American nationalism has always been seeded with very important ideals, including individual liberty and constitutionalism. But if we hadn't had this strong nationalist thread running throughout our history, we would have fallen apart right at the beginning. And no one would have cared very much about, well, it wouldn't have been the United States of America. No one would have cared very much about it. And our ideals would have been discredited. You're listening to Code Red with Secure America Now, the largest national security grassroots army.
Welcome to the Code Red Podcast. I am Alan Roth, president of Secure American App. Our special guest today is Rich Lowry, editor of National Review, syndicated columnist, and frequent guest on radio and television public affairs programs. Welcome, Rich. Hey, thanks so much for having me on. Rich is the author of an important book, The Case for Nationalism, How It Made Us Powerful, United, and Free. As we begin this discussion, the United States is in a wide-ranging debate over when to lift the coronavirus lockdown.
You recently wrote a column criticizing blackout extremists. Can you share with us your thoughts on the subject? Yes, I basically supported the lockdowns. Initially, I thought trying to keep the hospitals from being overwhelmed made sense. This was a highly infectious disease, largely unknown. So caution said, let's not let it spread out of control. And as we speak, we're over 70,000 deaths. So I'm not an epidemiologist. These models have obviously been flawed. I don't know what the number would have been without radical efforts to try to control it. There would have been multiples higher than that. But we've learned.
It's a tri-state area, particularly susceptible to it. The density of New York City, the subway system in New York, and how often it's used by people, all that has made New York particularly prone to this disease. And the rest of the country is not necessarily New York City. So I think, obviously, we are far too sweeping geographically. You look at just New York State. They're just counties in New York State that haven't been affected at all. So did it make sense to treat them as though they were Queens or Brooklyn or Manhattan? No, it didn't.
And then we did things that have a major downside effect, like suspending elective surgeries at hospitals. And elective surgeries, you know, it's not just knee replacements. surgeries for heart ailments, for cancer. So there's a real downside health effect of that. And we've had this bizarre consequence of, in the middle of the pandemic, hospitals being emptied out and having massively excess beds and having to furlough workers. So plus we've succeeded now, and the goal of not getting hospitals overwhelmed, and the curve has bent downward, not as much as any of us would like, but it's clearly bent downward. And there's an enormous economic effect of what we've done. So it's clearly time to, as most states are, to begin opening up again. And it's just crazy to me that you have one side of the political debate in the media.
saying if you realize there's a balance that now needs to be struck between economic and public health considerations, and there's some parts of the country that haven't been hit that hard, plus outdoor activity and beaches aren't a vector for spread. If you say any of that, you want to kill people and you want people to die, which is just insane. So we've gone from, I believe, a prudent approach, let's not let our health system get overwhelmed and destroyed, to this extremist approach to if you favor activity that might create any new cases on the margin, you're a murderer. And that just strikes me as absurd. If it helps, I agree with you completely. I think that they have been so successful in instilling fear into people that it has become an irrational opposition to even beginning the process of opening up our country. And which leads me to ask, you wrote what I consider an important book, and I urge everyone to read it, The Case for Nationalism. And in that book, you give a robust...
not only defense of nationalism, but you see it as a good, that it's actually a good thing, that we as Americans should be nationalists. Now, during this corona pandemic, across Europe, where there is a huge move against, there has been a huge move, and I'm not sure it still exists, against nationalism. We see countries shutting their borders, Germany, France, Italy, countries that have considered themselves globalists, are now turning. Do you think that the virus and the response to it has actually created a movement towards nationalism?
I think it has in certain respects. We just saw in Europe with this crisis that at the end of the day, no one was really European. They were German or Italian or Spanish or French. So they wanted to protect the protective gear that they had and use it for their people first, entirely understandable impulse. And they wanted to shut their borders against the entry of other people who might have brought this disease. So Germany, which of course led by Angela Merkel in the migrant crisis in 2015, shamed other European countries for trying to close their borders to migrants in control who came in and out of there.
countries. Germany was even doing this during this crisis. Germany shut down its restricted movements across its border without coordinating with other European countries. So this just shows it's natural, expected, and correct for a government to look after the interests of its people first. Now, that doesn't mean you need to be aggressive towards other nations. It doesn't mean you need to bear ill will towards other nations. But even when it comes to allied nations, if you have a choice, are these a million masks going to stay here and protect my people?
