Skip to content
Optimizing Your Landing Pages Part 2 episode artwork

Feb 21, 2008 55 min

Optimizing Your Landing Pages Part 2

from MarketingExperiments.com Web Clinic Podcasts Hosted by MarketingExperiments

The MarketingExperiments team conducts live optimization on Landing Pages sent in by our subscribers.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Optimizing Your Landing Pages Part 2

0:00 55:36
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Two weeks ago, we began having you submit your pages to us, and we optimized those pages live with leaders from our scientists group. There was an overwhelming response. I think we had, I'm not sure precisely, the number of perhaps 1,200 people registered for that event. We could clearly not get to all of the landing pages, but we did get through many of them, and there was such a demand for more of this. We're going to do a second session now. We're going to bring up the landing pages that you've submitted, landing pages from people in our own subscriber list, and we're going to start to optimize those live. I want to kind of prepare you for that and teach you something for just a few moments, and then we're going to go straight to those pages.

So if you would, just look with me at the formula that I have at the top of the page. It's OPR is greater than OPRN is greater than OCNN. Now, this is perhaps the most simple formula that we developed, but what it means is that in order of magnitude, it's more important to optimize your product first, and then your presentation, which is the way we describe the presentation of your product, your website and all the collateral around it, emails, et cetera, and then optimize your channels. And this is vital because many of us... work on our channels before we work on our landing pages. I can't help you with your product. That's different than marketing. There are times when we actually get into that level, but I can suggest that in a year where the economy is tightening and in a time when competition on the net only increases,

it's better to optimize the presentation, that is your landing page, than it is to optimize your paid search campaign. Because if you're going to spend $1 on paid search to get one person to visit your site, you might as well make the most money per visit at that site. And if your current site is yielding $1.10 and you spent $1 to get someone there and you've made $0.10 because they arrived, it would be much better if you were to focus on making that site worth $2 a click, and that will give you two advantages. Number one, you'll make more money. Number two, you'll be able to increase your pay-per-click bid and defeat your competition.

I'm going to continue, but let me just say this. When we've ran page search analyses, one of the ways that we've been so effective in giving someone competitive advantage is that we have optimized their pages so thoroughly that they actually make more money per visit than their competitors, and thus they can afford to pay more per visit than their competitors. So we are going to look at that in particular today, and we're going to use something called the conversion index, which is a formula that many of you have probably seen. It outlines a series of elements that we teach in our certification classes and that we've developed in our sciences lab for improving the performance on a last page.

A little static, John. I'd like you to check and make sure that there's clarity. I don't know if that static is on our end or anywhere else coming in, but let's just watch for it. It might be good for me to do a sound check with the audience. Can you hear me clearly? Just go ahead and use your Q&A or feature to let me know if you think my voice is coming in clearly. Good. It seems to be from the responses. Thank you. All right, so we want you to understand this index just before we begin, because while you're going to hear Jimmy Ellis and Aaron Rosenthal and myself talking about landing pages, it's going to sound as if we're working with an intuitive grasp based on the experience that we've had from hundreds upon hundreds of experiments and case studies.

And there's some truth to that, but actually there's a methodology that has been so deeply embedded into our subconscious that we do it automatically now without thinking. And that methodology is wrapped around the simplicity of this formula. This formula actually can be quite complex at times, but for the purposes of your landing page, you might find it a simple way to think better about your site. The number in front of the letter represents the significance or importance relative to the other variables. So 4 in front of M means that's the most important variable on the formula. And this 2 in front of A means that's important, but not as important as the M.

And I'd like you to look at this, and let's just walk through it and understand it before we start these pages. When we talk about M, we're talking about the motivation of the user coming into your site. The formula says this. The probability of your visitor converting... is equal to, and now we start on the index to the right. First of all, the motivation of the user. What we've discovered is that no matter what you do in optimization, a highly motivated user will put up with a lot of pain to get what they want. And that there's a segment of your traffic that's more motivated than other segments. And that if you optimize within that segment, you may not realize that you're still leaving lots of money on the table because those highly motivated visitors are enduring a lot more pain than some of your other visitors will put up with. It's very important then to study your channels, discover where your highest motivated users are coming from, and make certain that you've maximized the amount of people who visit through that channel.

So N is important, but it's very hard to optimize for, which brings me to the next variable, which is D, and that's the way you express your value proposition. If it's not the value proposition itself, it's the way you express it. We must assume that you have a good one, while it's true that many, many marketers do not, but let's assume that you do. Having a good value proposition is not enough. On that landing page, it must be expressed clearly, and it's the clarity that's so important. Clarity trumps persuasion, and you must have clarity there. They must understand why you are the best choice for them.

Your value proposition should answer the question, if I'm the ideal customer, let's suppose that I am, why should I purchase from you rather than any other competitor? That's the value proposition. In this case, in the formula, it's the clarity of that that's so important. F is friction. That's all the things in this type that annoy people. The reduction of unnecessary friction is vital in the formula. I stands for the incentives, and you balance incentives against friction, and almost no one is doing that right. There's tremendous amounts of money to be generated from doing this. A is for the relief of anxiety. John, go backwards and show us the expression again.

So if you can get the value proposition communicated clearly, and by the way, that's not something you do in a slogan. Every aspect of your side communicates your value proposition. And if you can get the incentive high enough to counter for any friction, for instance, if you have a long form, reduce it to the least possible number of fields and then incentivize people to get through those fields. And then if you can eliminate or reduce anxiety, anxiety actually can never be eliminated. It can only be reduced.

