Skip to content
Extra Viewing - ENT | Carbon Creek episode artwork

Jan 16, 2024 34 min

Extra Viewing - ENT | Carbon Creek

from Beam Me Up: A Star Trek Podcast

Did You Hear About This? This humorous pop culture podcast discusses the latest retro stories and pop culture news. Listen on: Apple Podcasts Spotify Support the show

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Extra Viewing - ENT | Carbon Creek

0:00 34:44

Chapters

  1. 19:58 [Ad] Did You Hear About This?
  2. 20:36 (Cont.) Extra Viewing - ENT | Carbon Creek
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hey everybody, this is Brent from Beam Me Up Star Trek podcast. As you may know, Matt and I have finished recording the main run of the show. However, over the course of our three and a half years of recording the show, we actually recorded several episodes that to this point have either gone unaired or they were exclusive to our Patreon page. Well, now that we're on the backside of the main show, we thought that it would be a great time to release those episodes to you guys out there, our listening audience. Plus, you never know when Matt and I may jump in with a random new episode. The final frontier begins. This is about saving the future of humanity. This is a huge victory for the good guys.

You've never seen Voyager. Commitment to this course of action is not emotional. Welcome to another episode of Beam Me Up, a Star Trek podcast. But it is that time again where we say not just any episode. This is our special Patreon exclusive extra viewing. You guys know me. I'm Brent. And I'm Matt. And if you guys are listening to this, we owe you a huge thanks, specifically to Eric, who was our first patron and has been with us this great long while. And everyone else who has joined along the way, some of you a little newer, some of you almost as long as Eric, although Eric was the guy for quite a while from the beginning of the show. But with Kristen, Alexandra, Corey, Yana, Sam, Carl, Eric, anyone else in the future? You guys are awesome. Thank you so much for supporting the show.

We hope you guys are enjoying your extra viewings. You're enjoying your extra early releases and whatever else. And Eric got to recently be on a charting the course with us. Actually, not recently. That'd been a long time ago by the time people were hearing this. But anyway, it doesn't matter. Guys, thanks. I'm not even editing that out because this is a patron. You guys love us.

You love us. Today's extra viewing is season two of Enterprise called Carbon Creek. Now, in this episode, T'Pol tells the story of her great grandmother who crash landed on Earth back in 1950 and had to survive with two of her shipmates for quite some time before finally being quote unquote rescued. But did it really happen or was it just a story? Now, Matt, you picked this episode out of all the ones that you picked. You went, we're past this in our recording. We're recording season four, but you want to go all the way back to season two. And you picked the second episode of season two. Why this one? Why now? I mean, we've talked about many, many times. I like origin stories and stuff like that. And we've talked about how Enterprise is really good about putting the pieces together.

and filling gaps and that sort of thing. And that's kind of what this sounded like to me. It sounded like we're going to kind of complete some more history or almost alternate history at this point, I guess. But it was a piece that was going to tie together things that we knew about in a sense. Now, I will say it definitely didn't play out quite as I had imagined, partly because I thought, this is probably just my faulty memory.

But going into this, I was thinking you had told me like T'Pol and somebody else, maybe Archer or something, like time traveled back. And it wasn't just like a memory or a story. Right. Like they were actually there and had to blend in and do their thing. But I guess that wouldn't quite make sense with the whole first contact thing either to have non-Valcans there. Right. But yeah, it's interesting for sure. All right. Well, we are definitely going to dive into everything having to do with this episode and your experience of this episode. Let me ask you, what did you think of it? Your first time watching it? I enjoyed it. I always enjoy these episodes where we get an alien trying to figure out a new culture. Sure.

