Skip to content
Establishing Clear Expectations and Consequences for Proactive Parenting - with Gary J. Edelstein episode artwork

Apr 24, 2025 32 min

Establishing Clear Expectations and Consequences for Proactive Parenting - with Gary J. Edelstein

from Divorce Dialogues Hosted by Katherine Miller

"Yelling is not a consequence. It's the avoidance of a consequence." - Gary Edelstein Gary Edelstein, a seasoned psychotherapist specializing in neuropsychology and family systems, is dedicated to advancing a collaborative co-parenting model. He underscores the importance of maintaining a unified front in parenting, particularly when children experience emotional, psychological, or neurodevelopmental challenges. Edelstein advocates for parents to establish consistent discipline rules across households' post-divorce, which he believes can prevent the polarization of parental perspectives and reduce conflict. By promoting collaboration based on neurocognitive principles, Edelstein aims to lower the emotional tone in households and support healthier relationships, ultimately benefiting the children's well-being. Key Takeaways ->Establishing a collaborative co-parenting relationship is crucial to prevent parental conflict and minimize the negative impact of divorce on children. ->Consistency in setting limits and discipline rules across both households is key to reducing disagreements and promoting a neutral authority for children. ->Parental conflict during divorce can intensify children's feelings of guilt and responsibility, making the divorce process even more difficult for them. ->Proactive parenting involves setting clear expectations, consequences, and rules in advance to address problematic behaviors without escalating emotional outbursts. ->Lowering the emotional tone in the household and implementing consequences for negative behaviors can aid in effective conflict management and strengthen family bonds. Connect with Gary J. Edelstein https://npiprofile.com/npi/1518003177 https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/therapists/gary-j-edelstein-brewster-ny/134476?msockid=3bb72f09a5256ac538a43db7a43c6be1 Connect with Katherine Miller: https://www.linkedin.com/in/kemiller1/ https://miller-law.com/

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Establishing Clear Expectations and Consequences for Proactive Parenting - with Gary J. Edelstein

0:00 32:37
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Welcome to Divorce Dialogues on Katherine Miller. DeWorse Dialogues brings expert guests to the airways chalk through your divorce questions and fill in the gray areas about separating. From thinking about divorce, to have a behavior in divorce, to what to do after, this is divorce Dialogues. Welcome to divorce Dialogues, I'm Katherine Miller.

I'm the founder of the Miller Law Group and a trainer at the Center for Understanding and Conflict, and I am on a mission to change how people divorce and how them divorce with dignity. My guest today is Gary Adelstein. He's a seasoned psychotherapist who specializes in neuropsychological developmental disorders. That's a mouthful, emotional regulation, and family systems.

With a deep commitment to helping families navigate conflict and build healthier relationships, Gary brings a unique blend of clinical expertise and neuro-cognitive insight to the challenges of parenting through divorce. Welcome, Gary Adelstein. It's such a pleasure to have you on the show. Thank you very much, nice to be here.

And since you work so much on helping families, family systems, sometimes people in divorce think, well, we're not a family anymore. I remember long ago, having a client, I had written some, I'd given them a folder with the Smith family, not their name, but the Smith family written on the outside and one of them crossed out of families that we're not a family anymore. But I think that's not true. I think that, and I really hate the term broken family.

To your kids, you're still family. And so you may not be husband and wife anymore or husband and husband or wife or whatever, whatever spouses, but you're still parents. So in the work that you do with families, Gary, what are some of the most common and behavioral challenges that are children? So this is still their family for, based during, through and after the divorce and how can parents help them with that?

Well, one of the things I tell parents when they ask about, what are they gonna say to their children about divorce? One of the things I recommend is to tell them that they will always be their children's parents and that commitment and devotion will exist forever. And I really think that. And when divorce does occur, it's really important to establish a collaborative co-parenting relationship, particularly where the children are experiencing emotional, psychological, and developmental issues.

Really, the core of what I work on with families is preventing the polarization of parental perspectives on the children's behavior and emotional issues. As those, as that polarization increases and concretizes, the level of conflict increases. In fact, with kids who have special needs, it's often a major source of the divorce or the conflicts that lead to the divorce. So I'm always working to heal that polarization and to create a formulation that's based on neurocognitive principles rather than evaluative principles that will sort of bind and allow for that collaboration.

