Skip to content
Powerful Value Propositions, Part II: Live Optimization episode artwork

Nov 14, 2008 1 hr 7 min

Powerful Value Propositions, Part II: Live Optimization

from MarketingExperiments.com Web Clinic Podcasts Hosted by MarketingExperiments

Presenters: - Dr. Flint McGlaughlin, Director, MarketingExperiments - Jimmy Ellis, Director of Optimization Research - Aaron Rosenthal, Director of Channels Research You got the principles from our recent clinic on value propositions. Now it's time for hands-on practice and specific guidance. In this special live optimization clinic, our team will show you how to improve your value proposition and your site's results. During this free, interactive Web Clinic, we will: - Review examples and the keys to a strong value proposition - Break down optimization steps you can apply right away - Optimize attendees' value propositions with our live audience If you attended the first clinic, you'll still get several new takeaways.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Powerful Value Propositions, Part II: Live Optimization

0:00 1:07:13
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

And I would now like to introduce our marketing editor, Mr. Hunter Boyle. Thank you very much, Sarah. Welcome, everyone. Thanks for joining us. I have Jimmy Ellis, our director of optimization research, and Aaron Rosenthal, our director of channels research, here today, as well as Bob Kemper, our director of sciences, and several other people on the marketing experiments team. We have several of our analysts on the call today, as usual. And although we don't have the same bank of 10 monitors that Flint typically uses, we're going to try and cover a lot of information here. We have a number of submissions from the audience.

for the live optimization session. And if this is your first call with us, if you weren't able to join us for part one of Powerful Value Propositions, we conducted a lot of principles in the beginning and went through a lot of information. What we'll be doing today is briefly reviewing some of those principles and some of those steps and some of those examples, and then we're going to jump right into live optimization of the URLs and value propositions that you submitted to us in registering for the clinic. Now, one piece of information that's worth noting is, as far as value propositions go, there was a lot of confusion at the first clinic. We actually took a poll of our audience and asked which of the biggest challenges marketers had with value propositions, identifying, expressing, or testing. And the fourth option was all of the above. And that turned out to be the majority option for the audience. About 32% chose all of the above. So we know that there are a lot of people that are having trouble and difficulty getting their arms around what exactly a value proposition is.

how to express it. So in today's clinic, we're going to review again very briefly some of the principles and some of the pieces from part one that explained what it is. We'll look over some examples to try and bring that to life, and then we'll talk about optimization steps that you can apply, and we'll work with some of those value propositions and some of those landing pages that we can see exactly how some value propositions can be optimized and steps that you can take for your own site, and we're going to look to you in this live optimization session. We want to make it very interactive, so when we get there, please use the Q&A feature, and we'll be looking for your feedback on those.

Aaron, Jimmy, are you on? He doesn't like to talk very much. Okay, great. Then let's get underway. This is a slide that I thought summed up nicely what the value proposition does to some people or the way it's perceived by a lot of people. As Scott Adams put it, a value proposition can be a long, awkward sentence that demonstrates management's inability to think clearly.

from a cartoon, it does actually speak to the idea that a lot of times when we're writing value propositions or we're trying to think of what we want to communicate to our ideal customers, we get wrapped up very often in buzzwords, in sales language, in talking to the audience, not trying to really establish a dialogue with them. One of the things that that leads to is value proposition, expressing the value proposition clearly, testing and refining your value proposition. To address this is to make it more of an ongoing cycle, not just a one-off, not just treating...

or a copy as something you do for one page or a headline or lead or subhead at a time, but making the value proposition clear and making it consistent from start to finish. And from that point, revising and testing it again. slide that just changed, one of the things that has made this easier for a lot of people to understand, what we've heard about from the first clinic, was the question, if I'm your ideal customer, why should I buy from you instead of a competitor? And that's one thing that really gets to the essence of what we're trying to do with our value propositions, is set aside the factors that a lot of competitors have, that language, such as we're the best, we have the lowest price, we have the most, we have the least, and get down to the specifics and really answer that singular question. If I'm your ideal customer, why should I buy from you instead of a competitor? We'll be referring to that.

a couple of different times throughout the clinic. If we move on, here's a tool from the value proposition worksheet, which you can get from our blog or from our website, which is the value proposition assessment matrix. It's a tool that was put together by our sciences department in an effort to try and make it a little stronger and a little more systematic for ranking your value proposition. If you look at this, it's for exclusivity, where zero is no interest, one is possible interest. And the way that you would use this is you rank your ideal customer's desire level for your offer from zero to two.

You rank the exclusivity of your offer. They go beyond just the expression. Then there's more work to be done, and that may be a product issue. But for the purposes of this clinic, with the desire and the exclusivity, we'll use this matrix for ranking some of these examples that we're going to look at. And, Hunter, if I could real quick, since this is a multiplication, since you're multiplying both numbers, you have to excel in one area in order to reach that two. What I mean by that is you have to rank at least a two in one area and at least a one in another area in order to reach that two. Otherwise, it's time to re-craft the offer. So unless you have a high interest in Desire or unless you have a nowhere else in exclusivity, you're not going to reach that two, and you have to add at least one two before it's time to re-craft the offer. Great point, Aaron. Absolutely.

