Skip to content
Extra Viewing - VOY | Resolutions episode artwork

Jul 4, 2023 1 hr 10 min

Extra Viewing - VOY | Resolutions

from Beam Me Up: A Star Trek Podcast

Did You Hear About This? This humorous pop culture podcast discusses the latest retro stories and pop culture news. Listen on: Apple Podcasts Spotify Support the show

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Extra Viewing - VOY | Resolutions

0:00 1:10:17

Chapters

  1. 16:33 [Ad] Did You Hear About This?
  2. 17:11 (Cont.) Extra Viewing - VOY | Resolutions
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hey everybody, this is Brent from Beam Me Up Star Trek podcast. As you may know, Matt and I have finished recording the main run of the show. However, over the course of our three and a half years of recording the show, we actually recorded several episodes that to this point have either gone unaired or they were exclusive to our Patreon page. Well, now that we're on the backside of the main show, we thought that it would be a great time to release those episodes to you guys out there, our listening audience. Plus, you never know when Matt and I may jump in with a random new episode. The final frontier begins. This is about saving the future of humanity. This is a huge victory for the good guys.

You've never seen Voyager. Commitment to this course of action is not emotional. Johnny! Beam us up. Welcome to another episode of Beam Me Up, a Star Trek podcast. But it's not just any episode. It is that time a month again, my friends, where Matt and I get to sit down and record our special Patreon-exclusive extra viewing episodes. You guys know me. I'm Brent. And I'm Matt. And I would like to give a big, huge, if you are here in front of me, hug, because I'm a hugger to you, Eric, and you, Witt, and you, Kristen, and you, Yana. You guys are awesome. Thank you guys for joining us. And anyone who joins us again in the future, because you guys will get to be able to go back and listen to these. You guys are awesome. Matt, are you a hugger? I am. You are. I am very much. I knew that, actually. I didn't have to ask.

They didn't know that. I was asking on behalf of them. Yeah. Yeah. It doesn't matter if you're a hugger or not. I'm going to hug you. It's true. I get the opportunity. I'm a hugger too. I would hug everyone out there. You know, one of the things that just, okay, this is extra viewing. So we get to the banter. So people know that I used to do another podcast.

with another co-host about the NFL. And it was called the Peter Cass. My co-host there was Ren. Got to actually just talk to him the other day for like the first time in a while, which was, it was really good just to connect with him again. I love him a lot. Anyway, the role that I had on that show, a lot like this one, like I was kind of in the, I don't get too much into the co-host host wordplay, but like my job was to sort of drive the show and move it forward and allow him to sort of be the comments and the experts on things and those sorts of deals. You know what I mean? And so as a part of that, like he understood and I understood. Sometimes I think he forgot though, but people like people didn't always understand. A part of my,

My job as the host in that realm was to make sure that I'm bringing up the topics that people out there are talking about. And like if I see somebody ask a question out there that I thought that I would think was a good question, I bring it up on the podcast. Even if I already have a thought, even if I already know the answer, even if like it's not that I'm asking the question, I'm putting the question out there for to be able to be talked about, but I would phrase it like I'm asking the question. I would also do that from time to time with. questions that I thought were absolutely stupid and ridiculous because Ren is not as nice of a person as I am. Uh, like Ren is a lot, he's just a lot more blunt of a person, uh, which is one of the things I absolutely love about the man. And, uh, he, like, I would ask some of these questions to be like, where the hell are you getting this question from? And they're like, there are things he would even continue to make fun of me later on. He's like, yeah, you're the guy who thought that, you know, this coach had just hired his replacement. I was like, oh my gosh, dude, that was something I pulled from over there. Right. I was like, because I wanted you to make fun of it. And you did.

You know, so anyway, but yeah, not, not everybody understood that that was, that was like the role, the job that I had on that show would be to ask the question. I already knew the answer to just so that it could be in play, you know, serve the ball. I've had to do that as the host of a podcast before too. You bring on a guest and it's like, okay, I've done my research. I know their background, but I'm still going to ask you questions about your background that I know the answer to. There you go.

just so the audience knows. Yeah, yeah. That's the easiest way to go about it. Right. Instead of saying, well, I know that you are from blah, blah, blah. Tell me where you're from. Yeah, exactly. Let the guests do the job. Tell them talk about themselves and their work. Yeah. And Whit out there, Whit came over from the Pewtercast. So, so, you know, Whit knows, you know, I think he knows exactly what I'm talking about with that whole dynamic with Ren and all that. I don't expect the rest of you guys to go back. That's, that is not an evergreen show. That is a show that very much depends on what just happened yesterday. Whereas our show is evergreen. You go back, you start from the very beginning, go all the way through with us, which people do. We had, we had like this last week, like it was at least like 10 new people that went back and like downloaded.

the whole catalog, which that when you see that, like you assume that that means that's a new listener because they've redownloaded, they've downloaded the whole. Oh yeah. When you see like a hundred downloads and it's, it's not a hundred of newest episode. It's one of each of every episode. Right. Right. Yeah. And that's what I've always assumed ever since like tales or any other show that I've done. Right. So it's always, that's always like when you get like a weird spike, like on a non-episode release day, you're like, what's just happened there? You know? So anyway, uh, but to you guys out there, thank you guys for joining us today is an extra viewing episode. We're changing it up this month, folks. We're changing it up for the last four or five months, I think.

On extra viewings? Something like that. Something like that. You have chosen all Ferengi episodes, all from Deep Space Nine. I like the Ferengi, man. And you kept giving me extra viewings with Ferengi. I gave you a potential Ferengi episode for today and you opted not to go with it.

I think part of that was, what was that? I think you should still watch it and we should still do an extra viewing episode on it. Maybe we can, but I think the thing was is you didn't actually give it to me as extra viewing. Just when you're talking about, well, do we have any Ferengi episodes? And it's like, well, there is this one. It wasn't actually one you gave me as extra viewing. And so part of the reason, and then part of the other reason is I just felt, yeah, we have done many, many months on DS9. Let's get at least one Voyager extra viewing in here. There you go. There you go. So the episode we're doing today from season two of Voyager, which we just completed, is entitled Resolutions, or as I like.

to call it Chakotay and Janeway sitting in a tree K-I-S-S-I-N-G almost yeah almost never quite not quite a few times almost right and then stupid they got beamed back anyway guys this is the one where Voyager is forced to abandon Captain Janeway and Chakotay when they are infected with a terminal illness and Tuvok leads Voyager on a mission to find their cure and oh yeah Chakotay builds her hot tub and a headboard because he watches her while she's sleeping which might be a little creepy or kind of romantic I'm not really sure which Matt but we'll get into all of that so you said you wanted to switch it over into a Voyager episode I've given you several Voyager ones why this one why'd you pick this one Again, I already know the reason we've had this conversation. This is for the benefit of our listeners. Well, honestly, I don't remember what I told you in the past.

But yeah, like part of it was just recency. It was kind of top of mind when we were discussing, well, what do you want to do? And it's like, well, you mentioned this one a few times and it sounded kind of interesting. Like I'm curious to see characters outside of their normal element. Sure. If that makes sense. So yeah, that is part of it. Did I give you a very specific answer before? You did. What was that? You did. I think it was, you really seemed to like this episode. And I think you were intrigued by the romantic idea because I told you like this is an episode that really leads to the whole Janeway, Chakotay, are they or aren't they a thing? That's right. You can bring that up. Yeah.

