Skip to content
Aortic Syndrome Part One: Aortic Dissection episode artwork

Jun 6, 2018 23 min

Aortic Syndrome Part One: Aortic Dissection

from Take Aurally Hosted by Take Aurally

Dr Craig Douglas came down to the NUH DREEAM booth to discuss Aortic Dissection, who gets it, why they get it, how they present and what we can do about it. We'll discuss 'Chest Pain + 1', what bedside investigations we can do that will make us suspicious of aortic dissection and then we'll have a look at the future and the ADvISED trial. As ever, you can find links and our #TakeVisually at www.takeaurally.com. Remember both Take Aurally and DREEAM are on Facebook and Twitter. Enjoy!

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Aortic Syndrome Part One: Aortic Dissection

0:00 23:35
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Thanks for downloading and welcome to Take Aurely, the podcast from NUH Dream Queen's Medical Centre at Nottingham. In this podcast we'll be discussing aortic dissection. As ever, all information is correct at the time of recording. All guidelines mentioned are correct for Nottingham University Hospital's NHS Trust. Other trust guidelines may vary. All views and opinions are the speaker's own. So hello, welcome back to Take Aurely. It's James Thomas here, my teacher fellows in emergency medicine. I'm delighted to welcome back Dr Craig Douglas, ED consultant, the veteran of our first ever episode of Take Aurely. Welcome Craig. Hi Jamie, good to be back. So here we've brought Craig back for the first episode of a two-parter on aortic syndromes.

And we're going to start today by looking at aortic disception. Looking forward to it. So I suppose the first question is, Craig, what is aortic disception and how common is it? Well, uncommon would be the answer. So aortic dissection, it is obviously a cardiovascular emergency and essentially what happens is that there is a tear in the innermost layer of the aorta, the intima, and you get blood which then tracks through that layer and basically starts to dissect off the inside of the aortic wall from the media or the muscular wall and it creates a false passage within the vessel itself which can travel.

backwards towards the heart or further down the aorta and cause problems downstream as well. As I say, it is uncommon. So roughly, you're speaking about three cases per 100,000 people per year. So it's not something that you're going to see very often in your practice. But we're very worried about it then, even though it's quite rare. So why are we so worried about it? Well, we're worried about it because it's a genuine emergency and there's a significant mortality rate associated with the condition. And if we don't pick it up, then these are patients who are going to have unfavourable outcomes because we can't initiate their emergency management. So I think overall, you're sort of talking about a 25 to 30% mortality for this condition. It varies slightly depending on the type of dissection, which we can talk a little bit more about. But that's really why we get worried about it.

And also the fact because the presentation is so varied and can be subtle as well. And that's why it always plays in the back of our mind. Yeah, I think it's worth emphasising this point because I think students sometimes get confused with this. This isn't the same as a AAA rupturing and blood being leaked out into a body cavity. This is about that false lumen in the wall of the... We're talking about AAA data, but this is different. Yeah, absolutely. So, I mean, the ways in which you will die from an aortic dissection, there are a few. As I said, you can... That blood leaking out into...

the wall of the aorta and then tracking backwards towards the heart, you can then get leakage of blood into the pericardium, causing a cardiac tamponade, so you can die that way. You can also get acute failure of the aortic valve, so you get sudden massive severe aortic regurgitation and result in heart failure, so that can kill you. You can bleed out through the wall of the vessel, that can happen as well, you can obviously exsanguinate from that. And the other thing is that... Because the blood is leaking into that false passage, it can compress branch vessels of the aorta, which then causes malperfusion syndromes and end organ damage. And that's yet another way that this condition can kill you. Pick your way. How do you want to die? So I suppose, obviously, not very common, but we need to be worried about it. It's a not-to-miss diagnosis. So what are the clinical features? What are you listening for in history that makes you think, hang on, this could be an aortic dissection? Sure. So in terms of clinical features, the big one is pain.

