Good morning, everyone. It's the Cat and Cloud podcast. Today, we've got part two of Source, a green buying panel hosted by Cafe Imports. So this is an event that we jumped in on at this year's Specialty Coffee Association Expo in Houston, Texas. And if you listen to part one, you already know this. If you don't, it was a panel of four people who are deep in the green buying community exploring what it means to be a modern green buyer or what it means to navigate through the modern green buying climate. So part one was...
me kind of moderating this conversation and pulling information out of the panelists a lot of really good discussions mostly on how the sea market works and a deep dive on tariffs and how they were going to affect every single part of the industry and this part is audience q a so we had really thoughtful questions from the people who showed up to spend time with us and it was very enlightening to see where everyone's heads at to see how much people care and how hungry people are to learn about this stuff so here is q a from the green buying panel again we've got omar susan charlie and piero on the mic so grateful for you to share all of your knowledge so grateful to cafe imports for putting this on and everybody who showed up let's get into it we've got some questions that are pre-games and we had a little app but i think the room seems manageable enough if anybody has anything that they want to chime in on just like throw up a hand butt in yell whatever we can we can make anything work so yeah Thanks. I would just like to know, on the side of the consumer, you guys aren't necessarily interacting with them a lot. And so if you could, through the cafe owners and the baristas, communicate to somebody that you have like 10, 30 seconds to communicate this value and what's changing here, how would you guys communicate that? Yeah, is it not enough?
what i do i don't know because i also used to be a barista and i remember there was i forget what year it was it was like 2009 2010 there was a jump in the sea market that's when we learned what the sea market was that year because suddenly like the roasting company that i worked for was you know had to increase their prices at retail and so all of us got a little like quick little education on what the sea market was and why it impacted all of our direct trade coffees and is it enough to just say coffee is more expensive than it has ever been it's not i mean um Your guests probably love coffee, but they love the way you make them feel even more. So leading the conversation with coffee, if you're trying to maneuver through this and you're putting coffee at the front, I think you've already lost as passionate as we are about this. Like I've spent my life, my whole modern life being a part of this industry because I fell in love with this thing. And sometimes it's.
Interesting to know that that thing is actually secondary to the interaction that you have with the people. It's like you want to create a place where people feel seen, where people trust you, where people have the best times of their lives, where people go and immediately leave and want to tell all of their friends about what they experienced at this shop, this crew. And it just it has to hit in the emotions. And I think that is one of the things that some of us have done well. But as a whole industry, there's so much more room to grow in that way. And one of the things.
that gets in the way of that is interestingly enough coffee sometimes and i'm as guilty of that as anybody else you know um i remember being a new barista finding all this stuff and all i wanted to do is just shove specialty coffee down the throats of everybody it's like you will love this this is worth a lot of money a lot of people work really hard and it's it's brilliant and i and people are tasting it like this i don't i don't get it you know i don't get it i can tell it's different than what i've been drinking but i just don't really understand um So a little bit of humility with the product, putting that behind the guest interaction. And then once, you know, once people are emotionally connected with you, they'll follow you anywhere. And then you have that trust and they know that you're not just raising prices just to raise prices. Or, I mean, I'm sure everybody who has a business has been in the shop and, you know, someone comes in, there's a line out the door. It's booming. People are like, man, you guys are fucking killing it, huh? And I'm just like, this is awesome, but it's not what you think.
So that's my halfway answer to your question. Yeah, I think the answer also needs to be really individual. Like your answer is your own because coffee is such a small part of the, in terms of cost and raw materials of the beverage that goes over the counter and the margin on top of just the cost of coffee looks ridiculous, right? It's like 90% or something over the cost, the actual cost of raw material, roasting and production, et cetera. It's like a few cents per gram ultimately. And it's like, you're selling someone a $5 cup of coffee. And it's like, that margin looks ridiculous to a customer, but you also have a business and you have people you're taking care of and you have properties and you know.
insurance and things like that. And it's like, it sucks to just say like, oh, everything's so expensive. I'm sorry. You know, but you have your own answer depending on your own business and your own people. I think it's not always, it's not just the coffee. Right. And then one of the things that makes me feel a little bit more comfortable about this is if the, if the cost is going up in the way that we've seen it going up, it's not going up for just you. It's going to go up for everyone. So someone's going to have to lead the market in these price increases if we have them, but eventually everyone's still going to be in the same ballpark price wise. You know, and we see that where we're at. I see that here, specialty coffee roasters, specialty coffee retailers,
The pricing's not so different in most of them. Everyone's pretty price competitive. So you won't be alone in this journey. So maybe there's some, you know, some friendship in that. I think one thing at SA which has been really great is...
seeing everybody here and knowing that we're all kind of in this together. But I think because of what's happening and we are businesses, we have things we have to pay, that self-preservation and not wanting that to kind of take priority over why we got into this in the first place. And so I think one question I have is we're kind of on different perspectives and we have different things. We're daily dealing with like, yeah, dealing with customers is hard, but on the roaster side, it's like having these conversations and sometimes having that trust in that long relationship isn't enough because of like what you were saying, those people had to make in Honduras the decision that was best for themselves that year. So sometimes those relationships aren't going to really like people have to make decisions they need to.