As far as testing your value proposition, one thing that we didn't spend a whole lot of time on in clinic number one, we kind of went through it quickly, and Aaron can also touch on this briefly, is using your PPC ads to create kind of a micro test. sharpen the language that you use. And, Aaron, I know that you're familiar with this process. If you want to just cover this idea pretty briefly. Sure. And this is not actually a test that we've set up, but you can see in each one of these pay-per-click ads at the bottom of the screen, they are using three different messages. One focuses on 70% less than consultants. Another focuses on since 1998. What they're attempting to do in this is determine what is of most value to their customers. And with that in mind, you can then start to craft your value proposition that you want to communicate on your landing pages. You're not going to be successful.

able to successfully communicate your value proposition within your pay-per-click ad because there's just too many character limitations. However, you can use it as a test platform to begin to test value proposition ideas within Google or Yahoo or whichever pay-per-click network you're using. Great, absolutely. And there's one other point about the microtesting, and Aaron almost touched on this. What we're going to talk about a little later on is taking a lot of verbiage around your value proposition and really shortening it, tightening it, making it as compact and concise and powerful as possible.

We have a challenge later on that speaks to doing that, but this really puts that at the forefront in terms of taking a number of words and distilling them down to the shortest possible lines, whether it's the headline, whether it's those two lines of copy, even the URL. These tests will definitely help you shorten down if you have a couple of different paragraphs or if you have 30, 40 words and you're trying to express several different ideas. This helps you distill that and get the language right down to the core and find out which ones work best with which customers. Now, again, just to briefly summarize what we covered here and what we covered in Part 1, the three steps for your value proposition, identify, express. Now, if you look at this slide that just came up here, here's an example that was submitted for our previous clinic, and I wanted to use this because it's a great example of what actually is not a value proposition, and part of the confusion that came about from Clinic 1 and some of the discussions that we had was

What is a value proposition? Where does it reside on page? What qualifies? And it can get pretty confusing. We've already discussed that. This one that was submitted was My Life is Beautiful. You can see it in the top of the page in the screenshot there. And one of the things that we talked about was this is actually a tagline, and it's not a value proposition. And there are reasons for it, but the easiest way to get that answer is that it simply doesn't answer the question.

a customer, why should I buy from you instead of anyone else? If you responded to that with, my life is beautiful, it's a complete non sequitur. So while this may not actually be a value proposition, we looked around on the website a little bit more, and on the About Us page, we found a block of copy that value proposition. This isn't necessarily a tightly written value proposition in and of itself. What it says here, our innovative diamond search technology evaluates the cost, size, and quality of the diamond to help consumers make informed and customized purchase decisions.

Consumers can graphically see the tradeoffs required when weighing each of these factors and speak to or email professional graduate gemologists with their questions. Now, again, that's not 100% value proposition. It's not been written to be that way. I don't believe that was copied on the About Us page. But if you think about how that would fit with the desire and exclusivity and think about what that text is really saying, when someone's looking to buy a diamond, they're concerned about trust and credibility issues. They definitely are even more concerned about that buying online than perhaps offline. And these concepts that are in the text here,

that with the graduate gemologist, the customers can see the tradeoffs, evaluating cost size and quality, and that this site offers a search function that allows users to do that. In that respect, while it's not a perfectly articulated value proposition, this is an example of where on some sites or in some web pages you might find the elements that would be stronger and that you could use in other areas. And we'll talk about that a little bit more as we go forward with the live optimization, and that'll be a key to some of the other examples that we go over with. Aaron and Jimmy, do you have any more thoughts on those? Sure. I mean, we see this type of stuff all the time where people are using taglines as actual value propositions, and it's simply there are two different things. In this particular example, their initial tagline was trying to get you to feel an emotion, not help the customer figure out if you have a product or service that they can use to actually help them make a buying decision. So when you look at this one, like I said, it's not perfect, but gosh darn, it's so much better than the actual tagline. I mean, even when you guys are reading it, can't you just kind of speak to your soul a little bit and just kind of say, oh, there's something here. I need to continue and check this out because I'm actually going to get a better deal or make a smarter decision if I use this site compared to, you know,

potential other site or another competitor. So the reason why this one is still just a two is because it's not exclusive. I mean, there's a lot of places selling diamonds. Their tool may be exclusive, but exclusivity isn't too high, but the pages and terms and conditions and stuff like that usually hold some of them. This other example, a lot of people, as I mentioned, had asked us for good examples of value propositions. We've looked at some that are halfway there. We've looked at some that aren't value propositions at all. This one was submitted for the initial clinic, and Stratasys FDM systems use production-grade thermoplastics to match properties with material that fits your needs.

giving you the ability to manufacture real parts that are tough enough for functional testing and end use. I don't deal with thermoplastics, and I don't claim to be the ideal customer. But in thinking about what their customer base and what their ideal market would want to hear, this seems to have a high rating on both the desire side and on the exclusivity side. As far as the verbiage, again, this is pretty close because it gets to very specific, granular information. It may not be as easy to understand for some of us as for their ideal audience. The one thing we noticed in looking at their URL is that they tried to support some of this with some of the other information pieces on there. If you look at the screenshot, it has a...

