Skip to content
How Substance Abuse Impacts Divorce with Aaron Thomas episode artwork

Aug 5, 2020 24 min

How Substance Abuse Impacts Divorce with Aaron Thomas

from Divorce Dialogues Hosted by Katherine Miller

Substance abuse adds another layer of complexity to the divorce process. So, what do you need to consider if you’re divorcing an addict? And what if you’re struggling with alcoholism or drug abuse yourself? Attorney Aaron Thomas is the Founder of Aaron Thomas Law, a family law practice based in Atlanta, Georgia. Aaron began his legal career in 2002 as an in-house staff attorney for Habitat for Humanity International. He also served as a trial attorney in the Dekalb County Public Defender’s office for four years before starting his own practice and shifting his focus exclusively to family law in 2007. On this episode of Divorce Dialogues, Aaron joins Katherine to discuss how substance abuse impacts the divorce process. He explains how drug addiction and alcoholism affect a judge’s decision-making around child custody, child support, division of assets and spousal support. Listen in to understand how Aaron handles a case differently when he represents the addicted party and learn what you should think about as the spouse of an addict considering divorce. Topics Covered Why substance abuse is rarely used as grounds for divorce even if that’s the issue How alcoholism and drug addiction impact child custody When (and why) a judge might award the addicted spouse a lesser share of the marital assets How Aaron handles a case differently when he represents the addicted party The trend toward seeing addiction as an illness vs. criminal activity Why it’s exceptionally challenging to represent the spouse of an addict The consequences of making your spouse’s addiction public in the divorce process Why a judge might base child support on the amount the addicted party SHOULD be making What a judge considers before awarding alimony to the addicted party Aaron’s advice to the spouse of an addict considering divorce Connect with Aaron Thomas Aaron Thomas Law: https://www.aaronthomaslaw.com/ Connect with Katherine Miller The Center for Understanding Conflict: http://understandinginconflict.org/ Miller Law Group: https://westchesterfamilylaw.com/ Katherine on LinkedIn: linkedin.com/in/kemiller1 The New Yorker’s Guide to Collaborative Divorce by Katherine Miller: https://www.amazon.com/New-Yorkers-Guide-Collaborative-Divorce/dp/0692496246 Email: [email protected] Call (914) 738-7765

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

How Substance Abuse Impacts Divorce with Aaron Thomas

0:00 24:33
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Welcome to Divorce Dialogues. I'm Catherine Miller. Divorce Dialogues brings expert guests to the airways to talk through your divorce questions and fill in the gray areas of that separating. From thinking about divorce, to how to behave during divorce, to what to do after, this is Divorce Dialogues.

Welcome to Divorce Dialogues. I'm Catherine Miller. I'm the founder of another law group and director of the Center for Understanding and Conflict. I am on a mission to change how to do divorce and help the divorce and dignity.

I'm thrilled today that my guest is Attorney Aaron Stumman. He began his legal career in 2002 with an in-house staff attorney for Habitat for Humanity International, and he then owned his trial fields from 2004 to 2007 at the Cal County Public Defender's Office, rising quickly through the ranks, representing hundreds of indigent clients facing both misdemeanors and felonies and winning trials in both states and superior courts. Since 2007, Aaron has practiced family life exclusively, helping secure favorable settlements and verdicts for clients from all walks of life in a wide variety of circumstances. Welcome, Aaron Thomas.

It's a pleasure to have you on the show. Thanks very much for having me, Catherine. You know, and one of the things that we talked about that is really a growing problem in people facing divorce and substance abuse, and I think people wonder if they have bad smoke or high weed or, you know, is it take a lot of prescription drugs maybe improperly or there are other substances involved. Is that a grounds for divorce?

Yes. In most jurisdictions, it will be. Certainly, there are no fault jurisdictions like California where there are no grounds for divorce, but in most areas, it is going to be grounds for divorce, the habitual addiction or drunkenness of the South. Yeah, but if you point out, most states, and you're in Georgia, I'm in New York, at least in New York, it's not that hard to get divorced anymore.

It used to be really not that easy, but these days, it's not that hard to get divorced even if you're just unhappy. Is that true in Georgia, Joe? Yes. Yeah.

