Hello and welcome to the RBI Performance Podcast Episode 2. I'm Blair Bundy and I'm joined by my co-host as always, Stephen Roundley. What's going on, buddy? Good morning, Blair. You ready to talk curveballs, man? I'm ready. So we thought we'd kind of go through a hot topic or, you know, just a kind of common assumption we see out there today. And that topic is, you know, should kids throw curveballs? We want to kind of introduce a little bit of literature research in this. And so I went ahead and pulled out an article from 2013 in the Journal of Sports Health entitled The Curveball as a Risk Factor for Injury, a Systematic Review. This is written by Grantsom et al. And they basically wanted to sit there and say, you know, they want to explore this kind of topic because they sit there and say that, yeah, the widespread acceptance of the idea that curveballs or kids shouldn't throw curveballs is, you know.
pretty widely believed amongst baseball trainers, coaches, physicians, things like that, but does the evidence actually back that up, right? And one of the reasons why these kids are getting injured more often, you kind of look at the research out there, and you see that, you know, they look at overuse, they look at high pitch counts, they look at poor throwing mechanics, they look at the curveball. I mean, there's all sorts of things they kind of theorize, but they wanted to tease out that one factor, and that's the curveball, right? So what they did was they basically performed a large literature search, extracted some relevant studies, and came up with about 15 different studies. So 10 studies looking at biomechanics, five looking at epidemiology, or actually just injury incidents of, you know, Baseball, injury, and curveballs. Those are their search terms. All right, so what they basically found was that in the five injury incident studies, 60% of these studies found no significant association between pitching a curve and shoulder elbow pain. But all the studies did kind of implicate an increased amount of pitching as a significant risk factor for arm pain or injury.
of the biomechanical studies they looked at, none of the studies they reviewed showed looking at the shoulder of the elbow indicated any kind of increased force or torque at the elbow joint when throwing a curve compared to throwing a fastball. It's pretty widely held and known that throwing a fastball produces the highest amount of stress on the elbow. They've done some studies back on cadavers, actually, and looked at the amount of force put through an elbow when a pitcher throws 90 miles an hour can exceed that of what it takes to basically tear in half a cadaver's ulnar collateral ligament. So we know that any time you throw a fastball above 90 miles an hour, that risk is there, right? The one thing all these studies did agree upon was that when kids throw curveballs, they actually have an increased forearm supination. And one of the things they took away from that was, well, maybe we should train the forearm muscles for the curveball then. We can get to that later. They found the changeup showed the lowest joint forces across all pitches. Fastball was the highest. And the authors kind of ended up supporting USA Baseball's recommendation to teach proper mechanics and emphasize the changeup to prevent arm injuries. All right, Steve.
If you look at the study, it kind of talks about, I think it's a good study. It looks and shows, you know, here's what's out there. Here's what's, here's what the research is showing. Here's what's kind of commonly believed. Do you think that if we just strain the forearm muscles in these kids, we're going to prevent these forearm injuries or these elbow injuries?
No. I mean, if anything, we're finding in baseball that A plus B does not equal C with regards to preventing shoulder and elbow injuries. Oftentimes, just as human beings, we want to distill out these simple, easy answers that we can lay on the public and say, hey, if you just do this one thing, if you eat one piece of kale, you'll never have a heart attack or whatever the case may be. And it's just the body is just so much more complex than if we were just to train a couple of forearm muscles that we could prevent potential injuries from throwing curveballs, which this study clearly calls into question. Yeah. They also talk about just...
teaching proper mechanics. You know, I mean, Stephen, I threw, I threw over the top in high school and I ended up throwing kind of down submarine three quarter style after having Tommy John surgery and trying to find a spot to play in college. So I would say that my mechanics differed significantly pre and post. And so, you know, what a good mechanics even look like to you, Stephen. It's a good question. After reading a bunch of different literature and going through books and classes and speaking with high school coaches and being a player myself and coaching myself, I think.
The ideal mechanics are based on a couple of things, the athlete's body and what their body can and cannot do. So I like to encourage my clients, my patients to think of their body or their mechanics, whatever the case that may be as a journey. And you're constantly just like a karate or some type of martial arts. You're constantly reforming, reforming, trying to improve your techniques. But if there was a singular answer, here are the best mechanics, we would have it by now. The American Sports Medicine Institute has been putting in tons and tons of money and time and effort trying to research what the best mechanics are. And there are some.
