Entanglement and Minimalism 4
from The Lydia McGrew Podcast Hosted by Lydia McGrew Podcast
More on bad methods and false premises that underlie non-conservative scholars' acceptance of premises that the minimalist wants to use. It's assumed that if C. H. Dodd and/or Dale Allison accepts that the disciples had some kind of group experience, this must be something they are forced to by strong reasons. So maybe we can dig back down to those reasons and finally find something unentangled.But no. Dodd uses form criticism, an epistemically bankrupt method, to try to find "concise" snippets of "early tradition" embedded invisibly in the Gospels' otherwise made-up resurrection accounts. That he thinks some sort of group experience happened (tho' even the "concise" narratives contain, according to him, apologetic "expansions") is a result of his assumption that this method has objective value--a false premise that we shouldn't treat as legitimate.Similarly, Dale Allison uses a completely faulty notion of multiple attestation (really, multiple embellishment, to the point of unrecognizability) to conclude that the disciples had some kind of group experience. But he almost gleefully emphasizes that the changes are probably so radical that not much is left to be affirmed.For more on Habermas's misunderstandings of Dodd, see this series:https://lydiaswebpage.blogspot.com/2024/05/gary-habermass-misunderstandings-of-c-h.htmlFor more on misuses of multiple attestation, see these videos:https://youtu.be/I5fuHkEqOZ4https://youtu.be/EGVlEhtv0Zo
Embed this episode
No transcript yet.