So almost all patients with a dissection will have pain, certainly more than 90% of patients. And it tends to be pain which is acute or abrupt in onset, and it's severe. Although the classic description is of a sort of tearing pain going through between the shoulder blades, actually when you look at some of the evidence out there, the most often it's characterised as a sharp, severe pain. Okay. So it doesn't need to be that tearing description. If someone says abrupt onset, sharp, severe pain, you should think about dissection. And it can be pain in the chest, it can be pain in the back, it can be pain in the abdomen. And again, it varies slightly depending on the type of aorta dissection, whether it's affecting the ascending aorta, which tends to cause more chest and back pain versus the descending aorta, which tends to be more sort of back and abdominal pain. Sure. I've heard the description of thunderclap chest pain, you know, but analogous to the...

I haven't heard that but it makes sense doesn't it I think the complicating thing, obviously, with dissection is that there are other things, other diagnoses that you'd want to consider with that same sort of abrupt onset pain, isn't it? Often it can be quite difficult to try and discern maybe something like a pulmonary embolism, what you think is the more likely explanation. So who does it tend to affect? So it tends to affect men more often than females. And it tends to be in a slightly older population, so mean age, around about the mid-60s. But it isn't a diagnosis that you can discount in younger patients.

certain groups of patients who are more at risk of developing this particular disease. Particularly, you want to think about patients with a history of collagen disorders, Marfan syndrome, patients who've got a family history of aortic dissection or other aortic problems. And you also might want to bear in mind recreational drug use. Patients presenting with severe chest pain after cocaine use would be the classic example of a drug-induced aortic dissection as well. Okay. So as well as the chest pain, like you said, it's a common presenting complaint. Every day in A&E, you'll see several with it. What other features are that go along with it? I've heard the chest pain plus one as a way of remembering some of the different ways that you get with chest pain. Yeah, it's a good way of looking at things.

you can get quite very varied and sometimes quite bizarre presentations of aortic dissection and some of that is due to these malperfusion syndromes which we've sort of hinted at. They say when you get blood tracking in the wall of the aorta compressing the origins of branches from the aorta then you can start to understand why you get these malperfusion syndromes. So that can affect the carotid arteries and can lead to symptoms of a stroke. It can compress the subclavian vessels. lead to problems with arm ischemia. It can compress the origin of your mesenteric or celiac arteries and cause problems with gut ischemia. It can lead to problems with perfusion of the spinal arteries as well and causing acute paralysis. So it's in these situations where you have chest pain and another feature, such as acute neurological deficits or acute vascular deficits in the limbs, dissection is something that you want to think about as a diagnosis that could tie these seemingly quite different pathologies together.

And I think the other thing that we have to think about with dissection is just pulse deficits, much along the same way that we've been chatting, important to feel for the radial, brachial, vernal pulses, an absent or reduced pulse, and similarly checking with blood pressures between left and right arms as well, and looking for that significant systolic difference, which might, again, give you another clue as to dissection that you're dealing with. So I've also read about the chest pain plus abdominal pain, if you've got a migratory pain, especially if you're getting a tearing and extending down the arms, you may get a chest and abdominal pain together. You mentioned there about blood pressure in both. arms, is that useful? It can be useful. If you don't have a blood pressure differential between the left and right arms, you can't exclude that it's a dissection. Literature would suggest it's present probably between 10 and 30% of cases of dissection, again, dependent on the site of the intimate tear and where the blood is tracking within the aorta. So there's a significant group of patients with a dissection who will have that.

blood pressure differential, but it's not something that you can hang your hat on seeing in all patients. Yeah. And is there a number of blood pressure difference that we agree on? The description is of a 20 millimeter differential in the systolic blood pressure. But it has to be at the same time as well, which is difficult as well, isn't it? And that's a key thing. So, you know, in these studies, they are looking at blood pressures done, you know, simultaneously in the left and right arms, which is often very difficult to achieve in a busy area. Okay. So we've examined our patient. They're a young person with...

and they describe the pain as sudden, right through to the back, they may have collapsed or something going along with it, there may be a blood pressure difference. For a junior doctor seeing the patient for the first time, is there a role for basic tests before going on to anything further? So are ECGs, are chest X-rays, etc., is there a role for these things? Yeah, I think there is. I think there's always a role for those tests, and they may give you helpful clues and just start to build the overall picture. I mean, it's worth just bearing in mind at this point that you can get...

some very sick patients presenting in this way. They may be unstable. Those unstable patients, you might need to change your thought process a little bit in terms of the tests that you're ordering. But if you've got a stable patient, then certainly I think an ECG is useful. It will be normal in about 30% of patients who have an aortic dissection.

