Skip to content
Star Trek: Enterprise | Judgment episode artwork

Oct 11, 2022 40 min

Star Trek: Enterprise | Judgment

from Beam Me Up: A Star Trek Podcast

Archer is arrested by the klingons and put on trial, with the lead witness being an ancestor of Duras. But in this court, the guilty verdict has already been decided and Archer's lawyer has to be reminded of what real honor looks like, even amongst the Klingons. If you're watching with us, the next episode will be the season 2 finale, "The Expanse." This is not a cliffhanger episode leading to Season 3. Contact the show: email: [email protected] Twitter: @beammeuppod Instagram: @beammeuppod Website: beammeuppod.com Support the show (https://www.patreon.com/beammeuppod) Did You Hear About This? This humorous pop culture podcast discusses the latest retro stories and pop culture news. Listen on: Apple Podcasts Spotify Support the show

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Archer is arrested by the klingons and put on trial, with the lead witness being an ancestor of Duras. But in this court, the guilty verdict has already been decided and Archer's lawyer has to be reminded of what real honor looks like, even amongst the Klingons. If you're watching with us, the next episode will be the season 2 finale, "The Expanse." This is not a cliffhanger episode leading to Season 3. Contact the show: email: [email protected] Twitt...

Ready to play

Star Trek: Enterprise | Judgment

0:00 40:35

Chapters

  1. 13:21 [Ad] Did You Hear About This?
  2. 13:59 (Cont.) Star Trek: Enterprise | Judgment
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

The final frontier begins. This is about saving the future of humanity. This is a huge victory for the good guys. You've never seen Voyager. This course of action is not emotional.

Welcome to another episode of Beam Me Up, a Star Trek podcast. I am Brent Allen, and I've seen every episode of Star Trek 47 times. And I'm Matt Sonnenberg, and this is my first time through the series. And this is the show where we are on a mission to introduce my good buddy Matt over there to the universe of Star Trek by watching the most important episodes that deal with the lore, the history, and the timeless message of Star Trek. But before you listen to the rest of this episode, you must go to BeamMeUpPod.com. Click on the YouTube icon in the upper right-hand corner and check us out over there. There you'll get the full episode, everything behind the scenes. But if you do not...

there. You will be subject to the most severe punishment that we can give you. I'm not going to tell you what that is because that's how the Klingons do it, but you'll be subject to the most severe punishment. Beware. Well, today's episode is from season two of Enterprise titled Judgment, or as I like to call it, Star Trek six part two. In case you guys didn't watch this one first, or maybe it's been a while since you've seen it. And this one, Captain Archer is put on trial from the Klingons because he tried to help a bunch of friendly aliens or rebels escape. And well, if you've seen Star Trek six, then you've seen this episode.

That's exactly how it all turns out. Matt, we're going to get into the recap of this episode. We'll talk about everything having to do with it. We'll dive into the nitty gritty of it. Well, let's kick it off as we always do. Give us your overall initial impression of judgment. Before I do quick, I need to add, like we didn't watch Star Trek six, right? We did. Did we? We did. Star Trek six, the undiscovered country. We'll talk more about it for sure. Okay. Okay. Thank you. Okay.

I'm not going to leave you hanging on that. We will definitely talk about it. This episode though, I was a little bit skeptical in the beginning because we were going into another courtroom and I feel I've seen a number of courtroom episodes on Star Trek. Had some with Q, we've had some with Klingons, we've had some with, maybe I am remembering one of the movies, but in general, I feel I have not enjoyed those quite so much. So I will say I was pleasantly surprised with this episode. That bodes well for the end of the episode. All right. I got to tell you, I really like this episode too. This one's really fun to me. I do typically enjoy those courtroom scenes in sci-fi.

I'm not big on the courtroom drama on primetime law and order, that kind of stuff. Like they're fine for a couple episodes, but then they get redundant. But in sci-fi, whenever they dive into a courtroom, I tend to really like those episodes and this one's no different for me. But this particular episode, Matt, I think a little bit of what you're feeling is one of those episodes that just, it seems like every sci-fi show does a version of, you know, that one where you get a crew member who's on trial, but the system that they're in is that you're guilty until proven innocent. And sometimes even when you get proven innocent, you're still not innocent. Kind of a, kind of a situation. Like we see this a lot, you know, the, that whole thing flipped on its head.

