Skip to content
James Lindsay Vs. Cynical theories episode artwork

Mar 11, 2022 50 min

James Lindsay Vs. Cynical theories

from DEKONSTRUKTIV KRITIK

James A. Lindsay is a mathematician, cultural critic, and co-author of the book Cynical theories together with Helen Pluckrose. He rose to internet fame through the Grievance studies affair. If you want to know more it can be found on James’ s youtube-channel New Discourses.For more info: https://bit.ly/DK_JamesLindsaySTÖTTA DEKONSTRUKTIV KRITIK på:SWISH 0046768943737paypal.me/ARONFLAMDKs Patreon: bit.ly/ARONFLAMDKBitcoin: 3EPQMEMVh6MtG3bTbGc71Yz8NrMAMF4kSHEdited by Marcus Blomgren Intro by: Intractable by Kevin MacLeod is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution license (creativecommons.org/licenses/...) Source: incompetech.com/music/royalty-... Artist: incompetech.com STÖTTA DEKONSTRUKTIV KRITIK: Swish: 1235198478 paypal.me/ARONFLAM Patreon: www.patreon.com/ARONFLAM Bitcoin: 3EPQMEMVh6MtG3bTbGc71Yz8NrMAMF4kSH www.aronflam.com Edited by Marcus Tigerdraake, Silverdrake Förlag www.silverdrakeforlag.se Intro by: Intractable by Kevin MacLeod is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution license (creativecommons.org/licenses/...) Source: incompetech.com/music/royalty-... Artist: incompetech.com

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

James Lindsay Vs. Cynical theories

0:00 50:08
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

You've got social dialed in. Search is doing its thing. So why do your marketing results look the same as six months ago? That's because you're fishing in the same pond as everyone else.

Podcast listeners are a different audience entirely. More engaged, harder to reach their traditional channels, and ready to act when someone they trust makes a recommendation. We're ACAST, and we put them right in front of you. Browse thousands of the world's leading podcasts, book host reads or run your own ads, and track every conversion in real time.

Same skills you already have. Brand new results. ACAST. ACAST.com.

Advertise. James Lindsay was involved in what has become known as the Grieven Studies Affair. It all started as a prank back in 2017 when Lindsay and Peter Bogosian published a hoax paper titled The Conceptual Penis as Social Construct. Later that year, they teamed up with Academic Helen Pluckrose to write 20 hoax papers for submission to peer-reviewed journals.

When their cover was blown, seven out of 20 papers had been accepted, and seven was under review. Together with Helen Pluckrose, James Lindsay has written the book, Cynical Theories, now available in Swedish. He also has a YouTube channel called New Discourses that I highly recommend you watch. With these words, I present James Lindsay and Joel.

Hello, how are you? I'm great. Thank you. And I want to welcome you to deconstructed criticism.

Glad to be here. Dr. James Lindsay. That's correct.

Hello. Well, my name is Aaron Flamm. We haven't met before, although I've been stalking you quite some. I've done quite a bit of research on user, and I must say, oh boy, you've done the work.

Well, thank you. I think I have done the work. There's a lot of work to do still though. So I usually start my podcasts with a very general question to allow you to identify yourself.

So that question is quite simply, who are you? That's a question I always hesitate to answer. I'm actually awkward around biographies of myself, but I'll do what I can. I have a PhD in mathematics that I earned in 2010.

I did not continue in academia. I left academia when I finished my doctorate, but I did teach math for the better part of eight and a half years at the university level while I was earning it. And let's see. What else?

I, in the middle, I guess in 2017 and 18, I participated in what's now known as the Grieven Studies Affair. So what I did was I wrote with two colleagues. His name is Peter Pergoshan and Helen Pluckros. I wrote a series of false academic papers to expose fields like gender studies, critical race theory, critical pedagogy as it goes into education and fat studies and disability studies and so on.

So we wrote these false academic articles that in my opinion are quite hilarious and quite obviously meant to be funny. To see if the peer review system would accept them in these kind of prestigious academic journals within the disciplines. And the answer turned out to be yes. They accepted seven of the articles that we wrote in just a few months before we got caught by the Wall Street Journal and asked to stop.

So I thought we had exposed that something was rotten in the state of academia at that point rather significantly. And from there, we decided to focus on exposing it more fully researching it, exposing it more fully. So the next big step was that I wrote a book with Helen, who also did the project with me called Cynical Theories, which was quite good at exposing what had happened as a kind of a runaway bestseller, to be honest with you. I have both the English version as an ebook and the Swedish version, which your Swedish publisher was kind of enough to send me.

I actually am looking around in the room, I don't know where it is. I actually have a copy of the Swedish version. It's the only foreign language edition that I have as I have a Swedish version here as well, which is kind of interesting. It was sent to me as a gift by somebody in Sweden.

And so it's kind of exciting and very nice and generous people, the Swedes. And so we wrote Cynical Theories. It was quite successful. It focuses on the influence of postmodern philosophy and scholarship had upon these critical theories that had been developing previously to create what we would call woke or critical social justice or whatever now.

