Episodes
-
The Million Dollar Hurricane Clean-Up
Following Hurricane Laura, Poor Boy Tree Service and Mobile Help 4U performed unpaid disaster recovery work for the City of Winnfield, subsequently suing the municipality for breach of an open account. Although the district court ruled that the mayor lacked the independent authority to form a...
-
Qualified Immunity At Harding Street
This appellate court decision addresses a tragic qualified immunity appeal stemming from a botched Houston Police Department no-knock raid on January 28, 2019, which resulted in the fatal shootings of Dennis Tuttle and Rhogena Nicholas alongside multiple wounded officers. The Fifth Circuit...
-
Can Parents Refuse a School IQ Test
A federal appeals court addressed a legal dispute involving a young child with Down syndrome and a school district, focusing on the interpretation of parental consent under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act. The majority ruled that the child's parents failed to provide valid consent...
-
Government Kills Pfizer COVID Vaccine Whistleblower Suit
The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed a lower court's decision allowing the United States government to intervene in and dismiss a False Claims Act (FCA) whistleblower lawsuit filed by Brook Jackson against Ventavia Research Group and others regarding COVID-19 vaccine trial integrity. The...
-
Why Louisiana’s Rape Kit Tracker Fails
This episode discusses an official evaluation published by the Louisiana Legislative Auditor regarding Louisiana’s Sexual Assault Kit Tracking System and the procedures used by law enforcement to investigate potential DNA matches in the CODIS database. The report highlights significant…
more -
Why The Law Has Historically Rejected Lie Detectors
This episode presents an overview of the American judicial system, outlining the hierarchical structure of federal and state courts alongside the fundamental protections established by the Sixth Amendment. They detail legal procedures and evidentiary standards, including the rules governing…
more -
How OGL Rumors Destroyed Kymoria
This Fifth Circuit legal case centers on a contractual dispute between Shawn Thomas and his company, The Tabletop Adventure, against Leyline Publishing and its affiliates regarding the collaborative development and marketing of a therapeutic tabletop role-playing game called Realms of Kymoria....
-
Clase Azul Battles Casa Azul Over Tequila
This federal appellate court case involves a trademark infringement dispute between two premium tequila producers, Casa Tradición (selling Clase Azul) and Casa Azul Spirits. After a bench trial resulted in a judgment favoring the defendant, the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals reviewed the decision...
-
Why a Procedural Error Didn’t Save Herndon
Desnique Deshawn Herndon challenged his federal sex trafficking convictions by arguing that the trial court improperly altered his original indictment through jury instructions regarding the victims' ages. Although both sides acknowledged that a constructive amendment occurred, the Fifth Circuit...
-
How a Paper Bag Overturned a Conviction
In State v. Mardeontae J. Lee, the Supreme Court of Louisiana reviewed the convictions of a defendant found guilty of aggravated arson and three counts of attempted first-degree murder after he poured gasoline around a home and ignited a paper bag. The majority reversed all convictions, ruling…
more -
How a Judge's Overreach Saved UPS
In United Parcel Service v. Benitez De Chavez, the Fifth Circuit addressed a federal diversity jurisdiction dispute regarding whether a district court could sua sponte remand a case to state court due to a pleading flaw. The appellate court established that while residency and citizenship are...
-
Fifth Circuit Blocks Motorola 5G Discovery
The United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit reviewed a dispute where Motorola sought U.S. discovery under 28 U.S.C. § 1782 to obtain an unredacted patent purchase agreement from Advanced Standard Communication (ASC) for use in ongoing European patent litigation. Although the Unified...
-
Why Federal Appeal Waivers Rarely Break
Rashon Harris appealed his 240-month prison sentence for a methamphetamine conviction after the Fifth Circuit previously dismissed his case based on an appeal waiver. Following the Supreme Court's ruling in Hunter v. United States—which established that appeal waivers are unenforceable only if…
more -
How Dashcams Took Power From Juries in 2007
In Scott v. Harris, the Supreme Court of the United States addressed whether a police officer used unconstitutionally excessive force by ramming a fleeing motorist's car to end a dangerous high-speed pursuit. The petitioner deputy argued that his actions were necessary to protect the public from...
-
Fifth Circuit Rejects Qualified Immunity For Retaliation
In Eva Kristine Stramaski v. Mark Lawley, the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit addressed whether a public supervisor can claim qualified immunity in a retaliation lawsuit filed under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA). After Eva Stramaski disputed potential paycheck delays…
more -
Why a Deepwater Horizon Worker Lost
The Fifth Circuit affirmed a lower court's decision to exclude the plaintiff's expert witnesses and grant summary judgment in favor of BP in a toxic tort lawsuit arising from the 2010 Deepwater Horizon oil spill. The plaintiff, Richard DuFour, Jr., alleged that toxic exposure during cleanup work...
-
Train Conductor Beats Union Pacific Wordplay
The Fifth Circuit reversed the district court's dismissal of James Bien's lawsuit against Union Pacific Railroad Company, concluding that his claims were protected by American Pipe tolling. Bien had previously worked as a conductor before receiving a color vision restriction, and he later sought...