The most common finding that you'll see are sort of non-specific ST segment, T wave inversion type changes. So I'll just give you a clue that there's something going on. And similar to chest x-ray, again, that will be normal in about 15% of patients who are having an aortic dissection. So you can exclude the disorder based on a normal ECG and a normal chest x-ray, but you can start to build a picture and start to put everything together. So I would say there is a rule for those tests. They don't take long to do and might give you the...

the extra clue that you need in terms of establishing the diagnosis. And so that chest X-ray, we're looking for the widened mediastinum? That would be the most common feature to see on the chest X-ray, for sure. There are other things which are talked about, pleural effusion more commonly on the left side, obliteration of the so-called aortic pulmonary window on the chest X-ray. But yeah, widening of the mediastinum would be the number one thing to look for. This is kind of just adding currency, really, to our argument, maybe, that we're thinking this patient has an aortic dissection, but forms part of the overall approach to anybody with chest pain. Yeah, absolutely. Yeah. Okay. So...

We've got our suspicions now. How are we actually going to definitively diagnose aorta dissection? So certainly in this hospital, and I think probably across most hospitals, certainly in the UK, then our sort of gold standard test would be to do a CT angiogram of the aorta, which has sensitivity, you know, certainly around upwards of 95% for picking up these cases. You could argue that the better test is an MR angiogram, but realistically that's just not something that we've got access to. And so that will then tell us our type of aortic dissection. So we should probably talk a little bit more about different types of aortic dissection. So I mean, I always use the distinction between a type A and a type B. Yeah, absolutely. Yeah, so when people talk about type A dissection, type B dissection, so they're using the Stanford classification system, which is the most widely used classification system.

Using that system, it doesn't really take into account where the internal tear is, just about which sections of the aorta are affected. So anything where the ascending aorta is affected would be a type A dissection, and if it was just a dissection involving the descending thoracic aorta, type B. And I think that's its most widely used system, and I think to avoid complicating matters, that would probably just be the one I would stick with unless you're a deep specialist interest in the subject. And have we got any problems with how we diagnose aortic dissection? Well, yeah, we do. So the problem with aortic dissection, as I say, is something that we don't want to miss. And there are a lot of patients who...

If we were to risk stratify them, they would be on the low end in terms of risk stratification, but we can't exclude it without doing a CT or angiogram test, which is an expensive test, time-consuming for radiologists, and subjecting patients to significant volumes of radiation and contrast, neither of which you would particularly want to do without good justification. So we end up doing a lot of these investigations, and actually the number of patients who actually turn up to have an aortic dissection is very low. In the published literature and certainly looking at our own practice here, you're probably looking in a region of about 2% to 3% of patients who have a CTA looking for a dissection actually having one. So we're doing lots of scans which are negative. So that's an issue. So it's a bit like PE. I'm thinking of PE. It would be amazing if we... I think we're going to go into a bit about risk classification, about risk scoring our patients. If there was a way of, if you're low risk, here's a blood test, then off you go, rather than scanning, as we do, the similar set we have in PE. So if we confirm aortic dissection, we're going to be on the phone to cardiothoracics, aren't we?

For a type A dissection, certainly that is something where you're going to want a cardiac surgeon involved in managing those patients. The mortality, trying to manage type A dissections medically is significantly higher than those patients who have a surgical approach, whether that be an open approach or an endovascular approach. Certainly those patients are going to need to go to be looked after by the cardiac surgeons. For type B dissections, where really the mainstay of treatment is medical management for these patients. There are a few patients who will end up having an endovascular approach, but the vast majority of type B dissections are medically managed, and they may go and actually be looked after by the cardiology team rather than the cardiac surgery. Yeah, blood pressure control and obstinate. Brilliant. Okay, so we've touched a little bit on some of the problems with diagnosing aortic dissection. So, you know, this is an area where there's new developments and research going into because of these problems I can talk about. Yeah, absolutely.