You can get most of anxiety gone, but you can never eliminate friction completely because if you're going to ask them for money, you're necessarily generating friction. The question is, how do you create enough value on the other side of the equation to mitigate against the friction? Now, if you're an old-time subscriber with our group, you've heard these things before. But I want you to know that with a fundamental grasp of this simple index, we're going to actually attack these landing pages that have been placed in front of us and do our very best to help some people who can actually take what we say on this phone and use it in their own sight. Now, clearly, we can't cover every single landing page for all of the many people that are on this call right now. But I think that by carefully paying attention, you can learn a great deal because we are checking.

and picking landing pages from the audience that should be representative of our entire audience, and the things we suggest for this site coming up next, for instance, may help you with your site. I mean, that's the whole point. I want to truly help the people who have submitted their pages, but I also want to help the rest of the audience, the rest of our subscribers, glean information that's practical, that's relevant, and that they can use to see an immediate gain. So help me. I'm going to be asking for your opinion as we proceed. And I see some questions coming in, and someone says, will you cover websites that are selling services and not products? I believe we are, and I know that we did in the last session.

So if there's any issue with this session, you certainly can go back to the last session and look at some of those. That's posted live. It's on the net. You can get the audio, and you can see the actual site along with our suggestions. Make certain that we are not blocking your spam filters because we will send you out all of this later. You'll be able to hear the recording, and you'll be able to look at our suggestions. They will have been written up by our editors here so that you can get that. Also, and this is not a commercial. I don't know if there's anything there for sale, but I don't think there is. Go to our website. There's more than $10 million worth of research, and it's free, all generated by the Science Lab. Get a hold of that and use that. Let's get started on the pages themselves.

So I have a page up. Yes. All right. Go back one, John. Where did we lose that page? All right. Here we are. All right. So the page is up right now, and you should be able to see it. And this was submitted. And, oh, this is the changes made. I'm sorry, John. I see why you did that. I thought John made a mistake. I should have known it was me. Remember the email that I quoted at the beginning? John, take me back and show them.

Let's look at this. I didn't realize that's what that slide was. This is the before page on the left. This is before the last clinic. We worked on this page live, and this is the new page after the last clinic. And we're going to watch and see what the difference is in performance. And, Eric, you've made some good changes. I'll be interested. I would put some bold font in those paragraphs, by the way, in that main opening paragraph. And once this begins to work, then I start testing my headlines. We can talk more about that later. But I commend you on being so quick to implement the changes. Well done. Let's go to a new piece and look at it. All right, so I'm at AutoGenie.

We asked the company that submitted this what their value proposition was. They said better service at affordable cost. We asked where the channel, where the traffic came from, and they said the primary source of traffic to the page comes from a direct marketing postcard. By the way, if you're online, you should pay attention to that. Do not think, do not believe that the internet, because it's so cool and new that the real play is just on the digital side and that you should be doing all of your marketing through the net. There's a powerful way to combine offline and online marketing, and the best marketers have discovered the two go hand in hand together. Use the net to test everything you send offline. Test it there first because it's much less money. And in addition to that, use the net to build community from all the people who respond to your offline advertising. In this case, we're looking at a website, postcard sent traffic here, and I'm going to ask Jimmy Ellis, who has been working all week, day and night, preparing for the email summit. We're going to be teaching how to optimize your messages at the email summit in Sherpa in Miami this weekend.

Jimmy, I know you're blurry-eyed, but take a look at this site and tell me what you would do. I mean, so when I look at – is this the postcard, do we think? This is the postcard. This is the postcard that stands. And I can show them the page, but do you want to see the page first, Jimmy? I'm going to talk about the postcard first because I don't – no, my problem is I don't see a value proposition on here, and I don't see a clear call to action of what you want me to do. So I've looked at these guys' page before because they submitted it to the left.

call them and we got a couple emails and we took a look at them. I know that they build websites for car dealerships. I had never known that. I had never known that. That's exactly the point. I don't see that on here. I don't see, for example, another solution, just by going on their site and looking around, is a really good one-stop solution for car dealerships. I want to see it. Show me. So you've tried to build this problem. People aren't buying garbage. We did it 50 years ago. But you need to go directly into how Autogeny can solve that problem. So don't just tell them that they're buying on the Internet. Show them how your solution solves that problem or helps them.

sell their cars on the Internet with their sites and stuff like that. And that would be my absolute number one. I don't know what this is instantly, and then I don't know what I'm going to do after I see it. And I would test that graphic. When you say, Jimmy, the graphic of the fan-reading newspaper, I think you're going to find that that is a positive and a very negative reaction. And you're going to polarize your audience with that particular photograph. But keep going, Jimmy. No, I mean, I would rather just get to the – I mean, that's why I put the postcard. I'll go to the actual site. At the bottom of the page is the sign-up for your free trial today, but I don't even see that. It almost looks like it's in the spot where an address would be or a –

you know, a tagline or something to that extent. I don't even see that you've got a free trial here. It hasn't caught my eye and you haven't brought any attention to it. So focus on that free trial. If that's your call to action, you're going to get more response from using the free trial.

Now, you're talking about the bottom of the postcard, aren't you? Exactly, exactly. The go-to webinar has already gone. Oh, there it is. And I want to say this to Jimmy and Aaron. Rather than, you know, three minutes to Jimmy and three minutes to Aaron, let's talk back and forth, all three of us, because I think we can interact in a different way. Have you guys noticed there's no continuity between the postcard, which you should see on your screen now, and the landing page? And the continuity is one of the most important principles. You create an expectation with a card when they come from that to the web page.

