How a Paper Bag Overturned a Conviction
from Swear on the Stand Hosted by Daniel W. Swear
In State v. Mardeontae J. Lee, the Supreme Court of Louisiana reviewed the convictions of a defendant found guilty of aggravated arson and three counts of attempted first-degree murder after he poured gasoline around a home and ignited a paper bag. The majority reversed all convictions, ruling that the evidence failed to prove the statutory definition of a "movable" for arson and lacked sufficient circumstantial proof of the specific intent to kill required for attempted murder. While the Chief Justice concurred by emphasizing the separation between criminal intent (mens rea) and physical acts (actus reus), a dissenting judge argued that a rational jury was justified in inferring murderous intent from the defendant's dangerous actions. Ultimately, the court ordered the discharge of the defendant due to insufficient evidence and the absence of valid lesser responsive verdicts.
Embed this episode
No transcript yet.