Skip to content
Has Backerkit Launch Lost Its Mojo? episode artwork

Mar 30, 2025 37 min

Has Backerkit Launch Lost Its Mojo?

from ComixLaunch: Crowdfunding for Writers, Artists & Self-Publishers on Kickstarter... and Beyond! Hosted by Tyler James

For years, Backerkit Launch has been a hugely powerful tool for driving funding for veteran crowdfunders. But is the effectiveness of this premium messaging tool waning? Tyler shares some feedback from comics crowdfunding pros and looks at his own metrics to answer this question.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Has Backerkit Launch Lost Its Mojo?

0:00 37:19
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

So, some people are saying, Backerkit Launch isn't hitting like it used to, but what is the data telling us? Comics Launch Session 506. Has Backer Kit Launch lost its mojo? Today's session is brought to you by Gemini Comics Supply. Use discount code COMICS LAUNCH at checkout and get 10% off comic flash mailers at GeminiComicSupply.com. Hey there. Welcome back to another session of the Comics Launch Podcast. This is Tyler James hanging out with you once again. It's a rainy day here in New England, and we...

Got one really good day over the weekend of just that felt like spring is officially here. Went for a bike ride with the boy and enjoyed it. And then, of course, the next day, the temperature drops another 20, 25 degrees. And today is super rainy. So this is one of those spring showers, I suppose. But it's nice that we are officially in spring. And hopefully, I don't know, it's been a long, tough, cold winter. And I'm hoping that spring brings about just, I don't know, nicer days and better news.

For you and for me and for everyone. But I don't know. The rain has definitely hit me with some melancholy. And so I guess that's appropriate for this topic, which could be a little bit of a downer topic or maybe not. We'll see where it ends up. But we're going to talk about.

Backerkit launch and how this tool is doing, whether or not this is still a top recommended tool here in 2025 for comic book creator crowdfunders. If you're unfamiliar with what Backerkit launch is, don't worry, we'll get you all caught up. And if you are a longtime Backerkit launch user, you may have strong feelings about this, or maybe you actually haven't gone and checked the metrics and checked your numbers to see whether or not this is a tool that is still getting the job done. But I'm excited to dive into it. We're going to look at some other creators experience. I sort of crowdsourced some feedback on this topic and I'll share.

some results from what some really great creators that are out there doing this thing and that are using Backerkitter finding. And then I'm also going to share some data from my own most recent launch comparing... Backerkit launch effectiveness now and in the past. And so hopefully you'll come away from this episode with a really strong update on what's going on with this tool and whether or not you might want to be using it in the future. And I'm also going to share just some high level things to consider about this sort of state of play here in 2025 for comp creators and crowdfunders. So if that sounds good to you, let's dive right in. So this was actually a topic that

came up based on a comment from a creator inside the Comics Launch Pro community. If you're new to the podcast, Comics Launch Pro is the private training community that I've run since 2016 for comic book creators and crowd funders looking to go deep on mastering of Kickstarter and audience building and launching and getting their comics out into the world. And so this creator is actually, in terms of total funding raised, he, I believe, has the top total funding raised. He's in the million dollar plus club in terms of the projects that he has launched. I've raised well over a million dollars now and it's just continuing to grow. And that's a creator named Aldrich Stibor. He was one of the masterminds behind the Colorpedia and just has done a number of tremendous projects.

He shared a comment in the group where he said, I want to mention something that some of you may find helpful. The launch product offered by Backerkit has lost its efficacy completely. Have you been noticing like a 2% open rate? If so, you're not alone. It's been acknowledged to me directly by the head of the accounts at Backerkit that it's happening to everyone across the board because of the way Google is parsing those messages into spam folders and the like.

He said, I noticed that Tyler and some of you have already made the switch or at least starting additionally sending your newsletters and campaign marketing efforts out from Substack. I've personally seen my open rate go from 2% to 50% by making that switch. Problem with Launch's low open rate was driving me cuckoo bananas. So just figured I'd share that here. And then he shared a little bit of context for Congress Launch Pro members. But the gist of it is, is that Backerkit launch was not working for him.

