Skip to content
51. Is Everything Kosher? episode artwork

Jan 2, 2019 36 min

51. Is Everything Kosher?

from Talking Tachlis Podcast Hosted by Talking Tachlis Podcast

This week Uri is joined by another very special guest, the amazing Aliza Abrams-Konig! They start off with a discussion about the future of lab grown meat, which gets them into kosher certification and its boundaries, including this week's controversy surrounding comedian Leah Forster. They then talk about the recent controversy surrounding an anti-Semitic Instagram post from Lebron James. Finally, Aliza and Uri discuss their shared experiences on service learning trips, and conclude with a discussion about some of Aliza's recent personal challenges. Links: WSJ video about lab grown meat: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bjSe-0vSRMY 15 Kosher restaurants closed down last year: https://forward.com/food/416599/why-did-nyc-lose-15-kosher-restaurants-in-2018/?fbclid=IwAR0gI3IH4WCbocg_UW7_PNNytGpP_hswwv72g3pc0SVhQC10xyqpwg96XN4 Leah Forster allowed to perform: https://www.nydailynews.com/new-york/ny-metro-jewish-lesbian-comic-20181231-story.html?fbclid=IwAR2ukVEnt_H0WCoNVJ6Ov99QdvkPrQyHWFaTSTdommaviSijexcOidNKnzc Lebron James Instagram controversy: https://www.jpost.com/OMG/Lebron-James-apologizes-for-antisemitic-Instagram-post-575254 Aliza's Layers Project: https://thelayersprojectmagazine.com/alizas-story-the-ultimate-gift/ Music: 21 Savage - ASMR (explicit lyrics) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SiuQXje057M

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

This week Uri is joined by another very special guest, the amazing Aliza Abrams-Konig! They start off with a discussion about the future of lab grown meat, which gets them into kosher certification and its boundaries, including this week's controversy surrounding comedian Leah Forster. They then talk about the recent controversy surrounding an anti-Semitic Instagram post from Lebron James. Finally, Aliza and Uri discuss their shared experiences on service learning trips, and conclude with a d...

Ready to play

51. Is Everything Kosher?

0:00 36:16
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello and welcome. I'm Uri, and this is Talking Tachlan. It's the podcast where we talk about Jewish life and life in general. Rifki is away again this week, but again, we have a very, very special guest host, Aliza Abrams-Koenig. Hey. Welcome, Aliza. It's great to be here. Thanks so much for having me. Thanks for going away, Rifki. Aliza is the assistant principal of Central YU High School for Girls, but we know each other from Aliza's YU days. It's true. We've traveled around a lot together on service missions over the 10 years that I worked at YU and the bunch of years that you were affiliated with YU as a student. And then after, I guess, you also staffed a few trips. Yeah. Those trips were a lot of fun. We're going to get to that, I think, a little bit later in the episode. But first, I wanted to...

read a couple of listener feedback emails that I got. And these are actually both people that you know as well from our YU days. Great. So the first one is from Joshua Davidowitz, or Jeffrey, I think, as he goes by these days. Okay, good guy. Great guy. And he sent a follow-up on a topic that's come up a couple times on the podcast, which is alternatives to the traditional concept of meat that we eat and think of. So we talked about something called the Impossible Burger, which is like a vegetable-based burger that's supposed to taste exactly like meat.

I've had it. I don't think it tastes exactly like meat. It's missing that juiciness factor, but I will say it's better than like Morningstar. Right. There's no like random vegetables in it. You know what I mean? That's what I said also when I had one. It's like probably the best veggie burger I've ever had. And like no complaints about the taste. It tasted great, but it just didn't really taste like actual meat. Right. You can't expect a hamburger. Right. Just not a veggie burger. Well, so the other type of alternative meat that we've discussed is lab grown meat. So Yoshua sent us a link to a Wall Street Journal video where Jason Bellini from the Wall Street Journal went around to different scientists and entrepreneurs and companies who are all developing this type of...

