Hey, so something worth knowing is a benefit for the nonprofit organization that makes Crash Course and SciShow Complexly. It's September 16th, 2026 in Los Angeles, California at the Wilshire Ebell Theater. Please join us. It's going to be incredible.
Friends of Complexly like Mark Rober, Katie Max, Simone Yech, and Moore will share inspiring talks about what makes them hopeful and join Hank Green on stage for fun, interactive discussions. Complexly has been creating free educational content like SciShow and PBSEons and Crash Course and Bizarre Beasts for nearly 15 years and 6 billion views. But this year, we have become a 501c3 nonprofit and we're doing something worth knowing as an in-person event that benefits Complexly and our impactful educational media. It's the first ever Complexly in-person event and it's a fundraiser to support our mission of inspiring curiosity and lowering barriers to knowledge building because curiosity builds understanding and understanding builds a better world.
Tickets to the general public June 30th at somethingworthknowing.com So come build a better world with us on September 16th and experience something worth knowing you can get your ticket at Complexly.info slash something. And welcome to Dear Hank and John! Or as I like to think of it, Dear Deboki and Hank. It's a podcast where two brothers and sometimes a brother and a friend answer your questions, giving you advice and bringing you all the weeks news from both Mars and AFC Wimbledon.
Today we are joined by Deboki Trapper-Vardy, who is our editorial assistant who's always helping with interesting science facts. Deboki, I recently got mad at my son because he was inhaling helium out of a helium balloon. I just didn't like him talking to me in that tone of voice. Thanks, appreciate that.
How long do I have to pretend that I'm laughing for? That was good. That was perfect. So, Deboki helps with a number of things but mostly is a sort of science consultant on Dear Hank and John because we get a lot of science questions and there was a time when I would wing them which went well 90% of the time but that 10% was a problem.
And now I don't have to wing them and what we do is Deboki and I before every episode of Dear Hank and John, we have a little phone call where we talk about science questions and Mars and I learned some things and make sure that I don't get anything too wrong. So, Deboki is always on this podcast kind of and what we've decided to- I'm the silent voice in the back. No! Don't say that!
And since John is on a little break, I was like why don't we bring Deboki into not a silent voice and we can just answer science questions for a day. Yeah, so now I can listen to this afterwards and say no to myself. Like I can have the retroactive self-criticism instead. You should not have no, you should not have but look, that's part of the fun.
No one expects it to be 100% right. It's dubious advice and almost definitely correct science information. Those are my specialty so. Where are you and what are you up to these days?
So, physically I am in Massachusetts in the western part between a bunch of schools and professionally, emotionally, all over the place. I do a lot of different things for Complexly, I guess. I work on this on tangents, on Journey to the Microcosmos. We've still got Crash Course Organic Chemistry going up so I've been hosting that as well.
So, a lot of different things. Yeah. And then you also do freelance editorial work for a number of different places. And you started in your degree is in- My background is in biomedical engineering so I did that through undergrad.
I also double majored in English but that was kind of just for fun because I wanted to be forced to read books while I was in college. And then after I did my PhD in biomedical engineering and spent a long time trying to teach T-cells how to do things. Oh, I actually tried to teach T-cells how to do things in my undergrad. Yeah, they don't listen.
They just don't want to do it. They do all kinds of stuff. It's wild. I did not realize how stupid the immune system is until I started to work on it.
But it is extremely complicated. And they're just like, I'm going to be a different person. You know, like some days you kind of wish you could wake up and be a different person. So, I can't be a reswitherspoon for a day.
A T-cell can do that. Yeah. And it's just a size. And the thing is, it's so stupid but it's also so brilliant.
Oh, of course. It's like, it's so hard to understand. Like you can spend your entire life trying to map out the immune system and trying to understand what it's doing. I mean, people have been trying to spend their entire lives doing that.
And you get to a point, I think, where you just have to accept the large amount of things you're just never going to get about it. Yeah. Yeah. Well, thank God for the immune system though.
Mine does attack me. But look, it's complicated. And I get it. It's confusing in there.
There's a lot of different cells and you have to decide which ones are bad, which ones are good, and it can get confusing sometimes. And then you just make me miserable for periods of time. I'm mostly better now. But only thanks to modern, miraculous, and tremendously expensive medicines.
Yeah. What little we have learned about the immune system has already made like a lot of progress. So that's the great thing. That is the great thing.
So we have a lot of, we got a lot of science questions, but we've also got like, we're not able to answer all of the science questions. And there's often been times when we're like, what do we do with all of this solid gold material? And we haven't really figured out a thing to do. But here's one thing we can do.
We have all science questions episode of Dear Hank and John. And I assume you've listened to the podcast. I have. That's great.
This is a podcast. I've just been waking up on Mondays and answering science questions for fun. And I think that we're just doing some science questions. I liked this one.
It was from Ben, who asks, Dear Hank and Deboki, could we bring back Neanderthals today? Like if we really wanted to for some reason, considering we have sequenced their genome in all pumpkins and penguins, Ben, have we seen their genome in all? I think so. I guess I kind of accepted the premise of the question.
Now I guess I got to throw it a wrench in. Yeah. I think that we've got pieces. I don't know we've got all of it.
genome.gov says that in 2010, researchers have produced the first whole genome sequence of the three billion letters in the Neanderthal genome. That sounds like a whole genome. Jeez, I guess they're not. It's wild.
Like you forget how recent it was. That we had other members of our genus. Yes. And I just can't imagine it.
I just can't imagine it. Oh, there is this other sort of different kind of version of me just like around. Yeah. Yeah.