And I think they did a great job of it here. And there's a lot of, there's a lot of nods to future Trek. Like this is a perfect prequel episode. I feel like I caught some of them. But there were probably way more that I didn't catch. I'm going to come to a spot here where we're going to talk about those pieces that are references. In fact, it's kind of really, really soon. I'm going to ask you first which ones you did catch because I'm interested to see where they do that. But before we get there, we have a character actor spotlight to get to. We're not going to do a main character this particular week because we've already done Archer. And let's face it, he really was the only one in this episode. But I have a real short one. I have a familiar face or perhaps even a familiar voice. Our Klingon attorney, Kolos, Matt, if you can pinpoint who he is and where else we have seen him before, you get 10 points. I'm not going to be able to.

but I think there was a name that flashed up in the credits that I thought I recognized, but I thought I recognized from somewhere else, like not from Enterprise. And so I wondered if there was going to be someone, and then I promptly forgot to try to identify them during the episode. And I'm guessing that's probably who it was. Yes. Koloss, our Klingon attorney, the good one, is played by my personal favorite Klingon actor, good old one-eyed Martok himself, J.G. Hertzler.

Yep. That was the name. Yep. And he is Martok and the voice has not changed. That is Martok's voice. And it's, they did a really good job making him look like a Klingon, but entirely different. Yeah. But it's his voice through and through.

Uh, and that's really it. That's there's a couple other times, but nobody that is familiar, but that it is JG Hertzler who plays more talk. Like I said, who's playing Koloth in here. And that actually is one of our reference points that we'll get to. Let's talk about this, how this episode came to be. Basically they pitched a storyline. They wanted to bring the Klingons back into the world. We haven't really seen them a whole lot since the pilot episode. There was one other episode called Marauders that I might've given you as an extra viewing. I don't really remember where the Klingons are kind of tormenting. One of the worlds had nothing to do with this episode. Um, but, uh, there's like, yeah, let's, let's bring the Klingons back in and let's make it a thing because the Klingons and humans remember Matt are not friends at this particular point in time.

Definitely learned that. I mean, they're half the episode is them chanting enemy. Right, right. And we won't become friends with the Klingons until next generation, really until Star Trek six. The name of the guy who wrote this episode, his name was David Goodman. When he was writing this, well, let me tell you, he talked about this. And what he said was judgment was all me. I shoved as many TNG Klingon references as I could in there. And most of them stayed in and didn't get edited out. And I was very happy about that. I like linking it in. So it was fun for me to write this episode that was an attempt to explain the Klingons in the original series are very different from the Klingons in the next generation. And I was sort of saying that the Klingons themselves were undergoing a sort of crisis of a culture that was.

the lead to the original series Klingons, but that would be the basis for the next generation Klingons under the surface. So that's kind of where he talks about this particular episode came from. Matt, I don't know how we could not have that though, and not talk about what the references are. And I pulled out as many as I possibly could. I looked a few of them up. Yes, I cheated. But Matt, I will ask you the question I told you a few minutes ago. I was going to ask you, you think you pulled out a few references? What did you pick up on? And then I'll tell you all the ones you missed. Well, the biggest one for me, I don't know if I'm going to have much more than this, but they're us. Yes, that's a big one. And it took me longer than it should have.

but I'm hoping I got it right because I did not look it up. It was the Duras sisters, right? Yes. Yes. Lursa and Bator. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. And so I'm assuming we're at least supposed to infer that they were related. They were related. Now, before we got to the sisters though, in the episode, I was going to say like their dad or something. No, their brother, their brother. Yeah. Yeah. Duras was their brother. I knew there was another one, but then those two hung around for a while. Yeah. Yeah. They were at the house of Duras and you had Duras their brother. And if you, if you remember from that episode of next generation, we definitely watched it because it's all a part of that Worf stuff. Worf's father was accused of being a traitor to the empire.

