Welcome to Beam Me Up, a Star Trek podcast. I am Brent Allen, and this is a very special supplemental episode, which means, as you guys have been listening to this, maybe this is your first time through the show with us, it's just me this time. Matt's not here. In fact, Matt is not allowed. I'll say it yet again. Matt, if you're listening, shoo, go away.
You're not allowed to be here. And if anybody else is doing a first time watch along with Matt, I can't force you to not listen, but I'd recommend you turn this off and come back later because this episode is going to be filled with all kinds of spoilers about the upcoming episodes on what we're covering here on Beam Me Up, but also what's going on in the larger world of Star Trek and how all of these things interact. Like everything's on the table. We're not hiding anything. So this is your last warning. Leave unless you just want to be spoiled or you've watched it all before. And which case, enjoy the conversation. For those of you guys that have been following along since the beginning, you guys know that we have a mantra here at Beam Me Up. The world needs Star Trek. The world is better when Star Trek is on TV. The whole world needs to sit down and watch Star Trek together. But with over eight.
hundred hours of Star Trek material, that can be a little overwhelming to somebody who's never really seen it before. So the mission here at Beam Me Up has been, how do you take that? first time watcher, a Trek newbie and condense that 800 plus hours and growing in there right now into a manageable 150, 175 ish episodes, basically like a regular seven season run and still give that Trek newbie a relatively complete understanding of what Star Trek is really about. The message, the hope of the future, that Gene Roddenberry vision of the future, the story of the future that Star Trek is trying to tell us and just some good old fun television all at the same time. Now that said, it has fallen to my shoulders to not just pick the good episodes of Star Trek, but the episodes that fit within that mission of the podcast, which means that I sometimes have to be fairly judicious, shall we say, with the episodes that we pick for Matt.
and with which ones we let go. It also means that sometimes our favorite episodes or storylines kind of get left to the side while we spend a limited amount of time focusing on others. And it also means that sometimes episodes that I generally consider to be really important, when I go back and look at them with more critical eye, I've discovered maybe they're not as important as I once thought they were. Doesn't mean they're any less bad. It just means we have to make those hard choices. Now, I had to decide a while ago that mostly because of your emails, that me making these choices in a vacuum was a really bad idea because you guys, how could you leave that episode out? So a while back, I started inviting people onto the show. By the nature of the show, Matt and I don't really get to bring in guests a lot.
So I love shows like this where I get to bring in a guest from another Star Trek podcast and we get to talk Trek. I just get to talk Trek with somebody who actually knows Trek, which is really cool. And usually. One of the things is I'm meeting these people for the very first time. I've never really truly met them before. And this is one of the cool things about having a shared fandom. It's like you're almost immediately friends. I'm really excited about my guests for this episode, because even as I get to connect with other podcasters, some people have been doing this longer. Sometimes these are people whose podcasts I've been listening to since before I got started. Or maybe it's even in this case, people I'm a little bit jealous of because their idea was so good that if I would have had it first, that's what I would have done for my podcast. But I didn't have it first. They did. And it's their podcast now. And that's absolutely awesome. And that's exactly who we have today. I'm really pleased to introduce and welcome to the show from the Trek Profiles podcast. John Krikorian. John, I hope I.
your last name right and welcome to beam me up and thank you in advance for what you're about to endure. Oh, you pronounced it just wonderfully. And I'm so glad that all the guests you really wanted canceled and you had to scrape the bottom of the barrel and find me so that I could be here. So I'm glad to pinch hit for all the guests that people really want to hear from. And I hope that I can provide some entertaining commentary as we go through some Voyager. We should. And I'm really excited to talk about Voyager season four. But, you know, John, you are anything but the bottom of the barrel, because here's the thing, your show, Trek Profiles, I want you to talk about that here in just a minute. But actually, go ahead and talk about it now, because I'll share something with you about that here in just a second. Go ahead.
Sure. So I've been a podcast listener since the very beginning of podcasts. Since 2006, I was a listener. So early, early days. And we listened to podcasts on iPods. Yes, we actually had iPods. There was actually a period of time when I had a car that didn't have a connector. So I was downloading podcasts on my computer and burning them to a CD and actually playing them in a CD changer in a car that I had. I mean, that's how long ago I was listening to these things. So I was very familiar with podcasts, podcasting, how it all works. And I've been listening to some shows consistently since 2006. And it was only when I got invited on some podcasts to talk about Star Trek, actually, that someone approached me.
from a network and they said, Hey, you know, you should do a show for us. And my answer was no, because I didn't feel like there was anything in the Star Trek universe of podcasting that wasn't already being done and being done well. And in fact, being done by like four different people. So if you wanted a rewatch show, there's a lot of them. If you want news, there's a lot, you know, you want analysis. There's a lot. If you just want like, Hey, I want to listen to people hang out and just talk about Trek shows. There's a lot. So I just didn't feel like there was anything that I could contribute that was particularly new or innovative in the area. So I was more than happy to guess when people invited me on and I just didn't worry about it. And I never gave a second thought after that. And I was
actually listening to one of those podcasts that I'd been listening to since 2006 was a tech podcast. And, and this guy who was an independent podcaster, his name is Adam Christensen, by the way, he does a show called the Mac cast independent podcaster started in 2006 and early days. And one of the things he talked about is how his show was not really for him. The joint doing the show was not about geeking out about Mac stuff or anything like that. It was about the community that has sprung up around his podcast. Right. And suddenly like a penny dropped in my head or a quarter dropped or the credit card got charged or whatever sort of term we would use these days. And I realized that the podcast that I could do about Star Trek,
would not be about Star Trek, really. It would actually be about the fandom and how people interact with Star Trek. how they found it, what they get out of it, why they love it and how it's changed their lives. That was something I thought I could do. And, and, and with some amount of humility, I will say that the thing that I think helps me be a good host for the show is that I'm not of strong opinions about Star Trek personally, meaning that I love the show, but I'm not one of those people that's like, no, you must love the show exactly how I love it in the way that I love it with the intensity that I love it in the correct ways. And if you don't appreciate these seven things about Star Trek, well, then you're just not a Star Trek fan. I can't even talk to you. I'm just, I'm just not built that way. So it enables me to talk to people who say like, these are the only series of Star Trek that I care.
about this is the only Star Trek that matters. You know, this is the one thing in Star Trek that I think is worth it. And, you know, everyone else is wrong. And I can talk to that person and have a conversation with them without feeling personally assaulted or feel like I have to convince them of anything. Right. So which I feel like that's a rare commodity these days in a lot of ways. So I think that that's been something that's been helpful to me in doing my show. And so I'm always on the lookout for people that have interesting Star Trek stories, how it's affected them, what episodes of the show have touched them in some way or changed their lives or affected them in some profound way. And, you know, it's interesting because you can take an episode that people do not care about or people would say that.
is a terrible episode of Star Trek. But because of something that's going on in someone's life at the time, they see something in that episode that makes them have a change or spurs a thought. And so they say that episode is very special to me and I love it. And it's an episode that would not make anybody else's top 10 list. And that's usually something that very much interests me. And I want to explore that with people because if people just come on and we talk about the same 25 episodes of Star Trek, it would get very boring. So it's really about that personal connection that people have to the show. So when people come on, we do like a three part sort of format. It's kind of loosey goosey, but generally we go into their fandom. You know, how did you get into the show? What?
what about it appealed to you? How did you discover it? You know, are you one of the lifers who, you know, basically say, I can't remember a time I wasn't watching Star Trek. You know, there's a lot of those. But recently I've been having, I've been doing a sort of an occasional series of people who discovered Star Trek later in life. People who were, you know, 20, 30, 40 years old and said, you know, Star Trek is stupid. It's for kids or it's dumb or, you know, Star Wars is my thing. And then suddenly they discover Star Trek and they swear allegiance to the guilt. Right. And they, they, they post something online, you know, and they're like, I've just discovered Star Trek. Where's this been all my life. And I'm like, I want to talk to you. And I love talking to those people because they have a very different experience of the fandom than those of us who sort of grew up in it. Right. So they don't have
to some of these fandom fights that the rest of us have been dealing with for a long time. So we do this fandom exploration. You know, you've been to a convention, you have a collection, you know, what does your fandom look like? And then we go into the episodes that really matter to them and why they matter to them personally, as opposed to just, you know, really good episodes. And then they always get the ultimate question, which is why does Star Trek matter to you in your life? And it's amazing the stories people have told me. It's been a way for me to reconnect to Star Trek in my own life. And it's been just glorious. The connections I've made, the people I've met, I consider it really a gift and just a wonderful way to just meet interesting people. We'll be right back.
Hey, if you recognize those sounds, then you're probably somebody who would like our show. We're called Did You Hear About This, and we talk about all kinds of news stories. It's like the 80s and 90s stuff that we grew up on. Yeah, this isn't stuff that's getting covered on the 10 o'clock news, I'll tell you that. You can check us out at didyouhearaboutthis.show. We're on every single podcast platform. Go find us.
You know, I got to tell you, I have heard other podcasts that discuss people's fandom. How'd you get into the team or how did you, how did you, how did you come to know this? And, you know, and, and particularly I hear that in the NFL world, you'll try to interview the various fans and stuff. And often I got to be honest, I'm kind of like, I don't care. Like, I don't, I don't care why you're a fan of this team because.
