Skip to content
Special Clinic: Optimizing eCommerce Websites (LIVE) episode artwork

May 8, 2008 59 min

Special Clinic: Optimizing eCommerce Websites (LIVE)

from MarketingExperiments.com Web Clinic Podcasts Hosted by MarketingExperiments

Presenters: - Dr. Flint McGlaughlin, Director, MarketingExperiments - Jimmy Ellis, Director of Optimization Research - Aaron Rosenthal, Director of Channels Research Here's your chance to experience our optimization experts in action, breaking down what is - and isn't - working on eCommerce sites.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Special Clinic: Optimizing eCommerce Websites (LIVE)

0:00 59:50
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

We have a full group again today. I think it's another record, and we have a significant amount of content that we're going to want to try to cover together. Our topic is optimizing e-commerce websites. As we have done in various clinics in the past on special occasions, we are going to be optimizing your own websites live. Many of you have submitted sites to us requesting that we consider them for this live optimization event, and we're going to be doing that, and all the while trying to draw out distinct principles that will apply to everyone participating in today's event.

This means that there will be live optimization interspersed with key teaching and learnings that we hope you'll be able to extract, remember, and apply to your own situation. And with that in mind, I thought we'd first of all give you a bit of a progress report. This is an email we received from one of the attendees in these last live optimization events. They participated and received suggestions or at least applied suggestions, and it says, The conversion rate, according to email, this is Eric Stevenson, rose from 3.9% to 6.6%. Now, I'm not selling anything here. This is just encouraging. We have a whole team of researchers. There's more than 150 of us across the three primary groups who are constantly trying to understand what we can do to improve performance for you. And to discover that you're able to log in and take this away and apply it is very encouraging. It also makes me want to compliment Eric for being diligent to try and take this and apply it to his own situation. As you can see from the email,

They applied the target to their paid-click advertising on keywords and cut out those. This is Jimmy. I'm interrupting you because the slide has not changed on my screen. I know I'm remote, but I'm still seeing a special event 2008 workshop slide. Send me a message. Can you see the proper slide? It says helping you improve results. Everyone is saying no. According to our screen, it's been changed. Let's give it a second and see what happens, and let me try the audience view. John, I'm not seeing the transition take place.

I have our technical team standing by, and we'll quickly try to discover this. We're with GoToMeeting on this, and we want you to be able to see the slides so that we can proceed. All right. We have found it, and I'd like to point out that it had to do with some complex, sophisticated technical problems. I forgot to hit the play button on my slideshow. So I am the absent-minded professor, but I think you should be able to see now. The screen is changing. So here's the email, and they had a major increasing conversion, 3.9% to 6.6%, which, depending on how you measure it, is much higher than the actual number reflected in the ratio.

They reduced their ad spend by 60% and increased conversion by 200%. So congratulations, Eric Stevenson. Well done. And I hope that those of you that are listening today will be able to get the same results as we try to find critical information that can make a significant difference for you. So let's get right on with the presentation itself. Here's the key question.

How do you know what to test or change, what to keep, and what really works when optimizing e-commerce sites? Now, the entire focus today is on e-commerce sites. In the past, we've looked at subscription sites, and we've looked at a general collection of both, but we want to focus on e-commerce. It's particularly difficult to optimize for e-commerce sites. For one thing, so many of the pages are driven by dynamic process, and also you have so many pages because a large e-commerce site might have 100,000 different product pages, and it becomes very, very difficult to test or to really engage in sophisticated optimization, but it is possible.

And we're going to look at this. And to do that, we're going to study the Market Firmish Conversion Index. We're going to kind of understand the profile of site visitors and their motivations, and we're going to talk about using weighted objectives. But that's all going to be interspersed with live optimization efforts. Along the way, we're going to be asking you to participate in certain polls as we rate these sites. We'll ask you to rate their value proposition as weak or average or strong. For those of you that are diehard marketing experiments students, we'll ask you also to help us rate the most important areas to focus attention, their motivation of the site user, the value proposition, synopsis, friction, or anxiety. If you're not clear on that, you'll understand more as we get to the actual examples.

Just be prepared, and with that in mind, let's get right to a site that was submitted, and let's talk about what we can do together. I'm joined now by team members from our sciences group, directors of optimization and channel research, more than one are on the line, Bob Kemper, who's the director of sciences, Jimmy Ellis, who oversees our... Optimization efforts, and Aaron Rosenthal, who also oversees optimization and channels. They're really on both sides of the equation, and they'll be helping us as we comment on these sites. You see in front of you greenfeet.com. All right, this is an e-commerce site submitted, and what we want to do first of all is look at the value proposition. It was submitted by Jill Richard, and we want to run a quick poll and ask you to tell us your opinion of the value proposition reflected on the slide in front of you. It says a green company online since 1997, exceptional customer service. Customers can be confident in placing orders because we utilize HackerSafe.

So is that a weak value proposition? Is that average or is it strong? I'm going to open the poll. And then after that, we're going to ask you a second question, and that is which element of the page in front of you actually needs optimization most? Let's start with the first poll. So let's just open it. Please answer this question, weak, average, or strong. As you vote, we're going to tally your efforts and reflect those back to you. All right.

Your results are starting to come in. 10% of you have voted. Continue to vote. Vote as fast as you can. I have a lot of sites I want to get to today and a lot of information I want to relay to you. We'll give you just a bit more time, and then we'll share with you what the audience thinks about this value proposition. Jill, this will be helpful for you. You have hundreds upon hundreds. I think there are 1,700 people registered for this event today, and you'll have expert marketers weighing in on the quality of your value proposition.

If you're not sure about how to use the poll itself, it's part of the tool set in the little box that's in front of you. 45% of you have voted. I'm going to have to cut it off in about 30 seconds to stay on time. 52, that's better. All right, I've reached a sufficient level. I'm going to close the poll, and let's see what people think about this value proposition. All right, I'm going to show results. Here's what we think. 60% of the audience who voted believe the value proposition is weak, 38% believe it's average, and 3% believe it is strong.

