This is part two. We had an overwhelming response, and again, we had record attendance last week, or the last session that we did on this particular topic. Many of you submitted your landing pages and paid search campaigns asking for us to help you with critiques that will deliver more revenue. All I want to do at the beginning is to quickly review a bit of content from before and then dive right into analysis of some of the submissions that we could not get to in the last session. I have up in front of me now the notes from the previous session. We're going to look at those for just a moment. And I want to take you just to a quick reminder of some things that we covered in the previous session.
One of those had to do with the University of New England. And here at the University of New England, we worked with someone who attended one of our events, and they took some of these critiques like we're going to be doing today, and they applied them to their own site. We saw this in our last session, but we have had so many new people come in, I want you to see it as a privilege to where we're going with our work today. So if you'll notice, you'll see in front of you the actual... landing page as it existed prior to optimization, and you can see the search term, and you can see the ad. We commented on these particular pages, and we also trained a bit in a certification class the person responsible for them. And without getting into too much depth or repeating the whole study, we saw...
A pretty remarkable set of results, and I'll just touch them quickly. So if you'll look on the next page, we applied this particular formula. Most of you are familiar with our sequence. If not, you go to our website, and you can get that along with $10 million of butter research. It's all free, and you can go there. What I want you to see now is the problems that we identified. I won't dwell on them as we talked to before. And then in the next slide, you'll see the enhanced version. This is the optimized version. It's not significant in the difference in terms of major stylistic changes, but it is quite significant in the results.
Again, if you weren't here last week, you'll be able to read this in depth when we send out or when you get the briefing from the last program. All I can tell you is that if you look inside of Google's AdWords, you'll notice that this very capable person who listened to our critique and who worked with us in our certification was able to go back and achieve a relative difference in conversion of 300%. In fact, they actually reduced the cost per conversion by 69% and increased the lead volume by 300%. It's worth showing that to you so that I can raise a simple question at the beginning of this program, and that is, what is it that we can do together in this particular call that will help you to also achieve a significant gain in your conversion rates for your landing pages or your page search campaign? That is the principle question driving this discussion this afternoon, and I would like to work with you by trying to answer that question through one illustration with a key learning and then moving directly into critiquing of the landing pages that you're submitting to us. So we're going to get underway trying to answer those questions, and this is, again, part two.
And I'd like to begin right away with a briefcase study. So here we are. We recently conducted an A-B test with a research partner to increase the conversion rate of a paid search campaign. Our primary research question was which pay-per-click landing page will produce the highest registration rate. It's very important to this company. They had targets and benchmarks they needed to get. We tested a revised landing page while keeping the ad copy intact.
Traffic was split evenly, and you can see the design, and there were two iterations. This is the control and the treatment. This is essentially something that laymen on the Internet call an A-B spread test, but in academic terms, it's a single factorial test. And this was from one of our tests, Test Protocol 1110. Let's discover what happened. Aaron Rosenthal is on the line along with Jimmy Ellis and a number of my other key researchers here in our laboratories, and I would like Aaron to just give us a bit of overview as I actually take us to the next slide, and you can see the page. So, Aaron, just kind of give us a summary of what you were trying to do and comment on this, and then we'll get to the results.
Sure. So this particular partner had offered access to SEC filings, and one of the popular terms was annual reports. This was a term that they were very relevant to already. They were bidding on. However, it was a very competitive term, and they weren't able to bid as much as they would like because the conversion rate on that particular term was not quite as high as it was in other areas of their industry. So what we tested was, in this particular instance, and we followed it up with additional tests after the fact,
We tested using the keyword with annual reports. The ad copy was for annual reports. But yet when you got to the landing page, there was no mention of annual reports. We used SEC filings. This was a standard creative that works very well across the board. We tested replacing the SEC filings terminology on this particular landing page with annual reports terminology or that phrase on this landing page. And I think if you go to the next slide, you'll start to see an example of that. All right. And I want to point out, for those of you that are experiencing page search, that keyword insertion is not something new or dramatic. There's more to all this than meets the eye. I'll let Aaron continue. Go ahead.
Sure. And so on this page in two different places, in the headline and actually on the button copy, we syndicated out the keyword phrase that the individual was coming through on. They clicked through on an ad copy that also replicated that keyword phrase, and they landed onto a landing page that replicated the keyword phrase on that landing page. And when you get to the next slide, you'll see that the results were dramatic. Essentially, we received a 26.39% increase on just this.
on just this ad group. And this prompted us to syndicate these changes across the board with their entire campaign dramatically changing the overall conversion that we received for this particular partner. All right, so let's think about that for just a moment. I'm going to take us to a kind of summer here. And, Aaron, is there anything that you want to say before we start looking at individual campaigns regarding this? I'm going to talk about relevance in just a moment, but any other particular learnings you might want to comment on this page as we go forward. I would point out that in this instance, this was one of the highlights of this test. This was one of the better performing ad groups. The keyword insertion on the landing page had increased performance, but it does not always increase performance. We had several ad groups to which we thought we were increasing the relevancy.
But, in fact, there was a disconnect when individuals landed on the page, and they weren't converting quite as high as with the control that used the SEC filings language. Why do you think that was the case, Aaron? I think that in most instances when we saw this appear, we were targeting subsets of traffic that may not have necessarily been a core customer.