I don't know that person and I don't really care why they're a fan of team. I just know that they are. I think sometimes it's only because there's only about five or six answers that you really get, particularly for a sports team. It's like either your parents or parental figure liked it or you grew up in the hometown or you had no loyalty, just chose that team or you liked a player and you followed them to the team. Like it's usually circled around that or some variation of that. But your show, I got to be honest, I find myself captivated by these people that I don't know. Like, like I find myself going, I don't know you. Why would I listen to you? And then I listen to it and I'm.
floored because everybody has a different story. And what you do so well, you just mentioned it half a dozen times, I think, is you talk about what does Trek mean to them? Why does it matter? And where are those episodes that are really important? And those are the those are really just the most.
fascinating places to come to. I'm one of the adult people, you know, and I, it's been an interesting exploration coming to Trek as an adult. And now with Matt, like I've still been a Trek fan now for 20 years, even though it's as an adult, but I'm watching him go through it for that first time and maybe even challenge some of my own notions that I have as a fan. And I'm like, Oh, you didn't like that episode that everybody else in the entire fandom seems to love. Interesting. Why not? Like, what was your first reaction to that? So it's, it's, it's been incredibly interesting, but here's the thing. A lot of the people that I've had sitting in this chair that you're in right now are people that I was quote unquote introduced to from your show. Oh, that's like, I would listen to your show to sort of vet them a little bit.
But, you know, not all, but some. And so it's been it's been real interesting. So the name of the show is Trek Files Podcast. No, Trek Profiles. That's what I meant. Trek Profiles. Trek Files is the other podcast called Trek Files, which you should listen to. That's Larry Nemechek. It's a wonderful show. You should listen to it. But that's a different show. Trek Profiles is mine. Thank you. Trek Profiles available pretty much anywhere and everywhere you can get your podcast. Anywhere you get your audio. But let me just say one thing, which is we're talking about the sports fandom. And I actually have a theory about this. And feel free to beat me up on it because this is just something I'm chewing over in my own head. I'm not sure if I believe this yet.
sports fandom and i just want to say i am a sports fan not of all sports but of the vegas golden knights nhl hockey right that is that is the only sports thing i care about and i care about it to an inordinate degree okay so i understand about that about sports fandom but sports fandom to me seems to be a fandom that is really about being shoulder to shoulder Like we are here together sitting side by side with our attention focused on the other thing, which is the sports. Yeah. The Trek fandom I've noticed is that it's very much a face to face fandom that people want to talk to each other about Star Trek more than someone. I mean, and there are cases people say come to my house. We'll watch Star Trek together. I mean, I get that, but that's not what it is. That is not the core thing of it. You know, it's when people find other Trek fans, they're like, we are going to talk Trek, bro. And we are going to talk about, you know, we were going to talk about discovery and we're going to talk about lower decks, you know, whatever it is. And people very much want to have that connection face to face about Trek with other fans. And so it's a, it's a major difference in sort of the.
attitudinal way that people approach the fandom, whether it's shoulder to shoulder or face to face. Anyway, this is something I've just been kind of noodling on. I'm not sure I have it fully fleshed out, but that's my thought. No, it rings true what you're saying, because there's definitely an experiential nature to being in a stadium full of people that are. mostly complete strangers. And, you know, if you sit in the same seat often, maybe you get to know the people right around you, but still like 70,000 of your closest friends or, you know, you're all just, just rooting for the same team. Whereas with Trek. Yeah. Like I don't have like maybe with some of the new Trek, you have like Trek watch parties, but it's not to that extent at all. Not, you know, it's not a Superbowl party. It's not, it's not about that. I mean, I've had them here. I had a thing at my house, you know, but it's, it's not that it's about people focusing. They really want to connect to each other. And you see this at conventions, you know, you see this at like all these fan run events. I mean, I don't know if, if people are getting together and having like conventions to talk about their local basketball team that is not sponsored by the basketball team.
Right. Right. Like, no, we ourselves are going to get together to talk about, you know, the local hoopsters. Right. Or, you know, the local footballers or whatever it is. It's just not a thing. But Trek fans do this kind of stuff. And so there's just something something a little different there. And I'm still kind of thinking about it. I like I like the face to face aspect of that. That's that's an interesting it's an interesting what you got me thinking about that for a while now of how that actually works. Well, John, why don't we go ahead and jump into our content for today? Let's do. As I mentioned earlier, we're going to be talking about and taking a look at the episodes coming up in Voyager season four. We are wrapping up season three. Matt and I are. And so what we'll do is we're going to go episode.
episode. We're going to discuss the episode, whether it's essential viewing. Like, do you absolutely have to see it to understand what's going on? Or, you know, is it a sketch it on the rewatch? You don't have to watch it right now. And we do have that third option that I often talk about when an episode doesn't really fit within the scope of the show, but it's still a really good episode and is really highly recommended for whatever reason. We mark those as extra viewings and Matt pulls those up for our Patreon feed. If you guys want to check that out, shameless plug, patreon.com slash beat me up. And that'll be an option for an episode he'll do over there. Also helping us out just a little bit here, two parters or multiple episode story arcs, we will count as one.
whether they are side by side or not. Cause there's a set of episodes in DS nine. I want to say it was season four that were two gold to cut episodes. There was like episode eight and episode 16, but we wound up smushing them together because they, they dovetailed into each other so well. And they were an exploration of the character. So if, if that's the way it works out, then we certainly, we have full capability of doing everything here. So with that, John, let's kick this off with the very beginning. I got to go back actually a little bit to season three, because as we tend to do, there's the cliffhanger scorpion, one scorpion, two.
which we're going to be watching these two because it's, you know, just a huge moment. I'm going to read the description. This comes off of, um, Oh, who should we do today? IMDB. Let's do IMDB. Uh, the, the Scorpion one is this.
Voyager finds a solution to combat species 8472. And all Janeway asks is for free passage through their territory. And Voyager is going to share their knowledge. And oh, by the way, they take on a brand new passenger slash soon to be crew member seven of nine. John, is there any way this doesn't make the list? Well, it's interesting you asked me this, Brent, because I was thinking about this very carefully. And I read the communications that you sent me very carefully. And so one of the things you had talked about was trying to narrow down the 800 hours of Star Trek to like a manageable number. And when you gave me that manageable number, I did the math. And I realized that we're talking about three.
or four episodes from the season is really the average that we would be picking. And then I thought about it more. And again, I looked at your communications very carefully. And what you said was Star Trek. Now, this brings to my mind the critical question in looking at season four of Voyager, which is this. There are episodes in this season which are absolutely critical watching for Voyager, which in the grand scheme of things.
wouldn't necessarily make a top 20 Star Trek list. Sure. So I could easily see a case where we have episodes that are like, if you want to understand Voyager, you must watch this episode. But if I was going to say, here's a list of like 120 essential Star Trek episodes, it may not make that list. Sure. And so I feel like I'm going to be getting people mad at me because there's episodes which are beloved and episodes that people think are amazing. Right. Which I would say when you apply the strict criteria, if you're only going to watch like 120 episodes of Star Trek, would this be included? Right. And even though it might be an essential episode of Voyager, even an excellent episode of Voyager, I don't know if it would make the list. So I think that understanding the whole seven of nine story.
generally speaking, is very important in all of Star Trek. And so I would say that Scorpion is absolutely necessary viewing for just understanding how the character gets to be where they are. And they end up being a huge part of not just Voyager, but also the Picard show. So you have to understand the origin story. And I think that Scorpion's enough of that origin story. And I'm phrasing that very carefully. Scorpion parts one and two is just enough of that origin story to get you where you need to go.
So I want to throw a wrinkle into this because it is. And I'll say this, if this sort of the litmus test I use is I wanted to know the story that Star Trek is trying to tell as well. You know, so sometimes you got, you kind of got to pat it a little bit with like, okay, we're going to stop here. Sometimes there's like, we had this one episode in next year. Oh, here's the other litmus test. If something important happens and I can't, there's only one test. Okay. Well, there you go. No, but like, like there's a couple of filters. Let's say I run it through. All right. One of those chemistry teachers are going to be throwing things at the screen right now. I was never good at chemistry anyway. Is if, if stuff is happening in an episode and I can't explain it in 30 seconds.
It's important. Then we just need to watch the episode like coming up. Worf and Jadzia get married. That's all that happens in that episode. Fun episode. That's it. I just explained it to you. So I haven't done that one yet, but my guess is that might wind up being a skip as much as we love that episode. But, you know, if you need to, if you need to go through that, but also like that, that relationship made no sense. And Jadzia was far too good for Worf. Sorry. Don't disagree with you at all.
I'm not even a big Jadzia fan, but that whole relationship made no sense. Yeah, yeah. Anyway, so there's certainly a couple, but I want to throw a little wrinkle at you because I want to talk about, Scorpion is definitely in parts one and two, but I want to talk about the next episode, The Gift. Basically, Kes says bye-bye. Kes's telepathic powers and latent psychokinetic powers begin to grow rapidly while Voyager's newest crew member, Seven of Nine, deals with her new individuality. As I rewatch these episodes, I realized, like, Scorpion just sort of ends with, like, Seven Trapped on Voyager. The Gift is the one where she decides, where they make the decision if she's going to stay and she's going to assimilate in. Right.
you know, cause I thought I could just be like, Hey, Cass left the show and she shot him 10,000 years into the future or 10,000 light years, 10,000 light years closer to home. Yeah. But I was like, I don't think we can do that. And the more I looked at this, the more I sat back and here's my question, is this perhaps a three-parter that we watch all together as one that it's Scorpion one, two and the gift watching all together. I think that's fair. I I've often done this myself. And if you've listened to my show, you know, I don't believe that there's a TNG episode called family. There's no such episode. It doesn't exist. It's a figment of your imagination and it's, it's wrong to call it that. And I will never acknowledge that that episode exists. There's best of both world, best of both worlds parts one, two, and three. And it's one continuous episode. And I never call it family. I think it's just wrong because it's not. And I, I believe that that's a reasonable approach to take in just the way that the episode is written in the whole structure of it, in the narrative arc of it. It's, it's a three-parter. And if you're not saying it's a three-parter, you're incorrect. And I'll, I'll touch it on that. Like have that on the Twitter.
And I think that you could make a case here for that. Do I think that it's as closely intertwined as like those TNG ones I was just talking about? No, not really. Not so much. It is, but to a lesser degree. So if under your rules for how you've set this up, if you want to call it like a three-parter, I'd be okay with it.
