Skip to content
Brendan O'Neill Professional Heretic episode artwork

Aug 20, 2023 1 hr 48 min

Brendan O'Neill Professional Heretic

from DEKONSTRUKTIV KRITIK

Essayist Brendan O’Neill visits Sweden to talk about his book A Heretic’s Manifesto. STÖTTA DEKONSTRUKTIV KRITIK Swish: 0046768943737 paypal.me/ARONFLAM Patreon: www.patreon.com/ARONFLAM Bitcoin: 3EPQMEMVh6MtG3bTbGc71Yz8NrMAMF4kSH Edited by Marcus Tigerdraake, Silverdrake Förlag www.silverdrakeforlag.se Intro by: Intractable by Kevin MacLeod is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution license (creativecommons.org/licenses/...) Source: incompetech.com/music/royalty-... Artist: incompetech.com STÖTTA DEKONSTRUKTIV KRITIK: Swish: 1235198478 paypal.me/ARONFLAM Patreon: www.patreon.com/ARONFLAM Bitcoin: 3EPQMEMVh6MtG3bTbGc71Yz8NrMAMF4kSH www.aronflam.com Edited by Marcus Tigerdraake, Silverdrake Förlag www.silverdrakeforlag.se Intro by: Intractable by Kevin MacLeod is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution license (creativecommons.org/licenses/...) Source: incompetech.com/music/royalty-... Artist: incompetech.com

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Brendan O'Neill Professional Heretic

0:00 1:48:39
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

You're listening to Deconstructive Criticism. I'm Aaron Flann, essays Brendan Neel visit Sweden to talk about his book, A Heretics Manifesto. But first, thank you for supporting Deconstructive Criticism, whether it is on patreon.com slash Aaron Flann, via PayPal, with Bitcoin, or on SWISH, double-o-46-768-9437. Double-o-46-768-9437.

You make my work possible. You can also support me by buying my book. This is a Swedish Tiger on Amazon. Brendan O'Neill is a British author and essayist.

He was the editor of Spike from 2007 to September 2021, and is currently its chief political writer. He has been a columnist for The Australian, The Big Issue, and the Spectator. Brendan has visited the podcast twice before. He is a lovely person and a brilliant writer.

His latest book, A Heretics Manifesto, is a beautifully argued defense of the Enlightenment, reason, and the right to disagree on the orthodoxies of our age. It is, as one says in English, a must read. Not that I think that you're not aware of the insanity of our side guys, of course you are. But I believe that armed with Brendan's arguments, you stand a better chance of battling it.

Whether it is the sexual mutilation of children, climate celery, race-baiters, or Islamo-censorship, Brendan's writings incisively cuts to the core of what's wrong with our culture. Using historical examples, he shows that we are not so different than we were before the Reformation. As luck would have it, his visit to Sweden and on the constructive criticism coincides with a fierce debate on Quran burnings that has led Sweden's government to repeat our freedom of speech and bend the need to some of the most authoritarian regimes on the planet. Enjoy.

Just reading all the names on your wall. Yes, I know how bad he's going to be in total, but interesting guy. Yes, I liked him. I interviewed him.

But that wasn't what we were supposed to be talking about. I'm supposed to welcome you back to the constructive criticism, Brendan O'Neill. Pleasure to be here. It's been a few years.

But you've been a guest twice before. Yes. And I've loved it by the time, so I'm very happy to be back. And I remember, I seem to remember last time, I nagged you to write a book.

Yes. And I finally got around to it. Yes, you did. But in my research on you now, because I haven't checked up on you in a while, I saw that you've already written a book under a pseudonym.

That's right. Oh my God, that was a long time ago. That was, Can I Recycle My Granny by Ethan Greenhart. And it was, when was that?

Ten, fifteen years? A long time. That was a piss take out of the Green Movement. So it was written as if I were an eco activist giving advice to the public on how to save carbon.

It's not still in circulation, is it? No. It was a hard time. Yeah, it did okay when it came out.

It was, it got some reviews and people seem to enjoy it, but it's not well known. It kind of has disappeared. If you can find a copy, let me know. I'll keep trying, but I'm not sure I can.

But I hope to get to England at some point in time, and I can visit some of your books if you still have. So now you've written a beautifully argued book or collection of essays called Heritics Manifesto. So what is the meaning of the word Heritic? So, Heritic is someone who goes against the grain, who breaks the rules of contemporary thought.

I guess that's what it means. I mean, Heritic literally, the word itself comes from the Greek meaning choice of thought. So it's basically someone who chooses to believe a particular thing. Usually something that runs counter to the orthodoxies of our time.

So we all know the Heritics from the past, the people who spoke out against the Vatican or who denied the Christ was the Messiah or who questioned parts of the Bible. I mean, these are the people who in Western Europe anyway, we are most familiar with those Heritics who were burnt at the stake and strangled to death in public and reduced to a pile of ashes. That's what Heritic in the past was. Today, I think Heritics are the people who speak out against the new orthodoxies, gender ideology, for example, climate change hysteria.

We've now gone from global warming to global boiling. That's what the UN is now saying, just complete hysteria on that front. It's the people who speak out about those kinds of ideologies who are treated as Heritics now and who are exiled from polite society, deplatformed from universities and television shows and other public platforms. So heresy hunting is alive and well, and my book is just trying to wring together all the various, horrifical ideas of our time.

So do you self-identify as a Heritic? Yes, I do. I know that's a bit pompous, but I do consider myself something of a Heritic. I prefer the word Heritic to the word contrarium.

I often get called a contrarian and I hate it because contrarian, it sounds like you just say things to irritate people. You know, you only write things or say things just not because you believe them, but because you just want to wind people up and get on their nerves. That's really what contrarian means, in the way that it's used. So I never liked that term because I do believe the things I say.

I do believe that if you have a penis, you're a man. I actually believe that. So for me, Heritic is a better word because it means that you're standing up to something you believe in, even though you know there might be consequences when you do that. I am glad you brought up penises because I came across this headline in the magazine, Low and Crime by Alberto Luparón on July 23rd, 2023.

Man shot and killed his pregnant boyfriend and then himself in murder suicide. Unbelievable. I mean, imagine going back 10 years and showing this to someone. Even that recently, people would have said, what?

This doesn't make any sense. Well, the headline was later changed to pregnant transgender boyfriend because of transphobic bullying, which I may or may not have participated in. So what's wrong with the headline? It's a lie, but they're now lying to us.

And in fact, one of the points I'm making about the first chapter of the book is called Herpiness. Yes. Because to me, that's one of the most fascinating phrases of our time. And you see it everywhere.

You see it in the Times, the newspaper of record in Britain. You see it on the BBC. You see it in courts of law. If a male rapist identifies as a woman, he is referred to in court of she.

And there have been actual court cases where they have said she undid her trousers and took out her penis. I mean, they're saying it in a court of law, a place where everyone swears to tell the truth and yet they're lying. So that headline there, Man Chodding Kield is pregnant boyfriend. It's a lie.

