Jonathan Sacerdoti - Oxford Union: The West Is Right to Be Suspicious of Islam

Journalist and broadcaster Jonathan Sacerdoti joins Peter to talk about Jewish identity in Britain, rising antisemitism, and his two Oxford Union debates.  He describes growing up in London as a British Jew whose father survived the Holocaust in hiding, and why he no longer sees Jewish concerns as separate from wider threats to Western society. Jonathon recounts the 2024 Israel debate, where students abused him on camera and the Union later edited the footage, and the more recent motion that “the West is right to be suspicious of Islam” in which he was on the proposition side with Tommy Robinson and Lawrence Fox. He discusses the Union president’s “true Islam” argument, reforming Muslims and ex-Muslims, treatment of women and apostates, protests outside the chamber, Jacob Rees-Mogg’s case against suspicion, and why he released his own recording after the Union delayed publication. Watch Jonathon's full Oxford Union speech here https://x.com/jonsac/status/2084205655892590917?s=20 Jonathan Sacerdoti is a journalist, commentator, and analyst known for bringing clarity and balance to complex and often polarising issues. With a measured and thoughtful approach, he explores subjects ranging from extremism and antisemitism to wider cultural and political debates. From in-depth podcast interviews and public speaking to television reporting and regular written commentary he is driven by a deep commitment to accuracy and open discourse. Connect with Jonathon... X                                               @jonsac  https://x.com/jonsac SUBSTACK                              https://jonsac.substack.com/ WEBSITE                                 https://www.jonathansacerdoti.com/   Connect with Hearts of Oak... 𝕏                         x.com/HeartsofOakUK WEBSITE            heartsofoak.org/ PODCASTS        heartsofoak.podbean.com/ SOCIAL MEDIA  heartsofoak.org/connect/ SHOP                  heartsofoak.org/shop/ *Special thanks to Bosch Fawstin for recording our intro/outro on this podcast. Check out his art theboschfawstinstore.blogspot.com and follow him on 𝕏 x.com/TheBoschFawstin