I would like to touch the value proposition briefly, but I'll wait, and I think we'll vote on the second aspect as we move to another side. Let's just hold here, and let's get experts to talk together. Jimmy, I'm going to open a dialogue with you and Aaron, and I want to ask you guys to quickly comment on the value proposition itself. Jimmy, why don't you start out? Well, I mean, when I look at this site, obviously it looks like one of, at least I hope, you know, one of the green sites, which means there's all natural, more nature-conscious websites. But the thing is with it is that it's just one element of the value proposition, like one benefit or feature with shopping with you in terms of why I should buy these products. Most people aren't just going to buy because they're green because right now there's a lot of green stores out there. So how are you different from them? If you had the best combination of green product and truly high-quality functional product, it would be a little better. And then in terms of, you know, there may be more to this, but from what the customers do,

When they get to the page right here in front of us, I don't see how that is communicated effectively. One, the fact that it's green. Two, how are you different than any other green company out there? Three is, okay, which products should I buy? Help me shop with you or help me find the best product to suit my needs. I don't see any sort of functionality or introduction that lets me figure out why I should buy from you. So, I mean, that would be like a quick version of that. Sure, and this could be...

Your value proposition could be that you own unique products. You have the lowest-priced products. What is it out there that helps make you different? What you've given us is a great statement about your company, and it's supporting information, but it's not a value proposition. And there's an important differentiator when you're talking about e-commerce sites as well, which Jimmy kind of hinted at. There's a value proposition for the site, but there's also, when you're dealing with e-commerce, there's a value proposition for products. And not only are you going to need to convey to a new customer your value proposition of shopping with you, why they can feel comfortable in spending their time and their money on your site, but you also need to convey the value proposition of the individual product. Help them make a buying decision.

Listen, when someone comes to this site, you have a few moments to do several things. The first thing is you have to stop them. They're already in motion. They're typically, unless they are coming particularly to your site to purchase, and those are the users with the highest motivation and they are not the ones you optimize for, you get the order from them. The ones you need to worry about are the marginal motivated users. Those people who come to this site need to be stopped. They're in perpetual motion, moving from one site to the next, hunting something or browsing. In either case, you must stop them, and the moment you stop them, you must transition to connect with them. The site does not allow you, because there is nothing but an image at the top, it does not connect in any way.

dialogue has to be started, and in the dialogue, you have to do the next thing. You have to communicate almost instantly why they should shop at this site. That is the expression of your value proposition, and as you've heard me teach before, the value proposition should reflect, in this particular case, the single most important reason why I, if I happen to be one of your ideal customers, should purchase from you rather than any one of your competitors. Until your value proposition answers that question, you do not have a value proposition expressed properly on your website. Stop me. Connect with me.

and communicate instantly your value proposition. If you move up to the logo, at the top it says Green Feet. I don't know what that is. I don't know what it means. I assume it has something to do with the environment. The Planet's Home Store. I don't know what that means. I don't know if I can buy planets here, but I assume I can't, though that's what the graphics suggest. And I mean this, Jill, graciously. I just want to be critical to help your company. Leaving Green Footprints since 1997, I don't know what that means either. I don't understand what it is that you sell that will help me meet a need that's already in my mind. So with that in...

With those thoughts in mind, I'm going to have to suggest that we can't take too long. I'd love to drill down deeply. But, Jimmy, I'm going to skip ahead quickly, and I'm going to show the channels, where people are coming from. So if you'll watch the screen, we're going to move you to the latest email send, the example Google paper click ads. and example keywords and product landing pages. You can see them. Here's the example Google Ads. Here's the pay-per-click headline compost Tumblr. Here's the other one, string shopping bags. And then underneath that is example keywords and virus cycle, string bag, clean canteen, kitchen compost crock, and then an example affiliate. We won't go to the affiliate, but there's got to be a sense. You cannot optimize a page. You optimize a thought process. And if you start with a web page, you're starting in the middle of the thought process. You must go backwards into the channel where the sequence of thoughts at least...

originated or where we can begin to track it. They went to paid search to find something. They have something on their mind. Let's discern what they have on their mind and let's take that thought and let's give them the next thought we want them to have because it is a chain of thoughts that will lead to the conversion decision, the decision to buy. And we're going to try to control the chain of thoughts and we're simply using the webpage as a series of markers or symbols to elicit the proper thoughts. And so we've looked backwards and you must always do this when you're optimizing. And now we're going to go forwards. We're going to go to the site itself.

So let me – I think I need to go this way, and I'm going to ask for Aaron to give me about one minute of the top three things you would change on this homepage right now. Sure. Aaron Wilson, call. Yeah. The first thing you want to do is you want to greet the customer when they come to the pitch. Tell them that they're on the right site and tell them why they can trust you, trust you with their money, but also their time. Tell them why they shouldn't leave and why they don't need to go check out their competitors. Really, it's your value proposition. And support that value proposition with real facts, facts like you've been online for 97. And you've got exceptional customer service, although if you had a rating or a third-party credibility indicator, that would be a little bit better. Then guide the customers through a shopping process. Don't just show them the five different products on the landing page, but present them with maybe your most popular or these are our editor's favorite.

products or help them make a buying decision when somebody comes to their site. Maybe you give them a story or something about one of your most recent or one of your most heavily used products. You know, help them make that buying decision. And then when they get deeper into that site, you want to support each one of those products with a value proposition of their own. You know, Jimmy, give us your one-minute feedback. Good thinking. Go ahead, Jimmy. Mine's along the same lines, Aaron. I mean, I'm going to start with some kind of intro-region headline that clearly gives me at least one reason that I should stay.

on your site for another 10 seconds and actually dig through it a little bit and see if you have something that I'm looking for. The other thing I would do is I would give some of the instructions, how do I shop here? I'm trying to answer that question. How do I shop on your site? I'm here. Things you can do to go green today. I didn't come here to learn how to go green. I'm probably already green. So show me more products that may interest me, and how I would do that is I'd match them up to any types of metrics. So you take your ads and your keywords in the biggest base. You take your website metrics, and you look at what are the top eight or ten products that you guys are currently selling. Put them on the homepage so when someone comes to the homepage, they're most likely to find the products that are selling the most. So the products they're going to buy are shallower on the site. You'll get to them quicker, and hopefully you'll make more sales. All right. Now, keeping that in mind.

