Skip to content
AI-Powered Spam Comic Projects Invading Kickstarter episode artwork

Aug 25, 2024 1 hr 4 min

AI-Powered Spam Comic Projects Invading Kickstarter

from ComixLaunch: Crowdfunding for Writers, Artists & Self-Publishers on Kickstarter... and Beyond! Hosted by Tyler James

A ComixLaunch listener alerted Tyler to a sudden and suspicious proliferation of seemingly AI-Generated Comic Book Kickstarter projects that have appeared on the platform recently. After taking a look, it does indeed seem like something fishy is going on, and one or more actors have been able to get obviously soulless, fraudulent projects past the Kickstarter project screeners. In this session, Tyler shares signs of obviously fraudulent comic book Kickstarter projects, discuss the ramifications should projects like this proliferate on Kickstarter, and offer advice on what legitimate creators should do now.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

AI-Powered Spam Comic Projects Invading Kickstarter

0:00 1:04:12
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

It's going to be a juicy one. It might get your blood boiling a little bit. I got my blood boiling a little bit once I dove into it. Prepare to launch in three. This is Comics Launch, crowdfunding for writers, artists, and self-publishers on Kickstarter and beyond. This is the show that teaches you the mindset, strategies, and tactics to fund your dream projects, energize and expand your fan base, and take your creative career to the next level. You'll hear some of the top minds in crowdfunding share what's working now for independent and entrepreneurial creators like us so that you can successfully bring more of your art to a world that needs it without waiting for anyone's permission to take action. If you're getting ready to launch, you're in the right place.

Comics Launch Session 475, AI-powered spam comic projects invading Kickstarter. Today's session is sponsored by Worst and Mayhem, a medieval caustic D&D-style adventure comic. Issue 2 is live now on Kickstarter. Go to worst-mayhem.com to be part of the adventure. Alright, hello everybody, Tyler James back from the Comics Launch Podcast, and today's episode we're going to talk about something that came up recently that I noticed that a Comics Launch listener tuned me into, and this is a sudden explosion of what seemed to be spammy.

fraudulent projects powered by generative AI tools that have somehow made it past the Kickstarter screaming mechanism and went live on the Kickstarter platform. And so what I ended up doing was jumping on and doing a live stream and pointed out a bunch of these projects and talked about how to identify these projects, where these projects may be coming from, what might be the reason for these projects, and a whole lot more. And so I'm going to share the stream audio. on this episode of the Comics Launch podcast. But then after the break, I'm going to provide an update on some developments, some positive developments related to this issue. And I think you're going to maybe be as concerned, but also hopefully vigilant about this new issue that may be just a blip or maybe something that we see more and more and we'll really have to stay on to. So I think you're going to enjoy this one. Before I dive into that, I did want to just mention currently on Kickstarter, four days left for the latest Sync Monsters campaign. This is the...

14th and 15th issue. It's a double-sized issue of the Sync saga that is continuing that saga right now. We're closing in on 350 backers, and I already have over $21,500 pledged. A real big bonus to the campaign was that we had some original art from Alex Cormick that he was willing to put up during the campaign. And so in what is usually a down period of the campaign, sort of the middle stretch, we've been running a...

original art sale and have been moving a number of high-priced premium products. So a really nice bump, even though this is usually a time of the campaign when things tend to be slow going. A lot of that bump is coming from... big time fans, people that are big time collectors and have been following this series and have been sync fans for a while. So it's always great to activate them. But again, it's a general reminder that if you are sitting on original art, Kickstarters can be an incredible time to make that available during your launch. And there are some creative ways to offer it and we did some things where we didn't put everything up all at once. We sort of teased what might be coming and put some things up, reminded folks that there were some time constraints on them as well as things sell.

using that as an opportunity to bring in new pieces so that more people would purchase. Also, one of the things that I made the call of as we were putting up some of these pieces, we did not have large format prints up, but we had had a lot of requests for those. And the difference in price between an original art piece and what you might charge for a large format print might be as much as 10 times as much. And so I did also put up some prints that our backers can choose to purchase as well for fans that really like the original art. don't necessarily have the budget for the original original art. So we've been offering some premium signed prints at, you know, a much more affordable price level, but still a price that where it makes sense for us to be able to ship those and send those in packaging that's going to protect it and to sort of do that separately from fulfillment during the campaign.

We've got some original art sales going on right now for the sync campaign, which has been a nice boon. Curious how the final four days are going to go, whether we'll have the bump we usually see in terms of getting return backers. Return backers have been really powering this launch. We have gotten some new backers, but this is largely powered on bringing returning backers back. And so we've been trying to do that, but we'll see where it all shakes out when the campaign is over. All right, let's jump into today's topic. It's going to be a juicy one. It might get your blood boiling a little bit. I've got my blood boiling a little bit once I dove into it. But this is one that about...

what seems to be a sudden proliferation of, I'm going to argue, spammy, fraudulent projects on the Kickstarter platform that are clearly made possible by AI technology, not just AI art, but also a chat GPT style generative text. And I am... wanting to bring this up because this is something that could be problematic. And so we're going to talk about this. And this was something that actually came as a result of me getting an email from a comics launch listener. Shout out the comics launch podcast comes out every Sunday, wherever you listen to podcasts, C-O-M-I-X-L-A-U-N-C-H for comics launch. Just search for it, get it in your feed, listen to it each and every week. And, but this came from a listener. And so here's what the email said. It said the title was Kickstarter AI projects. And so that was the subject line.

