What follows is an interview with Robbie Barnes and Sylvie Kashdan. We did this interview to get some context on the two plays, The Revolutionary Purity Showdown and The Illyria Street Commune. The interview turned into a two-and-a-half-hour conversation about a wide variety of topics. We hope you enjoy it. Let's start by seeing if you could give some of the context for these two plays. What was the milieu that they came out of? What were they trying to communicate? What was their significance? What I was just remembering is the place where they were put on was called Easy Space, and it was a super low budget.
place that you could only have in Detroit, I think, at that point. Yeah. And it's unheard of nowadays. But basically, all volunteer, you know, people wrote their own plays and put them all on and do like two or three performances. Yeah, just a community theater. It was a community theater, basically. Do you have any more you want to add? No, other than in terms of the plays context themselves.
Detroit was a place during the 70s where there was a lot of activity going on, as there actually was in Seattle and New York. People were feeling a little down because 1968 didn't lead to all the major social changes that we'd hoped for, but people kept going. There were a lot of things we were doing. There was a lot of co-ops, food co-ops, small food co-ops, and women's health clinics. do-it-yourself women's health clinics, not necessarily legally approved, housing, different housing initiatives, different child care initiatives. And in Detroit in particular, and also in Chicago and in some other places, I think in Seattle too, not as much in New York where Robbie and I were living, but there were places where people could get rentals of large houses.
in Detroit, in the area where a lot of the people around what became the anarchist scene, which was primarily the anti-authoritarian scene, in that people didn't want to necessarily identify with only the traditional anarchists. But in that context, a lot of those people were living in an area that had been built up for low-level... car company executives. So the houses were nice and big, but not mansions as such. So then a lot of them became group houses, people living there. But it was not something that was done primarily to make them into communes, although there were other places where people were doing communes in a more intentional sense of trying to have people live in a certain way and follow certain rules.
The ones that were in Detroit were primarily people living together to save money. And a lot of them were people who shared social ideas. So there was a lot of discussion about that. And the question came up, part of other questions, about how people should live together or how people shouldn't live together. And so there were a lot of debates. There were also debates.
that you can notice in the plays about how much money one should take from the government or big corporations for projects that you thought were really relevant. How much people should become professionals, should use their artistic, their creative skills to become professionals or shouldn't. And in general, how much people should try to integrate their survival needs with their... social desires. And so both of those plays are really about that. And particularly Illyria Street Commune is about how people would integrate or could integrate or didn't integrate their social desires with their survival needs. Wouldn't you say? Yeah, so like in Revolutionary Purity Showdown, you'll have situations as kind of one-upmanship where someone will say...
I saw you have the writer's market on your shelf. The person says, oh, you have the farmer's almanac. In other words, they take it to extremes. But that sort of gives you an idea, that kind of judgmental attitude that didn't go on. But in the Illyria Street Commune, it played out more seriously. You see them playing their roles, basically, in parallel to what people did in real life.
And none of the people in either of those plays are just one person, but all of them are combinations of people. So if you knew the people there, you could recognize some of the people, but you would notice, oh, this one is a compound of person A, person B, person C, but a little different than all of them, but you can see them. It's like a historical novel in that way. So these are historical, fictional plays. But it was an interesting way of carrying on the conversation. But I will say, somebody asked me, did people resolve the debates or the conflicts that they were having because of this kind of play or these plays? And the answer is no. There was ongoing issues, you know, because that's how it is when you're living in a society that doesn't suit your needs or your desires. And that was true of those people then too.
Then there's the other issue about people who have fallings out over how to put on a play. That's a whole separate thing, but it did happen, and that probably happens everywhere. It's like, oh, you hammed it up too much, or you didn't read it the way, you didn't say it the way I wrote it, or that kind of thing went on back and forth. Yeah, well, it was interesting because... Richard Aids, who was the one who wrote Revolutionary Purity Showdown, I sent the play to him and I told him that we're going to put it out, you know, we're going to print it up and circulate it with people. And he looked at it and he said, oh, there's one part that I changed near the end. In other words, I had a copy that somebody had given me where they hadn't noted his change, but even after all these years, he remembered what his change was. So it's incorporated in it. And like, even though these plays are fiction and so forth, they are meaningful to people so that they did remember a lot about them.
But would you want to just introduce yourselves and say kind of how you, what your relationship to these plays is? Hi, my name is Robbie. I guess I was one of many people who traveled to Detroit just to be with our friends there and go to those plays from different parts of the country in the 70s. the late 70s we knew the people that wrote them and put them on and like that yeah the early 70s and the late 70s yeah and whatever yeah yeah rabbi and i my name is sylvie and rabbi and i both lived in new york and we were part of the anarchist anti-authoritarian um milieu there and um we had known freddie and lorraine as far back as the late 1960s um we met them and corresponded with them freddie and lorraine perlman and uh We got to know some of the other people in Detroit when we went to visit. We were also going to Chicago. We knew some people who lived in Chicago. And we even thought about both moving to Chicago or Detroit. And although we liked some of the people we knew in Chicago, we decided we didn't want to live in Chicago. And Detroit, we thought very seriously about, but it doesn't have good public transportation and never did. So we decided it wasn't a place that we could live easily. But we visited there sometimes.
two to three times a year. We were in touch by letter and by telephone. It depended, like, there was a lot of traveling back and forth. People came to visit us in New York, too. And mostly it was hitchhiking across the country or shared rides or bus or train, all of which we did. And we didn't fly. Flying wasn't something that we could afford or that we did all that often. But we were visiting there.
We went a lot of times for the plays, and some of the plays were given to us, and then some of them we just saw were weren't given to us, but several of them were given to us at the time, because we asked, and also when people finished the play, they had the script that they worked on, and they gave it to us. We actually have a recording of one of them. Not one of these, another one. Who is Zarelli? Yeah. Who is Zarelli? Which is a play that Freddie Perlman wrote about the medical industry. After he had his first operation for his heart valve transplant, he had two in it. During the second one, he died. But during the first one, he was in the hospital, and he found it a horrendous experience. And so he wrote a play that's actually very funny. Funny and serious. And we will eventually...
get it together. We have the transcript as well as the recording and we will circulate it among people. We just haven't gotten a chance. But yeah, somebody had recorded it. So we have the recording and we have the written transcript for that one. Is it on tape? No, it's on CD. It was on tape originally. We did get it on tape. I guess it's an hour and a half or so. And we have like one of the problems with the...
the play script is some of it's parallel and you have to kind of piece them together figure out what they really were you know what it was really what was really happening in it what is it it is is actually robbie i figured it out is there is a narrator at the beginning and i remembered after i read it over the narrator summarizes the scene and then they enact the scene okay so that's why it looks like it's parallel but it's the narrator is speaking and you can hear on the recording anyway it was very interesting to hear the recording after years We hadn't thought about it. It was like one of these things we carried with us as we moved around the country. It's a good idea to save stuff. Save everything. Until you can't move at all. How many plays were there? I think there were 15 or something. We don't have them all, although we know the guy who did save them all, and we probably, if we get to them, we could eventually salvage a lot more of them. One was called Double Coupon Day Afternoon.
I guess it was a takeoff on Dog Day Afternoon. Oh, right. And the other one is about Sister Mary Magdalene. They were really into vamping on religion, so they had some plays they did like that. I forgot the rest. I've got a long title. And Sister Mary Magdalene was played by a guy with a beard. But what else? Yeah, there were several. And you said that people from all over the country would come out to see them? Yeah. I mean, as I remember, there would be some...
But Detroit was a pretty big place, so it's like you would say people come from all over the country to Seattle. Sometimes you don't notice, you know what I mean, because they're always there from different places, but they were glad to be at the place. Well, also it's like there were connections. In other words, the people in Seattle were in correspondence and in contact with the people in Detroit. People from Chicago were, people from various places down south, from Dallas. I know somebody who would come up fairly regularly. People from San Francisco and from Los Angeles, from Minneapolis, Minnesota.
a number of different places where people were, they would come to visit. because they had contact. So it wasn't like giant crowds. But, you know, it was, I don't know, a few hundred to a thousand. Never a thousand at one time, but, you know, probably over time. And like when people would come from Europe, they would usually stop in New York, stop in Detroit, stop in Chicago, stop in the Bay Area, stop in Seattle, and a few other places too. Oh, and sometimes Southern Illinois. There were a number of places that they might...
that they might go, because that's how the connections were. Even though it wasn't like a big anarchist movement like it is now, there were a lot of connections. That's probably how it eventually became. Yeah, I think it's part of it. Yeah, people were inspired by it over time. Right. And there were also groups of immigrant anarchists from all over the world, refugees from the Spanish Revolution, refugees from...
Mussolini's, Italy's, there were older anarchists in various places too, so that sort of added to it, although that wasn't the main part of it. There was some contact, but it wasn't the main part, but they sort of added to the mix also. Would you talk about, I guess, how you came to anarchist ideas and became involved in, or radical ideas, and how you became involved in the milieu? So I guess I came from more or less a very right-wing background, my parents, my family background. They weren't politically involved, but all their ideas were totally racist and off the wall and outrageous. I just thought it was wrong. And so the first chance I got, I left home when I was 18 or 19.
That would have been, you know, around the time when the anti-Vietnam War stuff was starting up and the civil rights movement was going on. And so, and I'd hear, you know, I'd be listening to Pacific Radio Station in New York about Bull Connor, you know, hosing down the protesters in Birmingham or whatever, in the South, you know, that kind of stuff. And then I'd hear about my brother throwing rocks at these black people trying to integrate a McDonald's, or not McDonald's, an hamburger place in the North. So, just made it. even stronger kind of a thing to be opposed to, taking it personally. And then I guess little by little I got involved in student politics, anti-war kind of stuff. I was actually involved in some radio projects. Me and another guy were the first people that recorded, I guess it was kind of teaching, it was a whole day thing at Columbia in 1965 about protesting or teaching kind of about the war, about the Vietnam War.