It should connect. Where is the psychological connection here? And you've already lost me because you're trying to sell me on this limited-time offer $397 when I came to your site believing that there was a free trial and that I was 90 days of a free trial. So as soon as I see that price, I'm out of here. First of all, I don't know what you do. I don't know what you offer. I don't know what your value proposition really is. And you just got me to your site because you're using a free trial. And as soon as you greet me on your site, there's no mention of the free trial. Look at all the ways that real estate's face. Look how large that image is. It's true that that image – scroll back up, John. That image is on the postcard.

But the headline doesn't connect to the postcard in a way that's clear. The image takes up way too much real estate and accomplishes very little. In fact, it sends people away. You have to get halfway down the page before you can find any content that's meaningful. And I mean this in – in a gracious way because we want to help someone. We're not here to pick on you, but by being critical, perhaps we can. It's not that you need to make some changes. You need to burn the whole thing down and start over. The postcard needs to be redone and the landing page needs to be redesigned. And if you're going to go to a long-form landing page, greet them, talk to them, use a letter, appeal to them in a way that they can truly understand. I would venture to say that a lot of the value from this, well, I wouldn't even go there. There's so much more that needs to be done. But I would suggest that you have in the conversion index, the only people you're getting are the people that are highly motivated.

Remember the four that's placed in front of the M? Highly motivated users. Those people will sort this out, perhaps figure out what it's saying. But your nav on your left, does it look like nav? It looks like banners? I guess it's nav.

which people then are completely lost. Jimmy, you go ahead. I want to kind of dig into the motivation piece real quick because a lot of times people don't really see it until you give them a few examples of how that ties in. So on this one, for example, if you had your own car dealership and you've been looking for a website solution, let's say for two or three years, you just haven't found the right one, and finally you get on here and you realize that's what they do, this is the only one you can find, although there's others out there, but this is the only one you can find, and you're just dying to sign up and get a free trial, then those are most likely the only people the Autogenie would be able to get at this point. They're not getting the people that may already have a solution or are less qualified.

Once you fix the other pieces of the conversion net, after motivation, you will actually maximize the less motivated people. So you're basically casting a wider net. Not only are you casting a wider net, but you're getting more of those people to the boat. Whereas the auto team right now is using a smaller net and only getting a few fish in that net actually to the boat. That was the whole thing. The relationship of motivation to converting on your pages is huge. And like I said, if you have super highly qualified customers for your specific product, it's easy to get sales because they'll do almost anything to get it. But when you don't, which is probably 95% plus of probably everybody on the site doesn't have super qualified, super motivated buyers, you have to hit those other elements before you're going to see the big game.

All right. I'm going to summarize and we're going to move on. The postcard itself needs to do several things. It needs to be a miniature version of your landing page because it's not something you can click through. People have got to do the extra effort of going to the website. Its only job should not be to sell you but to get you to visit the website. That's the only thing it should do. You should clarify its objective. It's trying to do too much work here. Once the postcard has been designed to do nothing but clearly communicate to you a follow-up reason that would make you invest the time to actually go to your computer and pull up the website, it's done its job. Don't do any more than that. Any more than that will interfere with the actual sale. Do all the selling on the page itself.

And I would probably do that with, A, a professional-looking site. B, I would probably have a letter written to them explaining what you're doing. C, I would sprinkle it with solid testimonials from real dealerships that could tell you how this offering has helped them. And I would then, D, probably eliminate NAB on the left, have it only on the bottom so that it didn't necessarily offer at all. I'd eliminate that massive top real estate waste, not just the man, but I'd shorten the banner at the top, deal with banner blindness and keep it very simple there, very clean, make it very easy for them to get to the page, see and understand what you offer.

and make a decision. I would also very likely promote one secondary objective on the page, and that is I would elevate the offer on the left of the page. You can't see it now where it talks about a free download of a white paper or something of that nature. I would, top ten reasons, whatever it is, I would make that incredibly attractive. I'd feature it on the page, and I'd try to capture the email address of anyone that I wasn't actually able to close through the page and then use that for a series of follow-up efforts, of course, with their permission based on, you know, Ken's Fan Act and so on. I think we should move on quickly. And so we're going to go to another site. We're trying to cover as many of these as we can. I'll bear with us. It's very hard to spend on each one.

All right, there's a link on the top. We're going to visit the site. This is the background. The value proposition, as they stated, is this. Creative noise-canceling headphones features extreme fidelity technology, which makes music and movies sound better than the headphones from competitors at this price point. There's problems with that value proposition, and that is that the stuff you're talking about has to have its own value proposition in order to support that value proposition. It's a value proposition within a value proposition within a value proposition. That means you've got to educate people before your value proposition has any impact. That's dangerous. That already mitigates conversion. Now you've got channel information, and this is telling us where the people come from visiting the page we're going to look at next. They come from a featured ad on Google. You can see the ad down there. From that ad...

on the left or from the sponsored link ad that we see on the right. They will go to the page, which we're going to show you next. I'm going to ask Aaron to start us, but I'd like this to be interactive like the last one, gentlemen. Let's just talk to each other about the site. Aaron, do you have any quick thoughts about the Google ad? You're an expert in this area. I absolutely do. The first thing that I'm going to point out is you're bidding on your own term for your branded term for the name of these headphones, and yet Amazon is bidding you on this term. And it may be because I'm looking at this and comparing your ad to Amazon.

