Skip to content
Christa Pike Awake, Speaking After Botched Execution, Shackled to Bed episode artwork

Oct 7, 2026 43 min

Christa Pike Awake, Speaking After Botched Execution, Shackled to Bed

from Crime Stories with Nancy Grace Hosted by iHeartPodcasts and CrimeOnline

Christa Pike's scheduled execution, aborted after failed attempt to deliver fatal drugs. Tennessee administered two doses of pentobarbital, but she did not die. Witnesses reported that she continued breathing and making snoring-like sounds long after the drugs were administered. She was eventually taken by ambulance to a hospital. After being unconscious, and on a ventilator, Pike has regain consciousness and is speaking. The state's remaining execution for 2026 and has been halted. Joining Nancy Grace today: Randolph Rice - Former Prosecutor and Current Criminal Defense & Civil Attorney at Rice Law, website: ricelawmd.com, IG, FB, X: @ricelawmd Phil Keith - Former Chief of Police for Knoxville Police Dept. Dr. Janie Lacy - Licensed Psychotherapist and CEO of Life Counseling Solutions, Author of "How To Heal From A Toxic Relationship: A Guide To Reclaiming Your Mental Health and Happiness", Host of "Let's Talk About It with Janie Lacy” Podcast on YouTube, janielacy.com, Instagram & Facebook: @JanieLacy Joseph Scott Morgan - Professor of Forensics: Jacksonville State University, Author, "Blood Beneath My Feet", YouTube Host: "Body Bags with Joseph Scott Morgan", @JoScottForensic John North - Senior Investigative Journalist at W-B-I-R in Knoxville, Tenn. Witnessed the botched execution. Dave Mack - Investigative Reporter, 'Crime Stories'

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Christa Pike Awake, Speaking After Botched Execution, Shackled to Bed

0:00 43:52
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

This is an iHeart podcast. Guaranteed human. Crime stories with Nancy Grace. Tonight, the double dose, torture killer, Krista Pike, is alive, not just alive. She is awake and speaking.

After her botched execution, she has shackled to a bed. What's next? Good evening. I'm Nancy Grace. This is Crime Stories.

I want to thank you for being with us. Krista Pike survives execution, keeping a piece of the victims skull as a souvenir of murder. And the curtains suddenly close. And the media witnesses are confused because she's very much still alive. She was still continuously talking.

I just kept hearing it. I was just looking at her. I was just looking at her. She got her run again. I was just thinking, do you want to see a run about?

I was just shocked. I was shocked. I was shocked. I was shocked. Everybody had a much clearer.

Is there a border that you shot and put to death? I don't think you can. You know the tripod. We transferred to custody for warning at the Tennessee Presumency. And third, 12th day of January, 1997.

Your body shall be subjected to shock by a special current electricity. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'm sorry.

I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'm sorry.

I'm sorry. Colleen will never hug her mother again. Her mother will never hold her teen girl in her arms again. Colleen was lured to a remote area. She was tortured, pentagrams cut into her skin, held down by this group of ghouls including the defendant.

When the victim, the teen girl tried to run, she, Krista Pike, chased her and stabbed her brutally in the back with a meat cleaver, bashed her head in with a chunk of asphalt so viciously with such velocity. It was like a major league pitcher. But Colleen's skull shattered. And what did Pike do? She salvaged a piece of Colleen's skull as a souvenir and showed it off to her ghoulish friends and danced a little jig around with the skull.

But somehow tonight, the double dose lethal injection survivor Krista Pike is alive talking coherent, cognizant. And the torture killer has somehow turned into the poster girl for anti-deaf penalties. That was my friends at WBIR joining me right now, special guest, John North joining us out of Knoxville, senior investigative journalist, WBIR in Knoxville. He was there at the bashed execution. He's also spoken in depth to Colleen, slimmer's mother, Miss May Martinez.

I mean another chapter of hell for Colleen's mother. But first, John North, thank you for being with us tonight. What happened? I'm going to see and hear in the death chamber. Well, you know, I've been to a couple other executions here in Tennessee, Nancy, and I've seen them go the way they were supposed to.

One was when we had the three drug cocktail. That one worked fine. The inmate was gone in about 20, 25 minutes. The other one was the electric chair. You know how quickly that works.