That is. Yes. And you know, that they would have had to have, I don't know, maybe they wouldn't have had to have, but it feels as if there would have to be some kind of large geographic separation. But if there was that large geographic separation, it seems entirely possible that a civilization could evolve and then discover that, Oh my gosh, we actually aren't alone here.
Though I don't trust us to end that situation pretty rapidly. Yes. I'm curious, like, who would have been the most trustworthy of all of all of these early humans? But maybe the fact that we're here is the sign that we were the least trustworthy of all.
I'm watching a lot of survivors lately. So I'm feeling very nihilistic about like groups of people on islands. Tell you what, tell you what, then the Neanderthals would not have made it through this. They would have gone them in the first week.
Yes. It was just far too nice. So, but, so we do have a full genome and just stick it in an egg, right? Yeah, maybe the thing is like, it's so hard to get DNA into cells to begin with.
And again, just coming from that background of like trying to get T cells, which like, it is good that your T cells will not just like accept any DNA really know like that is technically good, unless you're trying to graduate. But it is technically good that it is difficult to put DNA into cells. But I think particularly, like there are some human cell lines that people have created that are easier to engineer, whether or not we can then turn them into like a stem cell that's going to become a little, Neanderthal baby. Like that's a lot more complicated.
And then whether or not you would even be able to have that baby develop like inside, I assume a surrogate, I think, like it's to be like complicated. Yeah, we can't we can't have babies outside of people or animals yet. That's that's a long way off still. Yeah.
Though, though, certainly the data at which you can have a baby out of a parent is getting closer and closer. So, what's interesting to be there is like, my thought is just to get sticks and DNA in the egg, but it turns out cells have a lot of procedures for not having new DNA show up. Because that is that is often happens in problem situations, viruses and also just mistakes. And so that cell might be like, oh, something's wrong.
I'm just gonna off myself, which they do a lot. But we have been able to put some DNA into into cells before, right? Like is that how cloning works? Yeah, I mean, for sure, like you're saying like with viruses, like that is actually a way that we get DNA into cells all the time.
It's again, not simple and straightforward, because even making these kinds of viruses can be like pretty difficult because viruses are also not necessarily super excited about having a lot of strange DNA put into them. So there's like limitations on how much DNA you can put into it, what kind of DNA you can put into it, and then getting the virus into like the cell and getting it to like put all that DNA. Like, there's just a lot of there's a lot of issues. Like, I've had this conversation so much like with friends where we're just like, what if like we know what the sequence is like, I know what the sequence is on my computer of what I want to make with the DNA.
Why can I not just get it into the cell? I feel like I should literally be able to print a cell out that has all this stuff and apparently biology is pretty complicated. We're not there yet. I have confidence that we will that will be a much simpler proposition for students of the future.
But for Deboki of the past, I'm sure you were banging your head against a lot of walls. Yeah, it's gonna be like my most like children of the future who like learn how to clone and like their brain back in my day. So the question of can we which currently I don't think we can, but like I think probably if like you know society continues to progress that we will be able to and then we will be faced with the question of should we which of course we should not right? I don't think so.
It'd be like bringing about like I can see bringing back a Willy Maneth. Even that is hard though because elephants have strong culture, but not like in the Andrthal culture like bringing back a culturalist Neanderthal seems like it's almost like that's not what it is. That's not that wouldn't actually allow us to learn very much about them because that you know in addition to the fact he's created a person theoretically just for study and for kind of yeah to see if we could is a big problem. But then second like that's not really what we want to know so much you know it is not really about their physiology.
It's about who they were and how they acted and we can't know that because we will never recreate that environment. For sure like we're not bringing them back into the world of Neanderthals or bringing them back into a completely different world and that's where I feel like a lot of resurrection talk to me. I just I can never tell if it's like my own failure of imagination where I'm like I just I don't find myself super curious about what it would be like to resurrect Neanderthals or Willy Maneth. I just find myself kind of like hitting a wall like well okay I guess we bring the Willy Maneth back but then like And then you go to Jurassic Park like in a zoo experience like I don't it's not like the ecosystem is lacking for Willy Mammoths.
