Gilgo Beach Victims episode artwork

EPISODE · Dec 7, 2025 · 32 MIN

Gilgo Beach Victims

from Criminal · host Vmedia

In this episode, we uncover a terrifying serial murder case in Long Island, where four women—Maurine Brainard Barnes, Melissa Bartelemy, Megan Waterman, and Amber Costelo—were found buried symmetrically at Gilgo Beach in December 2010, after disappearing for years without serious investigation. Shocking unique facts include how the perpetrator, architect Rex Heuerman, used online platforms to target vulnerable women, leaving bodies in neat packages as if following a script, and making anonymous threatening calls to the victims' families. This discovery unfolded after a police dog found the first package, revealing a pattern overlooked for years due to the system's indifference toward women living on society's fringes.In this episode, you'll learn how an investigation delayed for more than a decade finally led to Heuerman's arrest through analysis of telecommunications data, DNA, and his online search history, as well as important lessons about the need to connect missing persons reports and listen to victims' families' voices. This is a story of systemic failures that allowed a predator to operate freely, reminding us to be more vigilant about social vulnerabilities. Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/criminal--6152643/support.This episode includes AI-generated content.

In this episode, we uncover a terrifying serial murder case in Long Island, where four women—Maurine Brainard Barnes, Melissa Bartelemy, Megan Waterman, and Amber Costelo—were found buried symmetrically at Gilgo Beach in December 2010, after disappearing for years without serious investigation. Shocking unique facts include how the perpetrator, architect Rex Heuerman, used online platforms to target vulnerable women, leaving bodies in neat packages as if following a script, and making anonymous threatening calls to the victims' families. This discovery unfolded after a police dog found the first package, revealing a pattern overlooked for years due to the system's indifference toward women living on society's fringes.In this episode, you'll learn how an investigation delayed for more than a decade finally led to Heuerman's arrest through analysis of telecommunications data, DNA, and his online search history, as well as important lessons about the need to connect missing persons reports and listen to victims' families' voices. This is a story of systemic failures that allowed a predator to operate freely, reminding us to be more vigilant about social vulnerabilities. Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/criminal--6152643/support.This episode includes AI-generated content.

NOW PLAYING

Gilgo Beach Victims

0:00 32:10

No transcript for this episode yet

We transcribe on demand. Request one and we'll notify you when it's ready — usually under 10 minutes.

Socialite Crime Club Burning Mountain Productions A new take on true crime, former investigators and successful entrepreneurs, energetically discuss their involvement in criminal cases across the country and what it takes to solve complex investigations. Join your hosts, Sy and Keri Ray, as they delight your insatiable desires for scandalous schemes, disgraceful deeds, secret soiree’s and criminal conspiracies. Explicit Scar Tissue With Fabian Di Marco Fabian Di Marco Scar Tissue is a wandering of conversations with successful, high-achieving people from all walks of life; from the criminal underbelly of the mob to CEO’s of Fortune 500 companies and everything in-between The show is a vessel, a means to learn from the best, from their wins and losses, to in some way become better; in business and in life. Hosted by Fabian Di Marco, entrepreneur and business strategist. Welcome to Scar Tissue. Explicit Who Killed Theresa John Allore This podcast was started in January of 2017, about the unsolved murder of my sister, Theresa Allore, who died on November 3, 1978. The project has grown to include unsolved murders of women in Quebec in the 1970s. Now the podcast is simply about justice issues and criminal investigative failures. www.theresaallore.com @justusguy Explicit Criminal Conduct Creative Babble Criminal Conduct is an investigative true-crime podcast series hosted by John Taylor and Javier Leiva.Season 1: The hosts look into the death of Michelle O'Connell, picking up the investigation where the murdered sleuth, Eli Washtock, left off.Season 2: The investigation of a rogue constable in Kentucky who is accused of planting drugs, stealing money, and shaking people down.Season 3: An American Serial Killer in Paradise: The story of serial killer William Holbert, aka "Wild Bill," and his victims.Season 4: Getting Away with Murder: The Death Investigation of Pravin VarugheseSeason 5: The Life and Death of Buffalo Jim Barrier Explicit

Frequently Asked Questions

How long is this episode of Criminal?

This episode is 32 minutes long.

When was this Criminal episode published?

This episode was published on December 7, 2025.

What is this episode about?

In this episode, we uncover a terrifying serial murder case in Long Island, where four women—Maurine Brainard Barnes, Melissa Bartelemy, Megan Waterman, and Amber Costelo—were found buried symmetrically at Gilgo Beach in December 2010, after...

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Criminal episode?

Yes, you can download this episode by clicking the download button on the episode player, or subscribe to the podcast in your preferred podcast app for automatic downloads.
URL copied to clipboard!