Then got involved in SDS and went to all those conferences and so all the Stalinists and Maoists trying to manipulate everything they could and got involved in the Columbia strike and all that stuff in 68. And little by little just realized I wasn't going to be part of the Maoist tendency or any of that authoritarian stuff. But I never called myself an anarchist until... like the 80s or something. I kept saying to myself, well, I'm none of the above. I'm just this person who's fed up with everything and let me go my own way. And there were a lot of people like that. I mean, they weren't numerically, they were anarchist individuals at the SDS conferences. And we would meet them, and that's how we got to know the people in Chicago, Detroit, in the first place. And they had the most interesting literature, and they were really interesting, creative people. So that was that. And some of them called themselves anarchists.
they didn't want to be directly involved in the student movement at that time. But later on, I guess, when the right-wingers started using anarchist as a bad word, then I decided that I wanted to be an anarchist. So that's been that way ever since. I mean, really, I don't like any ist at all, any kind of ist. But it has a tradition. The anarchist tradition exists, and there's so much you can get from it. Might as well. But I'd say we're on our own, really. We're just going to build something new, non-ism. Go ahead. Okay. Yeah, well, I...
grew up born and grew up in a poor multicultural neighborhood my parents were immigrants I was among the first generation to finish high school and go to college my mother when she came to this country she went directly into a garment factory at the age of 12 and she didn't go to school she could barely read and write just really barely and my father I think went to the sixth grade and his father was a house painter and that's what he did for his first job and the son who was the house painter also since he could read and write was the person who the other guys would ask to read the newspapers. So like this is a time when they were like painting by hand. They weren't using machines to paint or anything like that. And so they would all work a little faster so that this guy could read them the newspapers and then they would discuss the newspapers together. So that was sort of like how my father got his education by reading these different newspapers and hearing the guys talk about them.
I guess my family was, I don't know what you would say, sort of left, maybe even close to anarchists, but they wouldn't talk to me or my sister about it because they were afraid that we would be hurt if we either spoke any other language than English or if we knew too much about social ideas. So we sort of picked up things from them, but they didn't exactly tell us everything. So my father used to say at a certain point, like he's going out to the workman's circle. I didn't find out until years later that there were both anarchists and socialists who were part of the, it was like a union hall, who were both part of the workman's circle.
But my father never told me that. So I sort of got some of the things by osmosis. But then also, I had friends from all sorts of backgrounds. And when I was a teenager, I was invited by my black friend to join picket lines and basically picketing to demand jobs for people. Because in New York, people could, in fact, no matter what their skin color, they could eat anywhere. And maybe if you were not rich, you couldn't eat in a ritzy restaurant. But none of us ever thought about that as such.
Jobs weren't as easy for people of certain backgrounds to get. So we used to go around and picket, asking, you know, demanding that people, black people be hired. So I was involved in that. And then I became interested in opposing the war in Vietnam. But also, I guess the other thing is my mother came from Russia.
Russian-Jewish background, and they fled before the revolution because the czarist military and the society was very anti-Semitic. And my mother actually lived near Kiev in a little shtetl Jewish community, and when she was six years old, Cossacks passed through the town and, for fun, so they say, shot at the kids in the square. And several kids were killed, and my mother wasn't killed, but she... carried a bullet in her arm all her life that was never removed. She couldn't lift her right arm because of that. She could use it a little bit, but not a lot. She couldn't really lift it up high or anything like that. And she was also very emotionally disturbed. I knew her sisters, my aunts, and my uncles. None of them were quite as emotionally disturbed as she was, but because she saw this thing and she was hurt herself. So they had to flee Russia. They had to...
be smuggled across the border because it was illegal for them to leave. Borders are very strange things. You can be left in or out. And my father's family came from Siberia. They were Siberian natives. And his father, I'm not sure when my father was born, but his father, I know, left Siberia when the Russians were forcing their people to settle down. Not Jewish animists. But anyway, my understanding as I was growing up was that there were people like me and my family in Russia.
but that the government was never good in Russia. So I grew up with the sense that the czarist government was awful, the communist government was awful, and the people there weren't so bad, none of which matched with what I was being told in school or what the general environment was, but all of which made me more of a skeptic than my parents probably intended me to be. Since they wanted me and my sister to be safe, I don't think they were trying to encourage the kinds of thoughts that I had. But anyway, I became involved in the anti-Vietnam War movement. I did find, though, that a lot of the people who were involved were very authoritarian, very bossy people, very manipulative people, so I didn't like that. I also got to know in New York various anarchists, anarcho-syndicalists like Sam Dalgoff, I knew him, and Esther Dalgoff, and a lot of the people around the Libertarian Forum.
Also, not as well, but I did know Murray Bookchin and I met other people. So I just sort of felt I didn't want to call myself an anarchist because I knew that although I agreed with some of their ideas, I didn't agree with all of their ideas. That's why I didn't want to call myself an anarchist. I didn't realize that anarchism could be very multifaceted and that I could, if I wanted to call myself an anarchist, and say, well, I'm part of the general tradition, but I don't agree with these other guys. Oh, and also, I didn't know, but I knew of Paul Goodman and some of the other people who were more pacifists, and I knew I wasn't a pacifist. So as much as I respected them, I didn't want to be part of that tradition either.
It was through those kinds of connections that I got to know about the people in Chicago before the people in Detroit, and then about Freddie and Lorraine Perlman before they moved to Detroit when they were living in Ann Arbor and some other things. And so, I don't know, it just seemed to grow into it. As far as that goes, it just seemed to be a kind of a natural thing. And I think there were a lot of people around who were like me and who were like Robbie who... didn't go away, but weren't necessarily calling themselves anarchists for quite a while. And even, like, people talk about, you know, all these things that happened in 1968, and one of the reasons that they happened is because there were a lot of people around. And also, oh, I also knew, although I wasn't close with the people around the motherfuckers, up against the wall motherfuckers, I hadn't been particularly close with them when they were black masks, but when they were up against the wall motherfuckers, they had, like, a little straw friend.
on the Lower East Side near where I lived, and I used to go and hang out there, but I didn't hang out with the stars. I hung out with the non-stars. I had an aversion to stars. And some of the people could be, even though they might call themselves anti-authoritarian or anarchists, they could be a bit bossy and domineering. And I also got to know some of the people who became the American Situationists. And I was actually good friends for a while with one, John Horlick, and I was on friendly terms with Bruce Elwell and on friendly terms with Tony Verlon.
To a certain extent, I didn't really know Bob Chassie. I met him several times, but I didn't know him. But those are the four people who were the official situationists in the United States. And the other ones who call themselves situationists came later. And the situationists would call them pro-situationists, pro-situ. And they looked down on them. And the other guy looked down on other people. Anyway, I don't know. But I guess the thing that bothers me sometimes when the anarchist academics talk about how the anarchist movement was so sparse.
after 1968, and I don't think it was. I think they just don't know how to measure it, you know, and that there were a lot of people around and continued to be around, and people just did different things. In times of high activity, people do one kind of thing, and in terms of when big protests peter out, people spend their time doing other things, like cooperatives, like group houses, like health care centers, you know, developing other skills and other connections, and that continued. A lot of the anarchist academics want to say everything died down until the late 1980s, which I guess is part of the reason that Robbie and I got involved in scanning old Fifth Estates because there's a lot of record of that continuing anti-authoritarian activity through the 70s and through the early 80s. And I want to be able to show people that there was activity. It's not like all of a sudden these punks came along in the late 1980s and they reawakened the anarchist movement that had been totally dead. Everybody was off doing all sorts of...
mainstream stuff and all of a sudden new people came along and reinvigorated. I think there was a lot of stuff going on before that. So that's how Robbie and I started to scan a lot of that stuff because we had been subscribing to the Fifth State since it became an anti-authoritarian paper. So we had basically a full set of papers that go back to 1975 when they became an anti-authoritarian paper. And we thought we'd like to share it with people so people would have a better sense of the history that we have.
Yeah, you know, like people talk about the DIY things that starting in the 80s, but really it had started in the mid 60s. It basically... people didn't have money so the movement people learned how to do their own printing and they learned how to do all these skills and it never went away it's just that a different generation came along and kind of took it up again you know and obviously on a much bigger scale I forgot recently oh yeah somebody we know that got in touch and says hey I'm learning all these nice skills like how to do things with my hands and you know it's another generation of people in other words now the DIY people are further back in the in the line of March or whatever it's like it's great that it keeps going but Basically, what happened was after the 60s, little by little, the kind of professionalism started creeping in where NGOs started up and people started doing movement things for money or getting foundation money or whatever. So then it kind of faded back. Some of it was OK, like things like the women's health centers that proliferated and they're still around like they do good things. But there were originally the ones that were really kind of.
grassroots things that people started from their own houses and with all those skills so then that never really went and also like with the plays in detroit people making their own culture um that did pick up again in the late 80s but it wasn't just starting then you know just like just another another version of it it's a theme that we don't we don't need mass professional culture we need our own that's always been the case it just looks different each time i'm curious if these changes came about because of what was going on like in the wider culture or you know in the country or if it was more like age related like as people reached a certain age and maybe like had families or wanted to you know age out or whatever um they just started moving the direction of you know doing things for money or if it was more like the culture broadly was pushing people in that direction or both or what's going on there trying to figure it out like i'm trying to like trace it from all the individuals i've known over the years and say what did so and so do and what did so and so you know people for survival people went off and and learned how to do certain things professionally
you know like teaching or being a graphic designer you can survive with stuff like that where you can't totally survive by being a movement person unless you have lots of friends who could keep you you know and help you get along but so uh i don't know if it's age as much as the pressure of survival getting tougher and tougher as time went time went by but i think it's true that from the 60s on a lot of the stereotypes got broken down so that You know, like from the mid 60s on, nobody wanted to be a commuter, you know, or, you know, a stuffed shirt of any kind. We all wanted to be different. So then what you had is people just moved in from the suburbs into the cities and settled in the cities and got all kinds of jobs that were there, you know, like in New York, it's such a big media place. So a lot of people got into those things and didn't mean that they abandoned their authoritarian ideas. They just did different things. Like I know a ton of people who used to be involved in Left Bank now going, you know, back to the 70s and 80s.