The truth is he shot and killed his pregnant girlfriend. And there isn't that matters. Some people say what it's just about being polite. You're just using people's preferred pronouns.

Stuart Lee, the British comedian, once referred to political correctness, says all it is as institutionalised politeness. Since when did being polite mean saying something that you know is not true? When it's inside politeness mean lying to yourself and to other people? Because that's what this culture encourages us to do.

And one of the examples I give in that chapter of her penis is reporting the New York Times and on the BBC a couple of years ago, they had this report about an 80-something woman in New York City who murdered and decapitated another woman who was in her 60s. And I read this and I thought, hold on, women in their 80s don't do this. Women in their 80s tend to be quite small, quite frail, certainly not murderously inclined. I can't think of any instance in my lifetime.

Well, there could be a biological exception somewhere in the street. Well, yeah, there could well be. I can't think of any time in my lifetime where a frail old woman in her 80s has murdered and decapitated another woman. It's kind of thing that doesn't happen.

Of course, you get to the end of the article, the last line in the BBC's case. And it says, this is a transgender woman. You get halfway through the New York Times article and says, the murderer previously identified as a man but now identifies as a woman. So it's a man.

So the whole article was a lie. They were lying to the public. And the point I make in my book is that when you get to a situation where the cultural elites think they can lie to us and get away with it, think they can define reality, however they please and make us and gaslight us essentially into denying the light of our own reason and what we can see and hear with our own eyes and ears. And they think they can do that.

That's the highest form of tyranny when the establishment thinks that it can define reality to make sure that it accords with its own ideology. And we absolutely shouldn't. So that's why that headline's offensive because they are sacrificing the truth at the altar of ideology and we shouldn't let them do that. So you say you're offended by that?

I am offended, yeah. I don't want it to be banned. I'm not going to demand the enactment of cancel culture against whatever idiot wrote that headline. I don't want them banished from public life.

But I'm offended at the fact that they think they can lie to us. I'm offended by how they're treating us. They're treating us like the flotsam and jetsam of everyday life where they can just mold however they choose. And it's not just about changing how we think.

Sorry, it's not just about changing how we speak. It's about changing how we think. You know, the manipulation of language is always fundamentally about manipulating thought. So the more you have these drip trip of headlines about an 80 year old woman who killed another woman, not true, about this man killing his pregnant boyfriend, not true, boys can't get pregnant, men can't get pregnant.

Or headlines that I document in my book, many of them where they say a woman has been arrested for flashing her penis at passersby, not true. They're just lying again and again and again. I'm offended by that. I'm offended by the fact that they think we are so stupid and so gullible and so malleable.

And essentially we are their property and it's down to them to fill our heads with the correct thought. That's what offends me. Well, this is a bit different because law and crime is an American magazine. So it's privately funded and there is no tax revenue going to its financing.

Unlike I guess the BBC, the BBC has some public funding, does it not? Oh, yes. You have to do by law. Give money to the BBC.

I give it stuck. We're now used to be. If you have a television because it used to be voluntary, right? I don't know the answer to that question.

It may have been voluntary in the past. I mean, it's voluntary in the sense that you don't have to own a television. But if you do own a television, you have to give money to the BBC. You have to give them, I think, it's £15 a month now, £150 a year or something like that.

And if you don't, they will come around and sometimes you get arrested and taken to court and the people normally get taken to court for not giving their money to the BBC tend to be poor, single mothers, poor women who live on their own who can't afford to pay the BBC. So yeah, we are forced to give money to the BBC. So you have this publicly funded broadcaster, which is publicly funded under threat of criminalization. And it still thinks it can just treat us like crap by saying things to us that it must know at some level, I'm not true, and does not accord with its values, which is to tell us what's happening in the world.

Yeah. So we've covered the first chapter of your book then, I suppose. So why can't you respect people's preferred pronouns? I mean, I myself turn myself evil slash genius now.

So I respect that. Yeah, I respect your pronouns 100%. Evil genius. Because no man is an island.

And whatever we may think about ourselves, we live in a social world where there are established truths, established ways, established ways of speaking and established ways of greeting each other. We all know that there are men and women, boys and girls, and that there are some differences between them. We brought up to understand that. We know that our mothers are different to our fathers.

We know that these people played particular roles in our lives. If you grow up a boy, as we did, your mother will, in most cases, be the nurturing parent and your father will rough house you and push you around and strengthen you up and so on. We all know this. So if you come into that world in which all these things are already established and are very useful and important ways of knowing what's going on, you come into that world and say, well, actually, even though I've got a penis and a beard and I'm a bloke, my name's Dave, even despite all of that, you have to refer to me as she.

I'm sorry, but you don't get to do that because what you are defining is your freedom to define your own pronouns encroaches on other people's freedom to think and speak as they understand the world around them. So I don't respect people's preferred pronouns because I see it as an act of delusion. Delusional is a delusional belief and one that I or anyone else should not be forced to go along with. It is quite interesting because I remember my aunt, she's not alive anymore, but she used to be a psychologist.

And she, I remember her telling me when she was alive about working in mental institutions in the 70s where one of the most common delusions that they had to treat was people who thought they were Napoleon. And she said, usually we had five or six people who thought they were Napoleon in the same ward, but usually they got along great. I'm glad to hear it. Yes.

But we didn't give them hormones to make them Napoleon. We didn't. We drastically, surgically rearranged them to become Napoleon. We didn't acknowledge that preferred identity.

They preferred identity was to be Napoleon and we didn't acknowledge it. We said to them, you're illunatic and we're going to put you inside this institution. Now I don't think transgender people should be put inside institutions just to make that clear. I think they should move freely in society and do whatever they want to do.

And they should call themselves she and he and they and Z and Z should do any of that. And I think they should have the right to change their names and they should dress however they please, of course, I believe in freedom on all those levels. But where things get complicated is when the pressure is then put on everyone else to recognise and acknowledge and validate their identity. Not only to the level of where there is a huge pressure on us now to say he, to say she and her about someone who's obviously a man.

So there's pressure on us to lie to ourselves, to deny our own understanding of science and objectivity. But also there's pressure on women to have these people in their spaces. So if you're a woman in your changing room and you're taking your clothes off and this transgender woman comes in and takes his clothes off and he's got a swinging dick. You're referring to Leah Thomas.

Leah Thomas is one example of that. He has apparently got his penis out in a woman's changing rooms allegedly. There's a notorious case in LA at a spa in LA which I write about in my book where a transgender woman, as they call them, took his clothes off and had a semi erect penis. And one of the people in the changing rooms was a girl, a minor.

That's very serious. And you know what's interesting to me is that some strands of feminism have spent the past few years telling us that everything is misogyny. If you look at there's a movement in the UK called Everyday Sexism and they used to drop these lists of all the misogynistic experiences that women have every day. And they would say things like, you know, when the waiter comes to your table after you've had your meal, he always gives the bill to my boyfriend, never to me.