It became pretty apparent within a few minutes, Nancy, that this was going wrong, that things were not happening the way they were supposed to. I was expecting that within, I don't know, five minutes, six minutes, seven minutes, she would have become unconscious drifted off and then all of her systems would start to go down. That's the way it was supposed to happen. It didn't happen that way at all. It was within the witness chamber.

Six other folks, journalists, many of whom had seen executions before. So most of us had been through this. Some had also witnessed a botched attempt in May. But essentially what happened is that she never really went under with the first dose. She was talking, singing, chuckling.

Believe me, I was astonished. She went, we're 10 minutes in and she's moving her head and her foot is moving and she's still talking. She had a spiritual advisor who at the start was sort of what you thought to be blunt about it was sort of leading her down the path of what we thought would be a peaceful death, singing, kind of chanting, stroking her forehead, being with her standing right next to her on a gurney. But it just continued like that. After the first dose, well, I should say about three, four, five minutes into it, she said, because we could all hear because the microphone was dangling from the ceiling near her and it was piped into the witness chamber.

She said, have they started it yet? And I thought, oh yeah, they started it. You should be feeling the effects. But after the first dose, then abruptly the blinds come down. The advisor comes into the room with us and I thought, okay, maybe now this is where we kick into, if you will, the final phase.

That didn't happen. I think they were administering the second dose. He stepped out from where he was with us in the dark and witness chamber. Somebody whispered, the clergy needs to come back in. That referenced him.

He goes a couple doors down. I can hear the doors clanging and opening. Blinds come back up. There he is standing again by her side. And she's snoring at this point.

And I was aware that that is a step that inmates may experience or anybody who has a serious dose of pentobarbital. But then she would kind of her breathing would be kind of quiet. And we'd come back to snoring. Every once in a while there was an voluntary noise. I'm not going to go minute by minute through it with you.

You get the idea. But that continued off and on with the snoring sleeping, whatever, until 8.05. They clearly were administering a second dose. And at 8.05, the blinds came down again. And that was it for us.

We never saw again, whatever was happening. We could hear her very loudly and clearly wheezing, snoring, all of that. We didn't see what was going on in the last 15 minutes, I would guess. Believe it or not, her breathing kind of got a little bit more regular. And at least the thought hit me.

I think she's kind of rallying. Wow. John North, joining us out of Knoxville in the death chamber, when Pikes to unsuccessful attempts at lethal injection occurred. I was speaking to a lot of viewers and listeners. And they want to know, how does it work?

You mentioned blinds going up and down. I know you could see her because you stayed at her head was moving and her foot was flowing. How did the blinds work? And what did you see? I heard a lot of what you heard.

And I'm trying to decipher it and figure out what does it mean in relation to this brand new lawsuit that Pikes has just filed against Jonathan Scrametti, the Tennessee Attorney General, that said, what did you see? We're led into the witness chamber at about 642, 643 somewhere in there. The prison officer said, we're going to have the lights on for you. And then they're going to go off. And essentially, that's a signal that we're about to start when the lights go off.

And he said, your eyes will adjust. We're sitting in a room with about three rows of chairs. I'm in the front row on the left hand side. There's a door that I believe leads straight into the execution chamber in front of me to the left. There are four windows, four panels of glass.

They've got reflective film on them, something like that. So while we're sitting there with lights on, we can only see ourselves. But you asked what's happening. For roughly 45 minutes while we're in that room, they're prepping her. We can hear it.

I can hear under the door sounds of paper rattling, like tape unspooling. You're something that sounds like a chair rolling around. I can hear her whimper a time or two. That's all with the blinds down. Then the lights go off.

And that's a signal to us that, okay, now it's about to happen. Blinds come up, 727 PM. And you know this is a standard procedure. The warden is sitting, I can see through the glass, right pretty close to me up here. Krista's in the back of the room diagonal to us on a gurney, strapped down with the advisor next to her.

And the warden says, do you have any last words? She says, yes, I do. She proceeds to tell people that she's going out of this world the way that she lived in it, which was with love for the people who she knew hated her, as well as those who loved her. And she essentially said, maybe especially for the people who hated her. She offered love and she said, I'm at peace.