But what do you think from y'all's perspective and talking with people and also being on the other side that we don't see all this kind of, again, navigating under the one kind of mission with coffee and what we're trying to do? How can we best communicate and kind of rely on each other to get through this together? Because we all are trying to do the same thing while also trying to survive. So it's kind of your advice for that, if that makes sense. I don't know. I think like everybody is in it together. You know, survival is number one. Like you want to wake up tomorrow, have your business, be able to continue. And for the Honduras example, for the buyers who didn't get that coffee, it's not like it's over.
but their understanding is now a part of the relationship. Even if they don't get the coffee, the relationship is probably better, right? Because it's had this test and now they understand more the perspective of the community that's growing the coffee and their constraints and their opportunities. And it's like, it's kind of a win for everybody. You know, I don't see it as like people making decisions for their own survival so that they can continue in business with the best intentions. I don't really see that as alienating. I think it actually means we have more in common. That's my perspective. Yeah, I also, it can feel so isolating when you're going through hard times and I feel like we're all going through hard times.
And as trite as it sounds, I think really leaning into the relationships and increasing communication, it's more effort, but it's a great chance to lean on your importers and say, hey, we would love, can you have, apologies if I'm already, I'm going to fill up your time here with this, but we would love, could we do a Zoom call with our baristas and get a producer on the call and have an hour where they get to ask questions, where we can say, like, we've all worked a long time to establish our relationships, both as their supply chains, but same with you and your customers. So inviting them into the conversation, because once you understand what someone's going through, I think there just leads to a lot more empathy and understanding instead of just seeing that. increase so that's one thing that comes to mind yeah i think one of the other things is just transparency uh in the community you know one of the things that i fell in love with one of the reasons i fell in love with coffee was that was i remember being a barista a long time ago and people kind of sharing things sharing recipes i remember the first time someone let me use their chemex you know and i was like revolutionary um but i think that it's happening even amongst us you know um i'm talking to our competition a lot more than i ever have um i'm aware a lot more of what other people are doing and and it seems like people are more willing to share information because
Right now, a lot of us don't really know what will happen on Monday, right? We might wake up to something completely different, and we won't know how to navigate that readily. So I think part of it is that central pillar of specialty coffee, transparency, not just in the downward stream where we need to know what the farm gate price is, but transparency in all regards in the industry. So I think keeping yourself open to that and not being afraid to ask questions and be genuine, I think that that's probably one of the better ways to find support here. If producers and roasters want to dream about more fair and stable, less volatile pricing, do you think the best path forward to do that is learning to use the futures pricing for futures tools better or to try to break away from the sea price and find other ways to price coffee?
One anecdote for me personally is in January, I was in Nicaragua for a week. And then in March, I was in Honduras for a week. And both of those weeks were spent visiting basically like as many cooperatives as I could who sell coffee to Royal. And a lot of them have been selling coffee to us for many, many years, some of them multiple decades. And one question I asked everybody because of where the market was, was if you could choose.
a coffee price in the sea market to keep forever? Is there a price that you think would be the best for you? And almost everybody answered, everybody but one answered something like 225 cents or 240 cents, just because in their experience, that was a level where they could cover their costs, their associates in the cooperative were happy. And people wanted to buy the coffee because it wasn't too expensive. Okay. And that answer comes from just like, in some cases, just decades of dealing with the market and not really imagining a world outside of it. And one of the oldest cooperatives that we buy from, that's also the smallest and quite remote and had a history of vegetable farming before they got into coffee a while ago. I asked them the same question and the manager thought about it for a moment. And then he said, why would we use the market? I would just choose a price that gets, you know, an okay profit for everybody so that the farmers are happy and then we can sell the coffee there. And it just was not.
He didn't even he didn't think about the market, even though he uses the market all the time. And he sells, for the most part, low differential, non-certified coffee. Like he's he's quite low in the quality spectrum. And he was just like, why would I use the market? And so I think it's really difficult for people. If the coffee market is the whole atmosphere around you, it's hard to imagine a system outside of it, because why would you if you have to wake up and go to work and you have to you have to survive in a market scenario? I think a lot of people who do.
I'm talking about exporters now who do hedge their coffee and do use the market. I think if they're equipped enough to use it, I think they would probably say that it is valuable because hedging is a form of safety for them. And I think, you know, other people who are smaller and more vulnerable would probably choose a fixed price. But I don't think that necessarily everybody in the world hates the coffee market. I think some people have learned to live with it, frankly. And, you know, a year like this.
As difficult as it is and what it does to change competition for coffee in the field or constraints on exporters or the renegotiation of contracts, defaults, whatever, it's still actually a year of great relief for coffee farmers all over the world who suddenly have maybe some of the highest prices they've ever seen. Like this is for some people, for probably a lot of coffee farmers, this is what they have been waiting for, you know? And I don't think they would trade, maybe they would trade that for us, you know, they would train it for a sustainable fixed price. But I think not knowing what that is and not having that offer on the table, most people are accustomed to working with the market. And if they're sophisticated enough, it works for them.
Not everybody fantasizes about a world outside of it. Yeah, it's really hard. I think that in this industry, we're all kind of looking for fairness. Coffee, maybe this is like a hot take, but it's inherently unfair. It's extractive.
So we just have to try to do our best. Again, like I said earlier, the sea market's inescapable, right? So it's going to exist for a very long time unless something catastrophic happens. I'm not sure how to dismantle that system. It's something that we have to learn how to live with, which we already are. I think one of them is, one way to do it is knowing more. Like I said, the transparency, knowing where your coffee comes from, being curious about that.
