Skip to content
Star Trek: Voyager | Unity episode artwork

Nov 16, 2021 55 min

Star Trek: Voyager | Unity

from Beam Me Up: A Star Trek Podcast

What happens when Borg Drones get De-Borgified? Are they still just as terrifying? Can they ever get back to normal? Those are some of the questions this episode tackles. Plus, we have one of the best "How this episode came to be" segments we've ever done. Matt watches for the very first time. Let's see what a first time watcher picks up on this one. If you're watching with us, the next episode will be on Star Trek: Deep Space Nine | In Purgatory's Shadow/By Inferno's Light Contact the show: email: [email protected] Twitter: @beammeuppod Instagram: @beammeuppod Website: beammeuppod.com Support the show (https://www.patreon.com/beammeuppod) Head over to beammeupgiveaway.com to be entered into our giveaway for this month. Right now, you can enter a Super Cool prize. We would love to own it. But we can't, so you might as well. You can enter multiple ways every day. So be sure to come back frequently. Support the show (https://www.patreon.com/beammeuppod) About the Show: Matt doesn't know anything about Star Trek. Brent has been a Trekkie for over 20 years, having watched every episode and movie multiple times. Join Matt as he explores for the first time why is Trek the Cultural Phenomenon that it is today. Relive all those early moment when you first watched Trek. But since there are over 760+ hours of Star Trek, Brent's task will be to find the best 150 or so that best represent what Star Trek is, the story of Star Trek, and paint Gene Roddenberry's vision of the Future. Support the show (https://www.patreon.com/beammeuppod) Did You Hear About This? This humorous pop culture podcast discusses the latest retro stories and pop culture news. Listen on: Apple Podcasts Spotify Support the show

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

What happens when Borg Drones get De-Borgified? Are they still just as terrifying? Can they ever get back to normal? Those are some of the questions this episode tackles. Plus, we have one of the best "How this episode came to be" segments we've ever done. Matt watches for the very first time. Let's see what a first time watcher picks up on this one. If you're watching with us, the next episode will be on Star Trek: Deep Space Nine | In Purgatory's Shadow...

Ready to play

Star Trek: Voyager | Unity

0:00 55:09

Chapters

  1. 13:32 [Ad] Did You Hear About This?
  2. 14:10 (Cont.) Star Trek: Voyager | Unity
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

The final frontier begins. This is about saving the future of humanity. This is a huge victory for the good guys. You've never seen Voyager. This course of action is not emotional.

Welcome to another episode of Be Me Up, a Star Trek podcast. I am Brent Allen, and I have seen every episode of Star Trek 47 times. And I'm Matt Sonnenberg, and this is my first time through the series. And this is the show where we are on a mission to introduce people to the universe of Star Trek by watching, in air date order, the most important episodes that deal with the lore, the history, and the timeless message of Star Trek. But before we get into today's episode, I would love it if you go check out BeMeUpPod.com. Let us know what you like, what you don't like. Check out some old episodes, check out some new episodes, check out some giveaways, which you can find at BeMeUpGiveaway.com. You never know what we might be giving away.

It changes all the time because, well, we have to give stuff away and then we have to choose something new. We can't give away the same stuff all the time. That'd be weird. And you guys listen to the show at different times. So pick it up. We notice we're not actually saying what we're giving away right now. Intentionally vague. Yeah, because depending on when you listen, you could actually go get whatever we're currently doing. So you guys go do that. Beam me up giveaway dot com. But for now, let's talk about today's episode.

The 14th episode of Star Trek Voyager season three, entitled Unity, or as I like to call it, the prequel to the beginning of the end, which is actually what I've usually called this episode for years. I've called it that. In case you guys didn't watch this one first in this episode, Chakotay crash lands on a planet and discovers a society of freed Borg drones from all over the galaxy, some of them from the Alpha Quadrant. But they still have many of their Borg components intact, and they ask for Voyager's help in reactivating a dead cube, which kind of makes everybody a little antsy. Now, Matt, we're going to get into the recap of this episode, but I'm curious before we do all of that and we talk about all this stuff. I promise you, Matt, I think this episode has one of the most interesting, like how this episode came to be stories.