Before I clicked on it, I'm thinking, hmm, I wonder if this person's going to ask, hey, are AI projects okay on Kickstarter? Can you launch AI projects on Kickstarter? Or maybe it's a question about have I seen AI projects on Kickstarter or what are my thoughts on it? And AI is a big topic. It's a hot topic. It's a controversial topic. It's a topic that a lot of creators have very, very strong feelings about. And so I wasn't even sure I was going to open that email or get into it because that can send you down a rabbit hole. But it turns out I opened it and it did send me down a rabbit hole.

Here's what the creator named Matt said. He said, hey, Tyler, just wanted to share because I've never seen anything like this before on Kickstarter. There's eight new projects by first-time creators, and it all feels bot slash AI generated from start to finish. At a minimum, they all seem to share the same campaign format. The creators have zero backing of other projects, very short timeframes, and then there's the telltale AI art of it all. Even giving them the benefit of the doubt that these are legit, the smallest amount of research would tell them what the bare minimum is needed for a project to succeed. Assuming fake, what would the end goal?

for doing this be. It all seems weird. I appreciate your thoughts. Cheers, Matt. And so, hey, first, thanks, Matt, for listening to the show and reaching out and giving me something to talk about today. And my first reply to Matt was, hey, man, send me some links and I'll take a look at them. But then I was curious, you know, if Matt was able to pick these projects out as obviously AI, maybe it would be pretty easy to see exactly what he's talking about.

And so what I did based on what he shared to me is I just hopped on Kickstarter, clicked on the comics tab, and then I used my filters and sorted live projects and then sorted by newest because he said these projects all popped up relatively recently. And so I scrolled through a few and there's some real projects here. This one from Simon Burks. He's a creator that is in the Comics Launch Pro programming community. And so I know that he's a real project. I know that he's a real project. But after scrolling through a little bit, I did notice.

wait a minute, what's this right here? What exactly is going on here with this project right here? And I noticed how, wait a minute, what exactly does this say? The project is named Quantum Detective, but this is the... Yeah, it's just nonsense. And I know that one of the telltale signs of AI art is that it is not very good at writing actual English. It just has the ability to replicate something that looks a little bit like text, but is not actually...

text. And the text doesn't actually represent what's over here. And then the project right next to it, the timekeepers, kind of has the same thing. This text looks a little bit like timekeepers, but that's not how you write timekeepers. And that doesn't look like a legitimate logo. And then the subtitle is absolutely nonsense. So right off the bat, here's a couple. And then the next crew, like this one looks a little, well, this one looks like, all right, maybe this is a real one. The enchanted artifacts, I can't really see that. And this one, the magical marketplace, just from the project image.

Could this be real from the project image? Could this be real? Sure. Okay. This one, maybe not this one as well. So I'm looking at these projects and I'm noticing a couple of other things just about these projects. One, a bunch of these creators have first name, middle initial, last name.

First name, middle initial, last name. First name, middle initial, last name. First name, middle initial, last name. First name, middle initial, last name. I know a lot of creators do go like that, but it's not the most common thing. And so that was a little bit of a tell for me. And so I started opening up these projects and taking a look at these projects and just doing a quick scroll through. And I noticed that much like Matt said, so many of these projects had a very similar structure.

and a similar setup. Sometimes they started with a video, but they had small sections, some art, and they looked quite similar in their structure. And so I'm looking at a bunch of these and I'm like, okay, they're not all exactly the same. And the content is more or less around what the project title is, but these projects look very, very similar in terms of the structure. And this is not like the most common Kickstarter structure of how projects are structured. So that was weird. So this is sending out a lot of bells. And so my...

take as of right now is that there are at least eight, if not more projects on Kickstarter right now that all seem to be soulless projects, spammy projects. And so what I want to go over with you right now is how to identify AI generated spam projects. Because the reality is when I look at this list of telltale signs of AI generated spammy soulless projects, any one of the signs that I'm going to share with you here. would not necessarily be absolute confirmation or proof that it is a spam project. But the more of these that you have, the more likely it is that these projects are actually not legit and not spammy. Before I get into this, though.

It is worth noting that Kickstarter does allow AI art and AI technology to be used to launch projects. It does. But one of the things that it requires is that you detail in detail how AI is being used for AI projects when you use AI. And one thing that I noticed is that none of the projects that I am calling out as AI generated projects, none of them have declared how they are using AI. So this image right here for the quantum detective, clearly an AI image. They did not disclose that this is an AI image.

this project should potentially be in violation of Kickstarter's terms of service just on its face. So that is something that, and we'll talk about whether or not we should report these and what we should do about these kinds of projects. But let me talk about how to identify some of these AI-generated spam projects. What are the telltale signs that what we're dealing with is that they're not like us, okay? That these are spammy AI-generated projects. So one of the first telltale signs that I mentioned is that the project image is using a clearly AI-generated project image. This image...

which if you look at it quickly, it's a beautiful art. You know, it's nice stylist, cyberpunk, cool, you know, visuals, the color is nice. But when you look closely, it has some of the issues that AI art has. It has the text that is nonsense text. If you look at the text on the wall, nonsense writing for the text that's on the wall for these newspaper images. Other project images, you know, this one, less totally noticeable AI, except for there's some extra.