I'm ready to go. So that's kind of how it all started out. 727 with her offering final words. At this hour, Krista Pike alive, she is off the ventilator. She is speaking.

She's alert. She's cognizant. Recalls her name as memories of being in the hospital after surviving the two botched lethal injections. What does it mean? The memories of the hospital, but no memory of the execution attempts.

Pike is able to communicate. She had a very close guess at the date. She thought it was the end of September. She's been off the ventilator for some time now after being intubated at the hospital. This is after two doses, lethal doses, appendabarbitol, using at least seven needles.

One of them came out of her arm bent at a 90 degree angle and somehow she is now the poster girl for anti-death penalty. In all of this, somehow, Colleen Slimer and what was done to her has been totally obscured. I heard stated just then that everyone thought that Krista Pike was going to have a peaceful death. But Dave Mack joining us, crime stories investigative reporter, that's not what Colleen Slimer endured before her death, did she?

No, Nancy, what happened to Colleen Slimer goes beyond what any of us could even imagine. Now, she was lured to her death. There had been a time where Krista Pike had been terrorizing, had been bullying Slimer for some time. And she lures her out that night by telling her, you know what, we're going to make the man's we're going to pull this behind us and we're going to be best buddies. And so as Colleen Slimer is walking with Pike and with Todero and with Chidola, she thinks putting all the bad behind and it's going to be great from here on out.

And once they got here to an isolated area, the terrorization turned into violence. And Nancy, we've got a box cutter used to slice Colleen. We've got the cleaver, a small cleaver used to hack at her, the pentagrams. And number two, one, stretched into her chest and then her head. And so the damage that was done to Colleen Slimer's head goes beyond anything we can imagine, but her skull was crushed and Krista Pike got a piece of that skull and held it as a souvenir and showed it off to others later, almost as a threat and as a joyful experience for her to remember.

By the way, something that continues to mortify Colleen Slimer's mother is getting all of the pieces of her daughter's shattered skull. So it can be put to rest. That's what happened to Colleen Slimer and Nancy. Jessica Morgan joining us, Professor for NSX, Jacksonville State University. He is a star of body bags with Jessica Morgan on YouTube.

He is a death investigator that has conducted over 10,000 death investigations. Jessica, did you know that Colleen Slimer, the victim in this scenario, had over 300 slices to her body, including being cune, H-E-W-N, cune in the back with a meat cleaver. Her skull bashed in with a chunk of asphalt. What happened to the victim? Because all I'm hearing about is what's happening to Krista Pike, who is alive and well cognizant and speaking, clearly well enough to file this lawsuit I've got in my hands.

Let's just say this plainly, the perpetrators in this case, Chief Among Them is going to be Pike. They showed up prepared. This is not like something where we're going to arbitrarily find a box cutter on the ground or find a meat cleaver on the ground. Now they showed up with this and back to what David said regarding the luring to bring her back to this isolated abandoned area where they could do this for her. And Nancy, part of this, and I know that it's very horrific relative to the physical, but you had taunting that was going on with her where their terrorizing, her threatening her with death, not showing any kind of mercy on any level whatsoever when they laid hands on her and began to attack her.

And here's one of the things that has stuck with me. When she would not die, when she would not die, I'm going to say this very plainly, so hold your ears. When she did not die, you know, Pike is alleged to have said, the bitch won't die. The bitch won't die. And so it's at this point that, you know, she also states, I want to see brains flow.

So with that, a piece of asphalt is then taken this dirty, filthy, ragged chunk of asphalt. And she is struck in the skull multiple times. There's a classic image of my friend, Murray Marks, that's sitting on the stand there in Knoxville, and he has her skull there, and he's showing it, and it is fractured in so many areas. And this piece that Dave had referred to is kind of in the parietal occipital area. That was actually removed at the scene.

And this is what she was celebrating. You know, when she goes to, I think it was to lunch or something the next day, and she's displaying this. And, you know, and it is truly a trophy, Nancy. It's truly a trophy. It ranks right up there with stuff that Dommer did.

You know, I think that people want to separate this kind of evil, perhaps, but it's just equally as evil. You know, this poor girl had done nothing to anyone, was tortured, terrorized, and then literally obliterated. It was obliterated back there in that filthy, filthy surface back there in the ag area at UT. 30 seconds. In that time, you can check your phone, reheat a cup of coffee, or decide to skip songs.

