More on Bad and Good Multiple Attestation Claims
from The Lydia McGrew Podcast Hosted by Lydia McGrew Podcast
Even when we have multiple accounts saying the same thing, each account must have *some* credibility for what it narrates. Conjoining multiple individually worthless accounts of an event does not magically create powerful testimonial evidence by mere multiplication. That point follows from the very nature of testimonial evidence, as John Earman pointed out. While multiple attestation can be a very powerful tool, once you have stripped the individual attestations of *all* force, you can't go back and fix matters just by saying that you have more than one.Moreover, when accounts are so changed that we really don't know what we mean by attesting to the same event, multiple attestation also doesn't work, because there is no "it" that is multiply attested. For example, the account of the saying, "I thirst" doesn't attest to the saying, "My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?" And the account in Luke 5 of Jesus making a great catch of fish at the beginning of his ministry, before he has even died, doesn't attest to a post-resurrection appearance.Here on the Wayback Machine is Licona's response to Bart Ehrman in which he makes a bad argument that the authors of the infancy stories would be reporting secure core facts, due to "multiple, independent attestation," even if they were engaging in wholesale invention of incidents.https://tinyurl.com/LiconavsEhrmanHere is an article I published in the journal Themelios on some of these issues:https://www.thegospelcoalition.org/themelios/article/finessing-independent-attestation-interdisciplinary-biblical-criticism/
Embed this episode
No transcript yet.