Membedah Realistic Evaluation: Mechanisms, Contexts, dan Outcomes
from Perantau Ilmu Hosted by Dimas P. Muharam
Pawson, R. and Tilley, N. 2008. Realistic evaluation. Los Angeles: Sage. In this foundational text, Ray Pawson and Nick Tilley advocate for Scientific Realism as a superior alternative to traditional experimental and constructivist methods in social program evaluation. The authors argue that merely observing whether a program "works" is insufficient; instead, researchers must investigate the underlying mechanisms that trigger change within specific social contexts. By utilizing a formula that links mechanisms, contexts, and outcomes, the book provides a rigorous framework for understanding how different participants respond to various interventions. Through detailed case studies in criminal justice and public health, the text demonstrates how to design evaluations that generate transferable knowledge rather than isolated data points. Ultimately, the work seeks to move the field toward a more objective and cumulative science by treating programs as theories that can be tested and refined through a structured teacher-learner relationship between researchers and stakeholders. This approach aims to provide policy makers with practical insights into what works for whom and under what specific conditions.
Embed this episode
No transcript yet.