Yeah. And in reality, it was Duras's father. It was a traitor to the empire. But if that had come out, then it would have torn the empire into civil war. And so the blame actually got put on Worf's father, Moog. And that's how Worf was discommendated. And, you know, Worf wound up accepting discommendation to preserve the empire. But knowing that Duras was a dirty, rotten scoundrel and Duras wound up killing Worf's baby mama, Kalar, who we just talked about her last week, I think it was. And then Worf killed him. And then Larson Bator tried to, anyway, that whole family. Yes, this is the ancestor. Duras is the ancestor of Duras. Apparently it's a family name. One of the neat things.

though, or actually two of the neat things, is Duras' head ridges in this episode match the head ridges from the Duras family in Next Generation. So that runs through the family. And the other thing is Duras' ship. The IKS Bortos is the same name of the ship that was the flagship used by the Duras sisters in the Next Generation during the Klingon Civil War. Okay. So they pulled those two pieces together. I never made a note of it, but yeah, the Bortos, it sounded familiar. Yep. So that would explain it.

Yeah. And again, Duras, you know, the parallel between the Duras name here that who was the actual traitor and, you know, who actually defied the Empire and what the Empire should have done and acted dishonorably, it was Duras. And so this all certainly runs in the family. Did you pick up any other references, Matt? Nothing that I'm going to pull out right now, at least that I can think of. All right. Well, let's let's go back to I did mention earlier, the structure of this episode is very much based on Star Trek six, the undiscovered country. That is the final episode with the original series crew, Matt. We did watch that one. And if you probably don't remember, but in that one, I was going to say we probably watched it like a year or a year or two ago.

I, yeah, I don't really remember. It's been at least two, maybe even a little more. But in that, in that episode, basically you have Captain Kirk went on trial for the murder of a Klingon, but he goes on trial in a Klingon trial. Like it's, it's the same idea. The, and it's a sham kind of a trial, you know, like you're guilty before your innocence and your lawyer's not doing anything for you. The courtroom looked almost exactly the same. The gavel with the claw that is banging. Like all of that's the same. I was going to bring that up because like, I know I've seen someone use, like I always just thought about it as the ball instead of a gavel. I'm like, why would you use that? Like, but dude has a metal hammer.

I'm like, oh, wait, is that all like attached? Like he's just stuffing his hand into that. And that's kind of the gavel then. Right. Because I'm like, why would you use a metal ball? Like it seems like it's going to slip out of your hand. It's going to roll away. It's going to be embarrassing. Like, why would you do that? But I think by the end of it, I figured it was attached to that claw. And so it made a little bit more sense, but it's still weird. They both both the movie and this episode feature a a good natured defense attorney who's been a little bit.

downtrodden and it has to come up. And both of those guys happen to be played by a more famous Klingon actor that have come back. Do you remember who? You probably don't remember. I'll tell you who it was in Undiscovered Country. It was Michael Dorn playing an ancestor of Worf in that movie. I think I remember having that conversation. Yep. Yep. And then here, obviously, we have Martok who's playing this. In both the movie and this episode, the captain is convicted, but has their sentence commuted to life on Ruropenthe. They both went to Ruropenthe.

And both ultimately escape and get out of there. Of course. So the structure is, is I mean, almost beat for beat straight down the line. And that's, that's intentional. You know, it's, it's their homage to the whole thing. Makes me question a little bit. Cause I think I felt the pacing was.

generally pretty good in this episode. They just stuffed a movie into a 45 minute episode. Yeah, pretty much. I'll tell you about the movie. Yeah, yeah, pretty much. Although I love the movie, but I've also said I like the courtroom stuff in sci-fi, so whatever. They mentioned a planet called, and I'm not going to say this right, Taigocor. Taigocor. Taigocor. Now we have heard of this planet before, Matt. If you remember, there's a Deep Space Nine episode called Apocalypse Rising. It was a, I want to say it was season five premiere. In this episode, Sisko, Odo, and O'Brien turn into Klingons, get made up as Klingons, and they go down to a planet and infiltrate like a big Klingon party kind of thing. Do you remember this episode? That planet was Taigocor.

Okay. That was in there. And in that particular episode, Gowron had set up the military headquarters there as opposed to on Kronos and when they were trying to infiltrate all that. Anyway, so that's there. We also see the Klingon pain sticks and we see blood wine and we're eating Targ, the food. All of these things we talk about much later with the Klingons. Blood wine is the one I recognize the most. I actually did not remember the pain sticks. And I mean, the Targ seemed kind of familiar. It's like, okay, that feels very Klingon. We'll be right back.

