Convict. Confirm. Question.
from SHAREapy. The Podcast Hosted by Joel Barnes SHAREing
We are consuming more Christian content than probably any generation before us. Sermons. Clips. Podcasts. Reels. Devotionals. YouTube. TikTok theologians. Pastors we know. Pastors we’ve never met. People with microphones, platforms, Bible verses in their bios, and an opinion about almost everything. And I don’t necessarily think access to all of that is bad. There is some incredible teaching available to us. I’ve heard sermons online that have pushed me deeper into Scripture. I’ve listened to people explain biblical concepts in ways that helped something finally click. I’ve been challenged, encouraged, corrected and reminded of things that I desperately needed to hear. But access creates another problem: We have to learn how to filter what we’re hearing. Because “Christian content” and “something God is saying” are not automatically the same thing. And I’ve been trying to develop a simple framework for myself. Three words. Convict. Confirm. Question. Not because every message can perfectly fit into one of three little boxes. But because I need a way to slow myself down before I blindly receive something… or prematurely reject it. 1. CONVICT Sometimes I hear something and it exposes something in me. Not shame. Not manipulation. Not someone trying to scare me into submission. Conviction. There’s a difference. Jesus described the Holy Spirit as One who would “convict the world concerning sin and righteousness and judgment” (John 16:8). And Hebrews tells us that the Word of God is living and active, able to expose what is happening beneath the surface of our thoughts and intentions (Hebrews 4:12). So sometimes Scripture, or teaching rooted in Scripture, is supposed to make me uncomfortable. It is supposed to uncover something. Conviction sounds like: I need to bring this area of my life into alignment with God. Maybe somebody teaches about forgiveness and I immediately realize there’s a person I’ve been refusing to forgive. Maybe I hear a message about prayer and realize that I keep saying I want to hear from God, but I’ve barely created any space to listen. Maybe Scripture confronts the way I’m speaking to people. The way I’m spending. The way I’m serving. The way I’m loving my neighbor. Something inside me says: There’s more here for me. When that happens, I don’t want to run from conviction. I want to investigate it. I want to take it back to Scripture. God, is this You? What are You showing me? What needs to change? James puts it plainly: we are not supposed to merely hear the Word and walk away unchanged. We are called to do what it says (James 1:22). So whenever possible, I want conviction to become action. Because spiritual growth isn’t just hearing something that makes you say “ouch.” It’s allowing God to transform something. 2. CONFIRM But not every good sermon should leave you feeling like you’re failing. Sometimes the message confirms something God has already been developing in you. You hear someone describe a practice, an attitude or a way of loving people and realize: Wait. I’m actually doing that. And maybe instead of immediately searching for what’s wrong with you, you can receive the affirmation. Thank You, God. I see what You’ve been growing in me. Paul wrote about the Spirit Himself bearing witness with our spirit that we belong to God (Romans 8:16). And throughout Scripture, believers are encouraged not only through correction, but through reminders to continue faithfully in what God has already begun in them. Paul told the Philippians that he was confident that “he who began a good work in you will bring it to completion” (Philippians 1:6). Sometimes the message isn’t exposing rebellion. Sometimes it is illuminating fruit. Confirmation isn’t arrogance. It can be gratitude. It can also become stewardship. Maybe the thing being confirmed in you is something God now wants you to help cultivate in somebody else. Maybe you’ve learned how to pray consistently. Maybe you’ve learned how to sit with hurting people without immediately trying to fix them. Maybe God has taught you generosity. Maybe you’ve learned something about forgiveness, community, Scripture or trusting Him through uncertainty. Sometimes the message isn’t: “You need to start doing this.” Sometimes it’s: “Keep going.” And I think we need to learn to hear that too. 3. QUESTION This may be the most important category. Because sometimes I hear something and I don’t feel convicted. I don’t feel confirmed. I just think: Hold up. Something about that doesn’t sit right. And our culture has trained us to respond to that feeling in one of two extreme ways. Either: “Well, they’re a pastor, so they must know what they’re talking about.” Or: “I disagree with that one thing, so everything they’ve ever said is garbage.” Neither response requires much discernment. Scripture gives us another option. When Paul and Silas preached in Berea, the people there were praised because they “received the word with all eagerness, examining the Scriptures daily to see if these things were so” (Acts 17:11). That verse matters to me. They received eagerly. But they also examined carefully. Those two things lived together. They did not reject everything. They did not blindly accept everything. They checked. That is what I mean by: Question it. Not condemn it. Not automatically accept it. Question it. Paul gives similar instruction in 1 Thessalonians 5:21: “Test everything; hold fast what is good.” Not reject everything. Not hold fast to everything. Test everything. Then hold onto what is good. So: What does Scripture actually say? What is the context? What comes before that verse? What comes after it? Is the person describing what happened in Scripture, or prescribing what Christians should do? Is this consistent with the character of God revealed throughout Scripture? Is there another interpretation I haven’t considered? Have I misunderstood them? Have they misunderstood the text? Do I need wise counsel? Do I need to study? Do I simply need to say: “I don’t know yet.” There is tremendous spiritual maturity in those four words. STOP THROWING THE PASTOR OUT WITH THE BATHWATER This is where grace becomes important. We have an old saying: “Don’t throw the baby out with the bathwater.” The bathwater gets dirty. So you get rid of the dirty water. But you don’t throw away the baby. And I think sometimes we need to stop throwing the pastor out with the bathwater. That does not mean tolerating abuse. It does not mean ignoring manipulation. It does not mean remaining under spiritually dangerous leadership. And it absolutely does not mean pastors shouldn’t be accountable for what they teach. Scripture is actually very serious about teachers. James warns that teachers will be judged with greater strictness (James 3:1). So grace does not erase accountability. But accountability also does not require us to pretend that one error automatically invalidates every way God has ever used a person. There is a massive amount of territory between: “This person can do no wrong.” and “This person got something wrong, therefore God has never used them.” Pastors are human. Teachers are human. Christian communicators are human. They can genuinely love God and still misunderstand something. They can preach something powerful on Sunday and say something foolish on Tuesday. They can be gifted and still need correction. They can help you tremendously in one season and no longer be the voice you need in another. And… brace yourself… you may even continue receiving from somebody you disagree with sometimes. That requires maturity. Because discernment is not the ability to find someone you agree with 100 percent of the time. Discernment is developing the ability to recognize what is true. And Scripture actually expects us to develop that ability. Hebrews describes mature believers as people who have trained their powers of discernment through constant practice to distinguish good from evil (Hebrews 5:14). Discernment is not merely a feeling. It is something formed. Practiced. Strengthened. THE GOAL ISN’T BETTER CHRISTIAN CONTENT This entire conversation has become increasingly important to me becau… This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit wehavetoshare.substack.com/subscribe
Embed this episode
No transcript yet.