Or am I going to export them across the border so they can protect someone else when there's a shortage? Every government in its right mind is going to answer, we're going to keep them here. So I do think this will, at least at the margins, you know, I can't speak to the left, which is uneducable on a lot of this stuff. But at the margins, at least, this crisis will emphasize the importance of borders and the importance of when it comes to goods that are important to your own security or that you might need in a crisis, that it's a very good thing to be able to make those things on your own. In your book, The Case for Nationalism, and your subtitle, How It Made Us Powerfully United and Free, you actually explain why nationalism, and in particular, American nationalism, is a definite good.
And can you define for us what American nationalism is and does it differ from other forms of nationalism? Yeah. So first of all, let's get just real basic on the definitions because there's a lot of confusion about this. What's patriotism and what's nationalism? So if you want to be really technical about it, patriotism comes from the Latin root. Patre, father, fatherland. Patriotism is the love of your own, which is also very important in natural sentiment. Nationalism is a doctrine or ideal that distinct people united by distinct culture, distinct history, very often distinct language should govern a distinct.
territory. That's what nationalism is. Very often people say, use nationalism just to refer to all the things that are bad in national feeling, but that's not a correct or sustainable definition. So nationalism has really defined the modern world. We have a world made up of nation states whose borders are considered sacrosanct, and there's an important norm around honoring them that's violated only by a few malefactors. So that's the basic of nationalism. American nationalism has always been seeded with very important ideals, including individual liberty.
and constitutionalism. But if we hadn't had this strong nationalist thread running throughout our history, we would have fallen apart right at the beginning. And no one would have cared very much about, well, there wouldn't have been the United States of America. No one would have cared very much about it. And our ideals would have been discredited. So this was the key insight of the Federalists right at the beginning of the formal founding of the country, which is we need a national government worthy of a name. It needs to be limited. And there's certain things it just can't do, you know, and we're going to enumerate them in the Bill of Rights, but it needs to be functional and competent.
And the vision of George Washington and Alexander Hamilton, the original American nationalist, was we should become a great power on par with Great Britain. And that means, one, you have a capable national government. Two, you have a national market. You have an industrial and commercial-based economy. And you expand across the continent, and you make sure there are no threats on your borders. So we're going to chase all the remnants of European empires from our immediate vicinity. And that was just crucial to what this country is and what it's become.
And we wouldn't be as powerful or have had the influence, a good influence, I believe, on the whole around the world if that hadn't happened. In debates or critics of nationalism invariably say nationalism equals fascism. Can you explain why that's not the case? Yeah, that's, I think, completely wrong. So there's no doubt that fascists play on nationalist sentiments. And I think really any political movement should play on nationalist sentiments. You're kind of an idiot if you don't, because it's such a natural phenomenon. But fascism is much more than just nationalism. It's aggressive. It is often neo-imperialist, the way that the Nazis were. It's based on this charismatic cult of the leader and a romance around violence.
This is really a phenomenon of 1920s, 1930s Europe. Modern nationalism began in the 18th century. If it had been inherently fascistic, we would have had fascism much earlier. It wasn't. In fact, the first modern nationalists were liberals, and they were fired by a vision that the nation belonged to the people. And I think that's a key nationalist insight. It didn't belong to monarchs who thought their countries were their exclusive private property, and they shouldn't be controlled by empires.
with the capital someplace else and imposing its own culture and its own language on a nation. So the beginnings of nationalism were liberal. And I think true nationalism is based on that insight that the country belongs to the people and the government exists to serve the nation and the people, not the other way around, which is a vision absolutely contrary to fascism or any other sort of authoritarianism. In debate, oftentimes nationalism is seen as a direct contrast to globalism. And can you be both nationalist and globalist, or are they at odds with each other?