a lot of times we see the humans trying to figure out other alien cultures, but I think I appreciate a little bit more when it's the writers give us other, the alien cultures trying to figure out humans, right. And kind of breaking things down and getting a chance to say how silly and how stupid is this part of our culture? And how, how does this look to an outsider? Like just like little things like listening to baseball on the radio and Tamir is like, Oh, that's be some kind of combat. Not quite, not quite, but okay. Yeah. See where you're coming from when you're just getting the audio of it and little things like that. That's just like, how are things perceived by others? Right. And it's, it's more, it can be more fun when,

they're perceiving what I know as part of my life, part of my culture. It's like, how is that perceived by others? If you, if you, if you get a chance, you just kind of get a one-off, you got an hour to kill or something. There's an episode in Voyager called 1159. And that's like the time on a clock, 1159. And that is, it's the same sort of structure as this episode. The crew of Voyager sitting around Janeway's ready room, or maybe it's not even the crew. It might just be like Tuvok and Janeway or Chakotay and Janeway or something like that, or just seven. I don't, I don't know who all's there, but she's telling the story of her great, great grandmother or one of her ancestors from 1999 as it's turning into the millennium. And if you remember.

you know, uh, Voyager was there when the clock turned over to the year 2000 and the whole Y2K thing was a big deal. So turning into the millennium was a, was a thing, you know, that was really important and very topical, but they, they went back and obviously Kate Mulgrew played her own ancestor and things like that. So, uh, that's in, that episode is a lot like this one for me, um, where this is an episode that a lot of people are very high on. A lot of people really like this episode. Personally, I think it's good. Like it's just, it's good. It's a fine episode. Um, I don't find it, it's, it's not exciting. It's not that kind of an episode. Uh, I know. And by the end of it, I, I kind of found myself saying like, okay, this is starting to drag a little bit. Yeah. Like the,

pacing wasn't quite there thing things did take a little bit longer than i wanted them to but i think they just didn't have more story to tell like it's yeah they had their story and they had to fill the time so yeah and let's face it it's not the most exciting this this is an episode that should be rife with comedy to be honest with you like put these guys back it's fish out of water vulcans just don't do comedy very well they really don't well yeah and i think that that's the thing it's like those are our main characters to Vulcans and one of them we just met. And well, I'm technically, I guess both of them, all three of them we just met. Right. I keep, you know, obviously I keep thinking the one is to Paul, but I mean, it is, but it isn't. And yeah, but she doesn't feel new in that sense then. Right. And so it's like, you're right. Vulcans, comedy, don't mix. If you get, if it would be able to, that's where I think if we would have been able to time travel back there and you did have like Trip and Archer actually in the scenario, that would have been a lot more humorous. Right.

So with that, though, I found the character of Tamir, which played by T'Pol or the actress. Anyway, I found her incredibly obnoxious. Like, and I got to tell you, I find after watching this episode and not just this episode, but I think after doing this podcast with you for the last couple of years, Matt, my big takeaway from this whole thing is Vulcans suck. I don't like Vulcans. I don't, I really don't think I like them as a people group, like at all. Yeah. I'd much rather hang out with the Endorians. Maybe even the Tellarites once you meet them, maybe the Tellarites, but the Endorians would be far more my people. Like if I'm Archer, you know, like I want to rock with those guys for sure. But I just, I mean, just with the bit.

we've covered i mean yeah they're always kind of plain boring quote unquote logical yeah but then i mean yeah you don't really get anything else out of them because they're trying to suppress their emotions and so any fun emotions you don't get those either right like it almost feels like the only emotions they ever let out are the bad ones like so yeah they're they're not necessarily the most fun people to hang around So with that, Matt, I want to pick on the Vulcans just a little bit more before handing it off to you. Now, for people who've been listening to this podcast for quite a while, and I've told you this since the very beginning, that I've posited this whole theory about the Vulcans say that they're really suppressing their emotion. They don't do emotion. They don't do emotion. But actually, everything they do is incredibly emotional, like everything. OK, I'm not going to harp on that one in this episode, although it stands this entire episode. I want to pick up on another Vulcan falsehood, something that they continue to tell themselves and tell other people. And it's just not true. You want to know what that is, Matt? What's that? Vulcans don't lie. Bull poop and caca. Vulcans are liars. Dirty, dirty.

little liars all the way through. If you could tell they're lying because their mouth is moving, liar, liar, liar, pants on fire, Vulcans. These guys lie all the time. And we see them lying in this episode. I can think of several instances of Tuvok lying. I can even think of Spock lying. And the whole time they go, well, I'm not really lying because, and then they explain it away and they kind of give you a little wink and a nod. No, no, no, you're lying. So anyway, I'm going to throw that one on the piles too. They're a big bunch of dirty liars, those Vulcans are. I mean, the one thing I will say I've noticed throughout Enterprise so far is that since we have more consistent contact with Vulcans, they seem to be bringing that, the emotion thing to the forefront.

