Skip to content
Saving Forest Lake - NH Secrets episode artwork

Oct 16, 2019 59 min

Saving Forest Lake - NH Secrets

from NH Secrets Legends and Lore

In 1935 New Hampshire created Forest Lake State Park. One of the original 10 state parks. On land donated by the Newell family, New Hampshire created a "little slice of heaven" for working families from the area. In the ensuing years it would become a refuge for working class families in the North Country. 396 acres of woods and trails and a beautiful North Country lake where - on hot summer days - the families of working folks could escape from the heat of a hot summer day. Many of them would pack a lunch or a picnic and rest, swim and play until mom or dad could join them after a hard days work in one of the local mills. It was - and still is- a gem in the crown of New Hampshire’s state park system. Six months ago a Vermont company announced plans to create a landfill in the Forest Lake area and a firestorm of opposition was ignited. The people of Dalton, Whitefield, Bethlehem and nearby Littleton, led by a reluctant warrior named Jon Swan. Jon had come to the North Country from Texas by way of Iraq - where he was stationed after signing up at 38 following the 9-11 attacks. After two years in Iraq Jon returned to upstate New York and finally settled with his wife in Dalton, NH where he believed he had found his "spot on the porch" to quote Carlos Castaneda.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Saving Forest Lake - NH Secrets

0:00 59:53
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Welcome to the New Hampshire Secrets, Legends, and Lower Podcast, where twice a month we explore the world of New Hampshire that lies outside of the hard news. I'm your host, Wayne King, and I invite you to join us for an adventure that will take us on a journey together to explore those things that are unlikely to make the pages of your newspaper, the waves of your radio station, or the bits and bytes of your favorite news website. Yet, for many of us, these stories will reveal what makes life here in the granite state truly worth living. Together we'll uncover some secrets, speculate on a few rumors and legends, and we'll meet the people and a critter or two, both living and long departed, who weave together the colorful tapestry of New Hampshire's past as well as some who are helping to build our future.

We'll explore places known and unknown that you will want to add to your bucket list. We'll laugh together, gasp together, and maybe even shed a tear or two. It's not only a place to go for working families to get out and have their own little piece of heaven. When I was a lifeguard out there around 4.35 o'clock, the working men would show up from the factories that were still going and also just getting out of there.

You'd see these families come up and this was so important to them. Over the years it's remained a place where working class people can come and enjoy the park. That's Gary Guido, and I'm going to introduce you to him in just a minute. In 1935, New Hampshire created Forest Lake State Park, one of the original 10 state parks in New Hampshire.

On land donated by the Newell family, New Hampshire created a little slice of heaven for working families from the area. In the ensuing years it would become a refuge for working class families in the North country, 396 acres of woods and trails, and a beautiful North Country Lake where on hot summer days the families of working folks could escape from the heat. Many of them would pack a lunch or picnic and rest, swim, and play until a mom or dad could join them after a hard day's work in one of the local mills. It was and still is a gem in the crown of New Hampshire State Park system.

Six months ago however, a Vermont company announced plans to create a landfill in the Forest Lake area, and a firestorm of opposition was ignited. The people of Dalton, Whitefield, Bethlehem, and nearby Littleton led by a reluctant warrior named John Swan. John had come to the North Country from Texas by way of Iraq, where he was stationed after signing up at age 38 following the 9-11 attacks. After two years in Iraq, John returned to the United States to upstate New York and finally settled with his family in Dalton, New Hampshire, where he believed he had found his spot on the porch to quote Carlos Castanada.

When I heard about this David and Goliath fight to protect one of the gems of the North Country, I made arrangements to visit John at Forest Lake State Park. I will get back to John in just a minute as well as the fight for Forest Lake, but I wanted to provide just a little bit of background because as I stood on the shores of Forest Lake recently with John and looked south to Mount Lafayette and Mount Garfield and the twins thinking about guiding trips in those very peaks in my own younger days. I was overwhelmed with a feeling of nostalgia and remembered that my friend Gary Giddo, whom I had met back in the days when he was a journalist for the Boston Globe, had grown up in this area as well. And I recalled his stories about working at the park as a young man and during summers while he was in college.