-
How Junk Polygraphs Convicted Emmanuel Mervilus
In Mervilus v. Union County, the Third Circuit evaluated a wrongful conviction lawsuit brought by Emmanuel Mervilus, who spent over a decade in prison after being convicted using disputed polygraph evidence. The appellate court vacated the district court's summary judgment in favor of the...
-
Can Schools Punish a Refused Handshake?
This federal appeals court case centers on a lawsuit filed by Marc Lucio, a teacher and coach, alongside his family against the Brownsville Independent School District and multiple administrators following two distinct controversies. The first dispute involved an investigation into Lucio's son,...
-
Court Rules Eyewear Tracking Is Wiretapping
In Rachelle Rand v. Eyemart Express, L.L.C., the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit reversed a lower court's dismissal of a class action lawsuit filed by Facebook users whose private health information was allegedly shared with Meta without their consent. The Plaintiffs argued...
-
Fifth Circuit Denies Immigrant Bond Hearings
This case concerns the en banc review of consolidated habeas corpus petitions filed by three unadmitted aliens who were detained by immigration authorities under 8 U.S.C. § 1225(b)(2)(A) pending their removal proceedings. The Petitioners argued that their prolonged detention without…
more -
Why Jose Estrada Remains Under Federal Supervision
This episode outlines a Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals decision regarding an appellant named Jose Estrada, who contested the jurisdiction of a Texas district court after his supervised release was transferred from Pennsylvania. Estrada argued that the transfer was invalid because a separate…
more -
Judge Removed After AI Hallucinates DEI Ruling
The United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit reviewed a preliminary injunction that had blocked the enforcement of Mississippi House Bill 1193, a state statute designed to restrict diversity, equity, and inclusion funding and mandates in public education. The appellate court vacated…
more -
The Lawsuit Over Secret FEMA Disaster Rules
This appellate court ruling addresses a long-standing legal battle between La Unión del Pueblo Entero (LUPE) and the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) regarding transparency in disaster relief. LUPE alleged that FEMA systematically violated the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA)...
-
How the Second Amendment Saved Switchblades
In a recent Fifth Circuit decision, the court evaluated a Second Amendment challenge against the federal restrictions on switchblade knives. The judges determined that switchblades qualify as protected arms, meaning the government bears the burden of proving that the ban aligns with historical...
-
Water Taxi or Floating Office?
This federal appellate case centers on whether a Master Service Agreement between Quality Process Services and Whitney Oil and Gas qualifies as a maritime contract. Because the agreement involved oilfield staffing rather than direct maritime work, the court determined that the contract is...
-
When the FBI Shot a Bound Hostage
This United States Court of Appeals case addresses a tragic hostage rescue incident where a federal agent accidentally shot and killed the bound hostage, Ulises Valladares, during a tactical operation in Houston, Texas. Following a bench trial, the district court found the government liable under...
-
How US Courts Denied Afghan Protection
The federal appeals court denied an Afghan native's petitions seeking protection under the Convention Against Torture, alongside requests to reconsider his case or remand it for new evidence. The petitioner, who previously worked for the Afghan Ministry of Education and participated in...
-
Why Appeal Waivers Protect Botched Sentences
Following a Supreme Court remand, the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals evaluated whether an appeal waiver should be set aside for Devin Chaney, who challenged his sentence. Although Chaney argued that his classification as a career offender and the trial court's swift dismissal of his objection...
-
How an Unconstitutional Law Silenced Free Speech
In Joy Banner v. Michael Wright et al., the plaintiff appealed a lower court's refusal to grant a new trial following a unanimous jury verdict against her in a First Amendment lawsuit. Banner had been silenced at a public parish meeting after attempting to discuss a pending ethics complaint…
more -
Texas Blocks Chinese Solar Grid Access
In GH America Energy, L.L.C. v. Fohn, the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit addressed whether the federal Committee on Foreign Investment in the United States (CFIUS) regime preempts the Texas Lone Star Infrastructure Protection Act (LSIPA). GH America Energy, a subsidiary of a...
-
Diners Can Sue Over Fake Snapper
The Fifth Circuit considered an appeal regarding whether a customer, Todd McCain, suffered a valid Article III injury after purchasing what he believed was local premium seafood at a restaurant that secretly substituted it with imported frozen fish. Previously, restaurant executives and suppliers...
-
Court Rules FCC Phone Fee Illegal
In this federal appellate court case, the Fifth Circuit evaluated a challenge to the Federal Communications Commission regarding its Universal Service Fund contribution rates. The petitioners, which included various corporate entities and individual consumers, argued that the agency unlawfully...
-
How a Broker Pocketed Thirteen Million Dollars
The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals reviewed a legal dispute involving SEACOR Marine and GOL, a maritime broker that secured vessel charters for oil and gas companies like Cox Operating. After Cox filed for bankruptcy, it issued a $13 million partial payment toward GOL’s massive prepetition claim,...