Yeah I think I could be wrong like it maybe that the ecosystem still kind of exists in a way that like it would be more dynamic if it had that sort of giant grass eating machine but yeah I don't I feel like the care of you are doing the job you know. Yeah and ecosystems are just so complicated that you just throw something in there and it's gonna I mean it'll do something like something will happen if we put Willy Maneth back in the world but it will probably more than just like a uni-directional kind of like oh yeah now this is going to do that and now the ecosystem is different it's like gonna be like a whole series of cascading things. I guess maybe that is like a curious thing I just am not personally ever like oh cool I want to know what's gonna happen. It is you know I am interested in in de-extinction when it comes to you know the potential future where we have a world that can sustain that organism that went extinct but if there's a reason it went extinct and we haven't fixed that problem yet then there's no reason to de-extinct it because like then it will just be it will just be a lot of a lot of maintenance for a symbolic thing really rather than something about the earth something about the ecosystem and and I think we think of extinction symbolically a lot where it's like if we lose that last one then we've lost it forever and like that is you know obviously that is very true but the reality is that the loss is that there isn't a world left where that organism can survive like and we haven't changed that yet anyway that's a bit of a bummer I want to ask a different question this one is from Kristin who asks steer hank and debokey would I get sick if I were to eat the Mona Lisa nothing funny rhymes with Kristin uh Kristin what about like listen to Kristin Kristin Kristin that would be good listen to glisten oh gosh yeah Kristin ate the Mona Lisa I mean now that we've tried to rhyme her name sure why not but no I don't recommend it uh would she get sick yeah yeah didn't she was not painting the Mona Lisa with safety in mind yeah I mean to begin with like I guess the the stuff it's painted on is like a thin plank yeah it's painted on wood yeah so yeah so so so you're eating really old wood I don't which is fine like I feel like I could there was a lot of people there was recently a uh this was on I think I don't know it was on wait wait don't tell me maybe or or the other one um that there was a there was a bakery that couldn't sell cookies or couldn't name their cookies cookies because they had too much sawdust in them and I was like oh uh so then I guess you can eat wood but what if that sawdust was essential what if you just called it a sawdust cookie yeah look I don't know how the laws in whatever country that I heard about that thing that I vaguely remember work but I can tell you that if I ground up the plank that I'm on a Lisa was on and mixed it into enough cookie I could definitely eat it but definitely sounds like something that's gonna be like served at a future like billionaires evil villain kind of like the situation everyone eat a little of the Mona Lisa well look here's what you could do you just shave a little bit off the back you don't have to eat the whole Mona Lisa yeah you can also just tell people that the Mona Lisa is in what you're eating no one's gonna like look at the Mona Lisa and be like is something from it missing so if you were like have a menu and be like this is a Mona Lisa cookie with shavings a Mona Lisa on it no one's gonna like fact check you um except for the fact that they're not gonna die because they're not eating lead and they're not eating like bone dust oh okay so there's more to it than just bone dust I guess this isn't some of the the pigments this was not a time of a very safe well I don't know if now are times of necessarily safe pigments but DaVinci was definitely painting with some stuff that could make you sick there was a primer that had lead in it there was bone dust there was mercury sulfide like there's stuff in the pigments that will also just probably not be good to eat interesting okay this makes sense I then you really do what I just scraped the back off look I don't know like I'm not saying that I'm not saying this is good I'm not saying I would do what I'm not saying that if I was at a party where this was happening I wouldn't be infuriated but I could absolutely see someone buying a Picasso and like scraping a bit of it off and putting it in the cookie and like that actually actually being a thing like I'm not making it like I could see a debauchery party in Cannes where they're all drinking you know gallons of rosé and it's like the cookies have a Picasso in them uh I think that I think that Mona Lisa is oh you think it's safe for being turned into a cookie yes I don't think it's like eating it yeah I disagree with you DaVokey I've heard that lead is bad for you but that's just yeah I mean it's just I'm gonna do my own research I'm gonna margin to the loop right now and test this out but DaVokey you said that one of the concerns was bone dust and I have to make the case that I could definitely well if you're gonna make that case so far everything that I found about what makes bone dust bad for you is about like breathing it in when you are cutting up bones so okay okay maybe well how bones are fine animals you bones all the time true true I think we're fine I think I need bone dust I don't think that I can eat lead though yeah I think maybe it's the left so it would make you sick but it probably wouldn't kill you is I feel like where we're at yes but not like a little bit sick for a little bit are you eating like sick forever the whole thing you are gonna be doing so great yeah all right okay I can hear that it's all in the dosage everything everything's a pleasant dose including the Mona Lisa this next question comes from Joey who asks dear Hank and DaVokey we why have no other animals evolved to intelligence similar to our own I feel as though there are some who have had it just as much if not more time well for clarity we've all like all life honor this same amount of time yeah good it still happen I think kangaroos should be next Joey cute I like the idea that it also could just be like there are animals that have been alive as long as I have and have just like not bothered to learn things in that time get together this was a this was one of my first like learning moments that I remember I said to my I said to my teacher if trees have been around so long this is like third grade why haven't they learned how walk which is like basically the same same vibe as this question like why didn't a tree learn how to walk and the answer is twofold one is the trees don't need to walk because they're they're doing they're doing just fine the other is that like the the pathway to get to walking involves a lot of other changes that that trees have not made they've not had to make and that was on a different branch of the tree you know so like the like muscles are very different from how plants move and so the the and also like the requirement of I mean now but to book you now I'm questioning I'm questioning whether or not a plant could walk because they can move yes and some of them can move quite quickly there's a whole thing about like whether not trees or like in forests are migrating right but that's more about like the collective forest that's not like tree that's not like we're not an individual tree yeah an individual tree can move but only if the ground also moves yeah could could a plant walk I think they I think what they okay so I don't know if like an individual tree can walk but I think what they've done instead is like construct a really elaborate system of being able to disperse so like that is like what is valuable to them and their like method of survival right and instead of like going to find someone to mate with instead they attract pollinators to move their genetic information around yeah because I think one of the things that's like they saw the problem in a different way yeah because it's like we could look at it as well why have a trees to learn how to walk but it's also a