So, in Georgia, even if you have other grounds for divorce, most of the time, you're someone to follow and recognize all the differences. Sometimes there's a lot slower, an emotional element that gets involved that makes someone want to include these other grounds for divorce, but like you said, if it's not that difficult to get a divorce, I'll have those grounds. Right. So, the substance abuse really comes in to the finer point of the divorce case, not so much whether or not someone can get a divorce, but what happens inside that divorce proceeding with regard to custody, division of assets, and spouse or child support going forward.

Is that right? Absolutely, yeah. The devil is always going to be in the details, and substance abuse can certainly impact issues from custody, devil, revision, and the like. So, how can it affect custody?

Because I think that a lot of people who are married to people who have substance abuse problems worry, and maybe rightly so, about their children's well-being when they're with a parent with a substance abuse problem. What do you say to those people? Well, I think for those individuals, I think that they're right to be concerned. You know, substance abuse is an issue generally in our country, but certainly in marriages, alcoholism, or drug addiction devastates a lot of marriages, devastates families that can have a huge negative impact on the children.

And judges that are making a determination on custody, no matter what jurisdiction you're in, have to look out for, number one, what is in the best interest of the children. And if it is going to impact a parent's parenting ability, their ability to function, then overseeing the child's education, getting them from place to place, certainly something like drug addiction or individual drunkenness, whether that's prescription pills or legal drugs, those types of things are going to come into play. And a parent who is suffering from serious addiction issues is going to be at a serious disadvantage when it comes to determining what custody is going to look like. And what about the other elements of the divorce?

How does substance abuse impact that division of assets or ongoing support? Yeah, yeah, absolutely. It's a good question. I think a lot of people wonder whether drug addiction is going to or any kind of substance abuse is going to impact the division of assets.

So for most states, including Georgia and New York, where they're equitable division states, the court, the judge has the authority to divide the assets and debt, something other than 50-50, taking into account kind of the conduct of the parties or other considerations. And yeah, substance abuse can come into play. One example would be if a significant amount of marital funds, of marital money, had gone towards funding an addiction. It's not difficult to imagine a judge deciding that that spouse deserves to have a lesser share of the assets when all is said and done.

Aaron Thomas, is it punitive or is it a matter of contribution? So meaning, is a judge looking at someone who is actively abusing some substance, drinking drugs, legal or illegal, saying, you know, you're a bad person, you know, not a you, I'm going to give you less than half because of this bad behavior? Or are they saying, you know what, because of this history, substance abuse, you have not contributed to the marriage in an equal way, and therefore I'm going to give you less than half. And maybe I'm dancing angels on the head of a pen here and it really makes no difference to the person, but I'm just curious about that.

No, no, no, I think that's interesting. I think some litigants would probably feel as though it's punitive. Sure. And certainly, you probably know as well as I do.

You go from courtroom to courtroom or from judge to judge, and they may have different things that they say from the bench. But I think for the most part, the focus is more going to be on contribution to assets. So you imagine a couple where one spouse is working hard to put food on the table and pay the bills for the family, and the other spouse is not able to hold it together due to a drug addiction and is not contributing their fair share to the household bill. Certainly, it would be within a judge's authority to say, look, the other spouse has been the one supporting the family.

They're the one paying down the mortgage and putting money in the bank. What can be fair, what's going to be equitable is to give that spouse a larger share of what, frankly, they contributed during the marriage. That makes a lot of sense. But if you distinguish a situation, well, let's say you have a very productive person who works throughout the marriage, a man or woman, creates assets, supports the family, has a back injury, becomes addicted to some painkiller, and can't seem to take the habit, you know, within 12 months.

I mean, that would be a completely different situation than that person, it sounds like. In your view, it wouldn't be penalized for having this addiction, even if they were still actively using. Oh, yeah, I agree with you, Catherine. In that side of the scenario, I think, you know, the court can weigh all of the circumstances, but in that side of the scenario where someone's been contributing to the marital stay over the course of the marriage and, you know, maybe the addiction represents a small fraction of the relationship, it's unlikely that they're going to penalize them with a much lesser share of the marital stay, in my view and my experience.

So let me ask you this, Aaron Thomas. You worked in the public defender's office, and you probably had clients at the time. I'm not asking you to reveal any attorney-client privilege, but you probably had some in that situation who had substance abuse problems. Is that accurate?