Clockworks produced custom motorcycle parts in five days, reducing production time 82%. And you can see that examples of language like this try and answer that question, why should I buy from you? And for their ideal customer, they do that pretty well. Yeah, I'll make some more comments on this one, Hunter. Now, in terms of expressing the value proposition that Hunter said, they're using kind of a case study example to do that. I mean, there are definitely variations you're going to want to test with all your value propositions in how you communicate on the page. So in terms of this one, they're still using a tagline. If you look at the page from prototyping through manufacturing, I'm sure there is a better version of that that they could potentially use or using part of their main value proposition, which is the Stratus FGM system uses projection grade number of plastic, that longer one that they could potentially use there. But probably the best thing that it does is they're using those quantitative details, for example. In their case, they're right there. It's the main one you're looking at.

produce custom motorcycle parts in five days, reducing production time 82%. That instantly, no matter what they're using, whether it's their main value proposition or the case study, they're using elements with such credibility that lets a customer see the real value in using their service. So even though they're not stating it exactly, they're really implying it with quantitative details to help communicate it more effectively than just using some fancy words to say it or say that we produce custom motorcycle parts fast, reducing production time a lot. And we see a lot of that in some of the content used for value propositions. So think about that. So one is being able to have the value proposition. Our other piece was being able to communicate that. You know, our third piece is testing and refining. So keep that in mind when you're writing yours. That's a great point, Jimmy. You know, the first step is developing your value proposition. The second step is communicating that value proposition on the landing page. And the way that Clockworks is communicating it, you see it's slightly different than the way that they've written out their stated value proposition, but they're still doing a good job of getting the message across. Great point. Great point.

If we move on to this next example, again, submitted from a previous clinic, this kind of falls right in the middle there. We've looked at an example that's not. We've looked at an example that is pretty close and does a lot of things well. As Jimmy mentioned, it really leaned on the quantitative and the details, and a lot of the supporting elements were there on the site. If you look at the example that's up there now from tbonnet.com, here's a good example of where we find a lot of sites falling into the kind of middle ground. They have some strong ideas about what it is they do differently and what they want to express, but they don't.

or they haven't done it in a way that's quite optimized for the quantitative details or those different pieces that would really convey that message. And for Tivana here, if we look at the website and the home page itself, and Jimmy and Aaron will speak to this a little bit more, the way that the page is set up is one thing, and they have this Why Shop Tivana sidebar over here. It's not necessarily in the right place, and the copy isn't necessarily as tight or compact as it could be. But you can see that they're going in the right direction here. In essence, the WhyShopTVano.com is very similar to the question, why should I buy from you? It's kind of restating the question, and they make an effort to answer it. They've got subheads, which is good. But if you look within some of the copy there, some of the keys are actually not.

in the subheads, they're a little further down. For example, in the second paragraph, under fresh, delicious ingredients, which isn't really a differentiator, the second sentence is, every ingredient is hand-selected for health and taste, so you get the best tea every time. The fact that every ingredient is hand-selected is a lot more specific, it's a lot more detailed than fresh, delicious ingredients. If you look at the second sentence in the third paragraph, under the headline, only loose leaf tea is for us, it says, at Teavana, you can see the size and quality of the leaf immediately. That paragraph talks about why bagged teas are lower quality, and that's not what Teavana does. Those things are...

As you'll notice, those are the second sentences in the second and third paragraph. They don't necessarily answer that question as directly as they could, and unfortunately, this very sidebar has been taken off of the site. I guess that was a promotion there, and that's changed, but you can see from this example that there are sites and there are value propositions and elements that are kind of floating around, whether it's on homepages, About Us pages, or wherever else, but they're just not being pulled together or being as tightly phrased or expressed. Sure. And that's kind of what Jimmy and Aaron alluded to, and we'll be looking at with this page and some of the other sites. Aaron, I know you had some thoughts on this page as well. Yeah, this is a great example where on the last one we talked about the value proposition and how they're communicating on the landing page as representative of the value proposition that they're trying to get across. On this page, it sounds like they might know what their value proposition is or at least have an idea of what it is, but they're doing a really, really poor job of communicating on the page. When I come to the site, the first thing that I'm just greeted with is this scared of oolong, and then oolong teas are frightfully good.