That was an example of everyday sexism. Or you go to the bar and you order a pint and the bar man thinks you want half a pint rather than a full pint. You know, that's misogyny because he's making this presumption about a woman. These were genuinely treated for the past few years under the kind of crazy liberal feminism that was in the ascendancy as examples of sexism.

Now some of those same feminists are defending the trans ideology. They are turning a blind eye when men are walking around with their dicks out, flashing them at women. We used to call that flashing. Now we call it trans rights.

And they're saying, well, you know, don't make a fuss about that. You dig it. So there's a real problem with this. And by the way, I should say that in the UK, many, many feminists that are at the forefront of challenging the trans ideology.

So this is not all old. They're all old. I wouldn't say they're old, but they're a sub-nage, middle-aged or they're suddenly older. They remember sexism.

They remember sexism. They don't want blokes in their changing room. So they're sensible. And a lot of them come from a left wing perspective.

So they have a slightly more radical approach to these issues than the kind of upper middle class liberal feminists who came up in the 1990s and the 2000s. So something really weird is going on. And I do think we need to talk about it more, which is one of the reasons I write about transgenderism in my book. Which is...

You developed two chapters, two chapters. Yes. Two chapters. It's her penis.

And it's the chapter of the love that Dairnold speaks its name. Yeah. Yeah. That's chapter seven, I think.

Yes. Because in her penis, I look at basically the irrationalism of this ideology. And also the way in which the manipulation of language always leads to manipulating thought and controlling thought. And then in the love that Dairnold speaks its name, I look at the way in which the trans ideology is undermining not only women's rights and biological reason, but also gay rights as well.

Because what's happening there is that we now have... This is another bizarre and contradictory situation that we face. We now have a situation where lots of young gay men, I guess in their teens, young gay boys, and lots of young lesbians are now being surgically corrected to turn them into the supposed correct sex. You know, young lesbians, the vast majority of young women who go for treatment to turn them into men, the vast majority of them are people who would have previously identified as lesbians.

And they're having their breasts cut off. And they're taking drugs to give them which gives them a beard and breaks their voice. And once your voice is broken, as actual men, though, it doesn't go back. So it has a radical transformative effect on their life and on their fertility and on every aspect of their being as a woman.

So we now have a situation where over the last few decades, gay rights activists have said, conversion therapy is terrible. Look at these horrible redneck Christians in America who are getting these gay kids into church and praying and throwing the Bible at them and all that stuff, which can be pretty nasty. But at least those redneck Christians only try to pray the gay away. At least they didn't mutilate these kids.

At least they didn't castrate them. At least they didn't give them double mastectomies. At least they didn't give them drugs that radically transformed their bodies and had a destructive impact on their bodies. So you have a situation where the supposedly correct thinking section of society, which would look down its nose at Christianity and conversion therapy and all the horrible things that people on the right or people in traditional religious communities do, are now doing things which are infinitely more barbaric and infinitely more destructive and infinitely more homophobic.

Because the other country that does all this already is Iran. Iran is second only to Thailand. We all know Thailand has its lady boy population. Iran is second only to Thailand in the numbers of trans-surgery it carries out.

And the reason for that is because Iran is a violently homophobic country and it would prefer to turn gay men into women and lesbians into men rather than having gay men and lesbians in its society. As Ahmadinejad said a few years ago, we don't have any gay people in Iran. Because they have trans them into straight people, they trans the gay away. And the idol of the mainly issued what do they call them?

In the 60s when he was in exile saying transing is okay because we've got to get rid of these. So he was really progressive. He was in the eyes of the Guardian and the TikTok generation, he was really there at the very beginning in the 60s. One of the front runners.

Real front runner for trans rights. So every now and then you do kind of find yourself catching your breath and thinking what is going on? Why are some feminists defending the right of men to walk around with their cocks out amongst female children? Yes, why?

And another question, why are some gay rights activists defending the surgical mutilation of young gay people? And I think it's because, and this is something I try and get at in the book, we have entered a new age of unreason. We've entered a new age of hysteria where the constant churn of political correctness or wokeness or whatever we're supposed to call it, none of those terms are really satisfactory to describe what I would consider to be a grave assault on the Enlightenment itself. But the constant churn of that counter-enlightenment is just rolling over all the good positive ideas that we took for granted for the past few decades.

The sexual equality, gay rights, freedom of speech, scientific reason, all these things, racial equality, because I have a chapter about race as well, all these things that have grown and developed over the past few decades are now being destroyed by this age of unreason. And there's a real step back in relation to progressive ideas. And I know progressive is a controversial word because to some people's minds it means something good, to other people's minds it means something awful. But what I mean by it is ideas which help to push society forward.

And they are now all being undone by the unreason that has gripped sections of the elite and their foot soldiers. Well there used to be a word to describe someone who was against the Enlightenment. I think it's called a reactionary. Yeah.

Yeah. And we have a lot of them around now. But the great, the difficult thing of course is that these people don't think of themselves as reactionary. They think of themselves as radical leftists.

And they think they're the heirs to Mark and Luther King. They think they're in the same line. They think the right of a trans woman to take a dump in a woman's toilet, they think that's on a part with a right of Rosa Parks to sit wherever she wanted to sit on the bus. That is literally what they think.

Which to me is such a repulsive comparison. I've heard people make that comparison. That the right of trans people to go into certain spaces, toilets, change rooms, it's comparable to the right of Rosa Parks to sit at the front of the bus. That's how delusional they are.

And of course these things are completely and utterly incomparable. When Rosa Parks sat in the front of the bus she was making a great strike for civil rights, for public equality, for her freedom to choose how to engage with the public sphere. That was a wonderful expression of her desire for freedom. Which inspired hundreds of thousands of people's to make similar stabs for freedom in the public sphere.

When someone says I must have the right to go into that toilet and I must have the right to walk around naked in this changing room regardless of who it offends. That is an incredibly narcissistic self obsessed, egotistical desire to do whatever you want. Even if people around you don't want you to do it. Even if people even if it goes against every established norm that we've had for decades.

So it's incredibly self serving. It has no positive public impact whatsoever. I think it's just really important I think to look at what's changed in terms of what is described as progressive today in relation to what was described as progressive in the past. You remember the first time I interviewed you.

I think so. I mean you do a lot of interviews. I was in Stockholm. It was in a very nice hotel.

I remember. Top of who I got on. I came there with this same equipment and tried to rig it up and I was a technical idiot. I still am.

And I went through all of your well texts in Spike online. And then at the end of the interview I asked you how can you term yourself a Marxist? You know considering your positions on all of these objects. And you said well I still have a Marxist perspective.

But here's the thing because you grew up in England and it's never really been a socialist country. No it's a class society still has large swaths of conservatives in world strata really of society. And here's my take on it. What happens when you have an idea or a demand for radical equality or equity as they say nowadays.