And if that is the case, that this thing has completely lost its efficacy, I'm going to mess up that word every time, completely lost its efficacy, it doesn't work anymore, then that's something that we should all know about, right? Now, if you're scratching your head and saying, wait, what's this Backerkit launch thing again? And if you have never heard of Backerkit launch, I suggest you go listen to Comics Launch Session 299. In that episode, I do a deep, detailed review of the Backerkit launch product from Backerkit. Now, Backerkit is most known for its pledge manager and has, over the past couple of years, launched a crowdfunding competitor to Kickstarter that we've talked about on this podcast before. But the launch tool is one of the tools that is their most affordable tool that they offer and is just a highly useful tool in that it does something that pretty much no other tool that I know of on the planet can do. And that is that Backerkit launch is a way that you can import all of your backers from Kickstarter from all of your projects.

And you can do this not only from all of your projects under one account, but if you happen to manage multiple Kickstarter accounts, well, you can pick and choose which projects you want in a certain Backerkit launch account. In fact, you can even create multiple launch accounts. So let's say you had two or three different brands that were pooling projects from five or six different Kickstarter campaigns. Or if you're a publisher and you happen to work with a bunch of different creators that sometimes launch with you and sometimes launch on their own. Well, Backerkit launch gives you this ability to connect all of the crowdfunding that might be related to.

your next project and then import directly all of those backers from all of those disparate projects into one primary backer list and then you'll have data on that backer list and then you'll and backer kit launch if you pay the one-time $99 fee which gives you access to send messages through that tool for 60 days once you do that you can deliver a message directly to all of those backers that will go through backer kit launch and will end up in their inboxes. And then it will track the results of those emails in terms of who is opening those emails and whether or not the people getting those emails are actually pledging to those emails. And the other super cool thing about that is that the backer kit launch will know whether someone has backed your current project or not, and then it will let you not.

send messages to that audience. So it's kind of can filter that audience out. And that's something that as far as I know, there's no other tool that does all of those things. And so you might be thinking, well, hey, you know, if I've got people on Kickstarter, I can message them through Kickstarter. That's true. If I have people that and then I can actually get people to sign up for my email list and then I can pull all those people into my email list and I can send messages that way. Yeah, that's true as well. But not everyone who's on your Kickstarter is going to opt in to join your email list. And then on Kickstarter still to.

to this day, you can only message by project. And so you can't in anywhere on Kickstarter pool all of your backers into just one central backer list and communicate with them. Now, honestly, I wouldn't be surprised if that's something that Kickstarter addresses, given that that's one of the most requested features for forever. And they seem to be hell bent on addressing all of their most requested features and improving their platform lately. But we'll see if that ends up becoming something that they enable.

But even with the ability to contact your past backers through Kickstarter or through your email list, the one thing that you don't have the ability to do very easily is to then filter out people that have already backed the project that's live. You don't get access to emails of your backers until after the campaign is over. So there's no real way that you can filter people out once they've backed your project. And so that is one of the cool things that backend launch can do. I've talked in the past about how Backerkit launch, especially for creators that have multiple campaigns and hundreds or thousands of backers that have backed projects in the past, the $99 one-time fee to use Backerkit launch for a campaign often is among the highest return on investment, things that you can do to market your campaign. And we've gotten some sort of insane returns in terms of the pledges that come from Backerkit launch.

messages specifically. And so I've, you know, since that first review of Backerkit launch, you know, I shared that I thought it was one of the highest return on investment tools that you can use during a Kickstarter campaign. But here's Aldrich saying it's completely lost its effectiveness for him. And so I wanted to not just check my own data, but also see if other creators are seeing the same thing. So I just posted the simple question on social, is Backerkit launch still working for you? And then because again,

on this show and just a general practice, we try to stay focused on the metrics as opposed to just what our gut is telling us. And I said, I added, what are your metrics showing? And so I immediately started getting some responses. I'm definitely some people interested in this. John Schlimm Jr. said, very interested to hear more observations. I've been dormant for two years. And as I gear up for relaunch, this is really important to know. Backerkit launch was noticeably beneficial for me in the past. So shout out to John. Hope he is doing well and excited to see him get back into the swing of launching after having a lot of success over the past decade.