They're doing things like counseling vets or teaching and even some doing writing, some other things. Nobody's getting rich. And they're not different people. They've gotten different parts of their lives. Maybe age-related insofar as they've learned some lessons, they're taking them as lessons. They're saying, if I don't want to starve the rest of my life, I better get a skill or different things like that. Do you have a take on it, Sylvie? Yeah, well, I guess for me, it's also, it has to do with the general society.
After World War II, there was a lot of war industry that was left over. And that's when the suburbs began to grow. A lot of different companies settled in the suburbs and people were given the opportunity to move to the suburbs and have maybe slightly bigger homes than they had had and have jobs that were in the suburbs. So there wasn't big suburbs before. But there were a lot of people from poorer backgrounds.
uh working class backgrounds who were involved in um anti-authoritarian anarchist activity in the 50s and the 60s. A lot of people like me, actually, who were first generation going beyond high school and in lots of places like New York and California and other places, a university could be free or pretty cheap. So I went to, first I went to the State University of New York where I had a full scholarship because I was a smart kid in high school, stupid in elementary school, but smart in high school because I wanted to leave home. But then...
I didn't like it there because there were a lot of kids from the growing suburbs, so I didn't fit in. I went back to New York City and went to the City University. And there were a lot of kids with my kind of background. And a lot of the young people who were in what we call the movement were people from not rich, not well-off, not even suburban backgrounds. For us, going to college meant, among other things, that we wouldn't have to work in a factory or do the kind of shit work that our parents did and our parents didn't want us to do. Then some people afterwards started thinking about, now you have the college education, what do you do with it? And for some people, going on to become professional something or another seemed a logical thing. And that might be becoming a counselor or becoming a teacher or whatever. And then for some...
Like me, I worked five years in the university, the city university, and although I enjoyed what I did with the students, I worked with adult students in the evening division, and I really enjoyed working with them, and I had a lot of freedom, but it was a very exploitative job, and I didn't like the way my colleagues interacted, though I got out of that. But for a lot of people, it was a step up beyond what their parents had had. But at the same time, at the beginning of the 70s, All of those manual jobs, of which there were a whole lot before, began to disappear or change. So for a lot of people, it didn't seem like much of a choice beyond doing something professional. You couldn't as easily go and get a job.
in a factory if you wanted to. So I think it was societal kind of pressure as well as people not necessarily wanting to work the way that their parents had, whereas a lot of the older radicals might work a job as a factory worker and then do their social political stuff on the side. But for some other people it became more interesting to think about, can I... incorporate those things into my life. So for me, over time, it's taken something to realize that a lot of young people I meet come from what are called middle class backgrounds, which I would say are white collar working backgrounds. There were people like that in the 60s and 70s, and they were the ones who became the most visible, but lots of people who came from backgrounds of manual labor or retail workers and stuff like that.
were around too a lot of people whose parents didn't have much of an education and whose parents wanted them to have an education and who thought that the education was going to lead to a lot better things than they ultimately did but it's taken you know a while for me to to think about that you know we thought things couldn't get worse in the 60s but they have gotten worse and we you know we thought like The problems of racial and ethnic discrimination couldn't get worse, but in a lot of ways they have gotten worse. The neighborhood I came from was a poor neighborhood, but it was...
integrated in the sense that like I lived in a public housing project where there were people of a whole lot of different backgrounds as there were and to a certain extent continue to be in places like Yesler Terrace which is being destroyed now too and none of us considered it a really great place but things have gotten a lot worse and like the neighborhood where I grew up in Brownsville where apparently Howard Zinn grew up like 12 or 15 years before me was a neighborhood where you could get to know a lot of people from different backgrounds and but everybody was poor everybody was poor but now such A lot of people who I mentioned to don't believe that such neighborhoods ever existed. They did exist in Chicago, they did exist in New York, they did exist in Seattle, and they did exist in Detroit, and they existed in various other places. And they were never considered great places, but now people would feel a little nostalgic about being able to have associations with other people on the basis of having a certain commonality, even if you had tremendously different ethnic backgrounds.
be nice to be able to, you know, people would like to have more integrated neighborhoods. Well, I mean, not everybody, but lots of people, you know, like I would, I would, you know, like to have neighborhoods that were more integrated where I'm living here now. It's more integrated than other places, but it isn't all that, you know, there's a lot of tensions that, that even. because of the fact that there are people of different economic backgrounds, which I think is a lot harder for people to deal with. Some of my neighbors are very rich, and it's hard for them to understand those of us who maybe aren't very rich. Is that what you mean by integrated? What I mean by integrated is people from different ethnic and racial backgrounds. In other words, people living near each other and sharing situations.
Where I lived in my public housing project, one of my neighbors was an African-American family, and I used to babysit for the kid when they went out. It was a little baby. Next door was another family that was from Puerto Rico. I was friends with the girls. There were different people from different backgrounds, but we were all economically not really well off. It's harder for people to imagine that now in the sense that the way the structure of the society, it actually divides people more.
I mean, when I lived in New York in that poor neighborhood, and it was a tough neighborhood, but people knew each other. And so, like, I would walk down the street, and some guy or woman, mostly guys, would come up and bother me, and someone would walk up and say, leave her alone, she's my cousin's friend. And that happened to me many times, you know. It was a kind of a situation where people knew each other, and there was a certain amount of social solidarity that is harder, not impossible, but harder nowadays to have. It might have something to do with television.
Well, I think it has to do with a lot of things that divide us. Like what? Oh, I don't know. Identities. Well, a lot of the talk about identities, it's not that it doesn't have reality, but there is a lot of intersectionality that people aren't always thinking about. I think economic differences are also, there is a much bigger economic divide now.
between people who were not in the elite then. There was always a super elite, but yeah, I don't know. It's hard to say because none of us experience the whole society at any one time, so I wouldn't say that I know everything. I once had a conversation with Freddie Perlman, who lived briefly in New York, lived for a while in New York, pardon, New York, in Queens, in a neighborhood that was a little more... financially better off than the neighborhood I lived in. And it's like the kind of neighborhood that is depicted in letters of insurgence for the woman who lives in the unnamed country, which is usually the United States and whatever, but it's a fusion or whatever. And I grew up in a neighborhood where I didn't have a lot of contact with those kinds of people, but they were not rich or anything, but a little better off, maybe a little more like Robbie's family, like what we might say.
Lower middle class. Skilled workers or low level white collar workers. Or low level managers or small business owners or whatever. And so the conversation that we had, I forgot exactly the words, but it was something like, you know, I said to Freddie, well, you know. When I was growing up, I had little or no contact with well-off people. He said, New York is all made up of well-off people. Well, maybe you experienced it that way, but I didn't. I knew there were parts of New York where there were well-off people, but I didn't go to those parts as I was growing up. Different people experience things kind of differently because we all see little parts of the society. We can talk about the whole society, but none of us experience all the parts of the society, and I think it's gotten even more fragmented.
in many ways. I don't know. You probably experience it differently than me, too. Well, now it's different, that's for sure. Oh, yeah, absolutely. I know. I'd love to hear what you guys think about what's different and why. Do you have a sense of perspective that's invaluable? It's just that there was more slack. You could be a marginal person when we were younger. We were like 20 or 30. And there is now. Now you have to scramble just to survive. Yeah, well, that's the other thing. It's like,
You could, and I did, go on welfare in my early 20s. And I could be on welfare for a month or two. This is a time when you didn't have to be a parent or, you know, you could be a young, basically employable person. But I get to a point where I couldn't pay my rent and I could go on welfare for a month or two and then not be on welfare and then go back on welfare. There's no such thing now. There were...
Free dental clinics on the Lower East Side that you could go once a week and you didn't have to prove anything. And free women's health care clinics. And so it was a lot easier to be a peripheral person for a bunch of reasons. Definitely easier to be a person who didn't necessarily work. You could miss a few months without working a job and pick up money from the state without having to fill out 90 forms, although it wasn't fun, but it could be done a lot easier now. If you're a single person with no kids, it's a lot harder to get money to just survive. And I didn't have to go into debt to go to college. Maybe if I had wanted to go to a really prestigious school.
But even then, I could have gotten, there were more scholarships around then. So I lived for years as an artist model, a figure model. You know, you get like 13 bucks an hour. In those days, it was a lot of money. So now, probably, I don't know, they may still pay a few people, but I'll bet there's more competition. Right. We had lots of friends that did indexing. Yeah, right there, indexing. At the end of that, with a computer, does the indexing now. You know, for books, they would just, with cards, they would read a book and do all the indexing of a book. And they'd get like 10 cents a line. They'd get paid by the line. And they could do it in their, you know, at home. They could.
It's a great buy, but it's the kind of job that doesn't even exist anymore, I'm sure. And rents were cheap, too. Rents were a lot cheaper. We had rent control in New York. We were paying like $55 a month for an apartment in Manhattan. But we were making $55 a week, so it wasn't like... New York for a month? Yeah, that was expected. They always said, you should pay only a quarter of your income for rent. Now they say a third. That's the routine thing. Probably most people can't do that now.
And then Ravi and I were part of a little food co-op, so it was like 10 families. And so once a week, we would take turns taking one car and go up to the wholesale market in the Bronx and walk around early, go up there real early and walk around and get the best buys of the fresh fruits and vegetables at the wholesale prices, fill up the car, and then go to the yogurt factory where they gave away the yogurt that they hadn't sold in the store. It was misprinted on the container or something. So they'd give it to us. We could fill up the car. And they also, what was those nuns used to go there and get it? People used to go there to this yoga factory. It was funny because one guy had a car. It was a really beautiful purple car, but it was small. It was like a sporty car. And we had these yogurt containers up to the ceiling. We were just totally packed in with those yogurt containers and the produce stuff. So then we used to go home and we'd sort it out. Put it out in the hall and sort it out into 10 divisions. And that was really inexpensive. Yeah, of course.