hands and arms and weird arm artifacting going on here. So if you look closely, you can tell that. Again, this is one where the title, it got the title right, but the subtitle. doesn't make sense. And it doesn't match. And usually you'd have the spirit of the forest here is the title. And then usually you would have the name of the writer maybe underneath it. But where the writer name is, is nonsense text that doesn't match the writer of the project or the project creator. Here's another one also with some nonsense writing in it and really wonky hands, which we know is a telltale sign of AI art. So right off the bat, an AI generated project image is a telltale sign. Now again, Kickstarter will let you use AI generated images for your Kickstarter project image, as long as you disclose it.

but they didn't disclose it here. So that's number one. Number two is that one thing I noticed with most of these projects is that they have an unrealistic project goal, usually five figures. So Quantum Detective, 5K goal, all right? Adventure in a Parallel World, 10K goal. Witch Hunter, 20K goal. Spirit of the Forest, 25K goal. The Time Traveler's Diary, 14,999 goal. Forgotten Kingdom, $12,000 goal. The Cyberpunk Chronicles Rebellion in the Neon City, $25,000 goal. The Forgotten Realm, $20,000 goal.

The Darkness of the Moon, $12,000 goal. And these are all examples of projects where their project goal, with the exception of Quantum Detective, which is a 5K goal, all the other projects, while there are plenty of projects out there that will set their goals there and actually hit them, these project goals, compared to what they've done since launching, is so far out of whack that it was clear that either they were clueless about how the Kickstarter platform works or the kinds of audience that you need to have to hit a goal like that. And it just seems like it's an arbitrarily set goal at much higher than it should be. So again, none of these projects are funding and we'll talk a little bit about that. That's not the main issue that we're dealing with, but that is something that, you know, a really unrealistic five-figure goal would be a telltale sign for that project might be off. All right. Now, the other thing that all these projects have in common is, or most of these projects have in common, I should say, is that

Most of the project creator is a first time. This is the first created project and they have backed zero projects before. So we're seeing now this one, let's check out Sandra because I'm saying Sandra is not real. And she actually is the only one I've seen that has two projects created. And it looks like the last time she created a project, she ended up canceling the project. So this project was, was canceled on August 10th and it looks like she relaunched it.

a couple of days later. Okay. So, so, so this project, even though this creator, even though they have two projects created, it was the same project launched a couple of days ago by the same creator. So it's still only one project created. Oh, this is a project that was launched. Okay. That's when I just looked, looked at the witch hunter here. So this one is another one first created zero backed another one first created zero backed first created. Let me guess this project by Rachelle is first created zero backed. We have the forgotten kingdom, which is

by Matthew J. Condon, first created, zero backed. So again, you're going to see a lot of first created, zero backed on these. The next telltale sign is that rarely will you find a photo of the creator and there's really no face behind the project, no actual human face behind the project at all. So Matthew J. Condon, his project creator image is of a, looks like AI generated art of a female, not usually a name for Matthew. David A. Gillespie, looks like AI generated fantasy imagery of a female. We have Felicia.

has an image of a baseball field. We have Jason T. Cantrell. And this project, The Darkness Under the Moon, has actually got two backers, pledged $603. But again, just a weird graphic image for his project profile image. And then if you scroll down any of these pages, you won't find a single human face anywhere on here. You won't find a real picture of anyone on the creative team, not the project, not the writer, not the artist, not anyone on the team, not the publisher.

So that's definitely a serious telltale sign that these projects aren't legit. The other thing, yeah, so I said first, so these creators also, as I mentioned, zero backed. Most cases, they haven't backed a Kickstarter project. Like in fact, none of these creators that I'm flagging here have ever backed a Kickstarter project. And if you've been listening to the Comics Launch podcast for any time, you know, backing the project definitely helps to know the platform and to be seen as a valid user of the platform. And as a part of the Comics Kickstarter community, you want to back projects. So that's another telltale sign that this is not a legit project or creator.

Another sign is very generic creator bios. Now, again, this is the sneaky thing that makes generative and AI word processing tools difficult. It's like, it would be very easy. Hop on ChatGPT and generate some. realistic sounding bios. And so for example, this project creator is named Myesha Baker from Ontario, Canada. Of course, just a AI generated fantasy image for her profile name. But her bio is, we are a team of passionate creators specializing in sci-fi and mystery genres. With a background in both artistic and storytelling excellence, we bring a unique vision to our project. All right.

pretty generic sounding bio, but it did in English, right? And so it wasn't gobbledygook. Sandra, who's a creator for another one of these projects, about me. I'm a passionate creator with experience in the comic industry. Together with a talented team of artists and writers, we are dedicated to producing high quality, unique stories. That's Sandra. This next project, The Witch Hunter by Alan. I'm a passionate creator with years of experience in the comic industry. Together with a team of...

talented writers and artists, or a talented team of writers and writers, we were dedicated to producing high quality, unique stories. Wait a minute, didn't I just read that same bio? What are the chances that Alan Arduro from Fishers, Indiana would write the exact same thing or near, or paraphrase it as another creator that also launched at the same time or around the same time? What are the chances, right? And so pulling up, I pulled up a word cloud just of these bios. I popped in all like eight bios of these projects and the word dedicated and passionate and talented.

were, and team were all, were in like most of these bios. Right. And it just seems like, I don't know, these don't necessarily seem like the most common, unique or most common words that I would see in creator bios. I've looked at a lot of Kickstarter creator bios over the, over the years. All right. So, so yeah, again,

generic bios. And then the other thing is though, even though most of these say they've got a professional background and excellence, lots of experience, no actual credits for actual projects from actual publishing companies anywhere to be seen on these projects. And that is definitely a big red flag as well. So number seven, no video at all, or when they have a video, it's not tailored to the campaign. So most of these projects just have project images, no video. And in fact, I don't know that any of these have...