Today, he is a professor of journalism at the University of North Texas's Frank and Susan Mayborn School of Journalism. So I called him up to get a little bit of background color. I'm speaking with Gary Giddo, who grew up on Forest Lake for a number of years anyway, and I thought it would be fun to connect an old Boston Globe reporter with an emerging story in this area. So Gary, as I recall, you told me at one point that you actually were a lifeguard on Forest Lake for a while.

Yeah, actually that's true. I started there as a ticket taser. I had a little pick-a-booth out front. It cost 50 cents on those days for a car load to come in.

And this is 1970. And I thought it was a great job, you know, the outdoors. And then it was a perfect summer job when I went to college at Plun Estate. And every summer until 1976, 1977, I was kind of a fixture there at the park with my friend John Fogg.

He was a little thing guy who was another lifeguard there. And they let us live at the park. There's a really nice old built by the CCC and the 30s building there that had an apartment up top. John and I lived there for, I think, two summers.

And I had the park door ourselves after it closed. Nice. That was fun. Now there was a family that owned a lot of the land on the Lake originally, correct?

Yes, I'm not an expert on this. But the Newell family was a major landowner in the 30s and 40s. But they owned a lot of it. And the story goes that they wanted a road out to their property.

So they donated land to the State of New Hampshire, the Belmont State Park, with the Quid Pro Quail of the Guggenys Road out there. And there's a new lane that is on the road. And also there was a famous, and everybody in the White Mountains knows about it, of a certain age about newls, because you see that which was a music venue right on the water built up on some stilts and had a big old dance hall. And any given Friday and Saturday night in the early 70s, in and up to the late 70s, you could hear a lot of interesting greats.

In fact, a band that predated Aerosmith that Steve Tyler was in played there quite a bit. And it just had a great place to go out there and listen to rock and roll. Now, before that, I think they did orchascoze in the whole bit. And I'm talking in the 70s, it was a rock and roll kind of place.

Is that building still in existence or is it? No, I don't believe so. I don't believe it's there anymore. I think it was taken down or burned down years ago.

And does the Newell family still own land on the lake or have? I believe so. Yeah, I think the family, I think the family still has some of the late that they enjoy. Do you know what the road that actually leads to the State Park, is that the road that the state built in order to?

Yeah, South Canadian Highway. Yeah. And it's got to be. So it's now dotted with signs opposing the landfill and a number of homes along there as well.

Sure. Well, when I was a kid up in that era, a lot of folks in from Whittleton and Whitefield had very decent camps on the lake. I mean, these were just two season camps. And some of them had taken water out of the lake.

I mean, it was very basic, basic camps just the way it would be in the old days. And after the 70s and 80s, you know, people started moving out there more and more full time. So now they go out to the lake. You'll find remnants of the smaller camps or the big old large ones with families had, you know, but now basically pine camps.

And then now you're going to see full season, all season homes out there, repeat what gone out there and they're there. And what town did you grow up in? In Bethlehem. In Bethlehem.

Yep. It was about a five mile bicycle ride to the park. And then when I got older, I was able to get a motorcycle which made it a little bit easier. But as the crow flies, it's considerably closer, correct?

Oh, sure. I think I don't know what the boundary is, but it's yeah, it's much closer. I lived in the center of Bethlehem. But yeah, Bethlehem is one of the towns bordering the lake area along with littleton, Lakefield and Dalton, I believe.

Not sure about why I feel but I'm definitely Dalton, Dalton and Dalton and Dalton and I don't have to map here in front of me. Well I have just one last question and that is how did you hear about the plans that Cafella had to open up a new landfill there? Well, I'm pretty sure I saw it on Facebook first because the folks that the same forest like people definitely use social media and got the word out. And then I think I then my family was still have my still family up there.

They had heard about it. And you know, it really shocked me because you know, this park was the only place to go for working families to get out and have their own little piece of heaven. And when I was a lifeguard out there, you know, around four thirty five o'clock, the working men would show up from the factories that were still going and also just getting out of the air and see these families come up and that this was so important to them. And then over the years it's remained, you know, a place where working class people can come and enjoy the park.

And so when I heard about this, this clan, I was just absolutely shocked. A very bad idea. I hope that you're enjoying this podcast of New Hampshire's Secrets, Legends and Lore. Now in most podcasts, this would be the moment when we would both suffer through a pitch about sleeping on some kind of mattress guaranteed to give you the best sleep of your life or pillow that would change your life forever.