$15 a week or something for food. Yeah, I don't even remember how much, but it was a little work, but it was pretty neat. Yeah, that strikes me. It's so different to hear you talk about that kind of food co-op to the type of co-ops that exist now, like PCC or REI or something that really just resemble corporations. Yeah, yeah. Well, there was one, too. It was called Co-op America, and you could go in there and buy some of the kinds of things that you can buy in the PCC or the central co-op, but we would get our own stuff even cheaper. It was a big one. I don't know if it even is around now. They were just supermarkets. They might have actually given out, what do you call it?
dividend every year or something. But when you shopped at it, it was no different than a regular store. Well, that was owned by the Painters Co-op. It was owned by the Painters Union. Yeah, but it just basically looked like and was essentially a supermarket. But it was cheaper, and it did have higher quality food, but we did better than that on our own. So we couldn't get like soap powder in the Hunts Point Market. But yeah, so there was a lot of that kind of stuff. So people doing that kind of stuff a lot.
But it was easier to survive, I would say. It's not impossible to survive now, but it was easier to survive. And there were other kinds of jobs around that weren't, you know, waiting on tables or, you know, in a coffee shop or something. There were a lot of different, I mean, when I was in high school, I worked in a candy factory. you know, wrapping the candies on the line. And when I was in college and between college, I worked in a film packaging factory, packaging film for cameras and stuff, you know, that was before digital stuff. And I also, I actually sold cosmetics door to door and then in factories. Well, that didn't last too long because the guy who was the manager didn't want women doing that.
I did it with this one guy. We went to the factories. And that was interesting because we'd go there. You could work a whole day and maybe make $10 or $15 a day going door to door, which I did for a few months. And then this guy invited me to go with him to the factory, which is mostly what the guys had been doing. So you'd go in only on the lunch hour. You'd go to a factory. And if you sold to one person, then all the people in the factory would buy. And it was interesting to me because I saw the garment factories where my mother had worked.
and stuff like that. But when I went there, there were a lot of people from Puerto Rico and China working there instead of Eastern Europeans. It was an interesting thing. And then you could make like $100 in a day. But then the manager found out that I was doing it and he said he didn't want any women doing it. The guy had invited me because we could sell more together. I talked to the guys and he talked to the women. This whole thing. And, you know, you could get somebody, one person to buy, then the others would buy and get a lot more sales than going door to door.
But anyway, there were a lot of kind of jobs like that so that you didn't have to be somebody waiting on tables or working in a retail store necessarily. What effects have you seen the relative ease or difficulty of living have on radical activity? Because sometimes it seems like it can actually increase it because people are miserable and they want to fight back. But sometimes it can decrease it because people are just struggling to survive. It looks to me like people have less time to be together and do things together.
I think it probably makes people angrier than they would have been otherwise. But then I know a lot of younger people, especially, that I can't see them very often because they're so busy, you know. I think it's really hard to tell. I think, you know, it varies. There's so many different factors. I think there are times when people being really badly off have made them very rebellious. And there's times when, like in the 60s, they used to say, it was...
rising expectations that a lot of people not only in France and in the United States but in Mexico and in Czechoslovakia and in lots of other places were angry because they had hopes of things getting better and they weren't getting better for them fast enough so it was like people thought things were going to get better and they were anxious to take advantage of the opportunity to demand more humane conditions or more social possibilities but I think there's like such a variety of reasons that it's hard to say. You know, I think that that was even supposedly, and it's hard to say because there's always mixed motives, but some people felt like that was part of what was happening with the ghetto riots too in the 60s, of which there were a lot of, that people had greater hopes that they could feel that things were getting better in some sense, or they expected that they should be getting better because there's more wealth to go around.
I think there's lots of reasons. There's just so many reasons why people rebel, you know, because they experience police brutality, because they experience a little bit of social possibilities and they want more. I think you can look and see times when things have been more repressive, when people have rebelled more, and times that have been less repressive, times that are more impoverished, and times that are less impoverished, both. I remember thinking, like, during the times when there was the Soviet Union and the Western Bloc, and saying, well, if the Soviet Union ever disintegrates, then we'll really have it made, because everybody will see how this world capitalism sucks, you know, and we'll all, there'll be a revolt and everything will be fine. It didn't happen. I thought it might. I mean, it seemed like it did happen in a minor way. It was sort of like happening in Poland in the 80s, it started.
and in the late 80s and some of that looked a little hopeful but then uh i don't know people just weren't ready to go all the way like you know like in russia people there they even had memories of the magnavis and grunstadt they had some actual memories of that and anarchist movement did pick up there a lot but it's just going against centuries of repressive culture too you know the same crap is still with us those religions and um hierarchies patriarchy all that kind of stuff is still pushing back pretty heavily Can't make excuses, though. We just have to keep going forward and figure what the next step is. Yeah. I'm thinking about...
dovetailing off of the conversation about sort of how people individually get by, but about how I feel like in the anarchist movement I'm constantly around sort of brainstorming sessions of, okay, how do we get money for, you know, the publication we want to do, or how do we fundraise for this anarchist project? And, you know, there are kind of a few go-tos that we have, you know, do a benefit show or do this. Have you seen them change over time? Were there, like, sort of fundraising sources people had in the past that you don't see around, or are there new things that are exciting to you? I think that always there was fundraising. For a lot of the things that I was involved in and a lot of the things in Detroit, for example, the assumption was that people would take the money from their own pockets if they could and never expect to make much money and do fundraising as they could. I think people felt, as they do now, that it's really hard to get other sources. Obviously, there's things like...
Black Coffee that tried making some money in one way, or like in the 1990s, what was that, the Black Cat? Black Cat Cafe. Cafe in the U District where people really worked hard and ended up getting burnt out, but had a very nice cafe for a while. I think nicer, actually, than Black Coffee because it didn't have some of the problems of the Capitol Hill neighborhood. So you didn't have all sorts of weird people coming in.
causing conflicts, which did happen in Black Coffee, as well as having interesting people and, you know, interesting events. But for the most part, I think the thrust has always been either it comes out of your pocket, or maybe it comes from a fundraiser, or maybe it comes every once in a while from a donation, but you can't necessarily count on any individual or groups of donations. You keep on asking, but you don't expect it to be anything there. But I think the difference was that certainly in the 60s and the 70s, the problem of rent wasn't as big as it is. And certainly in some places, even in New York for a while, the problem of rent wasn't as big as it is now. There were a few places that you could have venues, even if you didn't entirely agree with them. Like in New York, we had a building owned by the War Resisters League, but anarchists could have meetings there and a few other.
places that were like that. In Detroit, the rents were generally low. Things could be gotten along on a shoestring for quite a while. Yeah, some things, I think a lot of it is similar. Trying to think about what kind of projects people might have.
In a way, in some ways, it was harder. People would do films. That was a big deal compared to nowadays. Sylvia and I were among the first people to do videotape. Black and white half-inch tape we did in the mid-'70s. Yeah, we didn't have the equipment. No, we had a place we could borrow it for free. It was neat. We took it with a big shopping cart. It was portable, but you couldn't carry it. Yeah, they trained us. They showed us how to use it. And then afterwards, they let us use an area where we could do editing on it and stuff. But that was some kind of foundation. It was called Merck Media Equipment Resource Center.
And anybody could go there and borrow that stuff. I guess they had it here in Seattle in the Community Access TV station. That may still exist, I don't know. But it was the kind of thing where you could go and make your own TV show once a week or whatever you want. What did you make? Well, a few things. I made some free-form kind of impressionistic, actually it was around the World Trade Center when it was first built. I walked around with this equipment and took videos from different angles and the traffic coming and going through it. We had been very much opposed to the building of the World Trade Center, as were a whole lot of other people, and that was part of the reason that you did that, I remember. We thought it was a big danger. It was built in a way that really and truly, with the outsides hanging on the...
the wall the outside walls hanging in a way that was new in terms of architecture and a lot of people felt that it it was a danger to the neighborhood and indeed when it was up when those buildings were up when the wind blew they moved a few feet four or five feet in each direction. So they weren't exactly fully safe buildings. A lot of people were very angry and didn't want those buildings there to begin with. But that's why I remember that's why you did that. Yeah. Yeah. No, I don't know what happened to him. I lost this stuff. We did an interview with Sam and Esther Dolgoff, too. I gave it to him. Yeah, we gave it to Benny. Yeah, this guy in Michigan who we thought was an anarchist librarian. He is. He's still around. He loses stuff, too. But we can't get it back for a copy. I can get in contact with him.
I wrote to him. I even talked to him on the phone a few times. Yeah, we can try. So, but anyway. He may have given it to a Labrador. I hope he gave it to a real library. Yeah. But that's what I was reminded of. There was certain ways you could, some projects were more complicated. You know, printing was a lot more complicated, but a lot of people figured out how to do it. Now it's very simple. I mean, to do it right takes something.
some acuity, some creativity now. But there were things like that. So like in New York, there was, what was it, the press? What was that called? Community Press. Community Press. It's like C-O-M-E, exclamation point, Unity Press is what it was called. And you could go in there and teach you how to do printing. So we did. We went and printed pamphlets and stuff. And in Detroit, Freddie and Lorraine Perlman developed the Black and Red Co-op where people could go in and learn to run the presses and then run off their own stuff with other people's help.
Trying to think about what the difference might be in terms of money. I think it might be analogous. It might be similar. Nobody ever has enough to do what they want. But maybe people want to do different kinds of things. I notice people go to China now and do interviews in China. That must cost a lot of money. But then maybe they have people that are willing to fund that separately. Yeah, it was interesting to hear you say that there was a struggle against the building of the World Trade Center. I have no idea. Yes, there was. I'm wondering if you have any other stories about struggles that were happening that maybe had been lost or forgotten.