lab grown meat um the first one in the video is actually an israeli guy wearing a yamaka which is cool i think there's some israeli companies at the forefront of this and so yeah obviously and so here's uh the beginning of that video What we're going to try today are the first thin slices of steaks we have produced in a lab setting. I think this is going to be the greatest revolution in the history of modern agriculture. This lab-grown meat is not just a plant-based alternative like the Impossible Burger. There's a technology that exists that allows us to, I mean, for all things purposes, have our bacon and eat it too, without any pigs being harmed. Cultured meat, lab-grown meat, clean meat, whatever you want to call it, is identical to conventional meat at the cellular level. Just grown in a lab, no slaughter involved.

Its arrival could have massive implications for meat-eaters, the US's $200 billion meat industry, and the environment, and it's happening at a pivotal time. We can't handle more agriculture, and this growing demand is asking precisely that, and we're going to reach a breaking point. Fascinating stuff. Yeah, so Elisa, what do you think? I mean, first of all, I highly recommend that our listeners watch the full video. It was really interesting, and they delve into the science behind this, as well as when we can expect to see this in our local restaurants. And they also discuss the impact that this technology may have on agriculture and the meat industry as we know it. But in addition to that, there's kind of like the Jewish side of the discussion, specifically as it pertains to kashrut. There's the philosophical ramifications, there are the ethical ramifications. You know, we just spoke very recently, Rifki and I, about the concept of, is the treatment of the animals...

should that factor into whether or not something is kosher or do we just narrowly look at, you know, was it slaughtered properly? If so, then it's fine. If not, then it's not okay. Like, you know, and then philosophically, you know, what if, I don't know all of the halacha about it, but if in terms of milk and meat together, would that be okay if it's not considered meat or maybe meat from a not kosher animal might potentially be okay? I'm not sure if that's how it works, but it's logical that it might be that way. Right. Or is it even considered really anything at that point if it's one cell? Definitely the treatment of animals.

is not something that I actually think about on a daily basis. But then when I stop and I think about it, I'm like, oh gosh, I feel bad. I do feel bad. I think my mind always goes to Rosh Hashanah time when you see those terrible clips of what's going on when people are doing Kaparos. And I've actually been asked by non-Jews who live like in that, in like different areas of Brooklyn, I've seen that. And they're like, do you do that too? And I'm like mortified. And I'm like, no, no, no, I grew up with pennies in an envelope. I actually once saw it in Sinek.

Oh, God. Yeah, I was a kid. But yeah, I think that's one of the stereotypical things that is most like Jews are most like ridiculed slash criticized for. I've seen it a lot. Yeah. And from understanding that the production of animal products is like terrible for the environment. There is a lot that's going on. So, I mean, listen, if they can create something that's healthy and is good for the world, that's really wonderful. I also do always think obviously there's a philosophical conversation around animal safety and or animal abuse. But then like in the clip, it's a 200 billion dollar, you know.

Industry. Industry, thank you. Like, what about those farmers? Like, they're not going to start working in labs. Like, what do they do? You know? And that also is a conversation to be had in relation to this. Definitely. Yeah, a lot of elements there. What about the part about, you know, a hashkacha or kosher certification?

being about more than just the technical food itself and the dietary laws that are in the Torah. So in light of recent current events, I'm sure you heard about Leah Forster and her, she's a comedian. She's originally from Bar Park. I believe she's still based in Brooklyn. She was supposed to do a set last night, New Year's Eve, at a kosher restaurant. The first kosher restaurant was told that they would lose their kashras from the Vod of Flatbush, I believe it was. And they said to her, listen, you know, no offense to you, but we got to cancel your show. A different restaurant offered to pick her up and then receive the same threat. And it reached, I saw it on NBC News. I saw it in the daily news. Wow, like mainstream media. Totally mainstream media.

