EPISODE · Sep 12, 2020 · 18 MIN
Eruvin 34: Accessing the Physical Eruv (Or Not)
from Talking Talmud · host Yardaena Osband & Anne Gordon
Do you really need to bring the eruv techumin to the place where you want to set up the eruv? (In the case where Shabbat follows yom tov) Perhaps the concept of the eruv is sufficient, without having a physical eruv set up. But the case of when yom tov falls *after* Shabbat is exactly one that poses a difficulty for that theoretical eruv approach - the theoretical has to be possible! Also, if you put an eruv deep in the ground, that makes sense if it's a private domain, which goes up to the sky, and deep into the earth. But what if the pit is in the public domain - where, then, is the temporary residence supposed to be? Above the pit - in which case the eruv is in the private domain of the pit? Or in the private domain deep in the pit - that's certainly the same domain. So the question hinges on a pit that's located in a karmelit, and where you want the residence to be above the pit. Plus: A case where the eruv is in a cupboard, and the key is lost... Is that eruv still valid? Is there another way to access the eruv?
What this episode covers
Do you really need to bring the eruv techumin to the place where you want to set up the eruv? (In the case where Shabbat follows yom tov) Perhaps the concept of the eruv is sufficient, without having a physical eruv set up. But the case of when yom tov falls *after* Shabbat is exactly one that poses a difficulty for that theoretical eruv approach - the theoretical has to be possible! Also, if you put an eruv deep in the ground, that makes sense if it's a private domain, which goes up to the sky, and deep into the earth. But what if the pit is in the public domain - where, then, is the temporary residence supposed to be? Above the pit - in which case the eruv is in the private domain of the pit? Or in the private domain deep in the pit - that's certainly the same domain. So the question hinges on a pit that's located in a karmelit, and where you want the residence to be above the pit. Plus: A case where the eruv is in a cupboard, and the key is lost... Is that eruv still valid? Is there another way to access the eruv?
NOW PLAYING
Eruvin 34: Accessing the Physical Eruv (Or Not)
No transcript for this episode yet
Similar Episodes
Jun 9, 2026 ·50m
Jun 1, 2026 ·31m
May 25, 2026 ·39m
May 17, 2026 ·37m
May 8, 2026 ·39m
Apr 28, 2026 ·25m