kind of guidelines, if you will, but there is no one size fits all approach. Not only that, I think that if there was, we'd see every guy at the highest level throwing kind of the same, you know, I think we'd see a lot of similarity between guys who, and you know, there's been lots of good, you know, I've seen presentations where guys will lay over mechanics of like a guy like Roger Clemens or a guy like Nolan Ryan and kind of show them at certain points in their, in their windup, how they are similar. But I still don't think it's a one size fits all approach. And when you make a blanket statement, like, okay, just make sure they have good mechanics, you're kind of putting in that box. And it's just because, you know, let's, let's say that I took a I took a kid down here in Houston to a pitching coach and then you took a kid up there in Round Rock to a pitching coach You think it'd be the same mechanics they walk away with? No, you'd get you know if you had a hundred pitching coaches in the same room talking about pitching mechanics You'd probably come up with a hundred different answers and if you look at the playoffs this season 2016 is
You're seeing some of the best pitchers, some of the best workhorses from Max Scherzer to John Lester, Jake Arrieta the past few years, 200 innings, pitch mark, mad bum, all these guys. And they have such extreme differences in their deliveries. And so the idea that there is one way to throw a baseball consistently without a chance for injury, all four of those guys never having major injuries. I think Lester had some bone chips taken out of his elbow, and that's about it. I mean, these guys have all been workhorses, guys throw a lot of innings, guys chew up games, and they all throw completely different.
And a lot of times guys who come into the league and are praised for their mechanics end up being the guys who get hurt. I mean, you see, you saw a guy, I mean, Steve, you're familiar with this case, obviously Mark Pryor, you know, when he came out of USC, he was Tom House protege. Everything was kind of like, you know, they were really basically telling this guy, he's got perfect mechanics. He looks great. He's just, he's built like a perfect pitcher. And same thing, ended up breaking down, having some elbow issues, had a Tommy John surgery. And yeah, so, I mean, I don't think that.
I'm just not sure if there's one single perfect way to throw a pitch. I do agree with your point that if you have a kid who's 6'10 and a kid that's 5'10, they're going to throw differently. If you have a kid that's 280 pounds and a kid that's 180 pounds, they're probably going to throw differently. They're going to assume some different shapes. We can probably agree on certain archetypes, what a good position and a bad position looks like, but I think it's going to definitely vary from person to person, kid to kid. So it's tough to make these statements like, okay, let's clean the mechanics up. That'll be okay. One of the things they did talk about, Steve, was about the changeup. Now, I can sit and talk to you about my pitching career. I didn't learn to change up until I got to probably my junior or senior year of high school.
And I was mostly a fastball curveball guy. And so I definitely violated this rule. I probably violated a lot of pitching rules growing up. We can get to that later. But I want to say that I didn't learn to change up until later in life. So I do agree with this statement. Like, hey, maybe you should emphasize the change up. How do you feel about that? Is that something you kind of talk to these kids about that you're coaching? What do you do?
Yeah, that's that's a big thing I think when you're still kind of in that awkward adolescent phase where bones are growing faster than muscles and then muscles are playing catch up and then you get all Uncoordinated and everybody's kind of seen that kid that outgrows his body in his nervous system And it looks like they're learning to walk and run all over again. I think the baby giraffes They I think the important thing is to just continue as a coach or as a parent to have a watchful eye I saw this last night on Twitter somebody in the injury prevention world, which is just becoming such a a buzz word now for everybody, but he calls it injury surveillance. He's like, you can't prevent these things. You just can't. And if you could, we would know at this point, the idea of injury prevention is falling out of favor with people that are leading and spearheading this world. So injury surveillance, I know it just sounds like wordplay, but it makes a lot of sense to me is, you know, your kid, you know, your athlete, you have that rapport, you've developed time and energy invested in them. It's important that you start looking for potential pitfalls that might get them into trouble as they're, as they're growing, as their body's changing. I think as a youth, that's the big thing is you see these kids grow so fast, or maybe they hit the weights for the first time and they put on five, 10, 15 pounds of muscle and then the ball comes.
out of their hand completely differently. I think the most important thing is you've got to find a repeatable motion that you can kind of build off of. And that motion hopefully live within what we kind of understand are some of the better technique pieces of throwing. I don't think those are steadfast rules, but the idea that there's one way to throw, we've already talked about, that's just not it. So I think you need to be within kind of the gray area. Then once you have an idea of what your arm action and what your mechanics look like, then yeah, I would say let's start with a changeup. Let's build from there. I think the changeup obviously has the least amount of stress going through the arm and the body, which is a great thing to preserve an arm.
But you're trying to develop the same arm action essentially as a fastball for not only control purposes, but to fool the hitter. And that's the purpose of an off-speed pitch. When they say off-speed pitch, they talk about all of them, whether it's a changeup, whether it's a slider, a curveball, cutter, whatever. The idea is just to fool the hitter. And in baseball, your job as a pitcher is to fool the hitter to get these guys to hit weakly contacted balls, pop-ups, foul tips, obviously grounders, those types of things. So in my opinion, that's kind of where we start is teach the arm action, make sure we have mechanics that aren't.
red flags written all over the place but at least we're kind of in that uh buffer zone and then we can kind of debate well should his elbow be here or there where should his front side be i mean at this point it's all debate because nobody really knows teach the change up it's a safe pitch um and then as as you start to get better feel and the athlete starts to get very attuned with his mechanics and it's more there's high repeatability there and we can start introducing other breaking pitches such as a curveball or something like that um to throw a curveball in there um ironically once my elbow started hurting um as a junior senior in high school the Pitch that hurt my arm the absolute most was the change of so yeah interesting. How'd you grip it circle change? Okay So and when I went into more of the the part of that action arm action that really bugged me was the the deceleration portion the pronation man It felt like my elbow was separate I remember the distinct feeling of a handful of times throwing thinking my form was going to fly off and go to home plate with the ball It just felt like my elbow was completely separating and it hurts so much. You said your injury was diagnosed as a flexor strain. Is that right?