What you have to do is you have to take away well the difference between the sexes because otherwise there's a difference between the sexes. That is not equal. And you have to get rid of all hero keys in society because they are a sign of difference between people. And there can't be any family because family promotes individuality.

The way you grow up the values your parents imbibe you with contribute to make you an individual and make you different than other people. So preferably in a communist society the state would be responsible for the upbringing of the children right. And then you have to get rid of religion because religion well it's not actually that it differentiates people that depends on the religion. But it is a competitor of socialism.

But what happens when you take away but it is also a system of morality religion and Marxism has its own system of morality. But what happens when you take away all these what I would say the forelegs that human life stands on is that humanity reverts back to its mean which is a heathen with a relativist world view and where truth does not exist and everything is subjective. Different gods in a polytheist society can they compete with each other right. But if there's just one god then there's one truth.

If there's many gods there may be many truths. And I think that is what we see happening so do you still call yourself a Marxist? Well sometimes I do and sometimes I can't be bothered. But I'll come on to answer your question in a moment.

I mean what I've discovered is there's no point trying to defend Marxism as an idea. I think the point I used to make in the past is I'm like those annoying fans of rock bands who will we say I prefer the early stuff. I'm like that with Marx. He was a liberal in his own.

I like the writing of Engels. I like the writing of some Russian revolutionaries pre-sarling of course. I think there's lots of intellectual stuff there and useful stuff and very pro freedom stuff. Marx's writing on press freedom are brilliant.

And right up to Trotsky even. Trotsky even using Mexico in the 1930s wrote some great stuff on press freedom and freedom of speech. That's what your Wikipedia says. Trotskyist.

Yeah and he was a stingy critic of the left. Not only in obviously Stalinist Russia who eventually killed Trotsky but also was critical of the left in Mexico and in America itself for always looking for the state to control the far right or to censor dangerous voices and he said no no no no don't ever do that. So there was a liberal strain in Marxist thought for a long time. And then obviously it just collapsed you know in Stalinist Russia it was a tyranny.

The Communist parties in the Western Europe were dreadful. Absolutely dreadful. And even after the Hungarian revolt which was viciously put down by the Soviets even then they still lots of Western Communist parties carried on aligning with the Soviet Union which was an unforgivable act of betrayal of that Hungarian movement for freedom as one example. So no it's it's not a particularly useful word anymore I think Marxist.

But I think the in relation to your broader question which was very well put you're absolutely right that there is a threat to all those things. The family religious freedom or religious belief or religious culture, individual sensibilities, all of those things are under threat to labor not from communism. They're under threat from our own governments. It would be hard for us to call the government of the United Kingdom a communist government.

It's a rubbish conservative government which is not particularly conservative and not particularly inspiring. But it's under those kinds of governments now that the family has been encroached upon all the time. There are so many social measures and policies which actually have the impact of undermining the sovereignty of the family and the integrity of the family and the authority of parents. And I think the trans ideology contributes to that because one of the key arguments put forward by trans activists today and there's a big fight about this in Britain at the moment is that children should be allowed to come out as trans at school and the school should not tell the parents and as the big tussle should parents have the right to know their kids as trans.

Of course they should have the right to know if your 13 year old son is going to school and put it on a dress and going to the girls' change rooms. You have a right to know but all of these have this very corrosive impact on parental authority and the tight knit nature of the family which should be its own world in which values are imparted and ideas are imparted and people have brought up in a particular value system. So the family is being undermined, religion has been undermined in the UK, the Church of England is undermining itself. I mean we recently had a bishop come out and say maybe we shouldn't save a prayer our father because it's too patriarchal.

The word father is a bit offensive, maybe we need to think of a different way or the Archbishop of Canterbury going to the very top after the George Floyd riots he said we need to examine every single church in the country, hundreds and hundreds of churches for any painting or statue or monument which in any way has a link to slavery. So they're having this kind of work exorcism off the churches to drive out the sins of history. So they're undermining themselves, they're saying we're basically evil, we have to cleanse ourselves. So people are a non-binary entity that lives in heaven and hell would be dynamic.

Exactly, right? So one of the big arguments that comes from some trans activists is that God is trans because he slash she is this external being that defies sex. And then of course individual freedom is being undermined all the time by new attacks on freedom of speech, freedom of association, the right to people to think as they want to think without being punished or discriminated against. So all those things are under assault but not from communism and the point I make to friends of mine on the right wing of politics.

I always say to them, look, if it's communism you're worried about you should actually be really thrilled by the rise of identity politics because to my mind, identity politics is the opposite of what we would have considered Marxism to be in the past. And I'm not saying that to big up Marxism by making it compared to something that we agree is terrible but just let me tell you if you look at, for example, identity politics doesn't care one eye-oater about class or the best is that it sees classes being in the intersection with everything else, the intersection with race and gender. So it's completely demeaned the importance of class. It's very uninterested in questions of economic power and wealth and who has the wealth and how we can get more of it to ordinary people.

It's not interested in that, it's more interested in self-definition, cultural issues, the right of validation and so on. It's not interested in economic growth at all. In fact, it is violently opposed to economic growth as we can see with movements like Just Stop Oil and Extinction Rebellion and the Green Movement more broadly who want to prevent economic growth. They now support something called de-growth which to me is a barbaric idea to support in a world in which three billion people still live in absolute poverty.

So they've given up on economic growth, they've given up on questions of class, they've given up on the fundamental question of Marxism which is where does economic power lie. And they've moved into realms that are just incredibly narcissistic and up their own arses and very kind of upper middle class and quite aristocratic. What language do you use? Are you using the right pronouns?

Are you bowing in the correct way to this person's identity? So it's post-Marxism, it's the end of Marxism. But I'm sure you've heard the term cultural Marxism. What happened in my view is that left lost the economic arguments between 1989 and 1991 when the war came down.

And then there was an academic Western strand of Marxism that was fighting a culture war already back then, at least in academia. And they sort of took over. Now the way I view classical Marxism is that it's basically, and I'm sorry if I offend you, but it's basically a conspiracy theory. It locks people in an endless class struggle between a good and evil, it's a moral tale, between the haves and the have-nots.

The benefit of classical Marxism is that class is not something, well you're born into it, but it can be changed. You can actually acquire a fortune. Or you can lose a fortune, right? But when they had lost the economic argument, suddenly they wanted it to be about sex or sexuality or skin colour, which is something you're born into but can never change.

I mean if you ask those people you can, but you can change your sex and gender, whatever they call it. But you can't change your skin colour because that would be wrong. So it's not logically coherent, but it's a relative movement, it doesn't have to be logically coherent. I have heard that argument a few times.

I mean I do understand the term cultural Marxism, I don't think it's a particularly useful term. There's this really annoying knee-jerk response to it in British politics, I don't know if it's the same here. Of course it is, it's a right-wing term. Right-wing term.