media. And what was the reason they wanted to shut her down? Was it because she was a woman? Or I understand she's also a lesbian. So she's also a lesbian, but supposedly she doesn't even refer to herself. So it wasn't really even about that. But they knew that she's out. And that's been certainly the conversation happening in the broader world about that. But then, is it because she's gay? Or is it just because they also have the ability to shut something like that down? Like, does a cautious agency have the ability to go into a restaurant and say, sorry, we don't like what you're doing? It has nothing to do with the cautious in the kitchen. So my personal opinion is, I actually do think that they're not responsible for the atmosphere in a restaurant. You know, if it was like...

a strip club that wanted hashgacha, I would see Avad having an issue with that. But I know alcohol, a lot of times it's very hard for a kosher restaurant to have a bar. Yes. The dog hasn't seen it. I had a really hard time, I think, in the beginning. And they had to make rules with kids being there, had to be with adults. I get that. I get the concern for alcohol, but like adults are adults. Like wouldn't you rather them be in a kosher establishment than a non-kosher establishment if they're going to have a drink? I'm not talking about getting trashed and doing bad things, but like we have the opportunity to...

to create an environment that is literally kosher. Or you could just say like, no, and take away people's kosher. And that also feels very like bullyish and, you know, mafia-esque. I don't know. Yeah. And I think those are some critiques of various kosher agencies that you hear in different kinds of contexts. I mean, I understand. I saw an article also, I think that you sent me this week when we were preparing about a lot, how it's so hard for kosher restaurants in New York City to survive, even though there are so many Jews who keep kosher for various reasons, partially because they have to pay so much for the...

kosher certification. I think an article referring to 15 restaurants closed in New York City in 2018 that were kosher restaurants. And one of them was quoted as saying that it cost them annually $60,000 just for their hashkacha on top of their $13,000 a month in rent. So first of all, people always complain, like, why are the prices so high in kosher restaurants? But that's because they have to make a little bit of an income when they're paying those expenses. And they have to close on Shabbos and religious holidays, which are theoretically big days for the general public. Yeah, these are complicated things. And I don't think that the kosher agencies are, like, scamming anybody. But I wonder if they could be maybe a little bit more efficient or if any of our listeners have an answer of why.

it needs to be that expensive or why some of these problems exist. We'd love to hear from you and get a different perspective on that issue, but it does sometimes sound troubling. Totally. I'd like to get to the other listener feedback. This one is from Dove Goldstein. Hey, Dove. Another guy that we both know from our YA days. I think he came on one of our service learning trips. Yeah, I think he was on definitely a coast to coast in California. And I feel like he went on the trip I ran to Israel that was focused on medical ethics, but I might be wrong about that. That would make sense for him. If you're listening, David Eckstein, I saw him today. So shout out to David Eckstein, also a former participant. And I think of you, Dove. Awesome. Well, so Dove wrote about a topic that...

we've also touched on many times in the past, broadly speaking, the topic of anti-Semitism. Yes. And I actually just want to read what he wrote because I like the way he said it. He actually sent this to me a week ago, but here's what he wrote. Apparently, LeBron James shared an anti-Semitic lyric on an Instagram post. He has since apologized, deleted the post, etc.

What disturbs me, however, is the report that the league will apparently not fine or discipline James over this. NBA commissioner and member of the tribe, Adam Silver, famously banned former Clippers owner Donald Sterling for life after recordings of Sterling's racist conversations leaked. Why is this any different? We are a tolerant society, yet we tolerate anti-Semitism? LeBron is easily the league's highest profile player with over 45 million Instagram followers. Shouldn't this accentuate the need to show that even, quote, minor misdemeanors are unacceptable? Even if we let this kind of thing slide in the past, we are not even two months removed from the Pittsburgh shooting where the professional sports community rallied together against anti-Semitism, and now it's okay again? Finally, does Silver's own Judaism?

somehow grant him the authority to decide what is and is not anti-Semitic? End rant. That's from Dove. Thanks, Dove. Yeah, I mean, as soon as I heard about the LeBron James Instagram post, it immediately was, you know, I thought to myself, why is he getting away with this? You know, we're living in an era where everyone's calling out somebody else for something. And it seems that when it comes to the Jews, where everyone's a little bit more tolerant. And it's, in my opinion, it's like totally biased and not, it's not fair. Yeah, I think it's...