And I think maybe it's just the writers trying to address it a little bit more and say like, like they, it's not that they don't have emotions that they're trying to suppress them and not all Vulcans are the same and some people handle it differently. And, and we are emotional, but like up until this point, like, like anytime before enterprise, I feel it's always kind of been stated like Vulcans lack emotion throughout enterprise though. It feels more like it's always been Vulcans suppress emotion. And so that seems to be almost be rewriting it. And just kind of like some Vulcans are better at suppressing it than others. And so you get these different levels. And so when emotions do slip out, it's not that they're breaking anything, breaking canon or anything like that. It's just this is what it is. Yeah. And to be fair to the writers of Star Trek, I want to push back on you just a little bit with the idea that they're rewriting it. This is how it's always been since the days of Spock. They are emotional. They've just learned to suppress it. But the other side of it is there's this thing called the Vulcan Rite of Kolonar, which is something Spock didn't even try to do to one of the movies. And Tuvok has done it. I think T'Pol has gone through it. Most elderly Vulcans have gone through it. But it is the Vulcan Rite. It's like a rite of passage where they purr.

purge emotion. And that's what they say. They're no longer even suppressing it because they have purged all emotion. And I don't even think that's true. I could be wrong, but like, isn't the idea like, I mean, almost like a cleanse, right? Like if you go through a cleanse, like it knocks out all the bad stuff all at once, but it's going to slowly build up again.

I don't disagree with you, Matt. The Vulcans deny it, though, but I don't disagree with you. Yeah, but that's how I've always pictured it. It's like, yeah, you go through this purge and yeah, you knock everything out at once, but it's not gone for good. It's going to slowly creep back in. But yeah, I just think like the writers are doing a better job of explaining it now in Enterprise. Yeah, well, think about it. We really haven't spent a ton of time, even though we had Duvok, we haven't spent a ton of time with Vulcans at large ever, because even though T'Pol is the main one, like we had Spock and we had Tuvok and now we have T'Pol. What we didn't have in the rest of those was the constant Ambassador Soval and the like.

you know, where they were in the high command. Exactly. Like we didn't, we didn't go through this as nearly as often in TOS with Spock or Voyager with Tuvok. Like as much constant contact with other Vulcans and the culture and everything like that where, yeah. there were constantly talking about Vulcans, whereas yes, they were a member of the crew, you know, Spock and Tuvok are members of the crew, but we might only focus on them once or twice a season. Yeah. And I would, and I would, I would say it is very, very fair to say that they explore Vulcan culture more in enterprise than they do in all of the other shows put together. And that includes TOS with Spock. I mean, I think it makes sense though. Sure it does. Cause they have the time to do it right. And the people. Yeah. I mean, well that, that's kind of just the time period we're in with enterprise. It's like, we don't know anybody else. We don't know any other alien culture. So who are we going to, you know, it's either.

other humans or the Vulcans right I mean now we're slowly moving into the Andorians we get a little bit more of them and well they did a whole season three on Zindi, I guess. But yeah, I mean, we're not running into a new alien species every week. There you go. There you go. All right, Matt. Well, why don't you take us through this episode? You say you liked it. You got your notes. Talk us through it. What'd you, what'd you see? What'd you experience as you went through this episode? Carbon Creek. I'll turn it over to you. I'm really, I'm really trying not to comment on this every week, but so now we've gone back in time a little bit from where we were in season three, season four, we've gone back to season two and we get our intro. They're talking about Carbon Creek and Paul's like, would you like to hear the story? And then it goes into the old version of the theme song, this nice folksy tune. And I'm like, perfect. They did it. They finally lined it up.

Like that intro song went with that opening. Like it worked. Right. If only they could do that every week. But I mean, that was like, you know, tell me a story. It wasn't like pew, pew, pew, pew, pew, folk song or anything like that. Like this one actually worked. Oh, man. Anyway, I maybe should have taken a hint from the beginning when Paul was like, would you like to hear the story? Like I was kind of shocked when we got to the end of this and she tried to play it off as, yeah, maybe it didn't happen. Fine. You don't want to believe me. It didn't happen. Like, I don't know where you're at.