Let's just – I'm going to try to help you, Gio. By the way, it's an interesting site, and I think I would be fascinated with your products. Let me just take what they've just said and sequence it for you in a series of action steps, and let's move on. I would – first of all, I would reconsider my slogan at the top of the page. Secondly, I would get navigation on the left side of the page rather than just at the bottom. Thirdly, I would greet them with a great headline, and I'd say something like – and I'm just doing this off the top of my head. Welcome to –

Greenfeed.com. Since 1997, we've been helping customers do X, Y, and Z. You may want to check out Y, X, and Y. And in there, I would stress the value proposition. And in that greeting text of one paragraph, I'd have several links to other things within the site. Because the goal of the homepage is to get a click. You don't make any money until they click. Your goal has got to get them to click deeper into the site. So embed some links into the text of your welcome. Feature more products. Make them smaller. Try to feature the products that are being searched for the most on your site and have the highest profit margins. Get an email sign-up on this page somewhere else. Where is that right now?

doing you no good, and there's no value proposition associated with that little email sign-up form, so you're going to get very low response rates to it. I would do those changes immediately. There's much more, but I think if you do that, you'll already see a difference in results, and let's then move on. One of the things you may want to think about as you're doing that is one of our companies that's part of our research group that we own is the Marketing Sherpa Group, and in our landing page handbook, one of the things we point out is that people come into a site like this typically, and as they get into the process, there's kind of an inverted pyramid, six stages within the conversion process. Be aware of that.

That second thing, bailing after reading a few words on the page, you've got to do something to stop and connect them. Before they get to the should I accept the offer, you've got to create the possibility that this is an offer or that there's an offer within this site that will help them. And think about the pyramid. This work will be – you can get it at the landing page handbook, but we're going to be sending you this chart in the briefing. Everyone who's on this call will get the web briefing. That's a written version of what we're talking about right now. I want to move on, and I want to look at a new site. This is norscosmetics.com. Let's drill down into that site. Let's talk about the value proposition. And if you can go fast, I'd like to get you to vote on this particular site's value proposition.

So do I need to open another poll on this? What do I need to do here, Hunter? All right, so let's just go right here and look at this in just a moment. All right, so look at the business value proposition. Bring a high-quality cosmetic product that allows women to use their imagination to bring out their inner beauty. That's what we were told is the value proposition of this site, and I would like to immediately get a quick look at the channel traffic driving people to this site. So let's review for just a moment how people are coming. And I think you can see, you know,

the page and the channel. Look at the example pay-per-click ad and the email send. I guess that's the subject line. And look at the ad down on the third bottom half of this page and the example keywords. With that in mind, let's turn loose. Jimmy Ellis, start with us, please. Tell us what you do.

Sure. Well, I'm going to talk a little bit. I know this is about looking at homepages. But in this instance, when you're looking at traffic, you're looking at ads that are more specific, like these ones, NARS Cosmetics, Lip Gloss, especially the Lip Gloss one, you do not want to land those people on your homepage. You want to land them directly on the NARS Lip Gloss category or product page, actually the product page, depending on how many that you have. So I'm going to start with that just because we need to make sure you guys are not thinking that we're taking super specific paperclip ads and telling you to send them to the homepage. We're not. So go back to the – I'm still on the ad page. Go to the homepage again, John or Flint. All right.

So when I get here, here's the thing. All I see, that image is so overpowering. I don't know what this site's about. I have no clue that it's about cosmetics. At the top of the page, I see NARS. I don't know if it's about cosmetics. I see this image that looks like someone that's supposed to be in an old 40s movie or something like that. New introducing Zanika, NARS summer 2008 collection. That's where I'm going. I'm seeing her. I'm seeing someone's text in the bottom left-hand corner. So now that I'm at the bottom of the page.

I skipped over the nap because it's so heavy and strong. I don't know how to shop here. I guess I can search. But it doesn't look like the store doesn't look like it doesn't help me find a cosmetic product I'm looking for. The other thing is, it doesn't tell me why to use it. Now, there's some benefits on here. Look, complimentary shipping, free ground, free duty. But why are your products other than the other 2,000 cosmetic companies in the industry? So that's what I'm looking for. I'm looking for credibility. Why should I shop with you? It's going to come in the form of giving me business information that says, man, these guys have been doing it for a long time, and they have great products, and they have something that's going to help me personally. I don't see any way to find those things.

Give me mixed good points. I would just say you don't want customers to have to hunt for the information about your company, about why they should be shopping with you, about why they should stay on your company. You don't want them to have to hunt for that. And when you greet them with this overpowering image and you don't underline your links in your navigation, you don't leave them with a headline, and the first text that they read is introducing Exotica. It does not introduce what NARS does and how you can help them. And that's what we want you to get into a mindset of doing.