And then I launched a company to continue the work of exposing this and to justify my research called new discourses. And new discourses has been quite successful. It's grown rather a lot in the last two years. It's now officially two years old this week or last week, I suppose.

And that's been almost all of my time now reading, as you said, doing the work, reading, whether it's Marxism, whether it's critical theory or neo-Marxism, whether it's postmodern theory, whether it's this newer identity politics based Marxism. I'm trying to characterize it for people so people can understand what's going on with the scholarship and then how it links to what's happening in the world. So many questions relating to this, I want to ask you first, but how come you specifically on Helen ended up as a, well, some would call it cultural warriors, I suppose? I always joke and say that I fell backwards into it.

I didn't intend to do that. I got kind of involved with arguing with people online as Helen also was very well known to have been doing. And the direction of the arguments online, maybe in 2012, 13, maybe even earlier, 10 and 11 all started to skew toward talking about things like sexism and racism and so on these culture or issues and talking about them in a very particular and peculiar way, which is in terms of systemic racism and systemic sexism, and this started to lead to cancellations as they call them now of people who are working around us or that we were interested in or thought leaders that we were following. And so we started to dig into that issue and to see that as a significant issue, many years before the mainstream did, not before everybody.

And so by 2014 at the latest, we were quite active at speaking up about it. The reason that we went full bore into it would have been when we were doing the grieving studies of error. I can't speak for Helen, but I know for myself at least. When we were doing the grieving studies of error, we wrote one particular paper that was about education and the response the peer reviewers gave it saying that it's a wonderful idea that the paper advocated child abuse.

It was a wonderful idea, but the problem with it was that it focused on using a compassionate approach and it should not because that might threaten to re-center the needs of the privileged is how they framed it. And that sentence actually was the one where, you know, as the internet meme goes where the guy says who radicalized you and the guy leans in and says you did. That was the moment. I saw that and I remember getting on a phone with a friend of mine who was collaborating with us with it.

His name is Mike, Nina. And I talked to Mike and we decided that that sentence indicated something very dangerous and very nefarious. This isn't funny anymore. It was kind of the moment we had there.

And I remember afterwards going to my wife and saying this is a potential threat to all the Western civilization. This isn't a small funny side show culture war. This is a very significant thing. If I would have had the vocabulary for it, I would have said this is the beginning of a cultural revolution.

And I didn't have that vocabulary though at the time. And so I asked her if I could quit my job and focus on it full time to expose it to the world so that somebody would be ringing an alarm bell because very few people, if anybody was doing so. Well, I will reserve the right to joke since I'm originally a comedian. And that's how I handle tragedy.

Yeah, yeah, yeah. Of course. So do I. I mean, my paper's about dog sex.

And I understand that in the American school system now, is it just that parents have started protesting against things like what you call gender studies? I mean, I come from Sweden here. It's called gender science and has been in the school system completely, publicly to everyone's years since the early 90s. So, so, so, so is it when I look at the US now, you see some sort of parental movement before the midterms trying to dethrone Democrats.

And one of the issues seems to be gender studies in school or gender science, depending on the point. Yes. Well, it's certainly not science unless we want to use the definition of science that somebody like Hegel used for a systematic philosophy, which is that, you know, there's the facts of the world, what rigorous people would call science and you get classified that as first on to understanding in German. And then there's this higher level understanding that is the system of philosophy, fair and known for the higher level reason that characterizes it and gender studies, as we call it in the US or gender science or gender sociology, as it's called in Sweden, is not science.

It's Marxist bullshit. Yeah, just to cut straight through. It is not science. It's, it's, I mean, you can make, you want to get together next week and make up 10 papers, we can't.

It's not science. Next week I'm skiing in Italy, hopefully, if I pass the antigen test, but, but I love to it. Really? Let's do a circle on Schulamik Firestone.

Yeah. So, so, um, there is a big pushback. It's centered primarily on critical race theory in the United States. And it's also centered on, as a second kind of center of gravity on what we would call in the US, we call it queer theory, which is an extension of the gender studies into a much kind of broader context.

It's touching on gender, sex, sexuality, even states of mind, mental health, et cetera, and wages war on anything ever being considered normal. And so this isn't led to the introduction of pornographic books and children's school libraries, and what looks like the outright sexual grooming of children. And so parents are rightly very upset about this. You know, again, this is public schools.

This isn't that they sign their kid up for some weird private school. It has some weird thing that they chose. This is the state run school. And so it's very upsetting to parents.

And so there's a big pushback against all of this. And what my work does actually is characterize this that these aren't separate things. This is all part of one much larger project in that itself is part of even one, even larger project to fundamentally remake Western civilizations for people who want to exert power and control over over people. I consumed quite a lot of your lectures and YouTube videos as well as a video book, but could you give me and most of all probably my listeners, you were elevator pitch for how it all seems to fit together this cultural revolution that threatens the West.