People say anti-Semitic. So some conservative politicians in Britain have used the term cultural Marxism, and we all know what they're talking about, they're talking about the kind of thing you've just outlined there, they're talking about the way in which some people use culture, academia, the education system to try and inculcate values into the next generation and so on. And that does happen, there's no doubt about it. But as soon as they say cultural Marxism, they're denounced as anti-Semitic.

They're denounced as anti-Semitic by people who come from a pretty anti-Semitic left, which we have a real problem with in Britain. So there's such hypocrisy there, but my view is I don't think cultural Marxism is an anti-Semitic term, I don't think it's a far right term, I understand what it means. I'm not convinced it's a particularly useful term, because I just think it doesn't get to the true nature of what we're currently living through. For two reasons, firstly, one argument I hear all the time from people who are kind of on my side of these debates is that the great clash between the classes that Marxism promoted has now just been put onto the issue of race or the issue of sex or whatever.

I don't buy that, I don't buy that primarily for the reason you've outlined, which is that the point of class politics was about bringing to an end the class system. So class politics had a radically transformative programme, whether one agreed with it or didn't agree with it. It wasn't just about saying I'm working class, validate my identity and take pity on me. It was about saying I'm working class and I want to ensure that the working class no longer exists, because you would demolish that social relation between the people who owned the means of production and the people who owned nothing more than their labour, which they had to sell in order to make a living.

It was about ending that relationship which was defined in Marxism as a social relation. So if it's a social relation, it can be changed. So if you project that as we're being told they're doing now, when you project that onto race or sex, it stops being anything like Marxism, because it doesn't have any radically transformative component whatsoever. It does become about ceaseless validation and complaint and grievance and black communities are presented as permanent victims and white people are presented as privileged and you have this tribal tension which is never ending and the role of the state then becomes to manage those relations.

So what this so-called cultural Marxism does, instead of changing society or inviting people to change their own living conditions, it creates this permanent experience of state management of everyday life. And cutting off your genitals is changing your current state. Well, it doesn't change your sex. It does change your life.

It changes your what's in your pants and it changes your life in a very problematic way. But that's delusional. I'm not saying you're being delusional, but they are being delusional because they think they're changing their sex and they're not. So there are things you can't change, one of them is your sex and yet they think they can.

And then when working for communities, vote for Brexit for example, or vote for the Sweden Democrats or Donald Trump, which are very clear demands for change, for a shake up of the current political system, for saying to the establishment that you've let us down time and again we want something different. Those people who are I think asking for a very sensible form of change or an understandable form of change, then look down upon as bigots and scumbags and idiots and morons, whereas the people who cast straight themselves or have double mastectomies are seen as radical inactors of change. So there's a bunch of contradictions in contemporary society. I just am not convinced that it benefits us to call it Marxism.

I just think, I just feel that that's ahistorical. And I think it's uninvolved. No, but I think what's driving that, and now I have to say no offense to you, I think what's driving that is this desire to bring the demons of the past to bear on contemporary discussion, because lots of people get a kick, particularly on the American right, there's some very sensible voices on the American right, I'm not criticizing that, but there is this desire to rehabilitate the monster of communism to make it clearer what we're up against today. And I think it can be a way of avoiding understanding the complexities of the current situation.

And so for example, why does a conservative government in Britain support trans operations for children, well for young people or, you know, people? Because that was actually my next question anyway, I wanted to know because in Sweden, I mean, we still do sex change operations or correctments as they're now called. But we don't do it to people under 80. Well, still in America, I follow this pink haired doctor of medicine on Instagram who brags every day on his Instagram feed about how many vaginal plasties and fellow plasties he's doing to minors, basically.

And I was wondering, is that something you do in Britain? No, no, with the same as Sweden, I guess, you have to be over 18 for that kind of surgical intervention. But you can get, although you used to be able to get hormonal treatment under the age of 18 and under the age of 16, puberty blockers, for example, that's now proven controversial. There was a court decision saying, people under the age of 16 are not old enough to be able to consent to that form of treatment, which I think is correct.

So that's changing too. But yeah, you do have to be 18 to get it. But the thing is, I think there's a broader question here. You're absolutely right.

If doctors are taking the breasts of a 13-year-old girl, that is utterly unforgivable. And I have no doubt that in 20 or 30 years time, I hope society will look back on that in the same way we look back on the bottom. It is mind-boggling, isn't it? It's my doctor is that don't believe in biology.

Yeah, exactly. How do you explain that? How do they live with themselves? I mean, how do they square it with themselves?

It's utterly surreal and it's a form of insanity. And the thing is that, you know, the Hippocratic oath says first do no harm. I can think of very few things more harmful than taking a confused 13-year-old girl into your surgery and taking her breasts off. I mean, it's just repulsive.

My American cousin, he was born without two of his front teeth. But he had to wait until 25 until they put in a new teeth because he wasn't finished with development. In 2025, his skull was still forming. But when it comes to cutting off genitals, apparently there is no problem.

When it comes to the sexual organs, knock yourselves out, do whatever you want. No, we're living through a moment of insanity. There is no question about it. In the UK, there have been challenges to it.

So there has been this ruling in relation to puberty blockers. We often refer to as turf island because we have so many turfs, trans exclusionary radical feminists. Those type of turfs. Yeah, gender critical.

Not like, tricks and love turfs. No, no, no. The good ones. Gender critical feminists, we have a lot of them and some of them are brilliant.

So they're pushing back on all of this and they're having some successes. So it is a reminder that it is possible to push back against the tide of unreasonable and it's essential to do so. But I just think it's such a confusing moment, just to finish my ask to do a previous question. It's such a confusing moment that I think people are looking for, I think people are trying to navigate the 21st century with 20th century language.

So you will have people on the left will say Donald Trump is Hitler. Populism in Europe, Brexit and so on is fascism. So they don't understand it. They don't know why people are voting for Trump.

They don't know why 17.4 million of us vote for Brexit. They don't get it because they're out of touch and they're aloof and they live in an echo chamber. So they look for a 20th century term that makes sense for everyone. This is the 1930s.

I mean, everyone Prince Charles has said that. The Archbishop of Canterbury has said it. The Guardian says it every day of the week. So they try and make sense of it by bringing that language, that clear language from the past.

And I think there are sections on the right who are doing something similar. So they can't understand why in the free Republic of the United States in 2023, doctors are mutilating children. They can't understand why a conservative-led country like Britain is doing some stupid crazy woke stuff. Like for example, street names being renamed and university buildings being renamed because they have the names of problematic historical figures.

As one example, they can't understand why that's happening. So they say it's Marxism. It's communism. It's a neo-neism.

They say it's that march through the institutions that began in the 30s and 40s, Gramsci and all the rest of it. All I'm saying in relation to both the left who fall back on the language of Nazism and the right who fall back on the language of communism, all I would say is it might be more complicated than that. And it might benefit us to try and work out what is new and what is different and what is particular about this moment. And that will then, I think, make it easier for us to challenge some of the excesses of what we live in through.