None of these projects actually uploaded a Kickstarter video. So that makes me think, well, if this was a program or a bot that's doing this, maybe they just didn't have the ability to upload a video. But a couple of the projects did have YouTube videos. And so this project for Spirit of Forest, this YouTube video is of an artist drawing. So it's a nice drawing. And the name of the account on YouTube is... So Rosemary is the name of the artist on the project. And she has a YouTube account for Rosemary G. Durham. And a little bit of information about the...

book, but this is literally the only video that was updated four days ago. So there's a good chance that the YouTube account was created just to upload this one video, which is a little... A little odd. I don't know. And then very similar to the witch hunter doing the same thing over here. And they're uploading a video of an artist. If I click on their YouTube account and check out how many videos up, look, they don't have any, they don't have any content. And it looks like they were just sort of pulling a video from another creator, I think. So they're stealing, stealing content from other creators to make this as well, which is kind of, kind of heinous. So no project video, or when they do have a project video, it's not actually tailored to the campaign would be another thing that is a telltale sign here.

Now, I think I already called this out as a telltale sign is that they've got like a near identical page format to other projects that are on there. And that's not terribly, that's not always a telltale sign. I know my buddy Joel Rodriguez from Metal Ninja Studios. He has kind of a format that he likes to use and some studios that launch a lot have like a go-to format that they'll copy. But this one has a lot of like, instead of using Kickstarters built in and whatnot, it seems like they're using a lot of stars in their formatting.

I guarantee you, if you go through and look at a bunch of these projects, you're going to find a lot of the same phrases, same things in there. So another thing, just looking like they're copying and pasting from other projects or using the same style of stuff for these other projects. Another thing that for a comic book project should be an absolute telltale sign is we've got all these comic projects, right? Not a single comic book preview of actual comics, actual lettered sequential storytelling, not a single one on these pages. Sure, they have some beautiful AI.

generated art that peppers the page and makes it so that, again, on a quick flip through, oh, the art looks decent or whatnot. But you won't find a single lettered page of sequential art on any of these projects. And that is, again, it's a no-no for what we real human beings that want to launch actual comic book projects on Kickstarter. We know the importance of getting our lettered previews up there on the Kickstarter page so that backers can read it, see it, know that you're good for it, and can actually do it. So this one, I'm looking at this, The Time Traveler's Diary, and it has some comic style art.

but there's nothing to read, nothing to read, no previews, no anything. Oh, and this, they actually, oh, so this one, actually, this project looks like it does have some comic previews, but I guarantee you, if I zoom in there, this is not real text. It's just, it's designed to look like text, but it's not real words. And yeah, so we're seeing a lot of a noticeable lack of comic text. Another thing, just a small thing, none of these projects have project updates.

The update is one of the most powerful things that you can use during a campaign to keep your backers engaged. But these projects are soulless, so they are not trying to engage any actual real human beings because they are not human beings themselves. Mike is my guess. Limited number of pledges. Most of these have five or under pledges, which is a little bit low for what most comic book creators do on Kickstarter. Most of them have a few more options. And I'm noticing a shocking similarity between the pricing structure. 10, 25, 50. This project here, it has 10, 25, 50, 100, 250. Okay.

This project here, darkness under the moonlight, 10, 25, 50, 100. This project over here from Rachelle, 1, 10, 20, 51, 250. Okay, so still about five rewards, but a little bit different. That's something. Rosemary, 10, 25, 50, 100. Again, nothing, just having that structure for your rewards doesn't mean your project is fake, but seeing all of these projects that share so many other similarities also mirror or have a similar pricing structures, again, raises a flag.

And then the last thing that I'll just call out is all of these projects, because they're using AI art technology, which can be impressive and on a, you know, just, hey, generate me an image. It can be impressive. Most of these pages have interesting, compelling first look grab, you know, eye grabbing images, but the images are rarely connected in a coherent way to what they're talking about. So for example, like this, this project has a bunch of sort of similar art styles. And then at the end, just kind of a random, a random swan that's covered in.

gems, which is just really weird. And you, again, when you look at any of these projects, it just doesn't make the images that they use. They don't make a ton of sense, even if, you know, for just a quick image that feels like an anime or something that looks good. Okay, great. But they're just not real images.