question of like well why haven't we learned how to survive without going anywhere and everybody in our society is all just rooted to the ground so who's really the intelligent one here that also has advantages yeah I could just sit here and eat sunlight can you do that can you do that little hangry yeah I think about this every time with microcosmos because anytime I learn about a new organism for microcosmos I'm like wow you have like really crafted a great lifestyle for yourself like I figured it out I think I've done so much in my life and then I'm just looking at this tiny little micro that can just like spring itself from a stat like a single place and just grab food and it doesn't like have the ability to like see or hear anything it just has all these other mechanisms like wow I don't know how to do anything I gotta tell your rotifer you seem happier than me yeah like if all being equal but intelligence is great and I do think about this sometimes and obviously there like intelligence has evolved independently on earth several times you know like like the best example being octopus like they're just like these animals are very smart and they definitely didn't get smart from and like the root of their smart isn't really connected to the root of our smart you know except in as much as like it's a nervous system that has has like a you know common connection to animals but like it's smart is very different and acts very different and and the and I have heard people say a couple of times if like octopuses lived longer than they would be just as smart as us I don't think that this is how it works yeah but I do understand the temptation of that thought that because they are so they are so short lived like they tend to only live for like a year or three yeah yeah is their intelligence go through like aging oh gosh I don't know I'd love to I'd love to talk to an octopus expert yeah like how does an octopus learn how to be smart how are they taught yeah but I have no idea you know I think that there is a piece of it that is do you need it but it so like that does the does the tree need to move yeah but the other piece of it is do you have the sort of requisite complexity to do it which like that is both a no for the tree in both cases with walking like a tree doesn't need to walk but also doesn't have the like sort of anything like the physiological background to evolve that trait yeah yeah and like brains take a lot of space they take a lot of resources like both through development and after so that's like that's a lot like you're gonna need to want like you're gonna need to get a lot out of the brain I think to make it all worth it mm-hmm and the thing that we get out of the brain is all is good and we were kind of the first I don't know that the thing that I try to remember about people is that like our smart is a side effect of our communication so like the thing that really makes a special is that we can very efficiently communicate a lot of information from person to person and even before we had like the internet or telephones or media I mean I guess we had media even back then we had stories we had the systems of sharing information are really good with people and that is the the advantage that that brought is what brought intelligence so as we got better at that there were more benefits and so there was this sort of this evolutionary feedback loop where the better you got it sharing information the better you got it surviving and the thing that made you better at it was intelligence yeah so you just basically need that to happen in kangaroos journey you need to get all these animals to start telling each other stories sitting around a kangaroo you need some reason that a kangaroo needs to tell a story in order to survive yes all all kangaroos and if you are bad to say kangaroo story teller somebody comes along and the kangaroo god just is like no you are no more you are you are a non-living kangaroo no I mean we say we just don't know what their stories are I mean they could be talking a lot of smack about us and we just don't know absolutely they are you've seen them oh god they're I used to play a lot of those Maxis sim games you know i'm talking about so back back in the day in the 80s and 90s there's like sim city and sim earth and sim life and sim ant and it was just like just games that didn't have a goal like you created your own goal and they didn't have an end yeah you can like beat them yeah and so you made a city but there was one called sim earth and on in sim earth you could like naturally if you sort of like had the best environment in a lot of diversity in a lot of life for a long enough time intelligence would evolve and then you could have cities and etc but also you could you could sort of give it something like an intelligence bonus by dropping a monolith on them reference to 2001 and now this wouldn't work on everything you can like drop a monolith on like a bacteria and get like a super intelligent bacteria yeah but like you could sort of decide I want my planet to be sort of full of intelligence stuff lipops which is very good that's amazing yeah like so what did that look like in the game like they would start like talking to each other or like they built a little like a little literature literally just like icon on the screen and like they I think that they got like a thing so instead of just being a octopus it was octopus with like a staff or something and and like the unmoving pixel icon of them within spread and then they'd have cities I've always felt like it'd be very difficult to have civilization underwater and I think that this is like I but I do not know why why you think that or why it seems like if it would be possible I like I don't know why I think both but like those are the same thing but it seems like if it was possible it would have happened there first because it's life has been there for so much longer for sure but also like we know nothing about the ocean I I would not so what you're saying is there's a chance that's exactly what I'm saying I have not ruled out the possibility of mermaids is what I'm saying I mean whales exist whales and dolphins exist and whatever they're doing is I just more more complicated than yeah yeah whether or not they would have built palaces is like a different kind of story or like whether or not they would be like waving staffs around that's a different story but right right and they do use tools like dolphins use tools which is and and teach and learn from each other yeah I can't imagine like if I like try to conceive of like an underwater like civilization it always looks like like the Atlantis movie the little mermaid Aquaman like I cannot imagine anything that doesn't look like that so it always seems absurd like I just it always like is inherently fantastical yeah I always try and think of how chemistry would like how would you build a chemistry lab underwater that would be very hard because there's water everywhere yeah you have to create a big air pocket and then go into it so that you could mix things together I bet there are underwater chemists who are like how they do chemistry up there there's air everywhere all right and also like it's not like chemistry was necessary for civilization and for like humans to evolve like we had we had we had you know intelligent human beings a long time before we and I could totally imagine agriculture underwater yes there's no reason that like if a dolphin figured like the problem is the dolphins don't eat grass yeah but like maybe they could figure out a way to farm grounds or something yeah yes I'm in they're farming lobsters and they're eating them and we don't know about it they're just doing it the way that we can't like conceive of like human beings in the underthaws living in the same society I think whales and dolphins have figured that out is what I've decided now um yeah so the underwater as a 15 seconds ago I I've solved it I've now understood the entirety of the underwater empire that's going on and they're all working together because some of them want to eat like animals some of them don't so like this is a collaboration