Well, I think personally that if we had in 1989, just would have scourged the socialist from academia, we wouldn't be in this situation. You take up the terms birthing parent and chest feeding in the chapter of her penis. I was wondering what you think about the new term for vagina, bonus soul. Oh my god, it just gets worse all the time, doesn't it?

I mean, they're just pornographic terms now. This comes from pornographic films, so I understand. I've read about someone said that in an article I read. No, it's just disgusting.

Bonus whole, the dehumanization of women's bodies. I do feel like sometimes I feel like I'm becoming a radical feminist, which is, you know, you and I have had discussions about the problem of feminism in the past and we should carry on having those discussions. But I do sometimes feel like I'm turning into a radical feminist because you wake up and you read an article and it says, you know, people have been encouraged to refer to the designers as bonus holes or in America, African American mothers are now referred to as black birthing bodies. And you think, hold on, when did we go back to slavery?

I'm sure that's what they said in the slavery era. You know, by this black birthing body, she'll be great in your picking up sound a bit of personal. In fact, there are some black women in America who are gender critical, who are making this point that the dehumanizing language about black birthing bodies in particular echoes the language of slavery and the way women were talked about then. Yeah, and we see across Western Europe as well, we see bonus holes, chest feeding.

There was this recent controversy in the UK where ITV News, which is one of our main news channels, they did a piece about mothers who are struggling in the cost of living crisis and they interviewed one mother for this piece, who was a man who identifies as a mother because he has a son or a child. And it was a big controversy and lots of women said, couldn't you talk to a real woman? Can you find one real mother in this country of 67 million people who are struggling in the cost of living crisis? And then this man who identifies as a mother, he responded to the controversy by releasing on Twitter a photograph of himself breast feeding his kid.

Chest feeding. In this case, it was chest feeding. So starving his kid. Right, because men cannot, I can't believe we have to say this, men cannot breast feed.

Men do not lactate. And even men who have had hormonal treatment to grow fake breasts do not lactate. They cannot produce milk. And in fact, it's very unwise, according to doctors for them to put their nipples into a child's mouth because they excrete hormonal residue from all the drugs that are pumping through their body because of course, if you're trans, you have to take drugs every day for the rest of your life.

Otherwise, you're fucked. When he released this photograph of himself, breast feeding his kid, people were really horrified because that's not normal behavior. And some people said this looks like a fetish. And in fact, then, some people found photographs of him on Instagram wearing nipple clamps.

This happened in Sweden years ago. There was a man who, as an experiment, had a blog. This was in the era where blogs were a thing. He attempted to breast feed his child.

Of course, they had to give him formula as well because obviously he can't do it. So he wasn't frowned upon by Swedish society. He was brought into a state television and treated like a fucking hero. Well, that's what happened with this breastfeeding bloke in the UK.

He was supported by sections of the Labour Party, obviously by ITV News, by the Twitter adi they also said, look, he is a muck. They also, she is a mother. And so I wrote a piece with Spike just saying, this is an act of provocation against ordinary people. This is not just an innocent, oh, look at me, chest feeding my kid and when the establishment lined up behind him and cheered him on.

That was an act of provocation. That was just, they were just making fun of us. They're laughing in our faces. They're lying to us.

They're offending us with these images of obscene acts and then calling them motherhood. They're saying a vagina is a bonus hole. They're saying this man should be allowed to take his clothes off wherever he wants. They are provoking us day in, day out and they're gaslighting us.

And I think that's one of the reasons why it's so important for people to start speaking out on these things because if we allow ourselves to be gaslit, we will just go crazy. But you want the platform, right? I see you on Australian news, I see on British news, I see on American news, but you have that type of job. It's a professional heretic.

Those people have normal jobs. They need them to support their families. Yeah, absolutely. So, I mean, there is an economic incentive, I suppose is the word, to not speak out.

At least, and then there's a social incentive that is quite strong as well because you don't want to be labeled the biggest racist, Nazi, fascist, pig, scum, whatever. Yeah, and that's a really important point and one that we shouldn't dismiss because it is fairly easy for me to say these things because that's my job is to say it's my job to write a book called a heretic manifesto and write about controversial issues. And if everyone spoke out, you wouldn't have a job. That's very true.

So, everyone shut up. Don't say anything. No, but I do, I have been no platform at universities like Oxford, for example, and there are usually when I speak at university, there's a protest, there's a gathering of people calling me a bigger than shouting at me. So, those things happen, but it's part of my job and part of my responsibility, I think, to be able to deal with all that stuff.

I know you've had similar issues. So, you're right, but the question then becomes why do people feel they can't speak out? What makes them think they will lose their job, lose their income? Which does happen?

I mean, to go back to that example, who I'm not as well known as JK Rowling, not as rich, who I'm not professional feminist like some of the other TERFs are, they feel they can't speak out. I get emails from women all the time, messages via Instagram or email saying I'm glad you write about the trans issue because I can't say anything about it. So that's one of the reasons we have to challenge cancel culture because people think the problem with cancel culture is that every now and then someone is silenced, every now and then someone is banished from polite society or JK Rowling is subjected to abuse day in day out. They think that's the problem, but those things are problems, but the real problem is the trickle down effect that cancel culture has, the chilling effect it has across society because it sends a message to everyone that says, if JK Rowling can be subjected to rape and death threats every day of her life online for saying that biology is real, imagine what will happen to you.

Imagine what will happen to you, the lowly receptionist at some big business, if you go online and say, people with penises are not women, imagine what will happen, that's what it says. It's a threat to everyone else and the cancel culture mob I think is quite acutely aware of this. They know that they go for the big names, they try and take down people like you, they attack they moan about people like me, they go after better known people, but they know that what they're really doing is policing the parameters of acceptable thought. They know that they are marching around the borders of what they consider to be the acceptable things to think and the acceptable things to say.

They know that's what they're doing and it's effective. So yeah, you're right, there are people out there who are afraid to speak out for either economic reasons or because they fear social ostracism and I think we have to create the conditions in which those people feel freer to say what they want to say. Chilling effect is an interesting term, considering that you have a chapter on witches accused of controlling the weather. So I think I wrote it down here somewhere, I'm guessing you're still not a convert to the cult of Saint Gretta, bless it be your name.

Absolutely not. No. There was some type of witches trial in England, I wrote down the, it was Agnes Simpson. Yes.

The North Béric Witch Trials. Exactly. Yeah, so that's the second chapter of the book which is called Witch Finding and it's basically about basically making the point that many of the witch trials of the 1500, 1600s and early 1500s were really about climate change. One of the key accusations made against these women and sometimes men, but mostly women, was that they were causing contrary weather because this was the era of the little Ice Age.

