Episode 114: From Crime to Curse - The Amityville Story

Over the last seventy years, Ed and Lorraine Warren have become household names in the world of the paranormal. Lorraine, the clairvoyant who claimed she could sense things most of us couldn’t, and Ed, the self-taught demonologist who dedicated his life to uncovering evil in its purest form. Together, they investigated hundreds of hauntings across the United States. But one case stands out from the rest. Amityville. Before the Warrens ever set foot inside that Dutch Colonial home on Ocean Avenue, it was already stained by something horrific. In 1974, tragedy struck when twenty-three-year-old Ronald DeFeo Jr. claimed he came home from work to find his entire family murdered in their beds. Police rushed to the scene but quickly realized Ronald’s story didn’t add up. He wasn’t a survivor. He was the killer. And that kind of violence, it leaves something behind. When the next family, the Lutzes, moved in, they didn’t last long. They said the house was alive with something dark, something malevolent. Within just weeks, they fled in terror, never to return. What really happened inside 112 Ocean Avenue? Was it haunted by the evil that took root there or something far more human? This is a story that reminds us that evil is everywhere, always lurking, always waiting, even sometimes for decades.   SOURCES: A&E – Inside the Amityville Horror House and The Long Island Town Where It Still Stands Today – Sandra Westfall – October 14, 2025 - Inside the Amityville Horror House and Its Long Island Town People – What Happened to the Amityville House? All About the Infamous Home 50 Years After Murders and Alleged Paranormal Activity – Nicole Briese – October 14, 2025 - What Happened to the Amityville House? Inside the Home 51 Years After Murder Wikipedia – Ronald DeFeo, Jr. - Ronald DeFeo Jr. - Wikipedia Daily Mail – What happened to George and Kathy Lutz? The true story about the couple who fled the Amityville Horror House – Zac Campbell – February 2, 2024 - What happened to George and Kathy Lutz? The true story about the couple who fled the Amityville Horror house | Daily Mail Online People – What Happened to the Amityville House? All About the Infamous Home 50 Years After Murders and Alleged Paranormal Activity – Nicole Briese – October 14, 2025 - What Happened to the Amityville House? Inside the Home 51 Years After Murder Realtor – Inside Gruesome History of Real-Life ‘Amityville Horror’ Murder House – 50 Years After Mass Killings Shocked the Nation – Charlie Lankston – November 13, 2024 - Inside Gruesome History of Real-Life 'Amityville Horror' Murder House The Horror Collection – Inside the Infamous Amityville Haunting: What Really Happened? – Razvan Radu – October 21, 2025 - Inside the Infamous Amityville Haunting: What Really Happened? American Ghost Walks – The Amityville Horror, the Warrens, and the Conjuring: Fact vs. Fiction – Mike Huberty – July 31, 2025 - The Amityville Horror, The Warrens, and The Conjuring: Fact vs. Fiction Wikipedia – Amityville, New York - Amityville, New York - Wikipedia People – What were the Amityville Murders? Why Ronald DeFeo Jr. claimed his house told him to kill his parents and 4 siblings – Emily Blackwood – October 18, 2025 - What Were the Amityville Murders? Why Ronald DeFeo Jr. Killed His Family All That’s Interesting – The Horrific True Story of Ronald DeFeo Jr. and the Amityville Murders – Erin Kelly – August 7, 2022 - Amityville Murders: The True Story Of The Killings That Inspired The Movie