The truth is that's just not me. I want to be able to spend my time discovering great stories, visiting new places here in New Hampshire, writing about people and communities that provide unique insights into our heritage and recording great stories for you to enjoy. And I can't imagine that you would want to spend five to ten minutes listening to anyone extoll the virtues of razors delivered right to your home or a new clothing fashion that you can return if they're not to your liking. So I'm taking the chance that perhaps you'll decide to support this podcast for the ideas and ideals that it brings to your life and the life of our state.

You can do that by becoming a subscriber to NH Secrets, Legends and Lore where you can make a one-time contribution or become an ongoing subscriber of the podcast at nhsecrets.blogspot.com. And just in case that's not enough, I'm offering also to provide subscribers with special edition shortcuts, especially made for subscribers and delivering fun brief podcasts to your inbox every few weeks. It may be a tip on a special swimming hole or a great place for a winter hike or a story that's just too much fun to pass up but won't fill the space for a longer podcast. You can subscribe or make a one-time contribution at nhsecrets.blogspot.com where you will also find images and additional show notes related to this podcast.

And now let's return to the podcast with an interview with John Swan. I'm speaking with John Swan, the leader of the Save Forest Lake Alliance. Tell me a little bit about yourself and how you came to live in Northern New Hampshire. I'm 53.

I grew up in Ohio, went to University of Texas. I was a school teacher for a while, worked with Dell Computers and then had an opportunity to move back up north. I'm one of the four seasons again. Texas is a great state but it's very hot and very crowded.

So after about 15 years in the state, I felt it was time to pack up and move back up north. So I moved upstate New York, more your neck of the woods for your ancestry. And beautiful area, but again, just the gosh, 9-11 happened. I wound up eventually joining the Army Reserve when they raised the age limit.

So I went to basic training at 39. I wound up deploying to Iraq in 2008, 2009. Came home and I'd been a realtor for a while up in upstate New York and found some land I like, wound up building a house, started farming. Then I met my second wife who was actually from this area and she was there in New York for work.

She had an option to go back to New Hampshire and she said, hey, live for your diet, you know, state income tax, no sales tax. And after about 10 years of dealing with New York State bureaucracy, I was like, get it up, let's go. So here we are. We found our beautiful home on 15 acres, not far from full length and just, you know, just a peaceful, beautiful area and it's, you know, the mountains, the fresh air, the water.

You could come here for that, you know, it's a vacation destination. I'm just fortunate enough to live here. And then six months ago found out that there were plans to create a landfill right next to the lake. And, you know, of course, I think everybody's first reaction when they hear something like that is, you know, it's got to be a joke because who could allow that to happen and come to find out they, the company of Cassellaway systems out of Rutland, Vermont, and they found a willing landowner that's 1900 acres, land to sell on also someone that kind of went to Stick It Me High in his neighbors.

So that's, and then of course the town of Dalton where the land is situated at that point had no zoning. So, of course, that figured in heavily, even though the company would say, according to their pre-application interview with DES, they claimed that the zoning had no issue, even though it's listed there in their paperwork assessing the community. So we, of course, were like, oh, please stop this and no one had any answers and a young firefighter in the area who, pretty smooth guys said, hey, there's a state statute that allows for citizens to pass a petition to call for a special time meeting and there's a statute to allow for towns with no zoning to enact emergency temporary zoning if they vote on it. So, we don't matter what, about three or four months, we got petitions passed out in the ballot.

And despite Cassella's heavy lobbying against the Emergency Temporary Zoning Act, we were able to get it passed. So, and believing nobody involved in one of zoning, but even more so no one wants a landfill. So, but that's where we're at right now. So, where does that temporary zoning obviously doesn't speak to the specific issues of a landfill, I presume?

Well, in RFA 674-28, it talks about industrial use and it really almost without stating it spells out a landfill as being prohibited. Obviously, hazard to health, noise issues, odor, it just spells out a landfill. So, give it some peace and, you know, I can't help but think that's one of the things that Cassella was really fighting against because, you know, when you look at something like that, and now of course, when they make application with DES, they do have to come to Dalton before the plan board and submit their plans before they did not have to. Initially, the only reason they even came to the town planning board, April 3rd, they presented what they called a lot line adjustment, which was they were carving out of this 1900 acres of land approximately 400 acres of land for the site of their landfill.