And I think you said it dives into it some more. Yeah. And I think I had also mentioned that I like this episode a lot. Like it's not super action oriented. Do what? That was another part of it for sure. Yeah. Like it just, this is one of those that to me is, is it's cute episode. And I just, I can't explain why I enjoy it so much. I just really do. Maybe because I'm really invested in these characters and I really, I really love Janeway and I really love Chakotay. And I am 100% absolutely on the Janeway and Chakotay train. They should be a couple. And in my mind, they kind of like they are, but they aren't a couple. And I'm not going, cause I know where it goes and I know what happens and I don't want to.

uh, spoil that for you. Like I know exactly how this relationship plays out, but I will beat the drum for these two to be together as a couple. Uh, because the, the, I think they're, I mean, maybe it's just Kate Mulgrew and Robert Beltran and the way they played this and their energy. I think that, I think this changes the way that Chakotay and Janeway react to each other going forward. Um, I think you'll like, you know, there's a point when Janeway says to Chakotay, she's like, we're outside of the command structure now. You should just start calling me Catherine. And he starts calling her Catherine from here on out. He called like when it's the two of them, he calls her Catherine. Like he continues to call her Catherine. Right. Uh, whereas before it's always been captain. Yeah.

And it's a little subtlety. There's, you know, whenever you see the two of them just sort of alone together, like there's a definite tenderness to the way that Kate and Robert play this, you know, their alone time together. Well, yeah. They get each other looking. You remember when. Uh-huh. But, you know, I mean, fast forward to the end. Obviously, they make it back on a Voyager by the end. There is the command structure that prevents them, or at least it's supposed to prevent them from being together. Yeah. You know, although we never saw that issue between Riker and Troy. Like, that was always okay. Yeah, but that also wasn't captain and first officer. It's true. It's very true. So, yeah.

I'm a little confused when it comes to what's allowed and what's not allowed. My feeling is, my gut instinct is that Gene Roddenberry would say, in the 24th century, we have gotten past that. And Captain and First Officer, if they were in love, would be allowed to be together. And it wouldn't be a big deal because they could handle it. We would have gotten past those sort of command structures. Obviously, Gene Roddenberry's been dead for a while now. For good TV, it can't run perfectly. Exactly, exactly. So anyway, like I said, that's just my gut feeling of what Gene Roddenberry would say. I could be wrong. But Matt, yeah, I do. I don't know. I quite like this one. And the conversation between Chakotay and Janeway.

It's a conversation that happens in the fandom. And honestly, I know I talked to you about the relationship between Picard and Crusher. I think this one is actually talked about way more than that one. And I think this one is way more impactful than that one. Now we did watch in the main run. I want to talk about this here. Why was this not in the main run? Did you find yourself asking that question at all? Like, did you feel like it should have been in the main run watching it? Or did you kind of see why I left it out? Yeah, this is not a main run episode unless like they actually got stranded there or whatever, right? Or even if they were stuck on that planet for more than one episode, maybe.

you could make the argument. Like if something bigger happened to Voyager in Janeway's absence, like if there was some world shifting event that happened while she was gone, like, yeah, maybe then I could see it. But like I said, everything went back to normal. They had a very, very brief run in with the Badiens, but ultimately inconsequential. Well, I mean, I think based on the fact that it wasn't in the main run.

probably inconsequential. Right. However, I do have some questions about the Deans because we apparently have skipped some episodes. We skipped an episode. Yes. And definitely let's, let's get into, um, let's get into all of that. I will say just to close up this conversation of why it was like, cause I, I've been sitting here thinking to myself, like we did the episode attached, which was the Picard crusher relationship episode. Well, they won't they, this is resolutions. This is the, I mean, to me, these, these are the same episode for each series. Like, you know, take these two characters, stick them together on a planet in a weird situation and let.

feelings develop, right? But Attached had other things going on with it that informed what was happening on Deep Space Nine, which is why we watched Attached. Attached was, like, that one was an episode we watched, honestly, more for the B-plot, because if you remember, it was about different treaties and what allowed people into the Federation and what didn't. Sure. This didn't have any of that. And you see, that's what I'm saying. If something bigger had happened with Tuvok and Voyager, like, then, yeah, maybe it would have been in the main run. Yeah, so it wasn't, this was one of those, it broke, because I really liked this episode. I wanted you to watch it. I'm glad you picked it for your extra viewing. I'm glad you picked it. All right, so with that said, Matt, there's no character actor spotlights. This is all a self-contained episode.

I'm not going to give you the name of the monkey. Sorry. I will tell you he was a spider monkey. And they're like, that's a weird looking monkey. He can make an alien. Superfluous. They pulled him out of the zoo. Pulled him out of the zoo.

All right. Anyway, Matt, take us through the episode, character moments, A plot, B plot, however you want to go, man. The show is yours. Okay. Yeah. They really made a big deal about Janeway likes baths. She does. Like, I don't know if this has been established previously or if this was specifically so Chico could build her a bathtub. Yep. We get a lot of Janeway before she was a captain, like personal Janeway stuff out of this episode. And it's really neat. I love the Star Trek authors. I think I've told you before about the book that just recently came out called the autobiography of Captain Catherine Janeway. Yep. Like I was watching this episode having just recently read that.

And it's like, oh, she talks about the bath. Oh, she talks about this thing she did with her mom. Oh, she talks about this thing she did with her dad. Oh, she talks about the garden that she used to have. Oh, like, and Una McCormick, who wrote Catherine Janeway's autobiography, because Catherine Janeway didn't actually write it. Spoiler alert. Like, she pulls all of these threads and weaves them into Janeway's story growing up, which was really neat to me to hear those, you know. It's a good writer. The context. Oh, yeah. I've seen them do that. The Star Trek authors, like, the threads that they pull from multiple episodes, and it's like just little throwaway lines, are phenomenal with what they pull out. So, anyway, yeah. Really proudly created for this episode, but, you know, it becomes a part of her backstory. Sure, sure. It's canon.

I feel one of the really tough moments, like I have gotten more used to speaking in front of audiences. Okay. And I've started, you know, live streaming and stuff. And so at least then I kind of have some interaction with an audience and such. Okay. Even if it's just names on a screen.

But it made me think like Janeway is set up to give this heartfelt farewell speech and she's sitting there staring at a forest. Can you imagine what that was like as an actress? Exactly. She can't see the people she's talking to. She doesn't even look at Chakotay. I mean, I don't know if it would necessarily help because she's not saying goodbye to him. Right. I'm stuck with you forever. Everybody else I'm saying goodbye to. Right. But it's like, yeah, I got you patched through the whole ship. I'm like, oh, OK, you're going to give a speech to 150 people. And sure. You hope they're listening. Like, can they respond to you all at once? Is it any different if she's on like the bridge of her ship or in her ready room? Let's say because on the bridge, there's still people around her. Let's say in the ready room.

room. She does like a shipline announcement from her ready room and it's just her. We'll be right back. Sure. But I mean, a ship wide announcement is one thing where if it's just like informational, but this is, you know, heartfelt good farewell speech and they can't see her. She can't see them. It's just this, it's like the ship's computer saying goodbye. I'm like, okay, except it's a voice they recognize. Would it be different? Like, like, you know, I think unfortunately my wife lost her grandmother this past year to COVID. Um, uh, and she only ever got to talk to her on the phone because her grandmother was also like 90 something years old and you know, she couldn't FaceTime.