All right, so break the down into English. Can you give an example of what polarizations look like and- The typical situation is that a child is manifesting certain behavioral problems like lack of compliance. They don't listen. They become emotionally dysregulated.

They have very violent, explosive temper tantrums. They refuse to go to school. So those are the problems that the parents are then addressing. The problem is that one parent may take one perspective on that.

Being that the child is just being a positional and defiant and characterizes it as negative behavior. The other parent may have a sense of the child's vulnerability and a sensitivity to that vulnerability. Now as those problems continue to develop, that polarized view continues to operate. And so that one parent is being very authoritarian, punitive and controlling while the other parent is tending to do the opposite, developing a more protective and enabling set of parenting behaviors.

Those clashing parenting behaviors become very confusing to the child and potentiate the erosion of parental authority, which makes those problems much worse. And so we really need to get those parents on the same page in terms of what is causing those problems and how to address them in a more emotionally neutral and sort of sensitive way. Yeah, I think you made reference to this earlier, Gary Adlstein, but I find that a lot of my clients come in to the beginning of the divorce process. And one of the big complaints is how to handle the children or problem with the children.

And they really have different views and both of them feel like they're right. And it's not only that they're right, but this is really important. Exactly. And they hold it so dear.

And they cannot seem to get on the same page because they're so convinced that they're right about it. And it matters a lot because it's about the children. And so how can parents, I also remember talking to an expert who did a lot of forensic evaluations and custody trials years ago. And he said to me that the conflict between the parents is the worst thing that can happen.

And it's better to make the wrong decision for the child and not have conflict about it than to keep fighting about it even if you're right. And I'm just wondering what you think about that and how people can help get on the same page right or wrong. Right or absolutely right. In fact, that polarization and that the feeling that one parent is doing the right thing and the other is doing the wrong thing, just raises the emotional stakes to very, very high levels and creates a real conflict that, as I say, often leads to divorce.

And in those situations, because the child is aware that their behavior is potentiating these parental conflicts, the feeling of guilt and responsibility for the divorce become intensified. And so it's already difficult for children to go through divorce. But if they feel they are the source of the conflict leading to the divorce, it becomes devastating. I would imagine exacerbates the underlying behavior in many cases as well, is that true?

No. So again, the approach that I take again is a neurocognitive, neurodevelopmental approach. Basically, it helps parents look at the problematic behaviors, not as behaviors. So this is a non-behavioral approach to behavior.

It basically looks at why is the child being oppositional? Why is the child not going to school? Why is the child having these temper tantrums? And what I do in the consultation with the parent and the child, and sometimes I do it with one parent in the room, because having both parents in the room will not be productive.

So I schedule separate meetings, but basically say the same thing, so that I'm working with each parent to create the collaborative parenting model. But I never bring them back into the same room because that would be too acrimonious and potentially explosive. So I begin by understanding, developing an individualized understanding of what's going on with the child. For example, when the issue is a lack of compliance or what clinicians call oppositional defiant disorder.

Can you give some examples of that just so people understand what you're talking about? So it's coming to bedtime, and the parents are exhausted. They want to put the kids to bed. They tell the child, go up and brush your teeth.

The child says, OK, I'll brush my teeth. Parents come back, they're not doing it. They prompt the child even more. The child says, I'll do it.

I'll do it. Parent leads comes back. Eventually, that will cause a tantrum, because the child is basically procrastinating and avoiding. Not so much because that's their preference, but because in their brains, the part of their brain that connects the intention to do something with the part of their brain that executes that intention are not communicating.

And so you get what we call an intention to activity gap, which is that I always say to parents, I've never met a child who you say, take out the garbage, and they say, OK, it's because the pathways in their brain are underdeveloped. And so that intention to activity gap becomes present in every direction that the parent gives. Now, where there are conditions like attention deficit disorder, that typical neurodevelopmental deficit will be magnified. And so you get a pattern of noncompliance.

As the parent views that as oppositional behavior, they treat it in a kind of authoritative punitive way. The child reacts to that harsh tone and things escalate. If we explain to them that there is this gap, and then they're able to develop strategies that are more consistent with facilitating that intention to activity access, rather than intensifying the conflict, which again creates a narrative that the child is oppositional, both for the parent and for the child. So the child starts to develop an identity, a self-narrative of being oppositional and defiant.