And in that lot line adjustment, they called it, they were holding out a 50 foot buffer between the land and the abutters with the original land owner, the seller, being the owner of that 50 foot buffer. So, in essence, he would be the only a butter and that's to clear the state park at Forest Lake. So, when DES was notified of a permit application, abutters would not have to be notified if this was successful. And thankfully, these all came planning board deemed it as more of a subdivision and not a lot line adjustment and they denied the application.

So, that effort to do that little thing, the 50 foot quote unquote lot line adjustment, was really an effort to avoid having to give any power within the process to people who abutted the land. That's correct. Wow. Very nice way to make a call of that.

That is a slimy move to begin with. That's not an auspicious beginning for developing a relationship. No, that's actually the word a lot of people have used when they hear about that. Darnie.

So, obviously, a landfill is always a red flag to people. But what is it about this that my understanding is that you have become very involved in understanding the effects of the landfill in the town of Bethlehem. It's Bethlehem, correct? Correct.

It's only about, oh, I think six miles of the crow flies and from a lot of the mountainous vantage points in the area, you can certainly see the landfill at Bethlehem and then you can also see where the landfill site would be next to Forest Lake. So, certainly something that, you know, it's not only something that, of course, there's people that will cry in enthusiasm. To me, this is an environmental disaster waiting to happen. I mean, the land is, the site is about a quarter of a mile from Forest Lake on the other side of the property.

The water flows, I believe, naturally towards Alderbrook, which empties directly into the Amunusic River. So, you have possible contamination of not only Forest Lake, which eventually leads to the Connecticut River, more directly you have potential contamination of the Amunusic River furthermore than what's already been polluted by the landfill of Bethlehem upstream. Now, what do we know about the pollution from the Bethlehem facility? Well, NCES, which is North Country Environmental Services, the umbrella organization, which runs the landfill, you know, obviously, at the Cacalla subsidiary.

They blame the contamination that's in the Amunusic in the area on the previous landfill that was there. I understand it was an un-filled or un-lined landfill. Cacalla claims that there's no contamination from their landfill, or their landfill. All that's right.

But, bottom line, they're under losses right now from toxic action and the Amunusic Conservation Trust for contaminants in the Amunusic River, including one for dioxin and some other chemicals. I can't remember what they are, but obviously not stuff that's supposed to be in there naturally. So, when the landfill was first developed, we're now talking about the landfill that's in Bethlehem, also owned by a subsidiary of Cacalla. Yep.

Is that correct? They must have purchased it from a different developer, from the original developer of the landfill. Yeah, I don't know the exact history. I mean, I've been in this battle now for six months, and my hard drive can only hold so much data.

So, that's not something that I'm pretty to. I mean, I absolutely know they did purchase it from the prior owner slash developer. And what I understand, I believe at one point it was just a small local landfill and it sounds like it's snowballed and certainly it had expansions. And at the same time, there's the many lawsuits, which furthermore, kind of a test to the character of Cacalla when things don't go their way, they're very litigious.

So, I just see them as a company that they have a bad environmental record, if you kind of look at their landfills that they operate, there's many violations, there's many odor complaints. And like I said, they're very litigious when they don't get their way. So, they're not a very good neighbor, not a good business partner. They chose Dalton because we have no zoning.

They found the willing landowner, but to me it's very predatory how they have just invited themselves into Dalton, uninvited a small poor, relatively poor, fertile town, small population. And I don't know if they figured they would have this much of a battle on their hands, but we feel that the environment up here, the landscape, the quality of life, it's always citing for it. You know, of course, I believe they've looked at maybe four sites in actually within a certain area here in the North Country. Why is it the North Country of New Hampshire, as all of a sudden, become the landfill for the northeastern United States?

I mean, Massachusetts sends its way to Rhode Island, Connecticut. I mean, 50% of the trash that goes into New Hampshire landfills is from out of state. So, we're fighting now to change that. You mean there's legislation that outlaws out of state trash?