Travis Gibb said, I am feeling the same. Tyler, I'll give you a breakdown after the campaign, but I think it may just be the economy. And so Aldrich added some color here. He said, BaggerKit launch has always been a big part of our success, but it's more or less useless the last couple of campaigns. And so it'll be interesting to see how some other metrics come up. Rob Maltari says it still helps raise funds, but not as much as it used to. The open rates have dropped. I believe it's because they use the same domain for creators instead of letting us set up our own so they look spammy. So Rob offers a view as to why it might not be working as well. Matt Knowles had a similar comment. He said it still helps.

But I think there are two factors, and Rob touched on one. Many people use it without adjusting the headers, and they just use the default templates that BackRocket provides, so it looks like a spammerific white noise. You must really differentiate your messages to have a chance. And then he also said even their posts get caught in spam filters now and go into folders that people might not even see in Gmail, so that really hinders usability. He does say it's a must-use still, but the effectiveness is way down.

John Cracky says, I don't have a huge history with it, but I feel it was more helpful with completing my five-part series than it has been jumping over to a new horror comic from crime. I'll have to look at the stats, but it hasn't felt effective for my current campaign. And so, yeah, this is one of those things that should be noted when it comes to backer kit launch. When you're putting together a pool of backers, the amount in which your next project is similar to the last project or the projects that those backers came from and supported. is probably going to have one of the strongest correlations in terms of will they come back and will they back again, and thus how effective that backer kit launch would be. So you might expect if you're someone like Rob Maltari, who has two primary series and they're both werewolf related, that he might have a very strong returning backer rate versus someone that might jump around from genre to genre, age range, style of project, et cetera. And so that will make a difference in its effectiveness for sure. Ryland Grant said, it's down for me big time.

But everything's down slash less effective, and launch is still the most useful tool. So I think Ryland's sort of reflecting that same sentiment that Rob kind of shared, where the economy, the uneasiness, just feeling like stuff is tough right now, but not necessarily that it's just BaggerKit launch, and that it still is useful. Charlie Stigney said, I think a lot of those emails are going to junk. I know my old Hotmail account, which I used for pledging, flags all of them. I also think so many creators are doing six-plus launches a year, so there are only so many dollars to go around. So Charlie definitely speaking to...

something that we've been seeing in terms of launch volume and the number of creators that are sort of creator slash publishers that have multiple series that are launching, you know, not even multiple times a year, but in some cases, multiple times a quarter. And so there you have it. Caleb Palmquist, who just wrapped up another very successful campaign over 500 backers for his latest Dragon Grit. Congrats to Caleb. He said, it's worth it for what it costs. I also don't know for sure which backers come from what. According to back at launch for my current campaign, I had a 50% open rate and launch is responsible for 5,900 of my current 15,700 in funding.

My open rate for emails on my mailing list is about 40% on average from a 2,600 list. Launch has me at about 3,600 total. So my open rate percentage and actual number of opens is higher on Backerkit. I'll have to look back and see if it used to be more effective or not compared to old campaigns. In response to Charlie Sidney's comments, I'm running nine to 12 campaigns a year. I'm no Shander tenor, but I'm launching a lot. So I am being a lot more judicious with my emails and Backerkit launch emails for each campaign. I try not to dip into the well too often. He also said, I don't really edit the launch emails at all, by the way, other than just replace a bit of text they ask you to replace.

Charlie also jumped back in just to clarify that he wasn't knocking people that multiple that back and launch multiple times a year just that that may be having an effect to the market. And they came back with some data. He said. He sent three emails with Backerkit launch. Email one had a 37% open rate and an 8% click rate. Email two, 44% open rate and a 9% click rate. And email three, which was the last two days, had a 33% open rate and a 3% click rate. He also just chimed in saying, well, it's still worth it. The value is way down versus 18 months ago when I was getting a 50% average open rate and a 13% click through rate. And so, yeah. So there's some actual data there from some creators, which was awesome to hear. And it was good to hear that the consensus.

was actually not what Aldrich was seeing for himself, that it had completely lost its effectiveness, but rather that it has gone down some, but is still a valuable tool. And I decided to go analyze my own data because I had just wrapped a sync campaign. And sync is an ongoing series that we've done multiple campaigns for. And the nice thing about this is I had a really good opportunity to compare like with like. because I was able to pull a sync campaign from four years ago or nearly four years ago. That was the campaign for dig number one. And what I want to do is just compare the performance of dig number one using backer kit launch and sync volume three using backer kit launch.