When the fact of the matter is, it's really just a glitch in the way their brains function. So intention to activity would be one example of taking a behavior and looking at the underlying neurodevelopmental substrate of that to understand what's going on. School of... I'm just going to remind people that I'm Catherine Miller, and that you're listening to Divorce Dialogues.

It's a podcast dedicated to educating people about divorce-related topics so that everyone can divorce with anything to the subscribe to the podcast, wherever you listen to podcasts, to be sure that you don't miss an episode and I'm talking today with Gary Edelstein about parenting through divorce. And right now, Gary, we're talking to us about the collaborative co-parenting model that you developed. So give us some more information about that. So again, as parents start to develop this understanding of the neurodevelopmental substrate of problematic behaviors, they can begin...

We can begin to develop strategies that work on enhancing the child's ability to overcome these deficits without adding a lot of negative express emotionality in the home. So yelling, screaming, really do not help. And the other thing we can begin to do is to introduce the idea of consequences for negative behavior or behaviors that fail to meet parental expectation. Oftentimes in these families, there's just so much emotional turmoil that there's a lot of yelling and screaming, but very little actual consequence and negative behavior.

And with the kids who have these emotional spikes, what parents often will tell me is that whenever they try to consequence their kids behavior, they get a negative spike, which basically trains the parents not to consequence behavior. So they do a lot of yelling and screaming, but I'll often talk to parents and say, when was the last time you provided your child with a consequence? And they say, you mean yell at them? I say, no, yelling at them.

And they think for a minute, and they say, I can't remember, because every time we try to do it, the kid goes off. So part of what I developed was a model of consequences that is developed to address these unique neurocognitive needs of these children, so that you're providing a consequence that is measured, but very, very consistent. So let me just interrupt you there one second, because I noticed that you're using the word consequence and not discipline. And so I just wanna highlight that, Gary, I'll see you and so that our listeners make sure that they highlight that too.

So could you just talk about that for a couple seconds? Yeah, I'm really glad you raised that. A consequence is basically a communication to a child of two things. One, I don't like what you did, and two, we're in charge.

Now, if you say that to some of these kids, they'll go off because they have real issues about authority and control. And so you have to develop the consequence as a message, as a communication of those two things. The analogy I often use is that, I live in a small town where the speed limit in the middle of the town is about 25 miles an hour, but people are speeding through and trying to get to work, so they're going 50, 55 miles an hour. Town gets very tired of that, so they put a police car around the curve.

And every time people speed, police car pulls them over. The officer says license, registration, rights a ticket, and says have a good day. That means that the officer is not yelling and screaming or spraying you with pepper spray. They're basically giving you a message that speeding is not tolerated here.

And if that police car is there all the time, people will eventually learn to slow down. So the consequence is like that. It's a measured formal statement of behavioral statement of authority. And so the consequence is essentially a delay that creates a space where the child can reflect on being impatient, but connecting that to what they've done.

And so the methodology I utilize is that first, parents identify what behavioral changes they want to see. Usually emotional regulation is the first area. So helping children not have tantrums. Usually a secondary is compliance, and maybe a third is respectful attitude.

But you can only work on one thing at a time. And so if you're working on emotional regulation, you're using your consequences just to reinforce and incentivize the child to regulate their behavior. So the first step is that the parents together, if possible, create the expectation, which is a statement, your emotional explosions are unacceptable. When they occur, there will, something will happen.

There will be a consequence. That's not a discussion. It's not litigation. It's a parental declaration.

Because what we're trying to do with these kids is reinforce or rebuild parental authority, which is often eroded by these emotional spikes. Second thing is that after the expectations are provided, the parents then have to work together to develop a menu of consequences that conform to this consequence model that are not punitive or excessive. But that can be given out consistently. Because what's going to change the child's behavior is not the intensity of the consequence.

It's the consistency of the consequence. Because what we're really trying to do is change the child's cost-benefit analysis of performing the negative behavior. We're basically incentivizing them to change their own behavior by creating enough of a consequence and expectation of consistency of consequence to change that behavior. Just like the police officer's presence is going to change the speeding behavior.