I never really got a good diagnosis. That's kind of what you think it was? That's what I think it was. I mean, I was so tender on that medial side of my elbow or the inner side of the elbow that I just I couldn't rest my arm on my center console in my car for weeks. I've been studying and writing, those types of things that would occasionally be swollen. But I wore that little, you see tennis players, that little tennis wrap brace on there. And I just cinched that thing down so tight so I could pitch through the pain. And I'm assuming that's what I had. I don't think I had any laxity or damage to the UC elbow. I was probably heading in that direction. I think it's probably a good point to bring up. If you see a kid with a tennis counterforce brace strapped to his elbow super tight and he's out there throwing, please get him off the mound.
It's not a good look, guys. It's just not a good look. It's time. Save him from himself. Let's get him off the mile. I agree, man. I think that a changeup, I mean, if I can...
armchair quarterback my pitching career I would love I wish I had a good change up growing up because I think the guys the most effective guys I faced were guys who could change speeds could locate in and out and had good movement on their pitches and whether that be had a good moving to seam through a good change up that had a little like sink to it those guys are incredibly tough to hit and I wish that that kind of would have been how I focused it you know trying to kind of just really master location in and out up and down changing eye level and just keeping guys off speed I think that's a great piece of advice and I do agree with the authors in this case that you know this was my kid and I know he's pretty pretty good at pitching and you know he's a he's out there throwing strikes and getting guys out. The second thing I might want to emphasize with him is how to throw a changeup. I don't know if there's a benefit or a detriment to teaching him more of just a palm changeup versus a circle changeup. I don't really know. That'd be something else to kind of look at, but I do think that's a good way to kind of approach it in terms of dealing with these kids. I think a lot of things, and the author spoke to this. I'm going to directly quote this, Steve.
Youth pitchers with the highest pitch counts are likely the better pitchers on the team and therefore more inclined to throw a curveball earlier in their careers, further emphasizing overuse as a confounding variable. So I'm not a fan of their assumption here that, oh, if they're good, they're going to throw curveballs, you know, duh. But that type of thing does come up again and again if you look at this type of injury incidents literature with youth sports especially. Kids who are good typically throw more and are thus exposed to higher workloads than they may be prepared to handle at that point in their career. You kind of agree with that?
Oh, yeah, definitely. I think that's the – when I was reading this study, before I even got to that part, that was what I was thinking. When the results came out and they were like, yeah, we're not finding a huge correlation between curveballs and arm problems. I was like, well, that's because these kids probably are just throwing more. And then, lo and behold, two paragraphs later, there it was.
You know, I definitely think that you tend to see that a lot as the kid who's, you know, he's a little bit bigger. Maybe he got bigger than his classmates, a little faster, and he's, you know, out there throwing a little bit harder. There's kind of that pressure, like, oh, okay, well, I'm going to throw a lot, so I got to learn my out pitches. You know, you watch TV, and you see guys throwing these big hammers, and you're like, okay, I got to learn how to throw this curveball. I mean, as a kid growing up, I didn't have YouTube, so I taught myself how to throw a little sketchy curveball, and my dad would yell at me playing catch because I tried to throw it all the time. I didn't really learn a curveball. I didn't learn how to throw a curveball properly, and we can...
put properly in air quotes because you know if I look at the literature and the research I'm not sure if I was doing it properly and I also blew my elbow out so who knows right so I didn't learn until I got with the pitching coach he kind of taught me actually you know I learned a very classic way you know you're trying to you know karate chop your hand towards home plate what they call pulling the light switch or have you what the cue is but you know i learned kind of that way too and kind of screwed around but if you're a kid nowadays and you're pretty good it probably wouldn't be that hard to go to youtube and type in how do i throw a curveball and get 87 different people telling you 87 different grips strategies release points all the like and so i really think that you know as a kid excuse me as a parent as a coach as a trainer someone who has access to these kids you may have the opportunity like to kind of if they ask you hey you know how to throw a curveball you may want to inform yourself first and get an idea of like It's kind of like the birds and bees talk, right? You got to prepare yourself for it. Well, this is the curveball talk, right? So you want to prepare yourself to be able to talk to your kid about just saying, you know, well, this is how I throw it. Or maybe let's go see this guy. Hey, why don't we work on this changeup pitch first? You know, you got to kind of have a plan for that type of thing. Did you just go birds and bees? I did. This is crazy. You made me blush a little bit there. Oh, boy. Oh, man. So, Stephen, they talk about training the supinator, training the muscles of the forearm as far as a recommendation to help kind of prevent these elbow injuries for these kids. So should everyone go out and just kind of get a five-pound hammer and start doing some pronation supination drills? What's the plan?