Yeah. And you probably, as a family lawyer, a matrimonial lawyer, also have had clients who suffer from substance abuse. And I'm wondering, is there a difference in terms of the way you as an attorney handle those cases when you're dealing with someone who really may not be able to help as much help you as an attorney work on their case and present their best face? Is there a difference there or not?

I think that, you know, in terms of a difference between someone who has a drug addiction or substance abuse issue and someone who doesn't, yeah, and I think that, you know, we as attorneys, we are counselors. I think where our job begins and ends can become blurry at times, but, you know, we meet our clients where we are and we try to leave them in a better place than where we found them to go to the public defender's office. And, you know, in family law, when I've dealt with individuals who have substance abuse issues, that are my clients, you know, we're trying to get them to a place where they can be a functioning member of society, where they can show a court that they've overcome their addiction or they've worked on their addiction when it comes to someone facing criminal charges. And then with someone in family law, if they're trying to reestablish a relationship with their children, if they're trying to, you know, get in a position where they can, you know, show that the court that they deserve, you know, a share of the marital state without reduction, I think that it's our duty to try to find the resources, which there are plenty out there, that can help them overcome their drug addiction.

I think a lot of times, you know, especially in a custody case, the courts don't want to see some improvement on their court where they allow a parent to have unsupervised visitation or parents don't want to be in the baby's office and drug addiction. Yeah, and I do want to talk about what improvement people can do. But first, I want to remind our listeners that you're listening to Divorce Dialogues. We're here on WBOX 1460 AM, alternate Wednesdays from 5 to 530, or perhaps you're listening on the podcast, which is available on all podcast sites as well as on the podcast website, DivorceDialogues.com.

I'm Catherine Miller, and I'm speaking with Aaron Thomas, and we're speaking about substance abuse and divorce. And I really want to distinguish the difference of somebody actively using, showing no indication of improvement versus someone who's really trying to deal with the problem, either they're in rehab or they're going to a meeting of some kind, and they're really struggling to get better or are actually in recovery. Are there shades of gray in those areas? You know, every time you see a celebrity of some sort, you know, get in trouble, especially some kind of family issue or maybe inappropriate behavior, you know, whoops, they all take out of rehab, you know, and it seems like that's the way they're spinning it.

Oh, well, you know, yeah, I've had a problem, and I'm sick, and now I'm going to deal with it by going to get some kind of treatment. And so what is the impact of that on a divorce case and specifically with regard to, you know, custody? Yeah, yeah, I think that, you know, judges have a difficult job maybe distinguishing between that person who is just putting on a face or, like, they're going to rehab to try to spin the situation in their favor and someone that is truly remorseful, truly trying to turn a page, certainly, you know, someone facing potentially the loss of parenting time with their kids, that can serve by itself as a wake-up call and scare someone into getting some help. And I think there's also a trend nationwide that we have to consider where, you know, someone who's suffering addiction is looked at today more as an illness rather than, you know, this is just a criminal, this is just a derelict, we need to be punished.

I think now there's a trend, and many courts today have drug courts or drug divisions where the emphasis is less on punishment and more on rehabilitation. So, and we as attorneys, obviously, if we can both help our clients get more time with their children as well as treat their addiction at the same time, that would seem to be a win-win. Yeah, I think that's really an interesting point because I think in some ways it's easier, I think, to represent the person who has the addiction because in that place you can help influence them and guide them to resources and institutions and ways that these problems can be treated where when you represent the spouse of that person, all you can do is sort of jump up and down like Rumpelstiltskin and say, something needs to change. But usually at that point the spouse has been saying that for years, right?

And to have their attorney say it just falls more on deaf ears. Right, right, right. And I think that's a great point that it is tough for, you know, the person who's been the addict, you know, in some respects, they may have nowhere to go above. And, you know, when I have a client and the spouse of my client is the one with addiction problems, we've got a difficult situation, you know.

A judge is not going to want to sever the ties between a child and a parent unless the circumstances are so strange, unless the addicted parent is so far gone that it's just not in children's interest to ever have a relationship with that parent. And I think that's going to be rare. And so it would be frustrating for the spouse of the addict to say, look, they've shown that they're unable to parent effectively. And meanwhile, the court is going to give them a chance to prove that they deserve a chance to be in their children's lives.