I think it's important to understand like cast sort of us choosing to ascend. Right. And seeing like them swapping out the characters. Plus, I mean, the amazing prosthetic work and all the stuff they did, you know, for like the intermediate seven. And she's like becoming, you know, the unfortunate, you know, silver catsuit seven from board seven. I mean, that's just amazing to watch and seeing the struggles that she goes through. Plus the cool, like ocular implants stuff and the eyeballs sitting on the, you know, on the table. I mean, it's wild stuff, man. It's, it's, it's really enjoyable and has sort of a nice mix of weirdness that I think is very much in line with a lot of Star Trek. Yeah, no, I'm with you. I think I'm going to keep these as a three-parter because I,
almost, and maybe it's, I've learned from that because we did best of both worlds. I actually paused where I normally would have had him do both together. I was like, cause he needed that. Like, you know, Riker says fire and then what's going to happen. Like, so I made him stop it. And then I let him go watch rest of both worlds too. But I think if I would have redone it, I would have just had him do best of both worlds too. And best of both worlds three together experience for the authentic fan experience. You should have had him watch best of both worlds and then watch nothing for three months and then watch best of both worlds. Yes. Yes. For the sake of the podcast, I couldn't let that happen. But I, you know, he did have about a six day reprieve. Oddly, he didn't like rush out to go watch the next episode right away. I do want to say that I mentioned earlier.
that on my show i've been talking to these newer fans you know people who discovered the show later and i just want to say without going too far into it you know people have interest they can check it out but i think that consuming the show in a binge on streaming really does change how you look at some of the episodes yeah i think that it really does and those of us who are like me people that grew up watching this stuff we were forced to let it marinate And we were also forced to watch episodes we didn't want to watch because in the days of TV syndication, there was an episode that was selected for you at six o'clock on your local channel or whatever time it was. And if you didn't want to watch that show, that episode, you didn't watch any Star Trek. So I do think there's something there that's a little different. So I just want to point that out. And I get that we're operating a different world these days, but I think that is important to point out. Very much so. All right, let's move on to the next episode. Day of Honor in this one.
Lieutenant Belana Torres and Tom Harris finally admit their feelings for each other while close to death and a race of homeless aliens ask for Voyager's help, but they're not quite satisfied with what they receive when they find out that the Borg is on board. John's got his hand over his face going, no, John, talk to us, buddy. I just had no interest in the Torres and Paris relationship. I just did not. I'm all for shipping and I'm all for rooting for characters to get together. But this particular thing, I just saw nothing there between these two. And every time that we had sort of tour to put the Taurus and Paris show with a few rare exceptions, there were a few scenes I thought that were really good. But those were the exception. And I just wanted to fast forward, to be honest. And I get there's some people out there that might have liked it, but it just was not my thing. So the more Taurus and Paris, you know, relationshiping we had in an episode, the less interested I was in it. But but but what?
I think this is the first time the Warp Core actually ejected when they wanted it to, which is amazing, right? It's amazing because we all know, like, you can write the script, right? Eject the Warp Core, and here comes Major Black, right? Warp Core ejectors offline, right? That is 100% of how it has gone in Star Trek up to this point. So how nice did the Warp Core actually get ejected? Does that make it something worth watching? No, but it is something cool. So my thing with this particular episode comes down to two questions. Like, so we have Scorpion 1-2, we have the gift, which the gift really ends with Seven becoming Seven, like who we come to know as Seven, or at least starting that journey with the hair. And, you know, she's...
got the seven look. This next episode is really that first foray into what now? what does it look like now with seven? And you know, like, like I think B'Elanna is real snippety at her in this particular episode, along with some other people and different people are feeling awkward around her and different things. And then, as you mentioned, there's also the Tom and B'Elanna stuff, which is a thing in the show. Like, so is that, you know, are those two aspects like, like is, is that enough to go, let's spend a precious spot here or will we pick up enough of the, of those two things later in other episodes that we don't really need this one? Well, you're the one who said, one of the questions is, could you explain it in 30 seconds or less? Right. Tom Paris and B'Elanna Torres start to get a thing going. That's it. Like there's nothing more to it than that.
Now, I'm not saying that's all that there is in this episode, but as far as the Torres Paris stuff, right, they, you know, sort of have they sort of have the beginnings of a relationship. Sure. And I just want to point out that the feeling that this evokes in me when I see people being snippy at seven and sort of, you know, where does she belong? I felt like that should have been a much bigger deal at the beginning of season one with the whole Maquis Federation thing. That whole thing, they blew through that in like a couple of episodes.
That is like a long-term festering thing that like should have occasional blowups and problems. Right. I mean, that is just, I felt like that was a major thing in the show that I don't know. They just kind of didn't give it its due in my feeling. But honestly, I always felt that was a very Roddenberry thing to do. Like, because Gene would remember that kid that Gene's like, yeah, this kid like just lost his parents. But in the future, we don't grieve over stuff like that because it's fine. And like the kid was supposed to be like cool with it. But then he wasn't like, I felt like that, like that was their attitude was like, Hey, this is the Federation. We get over that kind of stuff real quick. It doesn't linger and we could just move on and everybody's happy. And they revisited it occasionally throughout the course of the series. But you're right. Like you do that.
day that is the show there's the conflict and people people aren't scared to put conflict on star trek anymore uh so i'm with you on that the example that i would bring up that i think was gives us a little bit more that i think did it right um and that might be overstating perhaps a little bit but the example that i would point to is the remade battle star galactica show when the pegasus shows up and these are ships that were on the same side these were ships that were on the same side and when they show up it is not simpatico right it is not like we're all one big happy fleet and let's just all you know get together in one big happy colonial military right there's there's problems yeah and i think that that's how this would have been because these people were literally shooting at each other well you know that i mean to that point like so ronald d moore big star trek guy is the guy who did the new battle star galactica and i remember and i remember watching that live on tv when it was coming out and i remember seeing like interviews and stuff with him talking about yeah when we were on trek we weren't allowed to do this so there's a feeling to me of like this is the stuff he wanted to do when he was on star trek but he wasn't allowed and so now he was allowed to go do it and that's where a lot of that came from you know the story it might be apocryphal but you know the story about the photon torpedoes in voyager where they set off like 73 of them but they only had 37 well that's basically is it is that when ron moore was working on early voyager like in the writer's room he's like all right we gotta keep track of the shuttlecraft the photon torpedoes and you know we gotta keep track of like you know the food rations and you know all this kind of stuff and the show was like yeah we're not doing any of that like just stop it like we're not doing any of that he's like but this is the premise of the show like this this is not like like you know fangasming you know this is the whole point is that they're out there without resources right we have to keep track of this and it was it was a thing and i think that you can actually draw a through line from his experience on voyager to some of that stuff that he did later yeah oh i took that stuff very seriously i hold
Wholeheartedly agree. Wholeheartedly. I can say that, by the way, big fan of Battlestar Galactica, the redo. I tried watching the original and was glad it was a season. Anyway, so say we all say there you go. It's one of the best. What do you call those memes? Gifts? One of the best gifts with that one. All right, let's move on our next episode. Oh, wait, we didn't decide we're going to that. I tell you what, let's drop this in at least extra viewing because there is stuff that happens. It is there. Is it really necessary? Maybe not, but we'll at least put an extra viewing and let Matt decide if he wants to watch it. OK, the next episode, Nemesis shot down by Crossfire. Chakotay bonds with one faction in the midst of a war. So.
There's a good Star Trek message about why is it that we hate the other? Where does all this come from? Learning to overcome that. So there's a little bit of a Star Trek message in there. But then again, there's also aliens that look like they were taken from the Predator films. So, you know, that kind of put me off a little bit.
It's okay. It's an okay episode. I like it. Would it, would it make like my hundred episodes of like must watch Star Trek? Not for me. Yeah. I have this one down as just a skip all the way around. Yeah. I think the way they talk is a little bit neat, you know, the speech patterns they have, but outside of that, it's, it's just an episode, you know, I think it's an episode. It feels like one of those that Star Trek has tackled a few times, like as far as the message goes. So, so we'll, we'll put that down there and we'll move right along. Revulsion is our next episode.
the wonderful uh de jaron am i saying his name right it's been a while since i watched it uh so the engineering hologram right yeah who kills his crew right we were just talking about battle star galactica does he not remind you of a cattle like isn't that the same speech that a cattle gives yeah i don't want to be a biological life form right i want to be i don't want to chew things and look at you know things through my eye orbs i want to be in space. I want to see x-rays, right? That that's exactly the same speech that we get here. It's a, it's, it's really sort of a thing that I don't want to call it a trope. Cause I don't know if it really is, but it is something we see from time to time where you have these sort of other kinds of beings that are not biological and, and they really want to embrace what they are, whether it's an energy being or a hologram or a robot, you know, or whatever. So there's a lot there that I like. And I think it also is a nice contrast to the doctor. So it gives you a nice, a nice character frame to play off of, but I got to tell you the name of the episode is revulsion. That's also how I felt in my stomach watching like the Harry and seven scene in this one. Oh yeah. Oh yeah.
you gotta, you gotta just, you know, I really, yeah, yeah. There's, I mean, there, I mean, there's so much of like high school Brent in that that's just makes me cringe when I'm like, Oh my God, I'd like, I know where he's going with all that. And I, I just, you know, they, I thought they captured it, but it made me sick watching. You know, this is an interesting episode because we're really diving into this storyline that Voyager is going to explore particularly later on in the latter seasons of photonic life. This is picking up that data storyline of, of what is life? Can artificial life be life? And now we're seeing this, this really become, it's sort of sets that off, right?