One of the major drawbacks of the sea market is that it's not based on costs, right? So I think that that's first and foremost knowing what costs are. We've got several projects where we try to do that with, at least in Colombia, where we try to do that with some of the producers. But at the same time, that's all volatile, right? So the prices that we're talking about today, a year from now, might be completely different. Again, land value, cost of labor, fertilizers, things like that. So I think one of them is just knowing where your product comes from and also kind of generating that trust with whoever your provider is, whether that's an importer, exporter, or producer.
um i think it's not enough to just say like all right we're gonna buy fixed price coffees or we're gonna continue working with within the sea market i think um just adding a little bit more of that knowledge uh and finding out a little bit more about who the the growers are what the supply chain is i think will also help you kind of justify any potential price increases or justify a coffee that you might think is in price unattainable um Because like Chris said earlier, your customers follow you. They follow your brand. And it's the same for us, right? We have people we've been working with for 30 years, 25 years, who trust us, who know that what we're doing is in good faith. So yeah, I think asking questions and finding out more about your coffee is kind of a good start.
So going on price stability on the producer side, I think probably one of the things that the industry lacks right now is having small producers be able to access market accounts. Why? One is that it's expensive because you have margin calls. Basically, when the market goes up and down, you have to feed your account to cover the change. But one of the really interesting things that I heard last night was that there's this company that provides a service.
they're giving producers the option to do fractions of, so you don't have to trade a future to fix your price, but you can do 20 bags, 30 bags, 40 bags, which I think is great for small producers. And I think that's a really good way to producers to have some sort of a safety net, hedge their beds, fix a price once they know that they can cover their costs. So yeah, I think that's kind of interesting, and I think it's probably something that's going to change in the next couple of years. I'll speak to a related topic, not just on the price and whether it's fixed price or price to be fixed, but just about how financing works for many groups in that before the harvest starts, most groups, all groups I work with need to go to the bank, whether it's a local bank that has a pretty high percentage of finance rate or maybe a social lender like Robobank or Root and present a contract to say, I have a buyer. So, you know, an importer or trade, here's the contract, here's the value of the coffee, you know, can you give me a loan so that I can cover my costs during harvest? This might be.
months and months and months before the coffee arrives and before a roaster takes it. But as importers are unable to carry as much spot inventory, you might see our spot list going down over time. It's because of that high risk. And so when we're reaching out to our roaster partners to say, hey, I know that the coffee from last year landed not too long ago, but can you give us an idea of volume? It's not just because we want to get the sale. It's because
I need to go back. I need to write a contract in order for that producer to get financing. And with the market so high, it's been really hard for a lot of groups to get that financing because banks don't want to be like, well, that's a lot of risk. It's worth even more. So a lot of conversations I've had the last couple of days are, you know, groups need contracts. And like Omar said, the cherries don't wait. So they're ripening on the trees, but they can't pay the farmers until they have those contracts. One more quick example.
of sometimes the constraints of trying to work in a fixed price market. Yesterday morning, I was talking to an exporter who works in Burundi who sold a lot of her coffee prior to a big increase in the global market. And what she found when it came time to export the coffee was that the National Coffee Board in Burundi started to refuse exports that were priced below the current sea market price because in their mind, they were protecting or defending their cash crop and its maximal value. Even some producers or exporters with the best intentions who want to regulate prices, who have a price that works for them, and they want to acknowledge their contracts, there can still be constraints against working that way. Because in the case of Burundi, some people were shut down and their exports were denied, and they needed to get a new set of contracts from their buyers. And some exporters were forced to renegotiate their own contracts against their will to show the government, yes, we're taking advantage of the market. So that's a quick example of the ubiquity of the coffee market in people's thinking. And even if you are a coffee producer or a coffee exporter,
You don't always have the freedom to just do what you want. Like there are constraints against this. There are lending constraints against it. There are logistical constraints against it, security constraints against it. And even if you choose to negate the presence of the market, it still is still around you, you know, and it still impacts the people's thinking around you. I remember when I used to work for a roasting company during a really low year in the market and we were paying, you know, we were buying most of our containers around like $4 per pound FOB or something in the market was at like $1.07 or something. And I was talking with our CEO.
who loves coffee, didn't know a lot about coffee supply chains. And we were walking and talking and he was like, oh, I just had a cup of, you know, the Sumatra coffee that you bought. And it's one of the best coffees in the world. It's one of the best coffees in the world, isn't it? And I was like, yes, I think so. And he was like, great, great, great. Anyways, I've heard that the sea market is very low. Is this something we can take advantage of? And I'm like, no, we can't. So even it's like in daily conversations with people, with business owners, and especially on the export side, it's just sort of like, you can talk about your coffees and that's one thing, but also like, we're also kind of thinking about the market all the time. You know, everyone's trying to take advantage of it. So yeah, there's constraints all around us.
Hey, guys. Something that I think I've seen with a lot of roasters and cafes, ourselves included, is that we all fall into the tendency a lot of times to just do like a cost plus pricing model. You know, buy coffee, punch number and spreadsheet, spits it out. That's what we're going to sell it at. And then, you know, a lot of roasters who have lagged behind with raising prices might be having to do so now. But is it ethical?
frowned upon too with this increased price to switch to a more values-based pricing model to where if we're seeing that consumers are willing to pay a certain price for our product even when the market price goes down that first of all can enable better more sustainable margins for our businesses and then second can obviously enable us to buy better more traceable copies um i think of you know example being uh i was in columbia a couple weeks ago and one of the producers was asking how the volatile sea market is affecting us. He's like, I don't know what's affecting you. I was just able to pay off all my debt. So, uh, and you know, that really puts it into perspective of if the sea market does taper down, what kind of standard can we as roasters set to not be willing to go back to that place? And how can we, you know, communicate amongst each other to, to make sure that happens? Because as Chris was saying, you know, a lot of times it's, you see, uh, you know, you're pricing according to your competitors and the people who are in the industry with you. So, you know, it, it almost takes trailblazing and courage to stay at that point. Um, so I don't know, just love your thoughts on that.