When does an addiction become so bad that you sever the parent-child relationship? Yeah, that's a question, I think, for better people than I, or maybe a higher power, because I think that is a really, really tough question. And it certainly is hard to answer in generalities, right, because kids deserve to have their parents in their lives. And whether or not those parents are acting in their best way or not.

But if it's going to hurt them, then there needs to be some guidelines in there for that, and that's really tough to figure out where that is. So, Aaron Thompson, during the marriage that many years usually pass, at least that's my experience, many years pass before the person who is not the addict chooses to leave. And there's often a reason for that in the dynamic between the couple. So it's been kind of a family secret, or not so, maybe an open secret with the neighbors and larger family.

But in the divorce, it can become public, right? And these public allegations can really harm not just the addict, but the whole family in terms of employers finding out and other kinds of things like that. So how do you think families who are going through this can protect themselves from unwanted consequences? Yeah, I think that it's certainly a delicate situation often.

And back to your earlier point, it can be extremely tough on the spouse of the addict. Because in one situation, you need that addict's ability to play a role in the children's lives. You may need their help physically, transporting children, watching the children. You may need that parent contribution financially.

But at the same time, if you let the court know, if you put it in public record, if you put it in motion, if you file with the court that this person has a drug addiction, there's a risk of other people finding out, so they could lose their job over it. And then you've got to balance. And what's more important, letting the court know the extent of allegations they're making against the addicted spouse, or making sure that spouse has the funds to be able to contribute to your children's needs? Again, another really difficult question that we kind of just deal with on a case-by-case basis.

But it's probably down to the level of addiction and the amount of help that's needed. Yes, and I think that for the spouse, it often comes down to a level of rage. I'm finally saying no more. My experience is that there's an emotional desire to just tell the world I've been suffering, and yet that's just often ill-advised.

So it is really a challenge to try to find a way through there that makes sense for all people. I'm Catherine Miller, and you're listening to Divorce Dialogues here on WBOX 1460 AM, every other Wednesday from 5 to 5.30, and also available as a podcast. And I'm talking today with Aaron Thomas about substance abuse and divorce. And Aaron, if people are interested in learning more about you or more about this topic, how can they reach you?

I can be found online at www.aarontomaslaw.com. The name is A-A-R-O-N, that's name Thomas, T-H-O-M-A-S, aarontomaslaw.com. And that is the easiest way to keep up with my firm and what we're doing, and practice here in Atlanta, Georgia. Thank you for that.

I'm sure that there'll be listeners who are interested in contacting you and learning more about this really, really challenging topic. You know, one thing that we haven't talked about is the impact on substance abuse on child support and maintenance or alimony. And how does that impact the situation? I think that drug addiction can impact child support and impact alimony as well, certainly to the extent that it impacts a parent's ability to earn income.

So, for example, if the addicted parent is the parent that needs to pay child support because the non-addict spouse has custody of the children, that parent could say, well, I can't work. You know, I've got this addiction. I've got a problem. Or maybe they haven't been able to hold down a job.

In my experience, judges are extremely unlikely to absolve that parent's financial responsibility to pay some support for their children simply because they can't hold down a job because of the drug addiction. What judges, in my experience, usually do is they impute income or they assume the amount of income that that parent can earn or they say that they have the ability to earn that amount and they base child support on that. When it comes to alimony, it could be kind of a similar thing where, you know, normally a dependent spouse, a financially dependent spouse would be eligible to receive some alimony after the marriage. But if they're only dependent because of their drug addiction, in my experience, at least, the judge is not very likely to have a lot of sympathy.

And I think there's also the concern that awarding an addicted spouse some kind of monetary support could have the unintended consequence of fueling that addiction. funds to further buy drugs or have alcohol or not have to hold down the job. So you can certainly impact alcohol now when you know sex away. Yeah, I think you said a lot there, and so I want to split it up a little bit, because when you talk about imputing income, and that's a big word, but it basically means that a judge can say that I'm going to pay support based on the amount of money you should be making, even though you're not making it because you're an addict, right?

Exactly. And so in some ways, though, you just can't get blood from a stone. If this person is really suffering from a disease, and they had cancer, and they couldn't work because they had cancer, it would be very unlikely, in my opinion, maybe you see this differently, to impute income to that person because they were suffering from cancer. Do you agree with that?