Well, we feel that if the town, if New Hampshire were to copy what Maine's done and go municipal, we feel that, first of all, Cocella likes the main thing, that there's a landfill capacity shortage. We don't think that's true at all. We think that's Cocella's capacity shortfall. We feel that there's a, there's a, with a nonprofit that the landfill up in success, New Hampshire called Mount Carberry from what we've been in at our well-run landfill.

From what I've been told by numerous people who are more mittiest in the world of trash than I am, that it's well-run and it does have capacity to handle New Hampshire trash. And we feel that there's no reason why the 28 pounds currently go to Bethlehem and Cocella, when that landfill closes in 2024, there's no reason why those towns couldn't go to Mount Carberry and nothing to do away with any kind of public benefit or need for Cocella to even create a landfill at Forest Lake. Now, tell me a little bit if you know a little bit about sort of the state of the art of landfills as it exists today. Well, from what I've understood and from the research I've done, it seems that pretty much all landfills seem to leak.

They use liner systems. They dig down into the earth. Of course, Cocella helps their, their landfill proposal for Forest Lake is being state of the art, yet we all know that in 20, 30 years, state of the art becomes obsolete and then there's something newer and sexier. So we're not willing to take that chance.

But again, it just seems that the more trash you put into the ground, the heavier the weight, the pressure, not to mention, we really don't know what happens to the water below the surface, especially when, you know, top side is being manipulated in such fashion and then you include, you know, just movement of the earth, etc., etc. I just think there's a very presumptuous for us as well as for Cocella and companies like them to assume that they know what's going to happen in 30, 40, 50 years. And this is something, this is a potentially catastrophic event that we want to avoid now. We don't have to say, oh, I wish we could build a time machine and go back and stop this.

I mean, how many times have we heard that at other places? So we feel that there's enough red flags and warnings for something like this, but this is not a good site. It's not a good location. There's too much water.

There's a lot of wetlands surrounding the area, obviously a lot of natural wildlife and not to mention the fact that the North country of New Hampshire really relies on the tourism industry. And this would be devastating, not only to mention the environmental impact, but look at the traffic, the heavy truck impact on our roads. I mean, if you look at a map of the North country, the town of Whitefield will be at the epicenter of this truck traffic. And we're talking about 90 heavy, 22 wheels, jacket, chain, this full of trash coming from out of state going through the town center of Whitefield, which is right now just a quiet, you know, three lane intersection with no stop sign, no traffic light.

And that will be so disruptive to Whitefield and Whitefield residents, not to mention those further North, like Grove turn, Northumber lane, Tisquale, to usually three to come down to get the latest in there to be heavily impacted, not only with traffic and congestion, but you know, wear and tear on the road, as well as safety. I mean, these trucks are going to be dangerous, especially with so many distracted drivers nowadays. So we just want to avoid all this. We say that it's not necessary.

So when you say 90 trucks, are we talking per day per week? Okay, per day, per day, according to the fellow. That's round trip. So 90 going one way, 90 coming the other way.

And we don't even know if that includes the tankers that are hauling leachate. You know, in Bethlehem at the NCES facility, I was just looking at their manifest for July. They sent 8,000 gallons of leachate, which is that garbage juice full of all kinds of nice stuff. 8,000 gallons of that is sent daily to Concord and Franklin to wastewater treatment plants.

And we don't even know if those wastewater treatment plants are even treating that waste for removal of PFOS. I'm just inquiring into that right now. So there's a lot that we don't know about what's been going on, especially with the amount of press coverage that PFOS have been getting lately, especially here in New Hampshire and relative to our drinking water. This is something that really has to be looked at.

So one piece of speculation we're hoping to have out there this year is a moratorium on private landfills and expansions in order to really study all this. And to take a look at landfills capacity is do we really need another landfill in the North country, only six miles away from where Bethlehem is. And again, we've got a carberry up there in the success, Berlin area. And then of course, you've got waste management down at Turnkey and Rochester.

So you've got two landfills already. The Buffalo country closed in 2024. And I don't think we need to sell anymore in New Hampshire. Then go back to Vermont and leave New Hampshire alone.

How close is are they proposing to put the landfill to the actual lake? Well, the boundary of the 400 acres is about a quarter of a mile. And then all the actual documents, all of this is on our website, by the way, our website saveforkslake.com. If all the documents uploaded, so anyone out there can take a look at the plans, the actual three phases of each about 50 acres of landfill, probably about maybe up to a half a mile away from the water.