She didn't know how to FaceTime. Sure. She couldn't figure it. She barely figured out the cell phone. She's like, it doesn't have a cord. How does this work? Penny's grandma was awesome, by the way. I loved her. She was an amazing, amazing woman and she was hilarious. But she was notoriously not tech. Like she was resistant, tech resistant, you know? Sure. But is that really any different? Like we couldn't see her. She could, you know, you're just, you got the handle up to your phone and you're just staring at your wall.

one-to-one, you know, like, I feel that that is a little bit easier or a little bit more normal. Maybe that might be part of it. It's like, like, that's just not normal to have to address a hundred people blindly. Maybe that helps because like you said, maybe she does do it kind of on a regular basis. She does address the ship. Right. Right. So, so maybe for her, it wasn't so odd, but to me trying to like put myself in her shoes, it seemed like a big ask. Sure. I had, I had two thoughts out of that scene. One, I can only imagine what it's like to her as the actress standing out in that field. Cause I'm pretty sure that was an outdoor field. That wasn't on a soundstage or anything. Oh yeah. They went on location.

but she's just standing on the field like just like she doesn't actually have the ship calling back or she just has some script supervisor off screen like reading the other line back and she's got to just say this and when she's done talking her and Chakotay like or she especially like just staring off into the ocean or into the forest and they don't move for like a solid second before the screen goes to black you know like it's the dramatic pause and all that kind of stuff but she's just sitting there I was like that had been really weird just like like think Harry Potter have you ever listened to the actors describe like what it's like to use a wand like acting wise because they don't get the special effects with the light like they're just waving a stick at somebody like when they're filming the show right or the movie well I mean It's just as bad as, you know, any actor with a gun or like it doesn't like you just have this thing and you point it at them. And if you have a gun, you know, maybe kind of pull the trigger, but it doesn't make a sound. You can't see what it hits. I mean, there's no reaction from anything besides the way people are acting. And, you know, they add it all in post. So there's that. The other one to me is what I was remembering was Riker over on the Enterprise. How whenever he would talk, like whether he was talking to an individual or I don't think we ever saw Riker talking to the whole ship or if we did, it was very rare. But whatever, whenever he would use the comm system to call, he would always look up.

it's like the speakers above him or something. He's like, rank her to the captain as he's looking up at the ceiling. I can kind of picture that. I have always kind of wondered, like, yeah, where is the microphone? Is it in the comm badge? I don't know. It's remarkably clear. Like, because those microphones are not close. Well, I mean, I guess it's in the comm badge. Yeah, it'd be in the comm badge. But there's some in the ship too, though. Like, there's the comm system within the ship as well. It's not just the comm badge because people without a comm badge can still contact them, you know? So, yeah, I mean, it's not like the microphone's in the roof. And all of a sudden, it sounds like they're talking way out here because the microphone's really far away from their mouth. It's actually, you know, here. Yeah. It's the way it's out. So don't think about things like that, Matt. Don't, don

in the future, they have improved shotgun mics everywhere. Yep. It's about it. Yeah. Um, I, I kind of mentioned it before, but Janeway's whole thing with the monkey. So unnecessary. Was it? So over the top. Yeah. I have the conversations she tried to have with it and tried to talk to it. I'm like, okay, I understand you're trying to say this is like an alien creature, but regardless, like she almost made it seem like, I think this is like, they never use the word monkey. Right. Right. And some kind of primate alien primate. And I'm like, okay, come on. You can't tell me you don't know what a monkey is. You can't tell me that you're in 400 years in the future. You're not going to look at that.

say that looks like a monkey. No, it looks like an alien primate. Maybe you can speak with us. My name is Catherine. This is Chakotay. Do you understand us? Can I take some of your blood so I can see if there's antibodies in it to cure us? Yeah.

Yeah. I don't like, it just seemed too much. And like, it would have been okay. Maybe if it was once, but this monkey came back time and time and time again. And they never fed the monkey. No. Then they, like, they never even got to interact with the monkey. But, but, but I love the parting words that Janeway had for the monkey. You can use the house. Feel free to use the house. And the monkey's like, yeah. You know, and I was like, okay, I'm sorry. Can I talk about that just for a second? The house. They just left it.

I talk about, I mean, you're just going to litter like that's effectively what they're just going to leave it there to rot. Like, well, also no, my biggest thing is they just beamed all this stuff down from Voyager. Voyager is short on power and supplies and everything else. Why are you leaving all that stuff behind? You're going to leave, you're going, you remember what a big deal it was when the Kazon came to take a replicator. Yep. You're going to just leave it there. Yep. You're going to, I mean, you know, you leave the headboard fine. Leave Chakotay's redneck back of the pickup truck bath that he made for Janeway. Fine. But you're going to leave all the science equipment there. Like, oh, come on. Nope. Come on. Like, because it's not like it's a chore to get it back onto the ship. You beam it up, beam it up into the cargo bay. That's all I got to do. Like, that

That's all it is. And like I said, if nothing else, the replicator, because that's a huge piece of tech that they don't want other cultures to have right now. And so like, yeah, now what are the odds that the Kazon are going to stumble across this planet and find it sitting there? Right. You know, be tracking the subspace particles.

coming off of Voyager and, and tracks them to this planet. And it's like, they, they orbited this planet for two weeks. What were they doing here? We must search this planet. Or what about like in a hundred years when somebody like lands on this planet to like explore it? And they're like, Oh, signs of his life. Well, they've not been here for a while. And now we have a movie about what went on with that house. And this was the backstory. This was the prequel to that movie that we just saw. Like it's all, it's all, or it's going to be haunted. It's gonna be haunted house.

I mean, but it's just, look, it's not even like Janeway and Chakotay had to do it. They got 148 other people on the ship that can go get that stuff taken apart and ready for transport. But apparently it wasn't hard to put up. It's sure as heck not going to be hard to take down. And I promise you, I know from setting stuff up and tearing it down, tearing it down takes about a quarter of the time it takes to set it up. Yep. Yep.

We always had to do that for the big music concert at the end of the year at high school. Like it takes a week to set up all the stages and all the risers and all the platforms and stuff. It takes two hours to take down. It's one of the biggest, it's the thing that bugs me the absolute most because I do that. Like I set up and tear down, set up and tear down lots of gear, lots of equipment, usually on a weekly basis. And it just, you know, I'm thankful by the time we get to the end of the show, the teardown is only going to take like an hour and a half, you know, where, but we spent six hours setting it up and I'm like, oh my God.

And I'm always like, how can we make this go faster? Because this is nuts how long this takes. Should not take this long. So anyway, yeah. And back to the monkey. Though we were talking about the monkey, not the house. I don't need to talk anymore about the monkey. She said use the house. She shouldn't have been there. I mean, come on. There's no reason for that monkey. Yeah. It was the mid 90s. Like part of me wonders if that was the same monkey that was either in Friends. Right. In the mid 90s there. Or if it was, I forget the name of the movie. There's that movie with Thora Birch. Did she have a monkey? I think at one point. I don't know. I would have never seen that. All of these. I can promise you it's not. I promise you it's not the Friends monkey.

because the friend's monkey was a capuchin. This one is a spider monkey. Okay. So two different species of monkeys. Yeah, I guess people just didn't have zoos. Monkeys were the big thing in the 90s. They didn't even like, you remember back in TOS where they would like take a dog or like a sheep and turn it green or something like, or like put like a horn on its head. Like they didn't even do that. Didn't they have like a green goat or something? Right, right. Didn't they have like a dog or a cat with like a unicorn horn on it? Yeah. You know, like you could see it like wrapped around its head. Like, look, it's got a horn.