I want to stop you for just a second, too, everyone, and I want to explain to you. We're going to get into teaching. We're going to look at more of these sites, but there are, you know, what will you get when we're done today that you can walk away with? Pay attention to how these experts are talking intuitively, but there is a systematic methodology for evaluating these pages. I've been listening to your comments. Listen to some of the comments we have right now. Someone said it's a good proposition but not well written. Someone else said, and I thought this was a good point, that welcome is one of the most criticized headlines in e-commerce marketing in relation to SEO. I don't think you should use welcome as your headline. Welcome is part of the greeting text inside of the establishment of relationship. Don't use welcome as a headline. The headline should give them a reason to stop shopping. I get comments on this site that are quite interesting from you. Some of you are saying it looks like a magazine ad. You're absolutely right. Someone else said...

Someone else said that the chick looks crazy or dangerous. I understand that. And I think that you'll have, you know, we could kid. Somebody else has called it. They're quite critical to the picture. The reality is when you have a strong face as a primary way to greet people, you get a strong reaction. And that's what I'm seeing in the audience. And you will polarize your conversion rates. Never, never, never just put a face up there that hasn't been thoroughly tested. It needs to be the right face. We'll move on in just a moment. But I want to give all of you five questions that you should be asking about your own sites when we're done today. And you're starting to hear some of those being asked as we go forward.

How does this page stop the visitor and connect with him is the first question. And I think that's a problem because I don't think it does it properly. How does this page instantly communicate the value proposition? I do not think it does so properly. What I want to do is ask my audience right now to give me the number one thing you'd change on the page. So use your Q&A feature and tell me right now what you would change. Someone says, I'd change the photo. Get a headline, someone says. That's Bruce. Someone says, I would change the photo. Photo, the photo, the photo. I'm hearing that a lot.

As a woman, someone said, I was drawn to the makeup. If I hadn't read the value prop, the picture wouldn't have helped me, but having read what they do, I want the makeup after seeing the photo. That's an interesting point, by the way, and I think it's, Bethany, I think that's a valid point. The thing is, I wouldn't show the photo yet. The photo would come later in the thought sequence. It's too early. They're not ready for that yet, and that's why there'll be what's called site flow interruption, and there'll be a disconnect, which will hurt conversion. More text, someone said. Absolutely too much real estate taken up by this photograph. Some of you on the line may be large e-commerce retailers who have hundreds of thousands of products. We have you coming. We're going to be showing you what to do with some of these large sites as we progress through this.

But I think we've received interesting information. I'd like to end this by making it exceptionally actionable. So I want to summarize what I've heard said thus far and move us on to some more learning and to some more sites to look at. If I was the director of marketing responsible for this site, I would reduce the size of the real estate. I would test the image. I would start with, again, some kind of text that tells them where they're at and the reason that they should stop shopping and what it is about you that is special. I would demonstrate that later in the thought sequence down the page. And I would feature key products on this page. I would also lose the three-column approach down at the bottom. We found over and over again that that...

creates too many options, too much unsupervised thinking, and it mitigates conversion against all three. Those changes I would make right off the bat, and I think if you do so, you could see an increase in the number of people who click deeper into your site and thus purchase products. Thank you, Jimmy. Thank you, Aaron. Let's move on if I can. I'm trying to control the pace here so that we are learning and we're not going too fast or too slow, but I appreciate...

what's happened so far. All right. I want to talk to you about something that will be very critical for you. Many of you know about the conversion index. If you're not, if you're new to marketing experiments, you need to go to our site. It's free. There's $10 million worth of research you can access there and you need to study the conversion index. Just type in conversion index in the search box and many, many different articles and studies will come up. While that's happening, let me just point out for you that the highest performing website pages match up exactly with the M factor here called the motivation of the customer.

The V factor is the value proposition, and it's not just the fact that you have one, but the clarity with which you express it. I represents incentives, and F represents friction. A represents the anxiety associated with the process, and all of these have a coefficient, and if you apply it properly to a site, you can diagnose why you're leaking. We've taught it elsewhere. I will not teach it now. I want to take you to a new site. But first, I want to talk to you about the two kinds of shoppers that are coming to an e-commerce site. This is very specific to e-commerce. This is different than what, in many ways, than what someone in the subscription business has to worry about. But what we've discovered through our research is that you can loosely categorize your visitors into two groups. Now, there are more, and you can certainly get more subtle. But today, if you learn this, you could improve conversion.

Optimization is something that occurs not on the webpage. It occurs in the mind. And in this particular case, there's two mindsets. The first is a hunter. They've come to the site to find the product. They might be watching price across the net. They may have visited your site several other times. They may have found you in the comparison search engines. They may have gone into Google and clicked on a very specific ad for a very specific product. But this is a hunter. They know what they want, and they're looking for the quickest, easiest,

safest way. Now, I'd like to add that, Hunter, who is one of the editors, the managing editor of the Market Experience Journal, I'd like to add that word. They're looking for the quickest, the easiest, and the safest way to get it and to go. And then you have browsers, and their mindset is different. They may have ideas about a purchase, but they need more convincing, and sometimes they're just surfing the net, looking for things interesting. Now, don't take them for granted, because often browsers become hunters. And you will either convert them to a purchase now, or you will capture them for later through your email capture or other forms, and thus...

Approach them at the right time when they're ready to buy. However, and you must know this, browsers buy on the Internet every day. Often those are impulse purchases. Now, knowing that is very important because as you learn that, you're able to plan the way you're optimizing your site. You've got to think about the difference between these, and you've got to realize what the role of a given page is. A product page is primarily designed for a hunter, but a home page is primarily designed for a browser. You have to show the hunter immediately where to go to find what he's looking for, but you have to, at the same time, have the home page ready to attract the potential browser.

The mindset of a hunter is asking certain kinds of questions. One of them is something like what you see here, is this the place? Now, unless they already have a habit of purchasing from you, they are hunting for the place. And they're looking at your website the way you and I go through direct mail. We read our direct mail envelopes to try and figure out what we can discard, and we're trying to get rid of the trash as fast as possible. If I come to your site, my predisposition is not, oh, maybe this is it. No, this can't be, and I want to move on. Something that you do in the first few seconds has to capture my attention, communicate to me that this might be the place. Once they think that, they ask this question, where is it?