Well, I mean, there are two pieces. So an elevator pitch is very difficult because there are two elevator pitches that have to be done. Or the one elevator pitch for the kind of cultural identity studies like critical race, their gender science, or whatever you want to call it. All of that is actually what happened in the 1960s was that the Marxist realized that the working class were not going to be a revolutionary force.

So they threw the working class out and replaced them with identity politics. They reached to the racial minorities, the sexual minorities, the gender minorities, and so on, and the mentally unwell, so the mental health of minorities, they reached out to these people and they started to get them to see their problems in terms of what is ultimately a Marxist style conflict theory where instead of economic class being the stratifier of society, now it's whether or not you're normal, whether or not you're white or black or whatever race. So all of a sudden it became identity politics became the stratifying variables instead of economic class. The Marxism in other words reinvented itself.

So what we're dealing with is within whether it's critical race theory, whether it's gender science or studies, whether it's queer theory is we're seeing the reinvention of Marxism, Marxist theory using identity politics in place of economic class. And so they are working actually in conjunction. If you understand Maoism, they work in conjunction with one another. Mao created a list of bad identities and a list of good identities.

He called them black and red, but that's beside the fascist and communist is why, but that's beside the point. What he did was he labeled people he wanted to modify, especially in schools, schoolchildren, he labeled them in black identities and then he gave them a pathway to become a red identity. And this is exactly what you see with critical race theory calls everybody a racist, but it allows you to become an ally or you could go and undergo gender transition and something like this and become some kind of a politicized radical identity. So you have a set of bad identities and a pathway to becoming good identities where the good identities are all political radicals.

And it creates a funnel that's pressing mostly again young people through to get them to become radical activists using the relevant theory for Marx, economics. And for today, it's the identity politics. So allyship, solidarity, transitioning, adopting a obscure sexuality that seems like it was made up in the past three years, as long as those are all political identities becoming politically black, as they say, becoming a black face that wants to be a black voice, as one of our Congress women said, these are the kinds of things that they're doing. So what we see as a Maoist project, creating a cultural revolution, that fits within a broader project that is not unique to the United States.

And just kind of, you know, everybody says, Oh, you export your culture war to the rest of the world. No, it turns out that somebody else is helping them export it. It's not just because it's on television, it's because there are these entities, for example, the world economic forum that have created these large banks that they're partnered with and the governments have partnered with that have created tools like an environmental social governance score, which is a social credit system for institutions and companies. And if you want to get your social score within ESG environmental social governance, social refers to social justice initiatives, they dictate what those look like when they're correct.

And this set of identity Marxist policies is how they decided we're going to have a diverse inclusive equitable future they talk about that. If you want to have a high S score for your institution, whether it's your company, whether it's your university, whether it's your government, and therefore be taken care of by large asset firms like BlackRock and Vanguard and Goldman Sachs and to be on the page with whatever the agenda, the Davos agenda of the world economic forum or the UN sustainability agenda that they're tied in with. If you want to be on the right side of all of that and all of the trade agreements and the treaties and everything else, then you have to make sure that you're adopting these principles on the global scale. So there are two pieces.

There's the cultural revolution in the United States meant to break it apart and throughout other Western nations as well using identity politics like Marxism, so that these places become destabilized and can get wrapped up into something else simultaneously. You have this large global push through coordinated super national actors like the World Economic Forum and International Monetary Fund in the United Nations working in conjunction with the CCP to create a structure in which that's the way everybody has to behave all the time, and they're the ones that are actually the exporters. They're the ones who are creating the conditions by which lots of money and lots of support in all the corporations. You see no corporations taking another stand.

Nobody, no experiments are happening. Just like with COVID, everybody's going in exactly one direction. I can tell you a funny detail. It might mean nothing.

I don't know what you know about Sweden. Sweden is a long time social democracy and the political scale that we view the world through is a bit different than the one you see in the United States. For you guys, or at least you are right-wing and Republicans now called Libtards or Liberals, I would mostly, I would call them fake Liberals and true social Democrats in a way. I mean, I come from here in Sweden, we have a state institute of gender science.

So we've been doing this for a while and in 2018, I started, you could see at least one or two government reports talking about CRT and white fragility, which is interesting because Sweden has never really had a problem with African slavery. I mean, we had Vikings who in the year 800 or something took slaves, but I don't think they were mostly African, probably Danish or German or French or I mean, Gaelic or whatever you call themselves back then. So it's interesting to see what's happening to you and we seem to be getting some back. And I mentioned Shulamit Firestone because we have a sociologist here called the Professor called Ivone Heredmann and she's famous for conceptualizing, I guess you would say, what she called the gender system.

And it's really a simplification that borrows heavily from Shulamit Firestone. This was done in the late 80s and then introduced into a government official investigation and then as is usually the case in Sweden, which is a collectivist consensus society turned into law or policy. So that's where we're at. And I think we in Finland are the two, because Norway got rid of gender science and gender pedagogy in school, but Finland and Sweden still has them.