I agree overall. I think it's a little complicated. We can talk about it a little bit. Just to clarify for people who hadn't seen this story. So the song is from a rapper named 21 Savage. The song is called ASMR. And the lyric from the song that LeBron posted on his Instagram was, we've been getting that Jewish money. Everything is kosher. So here's the actual line in the song. So I think the context in the song is just about.

having a lot of money and buying expensive stuff and living a lavish lifestyle. And he refers to being rich as having that Jewish money. I think it could be worse in terms of anti-Semitism, obviously, but that's definitely not okay, I think. Totally. It's interesting. I mean, I want to talk about this more, but I've been to Poland a couple of times and actually in Poland, in the tourist shops, you know, you could buy magnets that say Poland or whichever city you're in. They actually have a magnet in like every shop that is a picture of a stereotypical looking.

I guess chassid, and he's holding a gold coin. And it's like totally like, yeah, Jews and their money. But non-Jewish people in Poland actually buy these and think of them as like good luck charms because Jews represent having money and they want to make a lot of money. That's really fascinating. Yeah. You know, and we're not talking about a country that wasn't heavily involved in the Holocaust. Yeah, I think that there's like this...

crazy like stereotype where people like to always joke or comment that Jews are smart and have money and they run the world. But why is that OK? Right. Well, I mean, I guess you could ask the flip side and we've discussed this in the past. Why is it not OK? Because LeBron himself, you know, in his apology slash not apology, which Rifki always critiques people's non-apologies. So this was definitely a non-apology. He basically he did apologize. But what he said was.

Apologies for sure if I offended anyone. That's not why I chose to share that lyric. I always post lyrics. That's what I do. I ride in my car, I listen to great music, and that was the byproduct of it. So I actually thought it was a compliment, and obviously it wasn't through the lens of a lot of people. My apologies. It definitely was not the intent, obviously, to hurt anybody.

Yeah. And it's funny because 21 Savage also actually issued an apology. And he said, the Jewish people I know are very wise with their money. So that's why I said we've been getting Jewish money. I never thought anyone would take offense. I'm sorry if I offended everybody. Never my intention. I love all people. Yeah. It's very interesting. To be honest, it could be that he's telling the truth, that he meant it as a compliment on some level, because objectively, our society values wealth and money. And so if you're saying that a group of people are all rich and have money.

That does sound like a compliment. Obviously, though, there are so many connotations when it comes to Jews. And I mean, I think LeBron is a pretty intelligent guy. He's also politically outspoken and involved. So for him to say, to plead ignorance and say that he had no idea that talking about Jewish money could be offensive, I think is very hard to believe. And in his apology, first of all, it's very cliche when people say, I apologize if I offended anyone. As if like, I didn't do anything really that bad. But if you were offended, I'm sorry. As opposed to saying I did something wrong. Totally.

Part of this story, I don't want to, like, psychoanalyze LeBron too much. I don't think he's a bad guy. I honestly don't know that much about him. But so this Instagram post came out last Sunday. The previous Friday, two days before, LeBron was on this HBO show called The Shop, where different athletes and celebrities were kind of talking about issues of the day and politics and stuff. And in that episode, LeBron actually criticized the owners of the NFL. And he said...

I got that slave mentality. And it's like, this is my team. You do what I tell y'all to do or we get rid of y'all. So he's defending the NBA and the culture of the NBA and criticizing the NFL. But basically, he's talking about old, white, rich dudes with a slave mentality that think the players are their slaves. And then two days later, he talks about Jewish money. That's not a proof, but it seems to be that there's a connection. It seems to be that's on his mind or that weekend he was thinking about it. I don't think it's far-fetched to say that he...