Snugins. Shall we play a game? It's over, Johnny. No! No! Wow, man! Hey, if you recognize those sounds, then you're probably somebody who would like our show. We are called Did You Hear About This, and we talk about all kinds of news stories. It's like the 80s and 90s stuff that we grew up on. Yeah, this isn't stuff that's getting covered on the 10 o'clock news, I'll tell you that. You can check us out at didyouhearaboutthis.show. We're on every single podcast platform. Go find us!

I was surprised that they chose Targa, not Gotham because Gotham is like traditional. Yes. That's the one I recall. Yeah. That's one that's like still alive. Yeah. All right. Now let me give you a really deep cut. Okay. You would not pick this up. You actually had to read the script in order to get the name of the planet where this particular trial takes place is called Narinda three. Now Narinda three is a planet that we have heard of. We've never been there. We've never visited as a viewing audience, but we've heard of it. Okay. There's a TNG episode called yesterday's enterprise, which is a fantastic enterprise episode. It's the episode where Tasha Yar comes back. Only something got changed in the past and it shifted everything into the future and guidance.

like, something's not right. This isn't supposed to be here. And suddenly Tasha was there and everything was real dark on the Enterprise. And it was the warship Enterprise and all sorts of fantastic episode. And it turns out what had changed was in the timeline, the Enterprise C had gone to rescue a Klingon outpost that was being attacked by Romulans. And that Enterprise actually wound up getting destroyed. And in doing so, that event is what led to the Klingons and the Federation moving on to the Kittimer Accords and formalizing peace negotiations and becoming friends. Okay. Well, that Enterprise wound up getting sucked out into a little time warp and brought in, and that changed the whole timeline because now the Enterprise C didn't stop that from happening.

and all that. Well, that planet that the Enterprise C had defended was Narendra 3, i.e. it is, or not i.e., but also it is this outpost where this trial is taking place is on Narendra 3. So do you remember that episode at all? I do. I do. Yeah. Great, great episode. It's, it's potentially, I mean, it's top 10, maybe even top five episode of TNG for me. Like this is a great episode anyway, but that's, that's Narendra 3. So those are most of the references I could find. It's possible. There are some others that I just missed, but yeah, there we are.

All right, Matt. Well, this is the part where we're going to start going through the episode and there's not really a B plot at all. The A plot is really just Archer on trial and being set up for it because Duras is bad news. Matt, take us through the episode as you saw it. What things jumped out at you? What stood out to you? What questions you have along the way? Specific plot points. And then just overall, how'd you feel about the story itself? So I'll start with that.

I think I mentioned the open, like, cause they did it twice. And that's why it bothered me so much in the cold open. Like you must prove your innocence or, and they just left, let it hang there. Right. And I'm like, okay, that's kind of weird. And then later on, it's like, you'll be subject to our most severe punishment. And I'm like, is it not death? Like, otherwise, why aren't you telling us? Like, I kept expecting it to be something else. I'm like, what do you consider, you know, what do Klingons consider worse than death kind of thing. Right. Or, you know, what is your most severe punishment? You know, maybe you don't have capital punishment, so you can't kill people, sentence them to death.

easier most of your punishment that you allow like i'm interested now let me know and then it's just like no it is death we're just not telling you okay but that that fell flat So kind of like, you know what else fell flat? And they build up super tense openings. And then we're going to play a super chill laid back song. Should be sung by Aerosmith. It's been a long road. Yeah. They did it again, man. They did it again. I'm going to bring it up every time I do it now because it just does not match the tone at all. And if you're going to do this consistently, you got to change that. You got to. Someone was not thinking when they approved that song. That would be Rick Berman. So, you know, that was all Rick Berman. I mean, Matt, there's a reason. This is the most made fun of intro music.

music and theme song in the entirety of star Trek. Cause it's so far out of the norm of every other star Trek that we have. Like it fits early 2000 sci-fi. Sure. Like it fits that mold. Yeah. Like, I mean, it's not that far off from like the firefly theme song. Like it's the same kind of tone. Sure. But for whatever reason, that one works. This one doesn't. So I don't know. I don't know. I understand now though. Why, why people will make fun of it. I will gladly get in on those jokes.