the underwater empire and there's a crown in there oh and it's okay now there's no crown this is starting to feel more realistic if I like put it in those terms there's no crown no no we're gonna remove the fantasy elements we're gonna remove the aquaman the little mermaid and if we describe it strictly in terms of whales and dolphins then I think the marine biologists have to agree with me okay um these are our meetings are only 30 minutes we would get to the whale and dolphin empire part of the show this next question bookie it comes from ray who asks dear hankin to boke what is the skin of your teeth I'm quite certain that there is no skin on my teeth is there I'm quite certain but not a hundred percent is this one of those stupid English things I'm confused ray it's not a stupid English thing I think it's a great phrase yeah I mean I hear skin of the teeth and I think of all the things that like don't come off your teeth when you brush them oh so I got through it by this by the the bacterial film yeah yeah which I assume is not actually what it means but that's just what I imagine it as well I think it's an it's an ex I this is how I feel it's an excellent identification of a very weird thing which is that we have a living body part that is not covered in epithelial cells and only one and epithelial cells being them so like you know like they are the skin cells but also they are in our digestive system and they're in our mouths and other places and but but on teeth they are they're living but they are not but they're exposed they are like so yeah either either the skin of your teeth is urinal and then underneath that is the living part so that would be like one that would be like a metaphorical skin so you have like your enamel that is covering the living part just like your skin is a kind of a dead part of you that's covering the living part but I think that it's saying like this is a living part of you that that you got it was so barely there that that you got by threw by like an imaginary invisible thing so like the only part of your body that you can't skin you skinned it yeah I don't think I ever really had like realized what an existential crisis around skin and teeth are but I think that that makes a lot of sense like the issue of it being like representative of like a basically imaginary barrier like I was thinking like oh it's like something super thin but like to the point of being basically like just metaphorical like because it just doesn't even exist I like that apparently like it's actual origin or at least where people have found it is from the Old Testament well if it's in the Old Testament it's it's yeah yeah um and so I guess when Satan is trying to like tempt or break Job I'm not super all completely well up on my like Old Testament stories but Job like actually says my bone cleavers to my skin and to my flesh and I escaped with the skin of my teeth but I don't think that it's clear what skin actually referred to there so it's just yeah I mean we're metaphorical we're poets yeah we've always been that way I feel like like because like my when I was in high school because it was a private high school we actually ended up reading the Bible and it was sort of like with the goal of like learning some of that kind of metaphorical language and I remember the like was like the camel through a needle or something like that's like one of those ones where it's like one of those things that sounds impossible and it could be in one interpretation but then it's also like maybe more about like a hair and this feels like that kind of thing maybe then where it could be imagined or could be super thin right like so so what you're saying is that potentially this is just a mistranslation and we've just stuck with it because it sounded good yeah I don't know I don't know you the bokeh I've heard that you are a Bible scholar yes that is actually what I'm here for yeah I'm glad that we started out with I'm here to answer science questions and we've now come to the Bible scholar I need you to do poetry and metaphor and Bible because because John's not here and I don't know how to do this well okay that's that's the John job yeah it is interesting like it is weird to think about like what we think about what we're saying because these kinds of phrases like you think about it all the time like you say them or you hear them and I've never thought twice about the skin of my teeth I've been like yeah that makes sense to me in my head but actually now I'm gonna have a crisis about it every time I hear it because I'm like gonna be like well I'm gonna ask whoever uses it I'm like do you mean that like metaphorically this way or metaphorically that other way and it's very important to be there is the enamel of the skin or is it an invisible imaginary skin or is the bacterial film yes yeah I need to explain which skin is on your teeth I'm gonna ask my dentist this the next time I tell me dentist you must think about this which reminds me to book it this podcast is brought to you by tooth skin tooth skin we're not sure the only certainty is that we do not know this podcast is also brought to you by Mona Lisa cookies just barely edible this the dose that makes the poison this podcast is also brought to you by T-cells they do not do what you want them to do which is probably for the best if you have a body but not if you have research to do this podcast is also brought to you by octopuses with stabs knabs stabs stabs stabs they stab things with their Yes.
They've got stab stabby octopuses and ultra smart kangaroos who are talking about you behind your back. Yes. The book you've also got a project for awesome message for this edition of Dear Deboki and Hank. It's from Atlanta Maddie who says hello, Hank and John.
Sorry, I'm sorry, Atlanta. Yeah, I'm very sorry. He'll listen, I promise. From the wonderful music community over on Twitch, we raised money for the project for awesome together this year and it's been wonderful meeting fellow and nerdfighters on the platform.
I didn't know about this music community on Twitch. This is cool. Thank you for all you do as a longtime listener first time caller. It's been wonderful following you both on your journeys and finally getting to participate in this small way is an honor to you.
DFTBA. That's lovely. Thank you. Well, this episode of Dear Hank and John is brought to you by Shopify.
There are a lot of things that stand between I have an idea and this is an idea that actually exists in the world and people are buying things from me. And that is what Shopify makes easier. When you start with Shopify, the tools to design and launch and take payments, they're all there from day one. You don't have to build a whole machine before you can start building the business.
And this is important because you also have to look good and with Shopify's templates, you could get a site set up really quick. That looks credible and professional without needing to code or duct tape a bunch of different tools together. And when things look real, that works on my brain. To be like, I'm doing a real thing.
It also works on other people's brains. To be like, this is legitimate. Shopify also has one of the best checkout systems on the internet. It's built to help customers finish the purchase effectively and efficiently without a bunch of roadblocks.
Returning customers can check out with a single click. That means less friction and fewer abandoned carts and a smoother experience for everybody. That stuff gives you confidence early on and it gives other people confidence in what you're doing. You're not wondering whether the payment system is going to work.
You're not wondering whether customers can get through the process. Shopify handles that foundation so you can focus on the thing that you're actually trying to do. It's really kind of amazing to me that Shopify is a tool that works from the first day to launches when you're just starting to get customers all the way up to being the size of good.store or dftv.com or being the size of like Mattel and Gymshark. When you build a Shopify, you're building with tools that already work at every scale.