But she goes back to her room and unwraps the purse, right? That was the purse that her great great grandmother or whatever was using back in Carbon Creek, right? Because that's what we're led to believe. So theoretically, like how else would she have that if it didn't happen? The ending shot implies that, yes, it absolutely happened, you know, but she didn't press it. She allowed she lied to the captain and to trip by a mission. It was a lie of a mission. She just stayed silent, allowed them to believe whatever they wanted to believe. And she led them to that. She led them to that conclusion, even though she might not have actually said she did. She's a dirty, rotten liar. Like all Vulcan. Yeah, like she didn't correct him. But.

She just kind of let them believe what they want to believe. Just like her great-grandmama. But yeah, so Vulcans apparently crash-landed on Earth when they're out here investigating Sputnik. But I appreciated that, like, oh no, two life forms are coming and it's two deer trotting through the forest. I'm like, so your first contact was actually with two deer. Interesting. And it crossed my mind briefly that I almost wish this would have been handled a little bit differently. Like, I don't know how much information they have on Earth and Earthlings at this point. Like, how are they to know that the deer aren't the main inhabitants of this planet? And how do they know that?

those deer aren't extremely intelligent. Maybe the deer can talk here. Well, yeah, I think the, we have heard before and it is, I think it is certainly implied that the Vulcans have known of earth and they've been keeping tabs on earth from an observational standpoint. And that's why they knew about Sputnik one. That's kind of what I figured. Yeah. Cause I mean, then shortly after that, there's like, well, there's this settlement over here. It still seems weird to call it a settlement. I'm like, that is a full blown city. What are you talking about?

Right now, I would I would also argue that despite this occurrence happening and let's just take it for face value that it did happen. And despite what Trip and Archer said at the end of we've rewritten our history books, this was not a first contact between the Vulcans and the humans. Like first contact is an official like where we know who everybody is. We're revealing our existence to everybody and we're meeting. I was going to say like that's something that I questioned then, too, because like the other day you texted me something like happy first contact day or something. And I'm like.

So then I had that in the back of my head when I was watching this episode. Yeah. Like, wait, which which day was it? Like, I don't remember. And like, I don't have that kind of date system in my head yet. But just for the record, it was not the other day. It was months and months ago back in April. Sure. The fact I remember that. Yes. So I'm like, but I'm sitting there thinking like, OK, did they actually rewrite history? And this is the date people celebrate or. But you're right. Like they never revealed themselves as Vulcans and aliens. Yeah. No. First contact day is the day that is depicted in the movie. First contact when Vulcans and humans first met each other officially.

That would make more sense. I'm always amazed. And I mean, I guess it was maybe the right time period that it would work. But in movies, when they go to foreign land, like, oh, we need to blend in. So we need to dress like people. That's just go grab some clothes off the clothesline. First of all, it's good you're in a place where they still use clotheslines and hang their clothes out to dry. Right. Second, to have clothes that fit you. Like, that's a whole other thing.

But like to be able to just walk into someone's yard, steal their clothes and no one noticed. Like this has always seemed weird to me. Right. But they do it over and over and over again on TV. And they tried comedy during the scene when Tamir put the dress on backwards. Right. Right. It just didn't work. Just didn't work. They went for it, but it just, you know. They tried. Yeah. But as soon as they had the conversation about like, you know, don't talk to anyone. And if we need to talk, like, let me do the talking. Like, first of all, I started wondering like, okay, wait, what time period are we in? Are we going to be in, you know, an older time period where, you know, the women don't do the talking. And so that's going to be a problem when she tries to do the talking.

But I just knew when they made a comment like that, too, it's like, how are you going to get away without talking? You're not. And then the first thing to do is go into a bar and like, you're not going to be able to go into a bar. Like the first thing they're going to ask you is, what do you want to drink? You can't get away with not talking. It's just a bad plan overall, I feel. And as I mentioned before, like the pacing of this and the way that they just need to fill time was made very evident early on here to me when they go into this pool game.