That doesn't communicate to me the value proposition of why I should shop with you and not one of your competitors. It doesn't mean anything about these long-term. So unless I know that specifically as I'm coming into your site, you've immediately got all these images that are on the – these Halloween-themed images. And it's okay to see in your promotions, not protect the images on your site to do the primary communicating that your word can do, that a headline, that a real value proposition should do on your landing page. So I'm going to add to Aaron's point about when you hit this site, which typically not just the overpowering image of the Halloween scene that's getting in the way of the actual value proposition on the right, but when you only have a few seconds to capture a customer's attention, you don't want to use a headline like why shopteavano.com. You want to hit them with some of those things that are in those three paragraphs. I mean, ideally, you take a version of those three paragraphs and come up with one very good, very concise statement that communicates that and then leads down into those three sections. And that's what you want to start the entire page with. You can use attractive traffic.

But you want to use it with the content copy. So you want your headline, you want your graphic there, and you want either bullets or your paragraphs around or, you know, directly next to that image, but not where the copy and the value proposition statement right here is all the hands out of the page. So this is, I guess, in terms of communicating it on the page, where they're locating that information on the page and the design of the elements on the page also helps communicate the value proposition. So getting that right. When you tell me, you know, you're better quality or that you can, in this instance, you can actually see the TV's are bigger or that they're healthier for you or any of those statements, back them up with real statistics. So, you know, don't just make it a qualitative statement.

tell me that your leaves are 42% bigger than bagged tea leaves, or tell me that it's better for you, tell me in what way. Don't just tell me it's better for my health. Help me understand that statement and make it sound. Great points, great points. Let's move on to the next slide. We've got another example. We're just about to dive into the live optimization. Just a couple more examples to try and wrap up some of these key principles. And if your slide is turning over now, you should be seeing one example from Shipping Solutions. The value proposition is submitted.

was shipping solutions software will reduce the time it takes to complete your export documents and meet your export compliance responsibilities by up to 80%. Now, there's a slight grammatical issue there with the ordering as far as export documents and responsibilities by up to 80%. But, again, this is another example of trying to go for the specifics and quantifying the benefits that you get. There's also a key point that comes with this that between desire and exclusivity, and this has come through in a couple of Q&As even on this clinic, exclusivity is a much more difficult quality to achieve. In many cases, it either comes from, we've talked about this before in some clinics, a patent or a proprietary system or other forms of products or services that are really unique to an organization. Solutions here, it's very difficult, as we've seen in some of these other examples, to get a two on the exclusivity. But as far as the desire, I think it would be easy to say that for most people in the search for,

shipping a service provider, documents being completed and meeting your responsibilities and saving up to 80%, something that a lot of people would go for. You've done a good job of telling us what your value proposition is, but when I get to the landing page, having not known any of that, I would have no idea. I look at this landing page, and I don't see that information communicated anywhere on it. In fact, the immediate information that you're speaking to me with is you're shouting at me, and then you're asking me three questions. You're saying, attention, exporters, exclamation point. Then you go into a subheadline.

You shouted at me and asked me three questions in a row, and you haven't given me a reason to shop on your site. Even though you can state it and send it to us, you have to. I'm going to actually speak a little bit to Hunter's point about the exclusivity because I think it's really important. There's exclusivity in terms of your niche or product that you have that no one else has. There's also exclusivity in your offer. You may be the only company that offers this way. Let's say tons of pirates everywhere, but if you sell pirates and you're the only ones that have shipping and have a 50,000.

a thousand-mile warranty to have X, Y, and D, but basically you have either more or better or higher-quality features than everybody else selling tires. The only place to get those conditions that basically help you get a better deal and have longer-lasting tires gives you – you have to communicate that. You can't just have to communicate that piece that is in your value proposition and with your offers. Absolutely. You may be sitting there, that's the case, the 80%, and then prove it to me, or it's validating that claim for you. Help me in that what you're telling me is you're not only claiming that you're the best, you're proving it to me. Excellent points. Thank you. Our last example, and we're talking about –

Proving it, not just saying it. You'll see on the slide coming up here was from 1-800-Bakery. I should load in just a second. Value proposition submitted was 25 years of experience means you can count on delicious and on-time delivery. And this goes back to exactly what Jimmy and Aaron were just saying there. You're saying now 25 years of experience, but is that something, as far as a bakery goes, that's going to get you a 2 in desire or a 2 in exclusivity? Well, not necessarily. There are bakeries that have been around for many years longer than that, and that experience...

Delicious and on-time delivery, well, again, those are things that really aren't doing a whole lot to set you apart from your competitors. And if you look at here, you'll see that down in the bottom of the page in unique bakery goods, for example, where doing something's right, it's not doing everything right, certainly, and there are a lot of things that could still be improved. But if you look at that section, it's way down at the bottom of the page. It says, when you place an order at 1-800-Bakery.com, it goes straight from the local baker's oven to the doorstep where you ordered it. And then the paragraph right after that mentions more than 800 fresh bakery treats from 53 bakeries across the U.S.