In 30 seconds, we can confirm an unknown identity, lock onto a distress signal, and switch course to respond. When every second counts, the Canadian Armed Forces is ready. It's every time. It's all the time. It's our time.

Learn more at forces.ca slash our time. A message from the Government of Canada. Crying stories with Nancy Grace. Another special guest joining us tonight in the aftermath of a double botched lethal injection of Chris the Pike. Convicted torture killer of a teen girl has been behind bars 31 years as the appellate process grinded to an end.

Phil Keith was a chief of police in Knoxville at the time. Colleen was slaughtered when she begged for Pike and her cohort to let her live. They did not. What do you recall happened, Phil Keith? What did you learn about the murder?

Well, the crime scene was gruesome. It's one thing to look at a picture. It's another thing to be at the crime scene, see what the medical examiner was doing to extract facts. There's been a lot of discussion, as you've mentioned, making Chris the Pike almost a poster child for whatever calls. Our local media refers to her as Chris the Bill Pike.

They never mentioned the number of they do. It's a parent. So, there's so much, there's so many dynamics that go on, and these kind of issues, particularly with the victim family, they have to navigate a very complex criminal justice system. They're not often informed. I ran round tables, victim round tables for the Department of Justice for about 12 years.

The message that came out every time was the gruesome details that they would have to experience and the inconsistent messages they received, either from prosecutors or from other sources. So what Colleen's family has had to go through for 31 years is it starts with the first notice of death. The last conversation her mother had with Colleen was the expert tonight that she was taken. She mentioned to her mother that she was having trouble with a couple of students. Then the facts start to unfold.

She's lured away as soon as I get over that road area of the University of Tennessee at campus. There was a hard concrete pad, and Pike immediately grabbed her by the head of the hair, drove her head into her knee, and the assault began. She had assistance from ship who was 17 at a time, very much playing a role in the attack and the torture. He's the one that actually carved the pentagram. There's been a mention of a second one, but there's no record of that in the medical exam examers report.

Sandra Elkins, who was a medical examiner at the time, said that the cuts were so multiple, she quit counting. But just going through watching parts of the investigation unfold with the investigator interviewing Pike and ship, there's just clearly no remorse. Pike planned this on the 11th. She told a friend at Job Corps that she intended to kill Pike. I mean, kill Collin.

After she came back, as you mentioned already, she took a piece of Collin's skull as a souvenir and bragged about it that night actually, and then the next day. She was interviewed first. Pike was interviewed first on the 14th by Randy Orr. I watched part of that interview as well as his ship's interview. It struck me about the lack of remorse, particularly with ship.

He actually fell asleep during the interview. When the officer went to the rest of the job corps, he was down to sleep. So there's just no indication of any kind of remorse. When Collin fell to the ground after being hit and had a second time, Pike continued to beat her with the chunk of asphalt and stated she could hear Collin breathing blood in and out and could see Collin jerking her words, not mine, but Pike continued to hit her and hit her and hit her. Krista got down in Collin's face and yelled, Collin, do you know who's doing this to you?

The victim only responded with groans. Krista Pike and her cohort grabbed Collin's feet and dragged her steel alive to an area near trees, threw on a pile of dirt and trash. Letter telling detectives the whole thing took about an hour. She removed the bandana from her own hair and tied it around Collin's mouth to prevent her from talking. It's overwhelming.

Taking up a piece of Collin's skull and putting it in her pocket as a trophy, proof she was the one to kill Collin. What Philke was the motive for murder? Well she conjured up the story that was a love triangle and that's what we believed initially. But there was nothing to provide proof that that was actually existing. Collin was basically a naive, pleasant, easygoing young 19-year-old who'd worked with her mother at daycare and been involved in helping children with disabilities and by all descriptions she didn't have a vicious bone in her body.

So Pike conjured up the story about Collin standing over with a box cutter, the love triangle, and his comments said there was no relationship. So, you know, this was all part of Pike's motivation to kill somebody. She told her fellow student at Job Corps the day before that she intended to kill Collin. And she wanted to make it. I broke down into yours.

