so the scd was designed to heal the intestinal tissue in order to restore its functions that's like the idea is very very noble and i'm not saying this won't be helpful for some people but when you understand how the body works you already have an understanding that while the gastrointestinal tract does turn over itself while lining every three days so if you can approach your nutrition for those three days to be somewhat healing and beneficial and then continue on with the understanding that from now on after these three days let's say you do three days of the scd i will follow a basis of and more anti-inflammatory diet that is nutritionally designed to help support the good and heal digestive disorders and heal the wall and support the microbiome and everything that can be done you don't have to stay on the scd forever or even i thought you can just follow a very good nutritional protocol that is not as restrictive as this i hope i'm not sounding like i'm trying to deter anyone i'm just saying that this is not the only way to do it um but the promoters claim that some people are less adaptive digesting foods certain foods like our lectin foods like our grains and legumes and refined sugars and high starch food additives and that this can be foods that resulted from certain agricultural practices and the modern food industry are what's causing the distress and the good and causing lots of problems in people and diseases and i totally agree with that so the supporters of this specific diet though um they agree that these specific foods will cause an overgrowth of thigh bacteria in your gut which does promote inflammation all over the body eventually diminishing your ability to digest food but also that certain foods have certain inflammatory molecules on them that when we ingest them they move to our body i always try to describe them that they move to our bodies like shards of glass as they go to our body they're just cutting up everything in its path damaging the sal walls damaging the joints tearing up tissues tearing up new personal linings like they just cause a lot of damage and these foods then are going to fall into these into this diet that you're going to avoid them and eliminate them so strict adherence to the scd is supposed to eventually starve these bacteria by depriving them of food allowing your gut to tissue to heal to this day the scd is primarily used to treat intestinal disorders but with varied success i wouldn't say it's the sole one because a lot of doctors will recommend fadma a lot of doctors will try elimination diets there's a lot of doctors now that'll say hey you should go vegan which i'm not to sound biased is a terrible idea if you have the astro intestinal issues and then we have some doctors now moving people towards the ketogenic and even the carnivore diet so there's there's lots of success in these all these different diets um as long as you have an understanding of what's going on in the body but um one of the major criticisms of this diet is its lack of concrete scientific evidence um because the research is still being put together it's still growing it's not as large of a basis of research as say the fadma diet would be so this is still kind of a growing area um but ultimately more research is needed to determine whether or not it's truly effective but in the real life scenarios it seems to be that some people will get some great results from doing the scd the same way some people will get great results from doing vegan and keto and whatever because we're individual um and that means right down to a cellular level your body will prefer one thing over the other and we can look at genetics and stuff there but in summary um wild proponents of the scd claim that it treats all of these gastrointestinal disorders very effectively and maybe it treats autism spectrum disorder and cystic fibrosis there isn't any 100% yes scientific research to support this notion but i definitely think if you're sound interested in this and you want to see it and you're okay with it being a bit restrictive and you have a health practitioner to walk you through it then um it may not be such a bad idea i mean you should consult your health care practitioner or provider before diving in and it may be less risky than other medical therapies um i think the bottom line is the scd is an elimination diet designed to treat symptoms of iBD and restore digestive function by purging many of those complex care containing foods and lactants due to the notion that they may harm your gut so while some people may notice improvements in their symptoms the research is not there but as long as you do it with the help of some sort of health practitioner that could decrease your risk of malnutrition i don't see a problem in trying it out even for a week see how you feel after that um and then if you decide you want to try it longer go for it but definitely speak to someone to prevent any kind of negative side effects or malnutrition for occurring malnutrition can happen very very easily like within a few days so even if you're eating but there's gaps in that kind of nutritional profile it can happen quite easily but that's the basic of the scd i suppose if anyone wants to try it they're going to jump in and buy the book or maybe they'll google the food list isn't that what everyone does nowadays um but yeah that's the gist of it it's not too complicated it's restrictive but not too complicated so i hope you found this somewhat helpful i wanted to be able to give you an understanding of what this type of diet is compared to the low fogma diets um they're both elimination diets but one keeps in certain carbohydrates and one doesn't so if you have any questions at all please do reach out to me i hope i made sense like i said at the start i'm a bit tired but i hope i made sense and you found this informative if you have any questions you can reach out to me on facebook instagram through my website there's a button at the top there saying contact me so that's chamainsmugglehealth.com if you've any topics that you would like me to cover over the next few weeks of course send them my way um and yeah i hope you guys have a great week ahead uh stay safe get this one while you can and as always please share this information with anyone you feel may benefit from it okay have a great week everyone and i'll chat to you soon bye bye

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Find your model health!?

This episode is 26 minutes long.

When was this Find your model health! episode published?

This episode was published on April 12, 2021.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Find your model health! episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.