The campaign back in 2021 for DIG was one of our more successful campaigns in terms of backer count. The DIG number one raised $35,884 on 570 backers. And so that was actually a much more backed campaign than the one we just wrapped. And that may be related to just the fact that the series is a little bit later. This DIG was a clean jumping on point for a number one versus the sync volume three. There could be a number of factors at play here.

When I looked specifically at the Backerkit launch details, dig number one, Backerkit launch had the emails sent, had a 50.5% open rate, an 18.2% click rate, and a pledge rate of 8.8%. Now, the click rate is of people that opened, and the pledge rate is of people that opened as well. The average pledge amount per person on that list that it was sent to was $3.14. And in total, we sent... For dig number one, there was about 2,363 people on the list. 1,194 people opened. 218 of them clicked. 222 of them responded, meaning took some kind of action, either followed or pledged. And then 105 of them pledged for $7,415. And so if you look at that, the return on the investment of $99 for dig.

number one was about 74.9 times in terms of pledge amount divided by the cost to use the tool. So we were very happy with that back in 2021. Now, if you compare that to what Sync City of Killers did... is in looking at the data, we actually had a slightly higher open rate of 53.2%. The click rate was a little bit lower, 16.6%. The pledge rate was definitely lower, 2.5% down from 8.8%. The pledge per contact, because we actually had a lot more contacts four years later, was $1.07. So for everybody on this list, they were worth about $1.07 a piece. And we ended up raising a total of $4,918 on 63 pledges.

from Backerkit, which shows a return on investment of 49.7x. So if you compare them side by side, you're seeing kind of a big dip in the performance metrics, total pledges, total amount raised, pledge per contact on the list, and return on investment. But there are a few things that you're going to do in life that are going to give you a 49.7x return on your investment. A few things you're going to do in your marketing life that's going to perform that well. So my take is that, yes, the performance.

has gone down. Yes, it is less effective than it was four years ago, but Backerkit launch is still one of the best tools in a veteran Kickstarter's toolbox. I have a few more thoughts for you after the break. In a moment, I'm going to give you today's comics launcher. But first, we need to thank our sponsor. Hey, are you getting ready to ship rewards to all your awesome backers? With more than a decade of publishing under my belt, I've shipped my fair share of comics and graphic novels over the years, so you can bet I was shocked to realize I'd been doing it wrong. One of the most overlooked aspects of the Kickstarter process is your shipping materials, which is a shame because how your package arrives is often the last impression your campaign will make on a backer and will be a big factor in whether they choose to support you again. And yet, I can't tell you how many creators are out there disappointing their backers by shipping comics and graphic novels in shoddy packaging. Now, for the longest time, I was using and recommending rigid stay-flat mailers for comic shipping, only to hear back from...

some upset fans that their packages were decimated by a mail carrier who must hate them. No more though. I now use Comic Flash mailers from Gemini Comics Apply and the shipping complaints have all gone away. Comic Flash mailers are engineered specifically to secure comics and graphic novels. They're constructed with high quality durable corrugated paper while still being lightweight to reduce shipping costs. Each mailer has a flexible capacity and is perfect for shipping a single bagged and board issue all the way up to 12 bagged and board comics or a few graphic novels in a single package. And here's a pro tip for you, especially for those of you guys in the US. Comic Flash mailers will slip comfortably into a flat rate legal envelope which can save you up to 50% or more on the

cost of shipping domestically, depending upon the weight of the package, of course. Now, I reached out to Brian Kelly at Gemini, and I told him I was a huge fan of his company, and I secured a special deal for comics launch listeners looking to upgrade their shipping game. Just use coupon code COMICSLAUNCH at checkout at GeminiComicsSupply.com, and you'll get 10% off your very first order over at Gemini, and you will be able to treat your books and your backers with the care they deserve. All right, your comics launcher for session. 506 is to go and take a look at your backer kit launch metrics.