I mean, that's a great argument for relationship buying, I think, you know, something that works for both sides. That's great. Importers don't work. Well, I mean, you of course can answer for yourselves, but I would say almost no importers really work at a cost plus model necessarily. Like we talked a little bit about price averaging and things like that, but it's like, I'm sure all of us here have sold coffee at a loss before because of whatever circumstances. I mean, that's, that's normal. It's almost inconceivable with the current tariffs and the ability for the coffee market to change so quickly. It's almost inconceivable that somewhere we aren't going to lose a lot of money just because we can't keep up with the changes, you know? And it might be that an individual coffee is profitable.
because we can bring it in and sell it at a cost plus, but it might be that overall we're starting to lose money because we're not keeping up with a lot of the changes. So I don't know that importers are the best answer to that question. I think buyers, meaning roasters and producers are the best answer to that question because importers being in the middle, like we're facilitators of these agreements and what roasters bring to me, for example. an agreement that they have set with somebody, then we're just facilitating the movement of the coffee and maybe some financing, et cetera, depending on what the roaster needs. But it's like, we're not trying to change a roaster's calculation of a value of a coffee if they've worked it out with the producer of that coffee. I just think the question is best answered by the two most important people for that coffee, which is the person who's selling it and the final person who's buying it. I don't know that an importer really can answer that. Just another vote for relationship coffee.
Well, thank you to this panel for all these interesting conversations and the questions. But I did want to ask, just to like end on a positive note, you know, we've heard a lot of like the... I would love to expand on the cons of the high market and the high prices on farmers, but what are the pros of this current situation for farmers? You have also touched upon that, but some more expansion, because I feel like a lot of my customers ask me, they're like, you know, I'm okay with paying these prices if it's actually going to the farmer. I get that question a lot of like, okay, the sea market is high, but how much of that is actually going to the farmer? I feel like I know the answer to that, but I would love to hear your perspective on that. And then I feel like something also interesting that I feel like I've been seeing is just like, how primordial is...
the u.s as a coffee market for green coffee buyers is there like a new competition of other um even like internal markets for the consumption of specialty coffee um i just it's like this perspective of like the u.s being like the center of the world and how this is changing and i i love it obviously but it just that perspective on the green coffee side i feel like there's this new reality that we're it's changing so what are your thoughts on that Okay, I'll go first and then I'll pass the mic. We talked about some of the price relief from the perspective of growers who, again, if you have options for selling locally and if you have local buyers and you have an okay relationship with them, local prices can be really, really good. And there was the example of a grower paying off his debts. How are you doing in the market? I love that answer. So, I mean, that's one example. Another one that's sort of bittersweet, I think, is the pressure on roasting companies and consumers to adjust to higher prices. I remember...
I don't know, 10 or so years ago, having a conversation with an importer who worked for a multinational company. And he was kind of like, well, get ready for $10 coffee. That's where it's going. And that was his talking point at the time, which was like, be ready for a future where there's less coffee and it's more expensive. And it might also be more expensive because, well, there's more coffee, but there's also a lot more consumer competition, which we're also seeing. So I think there's definitely a bittersweet aspect of it because it does hurt when you have to adjust your business model and raise prices on consumers. But it also is preparing us for a world where there could be a lot more volatility. We could go from here to 50 cents to $10. I don't know.
Um, but being flexible and learning how you can adjust to stay in business, you'll never forget those lessons, I think. And that's a good, it's a good stress to have right now. You know what I mean? And then one other quick example regarding consumption is, um, in Sumatra in particular, one thing that we're noticing is that local coffee consumption is like, has really been popping off for the last few years. So coffee roasters in Jakarta or Maidan, for example, who, you know, they're cousins with cooperative members or whatnot up in the Aceh area in Northern Sumatra, where there's a lot of coffee being produced, um, tend to compete with.
with international buyers for the best local coffees. Like I've had so many experiences and not just recently, but like, I don't know, eight years ago or something, visiting growers in Aceh and finding out that the coffee that they keep for themselves, because everyone drinks coffee in Aceh for the most part, that the coffee they save for themselves is actually picked over like 10 times better than any like double pick grade one that they tend to export that the cooperatives do. So it's long been my experience that the best place in the world to drink Sumatra coffee is not in San Francisco, it's in Sumatra. And this is like... I think a well-kept secret for most people, but it's like, you get like amazing fermentations and amazing results in local coffee shops in very small towns, like up and down the island of Sumatra and Java. Why? Because local consumption is becoming really, really sophisticated and local buyers are willing to pay, you know, $9 a kilo for a coffee that would otherwise export at, you know, $3.20 a pound or something in like a more average market. And it's like, well, who are we to compete with that? Like, we have to let it go. You know, I guess we just have to keep going back to Sumatra. Like I used to joke that like, it should be, there should be a world where you have to go to Rwanda to drink the best Rwandan coffees. Like I should be,
Flying there, spending my tourism dollars. I should be visiting farms. I should be having an experience on the earth where the coffee comes from. I should be shown what the best coffee is. I shouldn't have to go to San Francisco to drink the best Rwandan coffees. And I see that more and more in Indonesia, which makes me really happy. And most people kind of don't know this is happening because we're used to the typical export grades from Sumatra. But that was one of my favorite things about being a Sumatra buyer was just getting to be there to drink the good stuff.
Yeah, just echoing what Charlie said, I think one of the cool things of these high prices that's showing us that we can do that, right? We can operate in this world where we are paying people more money. You know, I come to my team all the time, my sales team. I don't really sell coffee so much. But I'm always like, hey, can I buy this coffee? It's a lot more expensive than last year. A lot of times they say, no, that's not going to be possible. Most of the time I do it anyway. And then the coffee sells.