Must be an alien creature. Yeah. You know, I wonder, I often wonder if, like, if you go back to the TVs that they had in the 60s that were like, yeah, like they were, they were 12 inch CRT black and white. It's like, you couldn't see the thing around its head, but like you blow it up and put it in color and like, ah. And so like neither DS9 or Voyager have had the HD upgrade that Next Generation and TOS have had. And people, one of the things we were saying is they're wondering if they do the upgrade, particularly with what we got in Deep Space Nine and Voyager, if you'll start seeing like the seams of the makeup, like where it potentially does that come in. I know one of the things they did in Next Generation was the, where they would screw the pants.

panels in, like the touchscreen panels that they had, you couldn't see them and you couldn't see the screws in the SD version. But when they did the HD, like you could see like the Phillips head screwdrivers. Wow. So they had to go in and digitally retouch all that. And that's, that's a part of why they don't want to do it. That's probably why we're not going to get a DS9 Voyager upgrade. They probably tried one episode and it's like, nope, not doing that again. Well, one of the, one of the, so apparently they had to go back and re-scan, like they re-scan them from the negatives, but they didn't like put the negatives in order of how they're cut. Like they're all just sort of like, all right, here's the box of that, that set of negatives. And they're like all in there. And like they had to go re- Because they never planned to have to do this. Sure. Sure. And they're, you know

This group is moving, trying to get through, you know, and it's not digital stuff anymore either. Like they didn't get digital stuff till enterprise, actually, I think. So anyway, yeah. Can we stop talking about the monkey now? Yes, please. So in a recent episode, do you remember how I kind of criticized Janeway?

for being super rash in her decision-making. Yes. She did it again, I feel. Oh, yeah. Except, I mean, by the end of the episode, it was reversed. But like last time it was like, yeah, self-destruct Voyager. Oh, you can't do that. The ship is broken. We can't allow that. Okay, fine. Now she's like, I permanently make you captain. Like, wait, what? We just started this episode. You what? Like no discussion? No meeting? No nothing? Just, no, you're captain. See ya. Don't come back for us.

What? Because he wasn't, he wasn't supposed to be the acting captain. That was not her intent. He's not the acting captain. He's the captain. However, did you catch it? He never changed his uniform color or his pips or his, you know. Okay. I did think about looking at the pips one side and I forgot to check it later, but no, not even that. The first log entry. Oh yeah. And that too. He said, he says six weeks later acting captain. And I'm like, I thought the point of making you permanent captain was so you weren't acting captain. Did I get something wrong there? Nope. Like the second entry he makes later on, he just says captain. But I'm like, dude, you're six weeks into leaving them behind and you haven't accepted your place as captain yet. Like you told her you would, you would take the captaincy.

So that one seemed a bit off to me. I think there's making things up. No, you're not making things up. I think there's two explanations for that. I think there's a real world explanation. I think there's a in-universe explanation. Go for it. Which one would you want first? Real world. I think in the real world, the writers flubbed because the actor does what's on the page. Yep. I think that's what happened. I don't, I just, I think they were moving so fast. They didn't stop to think about it. And somebody went, hey, wait, he's not really captain. He should be the acting captain. Right. Yep. Make him say acting captain. And they just moved on. They didn't like, no, wait a minute. So I think, I think they flubbed. I'll give you that. In universe, there could be a thing where even though Tuvok was heading forward, even though everybody seemed to be like, we've got to go back and get

the captain we've got to go back and get Chakotay and Tuvok was like no I've got orders to go forward even though that was all happening Tuvok was still trying to figure out how to go back and get Janeway and Chakotay and he had like he he actually hadn't fully accepted that he was the captain because he was planning on going back to get them some way somehow but he couldn't say that to everybody else yet if that's what they were trying to get across yeah but then like I said the entry he makes later it's just captain and it's like I wish he would have picked one or the other and that and I mean even that could be that that signifies when he finally gave over and said and actually I would have liked if he would have done that if that's when he would have changed his colors sure because he should he should have changed into red. And that would have made a lot more sense. And there's, um, we saw that change. If you remember the episode of next generation with captain Jellicoe, when he came in and took over the enterprise, uh, that's the one where, uh, that was chain of command where Picard went off and he wound up getting tortured and all that. Um, when, when captain Jellicoe, if you remember that episode, he actually like relieved Riker of his duties and kicked him to his quarters and he promoted data to be the first officer. Do you remember that? I don't know if you remember that. Yeah. Data switched to red. We saw him in red for those episodes, uh, or for that, for that time period. And then he eventually went back to yellow. So, you know, there's a, and there's another character that we will see who, when he enters command, it changes his universe.

color. And it's quite spectacular when it happens too. So it's pretty fun. You'll, you'll enjoy it. But it, and we, and obviously we saw it with Worf over in deep space nine. Like they made a point of it. Like you'd look better in red than you would gold. So yeah, he should have, like I said, I think that's probably if you were to answer the in universe reason, uh, that would be, that's my, my best guess to it. But I think the real life answer is the writers flubbed. And I think they were just moving so fast that maybe they thought about it. They just didn't think about it all the way through. So I know this wasn't the story they were trying to tell, but I would like to see a follow-up episode about what happens on the enterprise when you put your captain and first officer in stasis for 17 days. I'm like,

On the Enterprise or Voyager. Or you don't care. Just on a starship. I'm sorry. Yes. I meant to say Voyager, but any starship. Yes. I mean, let me see what happens because they just flew by that. Like I understand that's not the story they want to tell. So they just need to set up real quick. But the timeline of this episode, the time that this episode covers, right? It's pretty thick. 17 days in stasis. Then they send them away. Like they orbit for a couple of days. They send them away. We get a captain's log, acting captain's log. Six weeks later, we get a point. I don't know if I mean.

mention of the other timelines, but there were other times mentioned where it's like days and weeks and months. And I'm like, dude, like three months covered like half a year. Like what is going on? Yeah. It actually covers three months. You're absolutely right. The events transpire over a period of about three months, which makes it one of the longest times that viewers will spend with characters of a single episode outside of time travel and weird stuff. Sure. Sure. That that's, yeah, it doesn't count. And the way that breaks down to, to your point is the first, they actually spent four weeks in orbit of new earth searching for a cure and then Voyager with six weeks out away from them before coming back before coming back. So then they had to come six weeks back to pick them up, you know, which I mean, yeah.

That put them, you know, January said at the end, like we've lost a little bit of time. Let's get going. But I mean, that's what I'm saying though. Like that's a lot of time. Like how most episodes we see takes place over a day or two. Sure. So like, I mean, it feels to me, I don't know if it's accurate, but it feels to me like this episode probably covered the same amount of time as.

the rest of season two or close to it. Yeah. I mean, somewhere in that general timeframe, like it's, it's a lot. And if it weren't for them calling out timeframes from time to time, like I would have thought it was, yeah, you were down there for two days. So that's something that Ken Biller, which we've mentioned him several times before, he actually had a big problem with this, um, with this episode because he felt, even though this time was passing that as a, as a viewer, you never felt the time passing. You know what I mean? Like we never felt things were like Chakotay built a tub. I'm like, that didn't happen overnight. No. Right. Right. Or you saw like what he was doing for the headboards, right? Like, yeah, the headboards that, I mean,

even just a house going up. Right. Right. She had a whole garden with things growing in it. Right. Right. I mean, yeah, they've obviously been there for some time, but yeah, I mean, we're still only with them for 42 minutes. It doesn't feel like that long. Do you know, do you know what, what other franchise I had an issue with that before was specifically the third Harry Potter movie. Okay. Because that, that movie tracks its movement through the year by what happens to the Whomping Willow. You know what I mean? Like it shows the Whomping Willow. It shows, it goes to winter, to fall, to spring, not in that order. And back to summer. My first watch to that movie, it did not track, I did not track that Whomping Willow at all. Like it just felt like it was barreling through. And like, by the time I got to the end, I was like, I don't.