How has the effectiveness changed over time? And is this still a product that you are going to be using? All right. So just a few more thoughts on Backerkit launch and its use for crowdfunders. I'll still be using the tool unless Kickstarter comes out with an alternative at some point. I will still be using the Backerkit launch tool for the foreseeable future, but I will continue to monitor these metrics because I think that is an important thing to do. And this is something that I think we just need to recognize as creators and marketers and brand builders is that most

Tools, strategies, they do sort of follow a pattern of suddenly working amazing. And then eventually the effectiveness will wane or dip a while. But rarely will it go completely to zero. And I think that's the case with so many things. You know, there was a time when.

There's a time when you can actually get like a ton of backing from Twitter. And I know that there are some, you know, you could actually see like a tweets effectiveness at driving pledges. Whereas nowadays sending people off Twitter to a link, the algorithm is such that it deprioritizes so much that I don't know that there is all that much value in posting on most organic social media platforms. And so we have to sort of pivot and we have to be just pay attention to the numbers and be wary that. the things that work for one campaign are not always going to be as effective as the next campaign. That doesn't mean I would throw them out. It doesn't mean I would stop doing them completely. And I do think there are some things with like, whether it's AI or screening tools that email clients are using, that it might be more difficult for a tool like Backerkit launch that is sort of like there specifically for the people without a lot of...

marketing savvy. It provides a really easy tool for the creator that maybe doesn't even have a MailChimp account or their own email marketing service. It just lets them hop on and put really targeted messages in front of an audience that's most likely to take action on them. It does it really easy well, but because there's a tool that can be used by so many and is used by so many now. It also would be the kind of tool that sophisticated spam algorithms might really easily catch. You know, the fact that, as many said, they just sort of take the templates that Backerkit provides and barely edits them, you know, changes their project name in, but just lets it ride as is. That is the kind of thing that probably would get caught in a spam filter much easier than something else. And so I would recommend that you do what you can with your Backerkit launch.

marketing emails to make them a little bit more unique and don't just use the boilerplate template. Add your own subject lines. Try some things to make it stand out a little bit or to make it not blend in so much. And so that would be one piece of advice or action you can take based on what myself and many comics launch pros are seeing. The other thing is I have been trying to think and trying to focus on thinking about not just relying on the same old stuff every single time.

While it is wonderful when you go into a launch that you can just say, you know, these are things that I can do that I know work. I would still always focus and put 80 to 85 to 90% of your effort on the stuff that has been tried and true. But remember to also always try to. take a few new swings, try to try something new and it might not work, but you know, backer kit launch, there was a time when that was something that I was like, I was skeptical of it and I wasn't sure that it would make sense, but it was worth the 99 bucks to give it a try. And it turned out to be, you know, an incredible investment. And so the reality is though, is I don't think that.

all of the incredible investments or the incredible ROI opportunities that will ever exist have already been created. There are probably some new ones that people are just discovering, whether that might be finding your audience on Blue Sky or starting up a Discord and then incorporating some of the other cool tools of secret rewards for this one audience that you only have. I don't know exactly what it's going to be or what the next big thing is going to be, but I'll tell you. I'll tell you as soon as I hear it. And if you've been tuning in long enough, you know that I'm pretty good about sharing what works. That's what we're all here for. So anyway, those are just a few thoughts for you. But if you're thinking about bailing on Backerkit launch, make sure that it's a decision not based on what you're hearing or what you're feeling or what others are feeling.

making sure that its edition isn't based on the metrics. For me, and for most of the creators that I've talked to, the metrics say that, eh, this tool isn't the silver bullet that it once might have felt like, or isn't this like a magical tool that at one point it felt like. But hey, the numbers don't lie. It is still driving traffic. It is still getting messages in front of people that are most likely to take action on them. And it's still something that we're going to invest in in the future. Thank you so much for listening. Let me walk with you to take another step forward towards your next successful comics launch.

Looking for something new? These projects just launched on Kickstarter. I have great cover artists. I have Marcelo Salazar. He did the interior work. Andy did covers. I have Tiago Barca. He did the illustration. I have Famo who did a cover. I have Andy Duso. He did another cover. Yeah, but I appreciate coming on here. Let me come on here so I can tell the story. It's my first campaign. So I have from anywhere from 10 to 500. 500 gets all the covers. Gets a whole bunch. Like one of each cover. Virgin, foil, metal of each of the covers. Plus he has a CGC 9.8. New York Comic Con Winner exclusive preview book.