Making fun of the Enterprise theme song is a part of the fandom, Matt. So welcome to the fandom. I'm there, man. I'm there for it. So did Dr. Phlox just totally make up a disease? No, this is a real disease. Well, at least within the Star Trek universe, this is a real disease. And this is a disease that bones contracted during an episode of the original series.

that we completely skipped over. So I didn't even, that's why I didn't bring it up. Was he just completely, but it totally sounds like something he just came in and was like, yeah, here's this really weird sounding. He just wanted access to him. And like you see, he mentions, oh yeah, you got this real bad. And you see the Klingon, like I love the Klingon backed away into the hallway. Perfect. Perfect bit of comedy there. Right. But I was really disappointed though, that he managed to get his way in.

basically one-on-one with captain and he didn't slip him anything. It's like, here's a note or here's our plan or here's way out. I like, I kept thinking, Oh quick, give him, give him one of those little emergency transporters. I just saw, Oh wait, that was the movie. Wasn't it right? That was in the future. Uh, we don't have those yet. It's about 200 more years in the future. Yeah. Well, because it slowly clicked in my head. It's like, Oh, they're just figuring out transporter technology. They couldn't have those emergency transporters. Where did I see those? Like, I know it was recently, but it's because we interjected the movie into our watching. Ah, you're throwing me off rent, but still, I mean, something, anything, even just like a tracker.

they could keep tabs on on where archer was at all times or something like that like you don't like find a covert way in to visit the prisoner and then just have a two-minute conversation with him you give him something you got to give him something maybe it's a weapon you slip him a phase pistol say here fight your way out or hey we're gonna fire our way out now i have one too i don't know it just felt weird to me that like i mean i guess he kind of said this is what it gave them an update on what's going on. Like we're trying to get you out. The Vulcan high command is trying to get you out. Like they're, they're, they're working with us. I thought it was kind of weird, but yeah, if this, if this would have been something like deep space nine or maybe even, I don't know that Dr. Kershaw would know to do it, but like they go in with the medicine with some sort of hypo spray and like, it's going to have some sort of marker in it that they're going to be able to track them and they'll be able to pull them out with the transporter. Yeah. This is, this is a prequel, man. They don't have all that stuff yet. They're still using leeches and rubbing down people with gel to, to decontaminate people. So very true. And I had to put myself back in that, that timeline. Yeah. I was pretty proud of myself that I caught on to,

this is not what's actually happened or this isn't what actually happened. This is just the Klingon version of the story. Right. When they started telling us, because at first I'm like the battle cruiser enterprise, that's kind of weird, but you made an alliance and you support the revolt. This does not sound like Archer. So I do want to applaud the writing of the scene. It was, it was done very well. And it, it got like, I didn't catch on right away, but eventually they dropped enough hints that it's like, okay, something weird is going on here. What is it? And it's like, Oh, it's just the Klingon version of the story, but we're getting to see it played out in front of us instead of just hearing them talk about it. Right. Cause then, I mean, we get the opposite side.

of things we get archer's side of the story later and and see you know his version of events which i i don't know how i felt about that when we got to that point because i think we are to assume that everything archer told us actually did happen and was true and that's exactly how it went and it just kind of felt very lopsided it's like black and white these are the klingons are the bad guys we're the good guys they're wrong we're right and it kind of had I don't know. Maybe I just interpreted that poorly, but it very much felt like, yes, the second time we're showing you this, this is actually what happened. Right. Right. I always, I always felt like it was a little, what's the word? Um, even, even in Archer's version of events, it always felt like a little to the other far, like the, like with the hardest Duras was being like, it felt a little too far on that. Like the truth is in the middle somewhere. It always felt like to me, that's what I wanted it. Right. Yeah. And I don't know, maybe that's just harder to portray than I think it is. Right. But like, yeah, I wanted it to, to have some hint of this seems too good to be true. Right.