Where's the thing I'm hunting for? Where is it? And if you have a search box buried somewhere or a nav system at the bottom of the page difficult to find or just difficult to use, if you're using Java links in a way or some kind of JavaScript in a way that makes it difficult for them to mouse over in order to see what they're looking for, you are interfering with the where is it question, and that is costing you conversion. Once they get to your item, often they want to know if this is the best price. Before that, they often want to ask, is this the best solution? Sometimes they know the product. Sometimes they don't. Sometimes they just know the problem, and they're looking for the product. They're hunting for the product. It will solve the problem. And once they have found that,

Many of them are concerned about the price. And then there's a tangential, there's a marginal question, is it safe to buy here? I don't think as many browsers today, now this still happens, but I don't think as many hunters today are worried about giving you their credit card as they are about customer service. Will I be able to return this if it doesn't work? How quickly will they actually get my order shipped to me? Those questions. Hunters are in that mindset, and you need to be prepared for them in the way you design your site. And browsers, they're different.

They ask, can you solve my problem or fill my need? And often they have an interest or a need, and they're moving through a process. Sometimes they're surfing at work. Sometimes they're using you, your site, as divergence. They're actually deliberately trying to find a different place to focus their attention than something else. Sometimes they actually come to your site in a procrastination mindset. There's something else they should be doing, but they're going to shop on the net right now. You've got to be ready for those people.

And you've got to answer the question, why should I buy here instead of from your competitor? And is there a special incentive that will make me buy right now? Most important question on this page. That's the one that you've got to work with to convert a browser to a customer. So think about hunters and think about browsers, and now let's look at a website and see if we can use this information as we evaluate a site. This was submitted to us by Peter, and it's from Tasmania in Australia. Peter, thank you. And we have your site.

It's coolthings.com.au. And this is the value proposition for the site. Just use your Q&A for a moment and tell us what you think of the value proposition. I'm going to ask my audience. Rate the value proposition. And as you enter it in the Q&A, someone says weak, not high, great, strong, very good. Some say decent, fair, clear. Jen says, hmm, I'm not sure what that means. Good says, Charles, not bad. All right, I'm listening to you as you rate those. Now, I want to ask you a question before we go any further. I want to have you do one more thing if you're in the audience. I want you to look at this site, and I want you to tell me.

What do you think about the motivation? What would you address on here? M, V, I, F, or A. I'm going to open a poll and you'll see what those stand for. We've talked about them already. The match between the offer and visitor motivation? Clarity of the value proposition? Which one of these would you fix first? What's the most important element on this page? Just check the radio button and tell us what you think deserves the most attention.

I'm watching your vote. Already 11% of you voted. 14% have voted. Keep voting. While you're voting, I'm going to let Aaron or Jimmy go ahead. Jimmy, tell us what you think you would do on this page immediately. Well, I see the stated value proposition, get the cool good guys, good good games, stuff like that, but when I get to the site, it's not there. Okay. So here's the thing. You might have a great stated value proposition internally in your office, in your company, but if it is not communicated clearly on your site, it might as well not be there. In this instance, if it –

I don't see how anyone could have said it was anything but the lowest ranking, you know, the lowest rating for value proposition because there is nothing. I mean, I see, okay, let me tell you a little bit about why I see this. When I look at this site, I see the big interim image in a single offer. Like, I click here for, you know, you get a second Arizona. I see that takes my attention. And when I go down the page, I see this four or five image in the middle, cool featured thing. Why are they featured? There's nothing special about them. It's just you guys want to tell them to be over everything else. You don't tell me why I should buy those things. You know, do they jump to make the biggest noise? Are they the funnest to play with?

I don't know, but I don't see that stuff. I'm looking for the elements. If I go back to the top left side, which is kind of like the navigation section, I see cool things, free shipping, special offers, gift certificates. There's free shipping and stuff in there, but those look like nav links. Absolutely right. But the thing is, if you go down a little further, it's browse. And then there actually are links. The thing is, those don't look like links. That is weird. They're all low caps. There's no underlines. This is browse. I mean, are these game categories or cool thing caps? I don't know exactly what those are. Then I go to the bottom. Latest thing. The thing is, like, the cool thing at the top with the little bullets looks more like links.

but nothing actually looks like standard navigation. And everyone, listen guys, every side I've looked at has wasted the top center space with these giant graphics. Less is more. Everyone needs to understand when you're optimizing, you're controlling the movement of eyes as they relate to thoughts. And you use five elements, size, motion, shape, position, and color. And in every case, what makes those elements control what someone sees first, second, and third is a relative measure. If the entire page was in black text and you have one piece in red, that's what people are going to see. If the entire page is in text and you have one small graphic.

That's what people are going to see. When you have huge graphics at the top, what you're doing is really hurting your ability to establish a relationship, and don't underestimate this. You are still establishing a relationship. People don't buy from websites. People buy from people. The key space in this site is being wasted. Jimmy, I don't mean to stop you there, but I know that I've got more, and I want to get Aaron on here, but let's see what the audience voted is the number one problem with this site. So I'm showing the results right now, and as you can see, 36%.

36% voted that the main problem is the value proposition, and 28% says there's no match between the offer and the visitor. I think that's a valid point. In fact, if you skip ahead, Aaron, I can do one minute, and I need to move on. But look at the channel traffic, the latest email send, and what's going on at the site. What would be your comments, Aaron?