Yeah, so I think nationalism is opposed to cosmopolitanism or in tension with cosmopolitanism. A nationalist believes we belong in some deeply meaningful sense to a particular place in a particular polity. The cosmopolitan believes we're citizens of the world. And yes, we may reside someplace, but we don't have a deep affiliation with that place in particular, not bounded to it. We have this loyalty to humanity in general. So those things are in tension.
But I don't think they need to be mutually exclusive in the sense that if you're a nationalist, okay, that means you literally don't care what happens to anyone around the world. It means you never undertake any humanitarian initiatives that aren't directly in your interest. They're just going to help people if you have the ability to do that, that you're not going to form international alliances. That is extreme and simple-minded in my view. I think that the first step of immigration policy, foreign policy, is it in our interests. That's the most elementary.
nationalist question. And most people ask that. Most people do. But there is a radical cosmopolitan left that doesn't want to ask that question and believes our borders aren't really meaningful. And our foreign policy, if it's too aligned with our national interest, is nasty and small-minded. But push comes to shove, Alan. This is a tendency, this kind of cosmopolitanism. It has an outsized imprint on our culture and politics because so much of the elite is beholden to it. But it's still a very small percentage of actual Americans think that way.
And this was part of what made the Trump phenomenon so powerful is he said things in 2016 that struck a lot of the elite as completely outrageous and out of bounds. Not necessarily the insulting things that they said to people. I think some of those are outrageous and out of bounds. But things like borders matter. You have a country, you have to have a border. We're going to build a wall to protect ours. So the elite freaks out about that, whereas most people are like, yeah, that's common sense. And he was able to.
engaging in political arbitrage and that big gap between elite and ordinary people. And I think 80% of ordinary people may not realize it, they may not call themselves this, but are nationalists or have nationalist sentiments. It's this elite over top of them that's heavily cosmopolitan. In your book, The Case for Nationalism, you actually trace the concept of nationalism back to the Bible. You have a chapter called Ancient Israel Gave Us the Template of a Nation. And in that chapter, you have a subchapter, I guess. The Old Testament tells the story of a people and its land. Can you just give us an overview of the role that...
this concept of nationalism, of people in a country, develops in the Bible. Yeah, so this just to me just goes to how deep and powerful nationalism is. Now, you can't totally graft modern notions of nationhood onto the ancient world, but there are obviously key aspects of nationality are present. In the case of ancient Israel, there's a passage where God at one point basically sets out the borders of what will be Israel with the precision of a surveyor. So this just created a key template for.
nationalism and for a nation that is special and chosen. So whenever people started reading the Bible, especially in the vernacular, they got the idea, we're the new Israel. And there are different versions of this all around the world. France, it was like, we have the most Catholic king. So we're the new Israel. England was like, we're spreading liberty to the world. We're the new Israel. And obviously this was a hugely important idea in American history. And it's from the Bible where we get the idea of the covenant, which is...
a kind of bargain, right? And the Mayflower Compact is a covenant. The Constitution is a form of covenant. So that's a hugely important idea in our national identity that comes directly from the Bible. The idea that we're chosen people, or as Lincoln said, more modestly and appropriately, and almost chosen people directly from the Bible and from the Old Testament, and the idea that we're living in a promised land. Another key element of our national identity runs from the very beginning, also directly from the Bible. So I don't think you can underestimate the importance of the example of ancient Israel that came down to us.
In this country, especially the King James Version of the Bible. In the debate over immigration policy, there is a distinction made in most people's minds between legal immigration and, quote, illegal immigration. And you, again, in this chapter on the beginnings of this concept of a nation, you write about that the law is centrally important to Israel's nationhood. Can you explain to us the role of the law, the rule of law, in playing in the national debate?