Like most complete, like there's actually like a thread to how this episode came to be. Can't wait to get into that. Before we do all that, you just watch unity for the very first time I've watched. I probably watched it six times, just getting ready for the show, at least in bits and pieces over the last couple of weeks. What are your initial thoughts, overall thoughts on unity? It's a good episode. And honestly, I kind of want to watch it again because like.

I think it'll be better on rewatch even. Yes. It was good the first time. But I'm just looking through my notes and thinking about some of the things that were said early on in the episode. And like, oh, that kind of has a new meaning now. Or that makes more sense now, I guess. Have you noticed, Matt, just how many times you have lately been saying, I should go back and watch this one again. I want to watch this one again. Have you noticed how often you've been saying that here lately? Yeah. Just saying the show's working. The show's doing exactly what it's supposed to do. Beaming you up into the fandom there, Matt. Let me ask you this question.

originally I was going to combine this with last week's episode, blood fever. You've now seen both blood fever and unity. Would you have been mad at me to think if I smushed them together and left them the way that I'd originally planned on it? Or, you know, do you think it was a good, a good move to separate them out? I think it was a good move to separate them. Good. Yeah. Cause I, there's too much to talk about here that.

doesn't really have anything to do with blood fever at all. Yeah. Like we saw Borg at the very end of the episode, but I just want to talk about Borg this episode. So the connective tissue between last episode and this episode, whereas that little three second scene at the end of the episode and the fact they're both set in the necrot expanse, this is actually the final necrot expanse episode. Like after this one, they're out of the expanse. Like they've made it to the other side of that particular expense. So wasn't that expensive? Yeah, I figured. Well, no one had a map. They didn't know. Right. It's like, you know.

Columbus sailing across the ocean. He didn't know when he was going to hit land. Right. Could have been a week. It could have been three months, you know. Right. Who knows? Right. Although, to be fair, I think they could have just said we're still like they maybe just forgot to keep saying it. You know, it could have been a season long arc. It really could have. They just exactly what I would have expected to is for them to run it like through the end of the season, at least. I mean, they kind of jumped into it in the middle of the season. So even just half a season. Yeah. And don't forget, this is still 90s TV. They're still not trying to serialize the show like they want you to be able to watch each show individually and not have to watch the previous episode to know what's going on. That's still where they are. But they're getting.

They are getting better with it. Matt, I tell you, this is not actually one of my favorite episodes out of the whole thing. Really? But I have a lot of respect for it. And honestly, the thought I'm left with it is this is one of those weird episodes that I think for some reason in my memory is worse than it is in reality. Because I'm watching this episode going, this is a fantastic episode. Why do I not like this episode? I have no reason to not like this episode, but I just don't.

get through like 90% of the way through and say, oh yeah, this is why I don't like it or anything like that. No, I, no, I, I don't know. I don't know. Worse in your memory. Maybe, maybe deep Borgifying Borg is just weird to me. I don't, I don't know. I can't figure it out. I don't know why. Maybe it's a Chakotay episode. See, I like Chakotay episodes though. I can't explain it. Cannot explain it. Um, so anyway, we'll get into it, but I do, maybe I just, maybe this is one of those episodes that for me personally, no matter how many times I've seen Star Trek, like one of the things about the rewatches is you tend to find new stuff. Maybe I'm just finding new, like there's been a couple episodes. I'm like, it's all right. And then you and I get to talk about it. I'm like, actually, this is

I got one character actor spotlight I want to point out for us here. Very, very short. Go for it. I'd like to point out the director. You've been doing that a lot. I have. Well, because we've hit most of the main cast. I'm saving. In fact, today's character actor spotlight, I'm not really going to spotlight. I just want to mention because we're going to talk about him later in another episode. This is a guy that I like to call RDM or Robert Duncan McNeil, who plays Tom Paris. Tom Paris. Yes, there you go. This is another example, Matt, of the Star Trek school of directing at work. This was actually his second episode of the four he will direct for the series. And I will just say that post Star Trek, Robert Duncan McNeil's main job, the vast majority of his work is as a director. So he did.

four episodes on the show. And then that was his job from here on out. So we'll talk about him more. There's an episode coming up that I know we're going to do because I'm going to force us to do it. That is a very Tom Harris centric episode. And I'm saving his for when we get to that episode. So we'll touch more on Robert Duncan as we go. But I just wanted to point him out here because I think it's important to what's important to the overall story of the show as well. But I like pointing out when the school of directing and it's one of our main cast members comes up. Matt, I do want to talk about how this episode came to be because I think it's a pretty cool story to start. Let's rewind the clock all the way back to May of 1996. And now we're in February of 1997.