So it's a very cold period, especially in Northern Europe, which is where most of these witch trials took place. So crops were failing, people were starving, society, communities were suffering. So people went looking for the scapegoat, the person they could blame and that's when they would always be explosions in witch hunts during particularly cold periods and particularly moments of crop failure. And these women were accused of causing contrary weather, causing wintery weather, causing terrible storms and winds.

So Agnes Simpson was one of I think 25 witches were killed in North Béric in Scotland. That's more than the Salem Witch Trials. More than the Salem Witch Trials. It's quite well known, the North Béric Witch Trials are quite well known in the UK.

First time I've ever heard that. Yeah, but outside of the UK, not particularly well known. Nicholas Spurgeon, who was our first minister, apologized for the North Béric Witch Trials a couple of years ago. And at the time I made the point, well, when is she going to apologize for the witch hunting of Scottish feminists who don't think men can become women?

But yeah, so what's interesting I think is that we had climate witch hunts 400, 500 years ago and we have climate witch hunts today. Because one of the striking things about the climate change hysteria is the resuscitation of the, at least the feeling of the witch trial. So people are called climate criminals. If you drive too much or put your kettle on too much or go on holiday too much, you're seen as being a destroyer of the planet.

Big businesses are constantly being called climate destroyers. And they're all accused of causing contrary weather. We call it weather of mass destruction these days. No, it's not cold.

It's hot. Or the new time is global boiling. See the United Nations now calls it global boiling, which is just absolutely preposterous. There's still more people die of cold than not heat.

There's still more people die of cold. And that's what really gets my goat about the current global boiling hysteria. Firstly, you know, who the hell do they think they are to invent these terms out of thin air? And why are so many people taking them on board?

Why do people, so many people on the left in particular who want to be a bit suspicious of people in positions of power, as soon as a propagandistic term like global boiling comes from the United Nations, they start bowing down to it and saying this is a new term. They'll all start saying global boiling now, even though it's complete nonsense. And the truth of the matter is more people still die from cold weather, not only in places like Sweden and England, which get quite cold in the winter, but in India, in Italy, more people die from cold. Globally, actually.

And in fact, one of the points to make by Beyond Longborg and others is that at the moment, the warming trend that we are currently living through for whatever reason might be saving lives. Because if winter nights in the UK, for example, which has been the case, if they're a bit warmer than they used to be a few years ago, a few decades ago, fewer people will die as a consequence of severe cold. So at the moment, global warming, or whatever we're supposed to call it, I don't even like that term if I'm being honest, seems to be saving lives. And it seems to me that if the planet really is getting hotter, then the logical thing to do is to acclimatise to it, have better air conditioning, have more open public swimming pools, create the conditions in which people can cool down, build new housing around the possibility that it'll be very hot in the summertime.

We know how to do this. In the United States, it's been getting hotter over the past few decades, but fewer people are dying from heat because they've got air conditioning. But air conditioning is bad for the climate. Exactly.

This is one of the great contradictions where I was on British TV news, Sky News in the UK a couple of years ago, and they said to me, what should we do about the heating planet? And I said, let's have more air conditioning, and everyone went crazy thinking I was being flippant, but I wasn't being flippant at all. That is what we should do. But of course, they won't do it because it uses energy, which is a terrible thing to do.

It produces CO2s, which is tantamount to evil. And so they won't do that. So you think yourself, well, what do you want us to do, and what they really want us to do, is to basically reverse the industrial revolution, go back in time, switch everything off, have less, leave Africa as it is, because if they have cities like Stockholm or London or New York, then the planet will fry, so leave them in poverty. We don't care about them.

And just wind everything down. That's really what they're saying. And less people. And fewer people and less air conditioning, less production, fewer factories.

It really is a demand to wind back the great gains of the industrial revolution. The point I make is the industrial revolution is without question in my mind, it is without question the best thing that has happened to humankind ever. In all the wonderful things that we've done over the past 3,000 years, in particular 5,000 years, the best is the industrial revolution. It changed everything.

It radically transformed every aspect of our lives, not only in terms of living longer and the creation of health systems and healthier communities over time, but also that's where freedom comes from. Because if you're forced into a city with hundreds of thousands of other people, you start politically organized and you start calling for more rights. You start saying children shouldn't go up chimneys. They should be in school.

Educational rights come from the industrial revolution. Everything good that we enjoy was pushed into the forefront by the industrial revolution. I am so suspicious of anyone who's anti-industrial revolution, which is people like Greta Thunberg and the entire green movement, and huge sections of the political class itself. Well, Justice finally caught up with Greta the other day.

She was convicted of, I think, how do you translate it? Not listening to the police. She was protesting some oil refinery in Malmo or whatever. There are a lot of the North, as I call it.

Well, what was really striking about that protest with Greta and the Malmo oil refinery? There's some pictures from that. I read about them, and I think they capture environmentalism so well, because you had Greta and her spoiled, brat friends sitting down in the road. You could see that none of them had ever done a day's work.

They were all 17 or 18 or 19 or 20. Probably come from nice backgrounds. She does, like she does. She doesn't do it well.

Cultural aristocracy. Yeah, and their mothers are not pursuing her, and I'm sure they're all well-to-do kids. And then in the background, blurred out because they were in the background. You could see these blokes, working-class Swedes standing by their trucks, kind of texting and looking bored, wanting to be productive, wanting to do a job that is absolutely essential to Swedish society, as it is in every European country, which is to deliver oil, deliver energy, make sure that the country keeps moving.

I just thought it was such a good snapshot of the narcissism and classism of the green movement that you would have these spoiled brats sitting in the road, blocking the right of working-class men to do an essential job. Well, you did teach me a new word in your book, Gannen. I hadn't heard it before. And they are the ones working in those types of places.

For you Swedish listeners, it means quark, because Brexit years were apparently fat and red-faced, like pigs. And you do a wonderful analogy to how the nobility of England used to talk about the thrones, the masses. The whiteness multitude. Yes.

Yeah. So I'm going to talk about the book a little bit just to look at what's similar between then and now. And the Gannen thing was such a good example of that. So in the UK, the political left, the kind of bourgeois left, they've been using the term Gannen for a few years now to describe, as you say, Brexit voters, lower middle-class, working-class men, largely red-faced.

I was looking at the fact that often these men have red-faced because they've been working outdoors for decades, building things and having wind blown in their faces. And also drinking a lot from beer. And drinking beer in the pub after work, absolutely. And I think about the people the men I grew up with, I come from an Irish community in North London, they often were red-faced, because well, firstly, because they came from wind-swept parts of Ireland where they were being battered by wind's their whole lives, and then they worked on building sites and they drank in the parts.

So I just found the whole, I always found the term Gannen so disgusting because as you say, it means pig. People were being referred to as pig meat. That's how the working classes were being referred to by the bourgeois left. And then I was looking back through history and I found out that there was this journal in the late 1700s in Britain, there was a radical journal called Pigs Meat.

