Skip to content
Resolve Post-divorce Conflict With Mediation with Erik Wheeler episode artwork

May 20, 2021 24 min

Resolve Post-divorce Conflict With Mediation with Erik Wheeler

from Divorce Dialogues Hosted by Katherine Miller

Even if you craft the perfect divorce agreement, disputes still arise post-divorce. As circumstances change, conflicts come up. So, what should you do when you and your ex disagree? How might you leverage mediation to resolve those conflicts with less frustration and resentment? Erik Wheeler is the Founder and Family Mediator at Accord Mediation, a practice out of Burlington, Vermont, that specializes in divorce and post-divorce mediation. Erik uses conflict resolution and divorce mediation to help couples navigate disagreements around parenting schedules, custody and finances. Erik is also the co-creator of Divorce Peacefully, a webinar designed to educate divorcing couples about the alternatives to litigation—mediation and collaborative divorce. On this episode of Divorce Dialogues, Erik joins Katherine to discuss the most common conflicts that come up after a divorce, explaining why it’s crucial to get granular on the details of your parenting agreement. He describes how a mediator can help facilitate difficult discussions and shares his approach to resolving conflicts like who will claim the children on their taxes and how to split your kid’s expenses. Listen in for Erik’s insight on the challenges that come up when one parent relocates and learn how mediation can help you and your ex find solutions that work well for your family’s future. Topics Covered Erik’s insight on the kinds of conflict that come up after a divorce Why it’s crucial for divorcing couples to get specific on the details of their parenting agreement How the introduction of new partners can exacerbate conflict in divorced couples How a mediator helps facilitate difficult discussions by focusing on interests vs. positions What makes mediation a better option than litigation in finding solutions that work well for your family How to resolve conflicts around who will claim the children on taxes The challenges that come up when one parent relocates Erik’s approach to conflicts around splitting your kid’s expenses (including tuition) Why Erik suggests going to mediation as soon as a conflict arises Connect with Erik Wheeler Accord Mediation: https://www.accordmediationvt.com/ Accord Mediation on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/vermontmediator/ Call (802) 391-4121 Connect with Katherine Miller The Center for Understanding Conflict: http://understandinginconflict.org/ Miller Law Group: https://westchesterfamilylaw.com/ Katherine on LinkedIn: linkedin.com/in/kemiller1 The New Yorker’s Guide to Collaborative Divorce by Katherine Miller: https://www.amazon.com/New-Yorkers-Guide-Collaborative-Divorce/dp/0692496246 Email: [email protected] Call (914) 738-7765 Resources Erik’s Divorce Peacefully Webinar: https://howtodivorcepeacefully.com/ SupportPay: https://supportpay.com/ 2Houses: https://www.2houses.com/en

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Resolve Post-divorce Conflict With Mediation with Erik Wheeler

0:00 24:35
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Welcome to Divorce Dialogues, I'm Katherine Miller. Divorce Dialogues brings expert guests to the airways to talk through your divorce questions and fill in the gray areas about separating. From thinking about divorce to how to behave during divorce, to what to do after, this is Divorce Dialogues. Welcome to Divorce Dialogues, I'm Katherine Miller, I'm the founder of the Miller Law Brothers and Director of Center for Understanding and Public, and I am on a mission to change how people divorce and how some divorce with dignity.

And my guest today is Eric Wheeler, he's a family mediator based in Burlington, Vermont, and he specializes in divorce and post divorce mediation. Eric advocates for a peaceful divorce process using divorce mediation and conflict resolution. In post divorce mediation, Eric helps couples work through disagreements about parenting schedules, custody and financial issues. He offers a webinar about divorcing peacefully without litigation, which teaches people about two options divorce mediation and collaborative law.

Welcome, Eric Wheeler, it's a pleasure to have you on the show. Thank you for having us, great to be with you. So let's talk today about post divorce issues. What are some of the issues that come up for people after the judgment of divorce is final and they reach, they still have conflict?

What are the kinds of things that come up for them? Sure, yeah, so quite often people come to me with issues that come up afterwards. And it's a smaller part of my practice, it's about 40% of what I do, and the rest is divorce mediation. So as I've seen these people come with their challenges, I've realized that there's kind of a common set of themes that they bring, that they run into problems later after the divorce.

