Skip to content
The Lydia McGrew Podcast podcast artwork

The Lydia McGrew Podcast

by Lydia McGrew Podcast

The goal: To take common sense about the Bible and make it rigorous.I'm an analytic philosopher, specializing in theory of knowledge. I've published widely in both classical and formal epistemology. On this channel I'm applying my work in the theory of knowledge to the books of the Bible, especially the Gospels, and to apologetics, the defense of Christianity. My aim is to bring a combination of scholarly rigor and common sense to these topics, providing the skeptic with well-considered reasons to accept Christianity and the believer with well-argued ways to defend it.

From the show's RSS feed, refreshed Nov 10, 2026. Source feed.

Subscribe Bookmark

Episodes

  1. Lessons from suffering: The glory of God

    This unusual video gives a brief update on my chronic pain situation and lists three truths that I've become even more conscious of during the last 5 1/2 years.Here is the song I mention:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XyvFXplKEFwThumbnail photo istock purchased

  2. The Evidential Problem of Evil

    Why would a good God allow so much evil and suffering in the world? A common way to respond to this in philosophy of religion circles has been to appeal to what is known as "skeptical theism"--the idea that we have no way of knowing how much evil or suffering a good God would allow, because if…

    more
  3. The RIGHT way to use multiple attestation--illustrated

    After weeks of talking about the wrong way of trying to use multiple attestation after "giving away the farm" on Gospel reliability, this week I'm going to illustrate the right way to use multiple attestation concerning one of Jesus' alleged resurrection appearances.Hint: You start by assuming…

    more
  4. More on Bad and Good Multiple Attestation Claims

    Even when we have multiple accounts saying the same thing, each account must have *some* credibility for what it narrates. Conjoining multiple individually worthless accounts of an event does not magically create powerful testimonial evidence by mere multiplication. That point follows from the…

    more
  5. Entanglement and Minimalism 4

    More on bad methods and false premises that underlie non-conservative scholars' acceptance of premises that the minimalist wants to use. It's assumed that if C. H. Dodd and/or Dale Allison accepts that the disciples had some kind of group experience, this must be something they are forced to by...

  6. Entanglement and Minimalism 3

    Can the minimalist support the bodily resurrection by using the *reasons* that non-conservative scholars are relying on to conclude that the disciples had resurrection appearance experiences? Does this provide a fallback position for the minimalist idea that we can grant that the Gospels are...

  7. Entanglement and Minimalism 2

    Does it make it okay to use an acknowledgement of an "appearance fact" by a non-conservative scholar, even if he means something different by it than is needed for the argument, if we know that his different meaning is a result of his bias?Nope. Entanglement problems don't go away even if you…

    more
  8. Entanglement and Minimalism 1

    Why is it not illicit (per se) to use a premise that an opponent grants, even if he doesn't agree with your conclusion, but illicit for minimalists to say that a scholar grants that "the disciples had resurrection appearance experiences" when the scholar doesn't mean the same thing by the...

  9. An Undesigned Coincidence in 9/11 Testimonies

    Contrary to what I say at the very end, I decided to share this video on September 13 instead of the 20th, to put it closer to 9/11 itself.I will complete the miniseries on Kamil Gregor's naturalistic theory of the resurrection evidence next week.Are undesigned coincidences just (wave hands) some...

  10. Gregor's Weak Explanation 3

    Here I wrap up my discussion of Kamil Gregor's pareidolia explanation of the resurrection evidence.I first ask whether Gregor is fairly representing the claims of Christian scholars like Michael Licona and Craig Evans concerning Greco-Roman history. Unfortunately, his use of their claims is not…

    more
  11. Gregor's weak explanation 2

    Skeptics are fond of saying that they have an explanation of the evidence that does just a job as good as, the theory that Jesus rose again (or at least very close) but that has a higher prior probability than the resurrection.Here I argue that Kamil Gregor's pareidolia theory doesn't even come...

  12. Gregor's Weak Explanation 1

    I continue illustrating the fact that skeptics develop theories that they claim explain the evidence just as well as the resurrection, even though this can be easily seen to be untrue. They then run the priors, claiming that these explanations have a much higher prior probability than the...