Definitely. They can come over to my backyard and patch up my deck when they're doing that too. Hammer time. You know it. I have a hard time believing in that as an injury prevention strategy or just preparing yourself to throw a curveball strategy.
So there's a couple of points that I think are important. One, being in that kind of, again, for our listeners out there that are not in the medical world and don't know what supination pronation means. If you hold your hands out in front of you and you point your palms up towards the ceiling, like you're going to hold a cup of soup, that's supination. Okay. If you point your palms down towards the floor, that's going to be pronation. So supination would be obviously you're going to turn your hand or rotate it kind of more towards your head when your arms in the throwing position.
That to me is likened to throwing a football. So I don't think anybody out there throwing a football is necessarily training their supinators. And we don't see the arm injuries in football nearly as much as we do in baseball. So I'm going to go ahead and say, eh, I'm probably not going to spend a lot of time on that. On top of the fact that...
The supinator for, again, our listeners that have not done cadaver studies and seen these things, it's not a big muscle. Now, it's important because it is part of the dynamic stabilizing group or the muscles that are there to help protect the ligaments like the UCL. That's the Tommy John ligament. Obviously, there's importance to that, just like your pronator muscle there on the inside and your flexors, the things that move your hand and wrist and then the extenders and things that move your hand and wrist in the extension position. Those things are important. Don't get me wrong, but I think globally they should be trained. They shouldn't be really isolated.
That muscles really not built to be hypertrophied meaning to get it bigger like when you go to the gym You're trying to look good and you're doing bicep curls. You're trying to make your biceps bigger I've never seen anybody on a stage showing off their supinator. It's just it's just not a thing So you gotta come work out me sometime I've got a pretty solid supinator and anconia superset I try to throw in I bet you do building Bundy, so I just have a real hard time I think the authors felt Maybe like they needed to make some type of suggestion other than Just collecting evidence and saying, well, the idea or the notion that throwing curveballs is bad for your arm really doesn't hold water here. But if you're going to throw a curveball, we've got to tell you to do something. In this study, it would be a huge grasp to say, blah, something that's not related to something as isolated as a supinator. I think you have to look at the whole body, the kinetic chain. And that basically means how the ground plays in with your legs, to your core, to your shoulders, to your elbow, to release point, all those pieces linked together. And to pull out a muscle that's no bigger than a petite.
filet mignon cut in half i mean just a tiny tiny muscle to me is a bit of a stretch but i get why they might say something like that you got me hungry man want to talk about filet mignon this will be on our cooking podcast we talk about after this Yeah, I agree, man. We talked about this in our introductory podcast. We talked about Stephen and I's practice backgrounds. Stephen tends to work with more kids. Stephen gets a chance to work with healthy kids a lot of times. I tend to see kids who are a little bit more broken down. I see a lot of post-op kids. And I do focus a lot on training the elbow flexor, extensor pronation, supination. I do spend a good amount of time training that because I do think, like I talked to earlier, we know these studies show that the human cadaver, the ulnar collateral ligament in a cadaver, basically when exposed to the...
amount of force a 90 mile an hour fastball uh puts on the elbow it tears right and so i do think that there has to obviously be other stuff going on at the shoulder the elbow the forearm everything to help spare these uh this ligament these forces i do think muscle uh endurance and strength is part of that so i include that in my training for these kids but obviously it's not it's not the be all end all because like steven said if that were the case you see a bunch of guys walking around with one jacked forearm and you'd be like well it must be a baseball pitcher right a little different story than what we tend to see And to your point, Blair, your kids are oftentimes starting after a bomb went off on their arm and they're coming back from square one. So I guess to round out our point here is it kind of depends on where you're coming from. If you're healthy and you're in good shape, should you be investing a bunch of time into training your forearm pronators and supinators?
not a whole lot, maybe a little bit, I think that's applicable, but what you're going to get with throwing is probably going to be enough to, to spawn some adaptation there. But if you're someone that just had Tommy John or little leaguer's elbow, or you're coming off a flexor pronator strain or something to where you need to shut it down and you need to rebuild those, those muscles. Yeah, absolutely. I can see how that, but at that point, you're not saying injury prevention, which is kind of where the authors are coming from on this. It's, this is, you're getting back to baseline. You're behind the eight ball.