I feel like this was a whole year at the school. Like, I felt like, I felt like a whole year from the first movie because there was Halloween and then there was Christmas and then it got to spring again and you could feel that passage of time. I think I felt that with the second movie too. I didn't feel it at all with the third movie. It just, you know. Didn't they get a new director for the third movie? They did. And that's part of what, and everything changed for that movie. And I was like, oh, he doesn't want the same. I don't, you know, it sounded like another friend of ours who likes to criticize Harry Potter movies. Love you boss. But in any case, we eventually got into Janeway and Chakotay moving into this house, right? Yeah. So after we cut back to them, they've been down there for, you know, a couple days.

and they've changed clothes and stuff. Janeway let her hair down. And the rest of the entire episode, whenever I saw them, there's only one thing I could think of. And I don't know how familiar you are with Dr. Queen Medicine Woman.

I've seen an episode or two while at my grandparents' house. Okay. So what you have to understand is when I grew up in mid-90s, I grew up in a household with an older sister. I mean, two parents, an older sister, and a younger brother. And that meant if my mom and my sister wanted to watch something on TV, that's what we were watching. So I am very well-versed in mid-90s figure skaters. I am also well-versed in Dr. Queen Medicine Woman. It also helped that my grandparents on my mom's side loved watching it. My grandpa always referred to her as Dr. Queen Medicine Chick. But all that to say is I've seen a lot of episodes of Dr. Queen Medicine Woman.

And so not only does Janeway with her hair down and when she puts on a dress like that resemble very closely Jane Seymour in Dr. Quinn Medicine Woman. Yep. But then Dr. Quinn also has her Native American sidekick, Sully, who is always there. And they always kind of hint at, I think they do maybe get married eventually, but most of the show is will they, won't they? And so he's just always there, right? He plays the father figure for her children. And so this whole time I'm sitting there thinking, this is Dr. Quinn and Sully. This is Dr. Quinn and Sully. Like, that's all I can see. So for anyone else who is familiar with Dr. Quinn Medicine Woman, please, please, please tell me you saw this too.

because it was right in that timeframe too. Like Dr. Quinn was early to mid nineties, was probably on the air as this was airing. And so like, it's just too much similarity for me other than when they pulled out, you know, tricorders, but like Sully would have been the guy to go around and build stuff with his hands. It's like, yeah, Dr. Quinn, you need a tub? Sure, I'll build you one. Yeah. I would probably go with more Lorelai and Luke, but that's a whole different thing. I thought about that too. And it's close. Yeah. But just between the dress and the timeframe and like it seemed, yeah, more Dr. Quinn to me.

I definitely, I see the Dr. Quinn look that you're talking about, you know? So yeah, I get it. I totally feel where you're coming with that. Then I'm not sure how to go about talking about their whole, you know, will they, won't they thing on this episode here. It's, it started from the beginning. Like Janeway was kind of getting into it, getting all giggly. And then this was right before Voyager left. And so Tuvok calls down, like it looked like Janeway was about to like hug Chakotay almost. And like Tuvok interrupts right then. And I don't know if this was directed or just brilliantly played by.

by whatever, Mulgrew. But the look on her face, her face just drops and she looks super guilty. It's like, oh, that's right. I maybe shouldn't be doing this. Or she can't do this. From that moment, she would have if she hadn't gotten interrupted. She absolutely would have. But that's what I'm saying. She was reminded, it's like, oh no, this is not, I can't do this. And so if that didn't happen, completely different story. Even if he interrupted two minutes later, I think it may have been a completely different story.

But if they had actually like, even just so, so much as kissed, you know what I mean? Like there would have been something real close right then. Oh yeah. Yeah. Like it may have happened right then and there, but then we went the next, it took her like three months to unravel that moment basically. So that was frustrating. Like I, I, I love Chakotay's reasoning through all this. Well, before you go into Chakotay, I want to keep talking about January just for a moment, because even when we got back up to the ship, her and Chakotay walk onto the bridge, they, they take their seats and you know, it's like right back to business where like, she's like, okay, we need a ship status update. She says, Chakotay, you do whatever, whatever, whatever. And I'm going to do whatever, whatever, whatever. And he goes, I captain. And then they.

turn and look at each other and there's this, this look. Chakotay gives her a smile, but Janeway doesn't smile back. She gives him sort of like a nod, like a, no, there's a wall here now. There's a, there's a, there's a wall that has, has to be reconstructed. And, and I think you could tell she didn't like it. And I think you're absolutely right. This is how Kate Mulgrew played it. Like absolutely. In fact, Kate Mulgrew would go on to say she really, she really struggled in the coming episodes with the way they, they didn't allow their relationship to progress when she wanted it to. Let's put it that way. Uh, you know, and she would talk about that, like it, because even Janeway was like, no, no, something started there. They've got to follow that up. And you know, there's the command structure. It was.

It was like, hey, I will tell you this though, Matt, in case you're interested to know this. One of the earlier scripts, and I don't mean like super early. I mean like a script or two before the final draft got turned in, actually explicitly had them going much further romantically. Now, the source here does not quote exactly how much further, like where does that actually go? So leave that up to you to figure out how much further romantically they were going to go. But they actually backed off of it and purposely left it ambiguous for this reason right here, to allow the audience to interpret it and debate it for themselves, which I think is brilliant on the part of the production. Because if you give, you know, if you actually let them experience that and go,

with it, then, you know, we as the audience don't really have much to talk about because they did. But if you leave it ambiguous, it's like, oh, did they? Don't they? Oh, well, they won't they? Oh, they should go back. And then like if other stuff happens and you're like, oh, because like we kind of felt this with Riker and Deanna through TNG, right? Like, and I don't know how much you felt it where we skipped over so much, but there really was this like Riker would kind of go see his own women. Deanna would sometimes see her own men and then they'd be together. And then sometimes Riker would get a little jealous and sometimes Deanna would get a little jealous. And then more relationship between Riker and Troy than I did really with Picard and Crusher. Yeah. I think I saw more of Riker and Troy. Yeah. But Riker's and Troy's was very explicit though. Whereas Picard.

and Beverly's was just sort of this like subtle subtext that, you know, when they, remember at the end when they like, they were married for a while and eventually got divorced. Like, like that was the payoff of that, that they had been playing for the whole time. So anyway, yeah, just, just, they did. So, but you were about to talk about Chakotay and how he was playing it. Well, yeah, because I love the quotes he kept giving us. Like, why do you have to see it as defeat? Maybe it's just accepting what life has dealt us and finding good in it. Like that.

That right there is brilliant life advice for anybody. Like don't look at it as defeat. And then he goes on to say later, I can't sacrifice the present while waiting for a future that may never happen. I love that. I love that. So many people fall into this. Yeah. Like just trying to make the future happen or waiting for a future that may or may not happen when they're just letting life fly by them. Yeah. And like it all goes together. And like I, to me, I think I would totally be in Chakotay's.

boat. Like I think I would do the same thing in his situation. Really? I think so right now. I mean, I've never been in that exact situation, but that, that type of logic very much tracks with me. And so, well, yes, I can spend some time trying to find a cure, trying to find a way back. Like he was saying, like you can't spend all your time doing that. Like give it an 80, 20 rule, right? Right. Right. 20% of the time you can search for a cure, but the other 80% of the time.

be in the present in your life. I'm all about them trying to find a cure and trying to get off the planet and stuff like that. I really, like I get it. It's not like Voyager left them with a shuttlecraft that they would be able to leave the planet. You know what I mean? They did, or at least they talked about it. Voyager didn't, they didn't leave a shuttlecraft for them. They mentioned it once. Did they? Oh, then I missed that. No, I've never seen a shuttlecraft. They mentioned like a, you know, I don't know, class four shuttle can only go warp four, so it would take them 700 years to get home. Right. So maybe that was just in their meeting in discussion.