This has to be the most dramatic game of pool I've ever seen. The music, the camera angles they used, like, man, they really tried to ham it up. And it's just like, I'm sorry, it's not that tense. It's not. You're just stretching this for all it's worth. We'll be right back.

Oh, wow, man. Hey, if you recognize those sounds, then you're probably somebody who would like our show. We are called Did You Hear About This? And we talk about all kinds of news stories. It's like the 80s and 90s stuff that we grew up on. Yeah, this isn't stuff that's getting covered on the 10 o'clock news. I'll tell you that. You can check us out at didyouhearaboutthis.show. We're on every single podcast platform. Go find us. I feel like, Matt, you're almost talking yourself out of liking this episode.

Yep. We're getting there. We're getting there. It's getting worse and worse. Everything you say is like, man, this was just boring and it was slow and they were just extending everything. And then I just realized too, like stupid. And I think I had potential in that. Like I had hoped for a lot of things like Jack, the kid, right? Right. And they kept just, you know, calling him Jack, Jack, Jack. I'm like, hey, do I know any Jacks? Or, you know, what's the nickname for Jack or something like that? Like, who could this be? Give me a last name. Who is this kid going to grow up to be or be the great, great grandfather of? Zephyr Cochran. He should, you know, go to university. Tamir goes, gives him the money and puts him on. And by the way.

What's your last name? Oh, it's Cochran. Yeah. And he's the great grandfather of Cochran. Like, that's how that should, like, it was right there for the thing. I'm totally with you.

When she went off to the city or whatever to do something, which, okay, sold him Velcro, really? The patent on Velcro. I mean, it worked for Men in Black. Yeah, yeah. Hey, a little note on that, though, just so you know. The character of Mastral, Vulcan, who's kind of a rebel, gets his name from a guy in real life named George de Mastral, a French dude. Do you know what de Mastral was famous for? Nope. He's the real guy who invented Velcro. Okay. So I'll give him a little hat tip, a little head nod there. Fair enough. Good on them. They did something right, I guess. But yeah, when she went off to do that, I totally understood. Okay, she's going to interfere. She's going to do something.

And I knew it had to do with Jack. And yeah, I thought when she walked into the office, like she was going to sign the kid up and that was when we were going to learn his last name. Like I was totally with you there. Like I hadn't picked out a last name yet, but yeah, Cochran would have made most sense. But yeah, like that never happened. It was just a random kid, just a random bartender. I mean, that's what I'm saying. I think that this had so much more potential and that's why I was so high on it to begin with. But now I'm seeing like none of what I wanted to happen actually happened. And I don't know. I don't know how I feel about this now.

I'm trying to look it up to see if Jack had like a name in the in the script or something that they just didn't say. Yeah. Or maybe I missed it. And he did not. He's just known as Jack. Just Jack. How about his mother? His mother's Maggie. Is it just Maggie? Yep. It's just Maggie. By the way, Maggie, this isn't quite a spotlight, but I'll say her. The actress's name is Anne Cusack or Cusack. She is the sister to John and Joan Cusack. OK. She's of that family. Love John. Hate Joan. OK. We saw it. By the way, we saw Anne in A League of Her Own. A League of Their Own. She was one of the peaches. She's one of the peaches in that movie. I don't know that I've actually seen that movie. You should watch that movie. It's really good. I should. I watch.

it not too long ago with my son. It holds up really well. Of course, there's not really any CG or special effects or anything like that in the film, but it just holds up really, really well. Okay. So go for it. Anyway, I'm 100% all in with you on Jack. He should have been Cochran or even make him a Kirk or just any Star Trek name we know. Any name could get it. Even give me like.

uh i mean this would be a little absurd but like forest right since we're in admiral forest yes yeah yeah just some admiral that comes up once in a while yeah like maybe not that one because he's he's right there that'd be a little bit on the nose i think but um like anything anything with the federation he could have been archer jack archer i i did consider that at one point yeah but like for to paul to hang on to that information after working with archer for a year now like working with him directly like that's just mean at that point, I think. But then again, we're talking about the Vulcan, so who knows? And the more I think about it, the whole thing with Mistral, I didn't have a big problem with him in the first half of the episode, I guess, but when there's an accident in the mine, he's like, yeah, we got to use our weapons to get him out of there. And they do it successfully.