I think you have to have, and that's a big thing you and I have talked about, especially what we see in kids, is that there has to be a certain level of baseline fitness. They have to be able to move a certain way. They need to have baseline levels of strength. I don't think we have a good way to test for, oh, your supernatur strength is way off, bro, so we're going to just shut you down for a little bit. I don't think that's something we can probably screen out. But at the end of the day, I think if you have a chance to work with a kid and you're helping them develop an off-season program, develop some type of fitness routine, doing some type of arm care should be included. It shouldn't be the entire focus, I think, obviously.
getting kids bigger and stronger, whether it be just kind of big global patterns, your squat, your push, your pull, your hinge, all that kind of stuff. That needs to be the emphasis, but doing some things to kind of develop some resiliency and muscles that help protect the elbow and the shoulder from the pitching forces that are kind of spread around the arm. It's a great idea. So yeah, it's a blanket statement in terms of training the supernature, but if you expand that to a global 30,000 foot view, more than anything, train your athletes. Give your kids an off-season program, a chance to really just get stronger and move better and take care of their tissues, take care of their range of motion, make sure they're in a fit to train, fit to play state before you just sit out there and say, okay, cool, it's curveball time.
Now, Steve, when I talk about the godfather of sports medicine, who do you think of? You think of Don Corleone? Yes, definitely. I do. Yeah, of course. I know you're getting at here. So let's go down that road. Let's go down that road. So everyone, you know, if a baseball player hurts their arm in season and you're watching SportsCenter in your dentist's office and you're going to see the bottom line that so-and-so is flying to Pensacola, or I forget his office now, to meet with Dr. Andrews. James Andrews is basically the godfather of sports medicine. He has the tallest podium of everyone out there. And in terms of ulnar collateral reconstruction, obviously Dr. Frank Jobe is the first person to kind of pioneer the surgery on Tommy John, a pitcher for the Dodgers back in the day.
But nowadays, you tend to see Dr. Andrews kind of be the go-to guy. Dr. Andrews has since passed away, obviously. But Dr. Andrews is kind of the big voice in terms of these baseball injuries, these youth injuries. He's got a website, Stop Sports Injuries. They do a lot of research, like you talked about at ASMI, that look at injury incidents. They look at biomechanics, all this stuff.
A quote he gave that I think is pretty interesting. He talks about throwing curveballs in kids, and what he basically said was that if you throw it with good mechanics, it doesn't have any greater force on your shoulder than throwing other pitches, but you've got to throw it correctly. And we talked about this. We know that throwing with good mechanics doesn't have any greater force on your shoulder. I mean, we talked about that. The fastball has the most stress on the shoulder and the elbow, and that's been demonstrated and repeated in study after study, right? But Dr. Andrews also said it's misleading to say it's okay to throw the curveball with good mechanics because the rub is most kids don't throw it with good mechanics, and I would agree with that. At the same time, I don't know what good mechanics look like for your 13-year-old kid versus the other 13-year-old kid versus the next 13-year-old kid, but I know there's a difference.
He kind of concludes with saying, you know, my rule of thumb is don't throw the curveball until you can shave until your bone structure has matured and you have the neuromuscular control to be able to throw the pitch properly. Now, Stephen, there's a little bit of a CYA tent to that, like, oh, you know, just be careful. But I do agree with the gist of it. I think that, you know, a lot of kids who aren't skeletally mature and who don't have the control to throw the pitch properly, yeah, they probably shouldn't do it. What do you think about that? Well, I think he has, speaking for, I mean, I'm not obviously speaking for Dr. Andrews, but what I'm perceiving his point probably is, is he's got a big old platform to speak from.
I mean, one, he doesn't need to make an outlandish comment to get clicks and get people to show up to his practice. And two, what he says is going to hold water. So I would think a discerning mind in that position would ultimately make conservative statements. And I don't mean to belittle his statement. He's known more about the arm throwing action, Tommy John, reconstructive surgeries, all sorts than I'll ever know. I mean, the man is a legend. But I think as a parent, when you interpret these things, if you see these things in a video on Facebook, which I've seen before, or if you're reading it in the New York Times because there's articles about stuff, I mean.
We want you to have just a little bit more of a discerning opinion. Okay, I get what he's saying. It makes sense. But the practicality of it is my kid's going to end up being taught a curveball. Whether like Blair said, he gets on YouTube and is screwing around with his friends. I mean, I broke my mom's window learning how to throw a splitter at our house. And that cost me a lot of car washing for a few weeks. I mean, kids are kids, right? And they're exposed to all sorts of stuff. Now they could run into a coach that has really great intentions and say, man, if you just had a curveball, you would get a lot of guys out, blah, blah. And then boom, here we go. You know, then you have that.
that distance that you're already experiencing your kid turns a teenager i don't want to listen to you you don't know anything blah blah now you're telling me i can't throw a curveball blah you know it's like so let's all get on the same page on this so my opinion on that is one the studies that show there's a handful of these studies in this research review with youths that were studied versus college and high school and pro. And as far as I know, and I've read a bunch of the studies that are a part of this kind of analysis of these studies, as far as I know, the exclusion was not if you had good mechanics or bad mechanics. Because one, nobody knows how to decide, oh, you've got good mechanics and you don't. And two, if they're not excluded, that means there's a good chance these kids that were throwing curveballs did not have great mechanics.