All you need is the idea, Shopify handles the rest. You can start your free trial at Shopify.com slash deerhank. Start your free trial at Shopify.com slash deerhank. With new subscription only, while supplies last until September 27th, 2026.
See website for more details. One thing I love about summary is how easy everything feels. The days are a little more relaxed. My kids don't have to wake up at five in the morning and I find myself reaching for the same comfortable go anywhere pieces again and again, which is why I keep coming back to quince.
I often wear either a long sleeve or a short sleeve button down from quince and it fits well. And I never have any complaints. In fact, sometimes I get compliments about it. I was at the airport a couple days ago.
I often find myself in airports and someone said, I like your shirt and I said, thanks. It's from quince. Quince is 100% European linen pants and shirts are breathable, easy to throw on, and the summer upgrade your rotation needs starting at just $34. Their tees are soft enough to live in all day, and the lightweight cotton sweaters are exactly what you want when those summer nights cool down.
So that's why I'm wearing quince this summer. And you can make your summer wardrobe easier by going to quince.com slash deerhank for free shipping on your order and 365 day returns. Now available in Canada too, that's qunce.com slash deerhank for free shipping and 365 day returns, quince.com slash deerhank. This episode of Dear Hank and John is brought to you by FACTOR.
Imagine for a moment that you are absolutely immersed in some work where you're creating something beautiful or useful or useless and ugly, but you love it anyway. And you look up and suddenly you have a feeling. And that feeling is that it is 2.30 PM and you did not eat lunch. What are you going to do?
Are you going to get meal delivery that's going to cost too much and maybe be a bit of a mistake? Or are you going to go to the cupboard and just eat several fistfuls of peanuts? Because those are my two choices unless I have a factor in the fridge. You can get smokey barbecue chicken breasts with potato mash, cream corn, and peppers.
You can get creamy lemon pepper chicken with veggie rice peel off broccoli and carrots. This has the fiber I need. It has the protein I need. And it has the deliciousness I need.
What about garlic herb roasted baromunty with potato zucchini and burr blanc sauce? I don't really know what that means, but it sounds delicious. What about a black bean taco bowl with corn salsa and cilantro crema? A delicious high fiber high protein meal that no animals had to die for?
Any of those can be ready in two minutes. Fresh, never frozen, over 100 rotating weekly meals, including globally inspired flavors like Mediterranean and Asian, factors, shops, perhaps cooks and delivers straight to your door. So you have more time for everything. You love this spring head to factor meals.com slash deer hank 50 off and use the code deerhank 50 off to get 50% off and free daily greens per box with new subscription only while supplies last until September 27th, 2026.
See website for more details. OK, our next question comes from Ben in Ohio who asks, in Andy Weir's book, Project Hail Mary, the main character mentions that turning on a flashlight in space would move the person holding it. Is this true? If a flashlight is brighter, is the force greater?
Oh, I mean, you're just going to have to guess that if Andy Weir is busting out a fact like that in a book that he is going to catch so much flack if he got it wrong. There's a very low chance that he's got it wrong. Yeah, I write books for science nerds. That's terrifying.
Yeah. I interviewed him when that book was coming out, and I was like, do you? And actually, I read it beforehand. And I'm like, I don't want to brag, but I fixed something.
Oh, nice. That's very exciting. I was like, you forgot a vector. Here's how I would rewrite it if I were you.
And he was like, wow, that would have been really bad. That's the. That's the vector straight. Yeah, there's there's there.
I would like to forget about it. I mean, I know it would be rude. But if I had done that, I would have been like, yeah, I correct it and do where? Yeah, I do.
Man, I read a lot of books where I'm like, they should have called me. But when it comes to physics and photons, do not call me because I have no idea. So yes, it would. But why and how?
And yes, it would be more if it was brighter. But like, explain to me how a thing that has no mass has momentum. Go. Like, I don't know.
Oh, I had decided to accept that as the premise for the answer. I was like, cool. Physicists say that photons have momentum. I'm going to accept that.
And from what little I understood when I was looking this up, because I was very confused. I was both confused and curious. Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. That actually does feel very apt to describe how I felt researching this question. There are like our equations for describing momentum that do have mass in them. But there are other ones that like then come into play that explain why light has momentum as well.
And so that's basically what's happening here. But at least from what I understand, if you wanted to try to get anywhere with a flashlight in space, like you're going to get there very, very slowly. Like, it's especially because if you're attached to the flashlight, you have a ton of mass. So I think that's going to slow things down a lot.
So the flashlight on its own would travel significantly faster. Yes. But that's not what you're trying to do. You're trying to get back to your spaceship.
And you can't. You only have one option is to get back to your spaceship where you die and you've got a flashlight. And the answer to this riddle is you die. Yes, you sure do.
Apparently, this is like a very popular question on exam. So we might be like helping some people cheat a little bit. But apparently, it's like even faster. Like this is like a trick question, or it's even faster if you just like throw the flashlight.
Like that's going to get you faster. But because you've thrown the flashlight, if you get lost, like if you made a mistake, then like you're kind of screwed because you're just on whatever trajectory. You can only throw a flashlight one time. Yeah.
So like the idea, and this like you could test this in a lake. Like if you're on a canoe, you can throw a rock and it actually like the harder you throw the rock, the more your canoe moves in the opposite direction because you've pushed against the rock and it's inertia. And that is how rockets work is they throw lots of rocks out the out their butts and it pushes them up. That's why they named it a rocket.