We have some kind of technical issue. We go to a meeting, and we're not sure where that voice is coming from. Our customer service people are trying to track down. Does anyone on my staff? It's either a technical problem or there's a voice from on the high telling us that we're doing something wrong. I assume it's a technical problem. We're going to continue, but bear with us as we try to troubleshoot where that voice can be coming from. In the meantime, Aaron, go ahead. Sure. So it really was, in those instances, we believe it was an issue where the traffic that we were targeting, using the broad language on the landing page, it did get them to convert a little bit better because they weren't really sure if this was the offer that was truly what they were looking for. We were doing such a good job of meeting their expectations.
of what they just searched for on a landing page, but the landing page was not selling them because they were, as opposed to being sure that this was going to help them, they were sure that this wasn't going to help. Okay. All right. We'll continue with that. I want to get right into live optimization. You may recall last week that we talked about two concepts that are very critical for live optimization, understanding relevance in a unique way, understanding the difference between relational relevance and necessity relevance. Relational relevance is really identified by search engines through the algorithms that refers to matching your search terms against your ad content.
But there's a different kind of relevance that you need to have on your pages to get high results, and that is making certain that there's a specific relevance between the issue on the mind of the user and or the problem or desire on the mind of the user and precisely what they encounter when they interact with your landing page. You've got to match user motivation and intent, and that's a critical aspect of relevance that we're going to touch as we go forward. I point out to you something I've said in many of these calls. People do not buy from websites. People buy from people. And what you're really doing is trying to understand the sequence of thoughts in the mind of the person coming to the page and anticipate that sequence of thoughts and meet each expectation properly. Looking at that is going to help us as we apply the principles now to actual landing pages that have been submitted by our audience. So we're going to just kind of move forward doing these pages that have been submitted, and I'd like to get to the first one, and it is at...
So Jimmy Ellis is joining us. Jimmy, if I could get you to please take a look at this and tell us, friend, your first comment. There's the top performing keyword. Go ahead. Let's go to the next slide so we can see the actual pay-per-click ads and the landing page together. There we go. So we're specifically talking about relevance. And I'm looking at the ad copy of Lake Tahoe Weddings, zero outdoor venues, wedding locations starting at $1,900. And then I look at the landing page, and that's what Lake Tahoe Weddings has to be communicated in the headline. So that's going to be your first thing.
I have this huge image. I see 18 golf holes, open driving range, six daily specials, and a big image. It tells me nothing about Lake Tahoe weddings. My eye moves down the page to see lodging at North Star Resort. But at this point, why am I going to look for lodging when I haven't even confirmed that I'm on the right page? So mentally, psychologically, the customer is on this page. He's looking for that confirmation that I've landed on the right page after clicking on Lake Tahoe weddings. I still don't see it. It doesn't even look like a wedding. It looks like a lunch.
So the whole communication is not good. So the headline that says weddings is generic. They start off the first paragraph. It doesn't say anything about Lake Tahoe. The only thing I've seen on this entire page that says anything about Lake Tahoe is in that second section there, it says wedding packages, North Star at Tahoe. Another thing you're going to see is those two links, I actually pulled this up in a browser, wedding packages and wedding receptions locations, those are actually links to more information, and you have no idea they're actually links. They just look like sub-headlines. So in terms of communicating...
To me, this site will help me with Lake Tahoe Weddings starting at $1,900. It has totally failed. So that's what you'd want to do. You'd want to start with a headline with Lake Tahoe Weddings. You'd want to actually mention the $1,900 price, because most likely if they click on that ad, they've already had that qualifier. That makes them a little more qualified. They know it's going to start at $1,900. They're going to have to pay and stuff like that. You'd want to start with a quick intro. You probably want to have three to five bullets of why to use them for your Lake Tahoe Weddings. And then another thing I see on here is there's a simple inquiry form. If you actually pull up the page, it says fill out our simple inquiry form. Start the inquiry form on this page. No one's going to lodge or do any of this other stuff on the page.
until they figure out the Lake Tahoe wedding stuff. So your login and all-star result probably should be removed. Your inquiry form needs to be embedded on the page. Once again, it's relevant to Lake Tahoe weddings and looking for venues. It's exactly what you were trying to do before you got to this page. You probably didn't want to remove your left navigation if it's deleted form. So those are my not-quick comments.
Actually, Jimmy, that was superb. I'm going to shift to Aaron in just a moment. I want to thank Colleen Dalton who submitted this site, and Colleen and all of you that are going to be having your sites looked at, please bear with us because our job on this call is to be critical. Time is short. We want to find out what's wrong and try to give you something actionable that you can actually use. When Jimmy is done, I'm sorry, when Aaron is done next, I want to pull all this together and talk about general principles from this you can apply to your site, and as soon as I can get that done, we're going to move to the next one. So, Jimmy, thank you. Aaron, go ahead. Do you have anything to add to Jimmy's thoughts? Sure. The only thing that I'd add, and Jimmy focused primarily on the landing page, I'll add a couple of test ideas for the pay-per-click ad itself.