And then we've seen even like in a lot of New York there. So they've done studies with older complaints. And it looks like in the Seneca Falls, Waterloo area of New York, there's about a five mile radius for older complaints relative to the landfill out there. That's a little bit of the heart of the tourism industry for the mid country, because then the landfill is going to be cited.

The realt is about three miles away. So when you're down town, little thin shopping for candy and whatnot, and hitting all the cute stores with the family, and you smell that methane, that rotten age mass in the landfill, you're going to know where it's coming from. And is that an ongoing problem in Bethlehem as well? I just had a friend this weekend who was working out in the yard and stopped to text me a couple times to let me know how badly the odor was from a landfill while they were working out in the yard in the sun.

You know, of course you've got Turkey vultures, you've got, you know, sea gulls that will probably be coming in. We have a loom population at Forest Lake. And Forest Lake is actually the home to the only state park public beach in the North country. And I mean, the noise that you're going to hear from the equipment from the trucks, again, the smells wind blows from that direction towards the state park beach.

It's going to really change the whole nature, not only that lake, but again, the surrounding area, the values of homes. It's going to be a battle that could be very similar to the one wave against the Northern Pass. Now, as Casela already purchased the land, or do they have some kind of agreement subject to getting all the permits? Well, they have a right of our first refusal purchase agreement.

That documentation is, you know, recorded at the county offices and it's on our website. And we also have a mortgage, which at $1.2 million has exchanged hands. So, you know, they definitely seem to, they've got 22 test walls on the property. So they, it looks like they're kind of going to land the groundwork to move forward with this, but of course, I don't know that they really anticipated have to deal with zoning because they didn't purchase the front part of the property, which includes the actual road that's going to access the landfill.

That actually is going through the town of Bethlehem. The owner has land in four towns, Dalton, Whitefield, Bethlehem, and Littleton. So the road to access the property is in Bethlehem. The owner will retain that.

They didn't want to buy that because Bethlehem has zoning for us. But in Bethlehem, the way there's zoning is situated, this part of Bethlehem, what a road is going into the landfill to potentially propose landfill. That's district three. And district three is only zoned for light industrial, which is, includes sand and gravel.

There's a sand and gravel operation there. So this would constitute a change of use for that road in the town of Bethlehem because this is landfill and this would become landfill and that's only allowed in district five. So that's another roadblock we see for Pasella and Bellata to those landfill developments. So we're trying to throw up as many roadblocks as we can legislatively by zoning in Dalton, we're looking at Bethlehem to enforce its own zoning.

So ultimately, we really see that if it has an uphill battle on the hands, so, and of course, this is this is pristine property. This is a green field. It's never been a land a landfill before. And DES admitted that we met with DES back in June.

None of those people that are alive at DES working had ever permitted a landfill that was not an existing one prior. Oh, so tell me about the process that you went through to enact the emergency zoning legislation and the other things that you did to activate the community on this. Well, not too long after hearing about this and going through the town and select board and asking them, what can we do to stop this? And they told me nothing.

I came up with the idea of save for us like, so we go to the website, started just kind of spreading the word, what it matters to the auditor, getting back on Facebook, I'm not saying on Facebook, but it's a great means of communication. And really getting the word out there and again, learning about the RSA that allows for citizens to pass a petition calling for a special town meeting, so not having to wait until March by then, who knows, because I'm already putting an application at this point, there's no application. So we acted, passed the petition, had over 100 signatures, presented that to the town select board. We were then scheduled a public hearing on the Warren article, which was very simple.

State law even had the wording for us. So there was no altering that. It was just shall the town adopt emergency temporary zoning, RSA 674 24 to 29, yes or no. And we blanketed a town of Dalton with vote, vote yes on the, on the Warren article signs, but said, vote yes, no landfill and had our website say for the state.

And we registered door and it was a tough battle because not only did we have cassello lanyan of course saying, oh, this won't stop us, you know, zoning, zoning won't impact the landfill, but they had, oh, they sent out three mailers to the citizens and they had four informational barbecues to let people know how long they say they are and how state of the art their landfill will be. And of course, out of those four debicures, I want to say 10 people showed up. So no one of the landfill, no one wanted cassello and Dalton. So we had the public hearing on the 23rd, people weighed in for it against zoning, but also people, even though the town moderator really would not let us say the name cassello.