Yeah, so the law is a key concept because, one, it's a... It's a function of a particular polity that adopts the laws. And it's one of the reasons that Israel endured, despite the fact that it was dispersed and the land was taken from Israel and the temple was destroyed. The idea of the law and the text that was read through thousands of years sustained this notion of nationality, even when there was no formal nation, even when there wasn't a place on the map. And it's really one of the near miracles of our time that thousands of years later, the Jewish people actually returned to their land. And I talk about this very moving episode in the book where the bones of some of the last rebels against the Roman Empire, these ancient fighters, were discovered by archaeologists in Israel in the 70s, and they were reburied with military honors just because there was this direct connection.
that had never been broken, despite all the miseries and disasters that had been fallen, the Jewish people since that time. So the law is something that provides a sense of national cohesion and coherence, as well as language. Language is also extremely important. And if you're a people and someone can come and govern you and wipe out your language, you're probably gonna stop being a people. And that's why I put such an important emphasis on the book.
on the English language in this country. It's just a key cultural glue, and we have to be extremely vigilant about any erosion of English as a dominant language. Again, I want to compliment you on this book because it is so... filled with information that has been put together by you that makes a very strong case for why nationalism is a good idea. So as you just mentioned, I knew the name Barkovba, who you just retold the story about recovering artifacts related to the law from Barkovba's time. And I knew the story of Joan of Arc, but you put these...
fantastic historical figures into this narrative that is so compelling. You do a great job on educating at least this reader and I'm sure everyone else will read this book emerging to do. But I'd like to just end our conversation by going back to how we started the conversation about the coronavirus and response to it. One of the things that disturbs me the most is that governors and mayors bestowed upon themselves powers that make them autocrats in terms of determining what millions and millions of Americans should or shouldn't be doing, from walking in an empty park would be illegal if you didn't have a face mask on, that type of stuff. And my concern is that If the rule of law is usurped or just ignored, democracies have got a huge, huge problem. Given the current conditions of these, again, governors and mayors running around like they have no one to answer to, but simply to dictate to, do you have any thoughts on that subject? Well, one, it kind of depends on the jurisdictions. And a lot of them have just very sweeping emergency powers in public health.
emergency. But clearly there have been woeful excesses. I mean, we've all seen the stories of people arrested. I think there's something I saw just last night about a woman in Texas being arrested and sentenced to seven days in jail for opening her nail salon or whatever it was. And there have been cases of people arrested in parks. But what's been most disturbing is the restrictions on religious services. And this is something where there's been pushback.
You had a drive-in religious service like two weeks ago or whatever it was. I forget exactly where it was. I'm fuzzy on everything, Alan. It was Tennessee or someplace. But the governor, you know, banned it. And the judge said, no, you know, this is a country with the First Amendment. And I thought one of the more stark moments in the public debate over all this was a week or two ago when Governor Murphy of New Jersey was on with Tucker Carlson. And Tucker asked him what is the word he has under the First Amendment to suspend religious services.
And the governor said, well, that's above my pay grade. Well, he's the governor of the state, right? Who's above him in the hierarchy of state? And this is the key thing about constitutionalism. It's not, we shouldn't be relying just on judges to enforce it. Everyone in the country should be suffused with a sense of how important the constitution is and do everything they can to honor its letter and its spirit, even if they're not getting slapped down by a federal judge somewhere. And we've had public officials around the country falling down on that basic task.
I agree. And I'm also very disturbed about the closing down of the churches and synagogues and places of worship of all sorts. And here in New York, two days before Easter, the mayor of New York actually got on the tube and threatened people and priests if they went to church on Easter Sunday. That's a no-no. You will get fined $1,000 if we catch you going to church or you could possibly end up in jail. Very disturbing. And anyway, we'll...
We will get out of this one as well. Rich, I want to thank you for taking the time and sharing your thoughts today. And I also want to once again urge people, whether you're for or against nationalism, read this book because it's not a knee-jerk book in a sense. Rich clearly did a lot of thinking and research, and it is quite an experience to read the book and learn from the book. So thank you again, Rich, and anytime you want to come back on our podcast, we'd love to have you.
Awesome. Thanks so much, John. I really enjoyed it. God bless and stay safe. God bless. Bye-bye. Thanks for listening to the Code Red Podcast. Be sure to click subscribe to stay up to date and be the first to hear about our future podcast. You can also find and subscribe to the Code Red Podcast on Podbean, Spotify, Google Play, and YouTube.