*33.2 Makkos Daf 21 B (5 lines Up)*

*33.2 Makkos Daf 21 B (5 lines Up)*We learned in the mishna (32.3) that there’s a case where a man can plow one row and be liable for eight _malkos._ Ulla asked Rav Nachman why planting on Yom Tov was not included.*Summary**Rava: Only with regard to Shabbos there is a principle of _chiluk melacha_* _(each of the 39 melachos is a separate liability),_ but we do not have this principle for Yom Tov _(all 39 melachos are forbidden, but they are all lumped together as one prohibition. There would only be additional liabilities if there would be additional hasra’os, but it makes no difference whether the hasra’ah is for plowing or planting)._*Ulla: This is a good explanation!**Abayye: How can you say there is no _chiluk melacha_ on Yom Tov?**Mishna:* If one cooks and eats _gid hanashe_ with milk on Yom Tov, he is liable for five _malkos. (According to some, “Ein b’giddin b’nosein taam” a gid is not considered a food at all, it’s like cooking a rope. The idea here is that “Yeish b’giddin b’nosein taam”, a gid is considered a food)._ *1. Eating Gid Hanashe. 2. Cooking on Yom Tov* _(since gid hanashe is assur b’hana’ah, it cannot be cooked on Yom Tov)._ *3. Cooking meat and milk. 4. Eating meat and milk. 5. Lighting a fire on Yom Tov.*If there is no _chiluk_ melacha for Yom Tov, *why should there be two liabilities for Yom Tov* (#2, #5)?*Resolution:* #5 should be amended to read “The *_gid hanashe_ was of _neveilah”._* See acast.com/privacy for privacy and opt-out information. This podcast has been graciously sponsored by JewishPodcasts.fm. There is much overhead to maintain this service so please help us continue our goal of helping Jewish lecturers become podcasters and support us with a donation: https://thechesedfund.com/jewishpodcasts/donate