Well, I know one thing I had in Detroit was this huge fight against an incinerator that went on for like 20 years. Is that the incinerator that I think now exists? I think there's a struggle to tear it down. Oh, I think so. I think I read something recently about that. They're worried that what's going to be left there is totally toxic and can't be cleaned up ever or something like that. Maybe the same one. It may be different, too. There may be several. Detroit being what it is. But it was this thing like a lot of people...
know very radical people and very mainstream people just were against it you know and they got out there and fought the cops and law you know they just went on for years and years and i think they lost i think it was i think that oh you know what it is in detroit now that i remember there's a thing that they want to enlarge that's an existing uh kind of toxic reprocessing center that's in a kind of black neighborhood but they're going to expand it like 10 times of size and just you know make it worse so that's what that's what i heard about recently and um trying to figure out what the different fights were in the 70s. Well, anti-nuclear took up in the mid to late 70s. There was demonstration kind of things, occupations and things like that. They weren't anarchists per se. They left us things that a lot of people did.
And there's a lot of involvement, I know, of the pacifist crowd in that anti-nuke stuff. I feel like that's what gets recorded historically, but was there also an elements that you can talk about? Yeah, well, there's something in the Fifth Estate about the people we knew in Boston that got involved with the Seabrook stuff. They were anarchists, and they were not pacifists, and they had their run-ins with the consensus crowd who tried to just keep them out of decision-making, basically, and not let much happen. So there's, I don't know, what would be the easy way to find Rudy's article. Oh, I know where it is. I know, but in terms of if they wanted to look for a subject that where anarchists were active in the 70s. I can send it to you. I can send you. It's online. It's online. I can send you the information. But basically, the way I experienced, there were...
at least as many people who were not pacifists, and maybe more than pacifists, but some people were very impressed with the pacifists. But I don't agree with everything that Murray Buchan has written or said, but he also, as well as the people that we knew in Boston, wrote about the problems of relating to the pacifists who basically made themselves in charge of the Seabrook struggle and didn't want to... allow other people to have as much of a say in it and sort of monopolize. They became the spokespeople for it. But in general, yeah, they are, they are.
The pacifists weren't this dominant. There were a lot of people who weren't pacifists around. The anarcho-syndicalists in New York and Chicago and the Bay Area and Seattle were not pacifists, although there were anarcho-pacifists too. Some of the people here in Seattle and in all these other places were definitely pacifists, but they were far from the only people. who were, you know, involved. And interestingly, some of the people who were pacifists, like Dave Dellinger, ended up being pacifists at home, but sort of like, not exactly, but sort of like people like Chris Hedges saying, oh, but the Cuban Revolution is fine. And oh, but this other, you know, these other struggles that are not pacifists, they're fine for those people who are poor people in other countries. But here in the United States, we really...
I think the pacifist ideas are the best. So, you know, there was a whole, you know, big debate about that at the beginning of the 60s where there were some anarchists who... were identifying with the Cuban anarchists who had fought, as a matter of fact, several of them, quite a few of them, in the mountains with the people around Castro and also a lot of them who were involved in supporting from within the cities. But then when the Castro regime came to power, they repressed those people and they repressed the independent union movement and they repressed the cooperatives and stuff like that.
But people like Dave Dellinger said, still, it was a wonderful revolution. And that's, you know, for poor people, you have to understand that it has to be that way. And there was a big debate in Liberation magazine between several anarcho-syndicalists. And actually, I think David Week, who was a pacifist, but who came out and said that he did not think that the Castro regime should be glorified. Maybe it wasn't as bad as the Stalinist regime, but it doesn't mean that it wasn't authoritarian.
uh yeah so in a certain way a lot of these arguments that that go on now have a long history too and i think it'd be hard to quantify but most of the people that i hung out with were not pacifists yeah it's interesting you talk about the dynamics around the cuban revolution where they're can you talk more about dynamics of how anarchists related to or anti-authoritarians related to the you know authoritarian or communist regimes abroad where the party is here yeah well that's very interesting see like one of the things that as i said growing up i always wondered why so many of the people that i knew who were you know working adults didn't like the communist party i didn't understand because they seemed a little better than most of the capitalists that I knew, but I also had a sense that my family and people I knew didn't like the communists either. And then as I got to know anarchists, I understood better what that was about. But there always has been this kind of split.
I think more of the anarchists were critical of the Soviet Union. Some anarchists became enthralled with Maoist China because it seemed more populist, even though the glorification of central authority and the Cuban situation like split people a lot. But Robbie and I, as I said, we knew Sam Dolgo and the people around the Libertarian Forum who were very supportive of the Cuban anarchists. And we actually... had a lot of discussions with them about that in the late 60s and we learned about the debates that had gone on earlier at the beginning of the 1960s which i hadn't known about at the time because they were mostly in liberation magazine which i hadn't been reading but um then we uh read some stuff and then uh sam dogoff gave us the names of some cuban anarchists that we went out to visit in in miami and we found out that not all of the the the people in exile from cuba were
you know, right-wingers, that there were in fact people who were not right-wingers there. So it was an interesting kind of experience for us. So there was generally a lot of discussion and some people were clearer about it. A lot of the people in SDS were very enthusiastic, not among the anti-authoritarians that I knew, most of whom recognized what the problem was, but a lot of the people in SDS were very enthusiastic, and I remember feeling really angry. because I had some people who I was on friendly terms with, who went down to volunteer to help do the harvest with the Vincent Amos Brigade, and they came back with these wonderful stories. It's really wonderful. The young people there, the guys have to shave their beards, even though a lot of the guys in the United States considered wearing a beard to be, you know, a sign of rebellion.
didn't want anybody to tell them how long their hair should be or whether they should have a beard or anything. But, of course, in Cuba, you know, it's a society in construction. And, you know, the young people weren't allowed to do this and that. And here these Americans and Europeans are going there to help bring in the harvest. And they can do anything they want. They were putting people in jail if they wore a beard. Because only the top level of the revolution was allowed to wear beards. Right, right.
Right. And, you know, it wasn't until the early 70s that there began to be any criticism of the regime's attitude toward and treatment of gay people when some of the most prominent gay intellectuals and artists fled Cuba and started talking about it. But a lot of people didn't want to hear when the anarchists were talking about that earlier, you know. But it was something that I think some people who would consider themselves anti-authoritarians were very enthralled by the idea of... a successful revolution. And I think that's like with respect to China and Cuba, not so much with respect to the Soviet Union. It was also a lot of people were very uncomfortable with, you know, how people should understand the developments in Czechoslovakia in 1968 and 69. Like here we are involved in our own rebellions. And should one accept that or be critical of how the Soviet regime crushed those people? And so there was a lot of discussion on the left. And I don't know.
What can I say? Anarchists, people who consider themselves anarchists, have had all sorts of ideas. So some have been more influenced by Maoism and by authoritarianism, and some less so. I think at any one time, you'll always see more and less critical thinkers. I remember being so appalled. I haven't looked lately, but in the 80s, there used to be a lot of anarchist households that had big Che Guevara posters. I don't get it. These are people, they just like the romance of the revolution, but they didn't obviously look into who Che Guevara was.
or what he said about anarchists or wanted to kill him basically. So I think at any one time you're always going to have people who are more or less understanding of the meanings of some of these symbols and realities behind them. Yeah, and even with respect to Vietnam, I remember never wanting to say that I was for the victory of the North Vietnamese. I was not for the victory of the United States government by any means, but I felt like it's a question of why should they have to accept one dominator over another dominator? That seemed to me to be really clear, but there were some people who would consider themselves anti-authoritarian who were saying that they were for the victory of the North Vietnamese government.
It's never been clear-cut, but I'll say that among some of the anarcho-syndicalists, some of the positions that they took that I admired were their positions against the authoritarians in the different countries like that. Did you ever hear of Angogl Boulevard? Angogl? No. Well, this group actually still exists. It's called Neither East Nor West, and they would do...
supplement if sometimes it was in the fifth estate and it would be in various different magazines and mostly in the 80s and 90s that they're coming back now they're supporting you know there's new groups of anarchists in Cuba so they're supporting them they're basically were published in the 80s 90s they were publicizing what was going on in the eastern you know in Russia and Eastern Europe a lot So that's a good thing to follow up. I don't know how much of that's on the internet, actually. Some of it was in the Fifth Estate. What other? It was in the Anarchy magazine. Yeah, but no, there's an article about neither East nor West and a few issues back in the Fifth Estate. And neither East nor West is named after something that Marie-Louise Benary said.
The daughter, what's her name? Camila Beneri, who was an Italian anarchist who was an anti-fascist and went to Spain and was killed by Stalinists in Spain. But she immigrated to first, I guess, France and then Britain and was involved in Freedom Press. And before and during World War II, she and the people around the Freedom Press took the position of neither East nor West. And also, not for the Nazis or the capitalists, but not for the...
the authoritarian Stalinist, and her position was... If you have to choose, it's like choosing between cholera and the plague. And I admire her very much. She was a very articulate woman, wrote several things, wrote a lot of things for the magazine. We reprinted a tribute to her. I'll give it to you later on. I think I have an extra copy of that. It's online, too. Yeah, she's a very interesting kind of woman. And she was also involved in the support of the Spanish Revolution. But it's always been...
really difficult that people have to figure out for themselves and discuss about each situation. So like now, it's like discussing about what's going on in Rajra. Like, you know, is it a question of people organizing on a local basis and working things out and how... how much does that count, and how much does it count that they have to study the works of Akalan one or two hours a day, and the pictures of him appear everywhere, and that when people are interviewed, they always have to quote what they learned from him and stuff like that. So the question is, how do you weigh and decide which is important, and how do you decide how important that is to you? Maybe you'd say, well, this is really great that's happening there, and I certainly would rather see them not be crushed between...
the Western powers and the Russians and the Turkish government and ISIS and all that. But do I want to say that they are they have the society that I admire, which, you know, I think I think that's. Those kind of questions come up all the time, you know, whenever we have insurgencies in different places. It's very hard to say. There were debates, although I think by the 50s and the 60s, there were very few, very, very, very few anarchists who would be supportive of the Soviet Union. But some might be supportive of Maoist China, and more would be supportive of Cuba, and some would be supportive of the Vietnamese struggle and the Vietnamese government.
there would be, at anti-Vietnam War demonstrations, there would often be a contingent of anti-war vets, and they would be primarily taking neutralist, kind of pacifist positions, a lot of those vets, although not all of them, by any means, but that would be what would show the most. And then there would be, in the front of the march, usually these people carrying the North Vietnamese flag and chanting, ho, ho, ho, shiman. NLF is going to win. Right. And then, of course, the NLF being subverted by the North Vietnamese, like is discussed in the crossfire.