And you can see that the results are, they started going up in the beginning, especially for girls and then declining rapidly for boys. Now they're declining for both sexes. But the gender difference between the sexes are now abysmally large. And that's what I wanted to talk to you about because you define yourself as a liberal in the American context, right?

Sort of. I don't know. I've noticed in the American context that I keep using the pronoun we, when I talk about conservatives lately, I define myself primarily as a liberal in the gold flag context. So what?

W.S.I.B. W.S.I.B. presents The Lost Finger Club. I just got here after a table saw me seven at work.

Oh, coming to crew. That's a pinky pointy and thumbs. Hello. What's that guy's problem?

That's the bird. He can't help it. Keep your bits. Learn more at practiceafework.ca.

Great question. When was the last time a display ad changed your mind? Now think about the last time a friend told you about something they loved. Different feeling, right?

That's how podcast advertising works. A host who's built a real trust with their audience talks about your brand and their own words and their own voice. It doesn't interrupt the experience. It's part of it.

With ACAST, you can access the world's largest podcast marketplace. Choose the right shows, the right audiences, the right format. What's the data tell you it worked? You're not buying impressions.

You're buying influence. Learn more by visiting ACAST.com slash advertise. What Americans, I'm not exactly what Americans call a libertarian, but something closer to that. You know, government should be extremely small and limited, et cetera.

We have rights that are, I don't even believe in a creator, but the pre-seed, the state by one means or another endowed by a creator is one means of framing that and that the role of the government is to help secure those rights for the citizens with the consent of the government. Those kinds of views are the views that I hold. My orientation is primarily toward liberty and the maximum individual liberty and therefore individualism seeing people not as members of a collective, but rather as individuals who can willfully participate in the ways that they choose to do. But how do you distinguish yourself from other people in the United States who call themselves liberals?

The vast majority of the people in the United States who call themselves liberals actually do want something, as you said, they're false liberals. They're not actually interested in liberalism as a political philosophy. We look at John Locke or Thomas Jefferson or any of these kinds of characters, Thomas Payne and whoever else. They are not interested in that kind of a political philosophy.

They are actually closer to what you would call social democrats. They want a kind of, as a Democrat part of that is that they want a not necessarily so much representative democracy, but a kind of very direct amount, more and more direct democracy from the people. And they want large social programs that democracy is in choosing, you know, how they're going to direct a very large public slush fund really that they're going to be bringing in through high taxes, et cetera. They see, I mean, kind of, I mean, thinking this lately, I see that there are sort of three answers to the question and who is responsible for solving the problems that we face as a very general question.

Then the three answers I kind of perceive that people give are God and then society and then the self, the individual. And if you draw a triangle and put those up at three corners, instead of a political spectrum, I think in terms of the political triangle now, and the right wing generally tends toward God and the conservatives and the leftists generally tend toward society, society's responsibility to come together collectively to solve our problems and that people that I consider myself as a liberal tend toward, no, we're going to take personal responsibility. God helps those who help themselves as Benjamin Franklin famously quipped. And so I think more it's that, you know, we need to take up action as individuals who can cooperate if they choose to voluntarily form.

So it's like teamwork versus collectivism being two different ways of organizing people so that the voluntary aspects that each individual can choose which associations they want to be involved in and which ones they don't is in that top corner or the self corner, whichever you want to orient the triangle doesn't matter. So what distinguishes me is I'm closer to that self, it's up to us to solve our problems and we should have as much personal responsibility in that in the so-called Adam Smith invisible hand will emerge as an emergent phenomenon to individuals trying to solve their own problems in the best way they can with a political structure, liberalism, this designed to minimize violent conflict between people who don't agree, whereas the people who call themselves liberal in the United States, democratic party types are much closer to that society solves our problems. We are a collective, which is ultimately actually leftism, not liberalism. So if you think of there being three political polls, not two, it's not liberal versus conservative.

It's conservatives, liberals and leftists is three different orientations. Most of the people in the United States who call themselves liberals are actually much closer to leftists. Very few of them are actually liberal in their orientation, more or less at all. And I very much am.

Most of the people in the United States who consider themselves libertarian are very close to that liberal access, but I think they go more extreme than I do. I would probably place myself slightly toward the middle of it, not in the exact center, on the liberal part of the triangle, but slightly toward the center from what a pure, again, Thomas Jefferson or Thomas Payne kind of view of liberalism would be. I think that's a little bit naive to be purely that each individual will solve all of them problems for himself and everything will work out great. I think that misses something, but nevertheless.

It's interesting to hear you say that. I've never thought about it like that, but I usually divide up humanity into individualists on one hand, and then two different types of collectivists, egalitarian and hierarchical. Yeah, that's good. Yeah.

That would be very similar, actually, to you could draw a very similar triangle. And in fact, these two triangles might overlap virtually perfectly, depending on how you want to label the corners. And so I certainly am not in that leftist category, though. What distinguishes me, I don't accept the idea that it's my responsibility to solve somebody else's problems at a general level.