reasonably to a coin flip and they still showed that they had less stress on their arm and they still showed that pitching volume was probably more related to injury than it was the actual curveball. So I'm going to go ahead and just say. to my first point when we got started in the podcast was let's make sure that we have proper coaching someone that is an expert not just no offense to dads out there that are just volunteering but someone that's been there before someone that does this for a living let's let's get an expert even if you only see them once in a while or if it's you meet with them once somebody to teach you a grip that's tried and true and there's more than one way to grip the ball for a curveball someone to teach you an arm action that's tried and true and there's more than one way like we discussed to do that too and then let's make sure that the kid is prepared for it that they've had some development in their body that they that they're not going through some weird awkward stage and now you're trying to introduce a new variable to their pitching action let's make sure that their pitching motion is repeatable let's make sure that it's not at the end of a season like oh man great you've already pitched 70 80 innings in a year let's introduce because now it's the offseason let's introduce this curveball and really we should be getting our arm ready to go again there's a time and place for all this but
And the point of this podcast is to start thinking globally because when I see kids in my office that – the question I always ask when I first see a kid in my office that I know is coming up with a baseball injury is when's your next game? When's your next tournament? Because that's what most people care about. They don't care what I have to say unless I say, oh, I think you have a tear. Then usually faces get red and hearts stop. But usually they want to know, well, can I play? When they already know the answer. No, you probably can't play this Friday because your arm hurts and you haven't been able to throw in two weeks. I mean I don't understand why there's such backlash with that. I mean it oftentimes becomes a defensive conversation. And in the beginning when I first started practicing –
It was almost a gun-shy moment because you knew you were going to get that type of reaction. But now, you know what? If you don't want to buy into that idea that your body... physically hurt so much that you can't throw a ball and then you want to go throw this this weekend then I can't help you you need to get to a place in your head where that's acceptable so to kind of go full circle on this deal to wait till we can shave and wait till we have proper arm mechanics and yada yada on all those things I think you got to take that with a grain of salt because shaving for me was like 18 and I'm not gonna wait for you was like last week yeah exactly so I mean it's it's it's a it's a good statement in theory but just like everybody shaves at different time Blair was shaving when he was 11 I was shaving when I was 20 you know I mean it's there's different bodies there's your arm bones longer than my arm bone and blah blah just there's too many very But I understand where Dr. Andrews might be coming from. He's the face of this stuff. He's got to make a statement to satisfy the critics. I agree. I totally agree with that. It's definitely a good statement, but you should take it with a grain of salt from a standpoint that baseball is not a one size fits all.
type thing and injury prevention injury surveillance you know all this stuff it it's it's different i think if we if it wasn't we have figured it out by now we're smart people not me and steven specifically we just figured out how to make a podcast but there are people who are there are people who are much smarter than us doing very high level research with slow motion video cameras and doing force sensors at the elbow doing cadaver studies and looking at ligaments and tendons you know we still haven't figured it out and this is a billion dollar problem this is lots and lots of i mean we talk about the guys who are on uh disabled list and major league baseball level uh you know it's millions and millions if not billions of dollars a year that's being spent on this type of thing and we haven't figured it out yet and so i really think it goes down to that point you guys kind of talked to before is that kids who are good tend to throw more and tend to be exposed to higher loads and they're ready to go and so the solution in my mind is that you have to be able to identify these kids you know i think it goes back to the injury surveillance term be aware of if your kid is a kid who's good he's having to throw on his high school team and his select team and this team and that team maybe you need to monitor that workload you know maybe you need to kind of figure out hey you know it's fall and there's really no baseball going on right now. Why don't we go and work with a guy who's just a trainer and see if we can develop some just overall body strength movement, you know, baseline levels there. You know, there's some other things we can do other than just throw a baseball off a mound at maximal effort year round. I'm not going to sit here and say you should just take, you know, five months off a year and don't touch a baseball. I don't think that's the right thing either, but I think that there needs to be a, you know, I think it goes, it's more than just throwing a curveball. I think throwing a curveball obviously goes hand in hand with these guys being injured. And that's why there's obviously this widespread belief that, you know, oh, you know, if we just get thrown a curveball, they're blowing their elbows out. Well, I agree, but I think it has more to do with the fact that they just.
Physically, their body hasn't matured to a point where they can handle the loads associated with being a number one pitcher who throws all the time. So you're putting these grown man workloads on these 13-year-old kids, and it's no wonder they break down, right? So anyway, as far as just wrapping this article up, Steve, what was your big takeaway? I wanted to add in another quick point here on this stuff. I was reading some things. I did a Google search before we got started with this podcast, and I wanted to see when we type in something like, when should my kid throw a curveball? This is hopefully a common search that moms and dads in.