Yeah, and then there would be those of us further back who didn't want to associate with that, who certainly weren't wishing for the United States government to win, but didn't feel like we wanted to identify with that. There's an interesting book called Eyes to the South that talks about the anarchists in France with relation to the Algerian War, how they all had their different takes on it. That's kind of instructive. It's not something that we had directly, it was a little before our time, but it's pretty relevant. Yeah, there's a lot of splits and discussions.
Even among the non-pacifists. There were some pacifists that took principled things against all wars, but some of the pacifists wound up going with the people that became the government later on in Algeria, which isn't good. Sylvie touched on it a little bit. I wondered if you had any thoughts about Rojava and Ocalan. Well, I mean, I always pushed in my mind, I always thinking toward a better world or a better way to understand things. And I'd say to myself, if I was there, I wouldn't just read one guy's writings or just recite any one person's stuff. I mean, even if you agree with some of Mary Bookchin, you have to kind of wonder, is he the only anarchist that ever lived? Actually, I don't know that they know he's an anarchist. But regardless. No, it's Akelon who they constantly cite. That's what I mean. No, I'm saying this. They don't cite Bookchin themselves. They just...
have the retail version from him and so so then you kind of wonder if we're making a free society why aren't we making our own theory we're making our own ideas so we're just kind of repeating somebody else's but um it's really a hard decision i'm not going to actually take this super hardline and condemn, you know, and say, don't support them because they're not perfect, but just fervently hope that they learn more and more. But I must say, as I keep reading, I don't sense them taking in more things. More people are going there. You can see more and more reports of anarchists who go there and come back and talk about it, but you don't get an impression that, for example, do any of these mass meetings that equally include men and women actually discuss concretely things other than Okolan?
Oh, yeah, they discuss it with the local. No, I mean, in terms of ideas, I understand. They have a structure that they claim is much better than what they had before. Yeah, I guess we're always on the spot as far as support or non-support, critical support. Yeah, we don't want to be duped or betrayed by another revolution. Well, that's like what happened in Algeria. It became a military dictatorship. A lot of the people actually helped support the military and it looked the other way when the civilian Algerians were killed off by the military rivals and stuff like that. Yeah, how do you understand what a...
Or like what you had said about Russia, you know, after the fall of the wall and the crumbling of the Soviet Union, a lot of the people who would consider themselves anarchists were outmaneuvered. A lot of them had very strong feelings about what they would like to see happen, but didn't know how, and I'm not sure I would have known how, to deal with the situation, to be able to... push back against the authoritarian capitalists who took over. Well, you can even look here right now. We're in a potentially explosive social situation, and I don't know why we're not going to be. I think we're very likely to be outmaneuvered if people don't get together and start thinking more about what they want individually and as a group.
work out some framework of understanding, not just a way to talk to the media, but to talk to each other, to talk to ourselves. I think there's a lot of good stuff, a lot of good potential in the background, things that you can read in Crime Think or in the Fifth Estate. It's not like it's an intellectual desert here. We have lots of ideas and people have actually learned a lot about history, the lessons of history. But it'll be a big plus when people start.
you know, concentrating more on what might be necessary to keep from being outflanked. But in other words, the situation can get worse and worse. And a lot of people, as I say, are in motion. People are going to find real reasons to revolt. And so wouldn't it be nice if we could have something that goes in the right direction for a change? I was wondering if either of you had any stories or examples of ways that anti-authoritarians or anarchists have responded to moments of repression and arrests, jail support, things like that.
Well, I know that in the 70s here, I wasn't here, but I've been told by lots of people, when they're aware of the grand jury investigation, particularly during the second one later in the 70s, there were a lot of several young single mothers who were called before the grand jury and who refused to testify to give information. about different radical activity in this area, and by getting together they were able to withstand it. But in both cases, and in lots of other cases, it seems like really hard for people to hold together after that. As here, a lot of people sort of slow down and...
step back for a while and they come back but the repression is like a really scary thing for most of us so I think the history has been that there have been some people who were very stalwart despite the repression and then some people who get very scared and disappear for a few years and then come back and then some people who disappear and you never see them again so it's just really hard I guess that's one of the reasons that I find people like Frederico Arcos who just died in his partner who died in the 90s, Pura Arco, really neat people because of the fact that they not only were involved in the Spanish Revolution, but that they continued to fight against the Francoist regime afterwards. And Federico actually going into the mountains in the anti-Franco fight for a while, and Pura even right after the defeat.
continuing to do prison support from inside Spain for a few years. And it was dangerous for them. They missed their lives. Yeah, they could have been killed, you know. And so, and several of their friends were. So it's really difficult. So like after 68, there was this big upsurge and everybody hoped that things would go much further than they did. I knew at least 20 people.
who committed suicide after things sort of calmed down. There were still things happening. I mean, there were several strikes of different sorts that we considered could be really significant, but the high pitch, the very hopeful tone of what was going on in 68 in so many parts of the world sort of died back, and some people just became despairing, and some people dropped out. A lot of people didn't, a lot more than... Then their claim didn't, but there were people, I'm sure there were more than 20. These are just people who I knew who committed suicide. So I think it's not really easy, although there are definitely, you know, people who continued and didn't allow things to...
to depress them. But I guess it's like the co-ops, you know, the small co-ops, the different projects, the printing projects, the theater and stuff. That's the way I think that generally people have gotten through the repressive time by different creative activities like that. So like the printing co-op would publish. information to remind people about the good times and about the revolutionary times. But also it was something to do. Yeah, right. But the content served the form. The form was doing things together, but it wasn't just like bridge parties. It was doing revolutionary literature. But also it was like something you could do that wasn't being in the streets. But that still had some significance to it. And then really, like around here, that's when Books to Prisoners started in the early 70s.
Did the Books to Prisoner Stark before Left Bank? No, around the same time. Yeah, I think it did at 73. But there were a lot of little co-ops around here, too, and a lot of cooperative exchanges between all the little co-ops, different small-scale things. Like the people in Left Bank have stories where they would just trade books for everything, food, you know, like haircuts, bread. They're different. There were so many co-ops all over. They had this informal network. I remember even when we first came here, they would get people to bring pizza, different things.
the other co-ops, you know. So that was a thing that really worked for a while. And were you two involved in the beginning of Left Bank? No, not the very beginning. We knew them at the time. Yeah, we knew them when we were in New York. That's one reason we came here. We knew them in the late 60s, 70s, but we didn't come here until 81. So Left Bank started earlier than that. But we've talked with a lot of the people who were in on the beginning, both formally and informally. We moved in with them. Yeah, when we first came to Seattle, we were invited to stay in the group house of nine people, and I guess eight out of nine were involved in Left Bank in person.
I think things could be a lot worse now, even though people individually don't feel a little upbeat after the times of the 2010 to 2013. But there's still a lot of, there's still Danica's Black Cross and people aren't stopping. So maybe they just need to keep doing or do more of the same, you know, like what you're doing is great. Just pick it up and then something will come from that. Kind of a related question. I just know a lot of...
people that were anarchists in their 20s and then sort of stopped. And I was just wondering if you had anything to say about how you managed to be an anarchist for so long. I didn't become an anarchist until I was 40. That's the trick, see? Don't bother when you're 20. Keep skateboarding until you're 40. But you mean you didn't call yourself. Oh, I'm sorry. Yeah, that's true.
I guess my answer is I didn't see any choice, actually. I don't know. It's really hard for me to say. I do know that there's a lot more people around who are our age and in their 60s and 50s who have remained anti-authoritarian in one way or another, although they might not be involved in the same projects that they were involved in in the past, but who come out when there are big things happening. Part of it, I think, is what draws you to it. This is not a judgment, but it's very hard for me to understand people who come to anarchism from, let's say, the punk music scene or something. Whereas I came to it for social economic reasons. So that's why it's not that I don't like music, but it wasn't music that drew me to it. I don't know why people don't stick around, but it may be that those people who don't stick around will turn up later again. It may very well be that...
you'll see them again at some point but it also is like what kind of alternatives do people have are they you know why were they involved and what do they think were they involved because they thought there was going to be a big victory and once there was no big victory they're looking for something else or what was it that they were involved in and you know I don't know. I think it's really hard to say because it's obviously different for different people. There are some people who sort of flake off because they've gone and had children. And some people say, well, kids take up a lot of your time. But then I also know some people who had children and stuck with it, you know, and continue to be involved. And I think it's also true that people aren't going to always be involved in the same way. So I'm not going to be running in the streets the way I was in my 20s and my 30s because, first of all, I don't see now and I used to see them. But secondly, I think...
I wouldn't necessarily feel that I'm in a good position to do that. And I'm not always sure whether those kinds of demonstrations will result in a whole lot after they're over because I was through a lot of them and came out the other side and they didn't. But I'm not the person to say don't have those demonstrations because I know that sometimes they could lead to something that I wouldn't expect too. But I don't know. I guess it depends on a whole bunch of things, but also that you can't tell. I mean, wait until you're 50 and see.
who came around with the next insurgency. You know what I'm saying? We went to the celebration of the 50th anniversary of the Fifth Estate in Detroit. There were hundreds of people there from our age on down. So in talking to them, you see they're doing lots of interesting things, even if they're not in any particular anarchistic thing.