Like with the doctor figuring out like, hey, there is other life forms out here and maybe he really is a life. You know, we already had that a couple of times through season three a little bit. Maybe there is something that that informs him. So is this enough? Is there a message here or is there is there something about this that you think makes this a watch or is this skip? Maybe toss a text reviewing. What do you think? This is one of the episodes where I would say that I talked about at the beginning of our recording here, which is that if you're saying like this is essential Voyager, I would put it on the list because it really is a case where the doctor is really understanding sort of what he is in comparison to this other character. And it's a good it's a good learning opportunity for him.
Is it in that like, here's the list of 150 Star Trek episodes that everyone should watch to understand the show? No, for me. It's not to say it's a bad episode. I think it's a good episode. In fact, I think the guest star Leland Orser, if I remember right now, I'm doing that off the top of my head. I don't have the notes. You're right. That is who that is. He's amazingly good in it. And the episode has much to commend it. But if you're going to cut it down to a hundred and something episodes of Star Trek and say, this is what you have to watch. I don't think it makes that list, but I would watch it because I like this episode. So that to me says extra viewing, which is exactly where I had this particular episode when I kind of did my, my little breakdown of the, of the season. I'm going to keep it an extra viewing. I think that's a good, that feels like a good spot for this. Good stuff.
Maybe not in the whole overview of everything, because even with that stuff that we get, we're going to get more of that later. Like, we don't need this one to prep that one. So, but still a good one. All right, let's talk about the next one. The Raven. PTSD strikes seven of nine, causing frightening visions and prompting her under a panic attack to seek the Borg Collective where no Borg exists. We got some Leonardo da Vinci in here. Love John Rhys-Davies. Not a big fan of the Leonardo hologram program. Not a big fan of that. But if he was Gimli, it'd be awesome. It'd be totally awesome. You know, and my ex, if he just said that to Janeway, I think I would fall out of my chair.
Having said that, though, we get a whole nother episode later on that goes very deep into the Annika story. And we learn like how unfortunate it was that her parents, even though they were scientists, were dumb as a box of rocks and were, in fact, idiots. So we and I'm very strong of that opinion that her parents were dopes. So we get that later on. And so I don't feel like we really have to revisit like the childhood shuttles, like the shuttle in the story because we get all that later. Yeah. And you get a deeper dive into it. So you don't need it here. You really don't. Yeah. 100 percent. That's because I went into this. This is one of those that I was like, oh, this is definitely make.
in the watch list. It absolutely is. And then I did my rewatch and I went, actually, I don't think so. You know? So once again, I'm going to kick this one to extra viewing. I don't know that it's a skip all the way around. Like you can mention it. Matt loves his origin stories. This is not the origin story though. Yeah. Later. Yeah. More detail. And we're going to get that way. Don't need it. I'm near positive. That's going to be on the watch list. That one later, which the name of that particular episode is, Oh, it's no, it's a two-parter.
Is it, is it Dark Frontier? Yes, that's it. Thank you. Thank you. Yes, that's it. I can't remember that. You nailed it, but it's a two-parter Dark Frontier. Yes, absolutely. It is that one. And her parents were so stupid that being assimilated was probably like a better option because her parents were terrible. Well, when her dad turned up as one of the Borg there in the matrix chamber or whatever. That was cool. That was amazing. That's something you don't want to steal that from somebody. You want them to experience that in the show. But just, just the whole concept of, you know, these scientists taking their kid on this mission to explore this like homicidal, you know, destructive enemy. It's like, no, don't do that. You know, D-Day was not a, you know, take your kid to work day, right? This was just, it was a bad decision. Bad, bad, bad.
Right. All right. Well, let's move on. We'll put that one in our extra viewing list. The next episode, scientific method, a string of bizarre illnesses, a flicks Voyager, the doctor in seven to nine and cover a team of alien researchers existing out of phase performing medical experiments on the ship's crew. Yeah. If you watch the episode of TNG, I don't know if it made your list, but the one in TNG where the aliens are sort of pulling the arms off of Riker and attaching them and all that, like we've already seen this episode.
They had the table. They had to like recreate the table in the hollow. Yep. Yep. Yep. Yep. You know, um, more Torres and Paris stuff, which is a snooze fest for me. Uh, totally not interested in that. Uh, but I will say the Chakotay bit where he's drinking the coffee and we get the scan. Like that's cool. Like that's, you know, Hey, look at this cool stuff. I can do now with computers, you know, so there's some like nice effects bits. Um, but we've kind of done this episode in the past. Yeah. So I, I just thought, yeah, you know, if you're going to put together a list again, I'm going to say this a couple of times, you're going to say, these are like 120, 125 episodes of Star Trek. You must watch. You got a better one in TNG. Yeah. And honestly, we skipped that one there too. So we're going to skip this one too. I like that episode a lot
and TNG did it better. Um, but you know, there's some, there's some neat things where you kind of see them like walk around with the head pieces on them and you know, in the outfit, but whatever it is, I'm going to leave this on the skip side, unless you really want to, you know, pump it up for the extra viewing. Uh, he can just catch it on the rewatch whenever he knows. Cause I keep telling him he'll eventually go back and binge the entirety of each series. But, uh, you know, this is not that particular run through. All right. Next episode year of hell. We'll combine these as one part one and two Voyager comes across the current time ship. That's wiping a whole species from existence to change the existing timeline. And a year after Voyager encounters the current time ship, a badly damaged Voyager with a skeleton crew leads an armada of interplanetary ships against them to
Reset the whole thing so it never happened in the first place. Okay, so this is the episode that was on my mind when I was talking early in the recording about episodes of the critical for Voyager, episodes of the critical for Star Trek. Because at the end of Year of Hell, it's a reset. There's nothing in this episode that actually lasts, right? You don't need to know anything here to understand the rest of Voyager. And if you were to play like a little game and actually show somebody Voyager and not show them this two-parter, the story would make complete and total sense. Everything flows logically. There's no reason to, there's nothing in this episode that you need. Having said that, it's a critical character study of Janeway and it has some very interesting Star Trek in it.
this whole idea of, you know, what if you had this power and here's, here's a bad guy, Anorax, who just wants to be with his family. I mean, can you hate the guy for that? Well, I mean, that was, that was Malcolm McDowell's character from generations. From generations. Yeah. Same, same motivations anyway. That's right. That's right. So, you know, it's not like it's some mustache twirling, you know, guy who just wants to blow stuff up. Right. So is this essential Voyager? Absolutely. Yeah. Is it an amazingly great performance with wonderful effects? Absolutely. Is it necessary to understand anything else in the show? No. So I really struggled with this one. Right. And it's not.
I just want to be very clear. I am not criticizing the episode. It's a fantastic episode in every way that the whole two-parter. It's great. People should watch it. But given the criteria that you told me about, I'm not sure you have to watch it. I'm not sure you have to watch it. You should watch it. Is there something about it like this is important enough in the fandom to watch? And I'll give you an example. When we were doing TOS, we stopped to watch Arena, the Gorn episode. It's a one-off episode. It doesn't affect anything else coming up. They're all one-offs. Yeah, the entire TOS thing is all one-offs. But the Gorn is such a huge part of the fandom that people are going to talk about it. You're going to see the cosplay.
It's going to be in the commercials. It's going to be the toy action figures because it's the Gorn, which existed in one. Is this like Year of Hell? Because this is a marquee episode for Voyager, right? I mean, like I think as a fandom, we all tend to agree on that. Like, is this enough of maybe even just a marquee episode that Matt's going to go to a convention one day and he's likely to hear about this episode and maybe we should have watched it? What do you think?
Okay. Well, I'm glad you brought this up because I feel that there are things that exist in the fandom, which we make a bigger deal out of than people who come to the show later experience. And I'll give you two examples, which is because I bring this up specifically because I've had these new fans on my show who have not necessarily had access to the fandom. And sometimes I hit them with these questions and they're like, Oh, that that's a thing. Right. And I'll give you two examples. One is the Tuvix discourse. Okay. You want to get a group of Star Trek fans into a fisticuffs walk in and be like Tuvix, right or wrong. Right. And there were people who would be like, you know, about 40% of the room would be like one side.
40% of the room would be on the other side and the remaining 20% would be like, why are we even still talking about this? But everybody has a feeling like everybody is in a camp. Here's another one, Jellicoe, hero or zero, right? Captain Jellicoe, he did the right thing and Riker's a giant baby. That's a point of view that exists in the fandom, right? From TNG. There's something to be like, nope, he's not Picard, therefore he sucks, right? Or he wasn't respectful to the crew's opinions, right? There's a point of view to be had there. I'm making a joke, but there is a point of view there. It's a minor character who's in a couple of episodes, man. But like, if you walk into a room full of Trekkies and you'd be like, hey, who loves Jellicoe? Like half the room is going to be like.
shut up. And the other half is going to be like, he was awesome. And he's a guy who's in like an episode, you know, two episodes, you know, it didn't have actually all that much time in those two episodes, but it's a much bigger thing than people make it out to be. So when people say, well, this is necessary for the fandom, I'm skeptical. I'm just, I'm skeptical if that's a good enough reason. Sure. I understand. Again, not to say it's a bad episode. It's an amazing episode. You're of hell and people should watch it. It's great, but I'm mindful of the criteria you gave me. Sure. I had this in watch, but I,
I have to be honest. I'm, I'm with you and mostly a lot of it just because of the reset button that he gets. So I'm going to move this down to extra viewing as I'm doing so much. I found this, but I thought this, this season, I think this is a banger of a season. I really do. There's so many good episodes. You gave me the toughest season because we get the intro of the Hirogen who were a big part of Voyager. We get like the whole, like this is actually the season where Voyager really becomes a family. It does. I think in a lot of ways we get the first letters from Starfleet, you know, they get their communication from home. Kess goes away, seven arrives. There's a whole lot more doctor slash seven show that happens, which is a big part, I think, of the letter.
part of Voyager. I mean, there's a lot in this season. So I had to be tough given the criteria. And I just want to, I'm going to say it again. I don't want to make it seem like I'm dismissing some of these episodes. I'm not, they're amazing. But given the criteria that you gave me, I don't know if it hits that. First of all, let me just unequivocally say, I appreciate your thoroughness in that because this is the struggle that I've been going through for eight seasons of Star Trek. Now, however many, no, it's been more than eight, 11 seasons of Star Trek. Now I think I'm trying to decide which episodes are in and which ones aren't and how does, how does that line up? But I am going to move this down here to extra viewing because it's so good. You talk about, I'm sorry, for the record, I just want to make everything clear.