So, you know, one of the main problems I see is that they don't get specific on some of the details around their agreements, the parenting agreement, is usually where they have the most problems. So for example, they may not have specified specific details around the holidays. For example, they may have said, well, dad will get Thanksgiving in the odd years, but what does Thanksgiving mean? And quite often people are amicable at the time of divorce, and which is wonderful.

And sometimes they feel it's a little silly to talk about the specifics of, you know, what does Thanksgiving mean? When will the kids come to each person's house? But it's important to take that time and get specific, even if it doesn't feel necessary, because that agreement can help prevent a lot of conflict later. So if you determine that Thanksgiving means 9 a.m.

to 7 p.m., then that eliminates a lot of uncertainty and prevents conflict. With regard to the Thanksgiving example, because I think it's a really good one. If you didn't get really granular and talk about what each of you meant, people could genuinely interpret Thanksgiving in different ways. Some people could think and assume, and without discussing it, think that they were talking about a Thanksgiving meal.

So we're talking, we always do Thanksgiving dinner. It starts at five and it's over a day. Or we always do Thanksgiving lunch and starts at one and it's over by three. Or it's the whole day, we go to Aunt Sally's house and we get there at 10 and it's football and there's this and there's that and the other thing and that's the whole day.

Other people could think, you know what? It's a whole four days. It's four days. And it's a whole vacation Thanksgiving starts on Thursday morning or on Wednesday after school.

And clearly it goes all the way through to the next Monday because we maybe would go to end of Florida or we might go to the beach or we might just go to see relatives in another state or even just hang out at home. And so someone could be thinking, okay, we're gonna alternate Thanksgiving. One person could be talking about a two hour window, another person could be talking about five straight days. And when we're really careful about it and we're talking about what does Thanksgiving mean and that people could come in from a good place.

Not trying to be problematic at all, just have a different assumption about what that means. And I think that's one thing that you're talking about clarifying different assumptions and also clarifying things that happen when you actually go to live the agreement and realize it's maybe not the same as you thought it was gonna be, is that right? Exactly, right. Yeah.

And as you pointed out, there are so many different ways that people look at things like holiday. And so that's what I try to do in divorce mediation is take them through that and have them each talk about what's important to them. So one of them may say, I don't know, let's make it Thanksgiving day. The other parent may say, well, but remember, I like to take the kids to visit my parents.

And so they need to talk that through and actually have that discussion. And then they can come to an agreement that'll work for both of them. And just having that agreement and ideally in the final order will really help with that. So that's one thing I see frequently is people coming and having disagreements about the holidays or changes to the regular schedule or the summer schedule.

And like you're saying, it may not be malicious. It may just be a true misunderstanding from two very different perspectives. I think sometimes the parenting issues, the introduction of new partners can sometimes make people see things in a different way. What do you think about that?

Is that your experience? Yeah, definitely. So with a new partner, they're often getting, obviously, more details to figure out. So that new partner's family has different, their nuclear family has different practices.

And so that may impact the schedule or if they have their own children, that could impact things too, because of the schedule that their children are on. And then also just kind of getting perspective and advice from that new partner. Sometimes it really can exacerbate a conflict unfortunately, but they wanna kind of talk about what's important to them and how it impacts them, which is all reasonable. And sometimes I've had two couples in mediation talking things through.

If they can do that fairly effectively, then that works really well, because they're all talking about how these different schedule issues impact each of their lives. So Eric Wheeler, I can imagine someone out there listening to this conversation thinking, yeah, right, how's mediation gonna help? We've had a lot of conversations and it doesn't get us anywhere. All we do is end up arguing.

And so tell me what your experience is, why does mediation make a difference when people just can't seem to get anywhere on their own? Yeah, that is a frequent misunderstanding of mediation is that we can't talk things through directly one on one, then mediation's not gonna be helpful. But that's not the case for most people, because most people benefit a lot from having a third party and having someone facilitate, who's trained to facilitate people to go through those difficult discussions. So even if you're having a lot of conflict, you can come together in mediation and talk things through.