Point being, most of you, you know, I've driven this home, I think there's a lot of these telltale signs of spammy AI driven projects that are soulless, that don't seem to have a real human being behind them. And they're pretty easy to spot once you go looking for them. And especially when you can see them side by side by other examples of these projects. Now, what's the deal here? why would someone be doing this? Because we looked at all of these projects and none of these projects look like they have any chance at funding. So it doesn't appear that this is, if this is a way to make money, it doesn't seem like it's a great way to make money. And so why would somebody bother doing this? Theory number one is someone is tackling this as like a computer science engineering challenge, right? I can imagine someone bored with too much time on their hands, a programmer, and just wondering, hey, could I build a program?

that can tap into AI generating art programs and that can use the freely available or paid tools that are out there. Could I build a program that could build a, that could create a complete Kickstarter project and, and, you know, with a couple of clicks of the button, get it past Kickstarter screening process. If I was a programmer type and. I can see that as like a cool challenge, right? I could see that being like, all right, I'm going to write, I'm going to write a script that's going to be able to generate, just generate projects from the project title to the description, write up, write a script that can create a limited number of rewards, write a script that can generate bios and, and then also submit that through Kickstarter. Now I'm a little bit curious whether or not they would, they would have to also hook up Stripe accounts and bank accounts and all this stuff. I can't see how they got through the Kickstarter process without doing that. And it would be pretty impressive, I guess, if, if that they were able to do that, but I'm sure that technology exists.

So perhaps this is just some bored programmer trying to tackle the challenge of, hey, let's jump on. Let's see if we can write a script that can generate false Kickstarter projects. And that's just the be all and end all of it. Maybe. Another theory is, hey, this is a good way to scam people for their money. Lots of projects make a lot of money on Kickstarter. If I go over to the stats, I can see that right now on the comics category alone, there is, let's see, live dollars. There's 2.03 million dollars going, pledged right now for comic book projects. That's a decent chunk of change. And so perhaps this is just iteration one of an ultimate.

an ultimate scam job where they're trying to get this bot that they're building to generate these projects good enough so that they can actually fool the Kickstarter backers. Now, if you've been listening to Comics Launch, you know that launching a project on Kickstarter and then expecting that project to find a massive audience on Kickstarter is not how it works. It's not how it really ever worked. Kickstarter is the venue. You, my friend, are in charge of the guest list. And so if this bot is not also building big audiences, warming those audiences, getting those audiences excited for the project that's coming.

Well, those projects are still going to probably language. Now, they might get a couple of backers. A couple of these projects have one backer, two backers, three backers. But most of these projects, four backers here for Cyberpunk Chronicles, but most of these projects, no way they would come close to funding. But who knows? Again, this could just be wave one. Some of these projects have discovered, oh, maybe we can raise 500. If we can't raise 12,000, well, what if we can raise 300? Because we'll get a few people. But if we do that every day and it's automated and it doesn't take a lot of time or effort, maybe it's a scam where they can get this going and ride it while they can.

And then the last theory of it, if maybe it's not an engineering challenge, maybe they don't actually think this is a way to make money. Maybe this is an attack on Kickstarter. This is probably the more conspiracy-minded way, but Kickstarter is a platform that is the market leader for creative project crowdfunding. They have other competitors out there. And Kickstarter is also a company with an ethos, principles. They're a four-benefit company. They have banned some projects that they've felt are controversial and not in alignment with their ethos. Maybe this is a way to just fill up their platform with some fraudulent projects, waste Kickstarter's time, waste backers' time, create a worse experience on the Kickstarter platform, and thus bring down Kickstarter.

I don't know. Honestly, I'm not really sure which of these theories I subscribe to. My guess, just looking how similar these projects is, it's probably, it might just be one actor. I don't know that there's a proliferation of different actors or different people out there that are running these projects and creating these projects and uploading these projects and going to the trouble. It would, this doesn't seem like an immediately profitable endeavor. So it would be very surprising to me if there was, if this is like a common thing from multiple different sources, but who knows, maybe, you know, there could be somebody out there trying to sell his.

or her Kickstarter generating project software that lets you generate really fast projects really quickly. If you have a theory, let me know what's your theory. And then also, if you happen to be any of these creators that I have... suggested is a soulless bot or automaton and completely fraudulent for all the many reasons that it seems obvious that you are fraudulent and that you are not a real person who you are. But if Myesha Baker or who else do we have? Sandra or Alan R. Duros, if any of you are actually real human beings and I've somehow got this wrong or unfairly maligned you, hit me up, shoot me a DM, leave a comment on this YouTube video and explain yourself and how your project could be so easily confused with that of a robot.

All right. But so, yeah, so I'm hoping that this is not the new trend and that this might be just kind of one pernicious or one malfeasant actor out there that is trying to cause some trouble. Okay. So the last thing I want to talk about is, is this a big deal? And some might say, well, if these projects don't fund, no harm, no foul. Right. And honestly, I totally disagree with that. Kickstarter, unfortunately.

already had a spam backer problem and already has a spam backer problem. This is where you launch a project and most creators have the experience where at least a couple of projects seem too good to be true. And often they are. These are backers that might pledge big, but then lower their pledge in the middle of the campaign. Sometimes raise it back up again, then lower it, then back up again, then cancel completely. Or backers that back, but with the intention to ask for a refund. And actually they never had any intention of backing or they back consistently. And then they're...

Credit cards never, ever get charged. These are malfeasant backers, backer trolls. We've called them a lot of things over the years. So Kickstarter had a problem with spam backers. Kickstarter also has had a problem with spam messages that come from social media experts and people that want to promote your campaign on your behalf and want to help your campaign when, in most cases, what they're offering is not terribly helpful. And it's just a good way to spend money on something that doesn't generate a lot of results. So Kickstarter creators have been dealing with that for forever.