Jellicoe was right. Riker is a big old baby and Janeway committed murder. That being said, it's interesting. You talk about the idea of like new people because with Matt, um, I've gone into these episodes that are marquee episodes in the fandom that we just, we love, we admire, respect. I'm talking city on the edge of forever duet, uh, the visitor. Um,
I can't think of another one. Like these kind of like heavy, just emotional type episodes. And Matt's like, it was an episode. And like, I've been sitting here going, are these episodes that like, did I have this response when I watched them first? Or did I have this response having watched them multiple times and marinated it and, you know, having discussed it with, with other Star Trek fans, or was this really my first response? And I've had to struggle with that sometimes of going, wow, that's it. Maybe even, and Matt's liked a lot of episodes that I'm like.
You know, OK, well, we can talk about this for a second. One of the things I've talked about on my show from time to time, I think I've talked about this in a while, but there's this idea that I got from Timothy Leary, you know, the great 60s sort of nutcase and sort of public bon vivant. And so you're a sports fan, right? Is watching your favorite team at home by yourself in the living room the same thing as being in the stadium? Why or why not? It's because the people around you and the experience that it creates. And I think that Star Trek or any show, it's the same thing. We've been sitting with these episodes around people who've been telling us this is a good episode and here's why. And then we get our views changed because we're like, you know what? You're right. Look at that performance. Look at these effects. Look at the meaning of this that I didn't capture the first time around. And so we have a different experience than the people who are coldly going into this, who are seeing episodes for the very first time without having access to any of that other stuff. And they're experiencing something that is very different. I mean, just a personal example. I don't know anything about boxing. I had tickets to a marquee boxing event and I invited a friend of mine.
who actually knows about boxing. And he was able to explain to me things that I could not appreciate. And if I had just gone to that and seen it, I'd be like, well, they're fighting. Like he's hitting that guy, that guy's hitting him and they're hitting each other. Like what's happening at the fight there. There's fisticuffs. Yeah. You know, I had that same experience with WrestleMania this past year because I went, I'm not a big wrestling fan, but I went with a guy who is a pro wrestler himself. Okay. And he's in that world. And he was able to like, tell me all the stuff that's happening. And I just, I gained a new appreciation for it. Not necessarily, I think as a fan, but as much as like.
just in what they're actually doing to put this on, you know? Right on, right on. So that's what I think about when I watch these episodes, you know, is like, I'm skeptical. It's not to say I'm trying to bright line this stuff and say, you know, here's my opinion and it's right or wrong, but I'm just very skeptical of, you know, I sort of question myself when someone says, this is required viewing. I think, is it really? Are you sure? Yeah. Are you really sure? Right. You know, it's like when people talk about, you know, In the Pale Moonlight from Deep Space Nine, you know, when you see the multitudinous ways throughout the rest of the show that the decisions in that episode made, oh wait, I'm sorry, there aren't any because there aren't.
Right. They're the consequence of the production of the show is amazing. But then the decisions that are made and the corners that are cut, there's no payoff for any of that or calling to account for that later on in the series. They're just not. It's like they forgot about it, you know. And so that, to me, changes how I watch the episode, which as a production, it's amazing. Right. And you should watch it and love it. But they're telling a serialized story. But here's this amazing part of the serialized story that has no consequence. Right.
Like you'd want to see the person get caught or you'd want to see the thing happen. You know, I mean, I was gonna say, and that's been, that's been a bit of the show, like walking through with Matt, because there's this constant comparison to how television is done today, because we would explore that in television today. But, you know, I always say, I often say Star Trek is a product of its time. The original series was sixties television. This Berman era stuff was nineties television. What we're getting now with the whole Kurtzman era stuff is 2020s, 20 aughts television. Like it's, they're, they're each a product of their time telling that story. And I think you have to appreciate them in that way and trying to hold nineties television to the way we do it today. Like it's an, it's always been an interesting.
discussion of where we go. Cause like, there's so much we could have done there that we didn't. And honestly, I think some of that's why we have television today, the way we do, because people are like, Oh, we missed an opportunity there. I really wanted to go there, but they wouldn't let me. And now they do, you know? Um, so.
This is something I often bring up when I'm talking to the Niners out there, which is like, oh, it's incredibly serialized. I'm like, is it though? Is it? I'm not saying it's a bad show. I'm not criticizing Deep Space Nine. I enjoyed it. I liked it. I have talked to so many fans who said, yeah, what was the first Star Trek you watched? I started watching Deep Space Nine in season seven and it caught me on a Star Trek. Okay. You know, there are people out there like, you cannot do that. You know, bad, bad fan, bad. You must go back and watch, you know, from the beginning and understand like the development of Garrick and, you know, the cringy Bashir into like the, you know, cool Bashir. Like, no, that is not the show that they were making. It was not a case where you had to watch it serially and it is far less serialized.
people think it is. I know we're totally off the rails here. I apologize for that. Let's reel it back in. No, you're absolutely right, because I've previewed my season six and seven of Deep Space Nine, and I am shocked at how few episodes are, at least that I have initially said that I think should be in. Season five of Deep Space Nine was very bloated, but there's a lot that sets it up. But once that's set up, it really just sort of rushes to the end if you take out all the unnecessary episodes. Speaking of unnecessary episodes, let's talk about random thoughts. I tell them about the race. Arrest Valana for thinking bad thoughts, and it begins to infect their environment and their virtually crime-free society. Can you really hurt somebody? Can you really arrest them?
somebody for their thought in today's world of social media, where we send you like, if you think something wrong, we're going to hurt you for it. What do you think? Is this a necessary episode or one with a message that we have to stop at? This episode was quite prescient. I mean, this is our modern social media moment. It is a typo in this tweet, which therefore means that you believe these 17 things, which therefore means that you believe these other things, because everything you type, I will believe literally, whereas everything I type is meant to have subtext. So therefore, you know, I know everything about you because of these seven words you typed on Twitter. Right. And I've now judged your life. Yeah. This is our modern world. And so I think there's a really good message in this episode. And also.
I just want to say that this idea is very common in sci-fi. I mean, if you look at, you know, movies like total recall or the story, the total recall comes from. If you look at the Tech War books by Shatner, there's this whole idea of people playing back memories from others as kind of an entertainment. Also, the Talosians, right? I mean, you can't get more OG Star Trek than the Talosians, right? This whole idea of people just experiencing others' memories, right? It's a very, very powerful idea. Yeah, Stargate does it. Stargate does it in an episode with Dwight Schultz, Reg Barclay. Oh, fantastic. Same thing, yeah. So I like some of the content in the episode. I like sort of these intellectual kind of challenges in Star Trek, you know, and these things to think about and ponder on. So that's something I watch Star Trek for and I really like.
also Gwyneth Walsh, Bator, not playing someone under makeup. How wonderful for her, which is great. I don't think I knew she was in this episode. Yeah, yeah, yeah. So she's in this one. Does it make the criteria as like, this is one of the things you gotta watch? No. Right. Well, so let me, is there enough of a, that Star Trek-ian message that we need? Because there's one of the things I'm struggling with at this point in watching Star Trek. Like we've seen so much of Star Trek, like we get the idea of what Star Trek is and the messages and the commentary on society that Star Trek is providing. Like we've kind of hit a hit.
a lot of everything, you know, so far, like, is there still more left to dive into that? We're not just going to recycle from previous seasons and episodes or like, like, you know, I don't know that this was an idea back in their day. I think it does relate honestly to the social media of today, which means my Star Trek survives all these years. Well, if you listen to my show, you know that every now and then. random greek philosophy makes an appearance all righty and when you read greek philosophy from the ancients one of the and you read carefully one of the things that comes to mind is that people were arguing about the same stuff we're arguing about today 2 600 years ago yes same stuff the exact same stuff you know these kids today you know they're taking in strange ideas with their music you know whatever whatever i mean it is the exact same stuff so it's timeless i mean people arguing about these things it's timeless it's only our own hubris that makes us say well it's different now and so i have a high bar for this time it's different like that argument has a very, very, very big bar for me. So because if you read history, it sort of inoculates you against that. Sure. So that's my feeling on that. As a two thoughts on that real quick, just to jump off as a history teacher, particularly of American history. It floors me when we're like, oh, this nation has never been more divided than it is now. I'm like, no, no, no. This nation has been this divided since its founding. It really, I mean, when it's the same arguments, we're still having the same arguments those guys did back then. Oh, civility is shot. Really? Is it as bad as when Preston Brooks caned Charles Sumter in the well of the Senate and gave him life threatening injuries? You know, it's in the Senate of in the well of the Senate of the United States.
an actual beatdown, a physical brawl occur? I mean, are you sure? You know, like when they're just like, you know, wagging their finger at each other? I don't know. And then now as a Gen Xer who is now 40, 41, I remember the stuff people said about my generation when I was a kid. Our world's going to hell and you Gen Xers, you know, you're going to bring about the end of civilization. And now I know what my generation is saying about the millennials and whatever is my kids are post-millennial, like whatever that is. And I keep waiting for the millennials to get old and start saying the stuff about the generation after that. It's just interesting to see how that continues to perpetuate. So I had this in the skip category.