All right. May of 1996, Voyager season two is wrapped. They've finished production on it. They're just waiting on the final episodes to air. The writing staff is beginning to plan for the next season. And they start talking about what they're going to do in February when Sweeps Week comes up. You know, because that's like the big week. You got to have the big episodes during Sweeps Week, right? First Contact had just started production as the film. And so that's going on over there, you know, throughout the summer. First Contact's being done. And the writing staff says, you know what we ought to do for Sweeps Week? We should do a Borg episode. And everybody's like, yeah, let's do a Borg episode. Let's do a Borg episode. So as you might expect, they began to get tons and tons of pitches for Borg story ideas in the Delta Quadrant and somehow mixing in with Voyager.

Well, the writing duties for the episode fell to a guy that we've been talking about a little bit more and a little bit more often. And we'll talk about him continually more often. Ken Diller. This is that guy that was just sort of like an errand boy in the first season. And he like works his way up to running the whole dang show by the end of the series. Now, Ken, who self-admittedly is the least Trekkie of all the writing staff there on Voyager.

This is the guy he really wanted to do something new with the Borg, and he wanted to make them more than just this one dimensional, relentlessly come at you type thing. So as part of his research, he actually went over and asked his boss, Brandon Braga, who was the writer of one of the writers of Star Trek First Contact, said, hey, can I look at the script? I hear you're doing stuff with the Borg, right? So he goes and looks at the script and reads the script. And he's like, oh, they're adding a queen. And they're all I've been wanting, you know, I want to do more than what we've seen out of the Borg so far. So.

He uses that as a lot of inspiration. And it was then like while reading the script of first contact that he hit upon the idea of what would happen if you de-borgified the Borg? Like, how would that go? And in thinking about that, he considered the biblical tale of the Tower of Babel or Babel, however you say it. Here at the Tower of Babel, you have all these people who are working together on this big, huge project. You know, sound Borgish? They're all working on this big project. And when all of a sudden the tower gets knocked down and then nobody could communicate because they're not speaking the same language anymore. And then they all start vying for control. Right. And, you know, that's the Pandora's box, I guess, of the Bible. I never would have.

drawn that connection but i can totally see it now that's what that's where his mind went and that's pretty close to what we see wind up happening with the board being severed from the collective they they don't know each other they can't talk they can't communicate and they all kind of start circling each other trying to vie for control they split off into their little factions Now, Matt, you know how I've always told you that every iteration of Star Trek is a product of its day. TOS was a product of the 60s. This era was a product of the 90s. Today, Star Trek is a product of today. Well, this is 1996. The Soviet Union has just broken up a handful of years earlier. And now all these little countries that are part of that old Soviet bloc are starting to assert themselves and become their own country again. And they've had some chance to have some successes and some failures and to dip their toe into what new government looks like and all that kind of stuff.

And apparently what was happening back in the 90s was at that point, people were kind of like, you know, we kind of liked communism a little better. Like it was a little bit OK, you know, like they were just far enough away from anything to forget about the bad stuff and only remember the good stuff about it. And so he kind of took that idea and merged it into the storyline and particularly personified it with Riley, the character of Riley, who is, you know, that ex-Borg. And for as horrifying and horrendous as the Borg experience was. There's also some benefit to being a Borg and they sort of miss it. And they have some nostalgia. Like, actually, like we could heal each other really well and we could just think and move really efficiently because we're all acting with one mind. And, you know, all those things that they talked about in the course of this episode. And so here you get these ideas of the warring factions and a nostalgia for what it would be like if you could go back and how you fix all of that. So that's really where this episode came from now.