There may be places where I might need to be asked to contribute or something, or where it's sensible to, but in general, society doesn't fix our problems. Individuals solving their small problems scales up by the magic of emergent properties of behavior. I think you're right. That's why it's so troublesome for a person who lives in, let's say, the outskirts of the West, the northeastern outskirts of the West.

Two hours flight from Ukraine, by the way. So it's troublesome to see the most individualist country in the world, the United States, descending into, I guess you would use the word quagmire or John Stewart once upon a time, use the word clusterfuck. So do you see any potential hope or any good forces uniting apart from your own new disc courses? Yes, actually.

I mean, I get asked to travel all around the country. I think it would be, I could say, around the world if it weren't for the pandemic restrictions. I get asked to travel all around the country. I average a trip and a half a week.

So three trips every two weeks on average I take, and I go somewhere and I speak with people. And there are small organizations and large organizations kind of cropping up all over the United States now that are not, I don't like the word populist because it has a certain, certain flavor to it that people think it leads to fascism. But there are freedom loving people who are very large, in some cases, very large grassroots movements that are building. I mean, there's an example of Utah is not a particularly, you know, famously large and populist state in the United States.

Maybe people have heard of it, but they have a parents organization that has something like 60 or 70,000 members that they put together in a year. So there's, there's a lot of people to get together in a state that I think has only 3 million population or less. And so there are some things happening all around and they dip into my new discourses for inspiration and information, but they're not affiliated with me. I'm not creating a gigantic movement under my direction and I don't want to.

So I see this happening like a state after state, I was just in Florida last week and I saw it there. There's a gigantic organization headquartered there called Moms for Liberty. The Moms for Liberty is now got 31 or 32 states, 175ish chapters where it's just getting everyday Moms and I guess dads alongside their wives active to take on what's happening in the schools and in their, their kind of local governance level issues. And so these things are happening and there are a lot of reasons for hope.

I'm afraid of how much power our government administration's we've seen just recently with Canada more than the United States, but the United States has all of these capabilities and more as well to step away from, you know, their, their oath to the Constitution that we take so seriously and do something that's very tyrannical and very, very much forcing kind of a collectivist mindset on us. There are reasons to be very nervous. In other words, but I see a lot of reasons for hope. People I think have been sleepy maybe since 1989 when the Soviet Union collapsed, the Berlin wall came down and people incorrectly believe that large collectivist ideologies had been left in the past and Francis Fucqui on my rights, the end of history implying that liberalism of the American sort will now just slowly spread around the world and that's not what happened, of course not.

And I think we went to sleep, but I think we're also waking back up very quickly and it's, I find I feel like, I feel very encouraged most of the time where a year ago I felt very discouraged most of the time because I felt like people thought I had lost my mind and that I didn't have to study what I was talking about. Now, when I say things about what's happening, people say, oh yeah, I see that. You're right. This is the best way to understand it or a good way to understand this.

Thank you. And then what can I do? Okay. And then lawyers are thinking things up and teachers are thinking things up and people are, it's nashing, it's new, but people are figuring things out and taking action.

So I find it very encouraging. I tell people I'm cautiously optimistic, whereas previously I was hopefully pessimistic. So that's a, that's a bit of improvement. Well, it's very good to hear over here.

It's pitch black with no hope of redemption. But yeah, I worry a lot about Europe in general. And Europe lurched into this kind of tyrannical control model, much, and I'm no expert in what's happening in Europe. So don't let me mislead you.

But it lurched much more, much more thoroughly and quickly than the United States did. I've been invited to Europe, but I refuse to get injected. And so I don't come to Europe. It's just not possible.

I've been invited to do things in a handful of European countries last year and this year. And I refuse to take the shot. And mostly because they tell me I have to, which makes me think that there's something fishy about that. And so I refuse to do it just because I've been told I must.

I've even had the virus. Why do I care? But I've done too many drugs in my youth to say no to free ones. That's because it would be hypocrisy.

I've literally eaten things out of bags I found on streets when I was young. So it would be strange if I refused a little needle that for once was clean. Yeah. So but yeah, Europe has lurched much, much more quickly and deeply into this.

And then simultaneously, of course, you know, as you pointed out, two hours flight from Ukraine, we're right on the edge now of a teeth gritting conflict that is will have is having already global implications of kind of the most serious sort and the nature of that conflict superficially appears very clear. But if you scratch the surface, it's not at all clear what's going on for in reality between Russia and Ukraine, not at all clear. And what what that means for, you know, Eastern and North Eastern and Central Europe and the rest of the world also remains very unclear if you don't know actually what's going on. Well, in either case, if you do believe you know what's going on or you don't know what's going on, it's not clear how that's going to play out globally and regionally.

So Europe is an I don't envy my European friends and the prospects that they're staring at. But I also am a naive American and maybe American chauvinist a little bit where I believe that if America holds, then there's hope for everybody else on the outside. That's pretty much how I view it. I've been in your country enough times to know it isn't perfect, but I also know as superpowers go, there are far worse alternatives.