I think I'm inclined to keep it in skip and just let him catch it on the rewatch because in the extra viewing, I'm really going to press him towards your, he needs to watch it. I really want him to watch it, but I'm going to leave that there. Let's move on concerning flight after aliens raid Voyager. Janeway discovers her Da Vinci holodeck character is living independently as a trading post under the patronage of a shameless Prince of thieves. John, I don't even remember this episode and I know that I just watched it here in the last bunch of weeks. I still don't remember this episode. Talk to me about it. Let's move on. Fair enough. Cause yikes. Yikes. This is what I want to talk about though, because I'll ask you the question right ahead.
I don't know that we've ever dealt with this in Star Trek. This is one of those things I don't think Star Trek has dealt with so far. Mortal Coil, thanks to Seven of Nine, Neelix returns from the dead, but his lack of a glimpse of the afterlife brings about a severe crisis of faith. Yes. So, okay.
Now it's time for the talk about Gene's vision and the idea that religion doesn't exist in the future. And there's a very strong sense. And I think this comes, this is really part of Gene's vision. And I don't mean that in a snarky sense, right? But this was, I think, really part of his setting up of like the Trek universe in the earliest days, which is that it was a very much more of a scientific, technocratic sort of society in the Federation, sort of a dystopian hellhole in kind of ways that, and I realized that people just like, what are you talking about? It's utopia. I can debate. I think that's debatable. It's not a dynamic society with a lot of creativity and energy. It seems sort of static and boring.
in a lot of ways to me, how many times we see sort of Federation society. But in his point of view, it would be, you know, religion is something that is, you know, stone knives and bear skits. And this episode is right in line with that. And I think that it is very much part of the Star Trek mythos in that way. It's just an example of many, but consistent with a lot of Star Trek where they say religion doesn't exist, but then they use religion or make comments about how, but then they go back on it. Right. Like, you know, in TOS, right. Many gods, we find the one just sufficient. What? I thought we didn't have religion. Right. Like they say, like, did we find the one? What are you talking about? Right. Or, Oh, at the Christmas party, the what you have a Christmas party on the enterprise. Are you sure? Right. And so they do this kind of stuff in Star Trek all the time, which is.
why Star Trek canon is kind of a hopeless concept to begin with. But I think that this draws directly from that because at the end of the episode, we go back to the great forest. And I feel like it's just sort of in that line with a lot of other Star Trek where like they make a strong case to say, this is what we're saying the future is like. And then they sort of hedge their bets at the last second. Very weird. Very weird. I don't know how I feel about it. Yeah.
It could be because, and even Janeway, it doesn't Janeway at the end of this episode be like, who knows, maybe there's something out there. I don't know. Like she, she approaches it with the agnostic view of it. Right. Take a stand. Yeah. But it's, you know, it's one of these like, I know that Matt's a person of faith. I personally believe in some sort of life after death. And I don't know. We'll see. I don't know. I will figure it out. But.
The idea that Neelix is, is really confronted with, is there nothing really out there or is there? And, and how does that affect his life? Cause he goes through like, like he gets to a spot where he says life's, if that's not true, then life's not worth living becomes, I think his question here, you know, and he has to find a new purpose almost. And that's, that's really where I find this like such an intriguing idea, especially among today's, uh, among today, you know, um, great episode. Um, I would say that if that's the thing you're interested in, I think that it's phrased and written much more powerfully in Star Trek, the motion picture video is asking questions, Jim, is this all I am? Is there nothing more?
Fair. Right. I think, I think that whole thing you're just talking about is phrased much more elegantly, beautifully and powerfully with a character that I think is much more core to Star Trek. And that's not a slam against me. Like I'm a Neelix fan and supporter generally speaking, but to hear Spock talk about it in the motion picture, if you're going to, again, this is the task you set in front of me was to say, let's pick 120, 150 hours of Star Trek for someone to watch. If you want that message, I think TMP does it better. Fair enough. Fair enough. I've, I've often said, I, you know, when I first started with Voyager, I've heard people say, you know, you really, you could watch the first episode. You could watch the last episode and skip the whole rest of the series to find out.
No, wrong. Voyager's awesome. Voyager's awesome. That's what I said. I was like, no, we actually got to watch it and see what's in there. But I do, I do find this sort of weird bell curve with where we're going. I'm going to place this one in extra viewing. We'll let Matt see, see where he goes with that. And we will continue on to.
Ooh, this is an interesting set of episodes I want to talk to you about. All right. I want to specifically talk about the next. Let's talk about these three episodes together. Message in a Bottle, which is using an alien communications that Voyager is able to send their doctor to a Federation ship, the Prometheus, only to find out that it's been taken over by Romulans. And in Hunters, Voyager begins to receive news, both good and bad. And they also finally encounter this Hirogen race, which was actually sort of introduced back in Message in a Bottle, who only live to hunt and have their sights set on Voyager and then pray. We're not going to help one of these wounded Hirogen. And Janeway finds that the prey has voided Voyager.
And hold on. Did you skip waking moments? Did we? I did. I did. Because we should skip waking moments. Fair enough. Enough. Enough said about it. Naked Tuvok and Kissy Kissy Seven are very amusing and funny. Right. Yeah. Yeah. We'll skip that one. But there's these three episodes. Now, in my mind, hunters and prey have always gone together as sort of a part one, part two. But I started watching this back and looking at it. And actually, if there's a part one, part two, I think it's message in a bottle right into hunters. And then prey is just sort of this extra. We're just also talking about about the Hirogen in this very next episode.
what do we think about these three episodes together individually as one pair or another pair? What do we think? So I guess the question would be, do you want to tell the story of Voyager or do you want to learn about Star Trek? And this, this is something that's been a consistent theme for me thus far in the podcast, right? Which is, you know, if you want to learn about Voyager, you've got to watch these three episodes. I think they're absolutely critical. I think to understanding the story of Voyager, do they have to be episodes that you have to watch to understand Star Trek?
I think it's debatable. Right. Now I will say message in a bottle did not throw me only because I just did not find Andy Dick entertaining or interesting at all. Right. I get to that one. And I just wanted to fast forward like every moment he was on the screen. That's my own personal thing that he has his fans out there. I don't have any animus for the guy. I just didn't find the character interesting. I don't find the actor's performance particularly good in the show for me. It didn't land for me. So I was just not interested in him at all. USS Prometheus. Love that. You know, who doesn't love multi-vector attack mode? Right. I mean, if you just walk into a group of Star Trek fans, you go multi-vector attack mode. Like they'll be like, who are we attacking? You know, like.
Let's go. Right. Which is great. So this for me falls in the episodes where it's like critical for Voyager for Star Trek. Yeah, not so much. What if we were to watch these? Is it would it be message in a bottle and then hunters and pray? Would it be all three of them together message in a bottle and hunters and then pray separately?
I think hunters and prey go together. Yeah. In my opinion, more because we have the Starfleet letters and we have this incredibly, like, this is what I wanted more of in the show. And I talked about this earlier, which is that, which is we have Chakotay and Torres talking about all the Maquis are dead back home that we knew. Right. You know, I think that's like a really wonderful scene. And I wanted more of that.
I think we've got in Prey, we've got a wonderful Star Trek message about teaching Seven of Nine about compassion. You know, that's that's one of the most Star Trek things ever. I love the Doctor in Seven show. I know a lot of people don't like that, but I love the Doctor in Seven show where he's doing like a little bedside manner bit with her and teach all that. And I also the fact that she gets grounded at the end of the episode in a way. Right. You know, it happens like, you know, you cannot access any of the following systems, you know, or whatever it was. You know, I remember she cuts off her access to some stuff or threatens to. And I love that because that's.
things from previous episodes being brought in. Right. And it's part of that continuity. And I really like that. So I would put hunters and prey closer together and say, those are more of a sequence than message in a bottle, but I I'm open to influence on it and could be persuaded. Otherwise. Yeah. I think with message in a bottle.
This one and Hunter's both. But these two play into the because you keep saying, like, are we talking about the story of Voyager? And we are like, I think the story of Voyager is a part of the story of Star Trek. And so there's a bit of, hey, they're lost. How are we getting them home? And, you know, what are the key things that are happening along the way? The key explorations? I think a lot of that's really going to fall in the lap of the Doctor in seven, particularly in the last half of this show. But the idea that we're now getting these communicators back from Earth, like that's a big, significant moment that we've reached the threshold of being able to have any kind of communication back with Earth or with the Alpha Quadrant for.
Voyager. So these have to be in there, I think somewhere for just telling that story versus where I look at like a mortal coil, a year of hell, like year of hell would be great if there was any consequence to it whatsoever. Like love it. There's the reset button. You're like.
Your point, you could skip this episode and never know it was there and your life wouldn't be any worse. It would just be better if you did watch it. Yeah, you're missing a great performance, a great set of effects, a really powerful story. It doesn't have any influence on the contours of the show written. Right. And you're right. The Raven, the Raven is everything that you need. And the Raven is actually covered much better in Dark Frontier. Revulsion is actually fantastic. But again, we get more of the photonic life later. You know, in Day of Honor, we can explain real quickly. I don't know, John, I'm still I'm still struggling with these three and like in how to like I know message in a bottle has to be there and I'm sure Hunter's has to be there.
I like prey. I just don't know if they all go together as one. Do I separate them? Are you keeping a stack rank of these episodes as you're going through them? What does that mean? Meaning like you are actually putting together the list of like, these are the 125 episodes you must watch. And if you, if you hit 125 to add one in, one has to come out. No, no, that is not. No, it's we'll watch however many episodes we need to watch, whether it's 157, 172, 183. The idea is that's just about the number that I think we're going to get. All right. All right. All right. Then I would say include hunters and prey. I would say include hunters and prey in that list. I was taking it much more literally than like we are looking at like the hundred and.