We weren't allowed during our three minutes of public speaking at the hearing. We're not allowed to say the word cassello, but we could mention the landfill. And that was what the debate was about, whether or not we felt zoning was something that would be a roadblock to the landfill. And ultimately we won that vote was on the 30th, we won 154 to 129, the 30th of July, July, okay, you have the public hearing was on the 23rd of July.

And so we won that. The great thing is we've gotten a lot of great press. WMR was up here at the TV station from down south covering both the public hearing and the town vote. And we've had a lot of letters to the editor printed.

A lot of, you know, that was good coverage out there online to Vermont Digger, Wach dive. We held protests out at the Cocella, landfill and Coventry, Vermont, because they sent out invites to Dalton residents courting them. And this was only a couple of weeks ago. So September 14, we aligned with groups out of Vermont and Canada to show our opposition to Cocella at their quote unquote, open house at their landfill and Coventry Vermont.

It was a great event. And we're also having another protest, the street protest at the Bethlehem landfill on September 28, is there again, having another open house. They sent out mailers inviting Dalton residents who they're trying to court through their open house on Saturday, September 28, from 10 to three. So we will be out there with the veterans of the Bethlehem Wars, along with the folks from Vermont.

We've invited people from South Bridge, Mass, as well as New York State who had dealings with Cocella and landfill out there. So trying to build a broad coalition, not only to oppose the landfill at Forest Lake, but any future proposed expansions of the Bethlehem landfill. And as well as trying to find solutions to our garbage problem because we obviously have a garbage problem in this country. Right.

I mean, that becomes a principle challenge because right now it appears that there have to be, there still have to be landfills somewhere. Is there anything on the horizon that is an alternative to that? Well, again, we think there's any capacity, a cutberry, not a carberry. And then obviously, our waste management has, you know, they're a private company.

So they do import a lot of trash in other states. We would love to see D.E.S. try and tighten that up a little bit, you know, ensure that they're a permitting process that they are leaving room for New Hampshire trash. And we wouldn't even have this discussion with Bethlehem's landfill and capacity in 2024 if Cocella wasn't filling it with so much out of state trash.

34% of what goes into Bethlehem's from out of state. So there's going to be a capacity in 2024, the citizens of Bethlehem voted twice against any expansions because Cocella wants to expand there. You know, we do feel too that they're kind of using Dalton as a ledgerage process to try and get people to say, oh, you already have a landfill in Bethlehem. Just stay there and why do you want to come out with Dalton?

And we're not doing that. We are going to support the citizens of Bethlehem in their flight because, you know what, they are voted, they've let their voice be known. And now we're joining the flight and we just feel that we don't need Cocella in New Hampshire anymore. Is there anything being done to mitigate the odor problem in Bethlehem?

I do not, and not familiar with any kind of mitigation relative to what's going on right now relative to the contamination of the Ammonusic and what's getting out there. You don't know how you can. You've got to unfil or unwind landfill. It's how old, you know?

Right, right. What do you do other than dig it up? I don't know. I said there are places in the country where they are doing just that, where they're digging up old landfills.

And but I don't know all the details on that technology. Yeah, I've even heard of landfills being mined for metals and whatnot, you know, things that are of use. But, you know, it just has to come to a point where a secondary conversation we've been having is, you know, looking at our dependence on single-use plastics and styrofoam. You know, if you saw the 60-minute story on plastics in the ocean and the fact that the birds out at what is it, Midway Island, you know, their intestines are lying with plastics.

And, you know, it's just the amount of garbage we're generating. And, you know, I mean, I remember laughing when people started buying bottled water. I'm like, you get water on your tap. And now, unfortunately, they seem to be polluting our water supplies so that our drinking water is tainted and people, some people in fortune are having to buy water.

But, I mean, it's crazy to think that at one point, here we have tap water and people are starting to buy bottled water. You know, how do we get stuckred into this? And now it's like everyone's so heavily dependent on single-use plastics in full-way. You know, it's just, it's just maddening.