  13. Running back to the priors 4: Evidence does not matter

    Here I point directly to Arif Ahmed's "run back to the priors" move. He very nearly admits that his "explanation" of the resurrection evidence doesn't do a very good job explaining, but then he says that however low the prior probability of a naturalistic hypothesis, the prior probability of the...

  14. Running back to the Prior 3: Arif Ahmed resuscitates the swoon theory

    There are two different ways to try to address a strong case for some hypothesis H, and they are not sharply distinct from one another. One way is by just saying that "somehow" we have this and this and this evidence but H is not true. Another is to make a stab at actually explaining a set of...

  15. Running back to the prior 2: Vagueness, laziness, and antisupernaturalism

    Skeptics tend to be far too quick to make two assumptions: 1) That it is easy to find a naturalistic alternative to any claimed miracle that does just as good a job as the miracle itself at explaining the evidence for it and 2) That the conjunction of "no miracle" with the evidence in question…

    more
  16. Running back to the prior 1: More on why a partition is important

    We turn technical again today with a discussion of why it's enlightening and useful to investigate the case for a historical claim using a full partition. Which explains the specific evidence better? "The claim is true" or "The claim is false"? This allows one to see if there is a "cost" to…

    more
  17. Unified Personalities as Evidence of Gospel Reliability

    This video was originally recorded with Women in Apologetics with the intention that it would be exclusive content for the fall apologetics conference. As announced briefly on Facebook, that session will not occur as planned. However, WIA was entirely willing to send me this video file, so I am…

    more
  18. Does it matter exactly what the voice said at Jesus' baptism? That depends

    Should you really care whether the voice of the Father at Jesus' baptism said, "You are my beloved son" or "This is my beloved son"? That depends entirely on what other baggage is being brought along with the answer to the question. If Matthew is "making" something public here that really only...

  19. Bad habits of New Testament Scholars: Over-complexity

    I got this book of essays by eminent Gospels scholar Harold Attridge on interlibrary loan and then couldn't remember why. So I decided to make a video about part of it--Attridge's insanely complex theory about layers of source elaboration in John 7. If you ever wondered why I list "preference for...

  20. Consensus, Bullying, and Social Pressure in Gospels Studies

    Is consensus in Gospels scholarship really diverse?The sad fact of the matter is that there is a great deal of social pressure not to be "too conservative," and even some Christian scholars engage in subtle and not-so-subtle pressure tactics against conclusions that are deemed overly…

    more
  21. The Paradox of Improbable Evidence

    It's strange, but it's true: Evidence that is *improbable* even given the hypothesis that it supports can provide as strong an argument as you could want in favor of that hypothesis. At the same time, such evidence, if we don't happen to have it, is resistant to being used in an argument from...

  22. Competing models of the Gospels: Why is the confirmation of details so helpful to reportage?

    Here I return to a point I discussed a couple of weeks ago, here:https://youtu.be/Xs4mRIzICKwThe historical reportage model and the fact-changing literary device model give quite different probabilities to finding details in the Gospels confirmed. The literary device model says that it was part…

    more
  23. When are details suspicious?

    Here I'm anticipating a possible criticism--namely, that no matter what the details are like or even could be like in the Gospels, I'm always going to say that they indicate truthfulness or at least don't constitute any evidence worth speaking of against truthfulness. I give three categories (and…

    more
  24. Independence and the case of Mr. Jones

    Today I'm taking a hypothetical police case in which a mother and daughter testify. Since they live together and haven't been kept separate before they testify, it seems like their testimony can't possibly be regarded as independent, right? And that lessens the force of their two testimonies for...

  25. What model of the Gospels is confirmed by undesigned coincidences?

    Anybody who is trying to study the Gospels honestly is trying to get a good model of what they are like. Those who think that the Gospel authors were writing in a genre in which they were licensed to change and fabricate even details are making non-deductive arguments for their own model. (And…

    more
  26. Unexplained allusions: The little ladder at Civitella

    It's important to remember that unexplained allusions are not just realistic details. In fact, they are awkward and puzzling and in that sense "unliterary." I illustrate this by reviewing the "dispute about purification" allusion in John 3 and then reading a passage from one of the widows of...

  27. Unnecessary details: The raincoat at Civitella

    Unnecessary details provide a commonsense clue to truthfulness. See how this works in the testimony of a witness to the horrific Civitella massacre, which took place in 1944. We also find unnecessary details in the Gospels. "The Witnesses of Civitella," translation of testimonies, found...