And that speaks, again, right to the language of specifics, the numbers. Those are the pieces that are really going to do more to set you apart than delicious and on-time delivery or even 25 years of experience in this case. The problem is they're so far down the page, it's unlikely that people are even going to get to the top of the page making that instant connection. And, again, it's just another example of where some of these kind of buried treasure pieces for your value proposition might be hiding out. I'm going to make a point concerning the 25 years of experience in terms like that. What we've seen is a lot of...

traditional terms and copy people are using value propositions are becoming less or ineffective. And what I mean is there are so many people that say, you know, been in business since whatever, 25 years of experience. But it just doesn't, that's almost not that it's expected. It doesn't have any value to the customer unless, for example, you're doing a life. Years of experience aren't going to basically contribute to your value proposition, nor is customer service because everybody says they have customer service. At this point, at this day and age, it's pretty much expected. If you don't have good customer service, you're probably not going to be in business for very long, especially with people on the web that are expecting, you know, tracking numbers the same day and to get their product pretty much.

ahead of time, not just on time, stuff like that. So when you're doing your value props, pick the unique stuff that sets you apart. Don't just say your version of what everybody else is saying. Okay, we need to do it. And you can prove that you are truly the best service in terms of being rated that way or something of value, some kind of credibility indicator, then you might be able to use customer service. But if not, the review section and even the latest part of it, beware of the buried treasure effect. Look for some of these stronger value proposition elements, whether it's the language, whether it's the offer, whether it's some of the quantifiable pieces in some of the spots on your site that you may not necessarily be looking for, whether it's the about us.

ask questions to help. Sometimes even the careers page is where we've seen a lot of sites put information about what makes their company and makes their offer a little different than others. Now, right before we shift to the live optimization, I just want to take a quick second here to find out how we're doing with the pacing on this. If you could just use your Q&A and let us know if we're doing okay, if we want to speed up, if you want us to slow down a little bit. All right. The info is coming in. Good, good, good. Perfect. Great. Speed up a little bit. Pace is good. A little faster. All right.

Jimmy, Aaron, we're probably going to go a little bit faster here. We've covered the review part, so this should pretty much be like a breeze from here on out. We're going to start with a couple of pages that were submitted from the first clinic. Attendees came back, optimized after attending the first clinic, and we've got a poll on both of these. Again, we want our audience to get involved with this. Your feedback in the Q&A section in the polls is going to be helpful to all the people who submitted these, so we're going to try and get your input on these, and Jimmy and Aaron are going to kind of lead the way with optimizing the pages and value props. Let's start by looking at the first one.

That should be coming up any second. Great. We'll be looking at JMR Consulting. JMR submitted their value proposition at the first clinic. We do marketing and public relations that works for small software companies. Afterwards, they revised it. You see the revised version there. Get your own team of software marketing experts to help you grow your small software business starting at just $2,000 a month. Now we're going to open a quick poll just to try and get the audiences. How would you rate the revised value proposition? Which, again, was get your own team of software marketing experts to help you grow.

Your small software business starting at just $2,000 per month. We're watching the votes coming in in just another few seconds, and then we'll close the poll. Jimmy and Aaron are ready to tear it apart. What do you mean, Hunter? Aaron's ready to tear it apart. Jimmy's ready to tear it apart. This is Paul Abdul. I'm ready to trickle that bad boy. Great. We'll close the poll. And now, as you can see, the poll slide is showing up. Most of you, 67%, felt that it was somewhat improved. 22% felt that it was greatly improved. 11% said no improvement or less effective than the original. So let's go back to the page here.

And Jimmy and Aaron, let's get your thoughts on this. So, Jimmy, do you want to go first on this one? Sure, sure. So I'm preparing the original, which we do marketing and public relations that works for small software companies. It's not very specific. You don't really get the feeling of how it's going to help you. It's just this is what we do. It's a statement of what you do and how you can help me as a potential client. And the second one, I don't think it's greatly, but it's somewhere between somewhat and greatly because I don't think you've absolutely nailed it, but it's definitely better. Because look at the actual words. Get your own team of software marketing experts to grow your small software business starting in $2,000 a month. So they're listing what it costs. They're referencing that it's your own team of marketing experts.

Let me tell you a few things that you could probably do to potentially improve it. If you say software marketing experts, can you use any other quantitative details? One, do they have any certifications? You say marketing experts, but a lot of people say they're marketing experts. Is there any way to prove it? Or can you use some sort of results from previous companies or campaigns in there to make it a little more believable? And then it says, get your own team. What does that mean? Is it team one person? Is it team 20 people? It's $2,000, so if you're going to ask for $2,000 a month, I'm looking for a little bit more detail that would basically help it. I'm going to be like, wow, that's pretty good.