So for a while now, there's been some interest in terms of using D-dimer in much the same way that we do for our patients with suspected pulmonary embolism. In much the same way with PDE, just looking at D-dimer by itself has not proven to be particularly useful. It still misses too many patients who would go on to have a proven dissection. It's showing real promise, based on some evidence which was published in circulation last year, is the combination of a clinical risk stratification tool combined with a D-dimerism. So last year, the advised trial was published, which uses the aortic dissection risk score, the ADD-RS score, to group patients into whether high probability, moderate, or low probability. And for patients who fit into that low probability group,

If they go on and have a negative D-dimer, that particular study suggested that you can effectively rule out an aortic dissection in that group of patients. So that might, the caveat to that is, this study needs to be validated in different populations to make sure that these results hold up. But if this is borne out to be true, then you could effectively reduce your scanning on about 60% of patients who currently go and have a CT angiogram. There's potential massive change in practice and massive benefits. involved with this study. So hopefully we'll see some more positive studies that can back up those results over the next year or two. Absolutely. So that was looking at you as high-risk features, doesn't it? That's right. Low-risk features. Yeah, so the risk score looks at sort of three individual components. So it looks at high-risk conditions, so they're the same things we're sort of talking about, Marfan's family history, known thoracic aortic aneurysm, and then it looks at the presence and character of pain.

And then it also looks at the physical exam and whether there's evidence of perfusion deficits. So in terms of blood pressure, pulse deficits, the focal neurological deficits, those sorts of things. So it looks at those three areas. And if you score in either of those three areas, then you get a point. So the score ranges from zero to three. If you score zero or one, you fall into the low-risk group. Two more than three, obviously, towards the higher end of things. So the D-dimer is not helpful in patients scoring more than one.

because you can't rule out the dissection in those patients. There's still a decent number of those patients will go on and have proven aneurysm. Not aneurysm, I'm sorry, dissection. But in the low-risk group, there seems to be real potential there. Excellent. Is there a role in bedside ultrasound if you're in A&E and you've got a decent technician there? Is there a role? No, there is a role. If you can get a transesophageal echo, then that is a good test.

We would have similar test characteristics to our CT angiogram, but your chances of getting a transthoracic echo are essentially no. But for somebody who's a dab hand and he's an ultrasound probe, you're not going to... You won't get enough reliable information from doing a transthoracic echo and looking at the aorta in that fashion. Anything else do you want to talk about? Well, I think we've sort of...

chatted about most of the sort of main points and certainly for you know the students and junior doctors sort of listening to the podcast then I would just encourage them to have this diagnosis in the back of their mind to you know do a full a detailed physical examination you know looking for murmurs of the orchard regurgitation really feeling doing a good peripheral pulses examination feeling for those pulse deficits Not ignoring strange features and thinking about that sort of chest pain plus one mantra and thinking of the aortic dissection as a diagnosis, which might tie together quite disparate findings. And then just to involve their seniors at an early stage, do a good sort of basic work of chest X-rays, ECGs, and involve seniors in terms of the decision-making around further imaging tests. Thank you very much, Craig. My pleasure. Thanks. Bye-bye. Bye.

That was the Take Orally Aortic Dissection podcast. You can find more information, including the Take Visually for this podcast, at takeorally.com. You can find Take Orally on both SoundCloud and iTunes. And you can also find Take Orally on both Facebook and Twitter. For more information about education and research opportunities within emergency medicine, acute medicine and major trauma, you can find NUH Dream on both Facebook and Twitter.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Take Aurally?

This episode is 23 minutes long.

When was this Take Aurally episode published?

This episode was published on June 6, 2018.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Take Aurally episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.