Third part is that this menu of consequence is given to both parents. So that once this is done, the parents never have to talk about this again. If the child, if the one parent sees a failure to meet expectation, they select from the menu that they created together. Or if the other one does, they do the same.

So that even if they're in two separate households, the crime is going to be the same, and the consequence is going to be the same. So that saves parents having to have these discussions about, oh, did he really do this? Is the punishment too severe? Because those kinds of conversations create much more parental conflict than it's necessary.

Absolutely. Let me just stop you there for one second, because I really do want to also highlight this, Gary. And that is that I think that when parents have joint legal custody, meaning that they've got joint decision making, right? And it's easy.

Oh, yeah, we can do that. We can choose their doctors together, where they go to school and all that sort of stuff. But I always push them a little bit. Well, what about discipline?

It's one parent says, ah, Beth Adjana, you're grounded this for three weeks. Does that mean granted in the other parent's household too? Because when you go back a few minutes in our interview here to a place where parents disagree about how to handle something, now you've got like, well, I'm going to go to a mom's house because I don't want to be, you know, I'm not grounded there. Or does mom think that grounding is really unfair?

So I think this is a great way of getting ahead of that for any kid, but definitely a child that deals with emotional issues, developmental issues, refusal issues, and that kind of thing. Because again, it's done proactively rather than reactively. I always tell the parents, sit down, have a cup of coffee, and work this out. Ahead of time.

Ahead of time. In the can as they say. So it's all done. And that promotes a more emotionally neutral and formal type of authority rather than the emotional authority that kids just develop, you know, apathy towards.

The louder parents get, the more kids turn down the volume. And yelling is not a consequence. It's the avoidance of a consequence. You're listening to the Divorce Dialogues Podcast.

And I'm Catherine Miller. Divorce Dialogues has been educating people about divorce relationship issues for over 10 years. Subscribe to the podcast. And don't forget to check out our previous episodes on the podcast website, divorcedialogues.com.

And I'm talking today with Gary Edelstein about parenting through divorce. And Gary, if people want to learn more about you, contact you, check out your website. How can they do that? The easiest is on my psychology today.

Well, they can contact me at gjedelstein at gmail.com to initiate contact. And the contact information will be in the show notes as well. So we've been talking about the collaborative co-parenting model. And I think what we're talking about really is limit setting and discipline rules across two households to create consistency and diminish conflict between divorcing and divorce parents.

So are there any other rules that you might have? I mean, you have a parent who thinks, no, we need to be compassionate. Understand where this kid is coming from. And we have another one.

And we have another one that's like, no, we need to just set limits. How do those parents come together to create this menu? Basically, when I'm consulting with them, again, either individually, if things are too acrimonious and explosive to have them together or individually. I basically go through this model.

And basically the model suggests that when our prefrontal cortex is our central process of the brain, when that prefrontal cortex is operating, we're able to be rational, think things out, plan, organize, and regulate our emotions. So the function of that prefrontal cortex, which I describe like a central processor of the brain, when that's in place how our emotion is stable and our behavior is rational. When the limbic system, the emotional centers of the brain, become highly active, the central process shuts down because the way the brain works is that when we're dealing with an emotional threat, we react to it, we don't think about it. So the way the brain is organized is that the as emotions rise and anxiety and threat increase our prefrontal cortex functioning diminishes.

In kids, we see the shutdown of the prefrontal cortex as the behavioral spike. So when we see kids who are in that situation, they look like they're being very emotional. And oftentimes, we try to get to the bottom of what the emotion is. But in fact, it's emotional dysregulation because the central processor has shut down.

And you'll see just intense emotionality, but not genuine emotion. So it's an emotional dysregulation. And oftentimes, parents will try to get to the bottom of what's going on during that spike. The problem is during that spike, auditory processing, which is one of the functions of the prefrontal cortex, is shut down.

So any verbal feedback is like an irritant to the central nervous system, which actually causes an intensification in the duration of the spike. So whenever I'm talking to parents about kids managing these crises, I say anything you say to your child, during this spike will add three minutes to the duration of the spike, simply because their child can process. And that's what you're seeing is an absence of processing. So as I provide information like that to parents, they become more aware and more confident in being able to manage these crisis situations without themselves becoming desperate and emotionally dysregulated as well.