They just put together rock and butt and took out the beat. That's correct. Put it on the Wikipedia page, everyone. And cite this podcast.
Deboki, Chuck, have already said this. Don't vandalize Wikipedia. Especially in my name. There's not a lot of search results for my name.
I don't want this to be fun. Now that you have now that you've done this, now that you've involved our names, Deboki, I have to get rid of the fun and eliminate it. No, you can't. Don't vandalize Wikipedia.
Anyway, so you could throw the flashlight, or you could toss the photons out, but it's just a tiny force. But you did talk here about how it does matter. And there are things that we measure and that we have to account for this photon stuff. So there are these other weird effects that come up in terms of radiation and light and how that affects the movement of things in space.
There are actually asteroids that have their trajectory altered because of the way that sunlight will hit them. And if they're regularly shaped and rotating in a certain way, it's like the way that the light hits them will heat up one side of the asteroid. And then as it's rotating, it'll cool down. And that actually pushes the asteroid.
That cooling creates a force. So it's not the photons or just the photons? Yeah, I think it's really more radiation. Yeah.
Right, OK. Oh. Yeah, sorry. I put this here at first because that was the first thing that I came up and then I didn't delete it just because I thought it was cool because I've never heard about this.
It's called the Yarkovsky effect. Yeah. And it's like a thing that actually makes it harder for scientists to know if asteroids are going to collide with us. So that part's less cool.
But the effect is cool. So it's not like the asteroid isn't on a perfect path as would be defined by gravity because they're like, this tiny force is acting on them when they radiate heat away where they're basically giant flashlights but in the infrared spectrum. Yeah. Neat.
Yeah. Space is just a bunch of flashlights floating around. Yeah. That's how we see a lot.
I mean, when you're kind of looking at the stars, like most of the mass that is, you know, normal masses stars and they are big flashlights and we can see them. There they are. I can't actually right now. Stay time.
And I'm inside. It's cloudy. All the different things. Okay.
I'd say it's done. So the stars will be up very soon. Yeah. Oh man.
You're in Boston or in Massachusetts. So what do you get? Like what's your earliest sunset? Like 430.
I think we're now like something ridiculous like that. That's our sunset. 427 P. So not even 430.
That's the worst. Yeah. This next question, Deboki, comes from Bronwyn who asks to your hand. Deboki, last night in Vancouver, we had a very intense lightning storm.
And I was thinking about how much power it generates. I was wondering if people have ever tried to use lightning as a sustainable power resource, like solar power, just build really tall metal poles and then capture it somehow. I don't bran lose. I bran wind.
I like that. I didn't think I was going to like it as much as I did. Is it the saying it out loud makes it more fun? So I've heard that there are people who have wanted to do this and obviously like, this is a tremendous amount of energy.
There's a lot of energy that comes from water moving around in the sky and creating all this wind and then that creates this electrical differential that then can bridge a gap of many hundreds of feet when you're just or even more than that. These might be most huge. So there's a lot of energy. And I do want energy and I'd love for it to be created by storms instead of by fossil fuels.
And I remember writing about this in the old days in EgoGeek in like the early or mid-2000s and like there were people who had tried to do this, but there are problems. Yeah. Yeah. It seems really hard.
It's like all the other things that I've been thinking about. It's like a lot of energy. It's like a lot of energy. It's like a lot of energy.
It's like a lot of energy. But it's like over a super short amount of time. So you got to be super fast about it. You got to be able to store it all.
Yeah. It turns out unless there was a lightning bolt that just hit all of the time and never stopped, that would be great. But unfortunately, it's like one at a time. Maybe you could just like Ben Franklin and just like have the energy always coming down.
Yeah. Well, now that you say it like that, I feel like what we should do is figure out how to generate like a very localized lightning storm that is like in one spot and then just put the plant there and it's just always getting the lightning. Right. I don't see any downsides yet.
There is a place on earth that almost always has lightning. It's a lake in South America or like in Litt in South America. Interesting. And because of the geography of the area, it's pretty much a constant lightning storm.
Well, then it's perfect. That would be the place to do it. Yeah. Then we just got to figure out how to get the lightning.
That's the next challenge. Okay. Cool. The everlasting lightning storm.
I think we can do this. We just have to go. We have to go to Venezuela. Venezuela.
That's embarrassing. It's Venezuela. It's called Lake Montecaybo. And the shape of it.
So they have lightning storms, 140 to 160 nights per year, nine hours per day, 16 to 40 times per minute. So that's a lot, but it's not every day. But that is way more than I'm comfortable with. That is a lot.
It sure is. 16 to 40 times per minute. That's like almost once a second. Yeah, it is.
I think I'll stay here. Yeah. We got like three lightning storms a year. Can you imagine even having to try to like construct a plant in the middle of all this?
You're like, well, this is the one day of no lightning. No lightning on. So we can build this thing. Yeah.
But it comes in really hot. So it's hard to capture. Yeah. And then you have to store it because you can't just like send it onto the grid.
That would probably create some problems. And then electricity, I feel the same way as T cells. It's just like, I'm not sure anyone actually knows how this works. Yeah.
I feel that way about light T cells and electricity. That's it. Yeah, the rest of it. Devoking knows everything else.
It all makes perfect sense. We know everything there is to go. Yeah. And an expert also on Bible interpretations.
We really, I would pick the questions that go for my area of expertise. I mean, ancient Hebrew wasn't that hard to figure out for to put photons. Yeah. Has anybody done it?