And we're about to find that out to the hard way it looks like. Yeah. I was going to bring up something that might trouble you, but you know, I'm from the same country as Dr. Michael Nielsen, who has criticized cynical theories in the Israeli paper, Germany-owned parrots.

Could you tell me a bit about that? You know, I don't think very much about it. I read his criticism once some time ago. I find him to be a bit amusing, to be honest with you.

I read these kinds of criticisms and typically my reaction is to laugh and then to go on with my day. And you know, as a Southern American, I don't know that this translates into Swedish very well, but we say things like bless your heart when we think that we want to say something really well. But it sounds like bless your little brain for some reason. That's exactly what it means, bless your little brain.

Yeah, I mean... Well, every other channel is fighting for your customer's attention. Podcasts are where they've already given it. No one accidentally listens to a podcast for 45 minutes.

They choose to be here. They trust the voice in their ears. And when that voice talks about your brand, it doesn't sound like advertising. It sounds like a recommendation from a front.

ACAST gives you that trust at scale. Digital precision, post-read authenticity, and performance data that proves it worked. Don't fight for attention. Buy it with ACAST.

Learn more by visiting acast.com slash advertise. He's an interesting character. And I got a lot of criticism. There are a lot of criticism of cynical theories.

And in fact, I did a podcast. I got frustrated enough with these. His might have been among them. In fact, it might have been the one that triggered it.

I don't remember somebody. It was. It was. You called the podcast.

There's no good part of Hitler's mind comf. No, I actually had a different podcast as well. But no, I did one specifically about him, but there is no good part of Hitler's mind comf. I actually reread Mind Comf in December.

And I still stand by it. It's not a very good book. But I did another podcast where I said that I was giving the actual criticism that... ...

cynical theories deserves. As the author, I know it's shortcomings. And I know it's shortcomings very well. And I don't think that the ones that people are trying to point at are the shortcomings of cynical theories.

The shortcomings of cynical theories are that it's narrowly focused on postmodernism while ignoring critical theory in the broader Marxist context. And so I did a podcast about that. As far as being no... I mean, if we want to go after Nielsen directly, it's very simple.

He said that we picked for one of our fake papers. So back to the fake paper thing. It wasn't actually about cynical theories. That we wrote one of our papers was accepted by a social work journal.

And what we did was we took a chapter of Mind Comf and we took out everywhere Hitler said our movement and replaced it with intersectional feminism. And then we just started fudging things to make it work. And we had to change a lot of the language because there are plagiarism machines that will tell if you've plagiarized and we didn't want it to be given away. And it turns out that the way they work is they detect three consecutive words.

So very rarely could we leave three consecutive words intact. And so we had to move the words around and change the wording a lot, use a lot of synonyms and things so that it would disguise the fact of what it was. But it was the same argument that Hitler was making but saying that we need solidarity in the intersectional feminist movement as opposed to in the... What he was describing is his movement, the National Socialist Workers' Party of Germany, the Nazis.

And so he said, well, we chose chapter 12, which is the least bad. It's just this kind of descriptive chapter of what his movement will require of people. And I disagree with his characterization. He says the least bad chapter of Mind Comf that we chose the most milk toast one.

We didn't go... Chapter 11, it turns out, is the one where Hitler really lets loose on the juice. He really fires up about it. He mentions the juice over 300 times in chapter 11.

And so my rebuttal to him was really that's the point. So Hitler's book, for those who haven't read it, begins where he's complaining about his experiences in Vienna and elsewhere. He's complaining about what he sees politically. He's complaining about the circumstances of Germany following the first World War and proceeding that.

He's complaining about his own life. He spends a lot of time in the second and third chapter complaining about the Marxists who he hates. He thinks he ruining Germany and he says he hates them and he says he calls him to lose his mind arguing... I actually find that.

Maybe there's one good part of Mind Comf. But then he goes on and says that I suddenly realized, you know, in my anger one day, I think this is in the second chapter, that all the Marxists are juice. And then all of a sudden there's a massive change in the direction of the book. And so then chapter 11, it builds up and it gets matter and matter and matter and matter is political enemies.

So by chapters four and five and six and seven, he's very angry at his political enemies. These are often tied back to Jews and very anti-Semitic kind of conspiracy theory that he's laid out. And then by chapter 11, it was just a chapter famously about race and politics. He lays into both the Jews and his answer in an Aryan kind of race mythology with, you know, racial superpowers, a very positive eugenics approach to creating a super race, a super munchry race out of Germans and in the Teutonic peoples and Anglo-Saxons.

And so these are the people that he's identified as being the excellent superior people and they're going to be fostered into a super race to win a race war against all of these inferior races and there's no mingling and you can't mix blood. That's where you get the blood and soil thing from. And so he rails on them in this chapter 11. And then chapter 12, he says, we need a movement.