Archer and the crew seemed too perfect and like I didn't quite get that feeling like I guess thinking back about it like I guess maybe they were leaning in that direction but during the first watch I didn't I didn't get that hint as much as I did when I was listening to the Klingon side of the story and it's like yeah something's definitely off here I never quite felt that when Archer was telling his side of the story like I never felt like something is a little off it's like oh yeah I could see that being a Star Wars story or Star Trek I could see that being a Star Trek story sure so like it's it felt like that that piece was missing for me I guess but I knew from the first time that Colas told Archer not to speak during the tribunal, I think this is going to be a problem. Archer is going to speak out of turn multiple times. He's going to be reprimanded. Like that, that was just a, no question about it.

this is going to happen. And sure enough, it did. Because one, I got a pretty good handle on Archer now. And two, that's just how this story goes. If you set it up as you're not supposed to do this, you're going to do it. There were a couple of points in this episode, one in the middle here and one towards the end, that really kind of got me to thinking a little bit. And it's a little bit of that Star Trek message, maybe, or just, you know, how we always talk about different cultures handle different things differently. And the Klingons in particular got me thinking a few times, just in the middle here, they talk about, they feel that they're being lenient by only punishing Archer. They're not punishing his crew.

they're not punishing his species they're not blowing up his home world it's like no i mean we're we're letting all those people go go off scot-free and we're only punishing archer like we're being very gracious here like and and that's an interesting thought process but at the same time you know from my point of view it's like well any of that would have been a huge overreaction i feel i mean maybe his crew because they you know were involved in the situation at least but like extending it to like the entire human race or even going and finding like what planet he hails from and attacking that like that would be an overreaction i'm pretty sure like i think 99 out of 100 people would tell you that's an overreaction. So I was a little shocked with that, but it's interesting to see how they think because then we get it again towards the end when they're talking about his punishment. And it's like, okay, we're going to commute your sentence, but...

or no, it was before the commuted sentence. It was somehow, I think they, they made us think like they were going to let him go basically. Like he, like he was almost, it was his advocate had presented a very strong case. And like, we agree with this, but regardless of intent, the laws of the empire have been broken. Right. And like, we see what you're trying to do. We understand, you know, we thank you for, you know, everything you've done, but regardless, you broke the law and therefore you're guilty as charged. And it just kind of really made me sit back and think like, okay, like I can see that. And honestly, sometimes I wish that would happen.

More often on our planet, it's like you see this as like people either get off with a lighter sentence or just don't get punished at all, even though they were found guilty. And like, yes, you did break the law. But because of this, that or the other thing, we're not going to do anything. Whereas the Klingons here very much like, nope, you broke the law. We're going to punch you. So overall, I think that this episode was kind of an interesting look into Klingon culture a bit. It absolutely was. And that's that's exactly the way that it was designed to be. I mean, you heard the quote from Gooding earlier. He wanted to.

kind of create a bridge of how we got to the TOS aliens, the TOS Klingons. And where they went when, by the time we got to next generation and how next generation was almost getting back to where they are now. And they're entering the sort of moment of crisis. And you didn't really touch on this a ton, but, but like one of the things I found most, most fascinating was when he, the lawyer was like, you didn't think we're all soldiers. He says, Oh yeah. His dad, both his mom and dad, they're university professors. Yeah. And he's like, he's a lost. There are other classes. Yeah. You didn't believe we're all soldiers. Yeah. Teacher, biologist, but they need to be a lawyer. Yeah. They have to, I mean, somebody has got to build the ship. Somebody's got to build the buildings. That's one of the problems I think we run into a lot with, with Star Trek and other side.

in general is yeah you just you take this species and you meet just the warriors or you meet just or you or you even worse sometimes you don't include any other classes. You just say, this species is this one class. Like that is their identity. I mean, it's, I think you could almost make that case for like the Ferengi, right? Well, until, until we get like Rom, well actually Rom and Nog kind of go off in different directions, but in general, Ferengi, they're merchants. They make money, right? That, that is their defining characteristic. That's, that's who they are. And I mean, cause now, I mean, honestly, anytime I see a Ferengi, I expect them to be wheeling and dealing, right? You see a Klingon, you expect them to start a fight and that's how it is. But in reality, like you said, back on their home planet, if they're all warriors, who's making the food, right? What are they eating? I mean,

who is teaching them how to fight, who is raising the children, who is all those other parts of society that make up a culture and a race and allow you to live. You need all those different pieces. And so they have to exist within culture somewhere, but we don't get to see that a lot. And so I did greatly appreciate that that was brought up with the Klingons here. I think that helps too because I think the Klingons are one of the most kind of like...

they are warriors type of races that if you say, Hey, this is true of the Klingons. It helps you kind of assume like, Oh, this must also be true of other races too. Other species. So yeah. Yeah. I like that. All right, Matt. You got, you got anything else on this episode as you went through it? I did have a little chuckle when they were down in the mines. I don't know what, like it felt to me like they had just gotten there. I mean, they had just been sentenced there and we didn't get a like two weeks later type of thing. I mean, that wouldn't really fit with the show. Right. But, um, like it felt like they, they had just started working there and then this new groups coming, it comes in. It's like, Oh, new arrivals. Like already.