for $2,000 a month, but if it was two people, then the value of the service becomes less for me personally. So I'm looking forward to improve it a little bit more, but it's definitely an improvement. Even worth $2,000, especially in this instance where it's a little bit higher. So much greater than the perceived value of that $2,000, then you can absolutely use it in your value proposition, but you need to back it up with the rest of the market so that I know as a customer coming to your site that it is that much lower than all your competition. Because at this point, I don't know that. And what it prompts me to do is send them to this page, communicate to them clearly, don't use the hand side with some sort of background behind it, communicate it in the primary headline, back it up.

a sub-headline that supports that primary headline and then drive them into the copy, into the lead capture form, whatever you're trying to do on this particular. Don't give them an excuse to leave and evaluate your competitors by doing that. So it's okay to use a price. Just make sure that you have that overwhelmingly feeling that this is a great value, much lower than competition, and then back it up with supporting information. Excellent. Thank you, both of you. Live optimization of shots chocolate. The slide should be coming up for you any second now. The first value proposition they submitted,

can create unique, memorable, 100% edible chocolate gifts, promotions, and party favors. After the last clinic, revised value proposition, our chocolate printing technology and our creative graphic design enable us to help you create unique chocolate party favors and promotional items that make your life celebration or corporate event stand out and be remembered. All sinks in, thinks that that was improved, thinks that it's about the same, thinks that there's no improvement, or that it's less effective than the original. And again, while you're... I'll just read it again. Our innovative chocolate printing technology and our creative graphic design enable us to help you create unique chocolate party favors and promotional items that make your life celebration or corporate event stand out and be remembered. We're going to go very quickly through this poll here. We're just about there. And now let's see the results. Great. 33% of you said somewhat improved. 13% said greatly improved. And 23% said no improvement. 30% thought that it was less effective than the original. Jimmy and Aaron, let's get your thoughts on the page.

Sure. This is Jimmy again. This is Paul Abdul. I'm going to say somewhat improved, and here's why. The original one at the top is shorter and more concise.

And there is value to that because they're not going to have to read so much information to communicate what the value of the product and service is. And the piece that is helpful, and the first one that's not in the second, I think that should be, is the 100% edible chocolate gifts. They don't have it in there. They're talking about chocolate printing and chocolate gifts, whatever, but 100% edible is good. The other thing, I don't see anything about the value, sorry, about the quality of the chocolate. Is this like a really good chocolate? I don't want some really cool party favor or gift or whatever. That just tastes horrible. I think about that. So I think it's somewhat improved.

One of the main things in this particular case with a product like this where it's so visual is on this page I would take a version of those two where you include 100% and try to shorten it up as much as possible. You might have a pop in the center, and you have to move those images up. Those are thousands and thousands of words and are much more effective than almost anything that you could say. I would actually use better images, but those are at least good enough because when I saw that, you're talking about chocolate gifts and products, I saw that, and I saw that I could actually see the kids. That's pretty cool. Me personally, maybe there's some companies out there doing it, I've never seen it. So if you go look around and there's no one doing the same thing, I would almost go with we're the only company that produces one.

promotions and parties, blah, blah, blah, blah. You took the words right out of my mouth. I just wanted to say it along the same lines. This is a unique product, and it's very niche. If you are the only one, or if you're one of two, or if you're the only one that does it one particular way, let them know that. When I look at your value, there's so much going on. There's this wavy banner at the top of the page. There's unconventional navigation on the left-hand side. You've got left-hand and the right-hand side of the page. We're on the right-hand side. There's navigation on the right-hand side as well. There's so much going on on this page. I can't figure out what your value proposition is. It's a great idea, but I think the first thing that's not accomplished

got two other pages to look at coming up, and these are pages where the clinic attendees have changed their pages a little bit in terms of not just the value proposition but some of the other elements. So, Jimmy and Aaron, if we look at these two briefly on the next slide, you'll see that we've got a first landing page, kind of a before and after, and if you guys want to kind of run through these really quickly since we're getting low on time and give them some of the feedback and maybe a couple of additional ideas. Sure. I'll go first, Hunter. This is Jimmy. A whole bunch of elements. On the one on the left, look at that that's pretty much getting in the way.

but that's overpowered by that image. You scroll down the page, and the first thing you really see is start reducing your maintenance costs and solve your forming problems. It'll be on the page, and then you have a long form. So we don't have value props today, but these are making it a more difficult image. It's kind of confusing. It doesn't help communicate what you're actually there for. Then you have these three powerful images on the right. When I say it's powerful, it's that they've distracted your eyes. You're going over there, and watch out, watch out, read out, watch out. I'm not sure how effective those are. To me, it looks like it's taking people off the page and getting them just distracted to communicate why they should actually continue. So I'll look at the page on the right. There's no huge image at the top that you can actually see, and it flows vertically down the page. You hear us preach this every single week after week.