And I thought, that's interesting. Why was that? And of course, it was because Edmund Burke, very famous conservative thinker in British history, Edmund Burke wrote about the French Revolution. He was very worried about the French Revolution.

And he said that the swine-ish multitude is rising up. So you refer to them as swines, radical working class people as swines. And so radical working class people in Britain started to run with this analogy of swines and they had magazines called Pigs Meat and... So they made it their own?

They made it their own. They kind of reclaimed it. And they said, yes, we are swine and we demand rights and so on. And they said it would rather be a swine-ish multitude than a palker, drinking and eating all day long.

That's how they saw the aristocracy. So I just thought it was very interesting that you can have 250 years separation and yet the similar pig-based insult was being used against ordinary people. It was being used in the late 1700s and the early 1800s against people who wanted the right to vote or who thought that ordinary people should have more input into political life. And it's been used in the UK and the 2020s to refer to people who voted for Brexit, who are a bit populist, who want to be taken seriously and who oppose the establishment.

In both cases, they were referred to as pigs. Imagine calling human beings pigs. It's just beyond belief. And that is how dehumanizing this work culture has become.

Where people... Now the neurosocracy is left or at least they claim to be left. But the word... There's no question about it.

The insult gammon comes from the bourgeois left, the kind of influential left. We're not talking about just the old big-daddled, left-wing man who sells newspapers on the street corner. We're talking about the cultural left. We're going back to cultural Marxism, but the cultural left who are influential in the media and in cultural sphere and at the BBC and in the Guardian.

These are very influential institutions and the word gammon came from those kinds of people. And it was unquestionably a classist insult that was used to demonize ordinary people whose only crime was to vote to leave the European Union. I was one of those people. I remember.

I was one of my friends and my family. So for those people to be called pigs, no, it's disgusting. Maybe you should reclaim the word. Gabon on the t-shirt.

Yes, why not? Merchandise is a great way to make money. And if you know me, I love capitalism. So I wanted to talk a bit about the chapter, Islamo's censorship.

Because at the moment we have inflation in Sweden, as I'm sure you do, because Brexit in your case. But we also have an inflation in Quran burnings now. You do? Yes.

And it's fascinating. And Iran's supreme leader, bless you. His name Ayotollah Khomeini, not Khomeini, but because they're all named pretty much the same. He has said that Sweden has waged a war on the Muslim world.

It's so interesting. I want to get your views on this as well, why you think it's happening. But to me, I think something so strange has happened in Western society over the past few decades, which has become almost illegal. In fact, in the UK, you can't be punished in law and in France for being mean about Islam.

So for example, in France, Michelle Welbeck, the famed celebrated novelist was taken to court for calling Islam the stupidest religion. In the UK, in Austria, a woman was punished in a court of law for referring to Muhammad as a pedophile. Sometimes the punishment is extrajudicial. We saw that with the Charlie Hebdo massacre, or the heading of Samuel Petit, the French school teacher who had his head cut off on the streets of Paris, because he showed an image of Muhammad to his school kids.

In the UK, there's a school teacher who's still in hiding. He's been in hiding for two years, because he showed an image of Muhammad in a classroom discussion about freedom of speech and a fundamentalist mob turned up at the school gates and threatened to take action. In the UK, we've seen films being pulled from cinemas under pressure from Muslim mobs. And of course, then to top it all off, if that's the right phrase, we saw Saman Rushdie, they finally got to Saman Rushdie.

And he lost the use of an eye and a hand. So that's the contemporary punishment for criticizing Islam, an eye and a hand. This is just obscene in every level. And what's most shocking about it, which is why I wrote that chapter, is that there is a real problem with Islamist mobs.

There's a real problem with radical Islam, I think, in our societies. It's become a very dangerous phenomenon which actually kills people. Hundreds of people have been slaughtered in Western Europe over the past decade at the hands of radical Islamists. Scores in Britain alone, the Manchester Arena bombing, which targeted young girls at a Ariana Grande concert, which killed 21 people.

This is a very serious problem, but we're discouraged from talking about it, because if you talk about it, you will be accused of Islamophobia. Why are you obsessing on this issue? You know, the... The...

The... The phobia is a word that denotes irrational fear. Yeah, it's a very rational fear. It's very rational to be concerned about the growth of Israelical Islam and the violence of radical Islam.

Very rational indeed. And so I think what's interesting to me is the interplay between radical Islamists on the one side who want to crush any criticism of their religion and the cowardly elites on the other who are basically doing what they're being told. So they are demonizing criticism of Islam. They are arresting people in some cases.

Well, they are institutionalizing Islamophobia. The police use that term, educational institutions use that term. Politicians use it. So it's the connection between those two things that I find really worrying because there's always going to be radical nutters in our societies.

There's always going to be people who say, don't do this, don't do that. Otherwise I'll kill you. That will always be a problem. But what's particularly problematic right now is that it official to them in Europe instead of saying, hold on, you're not allowed to make those demands.

weder übel no hart Anna und Lara Hallo zemme! Mir si "weder übel no hart", zwei Zwilling us dr Schwiz, wo viel und gern rede. Genau so vielsitig wie eusi Interesse, werde au d Theme si, wo mr uf dem Podcast mit euch genauer wei aluege. Ehrlich, direkt und ungfilteret werde mir eus ustusche, euch unterhalte und euch vilicht drbi au neui Denkastöss mitgeh. Grenze setze mir eus keini; s git nämlich scho gnueg. "weder übel no hart" uf Instagram: @annauebelhart, @larauebelhart. Bi Froge, Aregige, Kritik, Feedback oder Idee: eifach e DM schicke. Explicit THE VOGS (Voice Of Galih Seto) Galih Seto Abadi Cerita di sini tidak abadi, hanya cerita kemarin, hari ini, besok dan yang akan datang. Selamat mendengarkan. Keluh kesah, gembira, dan harapan akan terekam disini. Karena ini Tidak Abadi. Kritik dan saran bisa ke, E-mail : [email protected] Ig : @thevogsid Twitter : @thevogs Powered by Firstory Hosting Explicit PODCAST TSx Podcast TSX podcast ini akan membahas berbagai macam topik yang menarik. Dengan saya @triskysantosoo . Saya tidak hanya sendiri karena saya akan di temani ngobrol ngobrol dengan teman teman saya yang tidak kalah menariknya. podcast ini akan di upload secara berkala tiap minggunya. Kalian juga bisa follow akun ig podcast ini @podcast_tsx atau email [email protected] untuk kritik saran dan masukannya. Terima kasih Explicit Penikmat Kutipan Putri wulan Podcast ini dibuat untuk memacu diri agar menjadi pribadi yang lebih baik.Bila ada saran/kritik kirim via DM @putsetiani Explicit

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of DEKONSTRUKTIV KRITIK?

This episode is 1 hour and 48 minutes long.

When was this DEKONSTRUKTIV KRITIK episode published?

This episode was published on August 20, 2023.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this DEKONSTRUKTIV KRITIK episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.