very likely knew at least somewhat what he was saying. And it's upsetting that it wasn't really a big deal. He wasn't fine. I mean, I was talking to some people about this and they were telling me about these baseball players who are getting in trouble now for tweets that they tweeted in high school that were homophobic or racist and like objectively terrible things, but they were children at the time and separate conversation if that's okay or not for us to know. criticize or fine them for that. But this is something that LeBron tweeted now. And so it is a little bit upsetting. Yeah, I think also like LeBron is in his own league. Like he's really, I mean, you mentioned the article says he has over 48 million Instagram followers. He's 45. Well, maybe he lost two anyways. But, you know, he's truly recognized in many areas for his greatness. He's created schools. He's funding programs left and right. He's, you know, recognized because he's stayed married to the same woman and has a bunch of kids. And he's such a great guy. You are in a tremendous role of responsibility. You're not just a basketball player. You need to.

In my opinion, think about every word you say. Or held to a higher standard than the average person. Correct. Because people are looking to you. Yeah. And I would even say, like, maybe, even though we've seen this happen, when you're, you know, in the locker room and you say something versus, you know, sending something out over Instagram or Twitter. Right. Like, that's also, like, this is now forever. He chose to amplify and express that to the world. Exactly. And, you know, as it says in Spider-Man, you know, with great power comes great responsibility. And he's got a lot of young people who are looking up to him. Yeah, for sure. Well.

Changing topics again, I just want to get in as much as we can while I have you here. I'll come back again. Okay, we can do that too. But now getting back to what we said in the beginning about the service learning trips, you know, talking about LeBron being a leader, whether he likes it or not, that kind of brings us to the concept of leadership and the service learning trips, which we're supposed to create, I guess, the leaders of tomorrow. So maybe we can talk about that a little bit, the kind of the thought behind it and whether or not it is or was successful. Do you want to explain a little bit what the idea behind these, what they are, these trips, and what the idea behind them is and was? Sure. So in, I would say, 2005, 2006, at the beginning of my career at YU,

We started talking about service missions. Now, a lot of people know what a chesed mission is, one that went to Israel, especially 2005 was not long after the Intifada. A lot of people are going back to spend money in Israel and visit with communities in Israel. But we took it to a different level. It wasn't to the exclusion of Israel. But service learning missions is an experience that's supposed to be immersive, where one is going into a community to do service.

It's hands-on work that could be anything from volunteering in a school to literally building homes to working in a soup kitchen. It doesn't matter exactly what the service is. But it's not just a one-day type of pop-in, pop-out. It's meant to be at least a few days on the ground wherever it is that you're working. And then the learning component that comes alongside it is that from having such an immersive experience, you are having a life-shaping experience. And I personally like to use the terminology life-shaping as opposed to life-changing because I think that makes it a little bit – life-changing is like way grandiose. Yeah, exactly. Whereas life-shaping leaves you with the experience and what do you walk away learning?

We actually, I would say the first like real service trip that I did was heading down to Houston right after Hurricane Katrina. It was not with a large group of white students. It was myself and two other people and both who are very involved in their own communities today. And it. It's about interacting with the people. It's not just like a flyby volunteer experience. And those types of experiences led to us creating winter break missions where we would take YU students for 10 days. In the summer, we led trips for four weeks and we went everywhere. We took groups to Israel, obviously. But again, it wasn't just, you know, hanging out in the typical hotspots in Jerusalem. It was going down south and volunteering in Yerucham and Dimona, which are these development towns that have very little resources in comparison to, you know, the bigger cities. I've led trips to Haiti. I've led trips to Ukraine. We've had groups in Thailand. Where else did we go? I'm trying to think. Well, I went with you to Newark.

Orleans and Alabama. Yes, that was amazing. After the tornadoes and also Katrina cleanup many years later. Totally, totally. And I actually did a Katrina trip the first January after they were allowing people to come into New Orleans and do volunteering. We were of the first groups, I believe, at least student groups that had gone down to volunteer. And I still remember it on our Birmingham trip. We basically were actually supposed to go to New Orleans and then the tornadoes happened and we switched the itinerary in like two weeks. Right, to include Birmingham. Yeah, and like our group slept on the floor in the shul. It was pretty wild. It was a lot of fun. I'm sure it was, yes.