-
How a Spreadsheet Busted a Fraudulent Chiropractor
Chiropractor Benjamin Tekippe appealed his conviction and sentence for multiple counts of health care fraud and wire fraud involving Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Louisiana. Investigators discovered that Tekippe routinely submitted identical service codes, charged more for massage therapy than…
more -
Ginnie Mae’s Extinguishment of Mortgage Tails
This legal dispute centers on a federal appeal regarding mortgage-backed securities and the authority of Ginnie Mae to extinguish a bankrupt lender's mortgage interests. When a reverse mortgage issuer defaulted, Ginnie Mae assumed control of the underlying loans, which effectively wiped out a...
-
Hogan v. FCI La Tuna Case Manager
A federal appeals court affirmed the dismissal of a habeas corpus petition filed by prisoner Dennis Michael Hogan, who sought First Step Act time credits for the period between his sentencing and his arrival at his designated Bureau of Prisons facility. Hogan argued that he was entitled to accrue...
-
Appliance Efficiency Standards and Federal Jurisdiction
In Bill Word v. U.S. Department of Energy, appliance consumers appealed a lower court's dismissal of their lawsuit challenging federal energy and water-consumption rules for dishwashers and clothes washers. The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals first determined that the plaintiffs possessed proper...
-
Winter Storm Uri Contract Dispute
In a legal battle concerning a natural gas supply contract, MIECO, L.L.C. appealed a district court decision favoring producer Pioneer Natural Resources USA, Inc. after Winter Storm Uri disrupted deliveries. Following an earlier appellate remand, the lower court conducted a bench trial and...
-
Navejas v. City of El Paso
Debbie Navejas filed a lawsuit as the representative of her deceased father, Armando Navejas, against Officer Steven Jaso and the City of El Paso following a tragic domestic-violence response where Armando was tased and subsequently died. The United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit...
-
United States v. Koan
The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals reviewed the federal sentence of David Daniel Koan, who was convicted of producing child pornography after serving nearly forty months in Texas state custody for a related sexual assault. During his federal sentencing, defense counsel requested a sentence...
-
Frankfort v. Metropolis Technologies
In Frankfort v. Metropolis Technologies, the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals reviewed a lower court's dismissal of a class-action lawsuit filed by drivers Curtis Goodban and Todd Frankfort against parking technology company Metropolis Technologies. The plaintiffs claimed that Metropolis violated…
more -
Phillips v. Ethicon Endo-Surgery
In these consolidated appeals, the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit reviewed two related Texas products liability cases arising from a patient's tragic death following colon surgery involving a surgical stapler and staples. The plaintiffs, consisting of the decedent's widow…
more -
Fifth Circuit Trade Secrets Appeal
The United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit issued a ruling in an intellectual property dispute between Pittsburgh Logistics Systems and Glen Rose Transportation Management. The appellate court affirmed the lower court's judgment that dismissed the plaintiff's trade secret and unjust...
-
United States v. Serna
In United States v. Luis Andres Serna, the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed the lower court's decision denying the defendant a jury instruction regarding the age of his victim. Serna had argued that under 18 U.S.C. § 2251(a), the government was required to prove he knew the victim was a...
-
Domanic v. Christian Brothers Automotive
The Fifth Circuit considered an appeal regarding whether a faith-based auto-repair franchise that exclusively partners with professing Christians unlawfully discriminated against Evan Domanic, an ethnic and religious Jew, by denying him a franchise. Domanic sued under 42 U.S.C. § 1981, arguing…
more -
Denial of Certificate of Appealability for Gerald Marshall
This episode discusses a formal opinion from the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit regarding the capital murder case of Gerald Marshall. After Marshall was sentenced to death for a 2003 robbery and shooting, he sought a certificate of appealability to challenge several...
-
Unconstitutional Interstate Handgun Sales: The Fifth Circuit Opinion
In Elite Precision Customs L.L.C. v. ATF, the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals invalidated federal laws that prohibit the interstate sale and delivery of handguns to nonresidents. The court determined that because the Second Amendment protects the right to acquire firearms, any categorical ban on...
-
United States v. Chaney: Enforcing the Appeal Waiver Standard
In this judicial opinion, the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals reaffirms the dismissal of Devin Chaney's appeal regarding his sentencing as a career offender. Following a remand from the Supreme Court, the court examined whether a new "miscarriage of justice" exception could invalidate Chaney’s...
-
Crawford v. West Texas A&M University Retaliation Ruling
This episode details a retaliation lawsuit filed by Nathan Crawford, a former police officer at West Texas A&M University. The case centers on Crawford’s claim that he was disciplined and forced out of his job after corroborating sexual misconduct allegations against a fellow officer. While a…
more
About this show
Court decisions are complex and difficult to digest. This podcast is designed to educating listeners on current legal decisions in a fun and interesting way. Researched by me and produced with the assistance of AI.
Hosted by
Daniel W. Swear
Categories