So in mediation, we try to identify what we refer to as people's interests, which are distinct from their positions. And understanding those interests, so for example, position might be, well, I need X thousand dollars. Let's say we're talking about asset division during divorce. If we understand what's underneath that, for example, while I'm concerned about my finances, when I have my new home, by myself, then there are a lot more opportunities to work through that and come to an agreement.

And the alternative litigation going to court is very different because it's really focused on the past. It's really focused on blaming, in those cases, focus on what that person did wrong in the past, and it's not talking about a solution for the future. So mediation is two people working together to create that solution for the future. It's forward looking.

And even if it's not easy to work together, you're much more likely to come to a solution that's gonna work well for you and your family, because you're working on it, you're in control of it. And that's why I love mediation. I actually spoke to a family court judge a while back, and she said, tell your clients that I wholeheartedly advocate for mediation. She said, I've got a limited amount of time to be able to make a decision.

So the two parties come in and I've got maybe half an hour, and I don't have the time to really get into the situation and understand it as much as I would like to make that decision for them. So she said, tell them that they're better off in mediation. You can tell them I said that. So she was a real advocate of it.

I'm Katherine Miller, and you're listening to divorce dialogues here on WVOX1460AM, Alternate One Station, 5 to 5.30, or perhaps you're listening to the podcast, which is available wherever you listen to podcasts, as well as on the podcast website, divorce dialogues.com. And I'm talking today with Eric Wheeler about mediation of post-divorce issues. And Eric Lee, we've talked about some post-divorce parenting issues, and are there financial issues that sometimes come up following a divorce that people come to mediation or need help with? Yeah, absolutely.

So one common one is about who's gonna claim the children for taxes, for tax purposes. And that can be quite significant. The Child Tax Credit, or especially in the last year, so the additional incentives that were given out to the pandemic release, that amount is quite a bit of money. So I see frequently that there's disagreement about who should claim the child or children.

And that's something that you can address beforehand. If you're aware of it, you can specify who should receive it and how it will be done. So for example, you might say that one parent will claim the Child Tax Credit every other year, they'll switch it every other year, or that one parent will claim one child, the other parent will claim the other child. So there are ways that you can structure this so that it's not a conflict later.

I've even seen some couples say that, well, let's do our taxes every year, see who gets the better benefit from claiming the children, and then we'll split the tax refund. So taxes is one that comes up frequently for me in post-abortion mediation. Well, it's kind of interesting because a couple of examples that we've talked about so far seem like they could have easily been addressed in the original negotiation, right? How did it might be giving?

How to handle a Child Tax Credit or exemption, depending on where we are, what tax you were talking about. But what are things that like come up that if everybody did everything right, dotted every I and crossed every T, you still end up with disagreements on the post-divorce? What are some things that could happen like that? And is mediation a good way for people to resolve those things?

Yeah, that's a very good question. And a good point too, that you certainly can't prevent every conflict. I wish that were the case, but you can't. And so you just have to do the best you can addressing as many issues as possible that you think could be problematic, getting specific as you can.

But in the end, there's going to be surprises, you know, most likely. So for example, let's say that one parent needs to move because of work reasons. So that's fairly common. And mediation allows people to talk that through in a way that they are going to find the best solution possible.

So when someone resorts to going to court or saying, well, I have solo custody, so I'm just going to do what I want to do. People often feel like court or using solo custody as the reason is going to solve the problem once and for all. But I find that that's not the case. So part of the problem is that if one person quote wins in court, then that issue might be solved.

It might still come up again though. But the main problem is that they may have resentments. The one who didn't quote win might have resentments that kind of come out sideways and create other issues. So mediation really gives you that chance to work things through.

And it's not always easy. You know, mediation is not rainbows and butterflies. It can be challenging. But that's kind of some of the work that needs to be done really.

Let's work that example through in terms of what those ramifications could be. So your relocation example, let's say families located here on the East Coast and one parent wants to relocate or needs to relocate to the West Coast for work. And if one, I don't know how it is in Vermont, but that would not, even if the parent, one parent had solo custody, it wouldn't really make any difference. You couldn't move with the child to another state without the, or far away, without the other parent's consent, whether or not you had solo custody or not, without the agreement of the other parent or a court order.

I think one point that you made, Eric Wheeler, was that it's not having solo custody, doesn't give you card lines to do whatever you want to do. Right? You still are entwined with the other parent. So let's say though, you went to court and you were allowed to move.