people associated with young kids with search. And there's a whole bunch of things that pop up. So I wanted to see what was going to be the top five, 10 type things and just kind of peruse through that. And what we're seeing is that, you know, everything is centered around a debate. Like the first article is the big capital, big debate curveballs and how old those types of things. I saw one of these articles I was reading through it comes from the baseball think tank and they, they kind of bring up some interesting points that, you know, I haven't had enough time to really chew over and think, well, how much water does this hold? But these are things that you guys are going to read when you're out there. And I thought we'd address them. And one of the big things they talk about is, you know,
could potentially, learning a curveball at a young age, almost stunt a pitcher's development. Because, you know, when you start, he uses references to two big leaguers, which is why I like this article. Neil Ramirez, he's a cubby, and Justin Grimm, the reaper. But both cubs, both guys throw hard mid to upper 90s. And, you know, this is anecdotal evidence, but the baseball think tank, they're asking these pro pitchers that throw hard, like, man, what was it like being a teenager? You know, when did you throw a curveball or how did you get to throw the ball so hard? And they're like, you know, I was always just trying to, like, I think it was Neil Ramirez or one of the two guys was saying, I always try to throw the ball through the glove at the first baseman when I played shortstop. And it got to the point my coach had to ask me to stop because I kept throwing it so hard it would hurt.
hurt the kid's hand or it pulls glove off you know and he says he claims that all the big flamethrowers that he works with they're all guys i got there and just tried to throw it as hard as they can now i'm not advocating that you tell your kid we'll just go out there and throw it as hard as you can you're gonna make a million dollars one day but um he brings up a good point you know if you're constantly worried about finesse and you're not out there exposing your arms to higher demands to a degree is it possible that throwing a curveball where you have to slow your arm down a little bit at least according to the literature where there's less there's less stress and forces going through the arm Yeah, sure. I can see that. You know, if you become a finesse pitcher and you're more worried about starting it at the hip and putting it over the plate and then you don't develop the command with your fastball, does that at least make sense? Sure. Yeah, I can see that. You know, if you take your focus off developing, working the inner half or the outer half or starting to spot your fastball up with two strikes or keep it down to try to get a ground ball in a double play situation. Like, yeah, I think you have to, you have to, everybody at the pro level pitches minus like knuckleballers. They pitched off their fastball, relatively speaking. They're setting guys up with it or they're trying to induce outs with it. And then they use their off-speed pitches to change, you know.
timing to try to induce weak contact. So by and large, as a youth, could introducing curveballs really affect how you develop your fastball? Sure, I'm not sure if I'm ready to get on that bandwagon, but it's an interesting thought. And, you know, if we look at just some of the other arguments that are out there, I remember growing up as a kid that as soon as you would see a kid with a big nasty curveball, the thing that would chatter through the dugout, and again, this was, I don't know, 20, 25 years ago, chatter through the dugout was, oh, he's just going to have arm pain when he gets older. I mean, so there's an element of fear as a kid being at a dugout. You know, you just saw one of your buddies, his elbows start to hurt and his doctor said, oh, you can't throw for at least six weeks and you got a big tournament up. And now all of a sudden you're fearful about throwing a curveball.
I mean, perception is a big deal with pain. I mean, the current pain science that's out there, and we can touch base on another podcast about this, but the way you perceive pain and the way you perceive a movement pattern or a stressor is super, super important. So another driving purpose behind this podcast is we want to remove some of the myths out there, things that just don't hold a lot of water but are commonplace. And if that can help a kid feel more comfortable with learning a curveball, hey, this has proven to be relatively safe if you do it right and we do it at the right time and at the right frequency. which we still don't know those answers, but at least gives you kind of like the sense of security as opposed to, well, I have no idea what's going to happen. I just know everybody gets hurt, which is not true. And now you don't feel sure about it. And you're throwing a pitch with less than 100 percent conviction. And I mean, whether it gets hit over the fence or your elbow hurts, I mean, neither of those are good results. So in my opinion, you know, let's.
Let's at least challenge those thoughts, those ideas. Let's try to remove that conversation from our kids and their kids' heads where, hey, that kid throws a lot of curveballs. He's just going to hurt himself. Let's make this more about being prepared, being educated, and making good decisions as to when and how much and when should we rest and when should we learn a curveball and when should we work on those pitches, those types of things. I know I didn't answer your question, but you might have to ask me again. I wanted to bring it up because it's a real thing. It's a thing out there, and I don't want parents and kids to walk away and think about throwing a curveball and just be terrified to do such a thing. It almost seems like you're advocating training with intent, throwing with intent. Nailed it.
Ah, okay. Intense or inside of tense? Yeah, intense. Shout out to Kyle Bodie and drive on baseball. I love their focus on intent. I think it's a huge thing that kids and trainers miss nowadays is that if you want to throw hard, you have to intend to throw hard. And we can get to that later. But yeah, man, that's a great point. You know, I have a lot of parents. You know, I treat a lot of kids who've got overuse injuries, little league elbow, little league baseball. Had a couple young kids with Tommy John issues. And I end up spending a lot of my time in clinic when the kids are doing their exercises, talking to the parents a little bit. And they kind of pick my brain and ask questions. And I've talked to parents about curveballs before.