The first thing I would point to is I'd say if your wedding location started at $1,900, and that really is a benefit, I'm presuming it's a benefit because it sounds expensive enough to me that you're either the low-cost leader or you're low enough that it feels like a benefit, test using that $1,900 in the actual title of the ad. The reason I say this is because if I look at the Google results, I see three ads that are all starting with Lake Tahoe weddings. You need to differentiate yourself within that title of the pay-per-click ad, not just with the body. Lake Tahoe Weddings from $1,900 or $1,900 Lake Tahoe Weddings, test iterations of that. The other thing that I would try is if you've got a lead capture process, if you're trying to get them to sign up for more free information, absolutely leave with that on your landing page, but start promoting that in the actual ad copy. So don't start with the sale in the ad copy. This is a different approach. Don't promote that it's $1,900, but start with the free information or whatever your giveaway is, if you can give them something that's valuable, a free wedding day planner.
or something along those lines, test that in your ad copy and then meet them with a landing page that talks about Lake Tahoe weddings and then starts the lead capture process on the actual landing page. Now we're going to, it's well done. I want to move this on. I'd like to just summarize principles that anyone on this call can take back and perhaps consider at least for their own site. Number one, I think the point that those links in the center are not clickable is a very important point. Number two, I think the point that there is too much content in between. When I say content, let's just say content images and peripheral or superlative.
factors in between the person's click on the ad and the person actually connecting with the meaningful content they were after. The big image, the 18 holes, the driving range, the 630 specials. Beware of the gap. The gap will get you. It will hurt your conversion. I think another valid point is that Jimmy suggested that this page needs to have the form embedded, and you need to have content that's actually selling someone's, you know, when I say selling, it's only selling a simple sub-value proposition, and that is that it's worthwhile for you to provide a lead contact information. It's valuable for you to respond with contact information.
You should not make them click again. You're losing 50% of your audience, at least asking them to click yet again before they can get to the lead generation form. I think that there's more we could talk about, but all of those things are transferable. Aaron's point about paid search, I think you should bear in mind that these are variations you should test. One might work better than the other, but one of the things you must do in order to maximize the value of your paid search campaign is to understand how to have several categories of ads to test. We work too often on taking one kind of ad and trying to improve it rather than developing a whole different strategy with your ad and testing one category against another. I want to move on. And you may even find that certain keywords or certain ads work well.
with certain keywords or certain segments of your market. So certainly test not just with one or two or your primary keywords, test a broad range of your campaign. Excellent. All right, so let's look at the next one. I'll give you background information. There's the top-performing keywords. It's customer service, customer care, customer advocacy. You can see the optimization steps taken there and the URL. They've had some pay-per-click optimization, some landing page optimization. Let's please take this page, go to the next, and I want you to help me.
If you will look in my audience, you're going to see the search terms customer service at the top left. Look down below, and you'll see that there's a red box around the actual page search ad customer service 101. Look to your right, and you'll actually see the landing page. It looks like you're only seeing the top of a very, very long landing page, and you can notice that if you look at the right column. Having set all of that optimized for me, I'm going to ask the audience to take a moment, use the Q&A feature, and tell me the first thing you do on this page to get a difference. They should rename the product to include the KW customer service. That's Kathy. Someone else.
Simplify it, someone says. Shorten it, says map. Keep coming with all those. There's actually hundreds of these coming in now. Someone else says shorter. Someone says take the nav bar off the right. That's John. Remove navigation, Scott said. Remove navigation, Rob said. Shorten, says Keisha. Repeat the headline, says Kevin. Change the submit button, says Dan. More white space, says Scott. Someone says I hate 90 pages this long.
All right. James, by the way, I want to continue, although I want to point out for you that a mini, mini experiment, long, long, long landing pages can work. You have to know why, and that's something we probably ought to do in another special edition of the journal. Let's keep going. Use 101 language, says someone else. It's too busy, says Scott. Use the ad title in the landing page, says Samantha, who's been listening. Free guide on the page, says Linda. Change. You know, one of the things that's interesting is my audience gets better and better at this. I've been watching you for two years respond to my questions, and I'm proud of you. The net in general is getting wiser on this area of basic optimization.
I think often get the tactical pieces, but they don't understand the core theory underneath it. And all I want to suggest to you, and we're going to be trying to teach some of this to you, you cannot understand optimization unless you understand the sequence of thoughts. Many of you have heard me say that. But I want to make some statement on this line that I've never made in any one of my conferences at this point, and here it is. You cannot understand the sequence of thoughts unless you can understand the story.
Think of me as some kind of postmodern philosopher talking about the importance of story. But believe it or not, every purchase is a story. And it's within the context of story that you're going to understand the sequence of thought taking place in the mind of these people. And as you understand that, you're going to be able to anticipate and thus optimize. Having said that, I'm going to turn this over to Aaron. I have valuable suggestions from the audience, and they're still coming in. But I need Aaron to speak to us for just a moment and tell us what you would do, Aaron, on these ads on this landing page. Sure. And let me start with the paper.