The court decided that it was in the best interest of the child for whatever reason. To allow either the parent who was who and the child lived more often than not, you know, we call the custodial parent to stay or to move or the other parent. And let's say then, all right, there's resentment that builds up between the parents and the children are stuck in the middle, right? So then how are the children going to have a relationship with both parents under those circumstances?

And there might be resentment that builds up an anger at one or both parents. It could be that if the parents can't work together to resolve it, it could be that kids get depressed or have alcohol or drug abuse issues that come up because of the fact that they feel abandoned by one, and maybe both parents. And again, it could be, on the other hand, that if the parents can work together and figure out a change in the parenting plan and the parenting schedule, so the kids maybe spend summers with a parent who moved or the other parent who stayed, regardless, depending on what situation is, or they work out some kind of change in the plan that allows the children to feel that both parents are participating in their lives, that mediation is just a better place for that. I think it's what you're saying because the creative possibility of working together to solve this shared problem comes to the fore as opposed to having just kind of an answer to one question forced on them.

And that one answer, that one question raises a whole bunch of other questions, which won't necessarily be resolved by the court determination. Is that right? Yeah, there's so many factors involved, like you're saying, and it really can impact the kids, and that's our priority, is really making things as smooth as possible for the kids. So working together to find a way to address those different pressures and disagreements is really what the work that needs to be done.

And one of the most difficult situations I find in mediation is that geographic distance issue. So it doesn't have to be enormous. You know, it can just be an hour away even, or I've seen cases where an hour drive between the homes made things very difficult for the parents and the kids. And even, you know, but it ends up being a few hours, or, you know, hopefully not across the country.

I have seen a couple of cases like that too. That's very difficult to resolve. So one of the recommendations I make to people as they're going through divorce is make every effort possible to keep that distance as small as possible between the two parents, because otherwise there can be issues that are pretty challenging to resolve. Yeah, I think that's really hard too.

I'm Katherine Miller, and you're listening to divorce dialogues here on WVLX 1460 AM, alternate Wednesdays from 5 to 530s, or perhaps you're listening on the podcast available wherever you listen to podcasts. And I want to encourage people who've got any family law issues at all in New York State. Give us a call, 914-8X2-7487. And I'm speaking today with Eric Wheeler.

And so Eric, where can people find out more about post divorce mediation or about you? Sure. Yeah, my website is accordmediationvt.com. So my practice is called Accord Mediation ACC ORD.

And my phone number is 802-391-4121. Great. Thank you so much. So I think that people have this idea that once you go to court, it's going to be over and done with.

And that's just not true. And I think that our conversation so far really indicates some of the things that can come up. But what are some other things that you have seen people use mediation to help with after they've gotten divorced? Yeah.

Another one that comes up commonly is how to split expenses for the kids' expenses. And that's also something that can be talked through. And you can usually anticipate a lot of different categories of expenses and prevent that discriminate later. But quite often, one parent might want to spend a lot more for whatever it is, kids' clothing or activities or whatever that might be.

And the other parent doesn't agree with that expense. If you don't have some parameters in place beforehand, then that's a lot more difficult. So for example, if one parent wants to buy a really expensive piece of clothing and then expects the other one to share that expense, that causes conflict that people come to mediation for. So what they often do in mediation, in this post divorce mediation, is talk through what those parameters will be.

They might say, well, for me, an expense over $200 is going to be quite a bit for me to consider sharing. So let's agree that if the expenses can be over $200, you need to pass the other parent first to make sure that they agree on splitting that. And so it doesn't mean that the parents are limited from spending that, so they can't automatically expect the other parent to pay it if it exceeds that threshold. That's kind of interesting.

I think it's another thing that I found people come to post divorce mediation for is if they haven't been truing that up on a regular basis. So if they haven't been a client, that they're going to split private school tuition or they're going to split whatever it is, if you let it get too much too many years ago, pass it, I had a couple of come to mediation once where the bill was in seven figures. You know, the one parent was looking for over a million dollars in reimbursement. And the other parent was like, no, that's too much.

And you know, it's really a problem. So if you do have an agreement that calls for a periodic true up or one person reimburses, first of all, there's an app for that. There are a number of apps out there that do that for you and do that calculation. So you don't have to be constantly texting.