So it's always kind of a testament to like, these things are possible, right? And especially if the entire industry is moving that way, it's not like I'm buying a $40 a pound coffee in a full container when coffee prices are super low. I think that it shows us that we can keep kind of going and pushing the needle a little bit, especially in a world where all of us are being affected by high prices. To your question on internal consumption, yeah, I think it's really awesome. You know, Mexico, for example, has a really, really awesome coffee scene. They've got a pretty strong economy as well that supports that. People are super interested in coffee.
There are a lot of people there who are getting into coffee, like people who are starting to produce coffee, you know, who don't come from a heritage of coffee, which I think is a really beautiful thing as well. And I think it's increasing competition for us, which I always welcome. You know, it's always nice to have a little bit of competition. Some people in Mexico internally and coffee roasters pay really, really good prices for local coffee. So it's really nice to be able to go to Origin and have the really good stuff there, usually pretty fresh. So I think it's wonderful.
Yeah, and I think we see that, like Omar was saying, in Mexico, a lot of times we get actually priced out of the market where we're competing with the local roasters and they're actually being able to pay a lot more, way more, maybe three times more what we could pay for this coffee. So yeah, I think it's a great thing. It's also challenging for us if we want to get coffee from these countries that have a very strong internal consumption. And then going back to your question, are producers getting all this price? I would say yes. Probably, I don't know if I had to guess.
probably at least 75 to 80% of FOB price is probably a good, good estimate of, of what they're getting. So, so yeah, I think obviously there's other costs involved, but, but yeah, I think, I think producers are actually getting most of the share of the pie right now, which is, which is good. Oh, uh, okay. So I've been working mostly in Honduras in terms of, hi, hi friends. Uh, relationship, relationship's really important. Uh, the relationships we have in Honduras are amazing. It's.
So I guess it'd be eight years now I've been going and all these things are resonating that we're talking about today. And something that has been just consistently challenging for me and I think us as a company is you want to find this emotional connection from guest to producer and you want to find a way to support. So, you know, it's gonna be a little bit long-winded, but you're talking about these factors that are so real. We start, we find these relationships, we set a great price, quality's good, this is awesome. We're buying all your coffee, you're new, you're coming up. And then we have this volatility in the amount of coffee coming and going, right? So when we're producers, we're buying all your coffee, we're in this with you for the end, till the end, 20 bags next year, 60 bags all of a sudden. And we're like,
We're going to figure this out. And this is a long winded way of saying a couple of things and asking some questions. Have you seen people taking unique approaches to support producers in different ways? And the Best Friends Club for us is one way of doing that where we kind of we tried to find a way to bring value and specific money directly to our producers in relationship and skip all the supply chain. And the reason I'm bringing that up isn't so much to talk about the Best Friends Club. It's exactly what you're saying with in talking to our producers. All of a sudden, also fertilizer is so expensive. We actually can't find anybody to pick cherry. So we are screwed. You know, like there's nobody. There's whatever a conglomerate of.
20 to 50 people who are available for the entire mountain of El Cedral or Santa Barbara Mountain. And so this is kind of a long winded question of, have you heard other, other approaches people might be using to try to connect and find a way to bring value to the producers while this, while this changes something that could be a little bit of a fix, like we got your back no matter what. And that's why. where the Best Friends Club came from. It's a dollar set aside per pound that just skips the entire food supply chain. And then we give it back to the producers that we work with that are in that program. And it is very much specifically relationship-based because we'll get there and I'll have these conversations like, you know, we need prices to come up. We need to pay, we need to buy more coffee at a higher price. I'm like, that is awesome. We'd love to do that. How, you know, and how does this all work? So anyways, and I don't know if you want to jump in on anything more, Chris, just because we talk about this all the time, but that was one of the solutions that...
That came to the table mostly in COVID and at the time there was two hurricanes and it was horrible for them to sell coffee at all. And it was a way to try to find connection hoping, okay, if our guests, if we can start showing pictures and stories about these people and say, if you buy this coffee, when we bring in 60 bags that we actually have no technical place to sell on our menu compared to what we're expecting to, you know, for our forecasting, can you buy more of this because it actually matters and you're actually helping? It was kind of this interesting connection. So is there anything that other people might be able to do? And I know that maybe looks like a way of cutting out potential business for some of you all. So I don't want it to sound like we're trying to do that because I totally understand that there's a need to supply everybody and protect and be a part of a sustainable business community. But have you heard of anything else? And I'd love to hear some because I'd also like to be encouraged, if I'm honest. Yeah, I don't know if I've heard of too many new things or anything like that. But one of the things that I know that we probably all do is bring a little bit of humanity to the decisions that we make, right? So as you're saying, remember that it's a relationship. Remember that relationships take work and that we have to think about the future, right? So if things are tough right now, how can we remember that?
We still want to work with this person in the future, and that takes a little bit of flexibility. So being flexible with things like cup scores, especially when quality is super down. I like to treat cup scores like they're negligible, like it's just not a thing. Obviously, we've created the system in the industry, specialty coffee, where they are the most important thing. They assess value. I don't know much about the CBA, but maybe that addresses something, or I don't know much about what's going on there. But I think that that's part of it, just remembering that it's a relationship, remembering that we can be flexible, remembering that when prices go up, maybe our prices need to go up too, that if a coffee doesn't quite hit the 83-point mark.
remember that it's still really, really amazing coffee. So that's definitely one of them, bringing humanity to the table. The other one that is a little bit more technical, and I think that maybe all of us do this, and at least at Cafe Imports, we have the capacity to pre-finance. It's kind of stupid in a way. It's unsecured lending that we give to people where we don't really have recourse to get it back, right? But we do that with a lot of relationships that we trust, relationships that are 15 years old. In communities in Wheela, where I work in, we're working with the exporter to get money into the hands of producers when the harvest starts. Someone has to pay for that cost of financing, you know, as well.