Customer Service 101, learn how to do it yourself, methods, tools, advice, free guide. You're trying to tell me a lot in that you've got methods, tools, advice, free guide. The most powerful piece that you have in that ad is the free guide. And if it's a free download or a free guide that you're giving away, and it's really of value, start with that in the headline, and then derive them and build it in the body, and then maybe even utilize the URL as well here. It will set you apart from many of the different advertisers that are on this page that you're competing with. Drive them to a page that focuses.
on that free download. One of the issues I have with your page is you're trying to do two different things. You've got the free download that you've grouped them with, then as they work down the page, you're trying to sell them on something. So I'm immediately confused, and I think the better approach is start them through, consider it like a funnel, and your first thing is get as many leads as possible. That is optimized to collect as many leads as possible, as many of these downloads as possible.
Then on the next page, after they've already gotten their download, use the download, use the thank you page, use the email responses to then sell the product that you're trying to do further down on the page. You're confusing customers by trying to do too much on this one page. Now, when I look at your ad and try to get to relevance with the landing page, unless I've missed it, you need to meet them with the exact same message that they click through on.
customer service. They've got these ads. They've clicked on your ad because they like what you had to offer, and then they get to your landing page, and immediately there's a disconnect because they don't see the message reiterated on your landing page. Make sure you're doing that, folks. Reiterate that message on the landing page. All right. I'm going to skip it now. ...about the actual way that this page is communicating, you know, that relevance between the ad and the landing page. But the biggest problem, or one of the biggest problems I see is that black banner at the top that has banner blindness. I don't even read that white text on that, you know, pattern background. And then if anyone can actually read the text that's on the gray, it says, you know,
I opened it up on a web page so I couldn't read it from the PowerPoint. It says field-proven strategies, methods, and advice for improving your customer experience. But to Aaron's point, it doesn't say anything about customer service 101. It doesn't say anything about learning how to do it yourself. And then the free guide's not communicated. The only reason you see that it's free is that you actually notice the Starburst on top of the images for the free quick reference guide. So I wouldn't even realize it's free. So not only is it not doing very good with the free guide, then you have the multiple objective of a $595 product on the same page. So, you know, make sure that you simplify the objectives. One objective for your pay-per-click ad is going to be the objective of your landing page. It's going to be able to capture that lead with the free guide. And then on the confirmation, Aaron's suggestion to put...
long copy letter on the confirmation page, the thank you page, the free guide, is probably one of the best lead gen strategies we've seen where you're going after customer information to actually selling them on a paid product. That sequence, you really have to test that sequence, but that's our service like that. It's going to be something you want to test if you haven't done it that way already. Now, Robert Howard submitted this page, and, Robert, I hope this is helping you. Please email us and tell us if it is and also send us results. My concern, however, is for all of you who are online and you're trying to translate this advice onto your own webpages. Let me extract the transferable principles from what was just said in a quick summary, and then we're going to move to another page. We're trying to keep the pace right so that both you're learning now but that we're covering as much ground as possible. So rapidly, I would suggest that Aaron's critique of the ad is very important. Let me summarize what he said. Lead with the most compelling element in your copy. The compelling element in this copy is actually in last place.
is the last phrase. in the ad. Do just the opposite. Lead with the most compelling element. Number two, when you get to the new page, pay close attention to the eye path. Everything that Jenny said about the black on gray, which is a horrific combination. The free customer experience, you do not, you can hardly read the word free because it's red on yellow, bad choice, because it's too thin, bad font, and because it's in the wrong place on the page, bad location. You just lost probably 30% right there of your potential conversion. Make certain that the most important elements are in the most important places of the eye path. You use five elements to control what people see first. Size, color, shape, motion.
position, and movement. Those five elements, size, color, shape, motion, position, and movement, actually impact what people see first, second, and third. My favorite point is understand the objective of the page and do not try to do any more than that. Hemingway said make every word tell. Do the same on your landing page. Make certain that you understand what the objective of the ad is. In this case, it's to get a click. It is not to sell. It's just to get a click. We send out whole emails that are trying to sell people, and then when they finally respond, they go to another page where we start selling them all over again.
One of those cells is superfluous. The goal of an email is to get them to click through to a landing page. All you need to do is say enough to get them to click through. That principle is being violated on all fronts across the Internet, and the advice of my science leaders here is very strong. And if you will take this and go back and say, what's the objective of this ad? What's the objective of this page? More particularly, what's the objective of this headline? What's the objective of this paragraph? And you'll get all of your objectives serving the same foundational or master objective. You're going to see much stronger results. Last thing I would suggest for you is that the suggestion to move part of this cell
further in the process, further down in the process, or further along in the process, is something you should consider also. We have some of our research partners who give away free information and then send you a series of emails, and it is not until the 10th or 11th or 12th email that you actually infer the core offer, and yet they are making more money that way than they would if they had it on the landing page. So think about the sequencing and the construction and development and building of the relationships. Sometimes there are multiple steps necessary to get them in the right place. I'd like to move on. This time I need you to vote. John is going to take us to a new slide. We're going there. And as we look at that, you're going to see a new site. I can't read the logo. Looking at the text on the right, it's word tackle. Top performing keywords are tackle, high school, wrestling, high school, cheerleading. They've made changes to the copy. You can see the site. I want you to now go to the next.