Like Tuvok said, yeah, we'll leave him with one. But maybe that got shot down. Yeah. But yeah, I mean, if Voyager did what they were supposed to do and just kept heading towards Alpha, like, yeah, there's no way even with the shuttle that they would catch up to him. Yeah, you're absolutely right. They did. They had a Type 9 shuttlecraft at their disposal if she succeeded. But you're right. I mean, there's no way they'd, I mean, you're not going to catch up. Like, they're done. They're gone. They're done-ski. But they could at least find someone else, hopefully. They could go find the... Borg. Nope, I was going for Neelix's civilization. Oh, the Talaxians. Talaxians, thank you. That we interacted with before that seemed kind of helpful or willing to help.

It's like, yeah, just go live with them or something. Or no, you wouldn't want to do that. You can say, go live with Kes' family. No, maybe not. But yeah, I mean, maybe they're not able to make it home, but they could at least make it somewhere where they could live, not alone. Sure, sure. I get that. But I don't know. I don't know about you, Matt. Well, let me ask you, do you find yourself falling more into the Chakotay way of doing things or the Janeway way of doing things? Like, are you the...

okay, this is our situation. I'm just going to accept it. And let's make this the best life we can possibly do. Or are you like on the January, like, no, no, we're going to dig this out. We're going to find this. We're going to find the cure. We're going to, we're going to get in and see what's what and make it happen. What are you, what would you do in that situation? My gut reaction says that I would do what Chico did it. Now, part of me says, well, no, I probably search for a way out, search for a cure for a little while. But I mean, like they said, the doctor had been doing it for, well, at least 17 days and probably longer. Like he was probably still going at it. But at one point, I think they said for more than a month, he's been trying. And so like, once again, like Janeway does have a very good mind.

But if the doctor didn't find anything after a month, are you really going to find something that, you know, he missed? Right. Like they had been orbiting that planet for a while. It's not like he didn't have access to the atmosphere or he didn't have access to like, he had all the resources he needed. So, um, although it is kind of interesting that the doctor couldn't figure anything out, but the Vidians had. Well, but remember the Vidians were much more medically advanced than Voyager, than the Federation. Like they're super, like, like they're, they were, they're the, like, that's their, they're the next step beyond where the Federation is. They just happen to have this really horrible disease. You know, you're talking about the Vidians for a little bit. Yeah. You said earlier, you had some questions about the Vidians. I don't know.

I don't remember if you said that while we were here on air or before we got into it. You said, I got questions about the Vidians. I do have questions about the Vidians. Because they seem to be very familiar with this doctor chick the Vidians have. And I don't think I've ever met her. No, you haven't. She was a couple episodes back that we skipped over. I think I gave it to you as an extra viewing, possibly. In that episode, it's called Life Signs. If you want to go back and watch it. If you want to do an extra extra viewing, we can do that. You did give me that one as an extra viewing. And in that episode, the doctor came across a Vidian woman who turns out she was a physician herself, a very advanced physician. And the doctor was able to take her consciousness. Wait, did you say the doctor came across?

uh, or the ship came across, whatever they came in contact with. Okay. And the doctor wasn't off outside the ship. No, no, no, no, no. Like they brought the patient into, into sick bay. Right. Um,

And yeah, no, Doctor can't leave sickbay. Or like, I think he can go to the holodeck now or something. Well, unless they accidentally beam him off the ship. Well, but they had, remember they put holoprojectors outside the ship to project all the other ships. I'm like, I've seen him outside the ship. He said it's his most embarrassing moment as an actor. Anyway, and the basic rundown of that is he takes her consciousness and puts it into a holographic body. But that holographic body was like a perfectly formed Badean woman without the disease. So now she was pretty and she was whatever. Well, this hologram doctor lady who's not really a hologram and the hologram doctor started like digging each other and like having feelings for each other and developing her. And she gave him the name because remember he's searching for a name. He doesn't have a name. Yeah.

calling him Shmullis. So she gave him the name. Shmullis. Yeah. Shmullis. I don't remember why. Already a garbled message that was coming across the airwaves. And so like, I don't know what you're calling him, but he seems to understand. So sure. Uh-huh. Shmullis. That was his name. Shmullis. It's like, I think Shmullis was like the name of her uncle or something. And like he, like he took that guy's name or something. Anyway, that's what she started to call him. So they started having a big thing. But then she was like, I'm going to have to go back into my body because the hollow matrix can't support my level of consciousness inside its computer buffers for much longer. And then like she goes back in her body and she's like, now I'm ugly again and you can't love me. And the doctor.

like, I'd love you anyway, because that doesn't matter to me. And we'll figure this out. And she's like, no, no, no, no. And she like, it was often, you know, so now they have a Vidi and friend. Yeah. And that's what I'm like, let's contact in our part. So again, we might've watched that episode if I was going to track through this.

Is it a spoiler to say this is the last time we see the Vidians? Like, I mean, we got out of Kazon space. Remember just with the basis. We got out of Kazon space. So we also left Vidian space. So, well, you can tell them it's extra viewing. We weren't even supposed to watch this episode. Exactly. That's, but I wasn't going to bring it up. So yeah. Yeah. Well, like I, I've never been big on the Vidians, but I kind of liked this doctor. Oh yeah. She's cool. Yeah. I love like one-off kind of characters like that, that are just super cool and ready to help you out. And like, she's all like, yeah, I totally thought this was an errand of mercy. Like I know, you know, our cultures don't get along, but I thought we were doing this thing for you. And.

like I'm glad to know that that was all legit. Yeah. Like she's legit and she wasn't trying to. do anything. Like that's the impression that I got at least. But like I said, I was missing a small piece of the puzzle there. Like, yeah, everybody knows her. I have no idea. Like everybody knew that they could trust her. I had no idea who she was. Right. But for the sake of the episode, like you knew within the context of the episode, like, oh, she must be a legit person. So cool. Yeah. They seem to make that clear enough. In case you're wondering, I'm showing Matt right now. Matt, this is what she looked like as a hologram without all the disease and everything. So yeah, really a lovely lady. Very lovely lady. So by Susan D. All. So like that was the biggest thing that I was wondering about was about the doctor. And that makes more sense now with her connection.

to the doctor and it's like, yeah, why are you just calling me on the comm system? Right. Yeah. Right. And she's sitting there like, hey, we had no, I had no idea they were planning to attack. And I'm like, Janeway knew they would attack. Tuvok knew that they were going to attack. But she's a doctor. Yeah, I know. I know. She doesn't think like that. Do they tell?

Does Voyager tell their doctor, hey, we're going into battle now? No, his mind is always just, how can I help? Sure, sure. Yeah, and that's, you know, and certainly they didn't have the personal relationship with Voyager that she did. So, but yeah, so the Vidians go in and they're like, yeah, we'll come help you and take all your people. Well, and I kind of feel like whenever she ran up the ladder, whoever, you know, was making that final decision was like, yes, we will meet with them. Yes, tell them we will help them. Like they weren't going to reveal their plans to her. Oh, sure. Absolutely. They want it to look all legit. So when they show up, it's an ambush. That totally makes sense. So how about Tuvok as captain?