But that's a huge thing, right? I talked about how prices are really high right now where a producer can deliver coffee. They pick it today, depulp it, and they can deliver it tomorrow for a very, very good price. Things are also really volatile, so they want to act fast. What I've seen is that when you ease that up for a producer, when you're able to get money into their hands a lot earlier, they can make decisions based on their brand and not just because they need to do it, right? They can say, okay, I'm going to make the best coffee possible. I'm going to take my time to do it. I have this window of time. So that's, I think, in our, at least mine and Piero's tool chest, probably one of the biggest.
um things that helps and i think that it also uh is indicative in the fact that it's um the coffee is usually better when people have time to invest in it so pre-financing and then yeah humanity So yeah, going off on how can we add value? Yeah, pre-financing definitely. We have a couple different parchment buying operations. So we're also able to pay producers in advance or basically when they deliver the coffee versus when the coffee ships. So I think that's also an advantage to us to get access to these coffees and also to get money into the producer's hands quicker. So that's one thing. Another thing that I'm working on right now in Ecuador, the south of Ecuador has probably more traditional landholders.
that basically survive off of their land. And we're planning on taking them up north where the coffee production is a little bit more technified. And we're going to give them some training, show them different processes, pruning techniques, post-harvest fermentation, et cetera. So yeah, I think that's another way that I think that we can also add value with training. Yeah, a couple things that came to mind are just you spoke to like the longevity of the relationship that has been so big. It's so let's say you can't afford to buy as many bags at the higher prices. Someone mentioned, you know, guaranteed, you know, coffee comes in all different qualities. So that producer or that group absolutely has maybe a slightly lower quality coffee. So maybe you can support them by.
buying even two grades and highlighting that for your, for your clients to be like, Hey, this comes from the same group. And you know, here's, here's, here's a little bit about processing. So that's one way. Um, another way I think is just a chance to be more collaborative. Um, I, uh, have been working hard to sell coffee from Congo for a long time. I think it's underrepresented, undervalued. It's really hard to, you know, it has a long way to go in a lot of challenges. Um, there is a group I absolutely love. Um, I'm just going to say a plug rebuild women's hope, Marceline and many other groups that we have worked with in Ghana, other really great cooperatives. And sometimes I don't have the demand as much as I,
value the relationship went out to dinner last night good friends and producer will come up and say this other importer really wants to buy our coffee but you've been working so hard i just want to kind of have this conversation and i know it's going to be slightly different for everyone you know you don't you don't want to be like working in the exact same market trying to buy the same coffee it might be counterproductive for how much of that individual coffee sells but i was like awesome like first of all you know that's really kind that you came to me but this is your choice and also if we can get more congolese coffee in the market then that's going to be a great thing for all of us. This is a chance for us to collaborate as an industry. So, you know, maybe you'll see Royal and imports carrying more Congolese coffee, one of the, you know, or I think that can only be a good thing where we're raising awareness of just the incredible breadth of where coffee comes from. So. Okay. The only, the only thing I have to add is.
There's two ways to do more with an individual coffee producer or an individual, let's say, cooperative. There's one unit of coffee production. If they're limited in quantity, you can increase the price, you can work to buy 100%. If they're maybe limited in quality, necessarily, you can work on the volume side in order to give more resources to that producer and reward them. So one thing that I really like to see in the roasting world is buyer's clubs. If you're a coffee roaster, if you have...
If you have leadership in your community, if you're a coffee roaster that other people look up to because of your knowledge and your participation and your experience, think about reaching out to other roasters that you get along with. Offer them an opportunity to also participate in buying, maybe not exactly the same coffee, but participating in buying some of the same volume from producers that you can't absorb. Like tripling your volume in one year for a local roaster is like, it's a lot to take on, you know? One way that... people typically will approach Royal about that is that they want to talk about their financing. It's like, hey, you typically hold coffee for me for like two months or three months before I have it all delivered and it's all paid. Do you think you could do it for six months? Like, what do you think about doing it for eight months? Like, we're here to talk about those kinds of questions. That's kind of an obvious first step, which is like, all right, I know I can roast the coffee eventually, but like, is my importer going to let me hold it in the warehouse that long? What does that mean? You know, that kind of thing. You can always talk about that. But one great way to also manage some of this is to get...
other roasters together and try and figure out how everybody can share a greater volume of the coffee. And then together, it's like maybe they're in your region. Maybe they're buddies of yours when you lived in a different city or something like that. You can figure out ways to share shipments of coffee. There are like a handful of examples of this that I have facilitated. And it's very cool. And I think.
This also ties into the question earlier about like, how do we stay connected to each other? It's like, well, if you're getting realistic about really wanting to buy everything that someone or a group produces in order to remove them from the volatility, really have a true anti-sea market relationship or something like that, then it's like, well, you should have somewhere to put all the volume. Reach out to your community and other roasters. I see this happen and a lot of times people say yes. Like it seems antithetical to competition, but.
This might be a hot take, but if you ask me, I don't think roasting companies really compete with one another on the coffee that's specifically in the bag. I think the competition is elsewhere. And I also think that, like, we have a lot in common, you know. We facilitate this for some roasters who then share green coffee or, you know, there might be a buyer from one roasting company buying a big variety of coffees. It's in one consolidated container and we import it and then the coffee gets delivered out to all the people in the buyer's club, you know. This can be a great way of doing it. As a roaster, you're kind of stepping into our world a little bit, which is like you have to make sure that your clients, you know, are...
you know, meeting their contract and they really are interested and they're honoring their prices. They're coming back next year. But in a tight knit community, this can be a super valuable thing. It gives you leverage. It gives you buying power. And you can always use that for good. You can use that to reward people. You can use that to kind of insulate a producer community or a particular person from, you know, the craziness of the market or something like that. I've seen it work really well. So buyers clubs.