And here you can see the key search term, High School Wrestling, at the top left. Below that you see the ad, High School Wrestling. It has a red box outline around it. On the right you see the landing page, and I want to open a poll. I want you to see that because I'm going to ask you a question, all right? And that is, how would you rate the relevance of this page to its paid search ads? I'm going to open a poll in a moment. Just look at it. Is it highly relevant, somewhat relevant, not very relevant? Think about it for a moment. All right, we're going to open a poll and let you vote. We want you to help this person. Christian Bush submitted this page, and we want to help him, and your opinion here could be very helpful.
So vote fast as you look at the poll. It should be in front of you now. Soon we'll share with you the results, and we'll share those also with Christian. I'm waiting to reach validity. You need to vote faster. Only 27% of you have voted. There's a lot of people on the line today, but just keep voting as fast as you can. Click on one of those regular buttons. Good. We're getting there. All right. Five seconds, and I'll close the poll. Okay. So we're closing the poll, and let's look at the results. Christian, you'll find this most helpful, but not a single person in the audience chose highly relevant.
I have a large enough sampling online today to give you a full focus group. I mean, if you paid for a focus group, you wouldn't probably get as many respondents as we have right now. 24% said somewhat relevant. 76% said not very relevant. Now, that's good news actually for you because rather than see it as a negative, it means that there's an opportunity here for you to generate significantly more response and thus revenue if you get this speech right. So let's go forward. I'm going to start this time with Jimmy Ellis. Jimmy, tell us how you fixed this page.
Well, first of all, we've already said that it's not very relevant. There's absolutely no correlation. The only thing that I can really see is the actual imaging references high school sports. There's a girl in a high school cheerleading outfit and a guy in a football pad. When I look at the page, if you go from the very top, I'm looking for high school wrestling, but you're not going to see tackle as the largest high school sports community. That text is almost gone. They're using a gradient. It's already starting as a gray text. It totally gets missed. All you see is you join now free, you see the guy and the girl, and there's no reason to join. Why should I join now? I don't care if it's free. You still haven't confirmed that I'm on the right site. You haven't given me any reason to join. What's the value in joining?
If you go down the page after the form, which actually says join now, join now, it looks like it's a free service. You wouldn't want to use join now. But you see some other information only on tackle. Make connections with athletes like yourself. Still says nothing about high school wrestling. There's actually not a single thing actually on here about high school wrestling, and that's your primary keyword term. So this is where you want to take, you know, if you have a lot of keyword terms and a lot of ads like this that are specific keyword terms and not specific pages, what you need to do is build a lot more pages or build a functionality in where it customizes the content on the page to be directly relevant to high school wrestling. High school wrestling clips, over 2,000 clips.
including, you know, if you want to include other sports, you can, but you want to keep it very focused on the wrestling aspect that is high school, and then you want to lead into this form, not start with the form. So my quick comment, I mean, it would take, I mean, we could talk for a long, long time, but basically redesign the whole process. The whole page, I want to say this, I'm going to turn over to Aaron, and Christian, please don't be offended, but this is one of the worst pages I've seen in a long time. It's bad because it looks good, which makes it even worse. If I could explain, you've got, you know, attractive graphics, it looks professional, it looks like, you know, you spent some time and money trying to get it right, and it's deceptive because all of the key elements of an effective landing page, for the most part, are missing here. And if you're getting any results from this page, think of how much more you can do if we can get it right. And we want to help you. So, Aaron, you go ahead.
Sure. And if I first look at your paper-click ad, you've done a relatively good job with the paper-click ad itself. The problem really comes in on the correlation between the paper-click ad and the landing page. And there are some areas where you can test with the paper-click ad. I would start with testing iterations of the URL. Use that advertising space, whether it's a subdomain or a file folder on the tackle.com domain that's displayed within Google.
Start testing the URL space there. Now, when somebody lands on your page, like Jimmy said, you need to get more intro copy. You need to meet their expectations when they're coming through from this. So tell them they're getting high school wrestling video clips. Tell them how many they're going to get. Tell them what the benefits are. And then present a form to them. But don't present the form you're using right now because there's friction all over that thing. You're breaking up, Jimmy. We can't do. I'm sorry, Aaron. You're breaking up. Sorry.
What I was getting at is there's friction all over your current form. The way that you want to, you're asking them to join now on this form. The fact of the matter is somebody doesn't know what your service is all about before you're asking them to join now. Tell them to get full access to free high school wrestling video clips. If you have a headset, switch off, but we have a hard time hearing you, friend. Okay. I'm going to continue.
You're breaking up, Aaron. I'm going to send a technical question to you if you'd like to continue. We'll get it sorted, and I'll bring you back in just a bit, Aaron, okay, after we've tested that out. In the meantime, to the audience, if you'll just look at the page, I want to take a moment, take the key things that have been said by both, and see if we can get this also transferable. Some of you heard before, so I'll only say some of the unique points. Be very careful, again, about iPad, but be especially careful about using any kind of gradient, particularly gradient on a background, especially a dark background. Remember this principle also, and this will apply to everyone on the line. Clarity trumps persuasion. I would rather your webpage be clear than full of the greatest sales buzzwords.