A lot of marketers aren't doing it. They aren't comparing how their ad compares to a competitor. And I know these headphones are very, very expensive. Amazon has them for $75 or a version of what you're trying to offer for $75. But even if it's a different version, the customer doesn't know that. So they're advertising $75. They've got free shipping in their ad. Honestly, they've got a better ad. And so they're above you in the search engines. They've got a better ad. And you're losing traffic to Amazon. So your first problem is that you're not getting all the visitors that you could be.

Very good. And that's also much more qualified traffic. Aaron, tell them why Amazon traffic is more qualified. Sure. You've given them a price. They know they're getting free shipping, and they're already in that buying process. Your ad talks about these headphones, but they're in a different mindset when they click through on your ad versus when they're clicking through on the Amazon ad. They already have made their decision. They know the price. They know that they're getting free shipping, and they're clicking through. And all that that page has to do on the Amazon side is meet the expectations that the ad is set for. It doesn't have to do any hard selling.

I'm going to move to the next page. I will say I think your ad on the right is better than your ad on the left, but not if you were competing in the other space. Editor's choice is good, but I know where that editor's choice is coming from. If you can put credibility behind it, it makes it sound more legitimate. A lot of affiliates and a lot of sites are calling themselves editor's choice because, well, the person that wrote the copy on the page is an editor, and he chose this product or he chose the rest of the content, therefore it's editor's choice. So you see it all the time. Put some credibility behind it. Give the name. If it's a reliable source, quote it.

I'm holding back a little bit because I sit ahead and I see what's on the next page. Yeah, I understand that. All right. Well, then there's more that we could say about the ad. Perhaps that will help you, but we need to know the ad. Never optimize in a vacuum. Always understand where the traffic is coming from because, as I've said many times in these calls, optimization does not occur on a web page. It occurs in the mind of the person visiting your site. You're trying to understand the train of thoughts. You're anticipating those train of thoughts, and you're actually trying to help them move through a sequence of these thoughts that will lead to a decision to purchase.

And you're looking for anything that interrupts that decision or anything that becomes an obstacle to the train of thought. And so you must go backwards from the channel, forward to the landing page, and straight to the end of the by-process. With that in mind, we're looking at the landing page. And I'm going to let Jimmy Ellis, who's a particularly expert on retail product pages, to talk to us about what he would do. And Aaron, I'm thrilled to jump in and talk with Jimmy as we go.

Yeah, so I'm looking at this page, and my headline is The Audio Revolution Begins. But that's not telling me – I mean, it's like more of a branding type of headline. I want something that tells me, you know, help me understand why these are the best options for me. That's exactly what I wanted to question. I want to stop you there because you just said something that people are going to blow past and not understand, particularly big brands. The headline that you see here is what I call an institutional advertising headline, and it belongs on a slick magazine, not a landing page.

That is not a direct response headline, and I think that's what you're talking about, Jimmy. That's a branding headline. It's institutional advertising. It's branding advertising. It is not direct response. And if you come from the media channels associated with a lot of big brands, you don't get direct response. That headline should do a lot more work than this one is doing, and it's way, way too imprecise to do that work. So, Jimmy, while you're doing that, I'm going to ask my audience to submit headline examples. So, Jimmy, you keep talking, and you guys in the audience, go ahead and tell us how you change the headline. We've got some experts on here. Let's see how well you do. Use your Q&A feature and submit your headline.

Jimmy, go ahead. Sure. So I'm looking through this page, and I'm trying to look for convincing things that make me believe that these are really good headphones. First of all, I see the price. It's $299. Man, those are expensive, so these better be really, really good. So how am I going to determine that these are really, really good? Well, I can't because I don't see the features on here. I don't see a chart. I don't see how it compares to other competitive headphones. For example, they said that in their value proposition.

these are better at this price point, better sounding at this price point than their competitors. Well, show me. Show me a graph or a chart that has the top three or four or five headphones that compare to this, and show me how this is better in a chart so I can scan through the specifics and the details. I can find the things that are important to me personally, and then I can make my decision. I don't see any of that. So, like I said, this looks like a print ad to me. That's what it's coming across as not as an informational help me decide type of thing that will get me to buy these headphones. Another thing is I'm not going to believe creative telling me that these are the best headphones. Obviously, whoever company...

company made the headphones, they're going to say they're the best. But if you had really great testimonials or reviews, either one of those things. Now, the PC Magazine is great, but I want the real people's information and input about these headphones. I want people to say, oh, man, these are so much better than my Bose, you know, whatever model number headphones. They're so much better than my Sony headphones. If you can give me that backed by a chart that shows me why these are the best, and then you let me try it for free because here's one of the things. Actually, Aaron brought this up right before the call because we were actually looking at these headphones because they're pretty cool. And it says, try it out. It says, try it out 30 days. It's free. In that instance, why would you tell them it's $300 when they can try it for free? You scare a lot of people away with that price.

And not only that, you're not realizing or you're not doing the process of looking at your ads, your pay-per-click ad, which is how you told us people are getting to this page along with this landing page. Because Amazon has already prepped these customers, even if they make it to your site and don't buy from Amazon, they know that Amazon is offering a version of these for $75. And they come to your site and you're screaming here $300. Well, what are you offering different that Amazon isn't offering? Well, I'm pretty sure Amazon's not letting them try them for free. So if that's the case...

screen this, screen the free trial from this page. I would almost, you know, put it up there with a headline, maybe even test it as a headline. Now, it doesn't give you real credibility as far as why you need to own these headphones, but it does relay confidence in this, that this is a page, and you're not, this is a page that they're interested in. You get them reading and finding out more about these headphones. You're not scaring them. I've got to move us on, brother. I've got to move us on. I want to read some headlines you submitted.