do kind of stealthily. But then, you know, Tripp and Archer keep asking my questions, right? Well, didn't anybody notice? Didn't anybody ask how they got out? Didn't anybody wonder? It's like, yeah, maybe they did, but then we left. Okay. Three months later, like, seriously? Nobody cared how it happened? Like, come on. Come on. That's a bit of a stretch there. And then like, Mistral stayed there for 100, 150, 200 years and theoretically lived out the rest of his life and nobody caught wind of him. Like, just wear a hat for 200 years? It's, I mean, the more I think about it, the more I don't like it. And you're right. I'm talking myself out of liking this episode.

Right. Like I, as a whole, I think I still, you know, enjoyed watching it, but I, I kind of wonder if it was the anticipation of the unknown and what could have been. Sure. And now upon further reflection, it's like, yeah, I think they missed out on so many things they could have done to, to that. I don't think would have like, wouldn't have, wouldn't have hurt the timeline. It wouldn't have, uh, what was the phrase they kept using? Contaminate their culture. Yeah. Right. There's, there's still things they could have done. And it's for how much they talked about not contaminating the culture and how much we in Star Trek talk about, you know, non, non-interference, especially the Vulcans, like,

they interfered a lot. I mean, a little bit of it kind of out of necessity to keep themselves alive, to keep themselves fed and stuff like that. They did have to interact with people, but they kept going beyond, you know, Mistral had his thing with Maggie. And then obviously Tamir had some sort of relationship with Jack. Cause like, it wasn't just, she decided to pay for his college. It was Jack got wind that she was leaving and came to see her. Right. So obviously there was some connection there. Like they weren't just staying on the fringe of society as much as they could. They could have been a lot more hermit like, but they got involved. Cause I mean, honestly, if they, if they needed money, why didn't she just sell the Velcro right away? Well, because again, that would be.

contaminating culture, right? You're giving them, you're giving them a technology that they haven't invented yet or that they're not ready for. But I think at the same time, like she kind of goes back and goes, okay, this is going to be fine. It'll help. I mean, honestly, you think about it, like the invention of Velcro changed so much, you know, like whoever owns that patent.

Or whatever. Oh yeah. Yeah. I think that's part of the reason why it's used all the time. Cause it was such a big deal, but of course I'll say this too. Like she kind of left him to figure it out. It's cool to look at it and see. So how do you make it? How do you make all those little teeny tiny loops? And then all those little hooks that will grab it instantly, but then we'll pull apart and not break and can just infinitely be used again and again and again and again and again and again. How do you make it? I mean, that's a real key, right? Right. How stuff's made was not yet on TV. And now I really want to know, how do you make Velcro? Like, can you make it without a machine? Probably not. Well, you have to imagine the first like prototypes are probably handmade.

to some extent. That's exactly what I'm saying, right? It may not have been quite as effective, but I think that was their other attempt at comedy, though, too, was the businessman playing with the Velcro and just being so amused by it. And honestly, he used it. He did it better than she did, you know? Yeah. I don't know, man. I'm finding less and less to like about this episode.

I'm sorry to kill this episode for you, Matt. It's no, here's the thing. Okay. Let's, this is a good episode. Yeah. But you know, I go back to my original statement. It's, it's not one that I love. Like it, it, it might be one of those. You just can't examine it too much. Yep. You know, cause I think so. Honestly, like I loved watching Mastral. Here's something I liked about it. Watching Mastral kind of buck Vulcan culture and all Vulcan expectations and get into her. Like his awkwardness with Maggie was so delightful. And I just wanted it to be a little bit more awkward as well. Like when she kissed him and he's just like, uh, and she like freaks out on him, you know? Um, and his flirting, like, like I would, I just want.