How about, how about Tuvok as captain? What do you think? What do you think of, this is the first time we've actually seen a Vulcan as a captain. I guess we've seen Spock in it a little bit too. But what'd you think? What'd you think of him as a captain? I think he did pretty well. You do? Yeah. In general, at least. Like I liked that, you know, he made decisions and he stuck with them for the most part, except for right at the end. Like I love the interaction with Tuvok and Harry and going back and forth, back and forth and finally just puts his foot down. It's like, no, you need to respect my, respect my authority. And he, he just put his foot down. It's like.

I'm the captain now. You might not like the way I run things, but here's how it's going to be. Sure. Now, of course I played right into the writers and it's like, okay, yeah, I'm totally on two box side. He's doing the right thing. Keep going, go, go, go. I mean, it doesn't help that I've never really liked Harry that much. So I, if we lose Harry, I mean, it's not that big of a deal to me. But it wasn't until Cass came in and made her argument that her logical argument, right? That you're not only caring for the physical wellbeing of the crew, but also the emotional wellbeing. Yeah. And that's actually where I, where I kind of want to talk about because I think that's an important thing to note as a captain that.

It is one thing to be a logical person. Like, you got to think about this logically. You know, I love Tuvok's line with Paris later. Paris, I know somebody in the briefing room, right? And he's like, you know, could you at least pretend like you give a damn about what's going on? And he's like, you know, that you're incapable of feeling such an emotion for how crummy we feel. And he's like, you're right. I can't feel that. And frankly, I don't see what good it would do, you know? And I'm like, like as a leader, I'm going.

Like that's a, your people aren't there yet. And your people like, while you may be there, your people have this need that you are incapable of, although I think you could be capable, but you are incapable of, and you are unwilling to meet them there and to, to acknowledge that it's a legit thing. He just delegitimized their emotions. Yeah. You know what I mean? Like, like he just said, all of, all of that stuff you're feeling is crap and you shouldn't be feeling it. And they're like, they're in the middle of it. I think that's where he fails as a captain. Yeah. Right. And if he had gone, had to go through the proper channels, he never would have been promoted to that point. But this is what happens. Like I said.

I want to see what happens on Voyager when you knock out your captain and your first officer in one fell swoop, right? And so it's actually kind of weird. I mean, I guess he was probably acting captain up until Janeway said, no, I effectively resign and you are the captain now. But I mean, what happened up to that point? Like people should have been kind of used to Tuvok being captain already, right? Or 17 days, right? Like that's what I said. I want to see, see what actually happens there. But, and that's, and honestly, that's another reason why he should have changed his command color to red and should have changed the pips on his collar because that says something to the crew. Like I am here now. I am taking.

this seriously you need to look to me like like it's a subtle cue that while logically it may not be a thing to him as a Vulcan if he can't understand that and you can't understand the needs of your crew then you can't serve them well and I'm really glad that he comes to a spot later where he's like well I don't understand this and I like that he got there eventually he just needs to get there a lot sooner and I hope that Vulcan captains go through this in training of like look it's not gonna make sense to you but it matters to your people and you have to lead your people so that's what I'm saying like I think if he had gone through the proper channels and gone through the training that most captains do yeah I think he would have been able to learn some of that I think he would have been ready for some of that handled that better. Sure. But when he's just, it was just thrust upon him. Like that's the difficulty of this episode. And he too is dealing with the loss of, of his captain and first officer and, and, you know, friends, uh, which again, again, I, again, I say, Matt, I go back and point out while the Vulcans say that they don't experience emotions or that they've purged all emotion. I call BS. I know. Because I think like, and I think that's a good example of that. And like, you remember the part where, um, Harry comes to see Chakotay in his quarters, or I'm not Chakotay, Tuvok. He comes to see Tuvok in his quarters. Tuvok gets upset with Harry. He gets frustrated and he gets upset. He's like, Ensign?

The next words out of your mouth better be yes, sir. Because he put that down. He had a limit and said, I'm not dealing with this anymore. There was nothing logical about that. It is not logical to relieve him of duty permanently because he's upset and he's emotional at the recent loss of his captain. That is illogical, Tuvok. Sorry. But it was a logical way to shut him up, though. And that's where Vulcans would twist the logic to make it work for them. And they just perpetuate the lie. Because you'll see Vulcans do that all the time. Oh, but it's actually logical because X, Y, Z. And I'm like, you're like my wife. I'm just joking, baby. I love you. I love you so much. And you know, you're Vulcan. We've had this conversation, by the way.

Everybody's not their one. If you say something. You've met my wife, Matt. She's very Vulcan-ish. If you say so. He's not stepping into that. Matt would like to be invited back over someday. Ultimately, though.

This did not resolve how I thought it would. Okay. So they just got the cure from the Vidians. Well, they didn't, they had to fight for it. And then like it got snuck to them. But yeah, they got the cure from the Vidians. They got the cure from the Vidians. Yeah. I thought, sure, they're going to try, but they're going to fail and just have to run away. Yeah. I honestly thought Janeway was going to figure it out. Oh, really? I really thought that's the way it was going to go. Yeah. Like she had some good ideas. But then once that storm came through and they're like, yeah, none of this is recoverable. My research is done. I'm like, oh, okay. I guess that's how they write that off. But I totally thought that she was going to figure it out. I don't know. So in an alternate script. Yeah. In fact, I mentioned the guy, Ken Miller, a little bit earlier. Now he did.

have a hand in crafting this episode this was this was mostly a jerry taylor episode though okay ken biller did have a hand but not much of one like so much so it's like he tried having a hand and then like jerry taylor's like no we're not doing that and he just sort of like okay fine i'm not gonna do much with it like like i almost get that feeling when when i read about it it's like yeah we're gonna do this we're gonna do this no no no we're not doing that well fine i'm just gonna go over here and work on this other episode while you do that it's almost the way but the story he wanted to do involved genuine chakotay eventually leaving the planet because they did eventually find the cure and then catching up with voyager through a time eddie but when they do they've actually aged 40 years it took them 40 years to find the cure and at that point they have a whole family by now because they did actually you know it together uh jerry taylor was like no we've already done that episode and next generation it's called the inner light where picard got really old and had his whole little family and stuff yeah yeah um and ken biller was like yeah that's where i got the idea this is a riff on the inner light and she went no fine i'll go write my own episode then okay but yeah man i think that's about all i have to say on the episode i think you've cut man you you delve into this episode a lot deeper than i thought you would i gotta be honest like you picked up a lot i thought this would just be like i thought this would be a 30 minute little extra i mean i really did shorter but some of those conversations went a little bit longer yeah i mean even even when we shorten this up when we truncate this out this is still gonna

to be probably plus, you know, over an hour. A normal length episode. Yes, yes. You're welcome, patrons. Because, I mean, you just, you dove into this episode and all the different, I really, I thought you'd be like, yeah, so Janeway and Chakotay, I'm for it. I think they should get together. And outside of that, it was cute. And there we go. And then I thought you'd go, all right, what the heck is going on with the Vidians? I figured you'd pick that one up too. So, okay, so Matt, I'll ask you that. Oh, wait, wait, wait, wait. Did you catch the 47? There's 47 in this episode. Yeah. When the Vidians were attacking, the shields are at 47%. Oh. Yeah.