So it promotes a pattern of, again, I call it more formal authority. The other thing that I instruct parents to do is you don't consequence during the spike. You delay consequences until the child's central processor has rebooted, and they can learn from the consequence. So the consequence is not a behavioral intervention.

It's not a reinforcement. It's an educational intervention that teaches the child that it's not in their best interest to engage in these negative behaviors. The key to this is that it has to be done enough times that those neural pathways, which are plastic in children, become redeveloped to facilitate children's emotional inhibition. You know, as I'm listening to your talk, I have five kids, and they're all adults now.

But what is this a walk-down memory lane? And as our grandchildren get to be born, I'm thinking, well, maybe we should just get them in touch with you a little bit ahead of time before that all happens, because that idea that you're in this yelling match with your kid and they're like, you're late for school. It's not making any difference at all. And the only thing that I can think about with my younger 22 now was I remember her saying to me, mama, I don't like it when you yell at me.

And I'm thinking, oh, okay, I get that. And then when she was yelling at me a few days later, weeks later, I said to her, you know, I don't like it when you yell at me either. And it was a real water-shed moment in our relationship. Like we were like, oh, neither one of us likes it when the other one yells at us.

One of the goals I always identify is lowering the decibel level. I always look at trying to identify specific markers of progress, you know? And lowering emotional tone in the house is definitely an issue. That really helped a lot.

We're getting close to the end of our time. But before we do, I'd like you to talk a little bit about couples in crisis. Like before they call me or someone like me, why do you think that couples can do to, well, what are some of the early indicators that they should seek intervention? Because I've spoken to a lot of marriage and family therapists over the year and they often say words to the effect of when people come in, it's usually too late.

And so when should they first fight? When should they first call someone like you? Really, the issue is this issue of polarization. So once it's identified, that's the earliest phase before it becomes more rigidified and concretized.

And one parent starts looking at the other parent as the enemy. That's where help in terms of developing more unified, scientifically based orientation to the problem is other issues include raising levels of hostility and verbal aggression, feelings of one parent undermining another parent's authority. Those are usually the issues that will drive the process toward divorce. But if they can be reversed and parents can become a collaborative team, they can often, that process of helping their child can actually help parents bond more effectively.

Okay, I was saying this has been a fascinating conversation. Thank you so much for being my guest and divorce dialogues, it's been really pleasure. Thank you very much for the opportunity.

A Spooky Action At A Distance David Masters Welcome to 'Spooky Action at a Distance,' a weekly podcast where we chart the mysterious spaces between the mundane and mystical. From ghostly tales to UFO narratives, music phenomena to divine conundrums, our exploration rooted in para-psychology challenges conventional wisdom, ignites thought-provoking dialogues, and illuminates the enigmatic threads of existence. Guided by seasoned hosts, we venture into the labyrinth of the extraordinary, investigating each peculiarity from varied perspectives. Tune in, open your mind, and join us on this captivating quest, traversing the spectral landscapes of the strange and supernatural. A Ground Zero Radio podcast Goldwater, Dubé TNKR Media Join lawyer and political commentator Anne-France Goldwater for the miniseries Love & Money by Goldwater, Dubé. Over the next few weeks, learn more about family law, divorce, youth protection, animal rights, the constitution and more from some of Quebec’s most experienced lawyers. Oliver Bardwell Podcast Oliver Bardwell Welcome to ”The Oliver Bardwell Podcast,” where insightful conversations converge. Join me, Oliver Bardwell, author, speaker, and seeker of wisdom, as I engage in thought-provoking dialogues that span spirituality, unity, and diverse perspectives. Delve into respectful discussions with legislators, doctors, education experts, and guests from every corner of life, as we explore a myriad of intriguing topics. From the heart of Iowa to the world, let’s embark on a journey of discovery and understanding together. Inception Dialogues Bernardo Kastrup Exploring the human imagination through conversations about art, myth, theology, psychology, true philosophy, and direct experience

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Divorce Dialogues?

This episode is 32 minutes long.

When was this Divorce Dialogues episode published?

This episode was published on April 24, 2025.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Divorce Dialogues episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.