Some of you are insecure about not knowing how to write brilliant copy or feeling that you have that gift for the persuasive writing and design. I want to say to you that you don't need to worry about that nearly as much as you do about communicating clearly. So that effect, when someone comes to this page, there is a sequence of thoughts in their mind. And what we've tried to do, first of all, is present the solution after we've asked them to respond and before we build the problem. So let's think about who's on the line right now. Your site may be an e-commerce site. It may be a consulting site or a service site. It might be a lead generation site. But either the problem has to be clear.
whether it's implied or stated, and it has to come first. Then comes the solution. Then comes the ask. If you do not have the page flowing linear, that's the problem with pages with multiple columns all trying to work equally hard, then we have too much unsupervised thinking. So regardless of what happens here on this side, every one of you need to go back and ask yourself, is my page communicating clearly in sequence? And is the problem clear? Is the solution clear? And are those two elements clear before I get to the ask? Because if they're not...
You're asking people to raise their hand before they know what they're raising it to get. And that does not help you with converging. So all of those are key points. I'd like to move on to another. And I think probably, Aaron, do you have your technical problems solved, Trent? I think so. Can you hear me now? I can hear you clearly. I'm going to have you go ahead and stand by for a second. Audience, we're looking at a completely different group. You can see the top-performing keywords. This is Talis Curran, underperforming keywords.
And we're going to look now at the actual paid search ad. So here we go. On the left, you'll see the – it should be coming up for you. On the left, you'll see the search term, Human Capital. You'll also see, further down the page, the Human Capital Strategy. That's the paid search ad. And on the right, you'll see the landing page. So looking at this page, we want to try to help Laura Brooke, who submitted this page. And let's start with Aaron this time, and then we'll shift over to Jimmy. Go ahead, Aaron. Okay.
Can I interrupt? I'm sorry, friend. I should start you, but I want to hear from the audience real quickly. Take a look at this page. Some of you are already starting to write me, and Aaron, just load up. I'm going to fire you in just a second. What would you do? Tell me the most important thing you would change about the landing page or the app. Someone says too much navigation, no call to action, too much copy, big call to action. Someone says limited text, too much copy, way too much information. Someone says add an offer. Someone said it's too busy.
Too many options, says John. The ad is unclear, says Michael. The title should match the copy headline, says Jennifer. And there are many more. No clear benefit, someone said. Sentence is too long. Poor relationships, the ad. A lot of you saying too much navigation. Someone said the stop photography, blah. That was from Ben. And I'm going to go on and let Aaron go ahead and give us his comments. Thank you, Aaron. So I'm looking at your ad, and I'm looking at the service you have to offer. And I look at your ad and compare it to some of your competitors.
And I think that one of the better ones – what I'm going to do is I'm going to give you a strategy because I think what you're doing is lead generation in some sense. But if you can take some of the good – points that I show you in buyerzone.com, who is third actually on the screenshot, they're using free quotes from HR providers. Now, I don't think that that's an optimum ad, but they are using, they are trying, and the next one down is a free download of our HBR article on measuring return. They're focusing on a free, on a service, what you're getting a customer out of it. When I read your ad, I don't exactly see what I'm getting out of clicking on your site. You're not telling me your value proposition, nor are you giving me a real benefit in clicking through. So it's human capital strategy, HR organizational solutions, towers for an official site.
That's not telling you what you do differently than anybody else. It's also not telling you what the real benefit is of clicking through on it. So if you have a free white paper, if you offer a free service or a free information on human capital, then promote that within your ad, drive them to a landing page that immediately leads into that offer, and go from there. If you're trying to get them to buy something, then start your value proposition within your ad. Give them a real reason. Help tell them why you're...
company is different than all your competitors. And don't just start it on the landing page. Start it within the paperclip ad itself. When I get your landing page from your ad, I don't see that the exact copy that is used within the ad is used on the landing page. Make sure you're reiterating the message on the landing page and then help guide a user through here. I see a lot of underlined text. I don't know if you're underlining it because you're trying to create emphasis or if you're underlining it because those are actual links. And you need to make sure you're focusing customers when they're coming to your page.
You're driving them. You're using it as a funnel, and you're driving them into the offer to point on the site that you'd like to get them to participate. Don't get into the mindset of letting them make the decision on the website. We'd like to refer to it as unsupervised thinking. You don't want any unsupervised thinking going on when you get to this landing page.
Jimmy, do you have some other thoughts on the landing page? Sure. So I have more of a strategy change, and it's for actually the entire process. The biggest – I have, like, a hesitation. Like, I look at the page, I get frustrated. And the reason is, from what I see, almost everything is too general. And what I mean is, using a very general ad and a very general landing page, you're going to get very general results. And what happens is, because there's so many products and services and so much more content on this landing page, you're trying to communicate. You're just not going to be able to communicate it effectively. You're going to have to go page to page to page, link to link to link, and it's just not going to flow right. It's not going to be communicated right, and you're going to get bad results. What I would do is, you know, to see more detailed lists of offerings here.