Everything you're saying is good. I hate to cut you off because it should be very helpful. And I will summarize. Here are the headlines, the top five I just received, not in terms of quality, but the first five. The sound you've been looking for, noise, get some peace and quiet. Nothing but music, someone said. Experience the auto revolution now. Effective noise control makes your music sound better. That means...

In fact, I'll tell you what I'll do. I'll submit all – if I can, we'll take all the headlines that were submitted, and we'll send them over to the people who submitted this page, and they can look at the headlines from the various marketers. I want to just summarize and move on. The first thing is this. We now know that you're Editor's Choice from PCMag, and that's what it said in the page search ad. You should probably – anyone who clicked on the Editor's Choice ad ought to come to this page, and it probably ought to have the best sound bite you should pull from the PCMagazine article that named you Editor's Choice, and you might even find out the headline. And if you did, you put in a headline in quotes, and underneath it, it would say PCMagazine. Then there would be a subheader underneath that that emphasized the primary value of this over everything else.

You take the price off the Try It Now and you test them, clicking on Try It Now for free, you'd have higher conversion, but you might have less conversion on the other end. You'd have to test it both ways. I would not have the price on if I'm going to have it there in that place next to the Amazon ad, as Aaron has said. You need an iPad in that paragraph text. It's too hard to read, and you need a vertical layout, and you need a chart showing why this is probably the best choice in the marketplace. I'm going to move on. I hope that helps you. And Aaron and Jimmy, thanks again, guys.

I've got one more quick one for him. If they include the full PC Magazine Editor's Choice review on this page, it would be huge for him. If they include the full review, it would be from a third party, from a professional review company, and it would add so much credibility and weight that it would be significant. Absolutely. Something else just came to me. I just saw it. The email capture at the bottom of the page. Don't use that at the bottom of the page. Use that with the free trial button. That's correct. And you build your list of people that are already interested in this, even if you aren't converting them on this. I've got to move it, though, guys. You're good. I've got to move it. Keep going. All right. I'm looking at Rhapsody next.

Look at the background on this. There's the value proposition. Listen to any full song in the Rhapsody Library over 4 million songs as much as you like. Download and buy only the songs you like. You can listen through and it goes on. Channel information, free primary sources of traffic, paid search, affiliate traffic, and reel.com. I don't know the split. I don't think they told us that. But those are the three primary sources of traffic. And I'm going to go from there right to the page so we can look at it. So here we go to the Rhapsody site. And Jimmy, you start us off.

So I get to this page, and I'm looking for a headline, and I don't see one. I have this image, and it's got like a player, and it's got some music and stuff, but I'm looking for a headline that tells me what this is or how it could help me. So the first thing I see that actually tells me that is not listening all you want. It's just a headline, get unlimited access to millions of full-length songs, and I'd say, and try it for free, something like that for a headline. We would just hop to the page above the image, then go to the image, which probably would not be quite as big and quite as tall, go into your bullets, and then your 14-day free trial. On this particular one, they have a button that takes you to the form. Why would you do this as a short, simple page?

It's not that much on the page. I would absolutely include your free trial form on here. I've taken the liberty to open the URL that we have at the top of the page, and it looks like when you click there, it goes to your 14-day free trial, but you have to sign up as a member, and that's going to be a huge impediment and friction for a customer trying to sign up for their free trial. Actually, do that for me real quick. There may be more problems after this page than there is on this actual page. It's actually a pretty good landing page. Yeah, it's not that simple. But there's some big problems with it. One of them is, if you're going to focus the 14-day free trial down there by the button, then get that up in the headline. Listen to all you want in the majority of it.

The majority of your traffic is coming from, you stated in the first slide, the majority of your traffic is coming from either your parent company, who everybody is familiar with Rhapsody, who's coming from Real, or your paid search ads, which you're bidding on the term for Rhapsody. So you don't have to do that much selling for this page if they're searching Google or Yahoo for Rhapsody or if they're coming from an ad within Real for Rhapsody. You don't have to do that much selling. So introduce the 14-day free trial offer further up in the page, and you're going to get a higher conversion. Get more people in that 14-day, and then there's the opportunity to capture email address on the first step at the very least.

Go ahead. Everybody needs to pay real close attention to what Aaron said because he really tapped into the source of traffic, and that's going to dramatically change the strategy for this page. If you ask someone, what he's saying is they're more motivated. They're coming from a company that they already trust, they already know. They know pretty much what the product is. All they want to do is sign up. If that is the case...

Just hit them with a free trial, put the form on that page, keep it as simple as possible. And you don't need to sell them because they're already sold. If they're not coming from that source of traffic with this highly motivated customer, they're coming from somewhere else, they're not familiar with Rhapsody, and they need to be convinced that this is an option for them or something they would want to try, you're going to want more content and a little bit more information to get them to click that button or to start that free trial. So make sure that what we're doing is we're matching landing pages to the motivation of the customer from the channel of traffic they're coming from. Absolutely. I mean, we have partners that might have ten variations of the same landing page based on if they're coming from email, from a banner ad, from a previous purchase, from faster recovery. Every specific channel typically has a customized landing page for where the customer came from based on what they're expecting or what they would need to see to make a buying decision. Well, and back to the thing, what you said is critical. If you are sending them to this page, you need to test it two ways, but one way to test it is to actually capture the email address right here under the click.

