Skip to content
podcast 388 – Yes, “the Trinity” is a Problem – Part 2 episode artwork

Feb 22, 2025 1 hr 14 min

podcast 388 – Yes, “the Trinity” is a Problem – Part 2

from Trinities

In this second part (part 1 here) I interact with the rest of this discussion between Dr. Sean McDowell and Dr. Fred Sanders. I do register some significant agreements with them, but on the whole, my criticism from last time stands: their apologetic defense of "the doctrine of the Trinity" is not anywhere near sufficient to rebut or refute the arguments presented by today's unitarian Christians. I also explain some historical problems with various things they're saying. Detailed knowledge of early Christian theologies and Christologies disrupts a number of common trinitarian narratives and assumptions. Questions addressed include: Was the doctrine of the Trinity copied from pagan religions and/or Greek philosophy? Can one read pretty much any pre-Nicene written source and find that the author is trinitarian? Was the doctrine of the Trinity established at the council at Nicea in 325? Was new creedal language produced by the council at Nicea a breakthrough in theological clarity? Why is there no clear "Trinity passage" anywhere in the Bible? And is this actually a good thing? At the end I offer to help. https://youtu.be/XEr7Em9wkV8?si=OnRHO39R_GPuMUWx Links for this episode: Tuggy, "When and How in the History of Theology Did the Triune God Replace the Father as the Only True God?" podcast 115 – the aborted council at Serdica in 343 podcast 114 – the recycled creed (342-359) podcast 113 – the council at Antioch in 341 podcast 31 – Dr. William Hasker on the “Arian” Controversy podcast 30 – The Council of Nicea podcast 29 – Arius Prestige, God in Patristic thought https://youtu.be/KxYtTQDo1dA?si=hfjRj1o8CYy44pds podcast 270 – Origen’s “one God” Tuggy, What is the Trinity? 10 steps towards getting less confused about the Trinity Clarke, The Scripture-Doctrine of the Trinity Biddle, The Apostolical and True Opinion Concerning the Holy Trinity podcast 348 – Novatian’s On the Trinity – Part 2 – Two Thieves and Three Arguments Hanson, The Search for the Christian Doctrine of God Unitarian Christian Alliance Church of God General Conference Spirit and Truth podcast 357 – Seminary student takes Trinity class, becomes unitarian – Part 2 podcast 356 – Seminary student takes Trinity class, becomes unitarian – Part 1 https://youtu.be/4OgtkJe5AyI?si=9pTEHjSxB6zeF7C0 Dustin Smith’s The Biblical Unitarian Podcast Sean Finnegan’s Restitutio Podcast McIntosh, ed. – Craig vs. Hasker vs. Branson vs. Tuggy – One God, Three Persons, Four Views: A Biblical, Theological, and Philosophical Dialogue on the Doctrine of the Trinity This week's thinking music is "Discipline" by Mr. Smith.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

podcast 388 – Yes, “the Trinity” is a Problem – Part 2

0:00 1:14:00

No transcript yet.

Requests help us decide what to transcribe next.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Trinities?

This episode is 1 hour and 14 minutes long.

When was this Trinities episode published?

This episode was published on February 22, 2025.

Can I download this Trinities episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.