  28. A very very unnecessary detail: "She was Estonian"

    Two years ago I discussed Dirk Bogarde's visit to Bergen Belsen, his biographer's doubts, and the unexpected confirmation from an independent source. Go here to watch that. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zW1nLyn70ZE&t=922sI've been revisiting that topic recently in my research, and I was struck…

    more
  29. The grass is only sometimes greener!

    Have you heard this critique of the "green grass" undesigned coincidence between John 6:4 and Mark 6:39? Here's how it goes: "The green grass around the time of Passover doesn't help to confirm the reliability of John and Mark, because there are times other than Passover when the grass is green…

    more
  30. Bayes, Skeptics, and the Resurrection 9

    Here Than and I talk about two pieces of mathematical malpractice in Blais and Paulogia's video on Bayes' Theorem and the resurrection. Blais tried to give the impression that Than made a mistake by his in-principle argument that testimony can (in principle) overcome even a very low prior. Blais...

  31. Bayes, Skeptics, and the Resurrection 8

    Than and I get into the much-vaunted issue of the prior improbability of miracles. Is it really true that a miracle has such a low prior probability that no testimony can overcome it? Is it really true that one would have to throw out one's knowledge of science and the laws of nature in order to...

  32. Bayes, Skeptics, and the Resurrection 7

    Than and I continue our detailed rebuttal to Brian Blais and Paulogia, who claim to be telling us what Bayes' Theorem says about the resurrection.One topic is a set of truly dreadful items of evidence against the resurrection via arguments from silence. Here is Timothy McGrew's published paper on...

  33. Bayes, Skeptics, and the Resurrection 6

    Happy Easter, 2026!Here Than and I discuss three alternative "explanations" for the resurrection evidence which Brian Blais claims are just as good as the actual resurrection for explaining the data. These are Kamil Gregor's pareidolia suggestion:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1FWyZRnI4e8James...

  34. Bayes, Skeptics, and the Resurrection 5

    Than and I continue to discuss objections to the resurrection case. Here we talk about the technical question of whether Tim and I overestimated the Bayes factor (a mathematical expression meant to represent the force of the evidence) in favor of the resurrection in our 2009 resurrection article…

    more
  35. Bayes, Skeptics, and the Resurrection 4

    The first techy topic here: Why you need to use a partition when talking about Bayesian arguments in history.Here is an earlier video I did on this:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y7umQEVtbx4&t=2sThe next techy topic here: Independence! This is a big and important topic for the resurrection case....

  36. Bayes, Skeptics, and the Resurrection 3

    The topic here: The Bible tells me so jingleThan and I discuss the abuse of the jingle "The Bible Tells Me So" by skeptics to trash the legitimate historical use of material in the canonical documents.Why is it wrong to throw out data because we have it only in a single source/Here is Timothy...

  37. Bayes, Skeptics, and the Resurrection 2

    Than Christopoulos and I continue discussing the resurrection, the max data case, and skepticism. In this video our topic is the fact that Brian Blais and Paulogia simply dismissed all the evidence for the historical reportage model of the Gospels despite its relevance to the resurrection.Here is...

  38. Bayes, Skeptics, and the Resurrection 1

    Several months ago Than Christopoulos and I got together to record a *lot* of material on Bayes's Theorem and the Resurrection.Our intention was to respond to this video by Youtube skeptic Paulogia and physicist/statistician Brian Blais, which claims to tell you what Bayes *really* says about the...

  39. Authorship of John, Part 10: Hand waving about emphasis

    In this second-to-last video in my series on the authorship of the 4th Gospel, I discuss a collection of forceless arguments from such things as John's emphasis on Jerusalem, not having "enough" unique stories about Galilee, and not mentioning some people who aren't mentioned in the Synoptics.…

    more
  40. Authorship of John, Part 11: Who was at the Last Supper?

    In this last video of the series I turn to the question, "Who was at the Last Supper?" If only the twelve were present with Jesus, and if the author of the Gospel is the Beloved Disciple and was named "John," then he must be John bar Zebedee.Commentators have long emphasized the fact that it's a...