I want to take each one of those very specific offerings, build a value proposition for each one of those pages of why your business should use those offerings, and then build your pay-per-click campaigns and ads based on that. So it's a reverse, you know, going from your product and that good value product of a specific, and you're building your campaign backwards so you're specific and everything connects. So, you know, I'm not going to improve this ad. What I would say with this ad is choose one of the, you know, whether you have five services or 500, choose one specific service, get very specific with the keywords, related, dedicated to that one ad and one keyword, not all these links and all the extra content, and then you use it on this page using, you know, your headline and your good imaging and your bullets and stuff to drive people down the page. You're going to do all that.
Get the strategy right. One thing to the audience that I would point out is I've got a whole group of these. I'm going to move rapidly through some more and actually speed up slightly as we get through the next segment of these. But in the meantime, Jimmy, could you just comment on the headline of this page? Capital services, and it has nothing to do with the value proposition.
All right, so I want to stop up, and I want to teach principle. I'm not going to talk about necessarily the headline itself, but I want to give you something that will help. Laura, this will help you with this site, but it will help everybody on the line or potentially help you at least think about your landing pages, okay? We all know that your business must have a value proposition. It's the reason you deserve to exist in the marketplace. It typically answers this question. If I am an ideal customer or a prospect, why should I purchase from you rather than anyone else in your space or any other competitor? If you can answer that, you have the beginning of a value proposition. Your next key is to communicate it clearly. That is the value proposition of your business. But most of us don't understand that every single...
step, we ask someone to have a sub-value proposition. Now, I want you to understand that I go all the way back to the paid search ad. Look at human capital strategy. This ad on the left has no sub-value proposition. It is trying to sell the whole business's value proposition, and it's not even doing that. It's just telling you that you have solutions. Well, of course, you must propose some kind of solution, but nothing in here communicates the business value proposition, and you think that's bad, but no, that's not what you really need to do with your paid search ad. You need to actually give people
a reason why they should click on this ad rather than any other ad on the page. You notice the parallel? It's the same reason why you're business. should exist in its space. So go back to the ad, compare it to all the other ads on the page, and answer one question. If I'm the right prospect, why should I click on this ad rather than any other ad on the page? Now, if you follow that thinking and get the story started in the mind of the person and they click on this ad and they go to the landing page, they're going to see a headline. Now, the headline needs to answer the same kind of question. Why should I stay and read this page rather than go on and read some other page? Give me one good reason not to hit the back button on my browser. And that headline must achieve that. And if it does not achieve that, you can't even start the conversation. The next paragraph has to somehow...
work against the implied problem or the clear problem, and then begin to give them enough reason to do whatever it is you're getting ready to ask them next. We are so confused about the role of sub-value propositions. You can't find anything written on them hardly anywhere. What you need to understand in this sequence of thoughts is that for every step they must take, you are justifying that step by offering them something that is worth the risk of their cooperation. And the weakness in this page is it does none of that, and then it leads. It's like a story with no beginning and no ending. It's not a story anymore. It's just words on a page.
All right. Hopefully that will help you some. I'd like to get your thoughts about some of these things. If we're talking about principles, it will help you. Use the Q&A to tell us, and let's move to another page. We have only eight minutes left. So here's what we're going to do. We're going to try to speed up the pace as we look at the next page. This is going to be, Jimmy, you've got two minutes to critique this page, and let's go right to the main part. Let's go to the page search ad and the landing page. So we'll go one more slide. There it is. Jimmy, give us your two minutes assessment. Go ahead. Sure. So that's the official site, a natural alternative to raw hot dogs use for front porch pets.
I'm looking at landing page. I'm looking for that same exact thing. Obviously, the first thing I'm looking for is Sam Zams, and I'm greeted with Bark, the Modern Dog Culture Magazine, Pet Finder, Jazz Online, and Pet Age. That's what I see as a customer visiting the site. It totally draws my eye to that section. It doesn't say anything about Sam Zams or a natural alternative to rawhide dog juice. If I look at the little text above it, it says, as seen in. So basically, there is no headline relevance on this page. That would be the first thing I do. Then you go into great reasons to try Sam Zams. Oh, my gosh, there it is. Oh, look, there's the Sam Zams image. So it kind of confirms that it's Sam Zams, and then it goes on the page.
On this particular page, you want to communicate that you're on the right page. First thing, when you see the headline, I would probably move or possibly remove the as seen in. I mean, those may be credibility indicators, but to me, they don't mean anything. In terms of additional relevance on the page, I'm looking for all natural alternatives, and I don't see that listed in one of the bullets. I'm looking for dog juice from front porch pets. So the rest of this is all about dog products, but that would probably be the first thing I'd do. It's not much. I mean, we could go through and bust up this page, but the first thing is going to be the headline relevance and then driving down the page and get rid of the extra friction that's between the ad and the actual content of the page.