Yeah, absolutely. Yeah, so there is a kind of contradiction, right? So we earlier spoke about the trend toward treating addiction as a disease, but there still is a kind of punitiveness, or can be, if it feels like, and it often does, I think, feel to the judge or to other people, like this is the fault of the person who is suffering from the disease of addiction. I think that's true.

I think there's an element of that. There will probably vary from judge to judge if their particular beliefs are. I think a parent who has an addiction problem but is actively going to rehab, I think the judge is likely to be more lenient with that parent when it comes to paying child support. I think a parent who has had multiple chances of rehab, has had multiple opportunities and resources provided to get clean, and simply refuses to do so or hold down a job, I think that's where you're more likely to see a judge come down and say, all right, I'm going to impute a certain amount of income, and you've just got to come up with the money to pay your child support.

Yeah, so that's interesting. To the extent that the person is treating their disease, the court is likely, and no one can guarantee anything, but likely to see that person with more compassion and more empathy and treat them more gently than someone who's just blatantly ignoring the impact of their addiction on themselves and their family. I think that's right. That's been my experience, I believe.

Yeah, that kind of makes sense. And with regard to the other, having an addicted spouse seeking support, it's sort of like what we're told about giving money to people on the street, right? You don't want it to fuel an addiction, but you do want to support the person. And I think the court is limited in the ways that they can help a person survive, you know, the place they live and eat and clothes that they need to work and all of those things, and also try to keep the money away from the substance abuse.

It seems like there could be more nuanced ways of dealing with that than the tools that are in a judge's hands. What do you think about that? Yeah, yeah. I mean, I don't envy judges in these difficult positions.

It's so much easier to be on our side of the bench arguing the case. Yeah, I have seen, for example, a judge, you know, order the spouse who has resources to pay for the addicted spouse's revalidation. And I think that was seen by this particular judge as a way to provide the kind of support in a positive manner without being cashed in an addict's hand. And certainly it's going to be, I think, you know, detailed circumstance dependent based on, you know, each individual case.

And sometimes I think it's going to be more likely to take a creative route than others. So, Aaron Thomas, we have less than a minute left, but I would like you to say, what is your advice if you or someone who's listening out there who has an addictive spouse, what's the first thing they should think about doing? I think trying to get that individual help. I mean, at the end of the day, especially if you've got children, you've got a family, getting someone off the drug and having a clean is going to be the best result for everyone.

And if not, you should also speak to a qualified attorney in your area. All right, I think that's great advice, Aaron Thomas. Thank you so much for being our guest on Divorce Dialog. It's been a pleasure.

Thank you very much.

A Spooky Action At A Distance David Masters Welcome to 'Spooky Action at a Distance,' a weekly podcast where we chart the mysterious spaces between the mundane and mystical. From ghostly tales to UFO narratives, music phenomena to divine conundrums, our exploration rooted in para-psychology challenges conventional wisdom, ignites thought-provoking dialogues, and illuminates the enigmatic threads of existence. Guided by seasoned hosts, we venture into the labyrinth of the extraordinary, investigating each peculiarity from varied perspectives. Tune in, open your mind, and join us on this captivating quest, traversing the spectral landscapes of the strange and supernatural. A Ground Zero Radio podcast Goldwater, Dubé TNKR Media Join lawyer and political commentator Anne-France Goldwater for the miniseries Love & Money by Goldwater, Dubé. Over the next few weeks, learn more about family law, divorce, youth protection, animal rights, the constitution and more from some of Quebec’s most experienced lawyers. Oliver Bardwell Podcast Oliver Bardwell Welcome to ”The Oliver Bardwell Podcast,” where insightful conversations converge. Join me, Oliver Bardwell, author, speaker, and seeker of wisdom, as I engage in thought-provoking dialogues that span spirituality, unity, and diverse perspectives. Delve into respectful discussions with legislators, doctors, education experts, and guests from every corner of life, as we explore a myriad of intriguing topics. From the heart of Iowa to the world, let’s embark on a journey of discovery and understanding together. Inception Dialogues Bernardo Kastrup Exploring the human imagination through conversations about art, myth, theology, psychology, true philosophy, and direct experience

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Divorce Dialogues?

This episode is 24 minutes long.

When was this Divorce Dialogues episode published?

This episode was published on August 5, 2020.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Divorce Dialogues episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.