And you put the email and you say, you know, tell us where to send your login information or step one or two. And they click. You capture their email. And if you've got the proper permission set there with a box, you can at least – you can still do basket recovery easily enough without having any real issues with spam. But there's more than that. If you allow them to opt in, you can use this to remarket to them in the future. And I've seen some cases – I've seen most cases where that resulted in far more email capture and essentially a much larger audience to market to. And you've already spent money getting there. You might as well capture that and not pay to get that person back again.

The other piece that's so vital, and we don't really have time to go into this, but I need to help a lot of people that have cards. Look at the card. All the selling is done. They've done something smarter here at the top of the page. They've tried to remind you that it's a 14-day trial. They've mentioned unlimited access. That is smart. There's more that you need to do down by the continue button, but in the end, remember something. Every single page of the process now needs to actually continue to remind people of the value. The selling is not done until the confirmation page has come, and that's when you start selling something else in most cases.

Very good points from the team. I want to move on and help some more people. So, John, go ahead. I know I keep slipping in there. I'm standing at a podium in front of 10 monitors, and I have a young man on my right who's driving all of this, and his name is John. So you'll hear us going back and forth. Sometimes I step over from the podium and take the controls to move something that I want to see. He does a remarkable job of helping me. All right, so we're on now, and I'm looking at the new site. Let's go to the next site. This is RegisUniversityAtGaline.org. Online MBA program supported by 130-year foundation in academic excellence.

and we aren't just a run-of-the-mill online university. I think the 130-year foundation is interesting. It does separate you. Online MBA, that's part of a value proposition. Here's your channel information. Aaron, you looking at those ads? Do you want to talk about those ads? I am.

I'm looking at your titles, and you're screaming online MBA programs to me. Every one of these ads has online MBA programs. I'm betting that everybody else that you're competing with also uses online MBA programs. So what are you doing that's different? When you say top online MBA program, how do you quantify it? When you've got online MBA program in Denver, well, does it really matter if it's Denver, if it's an online MBA program, accredited online MBA program? They're probably all saying that. What are you doing differently? What's your value proposition? Well, you stated it up there as 130-year foundation of academic excellence. To me, that's the kind of information that would need to be spelled out in the title. Greet them with your value proposition. That is your most important ad space.

And yet you're using something that's probably very generic. Now, it is – I think the accredited – Aaron, I think the word accredited, though, is vital. Maybe programs are not, and they emphasize that at least in one of these. It is, and I'd have to see how the competitors are phrasing the app. My guess is at least when I ran searches around here, a lot of them were using accredited. I don't know if this was a local search to the Denver area, but when I ran searches around here, I saw it was redundant throughout many of the apps. Now, the other thing that I would consider –

What do you have to give them? Do you have a free guide on choosing an online MBA program, and can your landing page then go into a free guide? Do you have a white paper on how to choose an MBA program? Can you get that and use that as your lead capture process on your landing page? Now, I'm getting a little bit away from the paperclip ad, but this is all stuff that you need to think about. If you can do that on the landing page, we'll do it in your ad, and you're probably going to get a higher click-through rate, so more visitors to your landing page, and you may get more leads coming through on your site. What can you give them? Let's look at the landing page. Let's go there. And, Aaron, that doesn't mean you have to stop, but Jimmy, jump in when Aaron comes up for Aaron. Tell us your thoughts.

What you're saying is very good. Continue. Right here, I've come to your site. It's Regis University Online MBA Program, academic excellence for over 130 years. The academic excellence for over 130 years is something that might be unique to Regis University, but I still don't know if it's strong enough to get somebody who's unfamiliar with Regis to click that inquire now and request information to them. The approach that I might take with this is a lead capture approach. What can you give them to get the information and build your lead database? It's a radically different design than what you're doing right now. It's something you would have to test.

But if you have the capability to give them some sort of free guide on how to choose an online MBA program or a white paper or something to that extent, you could capture their information on the first page they land on. You're probably going to get hired quick through it because in the title of your ad and in the body copy of your ad, you're going to be telling them we're giving you this free guide on how to choose an online MBA program. Aaron, I'm going to move us on, friend, to keep us moving. What you said is superb. Jimmy, what would you add? When I look at the page I'm looking for, why should I choose Regis? I mean, how is this better than any other university? How is this going to help me get a better job? Yeah, they've had 130 years of experience, and they're going to jumpstart your career, but that's not specific enough.

Show me, like, what's your graduation rate? What's your rate of getting people a new job when they graduate from Regis? Tell me those things. Tell me how their program is going to help me, one, find the career that's right for me to land that job and then give the tools in their program to be able to do a great job once I get there. So, you know, and then back to Aaron's point, you've got to inquire now. Why don't you have the form on the page? Why are you making them go to an extra click to fill out just the form? Put the form on the page. One less click, less friction, more people through the process. All right, now, I'm going to –

I'm going to go ahead in just a minute and get you guys in the audience to help me with this next one. I need you to vote. So stand by in a moment. I need your advice and thoughts. Some of you are putting in some very good things. First of all, Kimberly put in the job placement rate. Aaron, I think she put it in before it was being brought up, Jimmy. She cannot have credit for that. That's all mine. Kimberly, would you like to tell us?