This takes things to a whole new level. Spam creators on the Kickstarter platform make it so much worse. It is right now, without these kinds of projects, any given time you launch a project on Kickstarter as a creator, you're dealing with and competing with some 200 to 300 odd projects. Right now there's 279 live projects as I'm recording this over on Kickstarter. 279 projects. That's a lot of competition. And if you notice, when you go to Kickstarter Explore, there's only room for three projects across above the fold. If you go on Kickstarter's main page, even if you're a comic book fan, there's a limited number of projects that are going to be recommended for you. There's a limited number of projects that are going to be on the main page or the front page of Kickstarter. And so if this starts getting filled up with even a small percentage, 10 to 20.

fake projects every single month, well, that's going to make a big impact and make it even harder for hardworking true creators that are serious about this thing, that are putting their own money, that are putting their own talent, that really believe in their projects. It's going to make it even that much harder for those creators to stand out, to get traction and to get backed. This will also have a bad experience for backers who might come across projects that look cool on the surface. They back them and then realize that there was never any intention for these projects to get made. And then the worst case scenario, if these bots get really, really good, if these programs start making projects that are good enough to fool people like me.

that have been at this for a while, and these projects have no intention of ever delivering rewards, which I don't think any of these projects that I mentioned have any intention of getting funded and delivering on the rewards. What's that going to do to backer confidence on the platform? And then the other thing that someone like me especially doesn't like is that one of the best things about Kickstarter is that since the very beginning, it's been a very transparent platform. Kickstarter stats are something that I have used and I dive into. I mean, I already just dove into them just a minute ago on this show. And one of the stats that...

I've been charting and looking at since the very beginning of comics launches that success rate of projects. And we've talked about how the comics crowdfunding success rate has just continued to go up and up and up over the years to the point where right now the comics has the highest success rate of any project, any project category. But if every month now you're getting 10 to 20 fraudulent. projects that never have any intention or chance of succeeding because they're generated by these bots that aren't real. But if that counts, if that goes into this project success rate, we might see the comics category success rate start to dip. And that may start leading to commentary about, oh, well, actually the Kickstarter bubble is popping and it's actually so much harder for project creators to get their projects funded. Again, it's just bad data. And I hate seeing bad data muck with good. And honestly, I'm still pissed off that last year when I tried to do a real survey of my audience, over 600...

700 bots, basically brute force attacked my survey, filled it up with at first glance, what looked like legitimate responses. But at second glance, it was clearly AI driven gobbledygook and basically made it so that my survey was almost unusable and not worth the time and effort that I put into doing it and not worth your time and effort, the comics launch listeners for putting into it. So again, these AI tools are filling up and making it really easy to muck with what is otherwise good information. And so I'm not really happy about that aspect of it. And so I guess the last thing is, what, if anything, can or should we do about this? And so I actually already reached out to a contact that I have over at Kickstarter on the technical side of things. And I'm just wondering if this is something that the team knows about, they're worried about, and they're paying attention to. And hopefully we'll get some good responses there. The other thing that we can do is we can report these projects. I think the nice thing about all of these projects is that they are clearly in violation of Kickstarter's AI disclosure policy. And so even if we had no ability to absolutely 100% prove that these...

projects from start to finish weren't legitimate because none of these projects seem to be disclosing. that they are using what is obviously AI art. They're not disclosing it, which means they are violating Kickstarter's terms of service, which means they should be shut down until they fix that and come back and try again with something that is better. And so I want to encourage everyone out there when you see projects like this, projects that you just do not look right, that seem off, report them. Kickstarter is a platform and a community for creators. And I want to say AI tools out there, they are amazing, right? Like they're...

they can be very fun to play with. It is kind of awesome to be able to think in your head, you know, four or five disconjoined elements of a image, right? And type that in and within seconds have that show up right in your face. Like that's a pretty cool thing. It is very awesome to at your fingertips have what feels like an artificial intelligence assistant that can answer any question that can do often seem like impossible tasks or tasks that would take human beings hours, if not weeks, if not months, and they can do them nearly instantaneously. I'll be honest, it's very, very cool.

But this is a platform for creators. It's not a platform for bots. And we need to keep it that way. And we need to police this community some. And so if this means that Kickstarter might need to make it more difficult to submit projects, or if the screening process needs to be enhanced, well, that might be worth it to keep this crap, for lack of a better word, off the platform. I am surprised that all of these projects passed the screening of the Kickstarter team. And so hopefully I'll be able to get someone from the Kickstarter screening team to explain.

how they missed the, what seemed to be pretty obvious red flags between these projects and the set of projects that have all sort of launched recently that look like they're mirroring one another and doing the thing. But also with the volume of projects that come through Kickstarter's gates and with the sophistication now of the tools that AI is giving people out there, I'm not 100% going to get on Kickstarter's case for not cracking down on these because I'm sure the deluge is coming. And I think just about all major platforms are dealing just with this onslaught of spam and stuff that can seem at first glance pretty convincing, but which thankfully still fails under the careful eye of judicious, well-trained, well-owned creators and crowdfunders like us. In a moment, I'm going to give you today's comics launcher.