Have they built at least a pilot plant? People have tested it out in 2007. Apparently a company tried out a system to do this. That's probably the thing I wrote about an ego key.
That's probably the very story I cover. The alternative energy holdings, Inc. Holdings is a good name because it's a business term for like a company that owns things. And then but also it's actually literally trying to hold alternative energy.
It's like it's mostly theoretical. Yeah. I think it seems almost like it's mostly like research rather than anything to do with practical. There is a company that has tried to set off electric activity in thunderclouds with ultra short lasers.
So that's combining light and electricity. So I believe it. Now we are very confused. That's definitely look you convinced me.
Where do I sign up? I'm an investor now. Yep. Devoking since since you are the science person on the podcast and I probably know more about ASU women than you.
Do you want to do the Mars news? Yeah, I'll do it. Okay. So we're in Mars news.
It's very exciting. Researchers have found organic molecules on Mars that they hadn't found before. Always fun to find some new molecules. And the researchers actually found out about this because like there was a drill on the Curiosity rover that was malfunctioning back in 2016.
And so they were like, well, we can't drill for rock samples right now, which we really wanted to do and we wanted to collect these for later experiments. But we still want to test some things out and they had these cups with premixed solvents in them. So they were like, we've got these samples from a beach. We're going to just dump some of that into this little cup of wet wet things and see what happens and see what we can learn from it.
And so they're actually trying out a new technique for them, which is called wet sampling. And so there have been previous ways that we found organic molecules like toluene and benzene and those are usually by heating the sediments up. So this is the first time they were trying it out with this wet sampling technique. And from that, they found benzoic acid and some other organic molecules that were new to them.
They also found ammonia, which is inorganic, but it's produced through the breakdown of other organic molecules. And so none of these tell us like how the molecules came around. They don't tell us like, you know, what's their some kind of life that was making it, but it is cool that like we have this technique and that we can use this to find these molecules because these were things that were harder to find potentially with the other techniques that they've been using. Doing wet chemistry on Mars.
Yeah, just like the octopus is wood. Yes. Maybe they've already done it. The dolphins have already been to Mars.
I mean, I wouldn't wouldn't put it past them. What if the dolphins have gotten to Mars and then that's why the water left and then they came out. What do they do drink it? I don't know.
So, and this we can air see one of the news, they're currently playing a couple of tournaments that I think that I am correct about this don't have an impact on standing. So they're in the football week trophy tournament, which I think that they probably are done with because they lost the first two games. But they're also in the FA Cup and they won the first game of the FA Cup. That sounds like they won the FA Cup in the FA Cup.
And that was against Gisley, which because I've never heard of that team, I think it's in a lower league. So it's like pretty good. Like if they'd lost that team, they probably couldn't have written a really bad sign. They got a game coming up.
So that's good. And the thing about the FA Cup, as far as I understand, is the higher you go, the more you get paid. So if you can get a couple rounds into the FA Cup, then you have a chance of playing a really big team and then you make a bunch of money because they get like TV broadcast and stuff. Right.
That makes sense. So if someone is not doing well, there are a couple of points out of the relegation zone. So if you're following along and listening in real time to the podcast, you will have heard at the beginning of the season when things were looking great and we were very excited. And now we're in a situation where if we lose a couple of more games, there's a good chance that we, we, we, we, I guess I'm an owner of the team, thanks to a gift from my brother, that we would be in the relegation zone.
The good news is we've got two games coming up against teams that are not very good or aren't very high in the standings. I don't know how good teams are. Portsmouth and crew Alexandra. So both of those teams are lower in the standings along with AFC women.
So this is not like we're playing like the best team in the league next week. So that's good. We're playing some, some lower down teams that we have a better chance against. And that's sort of what I look at when John's talking about it.
I'm like, are we going to play a team that's like really good and like, have we played a lot of the good teams and that's why we're lower down? I don't know. The bad news is that there are not a lot of goals, goals being scored, though appreciate moving out from the first round of the FA Cup. We don't know who we're playing for the second round.
If we draw a really good team for that, then maybe it'll be a little extra fun. So people can see AFC women play on their on their televisions. And that's all I know that I do a good job. I think so.
I have no idea. I don't I follow the AFC women updates and then outside of the podcast, I live in an Arsenal household where like this is a team that started out the season. I mean, just like my one piece of life advice because I'm showing up on this podcast is like if you have the option, like somehow to tie your life to someone who was an Arsenal fan, don't do it. Like I did it and I love this.
I love this. I love this man a lot. I've introduced a lot of a lot of tragic moments in our household and I still am now along for the ride. But you know, it is what it is.
So sometimes I follow the AFC women who've been used feeling like this sounds a lot like what being an Arsenal fan sounds like really yes, I love them so much. And then also no. Stop doing that. Yeah.
Well, the AFC women's story is quite a story, but what we need is a billionaire to come along and give them a little leg up. Please, please. Devoki, thank you so much for being on this podcast with me today. It was a pleasure and I learned a lot.
Thank you for having me. I also learned a lot about where my head will go with science. If you want to ask your questions to us, our email address is hinkantjon at gmail.com. And without those questions, we don't have a podcast.
So thank you so much to everybody for sending them in, whether they are about science or not. This podcast is edited by Joseph Tuna-Medich. It's produced by Rosie Anna Hals-Rohas. Our communication score winner is Julia Bloom.
Our editorial assistant. Hey, it's Devoki Chakra-Vardy. The music you're hearing now and the theme of the podcast is by the great Gonerolla. And as they say in our hometown, don't forget to be awesome.