Just putting in the job placement rate, you need to compare it to your competitors. You know, we place 74% of applicants, and this is 15% or 20% higher than the national average or than other universities in our area. Qualify that so that it means something to somebody. Let me just touch two things and on we go. First of all, every photo at the top of that page blocks what's above it. It's complete banner blindness in the Develop Valuable Skills and Get the Edge You Need. All the eyes go down to Regent University's online MBA program, and that is not a headline. That just tells me what page I'm on. That should be there at the top, and that blue space should actually be working. That blue headline should actually be.

distinguishing the reason why I need to stop and pay attention to what's in the body copy. That's what a good headline should do here. It should point me to the body copy, and the next paragraph, or the subheader, should then deeply emphasize the secondary value, and the next paragraph underneath that should substantiate it with quantified, irrefutable kinds of statements and evidence. then you should not have or leave it the chance to get one button here to have one way to capture a lead. The picture on the left of a man standing next to a woman is an absolute useless place to space, no offense to the models. It should actually be a place where you offer them the white paper that Aaron just described, the guide, the steps, something remarkable, the book, the PDF. It should be right there, and that should be your secondary way to capture a lead. You should have two ways on this page. In addition to that, the pages above the Regis University Online MBA program, see the photograph?

I don't know if that's really your school or not, but every photograph on there should work. If you're going to use the photographs, put them to work. Right now, they're not helping me. If that's really your school, give me a clear picture, that one in the middle, because that's valuable. That tells me a real campus, brick and mortar, solid, looks old, steady. Give me something like that. And if it is identified, tell me what I'm looking at. Put a little title that I can see. Help me make the photos work. It's not about design now, and it's not about beauty. It's about making every single square, every single pixel on that page support your value proposition. Let's go on to the next one. All right.

The audience, I'm going to ask you to vote, so stand by. This is when I really need your input. We're going to measure your thoughts on this, and I'm going to have you rate the quality of this value proposition. It's called eatyourelephant.com. We help people and organizations to quit talking, dreaming, wishing, hoping, and start doing. And I'm going to go to the page. Show us the page. This is the actual page. We're going to give you a second. I know there's a delay between our end and your end. We're looking at it now, waiting for the Internet to display it for you. That's the actual page.

Now, you look at the page and vote after I read to you again the value proposition. We help people and organizations to quit talking, dreaming, wishing, hoping, and start doing. Now, look at your voting tool there. On a scale of one to five, rank the quality of the value proposition. We're opening the poll, and you can see the five areas. No real value proposition are stated unclearly. Limited value to a small market. Substantial value to at least a medium-sized market. Strong product differentiation. Unique, highly valuable to a large market. Five levels. Pick the level. And we're going to see how an audience full of marketers, hundreds of you actually, rank this. The poll is coming in. John, open that and let me see more.

Good. 50% of you voted. Keep voting. Vote faster. I can't stop until I get a higher ratio. 54 or 56? 58. Tell me what you think of this value proposition. All right. All right. We're going to close the polls now. We've got a good percentage, and you should look on the screen, and it'll tell you what you think. 45% of our audience says no real value proposition or stated unclearly. Jimmy Ellis, would you agree with that? I actually went with two because I think it's very limited.

I wouldn't say the other one, but the office is very limited. Aaron, what would you have voted? One or two, or whatever. What would you have voted? I voted one. I would have voted one, too. Jimmy's the nicest of the three of us, and I'm not surprised. She's sound like Paula on American Idol. It's not a value proposition at all. And I mean this graciously, but it's not a value proposition. I don't even know what it means. You're going to help me quit talking, dreaming, wishing, hoping to start doing what?

And this is not a value proposition. It's an aspiration. It's very nice. And I'm grateful that you help people do that. But what in the world is it about this that makes me think that you're the solution I need? I don't know what the problem is you're solving. So let's please look at the page itself. Jimmy? No, I'm not doing this one. You guys are on your own. Okay, Paula. Over to you, Paula. Looking at this page, Dean, what would you do?

Well, first of all, it needs to be clear, just like what we're asking you, what your value proposition is. And the way that you stated it, it's not clear to us. It's not clear to any of the visitors that come to your site of what you're actually doing. Aaron, while Aaron is talking, I'd like the audience to go ahead and, marketers, tell us the top three changes that you'd make to this site. Aaron's talking, but I'm watching them come in next to your name, and I want to see how you're thinking. Aaron, continue. Sure. And, you know, I read your pay-per-click ad, and I get slightly more. I see where you're going with it, but it needs to be.

You know, you need to tell me. You need to greet them with something. Setting a New Year's resolution, we help individuals meet 97.4% of their New Year's resolutions or whatever. You know, if it's not a New Year's resolution, we help you with your life goals or what you're trying to do in your life. And then back that up with points that support the headline. And then it looks like you have a free trial or a free webinar. I don't know if anybody's really signing up for a free webinar. You're going to need to try that against different approaches. But you've got something free. You're capturing their email.

then leave them into the free trial and get them in there. If you're getting a response from this page, it's because of the free trial. It's not necessarily because people really have a good draft of what you're doing and understand what you're doing. You need to do a better job of explaining that. Tell us what your value proposition is, back it up with some bullets, and lead me into a – I don't even think your graphic really helps that much. Your graphic over to the right.

Let me do this. I'm going to read what the audience is saying for a moment, and then I'm going to have Jimmy speak, all right? There are others that I'd like to get to. I'm watching our time show. Just listen to this now. This is what the audience is saying. Someone says a better image. Someone else says get rid of the girl. Ryan says what services do you offer? Let me draw these closer to names where I can see it clearly.