She was laying on table, talking, still laughing, picking up her head. Has anyone apologized to you for this? No, sir. Nobody apologized. Here we are, 31 years.

I knew laughing in my face again. And that's what I feel like they did. I want to think about Collin being there and saying thank you, Mom. You know, on her voice, the criminals get so much attention. Why?

She hasn't lost in this. And they'd also have a piece of her skull that we still can't find. She's been forgotten. Other than when she's brought up like this. That is Colleen's mother speaking from our friends at First Coast News NWHAS.

Joining us now, Dr. Janie Lacey, licensed like a therapist CEO of Life Counseling Solutions. She's the author of How to Heal from a Toxic Relationship. And the star of Let's Talk About It with Janie Lacey. Dr. Janie, thank you for being with us.

This mother, I'm talking about Colleen's mother. 31 years, she waited for some type of closure. Of course, there's never any closure. You just somehow managed to trudge forward. And now this Dr. Janie.

No, Nancy, I imagine, you know, I want us all to imagine. Being told for 30 years that a date is coming. And you brace for it. The day arrives and it doesn't end. You know, I think families in that position, they get caught in a loop of hope.

And then there's dread and then right now we're looking at potentially reversal. So people talk about closure as you stated, but there is no clean closure. When the process keeps reopening, mismarkinesses and the families wound. And her mom, who has said for years that she supported the death penalty for piping. Whatever happens next, I mean, I hope the states thinks hard about what these families are told and when.

So they are not just learning it from headlines because there is a family that has been waiting for for 30 years, Nancy. So you went in there thinking that just this was going to get shoved in. Of course, Chris, that pipe didn't make it didn't die. You had 31 years to do this. You had 31 years to make sure you guys got everything in order for this day to happen.

And for that to stop an hour before it just slapped in the face. From our friends at WVLT, that's Morgan Sealy, Glenn's niece, speaking out. Every Canadian deserves a place to call home. That's why we created Build Canada Homes. We're using new technology to build more efficiently, unlocking government land to build in more places and cutting red tape to get more projects started.

We're building more affordable homes faster because a more affordable Canada is a stronger Canada. Learn more at Canada.ca slash building homes, a message from the government of Canada. Crying stories with Nancy Grace. 31 years to get this ready and they still screwed it up. Red off rice.

I am reading this motion just filed by Christopher Pike's lawyers demanding that the Attorney General for the Safe Tennessee maintain and preserve all evidence regarding the double botched lethal injection. There's going to be a huge lawsuit for medical cause for pain and suffering, but will her deaths in its be commuted by the governor? Nancy, that's a great question. And I don't know that it's necessarily going to be commuted by the governor, but certainly the courts are going to get involved here. And this may go all the way up to the Supreme Court because there are two big issues here.

The first, the Fifth Amendment that says you can't have double jeopardy, which means you can't punish somebody twice. And more importantly, I think the stronger. But double jeopardy revolves trying involves trying someone twice. It also has it's also a portion that talks about double punishment. Double punishment.

That's why you're double jeopardy. There can't be double jeopardy, double punishment on double trial. This does not mean you're really something. Okay. Double jeopardy when when the Senate fails does not preclude the sentence being reenacted.

I'm still making that argument and I'm making it to the Supreme Court. And here's my second argument. Okay. Go ahead. Spin it out.

Rubble Stilston. Eighth Amendment can't have cruel and unusual punishment. This was cruel and unusual punishment. And this is distinguishable from all other cases that the Supreme Court has talked about, because in those cases, they couldn't get the needle in or electricity wasn't powerful. Now they got her to the brink of death.

Miss Pike was almost dead. They had to resuscitate her, bring her back. And now she's injured. This is one of those ones where I don't think they're going to put another needle in her. And to be honest with you, I would let this group in Tennessee give me a flu shot.

Good enough for government work. That's that seems to be the motto here. Hey, hey, hey, hey. I'm in a government worker my whole legal career. I don't even know what you're talking about.

Were you a former prosecutor? Isn't that the government? It was, but this group, okay, don't call that kettle black. Good enough for government. Okay.

Let me direct Randolph Rice to the law, not just his fantasies, his legal fantasies. I direct you to Louisiana, Francis the rest. The US Supreme Court condone and allowed a second execution attempt after the initial education malfunction. Bam. So I guess you're going to argue against the US Supreme Court ruling.