You just got here. Right. But then I did have the same thought thought at the same time that if life expectancy down here is actually just like six to 12 months, I suppose they do kind of consistently need new arrivals to keep any kind of workers in the mind. And I'm like, man, that's why they find everybody guilty. They just need people to work in the mines. So, yeah, they're just going to keep sending them down there. All right. There you go. It's a labor shortage. We got to find more people guilty. Yeah, I think that's about it. I mean, it was a trial episode, like you said. Well, before we get too much further, I do want to talk about a Star Trek message. And I feel like we haven't had a ton of these in recent episodes.

But I pulled something and actually I didn't even think about it until I started researching this episode. Well, this is Scott Bakula, Captain Archer. This is Scott Bakula's favorite episode of Enterprise. Okay. He did. And like, there's actually a YouTube video out there. It's probably a special feature on the DVD that they pulled out for the video for the YouTube video. But he actually was like, I don't really remember why this was my favorite episode. It just was. And he said, then he got halfway through watching the episode and he remembered why he says, cause there's a line in the middle of it where he's, where he is. Captain Archer says after three world wars, a few humans realized.

that they could make a difference. Yes. And that is such a Star Trek thing. Like it is, it is the most Star Trek of Star Trek-y things that you could talk about. The idea that after three world wars in the midst of all that, that just a few humans could make a difference. It gives us hope. It holds up a mirror to us today. And as we continue to wait on a better tomorrow here and now.

It's a little bit back to TOS with the Mirror Mirror episode where Captain Kirk tells Spock, like, you can make the difference. You can be who creates a change. That's this message. That's this lesson. This Star Trek message that puts out, you know, be the change that you wish to see. Like, you can actually make a difference. And they actually start that at the end of this episode because we get that message. We get that line in the middle of the thing. A few courageous people began to realize they can make a difference. And at the end of the episode, when like, hey, Coloss, come with us. It's like, no, I need to stay. And at first, it kind of just sounded like I need to punish myself for, you know, being so cowardly and not sticking up for those people.

in the first place, but he kind of ramped it up and turned it into, I need to be the change, right? I need to stick around and help the people. And so like, yeah, absolutely. He's going to make that difference. So with that, Matt, um, I mean, that's, that's really, that's really it. I have to tell you though.

to kind of go back to the whole idea of like, there's different classes within the Klingon culture. One of the things that you really get the idea is that the Klingons that we know in Next Generation, in the Berman era, is not what Klingon culture has always been. As steeped as they are in the thousands years of K-Less and what K-Less taught us and we must all be warriors and we must all, like, given what we find out in this episode, it feels like within the cultural history of the Klingons, that's a relatively new development. And to kind of what Gooding is trying to say, like, this is where, this is a time where they're at a moment of crisis and it starts kind of going sideways and it delves into what we see in TOS where they- become extremely warrior-like to what we see in TNG where they're warrior-like, but they're kind of goofy a little bit too, you know, like they pretend to be warriors, but they're kind of not as much. And, you know, it's more of a show than anything. I would be really interested. And I will tell you, this does not exist yet, right? Any current Star Trek producers out there that are listening to this episode, because I know you all do, right? Right. I would love to see a Star Trek story that is placed at some point in the future where the Klingon culture has reverted to this era of education, artistic excellence, you know,

I hate to say culture again, but a cultured Klingon society. That's not just about war. And it's not just about, um, honor as we know it now, maybe they redefine what honor means and maybe they get a better definition of it in the future. Like, like I would love to see what that kind of Klingon society looks like, you know, as juxtaposed to what the Klingon society is that we know about right now. And that we kind of see coming through this, this time period here. I don't know if anybody else is, but I'm interested. And I don't know if this would be enough to, you know, answer all your, your questions, but I think it may, it might help if we got like a Klingon lower decks, right? There you go. Cause I mean, it's, you could see all the other jobs on the ship and stuff and all the, you know, yeah, maybe like all the bridge crew are the best warriors.