One guy I was talking to, I didn't know him personally, but because of working on the archives, I know what he wrote in the 60s. He came back and he counsels, he's a psychological counselor for vets in Detroit. So he's still an anarchist. He's just not making that history directly. I think there's a big difference between people who actually fade or people who actually turn around and become authoritarians. And I think there's not many. I think, as I think back about the ones that I knew, who I know a little bit now, very few of them are...
basically different people they're just in different parts of their lives and some of it might be different if the surrounding conditions were different if there was some more that they could get involved in actual ongoing revolt you know what the revolt against i guess well even in terms of like different activities so i know somebody who was involved in the student activities in Montreal a few years ago and she visited here in Seattle and she talked about how tired people got doing different things and having to take care of so many different functions of the what was going on with the rebellion and so I asked her said well did you think of like enlisting some people who might not be in the streets to help with some of the other stuff getting them involved in a way that you know respectful meaningful way and she said no you know so all the people like who are doing some of these things, if people aren't going to push themselves forward, they may feel like they're not necessarily welcome. I think Robbie and I, maybe, you know, we show up a lot of places that other people our age or a little younger wouldn't because they don't feel welcome. And why did we? Because we're very interested to see what's going on. And if people are welcoming to us, we're very happy. And if they're not, we could be a little unhappy about it. But there are some people who feel like, oh, no one's going to want to talk to me. They're all only in their 20s. They don't care about somebody like me. So I think...
that's the problem and also like in terms of music music is a very funny thing because before like the 50s and 60s there wasn't necessarily that big a difference between the what different generations liked for music but now there's a really big difference so lots of times when there's parties there'll only be certain kinds of music playing that i'm not totally enthusiastic about so i might go to talk to some of the people but not stay around for all the music because i'm not that excited by it and i have said to people in different places like at left bank why don't you have a party with a variety of music so that from for different generations you know so we can mix it all up and that well that's not as interesting or you know well nobody comes around why should we you know do that so it's uh i think there's a few different reasons but um some people drift away because there's different things happening in their lives and it doesn't necessarily mean that they stop being anarchists or anti-authoritarians and some people drift away because they feel like
as they get older that they're less and less part of the social scene. There's a few different aspects that probably things could be made a little... more integrated. That's the nice thing about a lot of the older cultures, like the Spanish anarchists and the Italian anarchists and some of the earlier anarchists here in this country, too, where they made it a point to have dinners every month and different social events that people of different generations were involved in. When Robbie and I were in New York, I don't know what it's like now, but when you used to go to the Libertarian Forum once a month and there would be a kind of discussion, somebody would give a talk and then there would be discussion and there would be people of several generations there and then you could talk to the people and get to know different people.
that way because it was a context that people who were older and younger could both feel comfortable in. So I think that happens less here now, not just Seattle. Maybe it happens a little more in San Francisco, although since I haven't been there a whole lot, it's hard for me to say. I don't think it happens in Detroit right now or the Detroit area right now, that there's a lot of different contexts where people of different generations come together. I was wondering if anybody wanted to talk more about your involvement in the state and some of the history of that. So let's see, currently,
We're both editing. We're both part of the editorial collective. And like we said before, we have been reading it since it started being a radical paper in the 70s. We're trying to keep it on a high level. Good ideas and nice presentation. And we're hoping that people keep it going in different forms. As time goes on, different groups of people can take it over.
You have one copy. We don't have the copies to give away yet, but we have this most recent issue that just came out. It has an article by Peter Gilderleus about the Spanish groups in California who are working on developing solidarity actions, as he calls anarchist infrastructure. Maybe you've seen some of that stuff talked about. We're working to try and we want to have people, different generations involved because it's...
it's an interesting thing it is a paper that has been around a long time and has a lot of people who subscribe to it and also sometimes in some places like here we give some away and uh it can have not all the articles anybody's going to be interested in but it can have a variety of articles and even some different perspectives that make it possible to to have to fill gaps that papers that might be more focused in one direction or another might not fill and it's definitely not an academic journal we're hoping like robbie said that that young people will be involved too, and there are some young people who have been involved over the years.
If it turns out in a few years that nobody cares, then it will stop. But it has gone 50 years and it has a big connection. And people keep on writing letters about how they find it in libraries or somebody, you know, find back issues in one place or another and they want to make comments on it and they're really clear and enthusiastic about how that it's still going. Are back issues available? Well, back issues, some are available and some people have. Yeah, there are some back issues available. The oldest ones.
We're putting online, and they're not available in paper. But people have found issues that go back 10, 15, and 20 years. Little black cart sells some. People want little black cart and look for it. But people find them, like their friends find them in their collection and pass them around. Sometimes people find them in used bookstores and stuff like that, too. Over the years, I have written several letters and articles for the Fifth Estate, some with my name and some with a variety of pseudonyms.
which I use basically because I like the idea of people reading something for what it says rather than for who wrote it. And a lot of other people have written with pseudonyms as well as their own names too. So it's also like a little game. Play, see what funny pseudonyms you can think of. So that's the other thing. But yeah, I guess a few things that we, first of all,
decided we wanted to scan and put those things online because we wanted to be able to give people a fuller idea of what actually went on in the 60s and the 70s. And so we also scanned and proofread, probably put online at least the first three issues of Black and Red that Freddie and Lorraine and some other people put out, which came out before the Fifth State. It's in the anarchist library. Yeah, it's in the anarchist library under Black and Red. I have been annoyed for a really long time about this anarchist academic perspective, about how there really weren't very many anarchists around, and most of them were pacifists, and they're the ones that really laid the groundwork for the modern anarchist movement. Makes me want to throw something. Yeah, what was it called? Propose and... Oh, that Andrew Cornell wrote, Propose or Propose. Yeah, Propose and Depose. Yeah. And that was this whole thing. Is that the one that talks about the...
New American movement? Yeah, movement for a new society. I hardly, I vaguely remember hearing something about them, but they certainly were not particularly influential. He liked them. It's the only group he knows about. Well, he even admits there were only really 200, but he wants to say, oh, well, they influenced, and the Quakers influenced the civil rights movement, and they influenced this and that. And yes, to a certain extent, but they weren't the only ones. It's a lot more complex than that, I think. So, like, I like what Jesse Cohn talks about in Underground Passages, the different cultural and...
and social, political activities of anti-authoritarians and anarchists. Have either of you seen that? Underground Passages? It's really worth looking at. Right there, huh? Here it is. I like that book. I don't like all books, but I like that one. Anyway, it's interesting because it doesn't classify just as anarchist, but it talks a lot about anarchism as something that has a stream that runs through. Cultural resistance. Yeah, cultural. But it's not the whole story. But yeah, so anyway.
So there's two things. And then also, I wanted to have things scanned more so that more people with visual impairments could read the fifth state, which I think has had some very good stuff. If somebody didn't read it to them, they couldn't have read the earlier Fifth Estate or even now. And so I wanted to be able to make that available because there's a lot of people with disabilities of different sorts who primarily are exposed to writing and religious stuff. And I think it's not very fair, to say the least. So I decided I wanted to do that also. It's not the only reason, and it's not the main reason that I...
have been involved in you know associating with those people but i really felt like there should be more visibility of different projects so there are some other things that have been uh put online like anarcho-syndicalist review but first of all it doesn't go back as far and secondly it's more narrow than the fifth state the fifth state has had stuff by anarcho-syndical has had stuff by anarcho-primitivists and has had stuff by post-modernists and a whole bunch of different kinds of anarchists so It's much broader than, let's say, Anarcho-Syndicalist Review or The Open Road, which I think has had some stuff put up, but it's really not easily accessible. And it's also, in its own way, a little more narrow. And also, it doesn't have the same time period. It doesn't go back as far, and it's not as broad as the Fifth Estate. Because the main thing is the Fifth Estate had a lot of different participants. Yeah, I was going to say, the interesting thing about the Fifth Estate is it's a group of people that evolved over time as they got exposed to different ideas. That's true, too.
new ideas. Most magazines, you know, just have one thrust, one tendency that you can see over and over again. But if you look over time in The Fifth Estate, it started out as a pretty diverse group. And some of them were, I don't know what you call them, Groucho Marxists, kind of zany, kind of into revolt for sure, but really, you know, having fun doing it. And you see that a lot in the early issues. Then it gets more serious. Then it goes into criticisms of civilization, criticisms of organization.
different things they take up over time. Yeah, and then when, like in the 2000s, when I first moved to Pumpkin Hollow and those people sent Frag and others were involved, it was much more cultural kind of stuff. Yeah. Yeah. I think over time there's been at least a thousand, maybe more people involved in not just writing articles for the Fifth Estate, but working on doing editing stuff.
Art, a lot of different artists have contributed to their artwork too. Also, it's always had poetry and sometimes short stories and stuff in it too. And not the dullest of stuff. I mean, not like socialist realism, poetry and short stories. So now there's more than 1,200 articles online.
in the archive. The person can search, you know, you can search any name or anything you want to read about. And we're still scanning and proofreading and Robbie is still putting up more. I wonder if we could do any of them for the audio scene. You mean read them? Of course. Anyway, I'd love to. Yeah, we could, but I wonder if there are any that would jump out at you. One of my favorites that I've told people is this one about propaganda discovered in Detroit. That's sort of a play, actually. It's sort of like a play. It's just, if you just look up propaganda.
And it's just that somebody came across, they found this building, Detroit area, Detroit Auto Dealers Association. So this building has this huge da-da on it. And so they went and did a die-in in front of it and blocked the doors. They did all kinds of crazy things. But the person did a narrative of their experience. It's funny. Yeah, I mean, you just, you can, it's hard to say what would be the best kind of thing. Some of it's super serious, you can imagine, like all the discussion about.