And again, you heard Randolph Rice spinning out double jeopardy. Legal precedent states double jeopardy does not apply to a failed execution attempt. The state is not barred from trying again. Double jeopardy deals with not being able to try someone twice for the same crime. Here's an example.

Oh, J Simpson, even if he had stated, okay, I did it. And I'll tell you how I did it. He gave a full confession to murdering Nicole and Ron. He could not be tried again because he was tried and acquitted. He could not try somebody again.

And that's why you see very often you see prosecutors wait a long time to bring a case of trial because they're trying to get enough evidence to convict because if you miss the boat, if you screw up and there's an acquittal and then you get that big smoking gun too late, there's nothing you can do about it. Straight back to John North, senior investigative journalist W. B. I. Are not full.

What's happening is the death penalty going to be commuted? Is she going to be given life without parole versus the D.P.? What's happening? Tennessee is a really great state, Nancy. So you start with that as kind of the assumption.

This is a place where people are pretty hardcore about crime and they want people to be held accountable. On the other hand, as Randolph just said, the state couldn't execute somebody after assuring everybody that we're going to be no problems and we've already had a botched execution attempt in May. They didn't get the drugs into that inmate system. This one they did and she lived. What's going to happen is it's all going to play out, as you would imagine, in multiple courts on multiple platforms.

The death penalty is something we're already hearing from politicians, Republicans who are like, Hey, never mind with lethal injection. Let's go back to the electric chair right now. Lethal injection is the designated method for most inmates. If you're convicted today on the table, that's what you're going to get. This is not just a legal issue.

It's a political issue too. You know, it's unprecedented. Will people as a result of this say, wow, we need to take a serious look at death penalty in Tennessee? Yes, they will. Will it go away completely?

I couldn't give you that insurance. I did talk over the weekend with a district attorney general who handles death penalty cases and had one pending until there was a death of an inmate, but he said, you have to wonder now if Tennessee will ever be capable of carrying out another death sentence. So we're talking about not just months. And we have a new governor who's going to be taking office in January, elections next month. But you're talking about years to try and figure this out.

This is years. Now, meanwhile, just so everybody knows, Mike's not going anywhere. She's got this sentence. Whether it's commuted or not, she attempted to murder another inmate in 2001. She's got 25 years.

Well, I'll stop everything. Well, but what what what? Yes, she in 2001, she tried to kill another inmate here from Knoxville. Chief Keith would remember this case. A woman's name was Is Patricia Jones.

She murdered an elderly woman here in Knoxville. And she and Krista never liked each other. That's what the record shows. And in 2001, Krista decided that, you know, she was going to take a bootlace and and try and kill her. Didn't work.

The guards intervened while according to the court record, Krista is basically in control of her, saved Patricia Jones's life. A couple days after that, you may be aware there was a prison conversation. Those are recorded. Krista was talking to her mother and also a friend and basically said, I premeditated the, you know, what out of it. If I had been given another 30 seconds, there'd be a white chalk mark out there in the art.

Okay, Randolph Rice, there you go. Even if she is not given the death penalty again, she's going to get behind bars and try to kill somebody else. I, that's new to me. I did not know she tried to kill a female inmate. Then convicted for that.

And let's do have her, you have her sentence to death for that crime. But for this crime itself, again, I disagree with you. I think double jeopardy comes into it. I just want to make sure that what did you just say? Convictor on that and say, convictor on that case if you want to do that.

But for this case here, the one that we're talking about where they couldn't complete the execution, that is the issue we're talking about here. And that's the issue where it's botched. And the Supreme Court that gets that far is going to say, you had your chance, Tennessee, you failed miserably. The same people running the DMV seem to be running the execution chambers in Tennessee. You don't get to do it again.

So just kind of working what happened to the three-jug cocktail that seemed to work? Honestly, Nancy, I don't know why they went away from it. I'm sure that it was more lawyer speak relative to how they were going to go through this because with the combination with with each element that you combine into the so-called cocktail, that is a point that can be argued along the way that it's going to not be sufficient to do the job. So what do you do? Well, you drop down to a single agent, which is Pentobarbitol in this case, by the way, again, I'd like to emphasize this is the single most common standalone drug that is actually used to euthanize dogs with.