  41. Authorship of John, Part 9: Could the son of Zebedee have witnessed the Passion?

    Here I discuss a second much-used line of argument that the author of the 4th Gospel can't be John the son of Zebedee--namely, that Mark (and the other Synoptics) don't mention his presence at the cross. Richard Bauckham admits that this argument is used to claim that the entire idea that the...

  42. Authorship of John, Part 8: "Known to the high priest"

    Could the son of a Galilean fisherman have been "known to the high priest"? Sure, why not?!Here I argue against what is taken to be one of the strongest arguments against authorship of the Fourth Gospel by John the son of Zebedee. I argue that the argument is a combination of over-reading the...

  43. Authorship of John, Part 7: What's the point of a disambiguator that doesn't work?

    According to Richard Bauckham, the church father Irenaeus of Lyon believed that the author of the fourth Gospel was the Beloved Disciple but was not the son of Zebedee. Yet in his urgency to find some way to interpret Irenaeus's works as compatible with this view, Bauckham has robbed Irenaeus of...

  44. Authorship of John, Part 6: Irenaeus and "the apostle" who wrote the Gospel

    Does Irenaeus maintain a distinction between John the evangelist who wrote the fourth Gospel and John the son of Zebedee who led the early church with Peter in the first chapters of Acts? I argue that there is no reason at all to think that he distinguishes these and some reason to think that he…

    more
  45. Authorship of John, Part 5: Muratorian Canon

    Does the Muratorian Canon imply that John, the author of the Fourth Gospel, was not a member of the twelve? Here I reply to Richard Bauckham's strained argument to that effect.I briefly mention the "orthodox Johannophobia" thesis at the beginning of the video. Here is Charles Hill's (unfortuately...

  46. Authorship of John, Part 4: Irenaeus and Ptolemy the Gnostic

    Did Irenaeus, or a mid-second-century compiler, invent the authorship of John to help oppose Gnosticism? Nope. Turns out, the debate with the Gnostics was over the interpretation of John, not its authorship.

  47. Authorship of John, Part 3: Papias?

    Everybody who's interested in the authorship of John would like to know what the early church father Papias said about the subject. But alas! We have no unquestionable statement from Papias about who wrote John. Though probably he did say something explicit, this is another illustration of the…

    more
  48. Merry Christmas! The Word Was Made Flesh

    A blessed Christmas to all my listeners and viewers. Here we pause in discussing authorship for a Christmas reflection: The Word was made flesh, and dwelt among us. John's Gospel emphasizes truth because literal truth is, in John's view, inherently bound up with the Incarnation of God. The true...

  49. Authorship of John Part 2: Our Earliest Evidence

    Here I talk about the earliest evidence we have about the authorship of John. as it happens, the author isn't named as "John" in this evidence, but it is still very valuable. It's very important to remember that "the earliest evidence that has come down to us" isn't "the earliest evidence that…

    more
  50. Authorship of John Part 1: Introduction

    Today begins a series on the authorship of the Fourth Gospel. In this introduction I explore what one might mean by authorship and what assumptions you shouldn't make when hearing that someone affirms traditional authorship. And just how important is authorship, anyway?Get more content on the...

About this show

The goal: To take common sense about the Bible and make it rigorous.I'm an analytic philosopher, specializing in theory of knowledge. I've published widely in both classical and formal epistemology. On this channel I'm applying my work in the theory of knowledge to the books of the Bible, especially the Gospels, and to apologetics, the defense of Christianity. My aim is to bring a combination of scholarly rigor and common sense to these topics, providing the skeptic with well-considered reasons to accept Christianity and the believer with well-argued ways to defend it.

Hosted by

Lydia McGrew Podcast

Categories

Frequently asked questions

How many episodes does The Lydia McGrew Podcast have?

The Lydia McGrew Podcast has 106 episodes on PodParley. The most recent episode was published on November 15, 2026.

What is The Lydia McGrew Podcast about?

The goal: To take common sense about the Bible and make it rigorous.I'm an analytic philosopher, specializing in theory of knowledge. I've published widely in both classical and formal epistemology. On this channel I'm applying my work in the theory of knowledge to the books of the Bible,...

How often does The Lydia McGrew Podcast release new episodes?

The Lydia McGrew Podcast publishes weekly, based on its 106 episodes since November 2024.

Who hosts The Lydia McGrew Podcast?

The Lydia McGrew Podcast is created and hosted by Lydia McGrew Podcast.
Link copied