I remember you literally walk into a neighborhood and there is like nothing. Like all you see is like pieces of a home. You know, the stumps of trees because the trees are just blown away or knocked over. And it's... True, true devastation. And you've never met the people whose house you're literally taking down to the base of it, and yet they're so appreciative. And you build this bond with people you'll never see again, but you know you're helping. And I certainly am in touch still with people who have been on trips with me who still say they think about the experiences they've had. Even in Haiti, one of the things that still sticks with me is driving around in our air-conditioned bus, which was not fancy by any means, but you knew was different than everyone else on the street who was walking, and literally passing by people who were waiting at these gigantic water bucket things. I don't even know what the word for it is, just to wait for clean water. Yeah.

Yes, right. So Elisa and I went together. We went out west to California. Yes. That was mostly working with Jewish communities, but we did some volunteering and education stuff. Yeah, we volunteered at the homeless shelter. It's called The Mission, I think it is, in LA. And it's like literally a town of all homeless shelters. It's pretty wild. And that wasn't Jewish. Definitely not. Yeah. And then we also went to Israel together. That was a little bit different. That was Operation Healthcare that we think still may have been. Yes, yes, yes. Right, Operation Healthcare. And then we also, like, we were talking about the New Orleans and Birmingham trip. You said you went to Haiti. And I also went to Nicaragua on a different, similar trip. Also, very, very eye-opening. I think everybody, I'm still in touch with a bunch of people who were on that trip. And we still talk about it.

it first of all many years later and i think the impact that it had on us really was very strong but you were explaining to me earlier that um a lot of these trips are not happening as often as they were in the past why is that and what was the result did people find that they weren't as effective as they hoped they would be or was it a money thing like i know a common criticism when why you would send groups to nicaragua or haiti was why aren't you helping jews there's so many jews who need help that's one type of criticism another criticism is obviously You know, where the privileged upper class like Americans going into these underprivileged poor areas. And there's like that dynamic that's a little bit uncomfortable. It involves race. It involves money. That's a little bit complicated. And then also, why leave New York City? There's so many homeless and poor and people who need our help right here in Manhattan and in the five boroughs. Why do we need to fly across the world? All these kinds of questions, you know, have always been asked. I mean, what are your that's a lot. But yeah, look, even the money spent on these trips, you can literally build a school, you know, I think that the.

One of the reasons why I think these trips stopped is because I think people shifted, meaning funders of these programs shifted where they were giving their money. They felt, certainly from some studies that I saw, that they weren't seeing like a major impact. I actually always felt that certainly the students I was working on were being impacted. I see it to this day. One of the students who came on the Counterpoint Israel program who spent like I think three or four summers down south in Israel.

Sam Weinstein, he actually just moved to Israel, I think two weeks ago, and is already doing a fundraiser for an organization that he had worked with when he was a college student. He's doing a run with a colleague of mine, actually. I think that because of the upbringing that YU students had in particular, which, you know, we joke is very, you know, secluded and bubble and whatever. I don't like when people refer to it as the bubble. But for all intents and purposes, yes, we've grown up. There's something to that. Yeah. You know, growing up in the communities we grew up, but we're not exposed to the extreme poverty that the communities we're volunteering in live on a daily basis. And even a community over, meaning it's not like our...

community is even stepping into lowering the communities in new york city they might pass people on the street but they're not getting to know their story and i do think that when a yu student in particular can go into a place like nicaragua or haiti and for the first time in their lives be like whoa this is extreme poverty i mean we we went to a hospital in haiti where you literally saw people walking in because they the or rather the understanding is that you only go to the hospital when you're on your deathbed because you can't afford to get there anytime sooner. And here we are with healthcare. You can go to the doctor every time you sneeze. And to appreciate that, that's what I felt why you students came home with was this extreme appreciation for all that they had and then what they did with it next. And I do see that there are a number of people who have told me that they went into Jewish education or they went into the rabbinate or they went into other forms of work, communal work, social work, because of their experiences on these trips. And to me, that means that it was worth every penny.