I know you could say more, but I want to get Aaron to go. And while Aaron is talking, the audience may have ideas. Go ahead and use your Q&A feature and tell me what you would do. But, Aaron, continue. There's also title relevance from the keyword phrase that the user is searching for to the title of your Google ad. If a user is searching for Sam's Yams, your title may be fine, the Sam's Yams official site, but a user is searching for dog chews. You want to meet that search, meet that need with the title of your ad. And I'm not sure Sam's Yams official site is the best way to do it. I'd probably test an alternative like natural dog chews.
dog-choose natural alternative. I'm not sure that may not fit the character limit. And then drive them into the body copy, which tells them more about Sam's Yams. Sam's Yams are a natural alternative to Rawhide. And then gets them to the site. And when you get them to the site, you absolutely need to meet them with that same motivation that they just clicked through on a pay-per-click ad on the landing page. And what it looks like is you've got a bunch of banners or banner ads that are on the page. At least that's what it looks like to the consumer on the first time they visited the site. I get confused. I'm trying to figure out what I'm supposed to do here.
and you're going to have abandonment issues. You need to focus this. Now, another way to present your offer on this page, because you've already taken that alternative to Rawhide Choose or better than Rawhide Choose approach, is to do a comparison between these Samziems and traditional Rawhides and greet them with that comparison, help convey that message through some sort of comparison where you're pointing out the benefits of Samziems versus traditional Rawhides. All right. May I do this? Aaron's points are superb, Jimmy, also. I'm not going to summarize here. I am going to say that I'm impressed with some suggestions from the audience, and I can see you're thinking well. I have a few moments left, and I've seen from all the responses we've received in the previous clinics that you really would like to have some time to ask questions. In these remaining minutes, I'm going to try to fire away brief answers to your questions. So if some of you would like to get answers to questions, ask them right now. Here's one. Is there any way you could repeat last week's seminar? You'll be able to see the PowerPoint and hear our voices talking.
in an online version of it that you can download from our website. You'll be able to get last week in that way. Plus, there's a full journal briefing with all of our text or all of our comment in text form outlined in an issue of the Marketing Experience Journal. Someone said, how do you get certified? I assume that meant certified in one of our products. And the answer is, Kathy, I'll have someone try to help you with that. I don't know where to send you for that particular answer to that question, but we do offer programs. I know we're doing summits and marketing service summits. All right, so other questions. Someone's asking, when will we cover SEO? That's coming up. We're going to do a special issue on SEO. And let me see another.
Can you repeat the five elements for iPath? Yes, I can. If you want to hear those five elements, and this is part of our research. I don't think you'll find them in a book, so you might want to write them down. These five elements dominate or impact iPath. Size, color, motion, shape, and position.
The contrast of any one of these five produces or attracts the eyes, and we have capacity to actually track that in a number of different ways and study that. So hopefully that will help you. All right. Someone says, are we going to write a book? We have a lot of books in our publishing group, Marketing Sherpa. You can go there. Someone says, where can I get more info about effective ad copy? That's Matt. Matt, you can get help there on the Marketing Experience website. I'm not selling products. I hope you guys know that. It's not that I'm afraid to, but the site is free, and we've written quite a bit there. Also, download my article on transparent marketing. It's all about copy. It's been translated.
I don't know, 20-some languages, and it's full of – it might help you, Matt. Someone asked me, what are subdomains and how do they help PPC? Shelly, I'm going to ask somebody to write you the answer to that question here directly from one of our people so that we can give you a clear answer and keep going. Can you repeat the story quote? That's a good question, Danielle. Or, Daniel, let me tell you this. The decision to purchase.
is actually the unfolding of a story. Our entire lives are shaped by our view of the world, our paradigm. In German, it's called the Wilkerschung. It's the way you see things. Whether we like it or not, we're designed so that we see ourselves as part of some type of story. And understanding that story helps us understand the behavior of people. And when someone comes to your website, they are enacting a story. It's a story about a problem they're trying to solve. It's either something they need or something they want. And as any story, there's a narrative, and it's going on in their head. And you've got to understand what the narrative is in their mind if you're going to prepare a page that will produce the highest possible yield.
Our biggest problem with optimization is we think about our own interests, and we cannot get inside of that other person and understand their interests and think through their mindset. In the end, it's your ability to connect with the other person and to care deeply about what they're thinking that's going to help you to optimize your landing pages. This is not about bells and whistles. It's not about little tricks on a landing page. It's not about super persuasive sales words. It's about understanding the other person, and you've got to get inside your store to do that. And if that sounds like a bunch of postmodern...
You know, Dribble, just understand that I've watched that flow into our conversion sequences and generate millions upon millions of dollars for people who are trying to optimize their pages. It's a useful context for framing your theory. And I am doing a book on that at the University of London, which later I can help you with. All right. Could I get your feedback on today's program? We are trying to get the perfect pace for you, enough content, and yet seeing enough pages at the same time. And I'd love for you to use the Q&A feature and tell us if you found today helpful.
We're particularly interested in your thoughts. Was it the right speed? Tell us that. Did you get something actionable that you can take away and make a difference? Please tell us that. If you enjoyed this, we would only ask that you tell a friend. We do not charge for this. We do not charge for the journal and for all this research that we do. But if there's a way that you tell a friend and can go without this community, then that will help us. We are constantly trying to get a larger and larger group of us who can share results as we help each other in a community to understand marketing. Marketing is really about relationships, and we want to learn.
So thank you for today. We'll be back again in two weeks with another briefing, and everything we talked about today will be released in a written edition of the journal as well as a recording that has audio and video, et cetera. Thank you again, and we'll see you in two weeks.