I think that's really useful to use it because it means you don't have to talk about it, but also to not let it go years. Because it's just a lot that easier to get reimbursed 20 bucks than it is 2000 bucks, 2000 bucks and certainly 2 million bucks. What do you think? Yeah, absolutely.

Yeah. And it's really hard to talk about those expenses a year later too. So even if both might agree to splitting that expense to some degree, if you're talking about expense from a year ago and you're trying to dig up details on that, that's a lot more difficult. So I totally agree with recommending a periodic true up.

That makes a lot of sense. And tuition for private school or for college is also something that comes to post divorce mediation. So that's, again, one of those things that you can talk about as part of your divorce and try to come to agreement on how you're going to split that expense and to what limit. Some are perfectly happy to share college expense and they know that they are limited to a certain amount based on their income.

So they say, well, I can guarantee you'll share up to X. And those are important parameters that in place. Yeah. And I also think that mediation can be very helpful when there's been a change in circumstances where the person who was making more money loses their job or the person who was making less money is now making more money.

Right. And so I think that there's, from our conversation, my own experience, the idea that any post, will be calling the post judgment, but post divorce issues that come up can be much, perhaps easily discussed in mediation and that it's easier if people go to mediation right away when they have a disagreement instead of waiting until they're really, really dug in. What's your experience with that? Yeah.

I totally agree. And people ask me that sometimes. We do mediation now or should we wait a little bit? And I said, no, I'm talking about it now.

Even if maybe there's some details you need to figure out and you can't do those in the first session. We can at least get through a lot of the discussion and therefore come to some understanding of each other's side viewpoint and also get some of those issues out of the way. So the sooner the better because those resentments that build up, that can make things much more difficult to work together if they are building up over a long period of time. Yeah, I agree with that because people just dig themselves further into a hole and it's not getting better.

I mean, what are you waiting for? Just to hate each other more? No. And they have children at the long road.

They have together and if mediation can help them resolve the issues more easily, I'm all in favor. Absolutely. Yeah. And that they're working together for the kids' benefit too.

Yeah, so I think mediation just in our last few seconds can also be helpful if people have any kind of disagreement about parenting or decisions or school or doctors. It's a great place to go. Eric Wheeler, that's my experience. Absolutely.

Well, thank you. It's been great having you as our guest on divorce. I would thank you so much for your time today and for your comments about post-divorce mediation and I really appreciate it. Absolutely.

Good talking to the Catherine. Thanks for having me.

A Spooky Action At A Distance David Masters Welcome to 'Spooky Action at a Distance,' a weekly podcast where we chart the mysterious spaces between the mundane and mystical. From ghostly tales to UFO narratives, music phenomena to divine conundrums, our exploration rooted in para-psychology challenges conventional wisdom, ignites thought-provoking dialogues, and illuminates the enigmatic threads of existence. Guided by seasoned hosts, we venture into the labyrinth of the extraordinary, investigating each peculiarity from varied perspectives. Tune in, open your mind, and join us on this captivating quest, traversing the spectral landscapes of the strange and supernatural. A Ground Zero Radio podcast Goldwater, Dubé TNKR Media Join lawyer and political commentator Anne-France Goldwater for the miniseries Love & Money by Goldwater, Dubé. Over the next few weeks, learn more about family law, divorce, youth protection, animal rights, the constitution and more from some of Quebec’s most experienced lawyers. Oliver Bardwell Podcast Oliver Bardwell Welcome to ”The Oliver Bardwell Podcast,” where insightful conversations converge. Join me, Oliver Bardwell, author, speaker, and seeker of wisdom, as I engage in thought-provoking dialogues that span spirituality, unity, and diverse perspectives. Delve into respectful discussions with legislators, doctors, education experts, and guests from every corner of life, as we explore a myriad of intriguing topics. From the heart of Iowa to the world, let’s embark on a journey of discovery and understanding together. Inception Dialogues Bernardo Kastrup Exploring the human imagination through conversations about art, myth, theology, psychology, true philosophy, and direct experience

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Divorce Dialogues?

This episode is 24 minutes long.

When was this Divorce Dialogues episode published?

This episode was published on May 20, 2021.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Divorce Dialogues episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.