But first, we need to thank our sponsor. Worst and Mayhem is a medieval, caustic, D&D-style adventure comic series from Commonwealth Comics. Imagine Thieves' World meets Skull Kickers. In medieval times, when magic and mystery ruled the land, two broke mercenaries must outwit wizards and thieves to break the curse of a mythical creature. Worst and Mayhem is perfect for fans of Dungeons & Dragons, great storytelling, historical satire, and mythology. I backed issue number one myself on Kickstarter as John Eddingfield II and Ryan Kroboth are two of my favorite people in comics, and I'm thrilled that they're pooling their collective talents on a book that oozes with irreverent fun. Issue two went live on Kickstarter August 2nd.

through the end of the month. So I encourage you to go over to worst-mayhem.com to join the adventure. All right, your comics launcher for session 475 is I Want You To. For five to 10 minutes over the next week, scroll around the comics category on Kickstarter and see if you can identify any projects that are obviously fake fraudulent abusing the Kickstarter platform and help me keep this platform free of this kind of nonsense. And even if you don't find any, that's actually ideal. Maybe you'll find a project or two worth backing. All right, so...

This is Tyler jumping back on a few days after recording what you listened to earlier. And I do have an update for you. So as I mentioned about the importance of when you see projects like this, flag them, let Kickstarter know. They clearly got past, I'm guessing, the automated screening tool. But perhaps they also managed to, on a one-off basis, get past a manual review. I've put a request out to Kickstarter just for some clarity on how some of these projects are passing their initial screening process. But we did see some movement. And so I reported.

All of these projects that I was able to identify, there's, again, just you scroll to the bottom of any Kickstarter page and there's a report button. And there's a couple of different choices of things that you have to select to find the right reason why you're reporting this project. But I was able to do that. I think I did it on about eight projects. And within a day or two, I started seeing responses on a per-project basis coming just from Kickstarter with kind of a boilerplate message that says that they got the report and they took action on it. But they didn't say specifically what action they took. And so I got that note.

Clicked on the project and initially all of those projects, they didn't appear changed at anything. They were all still live and still active. But, and then shortly after, one of the projects, the project called the Time Traveler's Diary, updated its page with a disclosure of AI use. And so this was interesting because presumably this was like the first project that I got notified that they had taken action on. And it seemed like that creators or whoever is the entity behind this bot or this AI generative machine, whoever's behind that saw the note from Kickstarter and said, oh, okay, we don't have, because one of the violations that they were all clearly in violation of is the use of AI art and not disclosing it. So that in and of itself is in violation of Kickstarter policies. And so it was reason enough to shut them down. And so the Time Traveler's Diary went and updated their page. And here was the statement they put, disclosure of AI use. In the development of the Time Traveler's Diary, we have utilized artificial intelligence AI to assist with certain aspects of the project. Specifically, AI has been employed for

Quote, creating illustrations, analyzing and organizing content to ensure quality and consistency. End quote. It is important to note that AI serves as a supportive tool rather than a replacement for our team's creativity. Its use has enhanced our workflow and helped streamline the creative process. But the core of the project remains rooted in the original artistic vision and effort of our team. We hope this clarification helps our backers understand the role of AI in our project. Thank you for your continued support and enthusiasm. Does that sound like something any legitimate comic book creator would write? Like, I mean, talk about like, I mean, I think they're pulling like.

language from Kickstarter's AI policy, it sounds like something that was plugged into a chat GPT and say, hey, write me a disclosure of AI use statement. And also, it was still misleading because... It doesn't like there is no team like they did not they had nowhere on the page that they mentioned the team. So it's not clear what what their team's creativity that they're even talking about is. And, you know, enhancing workflow and streamline the creative process. It's not doing that. It's that's all they've shown is just a few pieces of AI art. So it was kind of just like, oh, OK, let's let's respond to this one issue that they brought up that we clearly were in violation of and we'll throw this up. And so, you know, I was like, oh, well, if all of these projects go and do that, is that going to be enough to keep them on the Kickstarter platform? I don't know. But.

Weirdly enough, I think that was the only project that updated its disclosure of AI use. And then when I checked back on Monday morning on these projects that I had reported, every single one of those projects, now when you would go to the projects, had a new funding suspended notice on the projects. So for example, if you go to the Time Traveler's diary right now, it now says, at the end of the title, it says the word suspended. And it has an orange. bar where the back button used to be that says funding suspended. Funding for this project was suspended by Kickstarter five days ago. So I'm kind of a little bit curious about the funding suspended category of project on Kickstarter, whether this means that the project is indefinitely suspended. I'm wondering if Kickstarter...

sent a boilerplate to this creator, suggesting some things that he or she would need to do to get it unsuspected. As of suspending, $20 of a $14,999 goal and two backers is the only activity on this project. So not likely to fund. And so, yeah, my guess is that all these projects got the funding suspended, and then that's going to be the end of it for these projects. The other nice thing is that while...

these projects are suspended and the link to the suspended project is still active. So I can check the status of the project. If you go to the discovery and search for these projects, well, these suspended projects no longer come up. And even if you type in like the full name of the project, that project just, it doesn't come up at all. It's, or it doesn't come up in search results, which is good because again, the biggest problem with these projects wasn't that they were going to steal potential money from creators or from, from backers. None of these projects really had.

a chance of getting funded, but they could really clutter up the Kickstarter platform, which was kind of the main thing that I was worried about. That and just, you know, any platform that a significant chunk or even an insignificant chunk, but enough to notice it where the projects were fraudulent, well, that's going to reduce the trust and just the user experience of the platform. So being vigilant, cleaning these things up is important. So the good news is, yay, I want to give Kickstarter its flowers. Thank you for cleaning that up, Kickstarter. And I did...