Right. I think also, right. So you were talking about Haiti. My experience in Nicaragua was also, I mean, before I just said eye-opening to elaborate a little bit on that. On the one hand, it's seeing the level of poverty, but we had a lot of discussions in the AWS people. Like some of the stuff they talked about got political and like sort of like anti-American, like sort of blaming America for all the problems in the world. That's a separate issue. But just in terms of humanizing people, first of all, understanding that the overwhelming majority of the people in the world do not live the way we live in a big city with the basic comforts of life.

not in terms of access to clean water access to health care we're talking about the majority of the people in the world do not have those things in the way that we do and just understanding that is just very important but at the same time it's also like i don't we were it was explained to us and it really resonated with me like the point is not just to feel bad for all those people it's to see that they are people also and they have their lives and they have their issues and their families and their problems and their happiness and their everything else that we have it just may be in a different way um and it's i guess a little bit broadening our perspective too so we really did interact with people they spoke spanish those language barrier but some of us spoke spanish and they spoke a little bit of english and we did communicate we had like a very fun We were there for Shabbos. There was like a Havdalah ceremony we did that they joined us for, which was really cool. Yeah, so just like a combination of all those things. Ostensibly, we were there to build this bridge, an actual physical bridge that we did build part of. And then other groups who went after us completed it, we ended up seeing pictures of the completed bridge. But yes, we could have just sent the money and locals could have built it. But I do think, I think you were getting at the follow-up. I think they were saying then also, if we just come home and then never think about it again, then the trip was a waste. But if we do think about it and then think about...

people who need help in our local community, or what other types of projects can we start and get other people to start and be involved in, that would make it a success. And you're saying that there was follow-up. You know specific cases of that follow-up. But you're saying even still, the funders are maybe not on board. Yeah. I mean, listen, I think people who have the money are entitled to give it where they want. They certainly, I saw that there was a shift, at least at AJWS, that instead of funding college students to go on trips, they then started funding.

just the educators and rabbis, I believe, because they felt that at least then they were taking what they learned and putting it into curriculum or into, you know, speeches and other spaces where they were teaching. These are people who are already going to be going into that type of work. Exactly. Like it might be, look, there are always kids who go on these trips who are just looking for a unique experience. But I still feel so strongly that the people who went walked away with something changed in them. And like you said, like you've made lifelong friends through those experiences. I think of all the experiences, there was something that truly shifted in people when they were having this type of a shared experience. Like so outside your comfort zone, so eye-opening that it's just,

Could you not walk away with that type of experience? And we definitely always have focused on doing volunteer work locally when we got back. And just another, you know, commonality we have, we had actually established a day of service in memory of our friend Ilan Sokayer, who had been on many trips. Who actually was on a Nicaragua trip with me. Yeah, I think I met Ilan through my first trip that I ran with him. He was on the first trip actually that I ran. Maybe not the first trip, but the second trip or so that we went to New Orleans. That was the one that went shortly after Katrina. And, you know, I, yeah, I mean, he's somebody who we volunteered alongside many times with and, you know, hope to continue.

keeping him in mind when we continue our volunteering. Yeah. Well, so Elisa, like, as you mentioned, you worked at YU for 10 years, then you had a very exciting transition to Central, where you're the assistant principal. How did the work that you did at YU carry over and come with you into your position at Central? Great question. First of all, I loved my work at YU. And the only reason really why I left for Central was because the opportunity presented itself. And I actually had always dreamed about being a principal, but I didn't actually want to be a formal classroom teacher. And so I took the route of communal service, communal work, and ended up at YU and loved every minute of it. And then this opportunity presented itself based on my experience and what I brought to the table. Central wanted me to come in as an assistant principal. And, you know, sometimes I joke that one of the best parts about being in a high school setting is at night when the kids leave. So they call me Mrs. Koenig. And I'm like, bye, Mrs. Koenig. See you tomorrow. I'm like, that's right. When I was at YU, like if the pizza for Midnight Madness didn't show up at 12 o'clock, like I was getting a phone call and I had to deal with that at midnight. So I do love that there are other people