Sure, and my slide hasn't updated yet, but I'm assuming it's going to real quick. Essentially, you've told us the channels are driving the majority of traffic, our SEO, affiliate threat type, and email, your own database. It is essential that you are optimizing per each channel. The way that you communicate with your email list, your own list, the people that you're sending offers to that have signed up for your free VIP gift, it is different in how you communicate with them than what you're going to say to somebody who comes in through organic search and through somebody that comes in maybe an affiliate website. The way that we communicate within the channel needs to be optimized.

per which channel, and per the motivations of that particular channel. Absolutely right. In fact, if you look, this is a poll. This is part of our benchmark research done for the Marketing Sherpa Benchmark Guide and the Landing Page Handbook. Look at this. This is the percentage of marketers sending clickers to homepage versus landing page, so visitors, really. Clicks from ads, emails, or search that are directed to a homepage, not a special landing page. Look at the number. In B2B, 44% are sent directed to the homepage, and in B2C, 48%. That's a crime. That's a crime.

You're losing so much revenue. The number one key to understanding conversion is that specificity converts. The more specific your offer is to the needs or desires of your prospect, the higher your conversion rate. Aaron, would you like to add anything else, or shall we move on to another site? I think Jimmy hit most of the points, but the two things that I would add is you've seen a lot of space as far as credibility indicators by including them in your top banner. When you've got testimonials from other users or third-party credibility indicators, make sure those are used in primary iPad. And I'm reiterating this because I've gone deeper on this site, and they maintain in that top banner spot, and I think they're going to be lost by many of the users. And furthermore, in your footer, you've got some credit card symbols, especially even on the home page. I don't think this is the right page to be implemented.

promoting credit cards on, because essentially that's what you're doing. Those aren't credibility indicators to me. They're just reminding me that your site's not going to offer me anything. I'm going to have to pay you something. And moving them from the home page, maybe even moving them from your site altogether is one of the tests that I can say. Just tell people you take every form of credit. When you get to the offer page, it should be assumed that you can take their card. I mean, actually, to the card page. All we're doing right now is building the brand of Visa and MasterCard, and what help do they need from us?

Let's make this actionable for Peter. Peter, I would lose the large graphic at the top. I would get text in there with a great headline. I would explain in the text what it is that makes you the most unique place in Australia or on the net to make these purchases. I would have embedded links within the text. I would feature products like you're doing down there, but I wouldn't use those hard bars across there because they stop the eyes. Something softer that gets them to continue through the products. I'd put more products on the page, and I would get people many reasons to click. I'd change my left nav. I would never do the white on blue. It's poor to the eyes, and we've seen over and over again it doesn't convert well. I'd get the free shipping, special offers, gift certificates, and site map and get that stuff in a different place on your site.

and I'd use the rest of that to get them engaged and use that as information you talk about in your opening text and that you feature in a key area elsewhere. Make the left nav, and if you're going to do it the best way, make it clean, clear nav. It would almost be better to be blue on white than white on blue. Keep those thoughts in mind, and you'll get more people to click into the site, and then your next challenge is to get them to complete the conversion process. All right, I'm just going to move forward rapidly, and we'll see if we can help you with some more of these that we've been preparing. Let me get feedback from you very quickly as I move into the next piece. I see I have an e-commerce provider coming up, and I have the five key questions that I want to show you that you should be asking about your sites.

But would you let me know right now if this is the right pace for you? Are we blending this properly in terms of the speed we're getting moving through the sites and the information we're communicating? Let me know your thoughts real quickly because we want to do everything we can to make the day helpful for you. Excellent. All right.

Yes. All right. That's good feedback. Thank you. I want to make sure that you walk away today with enough. And so I'm looking at another site. Now, the first problem with the value proposition, before we go any further, someone tell me, you that are in the audience, write to me right now and tell me immediately what's wrong with this value proposition. Thank you. Michael, you nailed it. That's Michael Moshkovich. And then there's a Michelle who wrote right after that. Yes. That's not a value proposition. That is a...

It's a pitch. That's a pitch. So it's not your fault. I'll tell you, who teaches us these things? Where do we learn this? You can get your MBA and specialize in marketing and still not know how to write a value proposition. So we can read it. We see that it's got problems. And because I want to cover as much content as I possibly can, I'm going to get right to it. And I'm going to ask Jimmy, optimize. Well, I'll tell you what. Let's let you see the channels. So you see the homepage. Let's go to the channels.

Organic search, they're number 100 on page 10, number 22 on Downfellow. Here's an example page search ad. And Jimmy and Aaron, feel free to go at this one and tell us what you think. Sure. Well, let me first comment on the paid search ad, and then I'll let Jimmy go into the landing page. Okay. As for your paid search ad, your ad reads down pillows looking to replace your flat feather or down pillows. Again, it's just like the information on the first page. You haven't given me a value proposition or reason to buy. If I look at the top ad there, an overstock ad, they're telling me I'm going to save 50% to 70%. The following ad promotes discounted FedEx shipping. You still haven't given me anything to buy. So if, for example, I know the first line said something about we don't harm birth.

What makes you unique? If that's your value proposition, if you're the only company out there that doesn't harm birds in creating these pillows, I would use it on the landing page, and I would test it in the ad copy itself. And I test it as a motivator, right, Eric? In other words, you need to see if it's a high enough motivator to drive sales. That's the motivation factor. Keep going. Exactly. If that's not a high enough motivator, you also had a free firmness adjust for your pillows for one year. You may need to test that as well. What you haven't done is enough reason to click on your ad versus your competitors and even spend the time on your landing page to evaluate you.

Even get me to your landing page. You haven't done enough. Good. Excellent. Excellent. Guys, I know at the beginning of this I showed you someone who we helped and they changed their paid search ads and got a tremendous difference. Aaron, if you pay close attention to what Aaron's saying, he's probably the leading expert, one of the experts in the world on this subject. In fact, if you want us to, we want to do a whole clinic just optimizing paid search ads. And if you think that's helpful, let us know. Write us and tell us that would be helpful because we really base these on your feedback. But I'm going to back up now and I'm going to let Jimmy comment on the page rapidly and we're going to move on. All right, Jimmy, we are running out of time and we want to help them, so give us the fastest version that you can.

