Skip to content
I Should Be Turned On Right Now… So Why Aren't I? episode artwork

Apr 29, 2026 52 min

I Should Be Turned On Right Now… So Why Aren't I?

from Erotic Reclamation Hosted by Kari Kinkead and Nicholette Routhier

Theoretically, the idea of sex sounds great. You're into them, you’re not too tired, it sounds like a fun time. But at the exact same time, your body is tensing, stalling, freezing, clamming up. This yes/no mismatch is so common, but we almost never talk about it. Instead, we generally either push through and perform, or shut down entirely. But there's a third option: learning to be honest about where your body actually is at, while also being honest about what you mentally want. In this episode, we get into what happens when your mind and body are on different pages during sex. As two women who have struggled with orgasm specifically, we unpack how the pressure to achieve orgasm (or deliver orgasm to your partner) collides with a body that has its own history — of trauma, of shame, of disassociation — and might need something completely different in order to actually feel good. Not just to orgasm, but simply to be present, connected, and alive in the experience. We also get into: - Why telling yourself "I should be turned on right now" makes it harder to get there - What it means to have desire without attachment to outcome, and why that's not the same as not caring - How to learn what yes and no actually feel like in your body, outside of sexual situations - What happens when you stop treating arousal as a prerequisite for saying yes - How to start listening to your body's signals without making them mean something is wrong with you ♥️ You can also watch this episode as a video! Find it here on YouTube. ♥️ Chapter Timestamps 0:00 — What we're talking about today: when your mind and body are on different pages about sex 1:51 — Why your body defaults to being tense, performative, unfeeling during sex 14:00 — What changes when your goal shifts from "great sex" to "staying present" 15:23 — Why telling yourself you should be turned on makes it harder to get there 18:27 — The wild, delicious world of sex that opens up when you stop focusing on orgasm 32:46 — You can actually be a fuck yes to sex without being aroused, and how to work that gap 38:03 — 'I want sex' means a thousand things, and the more specific you get, the more you'll actually get what you want 43:43 — How shame has infiltrated sex-positive spaces, making us feel like we need to learn better techniques rather than learn how to embrace our bodies 46:40 — Why and how your body signals it might need things to slow down, even when your mind is fully game 48:10 — How and why to learn what yes and no actually feel like in your body ♥️ Links: Upcoming programs: https://www.eroticreclamation.com/ Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/erotic.reclamation/ Substack: https://eroticreclamation.substack.com/ ♥️ Erotic Reclamation is where sex-positive education meets somatic, trauma-informed practice. We're Nicholette Routhier and Kari Kinkead: certified embodiment facilitators, kink priestesses, relationship coaches, and freaky guides for anyone ready to stop hiding their desire and start basking in it. Our approach goes beyond what you’ll typically find at BDSM workshops and play parties. We focus on: - Embodied exploration of claiming your desires, energetic eroticism, power play, conflict repair, and so much more - Meeting shame with tenderness, while reconnecting to your body's erotic intelligence - Trauma-informed containers that prioritize nervous system safety, transparent communication, and full-body “fuck yes” consent and boundaries - Building a healthy, integrated relationship with your sexual cravings and sexual partners - Finding the kind of pleasure your body and soul has been dreaming of, but wasn’t sure really existed… Whether you're curious about how to have better intimacy, navigating a kinky awakening, or wanting to explore even wider realms of pleasure, there's a place for you here. No experience necessary, but all experience welcome. Learn more at www.eroticreclamation.com. With love, Kari & Nicholette This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit eroticreclamation.substack.com

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

I Should Be Turned On Right Now… So Why Aren't I?

0:00 52:28

No transcript yet.

Requests help us decide what to transcribe next.

Girls on Porn Headgum A cheeky podcast aimed at helping you find adult content that you can feel good about! Each week, Laura and Rachel - cohosts, erotic enthusiasts, and all around horny gals - traverse the wet and wild of porn. We pick popular search terms, load up on research, and review porn that features that particular proclivity. We’re here to help you find hot, ethical material to upgrade your spank bank, and spice up your “self care” routine. Explicit Brave Love Great Sex – Couples Therapy Podcast Cloud10 Couples podcast to help committed couples keep it hot! Find hope to keep your marriage and committed relationships emotionally connected and sexually erotic. Certified sex therapist Dr. Laurie Watson is joined by global leader in couples therapy - George Faller, LMFT for an expert, frank and fascinating conversation about sex, love, therapy, relationship dynamics, healthy couples and marriage. We discuss everything from best sexual techniques and solving sexual problems, to building the emotional intimacy necessary for great sex in your relationship! Two therapists bring you sound, concrete tools to reframe your relationship problems and learn how to fall in-love again, rebuild trust, and feel desire. Subscribe to us today! Check out our sponsors! Foria Wellness -- try their excellent sex oils! Their Awaken Arousal and Sex Oil are excellent for enhancing a woman's orgasm! Try it and see! Use the link <a h Explicit Erotic Stories from Wylde in Bed Devlin Wylde Welcome to the world of sensual Erotic stories where your sexual desires and fantasies can be brought to life, with me your host, Devlin Wylde, as we embark on a journey of intense pleasure and immerse ourselves in your deepest desires. With surprise bonus episodes of my unique Experiential Erotica, Orgasmic Meditation and ASMR you know you want to subscribe so you don’t miss a single, throbbing pleasure. So loosen those clothes, put your earbuds in and relax back on that bed. I will join you every Friday at 10pm CST to whisper an erotic story right there…can you feel my breath yet? Explicit Holly Randall Unfiltered Holly Randall HRU is a podcast series that sheds light on those working in the adult industry, and explores all topics of sex with authors, educators, and advocates. Hosted by world renowned erotic photographer and director Holly Randall, she interviews some of the biggest names in the adult industry, and various non-porn guests who touch on the subject of sex in one way or another. With an honest and humorous outlook on life, Holly strips away the misconceptions on people who work in the sex industry, and offers sex-positive discussions on various social and political issues. You can follow Holly on both Instagram and Twitter at @hollyrandall and drop us an email at [email protected]. Expect to be intrigued, to laugh your ass off, and to learn something new! Explicit

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Erotic Reclamation?

This episode is 52 minutes long.

When was this Erotic Reclamation episode published?

This episode was published on April 29, 2026.

Can I download this Erotic Reclamation episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.