The week is vertical layout that goes from left to right, top to bottom. It's easy to read on the page. Look at the headline. Look at the intro paragraph. Sorry, the form is shorter, but they're using the free graphic. I actually realize that it's free without having to read something. Even if I'm scanning the page, I see that it's free. And then they have the actual form code. It's 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 6, 6, 7, 8, 8, 9, 9, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10, 10,

some great suggestions or made some great comments on this. And I think the most important thing for me to point out is they were communicating this. When I start to refine, I'd look at my form to begin my second test or my refinement test, you know, your headlines in your form, your button copy, the amount of information that you're communicating there. But I think this is a great step in the direction of communicating not just your value proposition, but information in a much more linear and easier way to digest and understand. Briefly, again, on conference, submitted the page on the left before I revised it, and we're running a test here, which you can see on the right. Jimmy, Aaron, Aaron, you want to go first this time? Sure.

Now, I do see that the international conference voice quality better, but you're not communicating it yet properly. Or something along those lines that actually communicates them. You can get to the bottom of the copy, and they're confused. They don't know where there's confusion. They have to say, okay, how do I get to the next step? How do I get to the next step? So in terms of the value proposition specifically, you're going to have a hard time proving that you have the best quality for international conference calling. That's going to be probably a metric that, unless you can prove it, it's not going to have much value for people actually looking at the page. I'm turning up your account in just three minutes, so it's quick and easy. But also what I see on the page is no set of feed or monthly feed.

and it's not going to cost you anything at all, and it's going to be quick and easy. So you're basically using quantitative copy and text to say, quickest, easiest, highest quality international conference calling service available. You want to say that, but with very quantitative measures. Now, other things that are kind of helping and hurting this page are, if you look at the left, their headline is on a white background, and it's not just the first thing you see on the page, but I still think it's doing a better job on the original page than the new one. The new one is white text on a light, you know, tan or whatever they call that is, box. If you even heard Aaron, he was having a hard time reading that line because it was hard to see the white text on the background. So I would definitely start with a regular headline. In terms of other elements that communicate value prop,

No one has all the states in the world listed there. Not necessarily communicating conference calling. And if that's the message that you're trying to get across, you may need to look for a different image or at least test different images there. Particular page before. You've got to run a bunch of tests before you're going to get to some more radical options. Yeah, one more thing. If this is lead gen and you have a free account and then later you're asking them to start this on your landing page, don't have them click before you're collecting a minimum amount of information. Collect a name, collect an email. Start collecting that minimum amount of information on this first page. And then when they drop off at the next step.

you can re-contact them, re-engage them, and try to re-attempt to get them through the process. And then just try and catch one more from our submissions here. Live optimization of Albert. This is the value proposition that they submitted. Ottawa's largest hotel suites for the same price or less as a regular room. This is the page. You can see that we pulled out some of the copy there. Jimmy and Aaron. A simplified image. Maybe an image of just your hotel suites, but met them with a headline.

you have your value proposition or a variation of this value proposition. How are those largest hotel suites for the same price or less as a regular room? Yeah, I'm going to say the same thing, Aaron. I'd rather see something like larger and 27% when you use something like a charter to back it up and show them a comparison of their rooms, the square footage of the rooms, the actual cost of the rooms, and that is going to speak volumes over you trying to get really, really big hotel suites. So all I feel like at the page, even if I do see the really, really big hotel suites in some of the content copies, okay, you have large hotel suites, and you say you're less than, but you're not proving it, and you're not giving me that many good reasons to do it. Now, I do like that second paragraph, because real workspaces, real balconies, they can pull those things out and put a little, each one so they can actually see them and prove it. There's one that I think has a lot of time, which we're flipping to now. There's a lot of things going on with the page there they have to work on, and I think that if you guys could just give them a few quick suggestions, really quick and rapid fire, it'll be very helpful. Sure. Jimmy, do you want to start with this one? There's no value proposition. The thing that they say is over 400 locations nationwide, and if you see the tagline, which is not a value proposition, top right. And so this one needs a lot of...

a bunch of attractive images and stuff on the page, but it doesn't help. It doesn't figure out if this is the right service for you unless you type in your zip code and look for locations and rates, and that's if you realize what it is. Luckily, their name, UStore, does a decent job of actually kind of communicating what they actually do. So for something like this, they need to figure out what their value proposition is. Maybe it's the most locations, but that's probably not going to do it because there's tons, tons, some of them are free, and that's bottom right, which is, you know, most locations, that graphic is bottom right. But you've got to communicate why you should use UStore over any of your other competitors, over U-Hauls or any of the self-storage places.

In terms of that, you also want to use an image that has black text on it with a testimonial that's hard to read. You need to start this whole page, like we've been talking to you over and over again, with a good, strong headline. You can use an image, you know, lay out your value proposition with probably an intro paragraph and a three to five bullet, something like that, that says, okay, are truly the lowest cost and you can prove it to them. You're going to want to get them interested in using a service before you're going to want them to start looking around for locations and rates. So there's a little tool on the left to get locations and rates if you figured out, okay, this is a storage facility and I just want to get started.