I wanted him to love earth. You're not from Mars. Are you right? And he just looks at her and she takes offense. Like I could, I could watch a spinoff of mistral on earth. Like that would be, I could, I could, that's a sitcom. That's the followup episode you want is give me that a hundred years of mistral on earth, right? Him and Maggie get married. And you know, it's, it's, I dream of Jeannie only except Jeannie's a Vulcan or bewitched or it's that show, right? Just mistral and Maggie. And it, and I, that's all I want. I want a half hour comedy, you know, sitcom. That's what that show should be. Yeah. I, and like of all the things I questioned, like why?

you're always wearing the hat and like they always deal with like the ears but what about their eyebrows like especially when the two of them were sitting in the car just staring at each other i'm like we get a close-up of his face a lot and i'm like why aren't you questioning that right especially like in this time period like if someone was walking around with eyebrows like that today i wouldn't question a thing but back in like the 50s or whatever like that's not normal but yes i you're coming up with great great spin-off sitcom ideas like that fanfic writers get on it let's go i was gonna say that there's plenty of new trek out there right now but they have plenty of options left Uh-huh. I'm pitching the show. I am. I am. I want to sit down. I'm going to call up Aaron. Aaron Wolke and the Hageman brothers. Guys, I got it. I got the show. There you go. I got it. Matt, did you catch the head nod to I Love Lucy in this episode? He did mention I Love Lucy's on tonight. He did. And you remember why that's significant and why it's a little hat tip? Yeah. Lucille Ball was the original push for this. Yeah. She put Star Trek on TV. The other note that I had out of this is Archer, you know, they mentioned at the end, you know, Archer's like, you could live to 100, 150 years and Topal goes 200. If that's the case, Mastral could have been alive for the actual first contact event that we witnessed in the movie. Sure. I wonder if at that point, like he's coming over.

all old and whatever and like take me home live long i mean that's the thing it's like have we ever seen like an actual old vulcan like not old by human standards but like old by vulcan yeah we um we saw sarah die he was very old spock's dad okay we watched him die i don't remember if you saw that episode or not i think you did i feel like you did it seems kind of familiar yeah like i don't remember the episode but that sounds familiar like i might have seen that and we'll we'll see we still have i mean some of those vulcans that we see in enterprise like in the future are actually rather elderly so uh we saw an elderly one at the monastery they went to but Sure. They're still pretty spry for their youth or their age, I guess. Yeah. All right, Matt, it feels like you're about done with this episode. I think so. I mean, no, no, that's about it. You know, it's one of those things I always take a bunch of notes, but then when it comes time to talk about, I'm like, there's not actually that much to talk about. Well, there's a reason we skipped it and I pushed it over to extra viewing. I understand. So with that, I'll ask you, did you like this episode? Have I completely ruined it for you? Would you want to watch it again? And do you get why we ultimately skipped it in the main run? I mean, I liked it the first time through, I think.

Initially, not so much right now, but now part of me kind of wants to watch it again. Right. To see if it is kind of ruined now that I know how it ends or if it is better than I'm giving credit for or what's going on at that. But yeah, I totally understand why I skipped it. I will say this. As much as I liked Mastral and I hated Tamir. Tamir got on my ever loving nerve in this episode. T'Pol's great grandma, right? Like she was such a stick in the mud. So whatever. Mastral is my dude, man. Like I was for him. When we get to the end of the episode and they look at T'Pol and like.

wait, was that a real story? And she goes, you asked me to tell you a story. Like she was pulling her leg and she just looks at him and goes, just told me to tell you a story. And then when she goes back to her quarters and she pulls out the purse, like you mentioned earlier, like I liked to like, that was the moment where I was like, okay, to Paul got a little something going there. Like, you know, like, like in that same vein that, that Mastral did. And she's been hanging out with a humans long enough. Her mom even called her on it, man. It's all that. Yep. All right, man. Well, I guess that'll do it for us then on this month's extra viewing episode, Patreon exclusive. What's up next time? Well,

That's a good question. We'll have to figure that out next time. Is there a next time? We're really close to the end of our run of the show. So we'll see if there is one, then Matt will pick it out then. And if there's not one patrons, thank you so much for your continued support of the show. As we wrap production here at beam me up. If you guys want to stump for an episode for next month, hit us up. We'll talk to you guys later until next time. Live long and prosper. Do you like how I was drawing it out? Just like they did in the episode.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Beam Me Up: A Star Trek Podcast?

This episode is 34 minutes long.

When was this Beam Me Up: A Star Trek Podcast episode published?

This episode was published on January 16, 2024.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Beam Me Up: A Star Trek Podcast episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.