You know, first 15 backers get the New York Comic Con, just a regular wall copy as well. Yeah, thank you, though. Hi, Comics Launch. This is Holly from Topatico, and I'm excited to tell you that Senna Diaz, the creator of the webcomic Dresden Kodak, has a new book live on Kickstarter. Dark Science is a queer cyberpunk comic that sort of Metropolis meets Ghost in the Shell meets Discworld. The City of Giants collects the first arc of the series, plus the bonus comics Mezzo Time with Kim Ross and Kingdom of the Last, with over 120 lavishly painted gigantic pages. Check it out on Kickstarter today.

Hello, Comics Launch. This is Kurt Zauer, creator of Ruxy Vampire, issues one through two, live on Kickstarter. Ruxy Vampire is the story of Dracula's granddaughter waking up in Prohibition-era Chicago with no idea how she got there. Thirsty for blood, booze, gambling, and excitement, she ventures out into a dangerous and supernatural world of organized crime. If you're a fan of action shows with a dash of sexy like Game of Thrones, Spartacus, Banshee, or Warrior, then check out Ruxy Vampire, live on Kickstarter. Hello, Comics Launch. This is Jon Wanslack, creator of Bolt Voltage Out of Sync, live on Kickstarter. Out of Sync is a story about a discovery droid in a post-human Earth that, through natural selection, begins to emulate emotions and spark life within. If you're a fan of Short Circuit, the Iron Giant, and WALL-E, then you should check out Bolt Voltage Out of Sync on Kickstarter today.

Hi, Comics Launch. This is Tinseltown creator David Luccarelli, here to tell you about my new comic that's live on Kickstarter until April 21st. Dr. Zamba's Ghostly Tales is a classic horror anthology in the vein of EC Comics and The Twilight Zone with a modern edge. Three terrifying tales from the past, the present, and an uncertain future. Ghostly Tales is a 42-page, full-color, double-sized, floppy comic book with a free ghost inside every issue. But be warned, everyone who buys this comic will die.

Hello, Comics Launch. My name is John Kratky, author of the graphic novel The Long Death, an 80-page gothic fairy tale funding on Kickstarter now. Victor and Iris escape their village, which has been scorched by plague. In search of sanctuary, the children learn there may be greater horrors awaiting them when they are captured by the butcher and the old crone. Will these cannibals be making a new batch of stew? Or will their prisoners take bloody revenge? Find out in The Long Death, where Hansel and Gretel meet the Texas Chainsaw Massacre. If you find this story making your skin crawl and keeping you up all night, just repeat to yourself. It's only a comic book.

It's only a comic book. The Long Death, fully funded and looking for new readers. Back on Kickstarter now. Are you a Comics Launch listener with a project that's launched or about to launch on Kickstarter? Tell us about it at comicslaunch.com forward slash voicemail and we might just feature it on our show.

Hey, before I go, I wanted to check to see if you've requested your free offset and digital print sample pack from ComicImpressions.com yet. A few months ago, I asked Rich at Comic Impressions to put together a few hundred free printing sample packs for Comics Launch listeners, and they immediately started flying out the doors. In fact, Rich has printed up a bunch more, and he's ready to ship them, so you should definitely request yours if you haven't already. I've already put in a few Comics Tribe orders with Comic Impressions so far, and I'm about to put in another big one soon, and I definitely recommend you check out their free samples. And if you decide to get a quote from them, know that you'll also get 5% off your order when you mention Comics Launch. It's never too early to start communicating with your printers, so head over to ComicImpressions.com.

Thank you so much for listening, and I can't wait to see what you launch next week.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of ComixLaunch: Crowdfunding for Writers, Artists & Self-Publishers on Kickstarter... and Beyond!?

This episode is 37 minutes long.

When was this ComixLaunch: Crowdfunding for Writers, Artists & Self-Publishers on Kickstarter... and Beyond! episode published?

This episode was published on March 30, 2025.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this ComixLaunch: Crowdfunding for Writers, Artists & Self-Publishers on Kickstarter... and Beyond! episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.