Jimmy, you nailed it. And you're using these ad boxes or ad tiles to try and communicate all these messages with. And what happens is each one of these ad tiles ends up competing with one another. So you've got all these different – you've got these location rates. You've got the testimonials that nobody can read. You've got to pay your bill at the bottom of the page, and then your first month rent free, and you don't know how to navigate. You're not guiding anyone. So not only do you not have a value proposition, but you're doing it very poorly into – Just one last slide. Stick with me. There's just one more. Let's see their potential academically, socially, and emotionally. There's a lot of things that they can do here. Let's just –

submitted academically, socially, and emotionally. There is absolutely no proof, no credibility in that statement. It's an organization of what they're trying to say. If you can copy or chart to graphs or any of the landing page, it's going to be more effective. I come here with you. Welcome to Montessori. You really don't want to say, welcome to my site. You want to start with why they should visit your site or why they should go to your school. Here's what my child is going to answer. And all they're saying is, Montessori and Redlands is a private nonprofit school, outstanding education, more than 350 children. So if you look at our elements to consider, yeah, you're getting specific.

not a single reason for me to actually use your service. So here's some of the things I want to do. Show me or show me proof that my child will, kids that have gone to this Montessori school, have they scored higher on standardized tests? Have they had more success getting into college or graduating from college or getting better jobs or with any of their particular goals? If you do that, have case studies, have information that shows a typical student in public school versus Montessori or private school versus Montessori because Montessori is a type of private school. Same thing with socially. In life or during childhood with relationships, is there a way to show that or prove that? I'm not sure how to do it, but those are the types of things you're going to need to see on the stage. Emotionally things, are they just...

Do they need less like that later on in life? I'm not sure exactly what to do socially and emotionally reaching their goals. You're using a print advertisement as your webpage. This is a print ad. This is not a webpage. You need to focus more so you're trying to communicate to a customer and getting them in through the products and background images to try and communicate that message. Thank you both very much. We'll wrap up here now with the live optimization, the best submission. We put this test search team and the optimization team here, and the winner was Stratasys.

we already covered earlier, so we'll just sit there now. You can see that the value proposition answered the key question and achieved the highest matrix for the submissions. They expressed it in effective ways throughout their website. And as a prize, they have received our 2009 landing page optimization workshop in Miami to see them and work with their site even more and do some of the tests and help them optimize it even further. For the summary of today, a lot of the key points, again, some we covered before, make optimizing your value proposition a cyclical process. Use the matrix, and that's available in the worksheet, which you can download from our blog, marketingexperimentsblog.com or the site. Refine it. Try and get it to a single instantly credible sentence if possible. Use your PPC microtesting methods. Focus on quantitative expression over qualitative. And one place to start is looking for that buried treasure on your site, some of those elements in your copy and other pages that you might find.

to help strengthen your value proposition. I want to say thanks again to Jimmy and Aaron for doing a great job in going over with us today. Thanks, of course, to everybody who submitted their site for the live optimization. We hope we'll see some of you at the Santa Monica workshop. You'll get the research brief and the clinic. You'll be notified via e-mail when this is available online, as always. And please keep an eye out for our clinics coming in December 3rd and 17th. We're doing our year-end analyst roundup and the blueprint for 2009. Right now, I'd just like to ask you, please give us your feedback on the post-clinic survey as you exit. Let us know if you found today helpful, what you would like to see more of.

et cetera, et cetera. We read all of it, and it's very valuable to us. And we hope to see you in Santa Monica or with our next live clinics.

French Your Way Jessica: Native French teacher founder of French Your Way Boost your French listening skills and test your comprehension with this one of a kind series of podcasts. Get the chance to listen to a real conversation between native speakers talking at normal speed AND customise your learning experience through carefully designed sets of questions (2 levels of difficulty) available for download at www.frenchvoicespodcast.com. All interviews also come with the transcript. French teacher Jessica interviews native speakers of French from around the world who share a bit of their life and passion. Where else would you meet in one same place a French yoga teacher based in Melbourne, a soap manufacturer from Provence, or a couple cycling around the world? Growth Triggers: Content Marketing & AI Luis Diaz Discover how to use your podcast to generate leads, sales, and influence in any market. On this show Luis shares his best tested and proven secrets, tips, and strategies from launching over 300 podcasts in over a dozen different niches and generating over 59 Million Downloads for his clients. Learn how to increase your podcast listenership, create multiple new revenue streams with your podcast, sell more of your core offer and build a show that gives you leverage and authority in your space. From picking the right monetization strategy for your podcast to learning how to position your podcast in a crowded market on Apple and Spotify; this is show is the ultimate marketing and sales resource for online business owners who want to know what works with podcasting. Get in touch over on Instagram <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow" class="link" href="https://www.instagram.com/luisr

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of MarketingExperiments.com Web Clinic Podcasts?

This episode is 1 hour and 7 minutes long.

When was this MarketingExperiments.com Web Clinic Podcasts episode published?

This episode was published on November 14, 2008.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this MarketingExperiments.com Web Clinic Podcasts episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.