Hi, good to see you all. Good to meet you. This is great. I appreciate the space and all the learning. My question kind of has to do with quality. How do you see quality changing or evolving as the market is at where it's at now? And do you see producers continue forth on their innovation in their processes? Are you encouraging it? How do you see it evolving? And then how do you see it continue to evolve even as there's the new CVA cupping stuff and Q grading?
Are you going to kind of like kind of what Omar said, you kind of go based on who your customer is. Are you going to go based on that? Are you going to go more on the cubbing sheet? Yeah, I just want to know your thoughts on how you're going to evolve, how you see quality evolving and how you see the market evolving in quality process. Yeah, I think I think we're seeing both.
both ends of the spectrum. Some producers are deciding to just sell locally, pick everything, greens, reds, ripe cherries, and just get quick cash. But I think in general, the industry has improved a lot in the last 15 years that have been involved in coffee. For example, I remember many years ago in Colombia, you would see super high moisture coffee, around 12%. And that's something that has improved quite a bit.
I mean, you see a lot of coffee now between 10 and 11 percent, which is perfect. So I think in general, yes, coffee has been improving. Processes have been improving. People have access to Facebook. There's groups where people talk about quality. So, yeah, definitely, I think we're seeing better quality more and more. But obviously, with the high C market, there's producers that choose to go the...
quote-unquote easy route or whatever they think is best for themselves and just sell a commercial coffee, which I think it's completely valid. So I would say both things. But in general, I think the industry is getting better and better in terms of quality. Yeah, at Cafe Imports, we have kind of a unique system in that we are buyers, so we focus on buying coffee. We have a sales team that focuses on selling coffee. And then we have a sensory analysis team that focuses on evaluating the coffee. Quality is one of those weird things that changes. It's based on fads.
it's highly subjective. As much as we want to pretend it's very objective with our little cupping sheets and notes and things like that and calculators. We have this thing called the Rose, which tries to eliminate a little bit of the numbers from evaluating coffee and focuses more on description, which I think is really brilliant. We still have a long way to go to perfect that and to perfect this entire system. One thing that we've been doing internally, we've got five buyers on staff. We've been communicating a lot more about what we see, not just in prices, but in terms of quality. We also talk to each other about how...
What our lab says, if it's a coffee that I have expectations for, I have a client lined up for it, and our lab comes back and says, oh, it's 83.5 points. It doesn't mean that we just can't buy it. It means that we just have to understand the coffee a little bit better for it to be able to move. Some of the conversations we've been having internally is just not focusing too much on just this arbitrary number. Like I said, our lab, it's not to say that they're wrong or that they're correct. I think that's impossible with a cupping score or a way to evaluate coffee outside of the physical analysis. It's a guide.
And especially in scenarios in which, you know, there's sometimes harvests where all the coffee is under 86 points, but people are still expecting 86 plus micro lots and high quality coffee. So we have to adjust for that. Right. And we have this system so that we are our cupping team. They know who these producers are. They also travel with us a lot, but their decision isn't made the same as we do. Right. So there's this purely analytical. They're looking at the coffee blindly and then they're giving that report to us where we're able to make the decision. So, again, maybe not looking at quality as just this like hard line.
right? That in order for it to be really good, it has to be 86.00 and above. And realizing that the quality falls on a spectrum and that we have stories to share. We have relationships to share. I love traveling with clients to Colombia and Mexico. It's really great because coffee usually tastes better when you know the person. Coffee usually tastes better when you've been there and when you're drinking on the farm. It can be objectively, if we had a machine, it can be the worst coffee you've ever had.
It tastes better when you're there, when you're smiling with people, when you know the story, when you know the hard work that's gone into this coffee. And I know that for most of the coffees that I purchased, not all, but most of them. But it's nice to be able to show a client that. And we've traveled to Columbia together and I've seen that with you as well. You know, like it's just a little bit better when you're there.
I'll add one thing to that and I'll pass it off for one more question because we're getting close to time. But one of the things we've seen in the retail space is market preference is playing such a huge role in what people want. The guest coming into the cafe has no idea whether that's 90, 84, 83, 87. They don't know the score. They know what it tastes like. They know what they like. So, and I thought it was interesting that you mentioned fads because.
10 years ago if you would have brought some of these naturally natural anaerobic things like we're drinking today to the table people been like what what what is this this is not what's happening right now but it is what's happening right now and it's it's interesting and yeah i don't really have an answer to that it's just uh it's an interesting note that your guests don't ultimately care about the score sheet they care about what they what they love like i love this tastes like jam i'm into it give me some more um one more for you and then we'll wind this bad boy down uh this is a little bit more of a comment than a question uh tying it back to what you were saying with uh competition and all that um We're all here to look at cool equipment and stuff like that, but I also think it's good for us to talk and kind of tie in tariffs and everything as well. I was thinking more about my bags coming from China. A lot of bag manufacturers are out of China and Taiwan and other places. We need to communicate where we get our products to and share that with other roasters so we can collectively kind of help each other out. It's not all about price, obviously, but I think a lot of roasters have huge value. I think Omar said...