Yeah. It's been a while since we've had a good 47. Yep. Usually I'll listen to the numbers. Yeah. And we've had a few like 37s recently, I feel. We've had some 42s. Yeah. Yeah. They've been floating around it. I'm like, why would you use 47 in that case? Why would you use 47? It's just a random number. Yeah. Nobody cares what the number is. Just throw it in there. And until the internet comes around full force, no one's going to notice. Right.

So I will ask you this question then, Matt. Where do you stand on Janeway and Chakotay? Do you think they should be a couple? Are you for it? Do you not care? Like, you know, should they not? Because the question, okay, let me phrase it this way. At the end of the episode, they're now back in the command structure. Should the command structure of Voyager, especially to Voyager in its unique situation, not being anywhere close to home, there's nobody else like them around. They are all that they have.

is this group. Should that command structure affect Chakotay, Janeway? And do you think that they should be together or not? What do you think? Should it affect their relationship? Yes, I think it should. Still. Yes. Even though there's, because that means that Janeway can have no personal relationship with anybody on this group. Well, I mean, I'm sitting here and thinking about it and maybe this, I don't know if I'm going to get myself in trouble for thinking about it this way, but if she does get in a serious relationship and things go all the way, now you're out in the middle of nowhere with a pregnant captain. How does that work? How does that work? Like, is that really the smartest thing?

But if that's where she wanted to go, wouldn't she have the right to have that baby? And not have to lose her job because of it? I might get myself in trouble for saying something like that. But ultimately, and I think we see the beginning of this year, is I don't think Janeway would go that direction with it. I mean, they were stuck down on a planet by themselves for three, four months, and she didn't cross that line there as far as we know.

Why is she going to do it back on the ship? Well, but see, I think that's the difference here. I think prior to this, they hadn't flirted with that line. Like, I don't even know that it was on her radar, you know? Because she's still, by the way, remember, she's engaged back home. I had forgotten about that. Yeah, like she has a dude back home. She has a dude back home. But she thought she was going to be here on this planet for a long time. I mean, she was there for weeks and weeks and weeks. And, you know, I mean, and by the way, she's two years and change into this trip, almost three years into this trip now. Like, does she really expect him to wait for her? It's not like they were married and had kids and stuff. How long was she originally planning on being gone? They were just going out to the Badlands to go find Tuvok and Chakotay.

and then they were coming right home. So a week or two, you know, she took off and didn't take care of her dog first. It's like, oh, can you go pick her up for me? You know, see you in a couple of weeks. We'll be back. This wasn't a deep space assignment for her. Sure. You know, it wasn't a five year mission or anything. It was, it was, you know, just a mission. So I, but in her heart or in her head though, it was like, she doesn't know. Maybe he is waiting on her. Maybe not. But now that she's had this new thing in front of her, you know, now that it's there, the can is open. At least it's, at least the seal has popped. So I, I'm kind of going to toe the line a little bit. Okay. And just because I know TV, like, I think this is going to be very much like those relationships we talked about earlier. Like, I think it is going to be

to be a Luke and Lorelai. And from now on, they'll play with it every few episodes. They'll tease it a little bit, but nothing is going to happen with it till... the last season. I don't know. Luke and Lorelai got together before. Don't ask me why I know that. Yeah. I've seen every episode. I couldn't give you those details. Once again, that, that is another, my mom and my sister, if they wanted to watch it, well, guess what? I was watching that. If I like, you also have to realize for, for people who may be younger back in the nineties, having more than one TV in the household was a luxury. We didn't stream things on our tablets and not everybody had their own individual screen. You get to watch what you want. It's there's one TV in the house and whoever has the remote, if you want to watch TV, you're watching whatever they're watching. Exactly. Exactly. I, uh, for just those of you guys,

out there, I think everybody in this group knows my Star Trek story at this point. The same girl that introduced me to Star Trek also introduced me to Gilmore Girls. Sure. So, you know, is what it is. All right, Matt. I got to tell you, I'm a, I'm a. Sorry, you just mentioned Gilmore Girls again. Thought crossed my mind. The one Gilmore Girls story my mom always loves to tell is that for, I forget, I don't know if it was the series finale. It may have just been like a season finale or something, but the power was out at my parents' house. I was gone at college. And so my mom called me and I held the phone up to the TV and basically filled in the gaps, like narrated the story for things that they couldn't see.

like when I went to commercials just so they could catch it live. This is the universe we used to live in. Anyway, you're saying. Yeah, I was done. I was just saying, same girl that introduced me to this track, introduced me to Gilmore Girls. You know what? These are the kind of conversations I would normally cut out of the episode for the main run. Oh yeah. But you guys are patrons. You love us. And so, you know, you get all these, you get all this. I would hold my tongue usually. Yeah. Right. Yeah. Yeah. I've definitely gone down a few rabbit holes in this, in this episode that I wouldn't normally, uh, uh, to do that. So anyway, all right, Matt, well, uh, let me ask you, did you like this episode on, on watching? Yeah. Okay. Do you, do you agree with me? Like it's a cute episode. It's not like big, but like it's, it's cute. Like it's a, it's a heartwarming episode and endearing episode. It is. And honestly, I thought we were going to spend.

more time down on the planet. I feel we actually spent more time back in Voyager trying to find a cure. You know, I forget who it was, but one of the producers was like, they felt like the B plot was actually a bit stronger than the A plot in this one. Which is A plot? Which is B plot? A plot is them down on the planet. B plot was them up in the. Okay. That's how I wrote down my notes because like that's what you kind of prepped me for. It's like them down on the planet. And then as I was taking my notes, I'm like, I'm taking more notes about the B plot here. I'm taking more notes about Tuvok and Voyager. Like, was that supposed to be the A plot? Yeah. Yeah. I think we're conditioned to the idea of like, here's the A plot and it's going to take up like 70% of the time. And then you have the B plot, which is this little subplot that may or may not have anything to do with it. Maybe it becomes background, but it's going to fill in like the rest of the 25, 30% of the time. This one was really like a, I think when we're seeing these A plot B plots, it's more just a, it's all one plot.

on with this group of people over here and what's going on with this group of people over here as opposed to that traditional different thing you know uh completely separate storylines that may not actually have anything to do with each other it's more like a plot uh three plot what meaning that like there's no direct relationship between them oh i see it's not a and b it's a and three i see i see what you're saying yeah yeah yeah exactly exactly but in this case in this case you have like the a plot which is i feel like you have the a plot which is like the whole story and then you have you know the a plot and then you have like little i over here and like little i2 over there you have the relationship subplot and then you have the two box subplot Right, right. Because, I mean, because obviously the two affect each other with where we're going. So, all right, Matt. Well, I guess that's going to get it for us here with resolutions. Any final thoughts before we get out of here? I think that's about it. All right, Matt.

So what's our next episode going to be, Matt? Our next extra viewing episode for next month in September. You got me. I don't know. We'll figure it out when we get there, though. We got a while. Matt's going to be the one that picks. I can't tell him what to pick. He's the one who makes those. If you guys want to stump for an episode in next month's extra viewing, do that. You know how to email us, guys. BeameUpPod at gmail.com or head over to the website BeameUpPod.com for more, and we'll do that there. Matt, they know how to find you out there on the internet. They know. Hey, the new one, at SCLMatt. They should go check you out there. You can do that. Or I'm at BrennanLive. We'll talk to you later, guys. Live long and prosper.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Beam Me Up: A Star Trek Podcast?

This episode is 1 hour and 10 minutes long.

When was this Beam Me Up: A Star Trek Podcast episode published?

This episode was published on July 4, 2023.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Beam Me Up: A Star Trek Podcast episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.