know, fight, fight, fight, fight, fight. But like I said, someone's still preparing their food and someone's still, you know, we do know that they do Klingon opera or we know that they do Klingon opera. We know that there's arts involved in Klingon society. What about elevating those things again? What about Klingons turning into what we picture the Federation? Like they are full members of the Federation and fully embrace this. Like, what is that? Like, I don't know if that that's actually the right thing. Maybe it is. Maybe it's not. I don't know. But what if that's where it goes? I just, I'd be super interested to see what that Klingon society looks like getting, getting back maybe. And maybe they reinterpret the teachings of K-Less within that new society. You know, like it's the same teaching.

that we hear Worf talk about all the time and Kalos, not Kalos, but Koloth and all these great Klingons, Bartok, Gowron, they're quoting Kalos, but we hear them make the same quotes, only they're applying it differently. It'd be kind of neat. It'd be kind of neat. So anyway, that's all I really have on this particular episode. Matt, I'll boil it down and ask you the official question. Did you like the episode? Do you want to watch it again? And do you understand why this was part of our very limited run through Star Trek? I think I enjoyed it. Like I said, I was pleasantly surprised given that we started off in the courtroom. Want to watch it again?

Yeah, I'd probably wait a little while because like I said, some of the references and stuff, like I think I want to immerse myself in some more of the episodes and maybe rewatch some of the ones, maybe go back and watch the movie or something. There you go. Then come back and watch this again. But yeah, I could do that. And why is it part? I mean, it's kind of that connection piece that we were talking about, like all the references from the old to the new and making everything work together. I think that kind of fits into what we've been going after in this enterprise run a lot. Yeah, I can't say too much more right now. There may be something else, but I can't tell you. I can't say too much right now.

Uh, we'll, we'll come back. This, I was like, this may be one of those that I come back and say, we could have left it out, but I think it's better if we don't. I just, I think it's worth a stopover, uh, to, to check this one out. And it's possible we might be able to say the same thing about the next episode. Matt, you want to, we're watching next week. That would be useful. All right. Well, as we are heading down season two, we're going down closer, really, really close to the bottom to an episode called.

Bounty. Bounty and Matt, if you think really hard, you might be able to get a picture of what this particular episode could be about, but I'll save that for next week. I do have a couple of extra viewing episodes I would like to give you before we get out of here for tonight. The first one is an episode called Regeneration. And in this episode, two cybernetic beings of obvious alien origin are found frozen in Antarctica. And the Enterprise is recalled to Earth to help figure it out. And in the process, these cybernetic beings begin to assimilate some of the researchers. And just before they're destroyed and blown out of the sky, they get a message off that's on its way to the Delta Quadrant, giving them Earth's coordinates. But don't worry about it. It won't be.

there for about another 200 years. I'll just leave it at that. If you'd like to watch it, we have an extra viewing episode coming up. You guys can find out more about that at patreon.com slash be me a pod. Matt, one more that I want to give you this, this one I really considered putting in the main run, but in the end it just didn't fit with what we're going for through this show. But this, you say you like your origin stories. Well, this particular episode is called first flight. And in this episode, Archer tells the story about how he and a friend went to top gun school for warp drive starship people. And they were in a competition to see who'd be the best test pilot for warp barrier breaking stuff. Sure. Kind of how Archer got his wings, I guess. So that'll wrap it up for us today. Then Matt's and.

do it for us here this week on beam me up a star trek podcast remember folks if you'd like to get in touch with us you can do that by emailing us to beam me up pod at gmail.com or head over to beam me up pod.com for more ways to contact us tell us what you think about judgment you guys know what's happening next week with bounty matt where can the folks get a hold of you out there on the internet you can find me personally both on instagram and twitter at as a matter of matt and if you guys want to get in touch with me i'd love to connect with you out there at brent allen live across all the social medias until next time folks live long and prosper

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Beam Me Up: A Star Trek Podcast?

This episode is 40 minutes long.

When was this Beam Me Up: A Star Trek Podcast episode published?

This episode was published on October 11, 2022.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Beam Me Up: A Star Trek Podcast episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.