And I think we just have to, we've gotten here within a generation and I think it'll probably take that long, maybe even sooner to change that mindset. But we've got to start holding in fact, which is responsible for the end of life of their product and not just that winding up in a landfill or being sold to China, which they're aren't doing anymore and then them doing whatever they're doing with the plastics, the so-called. I mean, how long have we fought that? Oh, these are all being recycled.

We're just throwing in the recycled bin. They're fine. They're being put to use. And now we find out they're not.

You know, how many more instances are we going to discover we've been lied to? You know, I mean, we even have PFOS now in our food supply. We have PFOS in our bodies. Gosh, I'm just delving into research relative to leachate and wastewater treatment and the fact that, you know, like, Coventry Vermont, let's use that as an example, that landfill.

They've been sending their leachate to Newport, Vermont, to the wastewater treatment plant there and they come to find out they're not capable of removing PFOS from that water. So now they're having to ship that elsewhere. But how many instances, how many years have we seen where wastewater has been supposedly treated and then has just been put back into the, you know, natural environment? And now, you know, even with biosolids, look at the hockey breeding stories about how even cassellas, how they biosolids as the future for a growing population, you know, turning it into fertilizer for farms.

And I even read with the Concord New Hampshire wastewater treatment plants. They have a flyer that talks about their biosolid, claseted, biosolid, fertilized that's being used on farms and it's even recommended for corn crops. I mean, that bottle's in mind. And corn, of course, is in everything.

Right. That's just a crazy world. I wish I'd never opened up this Pandora's box but I had to, you know. So you're a reluctant warrior, John.

I am. I want my old life back. That's my goal. But you know what?

It's kind of like, you know, I really like it at the Pearl Harbor, you know, you wake up one morning and find this, you discover this and it's war, you know, I'm a war. So, so you responded to 9-11 by, by signing up and now you've responded to the, to the danger to Forest Lake and the surrounding environment by doing the same thing. Correct. I guess so.

You're, you're, you're a white knight. I was lucky. I was lucky in the white knight. I don't know.

I'll be honest with you. I was always in partial to the black knight. So well, I can fit a Lord Vader in my father. He wasn't my own father.

You know what? The black knight is just as good as a white knight. You know, the hound is my favorite character on Game of Thrones. So, well, John, thank you very much for taking the time to talk with me.

I would like to make an arrangement at some time in the next week or so to come up and visit with you and have you get any sort of a tour of the lakes because that, you know, even though I'm a North country boy, I've never, I've never been to Forest Lake. So I think you're going to find it. I think you're going to enjoy it. I think you're going to find a gem in the North country and I look forward to showing you around.

And I just want to know. And, you know, of course, I certainly appreciate that opportunity to talk about something that's very near and dear to my heart. Okay. Well, thanks very much.

And I'll talk to you very soon. All right, sounds good. Have a good day, Wayne. Thanks.

Take care. Bye. So that was John Swan, the reluctant warrior of Forest Lake, explaining the work that he has done to try and stop a landfill that is proposed for the area surrounding Forest Lake. It's probably worth explaining that when John talks about the amount of waste that's coming from outside of the state of New Hampshire, that I clarify the reason that that is so difficult to do something about.

The current state of affairs in New Hampshire is that most landfills are owned by private companies. And to restrict trash that is coming from out of state to a private landfill is a violation of the Commerce Clause of the Constitution. In other words, you can't restrict interstate commerce between private corporations. So therefore, those private corporations are able to accept the trash, which comes with high tipping fees, of course.

And there's nothing that the state can do about that. What John has proposed is to move back toward a system where municipalities control landfills, in which case those municipalities would be able to restrict the solid waste that was accepted. My thanks again to Gary Giddo for bringing us some color at the beginning of the podcast and to John Swan, not only for explaining to us the process, but also for the work that he has done to protect what is a valuable resource to the state of New Hampshire. You can find information about how to contact John Swan and the Save Forest Lake group in our show notes.

You can find the show notes for this show at NHSecrets.blogspot.com, where you can also make a contribution to the podcast. I hope you'll also take the time to leave a review because that helps other people find us. I hope you'll join us again the next time on New Hampshire Secrets, Legends, and Lore.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of NH Secrets Legends and Lore?

This episode is 59 minutes long.

When was this NH Secrets Legends and Lore episode published?

This episode was published on October 16, 2019.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this NH Secrets Legends and Lore episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.