I'll attempt it. So when I get here, I did a search for down pillows. I don't see anything about down pillows. It's down and feather company. It's the name of the company. That's not a value proposition, nor is it a headline. It looks like an about a space. So tell me something like, you know, three easy ways to find the best down pillow at the best price. And then within that, you will bullet out and prove with content and credibility why you guys have the best pillows and how you're going to get the best price or the highest quality or whatever it's going to be. Whatever your true value proposition is, those bullets are going to reemphasize that and dwell at home. I'll look at this. It's down and feather company. It's a luxury brand of down bedding with a passion for running uncompromised quality.

I just searched for down pillows. Where's my down pillow? I see a lady on here looking at imaging. I see a lady on here, legs crossed, read the book. This says nothing about their value proposition, how they're going to help you find a pillow I'm looking for. And even if I do get through these paragraphs, the paragraphs are bad. Here's why the paragraphs are bad. They're hiding good points within it, but I can't scan and see it. We always say start with a good headline. It's got to be much bigger and false. It's about the same because they're down for the company. You lead into introductory, you know, one, maybe two sentences.

drill into three to five bullet points that really hammer home your value proposition. Then you directly go into where you want the customer to go. I have nowhere to go. Sorry, I read through this page. Where do I go now? There's some sort of top nav, but it doesn't look like nav because it's this white text with no underlines that look like length.

I'm looking at where to go. So now how do I find my pillow? I've got this whole page. I've read every single word. How do I find my pillow? I have no idea. Follow your rest collection at the bottom. Care instructions. Customer service. I guess those are links. I see free shipping. I still have no idea how to find a pillow. You know, if I go back to the title, maybe I find pillows up there, but it's just... The nav and the banner is completely lost, David. David submitted this site. The nav and the banner is completely lost, and the nav down below looks like it's bullet points for an ad. Yeah, and furthermore, the bolding that we see here are actually text links. So I've been to the site, and feather beds, luxury bedding, down... Underline them.

If those are links, underline them. Call attention to them. People don't realize that those are links. You think you're just emphasizing it. All right. Excellent. I think there's actionable in there, and I want to move on. Now, I'm leading up to what I think is most important, this five-point criterion, but before you understand it, you need to understand weighted objectives. When you hear these next three slides, you're going to understand why our guys are talking and approaching these sites in this particular way. I cannot teach them. I can almost just touch them lightly and then move to another site. This is a large e-commerce provider, and that's where I want to go before we close. So let me play, just for a few moments, just a coaching role with you and help you to understand how you use weighted objectives on a page. You must weight page elements and emphasize.

the right elements so that they are seen in the right order. And you have to understand how the page is working. If the visitor is a hunter, lead them quickly to what they came for and eliminate elements that distract the eye path from the objective. Less is more. If your primary visitor to that page is a browser, step up the appeal factors and feature products with the highest demand and margins. Emphasize selection and related choices.

Do not have competing objectives evenly weighted. Please do not weight your email sign-up form at the same weight that you weight your click here or product feature or special. Decide what you want them to do first, second, and third, and then increase the attention for those elements. And you do it this way. The position you put them on the page, like the upper left is prime. The color, the motion, now be careful of that. The shape, these five things, size, position, shape, motion, and color, determine what people see first, second, and third, and you want to control that in the right order. And do not use...

layouts that are like horizontal, but sequential layouts. The primary text should flow down, not across, in four columns or three columns. You can use three columns. If the other columns are left as now, the right is a special, and the middle is a meet. But keep it clear, very clear, that you flow in a special sequencer order. All right, with that in mind, let's look at how that works in a particular example, and then we're going to get to the side. Not this.

And you'll see it's a little blurry. That's not your monitor. We blurred out things that we had to do to protect them from knowing it's a research partner. In this, there was too many options for a hunter. So we go to this, where we gave them sequence. We used numbers, one, two, three, and believe it or not, we moved NAV from left to right. Why did we do that? Because we found that there was a way higher conversion rate for this retailer. And this is a good retailer. This is an excellent retailer. We found there was much higher conversion for people who entered this little configurator. So we weighted it by putting a dotted box around it. We made the blue button strong.

These honors, they're coming here to get memory. They're not browsing. So NAV is over on the right-hand side, and it's there because we felt like if we eliminated it, they wouldn't trust the site. They needed to see it was a substantial site. But instead, on the left, we put customer testimonials, and we then gave them a one, two, three, and we had greeting text that told them they can shop three ways. That's powerful. And by the way, it had a major impact, and over a period of two to three years, it's still the number one producing page. Not this, but this.

All right, that leads me to the five questions I want you to learn, and then we're going to look at one more site. These are the most important questions you can take away and apply to your site when you get off the phone based on the things we just talked about. Number one, determine what's the predominant type of visitor, hunters or browsers? Is this page trying to serve hunters or browsers? Favor the browsers, because a hunter just needs to clearly see where the search feature is or where the nav is. Favor the browsers on a homepage. Get them, create appeal for them, but make it really easy for a hunter to find just what he or she wants.

Then print the page and ask, what's my first objective, second objective, third objective? And then ask yourself, okay, am I really actually achieving enough weight, enough attention on those objectives based on the way my page is designed? Use those five elements I just described to change the weighting. Then ask, how does this page stop the visitor and connect with them? What is it doing in the headline to stop them? What is it doing to connect and establish relationship? Retailers are horrible at that. Subscription sites do a better job of this. But you know what? You still need to connect. Even if you're a great retailer, you still need to connect. There needs to be relationship established. Ask this fourth question. Does this page instantly communicate?

my value proposition. And then ask this question. How does this page attract my visitor deeper into my product mix? Very important, especially for a homepage. So let's apply it. This is a page submitted by Adam. And Adam, I don't know if it's Parikh. I think I said it properly. This is officefurniture.com. It's got a large selection of small and home office furniture at low prices. Jimmy and Aaron, with your permission, I'm going to optimize this and then have you comment because we only have three minutes left and I want to get as much in before we go. And I think we don't have time. Either I need to do it or have one of you do it. But let's go for it. You're on it.