You know, he had a lot of people helping him and sharing good information. That's not always the case. I think coffee is sometimes traditionally gatekeepy, depending on where you are. So, yeah, I think I just kind of wanted to get your comments on that as well. But in my opinion, I think we should, especially bigger roasters who have kind of been through the cycle, like share your information. Yeah, I think this is a really cool example. You know, speaking with two other importers, our competition, right? And maybe not treating them so much as that. We're all kind of doing the same thing and we're all doing it hopefully in good faith and for a better future for coffee in general.
We had a roaster who had a kind of an agreement with a couple of the roasters in their city that if any of their roasteries burned down, knock on wood, they would work together to make it work while they figured it out. And unfortunately, one of the roasteries burned down and they had that. I mean, they were working overnight, you know, but they had that work. So, you know, if... This is a metaphorical fire if ever I've won the situation we're in now. And so I do think it's a great chance for people to come together and say, hey, what can we do when one of us is struggling? And I will say, too, I love this example of getting to sit here with these other traders. And, you know, there's not some curtain where, like, behind it all, like the curtain of Oz, we know it. Like, I'm on WhatsApp saying, what are you doing about this? What are you doing? And so with this increasing volatility, these increasing risks, it has been a really nice chance to collaborate more instead of, you know, just be competitors. I think in regards to quality as well.
Since this plays a big part of it, because desire for a coffee is going to really dictate whether someone is willing to pay the tariff, pay the price, you know, sign the direct trade contract with the uncertainty in there, things like that. In terms of quality, quality has never felt so individual. in my experience than it does now. Like you could take like a lot of the coffee in the world and kind of divide it into two different areas. And one area would be replaceability. Like, is it easy for someone to reproduce another container of coffee that tastes very similar to this, such that it might have the same price, the same cost of production, you know, the same shipping schedule, stuff like that. And then there's the other coffee, which is like, this coffee is one of a kind. It can't really be replicated. There's other coffee that's as good or that might be washed and from this region and, you know, taste like apricots or something like that, but it's still very individualistic. So coffee in these two areas, it's like,
We're seeing more and more coffee move into that second area and more and more for us in terms of sales. When we're tasting these coffees, sure, we're evaluating them, you know, but like Omar was saying, our first thought is not what is the score for this coffee? Our first thought is who might be interested in this coffee? You know, we think of people when we're tasting coffees from a sales perspective. Of course, we're thinking of like cost and business arrangements and things like that when we're coming, you know, for approval for coffees that we contracted. That's different. But for coffee that we're selling.
When we're at the point where the coffee's arriving or even on an appreciation basis, if we're offering the coffee, then it's like we tend to think of people as we're tasting coffee. So our opinion, it's not irrelevant because we are interpreters and we do curate coffees for people. A lot of our customers really want Royal to be like a sanity check on an experimental process or a co-fermentation that they maybe don't feel equipped to understand. But if we co-sign a coffee because we sell it as a micro lot, we put up a bunch of analysis, we explain the processing, you know, moment to moment, and we justify this coffee that might taste strange to a lot of people, we can. We're getting pretty good at winning that argument if we think the coffee has value. But more and more, it's about what other people think, you know, and we facilitate that. And this is a big part of my work because I tend to work with tricky micro-lock containers where there's a lot of diversity in a single shipment or direct trade coffees. And we really want to be sure that the understanding is solid between what people are buying and what is being shipped and things like that. But that's really our experience now in terms of quality. And the diversity is excellent, you know, but it does require a little more commitment and a little more understanding from people because we end up.
You could say taking a risk on buying certain coffees because we have a handful of people who might be interested in them. And it's like, well, if that doesn't work, if those handful of people change their mind, maybe this coffee that is really expensive, we think is exquisite, might end up being really hard to sell because it's not personally the coffee that everyone else is interested in. This is happening more with experimental processing. This is happening more with diversification as well. I mean, we just recently had a shipment of really nice micro lots that was actually canceled at origin because the cooperative needed all of that quality to blend.
with the other full container lots in order to make sure they hit their minimum price point. And it's like, ah, that sucks. Like the thought of all that good coffee being blended away, you know? But then again, you have to respect the decision, you know? So yeah, I guess those are my general thoughts. Like we really, we taste coffees and we think of people, think of our customers when we're doing it because that's the most important thing. Who is going to like this coffee, you know? So we're really, we're thinking on behalf of our customers most of the time, more than just gatekeeping in terms of quality, yes, no, or dictating to our customers, you should buy this. Why? Because it's the best. It's sort of like, is this for you? You know, it's more like that.
That's an incredible way to end. I just want to thank the panel. I learned a whole lot. I wish I had a note taker. I guess I'll watch the video, but thank you so much. This is, this is, I mean, it's really rare to have access to people like you all together kicking these balls around. So thank you so much. Thank you everyone for showing up. Thank you to Cafe Imports for putting this on. Wiser, setting everything up. I see you over there, created Kofi's beautiful glasses. I mean, I know you got a lot of choices to where you can spend your time this weekend. So thank you everyone for your participation. Let's wrap it up. Let's get to the show.
And that's a wrap on the green buying panel. If you enjoyed this and you want to listen in a more dynamic environment, we're uploading these things to our YouTube channel. So if you want to watch and feel what the energy was like in the room, you can do that as well. If you love these panel discussions and want more of them, let us know. There's two ways to get in contact with us. You can DM us on Instagram. We're pretty responsive over there, or at least we log all the questions. And then on our website, there is a speak pipe on the podcast page where you can record a question for the podcast. So if you have burning desires, things you need to know, ideas for topics, just let us know. And if...
you want to be anonymous, let us know that you want to be anonymous. It's really fun to play the questions from people, but they don't always want to play. So just a note there. All right. Appreciate all y'all for listening. Hope you're having a great week. Stay down, y'all. Peace.