taking care of my students at night. But what I brought with me was, I definitely brought, you know, this passion for experiential education and for service learning to Central. They already have a fantastic program. They actually call it CSI, Community Service Initiative. And each grade goes out and volunteers. We have a very active chesed club in school. Now at Central, one of the draws to coming there was that I interact literally with 300 students on a daily basis. They're fantastic kids. When I was out on medical leave, I had a kidney transplant last year. That could be another podcast. But not a day went by where a student or a teacher didn't reach out to me to just say, hey, how are you doing? And it's really incredible.

to be a part of a community like that and to be able to know that I am. directly impacting students on a daily basis. And it's really special. I think they're very, very lucky to have you. And because you brought it up, and I think we would be remiss if we didn't mention it, you were very open about your kidney transplant and everything that went along with it. And I think this is similar to, we spoke to Abby Wasserman last week, and she had a similar thing with infertility that she helped break down some of those taboos and being very open about her struggles and other people really related. And you had this in terms of the kidney transplant. I mean, what was, in a nutshell, because we don't have that much time, but first of all, I really commend you for that. It was really, really amazing. Thank you.

of you and I think you really inspired a lot of people um what do you what was that like did you feel I'm sure it was not easy to be to feel so exposed like that yeah um it was probably a two-year process until I actually felt comfortable sharing my story from the point that I actually had reached out to Shira Lincoln Sheps initially about the layers project and I just said here's a little bit about my story but I'm not ready to share and she said to me well when you're ready to share you come back and tell me and um it was just a few months ago September October time where I felt like I'm getting more comfortable and I'm ready to share more of the backgrounds of the story. To be perfectly honest, I felt like in the community, people had heard that I had a transplant. Some people didn't hear that I had a transplant. I knew people were sort of whispering, and I felt that if I shared the story, I owned the story, and nobody was asking my siblings questions about me. Instead, now they knew that they could either come directly, they're probably still asking my siblings, but at least the information was out there in a way that I was comfortable with. It was a really, you know, bearing your soul kind of experience, but I also felt a tremendous weight lifted off of my shoulders by sharing it. I am a very private person, even though I'm a very public personality.

But I also felt that I was doing a service to myself and to the community because we are so quick to say, like, everything's fine or to make assumptions. And it was important to me. Somewhat similar, somewhat different, though, to Abby. You know, people always wondered. My husband and I, we married four years on January 4th. And people were asking other people in my family why I wouldn't have children yet. It's none of anybody's business. But now they know it's because I had kidney disease. And it would not have been a healthy decision for me to have children. And it wasn't because I was struggling with fertility issues. And my heart goes out to people who do.

But there are people in our community who do not have children, not because they have fertility issues, just for a variety of reasons. And we shouldn't make those assumptions about people. And that experience of letting people know that was super empowering. And that is why I'm so happy that I did that Layers Project experience. Yeah, that's amazing. And we'll definitely include a link to that piece in the description on the episode. Thank you. Well, Elisa, thanks so much for joining me on this episode. If for no other reason, we got to hang out a little bit. It's been a while. It's definitely been, and it was great to be here. Yeah, and we got to cover a good number of topics. That was pretty fun. Thank you so much for the experience. Again, Rifki, thanks for going away. I couldn't have done this without you. But really, Uri, it was great to be a part of this, and thanks for inviting me.

Of course. And if any of our listeners have any comments, questions, feedback, things you want us to talk about, we'd love to hear from you. Our email is TalkingTalklessPodcast at gmail.com, or you can interact with us on our Facebook page, Talking Talkless Podcast, and we'll see you next week. Bye!

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Talking Tachlis Podcast?

This episode is 36 minutes long.

When was this Talking Tachlis Podcast episode published?

This episode was published on January 2, 2019.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Talking Tachlis Podcast episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.