So the first chapter of the solution to what he's laid out as a gigantic race, race problem and conspiracy theory in the Jews, massive anti-Semitism. The next chapter in the book is we need a movement to solve this problem. That's not the best. That is not the least bad chapter.

That is the beginning of the nightmare. And so that's the one that we translated into intersectional feminist language or transliterated, I suppose, intersectional feminist language. I disagree with this characterization. I would understand.

I would sympathize with this argument if I kind of step back and abstract from what he's trying or wanting to say. The intersectional feminist project is not Nazi. It is not national socialist in orientation. My new book, Race Marxism, I have an entire section where I go into exquisite detail pointing out that even though it uses racial-focused nationalism, even though it has these uncanny parallels, even though it actually classifies Jews as white and then scapegoats Jews in the same way that the Nazi scapegoats Jews, what we're dealing with in critical race theory, for example, is in fact Marxist, not Nazi.

It is not fascist. It is, in fact, communist. And so if we take back to the furthest step, Nielsen's best criticism that he could have given is he's conflating a communist movement and a fascist movement. And in fact, if you look closely at the contours of this intersectional feminist or this critical race theory that he's complaining about, you will find no contours of Naziism.

You'll find no positive race ideology. There's no positive race ideology in it. You'll find instead a Marxian conflict theory that at the time of writing, they were naive and didn't understand it. Therefore, conflated things they shouldn't have conflated.

That would have been the best argument that he could have made against what we actually did. That's not the argument that he made. He said that we fundamentally misunderstood what we're doing and that these fields are actually doing important social work and the correct direction and that we're actually clowns who don't know what we're talking about. I think he left you a clue at the end of the article.

I don't know if you remember. I don't. But the last paragraph was basically a rallying cry for socialist ideology. He said, guys like James Lindsay or Peterson or Ivar RPL of Sweden, they are conservative or paleo conservative individuals.

And they just want to destroy equity. I think you would call it in American English nowadays. The Russian word originally is chugaluvism. It means sameness.

It's not the same as equality. And I wanted to bring him up because you see a few years ago I wrote a book here in Sweden about what I call a Swedish culture of silence. That's permeated the entire social democratic reign which is almost 100 years. So it looked like this.

And then the state prosecuted me for they said the cover of the book because I had defamed the national symbol. But it was really about the content. And Michael Nielsen, he hadn't read a book but he told me on Twitter that I was a liar in a charlatan. And then he started what you call it when someone badmouths you.

Smears? Yeah, it starts smearing me on Twitter for months. And that went on until I had won a Pills Court. My case went up to a Pills Court and I won and I was free of charges.

And then the day after I had won the biggest social democratic paper, RBL that published an interview with Nielsen and then the think tank of the social democratic ruling party, the workers movement and the unions started collecting money online for him to write a book to smear me. So I just wanted you to know when it comes to Michael Nielsen, he is not entirely objective. And I know you've talked a lot about how these people from what you might call these leftist contingencies operate. Would you like to expand?

Well, I mean, he's done similar things to me on Twitter as well. I don't pay very much attention to him. And my account is so large. This isn't a kind of a bragging thing.

This is a structural problem I don't know how to deal with and maybe shouldn't deal with. The way that Twitter is structured is if your account gets larger and larger, they only give you notifications from people who have significant also larger accounts or the blue check mark. And so I very I'm very frequently only see things from him if somebody sends them to me directly, because otherwise it's not that I'm ignoring him. It's not even delivered to me in a meaningful context that I can see.

Or if I have every now and then I will stumble across it. I'll see it just by chance. I never search my own name. So I don't go looking for I never ever do.

I just don't care what people are saying about me and I find it distracting and a waste of money. So this is exactly the kind of thing. What he gives this clue about rallying cry for socialists is the thing that they do. They attempt a manufacturer a sense of false consensus, which is very dangerous in a country like Sweden where you said that it is a collective as consensus driven society.

This is what in fact the postmodern philosophers, one of the things that they got more right than wrong. They still had their parts that were wrong with it. John Francois Lietard for example, wrote about the legitimation by pherology. And nobody knows what that means.

What it means is that we tend to go with consensus and that consensus can in fact be what he said was in fact is a political phenomenon. What we might even in his more extreme manifestations, it takes on the shape of mass formation. Psychosis is the phrase of the year happens to be already. And so the socialist approach frequently is to generate a sense of consensus that nobody in their right mind or nobody intelligent and educated or nobody who's a good person would say these things.

And so you try to create a consensus push away from people who say inconvenient truths for their political ideology and every political ideology faces inconvenient truths. There's particularly faces a lot of them as it turns out because at least if it's Marxist socialism, which not all socialism is, but if it's Marxist socialism, Marx was a disaster. It's philosophy is catastrophe. It doesn't work.

It's completely an inversion of reality. So it's going to create inverted results, which means the inversion of flourishing and living is failing and dying. And so that's what you see everywhere Marxism has been forced into power. So it doesn't surprise me to see this kind of behavior.