I give the same advice. I kind of talk about saying, you know, you want to make sure your kid is strong enough and has the right kind of can check all the boxes to be able to pitch first and foremost before you worry about throwing a curveball. And a lot of times that isn't the case. You get a kid who just tends to be out there and happens to throw harder than his other guys on his team and can get up innings. And that's how you tend to get these overuse injuries. But in my opinion, you know, there has to be some.
some boxes that check, so to speak, before you just allow a kid to get out there on the mound and start just throwing hammers. You know what I mean? So I talk to parents and I basically say, you know, the big point of the big focus of what we do in rehab is we don't just look at your son's elbow, look at your kid's shoulder. We're trying to approach them holistically and take a look and see, you know, what kind of athlete are there and how can we then prepare them to go back and return to their sport and be successful and not have these same issues? What are some things that we were missing beforehand? And so that's a big focus of how I tend to look at stuff. Obviously, you know, we're trying to treat this out of pain.
If a kid has elbow pain, we're trying to work on the elbow specifically. But I do think that you're doing a huge disservice to your athletes if you just look at the elbow. Obviously, you've got to look at the shoulder. You need to look at the thoracic spine. Look at the hips. Look at their core. Look at their legs. You need to look at everything. Because throwing a baseball is not a...
not an individual movement you're not trying to isolate the rear delt or the infraspinatus muscle it's you're literally using your toes and fingertips and everything in between to try to throw a baseball as hard as you can to home plate and if you don't address different issues kind of up and down the chain you know who knows you could be looking at looking at some injuries or some uh some pain down the road so that's the discussion i tend to have these parents is like look you know i think curveballs are obviously a very effective out pitch but you know let's make it let's first and foremost get your kid strong get your kid moving the right way and then look at his mechanics when he throws and then we can have that conversation you know, to keep in perspective too, I say this frequently to the clients I work with, um, cause there will be times and unfortunately there's going to be people out there that are going to listen to this that are, and I say this, unfortunately you're doing all the right things, but unfortunately your kiddo still gets hurt or you have some athletes that get hurt. And that's why I love the injury surveillance kind of verbiage, but it's.
Everybody's gotten a new car or at least bought something that's important to them. And if you use it enough, you take the car out of the garage enough, it's going to get a ding in it no matter where you park it. You can't always park it in the back corner of the Target parking lot and walk two blocks to get to Target. At the end of the day, you do have to get a little lucky. You have to have some good fortune. But to keep in perspective that you might go out there and your kid's never had an elbow problem or shoulder or whatever the case may be, a pain with throwing. And then you teach them a curveball and you have the right coach and you have a good plan in place. And if all of a sudden, six weeks later,
Two months later, something starts hurting. One, don't jump shit. Don't throw the baby out with the bathwater. Don't say, oh, it's a damn curveball. There's so many variables that go into it. So I think our point here is let's do what we know science is telling us from the best evidence that we have. Hopefully 10 years from now, we'll revisit this subject and we'll have some different opinions. If we don't, then I guess that's as good as it's going to get or we just quit looking. I mean, this is an evolving field. I think that's why Blair and I love it so much. It's a puzzle. You can't ever solve it. So we're just going to keep.
putting good information out there, giving you guys a platform to at least make some decisions on. And then ultimately you have to make a decision that you, your coach and your son can sleep on at night and feel comfortable with that. That's the big thing. And I think that's the driving focus. The purpose behind this podcast is just to remove that gap of information. So everybody that can sit down at the table and make a good decision and that the people out there just selling crap or the people out there just selling buzzwords and saying things like core and movement patterns and injury prevention. And they just rattle off all these things that don't even make any sense. Um, it's, it's,
We're kind of throwing them out from the shadows and making them stand up on their platform. And you as a parent now can go toe-to-toe with them and have a good conversation that benefits the person that needs to be benefited, and that's the athlete. Absolutely, man. So to kind of wrap up this article, I think that curveballs, should kids throw them? The big answer is we don't know. We do know that kids who are good and throw more and are exposed to a higher volume of pitching throughout the year, they need to be monitored closely. Obviously, we know that the workloads are what tends to be responsible for these types of injuries. And so if you have a kid who's a stud and he's throwing all the time, maybe you need to take a close look at his overall workload, kind of see if you are giving him some.
time off for the year uh you know not letting him pitch when his arm's tired things like that and number two was just you know kids need to get stronger kids need to move better uh so does your does your athlete have a you know movement practice in place are they doing some weight lifting some weight training are they working with a strength coach are they doing some things in their high school weight room are they doing more than just running poles and doing some band work i think kids need to kind of develop some resiliency in the weight room and just kind of out and do some explosive work on their own so yeah that's kind of my takeaway you agree steve yeah absolutely All right, guys. Well, thank you for joining us again for another episode of the RBI Performance Podcast. It's been great having you guys just kind of be our audience, and we appreciate all the support. And we'll be back next week to talk to you about long-term athletic development. All right, Steve. Good talking to you, buddy. Be cool.