Send a message over to Kickstarter, sort of asking for some clarity on sort of how these projects are able to make it through the screening process and what, if anything, they're doing in light of the advances in AI and generative AI to make it so that people can, with low effort, create tons of content and stuff that could approximate what a Kickstarter project might look like. I do want to say that when the projects like this do get through, the fact that Kickstarter team has a process in place where they can take action on it, get them suspended, get them cleaned up off the comics page is a good thing.

But also over the weekend, I will also say that there have been a couple of other projects that popped up even after my first run of identifying projects. These projects looked very similar, not in necessarily the genre or the exact language used on the page, but how the campaign pages were structured, the deep reliance on AI everywhere, the lack of creators or team. So there were a few more of these sort of projects that popped up and that have not yet been canceled. I've reported those as well. It's been a quiet past couple of days, so I'm wondering if the fact that projects actually did get shut down, maybe that has thwarted whoever is behind them, or maybe they're just retooling their bots and are going to make another go of it, and this time the bots are 2.0 and even better and harder to detect. But again, message Kickstarter for a statement. Hopefully we'll get something that I can share on the podcast in the future. But in the meantime, I'm hopeful that this is a blip and not a trend, but we're going to have to stay vigilant. I'm generally...

very much a live and let live kind of person. If someone makes a comic and launches it and it's not for me, I'm not going to spend too much time worrying about it. I don't really care about it. I say, you do you. But when that someone is not actually a creator and is actually a bot or a programmer who is using programming and generative AI tools to spoof a comic book project, and has no actual intention of making a real comic, of delivering it to backers, of treating the Kickstarter platform with the respect that it needs, then that's a line worth policing and making sure that we're not having the platform cluttered up with fraudulent projects. That's on all of us. So that's my stance. That's where I'm at. But we did end this episode on a positive note, and I hope you're feeling good about that as well. Thank you so much for listening and letting me walk with you as you take another step forward towards your next successful comics launch.

Looking for something new? These projects just launched on Kickstarter. Hello, Comics Launch. I'm indie comics creator and good-okay-bad critic Seth Tihani. I'm crowdfunding Munkus and the Springtime Sonata on Kickstarter. This is a children's graphic novel aimed at ages 3 through 8. Munkus is a 100-year-old little girl homunculus who lives on a mysterious island with her best friend, a puffin named Puffin. It's a warm-hearted, vibrantly colorful story of whimsy and delight, a celebration of friendship and adventure and the entire mystery of life. Hello, Comics Launch. This is Sarah, creator of Rough Cut Vegan, which is live on Kickstarter. This is a graphic memoir about what it was like to go vegan nearly 50 years ago.

and how being a vegan led to my cinematic dreams of becoming a film director. I was super happy last night to find out that Kickstarter gave me one of their Projects We Love badge. That was super cool. I hope you'll come check out Rough Cut Vegan on Kickstarter today. Thanks. Yo, Joe, and roll out to the Comic Launch community and Tyler for helping get projects funded by supporting us independent creators that use all kinds of awesome strategies to be successful. Keep up the great work with helping us. I am Josh Egeving, author of the After Action Report book series, coming to you from our headquarters in Southern California to announce our latest new book.

Our current Kickstarter is the unofficial G.I. Joe and Transformers comic checklist book. The quick summary about this book is it includes all G.I. Joe and Transformers comics from 1982 to 2022 in a checklist format designed to help you track your collection all in one book. So when you go to a con or comic shop, you can know what you have and what you're missing by tracking it in this book. As of this recording, it's at 50% funded with more than a month to go with cool stretch goals already announced. So go be a backer of our Kickstarter and help us get to the goal. Thank you. And you can also visit our website.

afteractionreport.net. Are you a Comics Launch listener with a project that's launched or about to launch on Kickstarter? Tell us about it at comicslaunch.com forward slash voicemail and we might just feature it on our show. Hey, before I go, I wanted to check to see if you've requested your free offset and digital print sample pack from ComicImpressions.com yet. A few months ago, I asked Rich at ComicImpressions to put together a few hundred free printing sample packs for Comics Launch listeners, and they immediately started flying out the doors. In fact, Rich has printed up a bunch more, and he's ready to ship them, so you should definitely request yours if you haven't already. I've already put in a few Comics Tribe orders with ComicImpressions so far, and I'm about to put in another big one soon, and I definitely recommend you check out their free samples. And if you decide to get a quote from them, know that you'll also get 5% off your order when you mention Comics Launch. It's never too early to start communicating with your printers, so head over to ComicImpressions.com

You've been listening to Comics Launch with Tyler James. Go to comicslaunch.com for show notes, free resources, and to connect with me. Thank you so much for listening and I can't wait to see what you launch next.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of ComixLaunch: Crowdfunding for Writers, Artists & Self-Publishers on Kickstarter... and Beyond!?

This episode is 1 hour and 4 minutes long.

When was this ComixLaunch: Crowdfunding for Writers, Artists & Self-Publishers on Kickstarter... and Beyond! episode published?

This episode was published on August 25, 2024.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this ComixLaunch: Crowdfunding for Writers, Artists & Self-Publishers on Kickstarter... and Beyond! episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.