It doesn't surprise me one bit to see this kind of behavior. Well, I wanted to do that. I had another comment. Every time someone sends you a tweet from him or whatever, you can send a thought of thanks to the Swedish Social Democratic government who helped finance him.

Our school minister helped to collect money for him online. Yeah, how about that? That's the other thing. I was a lot of these things are very crooked.

We talked about the American phenomenon of these parents fighting back for school boards. What I find in state after state after state that I travel to is that parents are getting informed, they're digging in, they're finding out what's going on for real and their school boards and that what you have is a small number of fairly well healed and very well financed activists who are coming in and they work up a group of people in the local area that make noise and can push things around as it turns out. This is straight out of the this is this is what if we were in the military, we're calling an insurgency model. They are engaging in certain behavior.

It's sad to find out that the Social Democratic government of Sweden is financing an insurgent for a for their political program. But this is this is the name of dirty politics. This is this is how it works. And it's unfortunate.

And I actually interestingly spoke with a military intelligence officer recently in my own personal life and we were talking about insurgency and counterinsurgency and he was actually a counterinsurgency expert for the US Navy. And what he pointed out to me was that the way that you stop the insurgency model is by shining light on it. You put a spotlight on the guy who's receiving money, you show that where the transactions are taking place and then people don't trust that they no longer trust. The insurgent and he can't whip up the local population because he's seen as a troublemaker.

And so it's helpful. We should we should think the Swedish government every time he does his propaganda because every time that that people become aware of that connection, he becomes less influential with his propaganda. I hope so. I hope you're right.

I've taken up quite a lot of your time, I say, but I want to thank you so much for coming on deconstructive criticism. And I hope I can call you again at some point in the future. Yeah, we can do that. We can definitely do that.

Thank you. Thank you, James Lindsay. Thank you. Thank you for listening to or watching deconstructive criticism.

This episode's guest was James Lindsay. You can find his work on YouTube under new discourses and the book, Cynical Theories, is available online. You can find the link to the Swedish translation on my web page, aronflamm.com in the description of this episode. Thank you for supporting deconstructive criticism.

You can support my work on patreon at patreon.com slash aronflamm via PayPal, bitcoin or swish double four six oh seven six eight nine four three seven three seven. If you want to find out more about me, you can always visit my web page aronflamm.com or by my book as an ebook on Kindle. This is a Swedish tiger. It is also available on my web page at aronflamm.com slash merchandise.

My name is Aaron phlam. Until next, have a good unit of time. Do you keep hearing podcast ads like this one, for example, but always wonder how you actually get involved with them for your own brand or organization? Well, it's easier than you think.

We're a cast and we give you the platform to do it all yourself. Browse thousands of popular podcasts, choose the shows that match your perfect audience, set your budget and launch. And if you want to hand, our podcast specialists are there to help you launch with confidence. This is podcast advertising without barriers.

Get started at acast.com slash advertising.

weder übel no hart Anna und Lara Hallo zemme! Mir si "weder übel no hart", zwei Zwilling us dr Schwiz, wo viel und gern rede. Genau so vielsitig wie eusi Interesse, werde au d Theme si, wo mr uf dem Podcast mit euch genauer wei aluege. Ehrlich, direkt und ungfilteret werde mir eus ustusche, euch unterhalte und euch vilicht drbi au neui Denkastöss mitgeh. Grenze setze mir eus keini; s git nämlich scho gnueg. "weder übel no hart" uf Instagram: @annauebelhart, @larauebelhart. Bi Froge, Aregige, Kritik, Feedback oder Idee: eifach e DM schicke. Explicit THE VOGS (Voice Of Galih Seto) Galih Seto Abadi Cerita di sini tidak abadi, hanya cerita kemarin, hari ini, besok dan yang akan datang. Selamat mendengarkan. Keluh kesah, gembira, dan harapan akan terekam disini. Karena ini Tidak Abadi. Kritik dan saran bisa ke, E-mail : [email protected] Ig : @thevogsid Twitter : @thevogs Powered by Firstory Hosting Explicit PODCAST TSx Podcast TSX podcast ini akan membahas berbagai macam topik yang menarik. Dengan saya @triskysantosoo . Saya tidak hanya sendiri karena saya akan di temani ngobrol ngobrol dengan teman teman saya yang tidak kalah menariknya. podcast ini akan di upload secara berkala tiap minggunya. Kalian juga bisa follow akun ig podcast ini @podcast_tsx atau email [email protected] untuk kritik saran dan masukannya. Terima kasih Explicit Penikmat Kutipan Putri wulan Podcast ini dibuat untuk memacu diri agar menjadi pribadi yang lebih baik.Bila ada saran/kritik kirim via DM @putsetiani Explicit

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of DEKONSTRUKTIV KRITIK?

This episode is 50 minutes long.

When was this DEKONSTRUKTIV KRITIK episode published?

This episode was published on March 11, 2022.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this DEKONSTRUKTIV KRITIK episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.