They had this series called Swamp Fever that's basically talking about neo-primitivism, why I'm not a primitivist, or why I'm no longer a primitivist, and something that got really serious at a certain point. And in those times, like in the 80s, it was a big tabloid kind of newspaper thing. So some of those articles are actually really big. So if you were going to read it, it would take two hours to read it. Nowadays, in the magazine format, it lends itself to reading because each one is like 15 minutes or something like that.
Well, I think some longer articles, you know, things could be a little longer. Yeah. No, I'm just thinking about some of the differences. Yeah. Yeah, it depends on what you want. Like, you could think about a particular theme. Like, this theme is anti-civilization or anti-technology, and there's, oh.
There are other themes. There's the one that's in 281 that David Watson did, Triumph of Capital, which is about the end of the Soviet bloc. That's an interesting one. Triumph of Capital. There's been a few good things on education, themes, whole themes on alternative education approaches. Then there's the issue that...
the recent issue of anti-Marx that has some earlier stuff reprinted, but also some newer stuff criticizing why Marxist ideas aren't necessarily that valid anymore or ever. So there's a lot of possibility. I mean, it depends on what you would find most interesting. What would you think would be the most interesting kind of a thing? You know, like politics, there's been a lot of organization. That was a big theme in the mid-70s.
Jacques Comate, who isn't an anarchist, but had this kind of theme about all politics is a racket. So people in the physics, they hooked onto that and did some interesting work. I don't remember how much of that is online, actually. So that indirectly talks about how to create more anarchists, because it's like talking to people who don't want to be organized. It's not that they want to be scattered or disorganized. They just don't want to be manipulated into somebody else's line. Well, there's a nice thing you want to read. It's online about Vavilov, who's a Russian
What do you call that? Ethnopotanist? I don't know. He was a geographer, sort of like Kropotkin more recently, though, like in the 20s and 30s. And so kind of corroborates the kind of things that Kropotkin was talking about. Mutual aid being a healthy thing, healthy social development.
in terms of evolutionary survival kind of stuff. That's in the Fist of State? Yeah, remember? That's Jeff Hall. Oh, okay. Oh, yeah, that's right. I forgot what the title is, but if you look up Vavilov, V-A-V-I-L-O-V. Or G-E-O-F-F. Jeff Hall. Yeah. There's a...
a drop-down list of authors for the fifth estate. So if you ever see a person's name of an author that you want to see more of what they wrote, you can find it by going in. So now that's a person, Jeff Walls, a person that we know from way back. And he is very interested in anarchist ideas and involved in a lot of things. But then he, he's not burnt out, but he went off and became very interested in ecological issues. And now he still visits people and he's still friends with people, but he's not as deeply involved.
We were friends with him and stayed with him in Montreal in the middle of the winter one time. We stayed all winter. We were thinking of moving to Montreal, but Montreal is a great city, but in the winter it's too cold for me. Tempty to snow. And so there's a lot of people like that, you know. Yeah, and he did a nice translation of a pamphlet about the Spanish, the dissident anarchists during the Spanish Revolution. I don't know if he did that translation or he printed it anyway.
It's called A Day, Mournful, and Three Years. It has a funny title. I think he did do that translation. It was A Day, Mournful, and Overcast. Yeah, yeah. We actually recorded it. Oh, did you? Oh, okay. It's like an autobiography. Yeah, does that have Jeff Hall's name on there? You know, I don't know if it does. I'll have to add it. Because I think there have been a few translations, but I think he did the first one. Okay. Yeah. And what is that? The Friends of Derudy? I forgot who did it. Yeah, it was one of the members of, or the account was by one of the members of Iron Colin. Okay, yeah, yeah. I remember that.
Yeah, he's done a bunch of printing. I don't know if he's done a lot lately. No, I don't think he has. I think he's done a lot lately. Yeah, that's an example of a person who you wouldn't see around a lot now, but his heart is still in the right place. I think that's the thing is that there's a lot of people who, when there's things that inspire them, are going to come around, and when there's not things that inspire them, you're not going to know they're there, but then...
That's one of the reasons some people say why some of these insurgencies can be so surprising. So like in the early and mid-1960s, people were saying, oh, there can't be any big social insurgency in the Western countries, the United States, Britain, France. These countries, people are too comfortable in them. Nothing can ever happen in those countries. It's only in impoverished countries in Africa, Asia, or Latin America that you're going to have insurgencies because people are deprived. But then, all of a sudden, we find ourselves in 1968, and everywhere, including in the most highly industrialized country, people are rebelling and really anxious to see things happening. And not just people who are, you know, well-known.
malcontents but all these people come out of the woodwork so to speak and they were really there all the time they just there wasn't something for them to uh be responding to and you know that's happened again and again in so many different places it's not just a question of spontaneous combustion but a question of whether the people are really there it's just not the situation for them Yeah, the other thing is like, it's like what happens with different events. So sometimes when you have an event in Seattle, not as many people as you would like turn out. And then sometimes like a few of the things that we had, which were poetry reading, we got a lot of people coming because a lot of people were really excited by poetry. And I was a little worried because I wanted to have poetry that was, you know, anarchist-oriented poetry, poetry of revolt. I was a little nervous. It turned out most of it really was that way, that oriented. People came and read their own stuff. Yeah, but it wasn't, you know, I was thinking, oh.
Is it going to just be that people will be coming and they're going to read stuff that's like not really, doesn't really address social solidarity and social insurgency? But it did, you know, because it was something that really struck a chord. One woman brought a poem that we actually put in The Fifth Estate that was pretty good. I'm glad we got it. Under the Wall, it's called. Yeah. I think it's in the last one. No, the one before the last one. Yeah.
I think that's the problem, that we don't have it figured out. Well, you know, the question, like Robbie said, in the 70s was the organization question. You know, like, how do you discuss, what do we want? You know, like, a lot of the council communists, anti-state communists are talking about, well, we have to have workers' councils or something like that. And a lot of the anarchists who are anarchists say, well, we have to build up revolutionary unions like the old IWW. You know, and then there were people who were saying, you know, these kinds of organizations don't necessarily...
They're not going to spark off a revolution. If there's revolutionary insurgency, these things happen, but they don't necessarily spark off revolution. You can't make it happen. It's not that easy to make it happen, even though you may like it. You can't separate a revolutionary organization from its revolutionary context. Right, exactly.
And just because you want it to be revolutionary doesn't mean it will be revolutionary. So I guess in the 80s and the early 90s, there were some people who were trying to make anarchist organizations in this area. And I went to a few of the meetings and they were absolutely boring. So I dropped down. Well, also, I think that one of the biggest challenges is to try to avoid repeating the worst of the previous attempts, you know, like the things that went wrong. Some of it's easy, like the RCP coming in and trying to take over whatever you're doing, you know, but it's subtle. Other things can be more subtle in terms of when things get moving, how to keep the momentum, you know, how to not let people be satisfied. Just keep, you know.
Never satisfied, if there's a revolution, never consider it finished. I think that's part of the problem that some people have is saying, when such and such happens, then we're okay, or it's my dream, or whatever. You have to just see it as a process, not a goal. It's interesting because I know a lot of people have been moving out to rural communities, and that is something that happened in the 70s also, that some people moved out to rural communities and then later came back to the cities because... Rural communities can be very interesting, but maybe in and of themselves, they don't necessarily lead a lot of places. But sometimes it's good to have that kind of place to go to to rest up. People keep on experimenting, but it's really hard to know. I think, you know, people were trying really hard to resist police repression and very valid action, but very few people thought that Occupy was going to develop the way it did. But then the question is to know how to be able to influence or not to, you know.
not to be swept away by Occupy. I notice at several events that I've been to in the last few years, there are a lot of people who turn up who are at Occupy. And I'm not sure if that's good or not good. I don't know how you feel about it. I haven't totally figured out it for myself. I feel you on what you just said.
Yeah, I think it's a very good kind of example. I like occupations, real occupations. I was really excited when people started occupying houses, and I wish that could have been prolonged, but I think, again, problems also. But then I know some people who were anarchists who tried to be involved in the subgroups to determine procedure or different special projects, and that also ended up not being very good. Yeah, well, see, that's the thing. That's what we've been through. I mean, Occupy is actually a good example of that. Maybe you feel like, oh, it didn't go as far as some of the things in 68 or whatever, and maybe some of its moments did. But it's always a very mixed bag and with a lot of frustrations as well as possibilities. Next time we'll get it. Well, next time you'll get something different. You won't be bored as much next time.
It's like this little story that David Watson reports about Frederico, which we also remember him saying, like that during the revolution where people were burning money and he thought he would save a few pesos so he could tell his children, you know, people actually died for this. He thought, maybe there won't be any more money. But then unfortunately, ended up that there was. They didn't burn enough. Maybe that's the answer. Just go around burning money. You don't have to do anything else.
But it was a big debate. There were people who also debated things like, you know, should you take welfare? So I did take welfare sometimes, but some people did. People were critical of that. Yeah, some people said, you know, you shouldn't take any money from the state. You know, so. Well, it's also like nowadays, you know, I was a teacher for a while. I mean, you can say you're working for the state, you know, if you're a teacher in the school, but you're helping kids, you know, you can be a better or worse teacher, or you could be a more authoritarian or less authoritarian. And then there's a whole thing about need to survive. You're going to be a good teacher or...
prison guard, you know, have a choice. Don't do the worst thing possible. But I think it's also relevant to know how to make coalitions and not get trapped by the coalitions, that the anarchists who are in the coalitions may be more willing to be cooperative than the others, may be more willing to experience diversity than some of the groups with other tendencies might be. Did either of you read that to our friends? Big pamphlet? Yeah, it's actually on the website as well. 70 pages. Yeah, some of the translations are a little glutsy, but in general it's pretty good. Yeah, there's a lot in there.