25, 150 episodes that like, this is it. And if we're going to include one, one has to come out. Yeah. The Highlander approach, there can only be one. Yeah. Yeah. The original, the original thought for this whole podcast was a hundred. Devolved the whole thing down to a hundred episodes. You can do what you can do, but you know, it's, it's one thing to go through these episodes and be like, Oh, that's an incredible episode. You have to watch it. I mean, I had on my episode, excuse me, I had on my show, Jim Warhouse, Enterprise Extra on Twitter. And I asked him, how did you come up with this whole idea of Trek ranks? It's because every time he would talk to another Star Trek fan, he'd be like, that's top 10 episode. He's like, dude, you said that about 35 episodes. Right. So he literally had to go and rank them.
And if you rank this one, number two, that other episode is not number two anymore. Right. Right. And when you go through that exercise, I mean, now for me, I'm not much of a ranks person. I don't know if I could really do that process, but, but if you're going to say like, here's 150 episodes of Star Trek to understand if you include one, one has to go out. What would be that list of 150? That's a much tougher question than what you're doing here. And I'm not saying you should do that, but that was sort of my point of view as I was going through. Yeah. Yeah. No, let's the, the, the dangerous part of that of saying, listen, if it's an episode we need to watch, we'll just watch the episode and we'll call it good. The dangerous part is you can balloon really fast and you've got to trying to prevent that from happening. So, um,
Again, this season was one. I love the season. But even as we're discussing here and as I went through, I went, wow, there's so much. There's a lot of good stuff in season four. Sure. A lot. But not much that is like you absolutely have to kind of a thing. All right. So I'm going to leave all three of these in. I think I want to keep message in a bottle and hunters together. And then I want to do pray separately. That's that's my gut reaction right now, because I think there's a part one, part two where they're using that network and they roll hunters and pray. I just remember watching it thinking these two episodes are really much more.
disconnected than I originally thought they were. So I'm going to go back and rewatch these and see maybe because I always maintain the caveat. I could change these at any time. But yeah. All right. So let's move on from those to an episode called Retrospect. Seven of nine claims to have been assaulted by the arms trader who just sold new technology to Voyager. It's a dumpster fire. Skip it. Fantastic. Let's talk about let's talk about the killing game because this is what I really had to get to. I love this episode. Killing game. The Hirogen take over Voyager and turn the holodex into a massive World War Two ish type gaming scenario where they keep killing them and bring them back to life.
And it's an interesting discussion because ultimately this is where they come up with the idea of giving the Hirogen the holodeck technology because their main guy's concern is we're hunting ourselves to extinction. We're going to run out of people or things to hunt. And this idea of helping those who would harm you and what is the necessity of growth and change and not staying in your dogmatic way of doing things as they've always been, you know. But I'll ask you, John, is this essential? Well.
How can one not love Janeway the Klingon? That's in this one. And if memory serves, we also get Jerry Ryan singing. We do. Which is glorious. Yes. So if you don't love Janeway the Klingon and Jerry Ryan singing, I don't think we could be friends. So I think the episode is majestic and wonderful just on the basis of those two things. But having said that, the Hirogen, I don't know, they compared to species 8, 6, 7, 5, 3, 0, 9. They just weren't as as like scary as those guys. Right. And so the Hirogen really just.
They just didn't do it for me. I thought the Vidians were far more terrifying in a lot of ways. Yeah. Especially given COVID and discovering that the human race, we're the Vidians really in Star Trek. That's the race that we are, is the Vidians. I'm very convinced of that. So when I look at this episode, the Hirogen really don't light me up all that much. Right. But there's a lot that's in this episode that's just wonderful. So as a production and as an episode, I love it.
Is it necessary for understanding everything about Voyager? Nope. Because the Hirogen just sort of don't amount to much in the grand scheme of things of Voyager at the end of the day. So they're not really that critical. So would someone need to watch this to understand Voyager? No, not really. But they'd be missing out on some really great Star Trek and some really great, just a really great episode. So I'm conflicted about this one. You know, this is one for me that they could have ended the Hirogen storyline after this episode, and I would have been perfectly happy. They come back to the Hirogen a couple more times after this, but not many. You know what I mean? Like, here's the Hirogen. We introduce them. They're a big threat. And then they have a problem.
And Janeway effectively solves it for them. Right. Except we know that later on it kind of stops thrilling them. So there's, there's a bit of me where this is kind of like, you know, like we followed the Vedians all the way through in the early episodes. They were only like four or five episodes. They really weren't in that many episodes. But they have their very own Star Trek plate, which if any curious listeners are out there, you should go Google Star Trek plate Vedians. It's terrifying and bizarre and amazing. Go check it out. Like it's one of these things where you're like, I can't believe somebody made that. Oh my. Right. Oh my.
you're going to eat food off of that. What? No, you don't eat off those plates. They're there for decorative. They're for, they're for decoration. If you can imagine. No, but still it's horrifying. It's horrifying. Oh, it's a void plate. It's a void plate. Oh man. Um, yeah. Ah, you know, I really, I, I want to, I want to keep this in, in the view. Cause I do, I do think that there's enough in here to really dive into and, and, and enough meaty conversation, uh, which, which again really comes out. I mean, cause these erosion are, are, um, I mean, the way they're basically killing these guys and then bring them right back to life, uh, is, is just horrible, absolutely horrible and atrocious. And, you know,
the way that they've been treating the crew of Voyager, the crew of Voyager could have, I think rightly just obliterated these guys and moved on, but they didn't. And there's this real pathos to the Hirogen, I think, especially with the commander who is played by, I forget who, but it's somebody just amazing. Yeah, I don't remember. Coming up with the solution here. So, you know, it almost is like, this is like the core of the season a little bit, which is very weird getting in here. And I didn't pick this to be a core of a season. I just think it's kind of shaping up that way.
Um, plus it's a two-parter and we get to see B'Elanna like really pregnant B'Elanna. Um, yes. In real life. So, uh, with that, I'm going to leave that there and we'll see how, how the rest shakes out. Maybe, uh, the next episode is vis-a-vis Tom Paris befriends an amiable alien unaware that he's a serial form exchanger who switches appearances and troubles with others without permission. Some fun acting bits, uh, some enjoyable Star Trek stuff. Yep. Uh, does it make the list of like essential Star Trek viewing? No. Yeah. I'm with you.
I'm with you moving on the Omega directive. I got to tell you, this is a personal favorite of mine. The detection of an Omega particle puts all other priorities and star feet directives on hold. Janeway is duty bound to destroy the particle above all else. Even if seven of nine objects, lots of great stuff to talk about with seven of nines motivations and the Borg motivations of getting towards perfection, actually giving the Borg real motivation for what they do other than just full on assimilation. Like it speaks, I think a lot to the Y, but what do you think, John?
Well, you're not going to get an unbiased opinion from me because while I've never been as disciplined as my friend Jim in actually trying to rank Trek, if I were, this would be a top 10 episode of all Star Trek for me. This is an episode I think about often. It's an episode that I've taken into my own life to really think about what's important to me. It's an episode that I think is emblematic of the best of all of what Star Trek is in my estimation, which is the quest to really explore the universe and to have total knowledge of all that is. Which, you know, when you go right back to TOS, that's really what it is, right? We're out here to seek civility.
civilizations we're out here to boldly go right and and that is really a key part of the omega directive we try to understand all the things that are out there in the universe we found something really dangerous there's not really there's no bad guy in the episode right who's the villain there isn't one thing right yeah yeah it's a it's a particle like it doesn't have a motivation or interest right it's a thing right it might as well be a block of lead right it's just it's a it's a it's an object it doesn't have a motivation um But the whole concept of why Seven is so interested in this and her revelation as she sees that moment of perfection and talks about it to Janeway, it's just majestic and glorious. And to me, this is one of the very best episodes of all of Star Trek. And I would put it in my top 10 and recommend that, you know, if someone would say to me, show me one episode of Star Trek Voyager to sort of understand what Star Trek is about, this is an episode I would seriously consider.
And I had just one episode of Voyager. This is one I would seriously consider. Yeah, I'm going to leave this and I have down as my little note. Is this a must watch? And I think it is like I really do. I think there's there's a lot of meat in this episode to grab on to. I think it explains Janeway. It explains some stuff with the Federation we've never seen. It explains.
The Borg, as I said, and it's just a great episode all the way around. So I'm glad you said that because if you said it was a skip it, we'd be fighting. No, no, absolutely not. And I mean, I said, this is one of my favorite episodes. And Voyager is my like Voyager was my introduction to Trek. So like, yeah, I hold this one in pretty high regard. The next episode, though, let's talk about that. Unforgettable. An alien woman from a closed world seeks asylum aboard Voyager claiming that she's been there before and that she and Chakotay were lovers. But no one seems to be able to remember her. Forgettable. I mean, I mean, the Kellen story is very sad. You know, she goes back to her planet at the end and all that. But.
I just wasn't interested in it. I really wasn't. I was glad that Chakotay got an episode to do, but that's really inside baseball. For those of us that know that like Star Trek had this rule about, you know, each episode had to be about a character in a way. I don't think that's something that we necessarily need to have represented in this list that you're putting together. So I would skip it. All right. I'm with you. I'm not even going to. It is. Yeah, it's very much in the skip list. The next episode, though, we'll find out where it lands. Living Witness, the doctor awakens in a museum of an alien culture 700 years in the future where Voyager is thought to have been a passing warship full of cold blooded killers. And they get a lot of things right, but most things wrong. John.
where do we go revisionism it's a thing yeah uh and also just the mess of history it's a thing and i love this episode and i think it's really bold of star trek especially at the time yeah to jump like that far into the future and and to have this sort of retrospective view of what happened with voyager i i loved everything about this episode and it's just really the kind of thing you can only do in sci-fi And so for that reason, I think it's essential viewing for Star Trek. Yes, I agree. Wholeheartedly agree. And there's, you know, I've often, even as a kid, I've had these thoughts of like, OK, so in like a thousand years and somebody like digs up my house and they find my homework, like what are they going to think about me? You know, like what are they going to get me right? OK, when we look at our stuff today, what do we get right? What do we get wrong about these these people and these conceptions we have? You know, if the people of yesterday were to watch some of our movies that we make about them today, how much would they do? No, no, no, no, no. That is not what happened at all.