You know what, Jimmy? You oversaw a huge retail optimization project like this for multiple years. Let me defer to you. Tell me what you do. Give this guy actual information. I know you know exactly what to do. I'm going to pick a couple things. I'm going to put my perspective as a hunter. I know what I want to buy. I'm pretty sure I want a desk. It looks like I want a certain type of brand. All these feature categories, feature stuff, best sellers, all gone. What you're going to want to do is help him dig through the navigation on your site to get them to that product as soon as possible if you can't land him on that page after the first click. He's coming off an ad.

you know, Sony, Bushnell desk. One of the things you want to do is have a navigation that will list that on the first page. Again, that's the hunting port. So I'll tell you, there's three ways to shop at offshore furniture.com. Boom, boom, boom. So they have a left navigation, but for hunters, if you're redesigning this for hunters, you might want to put that navigation in a prime main space of the page or own that whole top of the page in a little bit more horizontal fashion, but it's the only section up there. So they have to start by hitting on your navigation elements to get them to the product because they're not going to want to see the features. They're not going to want to see the best sellers or anything else. They want to know if you have that Bush desk.

So if I was in the perspective of a browser, you're going to want to have a lot of these feature categories, but you want to state them differently. Feature is not going to help them. If you're going to show them the ones that are the lowest prices, the best sellers, the most popular, those are the types of things that are going to help a buyer figure out, oh, hey, I might want this particular item or desk or office equipment from browsers. Buyers buy great deals. I think that's just this for a couple minutes, actually, before they call. And you have some great suggestions for how to do the intro for this thing, especially with a three-column top nav.

Guys, do you see that box of interesting information? They have text, but it's in the wrong place. What is the point of this big desk here at the top? It's another wasted graphic. Office in an Hour, that whole big graphic is in the way. Talk to them. Get them into the site with links. Don't feature all that. I don't know what Office in an Hour even means. And I certainly don't need to see a desk if I came here to buy a chair. So you just sent me away before I even got into the rest of the site. Get that left text. Improve the text on the right and get it over in the left. And then do as Jimmy said for the rest of this. And there's great questions. I wish I had time to answer some of them. Yes, you don't need all that stuff at the bottom of the page.

Those are things in the wrong sequence of thought. They belong on the buy page. At this stage in the game, people are not worried about this rate, the Better Business Bureau, or which credit cards you accept. They're in the way. They should not be on these pages. They should only be on the pages in the right order, at the right sequence time, when someone has already made a decision almost to purchase, and they're wondering, is it safe? I have to go on. Time is out. If you'd like another topic, another...

On this particular for e-commerce, please let us know, and could you right now before you leave, give us feedback. If you're new, I want you to know that we read every single thing you write to us, and I mean there are hundreds coming in. We put them in categories, we quantify them, and we design our entire presentation around your feedback. Has this been good today? Have we helped you? Is it the right mix? Please let us know, and we'll do our very best to continue to conduct research, discover what works, and communicate it to you. Also, there's no charge for this, for what we're doing right now. We would only ask that you just tell a friend. Many of you write and ask about research, or we help you optimize your pages. I think I have an FAQ about that.

I don't know where that FAQ is. It might have been moved up to the front. I'm not sure. But for those of you that are interested in getting help with some of your pages, I'm going to try to click there and leave that open while you're, you know, if you'll just talk with us and tell us right now what you feel about this presentation and if it was helpful. I'll slide over there as fast as I can and get you to the page to answer those questions. There's a survey I'm being told by the managing editor, and is that going to be sent to them?

All right. In a bit, you'll see a survey, too, that some of you can take when you close out. That'll help us get good information. For those of you that ask about getting help with your pages, this is a page that tells you about that, and you can click there to discover more about it. In the meantime, I'm grateful for your trust. We'll keep trying, and we'll read all of your feedback and try to get better at what we're doing here. Tell a friend, and we'll be back in two weeks.

French Your Way Jessica: Native French teacher founder of French Your Way Boost your French listening skills and test your comprehension with this one of a kind series of podcasts. Get the chance to listen to a real conversation between native speakers talking at normal speed AND customise your learning experience through carefully designed sets of questions (2 levels of difficulty) available for download at www.frenchvoicespodcast.com. All interviews also come with the transcript. French teacher Jessica interviews native speakers of French from around the world who share a bit of their life and passion. Where else would you meet in one same place a French yoga teacher based in Melbourne, a soap manufacturer from Provence, or a couple cycling around the world? Growth Triggers: Content Marketing & AI Luis Diaz Discover how to use your podcast to generate leads, sales, and influence in any market. On this show Luis shares his best tested and proven secrets, tips, and strategies from launching over 300 podcasts in over a dozen different niches and generating over 59 Million Downloads for his clients. Learn how to increase your podcast listenership, create multiple new revenue streams with your podcast, sell more of your core offer and build a show that gives you leverage and authority in your space. From picking the right monetization strategy for your podcast to learning how to position your podcast in a crowded market on Apple and Spotify; this is show is the ultimate marketing and sales resource for online business owners who want to know what works with podcasting. Get in touch over on Instagram <a target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow" class="link" href="https://www.instagram.com/luisr

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of MarketingExperiments.com Web Clinic Podcasts?

This episode is 59 minutes long.

When was this MarketingExperiments.com Web Clinic Podcasts episode published?

This episode was published on May 8, 2008.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this MarketingExperiments.com Web Clinic Podcasts episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.