All right. Let's keep going. Eliminate the top and side navigation, says Jay. A clear headline, says Patty. Turn resolutions into real accomplishments. Not bad, Dennis. That's from Dennis. Make the call to action clear. Someone else says, give me a percentage of your number in the headline with a benefit. James, he sounds like you there for a moment, Aaron. All right. Let's just stop for a second. We only have a lot of time. I want to say things about this page. Jimmy, fire away.

So the one thing that I think really needs to happen on this page is that it needs to be much, much, much, much, much more specific. And let me dig into that a little bit. It's way too generic, and that's why we're all lost with no clarity. If I said... let us help you get organized in less than 30 days, or let us help you find a new job in less than 30 days, something like that where you're clearly stating a problem, and then you're showing them how you're going to help them for that specific thing. So what I'm saying is this turns into potentially hundreds of landing pages, but they're very specific to the customer's problem. So you would change the way you drive traffic as well because you have very niche topic-specific landing pages. Let's say, for example, finding a new job. You would do a pay-per-click just for finding a new job, send them to a landing page that starts off with, let us help you find a new job and get results in less than 30 days, and then you drive them through the bullets and the content and the copy, and here's how I do the content and the copy. It would be...

either a letter from the founder or from a previous person that's gone through this webinar telling their story of how this webinar or whatever helped them achieve their goals, including results and everything, and that all you have to do is tell us where to send your free access, and you'll be logged into the free webinar. And, Jimmy, wouldn't it be great if they had, like, 30 landing pages, each one to a specific problem tied to a specific page search ad? Same offer, but wrapped around a different problem and a different, basically, talk train. It changes everything. It changes everything on this page. Your landing page is better, and your ads are going to get a higher click-through rate because they're more relevant to what somebody was searching on, and they're going to a relevant page. It's all going to work better with one another.

I'm going to stop us. Listen, the audience, a couple of things so I can help everyone. There's one of you that set your page that we promised to get to today if we could, and we can't. So we're going to call you personally and go through your page with you because we want to be gracious to you, and I think we made a promise to you. And you'll know who you are because we haven't got to your page today. If you'd like, in two more weeks we're going to be doing this again, but it won't be landing page. It'll be more optimization experiments and testing. Also, for many of you that may be at the Marketing Sherpa Email Summit, we're going to be teaching optimizing your email messaging, and there'll be a bunch of these guys at the Summit in Miami.

The other thing is I need your feedback again. Your feedback makes every one of these better. Would you write me today using that same feature that you gave us your comments on and tell us if you found today good, if you found the rhythm helpful, about the right pace? And, you know, let us know if we're doing what you need because we're trying so hard to help you discover what works in optimizing your marketing communication. If you're going to be at us next week, make sure you stop by the booth and Jimmy and I will do a live optimization for you at the summit. Yes, yes. We'll be doing a lot of live optimization at the summit. I don't know if you know, but we own Marketing Sherpa and that summit.

is an event that we, you know, they're another research group that works closely with us, and there'll be a lot of our team there, and you can talk with them there. We're grateful for everyone's trust. Tell a friend. We don't trust for any of this, and the only thing we ask for is to tell someone else. But kind of, we want to build a community of people that are deeply concerned about, you know, approaching their marketing with a kind of honesty, and it comes from testing. And then the same thing in terms of the claims they make on their own sites.

We can all help each other. And the more that we get together on these lines and talk and subscribe and work through the journal issues together and learn and conduct experiments, the better off we're all going to be. If we helped you today with your site and it made some kind of progress or it didn't, email us. Show us what you did. Tell us how you take these suggestions. And I'm going to stand by now and read the comments as they come in. We read every single one and catalog them. Thank you very, very much. And we look forward to talking to you in the future. John just put up something I see and pointed to this. If you're interested in doing some research with us, you can see on the screen how you might be able to do that. Thank you all for coming, and we'll see you again in two weeks.

French Your Way Jessica: Native French teacher founder of French Your Way Boost your French listening skills and test your comprehension with this one of a kind series of podcasts. Get the chance to listen to a real conversation between native speakers talking at normal speed AND customise your learning experience through carefully designed sets of questions (2 levels of difficulty) available for download at www.frenchvoicespodcast.com. All interviews also come with the transcript. French teacher Jessica interviews native speakers of French from around the world who share a bit of their life and passion. Where else would you meet in one same place a French yoga teacher based in Melbourne, a soap manufacturer from Provence, or a couple cycling around the world? Growth Triggers: Content Marketing & AI Luis Diaz Discover how to use your podcast to generate leads, sales, and influence in any market. On this show Luis shares his best tested and proven secrets, tips, and strategies from launching over 300 podcasts in over a dozen different niches and generating over 59 Million Downloads for his clients. Learn how to increase your podcast listenership, create multiple new revenue streams with your podcast, sell more of your core offer and build a show that gives you leverage and authority in your space. From picking the right monetization strategy for your podcast to learning how to position your podcast in a crowded market on Apple and Spotify; this is show is the ultimate marketing and sales resource for online business owners who want to know what works with podcasting. Get in touch over on Instagram <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow" class="link" href="https://www.instagram.com/luisr

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of MarketingExperiments.com Web Clinic Podcasts?

This episode is 55 minutes long.

When was this MarketingExperiments.com Web Clinic Podcasts episode published?

This episode was published on February 21, 2008.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this MarketingExperiments.com Web Clinic Podcasts episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.