Just let that sink in. It's used every single day all across the country by the veterinarian offices. So with that said, they settle on this one drug. It is not the drug. OK, it's not the methodology.

This is what used to be referred to in computer speak as operator error here. They failed to get the delivery device into her vessels. OK, now I would love to tell you this and just. They did not inject blood vessel. Is that what that just meant?

Yeah, it is. They went into probably the industry. They couldn't find a vein, which one of them they couldn't find a vein. Yeah. And the one of the things that's one of the tropes that's been put out, well, she dehydrated herself, you know, days prior.

Let me tell you something. They're they're wonderful nurses and CNAs, all in paramedics and all kinds of people out there all across America right now, as we speak, that are setting up IVs and yes, sometimes you have problems and sometimes you don't. But Nancy, you're talking about going through and you said this going through seven needles. OK, how many do you need in order to make this happen? The way that this process is set up in Tennessee is that they have this 30 day window. It's like a spin up and then they have these these markers.

They have to go through like it's like retraining, right? So you have you have the initial contact and then everybody's supposed to know what they do. Where in the hell did they fail here? How can you be this just blatantly incompetent? Agree, agree.

And it started the ball rolling and a legal and emotional nightmare. The bill already is a pro is estimated to approach $200,000 for the medical bills. And there's going to be the lawsuits for pain and suffering on behalf of Krista Pike. But what about Slimmers mother? John North joining a senior investigative reporter, W.

B. I R Knoxville. You spoke with Colleen's mother. What is her response to all of this? Disgusted despondent.

She's kind of giving up. She said things to us yesterday, like this was never going to happen to begin with. She's called it fake. And I said, if you don't mind me asking, what would you like to see done? She said, it doesn't matter what I think they don't care what I think.

So that kind of summarizes where she is mentally. What was her demeanor as she spoke to you, John North? Increasingly frustrated and angry, Nancy. We've known each other for 30 years. I've tried to stay in touch with her.

There were many times where she was like, it's not going to happen. It's not going to happen. And I said, may you just have to trust the legal process. We talked to her the night before the execution, went over and met her in her hotel room in Nashville. And she was kind of like, OK, you know, maybe this is going to happen.

And I'll be there for Colleen to witness it. But I mean, she was seeing the same thing that I was seeing Wednesday night. And she was back to being let down from her perspective again in thinking, because it never ends. First of all, the family of a murder victim, the rest of their life is altered. It never goes away ever.

Everything is changed. But this I don't know how Slimmer's family can keep going. Guys, you were seeing video just then from first goes news, N. W. H. A. S.

As John was speaking, Nancy, Krista Pikes, attorney spoke this afternoon. They said first thing she said was, where am I and who are you? But she remains shackled to her bed. And her lawyer, Andy Spivy, says the murder is still severely unwell, cannot move her arms or swallow, has a blood clot and pneumonia and a request to unshackle her was refused. Pikes attorney filed an emergency motion to secure the execution materials, noting that she only regained limited consciousness and speech the day before the hearing yesterday.

Davison County Chancery Court Chancellor, Aisha L. Miles ordered the state of Tennessee to preserve all evidence connected to the failed execution of Pike. The judge's sweeping order requires Tennessee Department of Corrections to save anything that was in the actual room. It's an extensive list, including medical supplies like syringes, needles, unused drugs and ivy lines, records and documentation like execution logs, drug, glotten numbers, time logs and medical records as well as communications, emails, text messages, witness accounts, video footage and any 911 calls made during the incident. We wait as justice unfolds.

And tonight we remember an American hero patrolman, Cassie Johnson, Charleston, P.D., West Virginia, just 28 shot and killed in the line of duty, leaving behind her mother, Cheryl, and siblings, Chelsea and Charles. American hero patrol person Cassie Johnson. Thank you to our guests, but especially to you for being with us. Nancy Grace signing off for tonight. I'll see you tomorrow night and until then, good night, friend.

This is an iHeart podcast guaranteed human.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Crime Stories with Nancy Grace?

This episode is 43 minutes long.

When was this Crime Stories with Nancy Grace episode published?

This episode was published on October 7, 2026.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Crime Stories with Nancy Grace episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.