So I actually have a thought on this, which is I love to listen to lectures by noted professors. Right. This is just my own edification. And I listened to a lecture by a professor of antiquities in Roman history. And he talked about the idea of.
doing historical research into the Roman period. And he described it like looking into a keyhole into a room. And if you peek through a keyhole, there are some things you can see incredibly clearly. Like, you know exactly what is right in front of the door. You know what color it is, the shape of it, what's going on. And then things start to get a little fuzzy around the sides. And there's vast swaths of it that you have no knowledge of. And a lot of that is supposition. And a lot of it is based on the flimsiest. Well, flimsiest is the wrong word, but let's just say there's scant evidence to tell us about a lot of things. And we've extrapolated a lot from that, but it really could be off the mark. We just don't know. And I think that that's an example of this.
And I think it's an important lesson in understanding our world, how history comes to us and what lessons we should draw from it. So I'm on board. We need to watch this episode for that reason. All right. I love it. I love it. Rounding out the season here real fast. Demon, critically low on energy. Voyager limps into a hellish Y-class demon planet for much needed deuterium. Tom and Harry beam down and make an accidental contact with a gooey life form.
And yeah, that's about it. Uh, John, they leave their duplicates behind. Listen, this is not the first time that Voyager has left their offspring behind looking at you, Tom Paris and the lizard baby. They left their, their silver blood duplicates behind. I mean, what the, what is, is that the Federation is a utopia? Are you sure? Right. Because that is not to me seem like the kind of behavior that you would want to have in a, in an idealized society. Oh my God. It's, it's horrific. It's horrific. And it's morally offensive. I believe I was not a big fan of this episode when I watched it. Um, and a lot of people gave me grief about it.
And I think it's because like I had watched, I was live tweeting Voyager on my first watch through. So I was in the military when Voyager was actually on the air, see a lot of these episodes and original broadcast. And so I was live tweeting them as I was watching them for the first time. And people were very good in not spoiling the fact that we do revisit these guys again. But I was, I found it just morally offensive that they left their duplicates behind. It really bothered me. And I was not a big fan of this at all. And it just sunk the episode for me. It can be my own personal bugaboos, but that's how I felt about it. Yeah, no, I'm with you on this. And the episode later where they revisit these guys, the one where we see fake Tom and fake Bologna get married and then they all melt or whatever it is by the end of the episode. Like, I promise we're going to skip that episode too. So I don't need this one to set that one up. And I'm just going to skip this one. Voyager landing is cool.
There's some cool effects here. Listen, but we saw, but we saw that in basics part one and two. Yeah. I do. I do love the boy. I, I, I asked, I asked people like, what was a better like visual sequence on screen, Voyager landing or the enterprise D separating from the saucer section. And, and I ran that out and people overwhelmingly chose the enterprise D separating from the saucer section. But personally, I really liked the Voyager landing sequence. Matt was like, why would Matt was like, why would a Star Trek ever, why would a starship ever have struts and have to land at all? Like everyone on a planet. And I'm like, yeah, don't think about that.
All right. There you go. All right. Our penultimate episode of the season one traveling through a toxic nebula puts nearly all of the Voyager crew in stasis, restricting the doctor to sick bay and degrading the ship system, leaving seven, the only one who is in charge and awake. Love it. I love it. I love the doctor and I love seven and I love the doctor and seven together. It's a feeling that I also get in enterprise. Every single scene I've seen between Jolene Blaylock and John Billingsley, you know, the two non-humans on board the enterprise. I just, I love the whole concept of it. And they're talking about, you know, what it's like.
you know, being on the ship and what it's like around all the humans. I love that stuff. And I love it here as well. Seven being by herself, being tempted by the Borg, you know, this whole idea of like what it would be like to be re-assimilated. And, you know, she really feels that, that tug in her psyche. I just, I love it. I think it's a great episode. I have so much love for the doctor slash seven show that I would include it, but I'm also skeptical of my own opinion on that. So I'm with you on that. The only thing that gives me pause is.
do we not also encounter the same thing of sevens pull and desire back to the board and back to the collective plus the whole seven and doctor thing? Do we not get that in other episodes throughout the rest of the run? Tons of seven in the doctor. Exactly. So do you need this one? No. But you know, the whole idea that they're alone on the ship, I love it. You know, I, I really do. It also reminds me of that enterprise episode where the doctor has to go into hibernation and sort of the flip side of that. Right. We're like, okay, now, now it's just the doctor. Now it's not the doctor. Right. And so I, I really liked that whole sort of, you know, taking that character out of the, out of the, off the board for a minute. And so here we're taking all the other characters off the board for a minute. And I think.
that that's something that has a long and glorious history in trick i mean right back to tos where we remember the episode where kirk wakes up i think it's the mark of gideon and he's on and he's on an enterprise that has nobody on board right right it's because he's been kidnapped by those aliens where they have that disease where they don't die so they need a disease that kills them right um so so you know there's a through line of that sort of point of view in a lot of star trek um is it essential viewing no i guess i i would be i i okay you've convinced me i i take it off the list yeah yeah this is where i gotta go i don't know because i'm looking at all the other ones yeah yeah i'm gonna keep this an extra viewing though who knows maybe matt picks it uh maybe we've We've hit our year of hell and then this comes up for the next cycle on that one for where we go. All right, let's close out the season though with a non cliffhanger episode, which is very weird for trick hope and fear a tough coded message from Starfleet with a promise of home and a helpful alien adept at cracking language patterns. This coincidence seems all too convenient for Captain Janeway. Turns out it's all just a trap. It's a trap. And then we finish the episode. It's a trap. Yeah, not so great.
not a big fan of the episodes. Yeah. I, I, I just, I just didn't feel that it's in the like top 150 or so episodes you need to watch to understand star Trek and not even to understand Voyager to be honest. Right. Um, should you watch it? Sure. You know, if I was doing a watch through, would I be tempted to skip it? No. Do I feel like you have to watch it? Nah. Yeah. To me, this was like a mid season episode that they put as a season finale. Like if I would have watched this live and gone, this was the season finale. I've been like, really? Okay. Well, maybe we're going somewhere. Yeah. Like we're so used to the cliffhanger and to go.
so not a cliffhanger. Okay. Are they doing something when they come back? The cliffhanger, non cliffhanger thing is, you know, neither here nor there for me. It's just the episode itself is just sort of, I would have been confused as a season finale. I would have been confused because the very next shot of Voyager we see opening season five is a black and white Tom Paris flying through the air, which is awesome, which is awesome. And that's not this particular season. So I'm going to leave this one. I'm actually going to keep this one and skip to be honest with you. I just, I'm not even going to mention it because I just, it's just weird. All right. So John, let me read through the list because it's not set in stone. We'll give you, we'll give us thing to go. Okay. Does this feel right? Do we want to move one up, move down wherever we want?
going to go in our watch list. I've got the Scorpion one, Scorpion two, and the gift together as one episode. We're going to skip a bunch. And then I've got message in a bottle and hunters together as one episode. And then we'll follow that up with prey. And then we'll do the killing game one and two. We'll do the Omega directive and we'll close this out with living witness and extra viewing. We've got day of honor, revulsion, Raven, you're of hell, mortal coil, and one all excellent episodes. Uh, I would say, except for you, probably not day of honor.
but the rest of them, fantastic episodes. And then skip nemesis, scientific method, random thoughts, concerning flight, waking moments, retrospect, vis-a-vis and hope and fear. Some okay episodes in there, but some not. John, how do you feel? Does that feel like good? Do you want to move anything up or down? You want to make a case? I feel pretty good about that. Raven's still on the bubble for me. It could be go, could go even lower. Cause like I said, you get all that stuff later in another episode. So I, if, you know, and I guess that's a case where it depends on what your final lists end up looking like. Like when you put the final thing together, you know, if you need one to boot, I boot Raven. Cause you get it all again later. Sure. Sure.
All right, I'll just move down to skip. I won't even bring it up for him. I'm not trying. I wasn't going to convince you. That was in the bubble for me. But here's where you say that. I know how much Matt really likes origin stories and we get it over there. Like this is not the origin story he's looking for.
You know what I mean? Like, like I don't even want to tempt him with this one because this is not the one he's looking for. He really wants that one over there. So fair enough. And yeah, so we'll leave it there. So I think that's a that's a season. That's a course for how we're going to handle the season. All right. Great success. There it is. There it is. John, my friend, my new friend. Yes. Many, many thanks for your most diligent work and going through this and really honoring the spirit of what this show is about, because it's so easy to just go. I love all these episodes and we're going to put them in and really having to do the work for a while. I very much appreciate your attentiveness to all of those things. Once again, tell them one more time where folks can find you if they want to catch up with everything you're doing.
And folks, you should. Yeah, you can just go to trekprofiles.com. That's my website. And there's a how to listen page there. It'll have every possible link to every place where you can find us. So we're on all the places you can get audio. If you want to listen via RSS, you want to listen on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, Google Play. We're in all the places. And the great thing about my show is that it's not sequential. Every episode is standalone. And if you want to get into Trek Profiles, the one suggestion is any episode is a great place to start as long as it's someone's name.
If it's not named after a person, it's probably a special. So you probably want to skip those for now, but start anywhere with an episode that's named after a person and you can get a sense of what we're all about. There you go. I love it. Once again, guys, go check them out. Trekprofiles.com. If you're not listening, why not? You should be because it's such a great examination of the people that make up the Star Trek fandom. John, thank you once again. I very, very much appreciate it. And to all our listeners out there, hey guys, listen, we'll be back next week with the Scorpion 1, 2 and the gift to kick off Voyager season four. Until next time, folks, live long and prosper. Living long and prosper.