Biller, for his point, considered Riley's motives to be very pure and worthy as he's writing the episode. Well, let's enter Robert Duncan McNeil as the director for the episode. He gets the script, he starts reading it, and he's like, as an actor and a person who's kind of been around Star Trek, he's like, I think these guys are still really evil. It's not pure and pure and worthy. Like he felt like, no, no, this is really evil. In fact, his, his direction to Robert Beltran was think about it as if you're being seduced by the devil, because while it looks all sweet and sickly and everything from the outside in this, and it might even make sense in like a twisted sort of a way, it's still not good. And they're still going to force themselves on you. And it's still, you know, but you're, you're, you just, you kind of get it. It looks good, but it's not really what you, what you want to get into. Now, that being said, Robert Duncan McNeil didn't completely abandon Ken Biller's ideas. He did do a bunch of research on the disintegrating Soviet union block and all the politics that went into that. And even though this wasn't a very big political episode,

He still incorporated a lot of those ideas from his research into this episode that they put out. And, you know, this was a very favorite episode around the, around the production and did very, very well for them during Sweeps Week. So that's kind of how we get into this episode, which I just, you know, I like it. It just went, you know, here's this element and this element and this led to this. And you and I were just having a conversation about how A leads to B leads to C until you get this, this episode. So there we go. That's how this episode came to be.

I like it. You like it, Matt. This is the part where we're going to go through the episode now. And you're going to walk us through your experience of this, watching it for the very first time is the rest of us have watched it. A lot of times we'll talk about the a plot. We'll talk about the B plot, which I think you have it as Chakotay story. And then what's going on on Voyager. Uh, but before we do that, I'll, I'll give it to you first of any specific plot points or little things that you want to, you know, moments that happened that you're like, Oh, I got to talk about that and make sure I don't forget that. We'll be right back. It's over.

So most of my notes this week are not necessarily moments from the episode, just more... ponderings that I had during the episode, I guess. You know what? No, that's the sort. This episode is supposed to do that. And because this podcast is about taking you through the series as you're experiencing it as a first time watcher, I am way more inclined to talk about those ponderings than to really worry about all the plot points. Sure, sure. But they're not like the deep like what ifs. It's more my surface level stuff, but that's fine. That's fine. That's probably where the second viewing would come into is you get all this stuff. Yes, I did. I'm sorry. I did have one point that I wanted to make, but if you've got something else, so I don't know where you're going to go because I might be quick. Don't worry. OK, go ahead. I don't know if it's ever.

mentioned on the show before, but Chakotay vegetarian. I believe it has been as a vegetarian. I believe it has been. I think it's part of part of the Native American tried. And I think it's I think it references that. Yeah. Yeah. Living off land or something like that. But fair enough. Although I don't know, to be fair, I don't know that I've ever considered Native Americans to be vegetarians in and of themselves either. Like, I'm pretty sure they were meat eaters, too. So, well, yeah, hunters and gatherers. Sure. One forty seven reference. Oh, you caught it. Oh, they repeated it over and over and over in your head. Yeah. Transport to module forty seven omega. There you go.

Then the doctor. I've thought about this a few times, but it really hit me this episode for some reason. Near the end, they ask him, or it was Janeway and Chakotay. And they're like, can we have a moment? And so they're asking Cass and the doctor to leave. Right. And every time I'm like, this is sci-fi. It should happen. This is sci-fi. It should happen. It never does. And it's probably a cost savings because it would be a special effect they have to put in. But every time I'm just like, the doctor should just turn himself off when they ask him to leave.

Right. Instead of just walking out of the room. I'm like, dude, it'd be so much cooler if you just disappeared. Were they, were they in sickbay or were they in Janeway's wedding room? I'm pretty sure they were in sickbay. Okay. Yeah. Because, because Chakotay was being like revived or whatever. Yeah. If they're anywhere else, but sickbay, the only, the only problem with that is because the doctor has the mobile emitter. Sure. That would just drop to the ground. You don't want to damage that. But outside of that, then yeah, absolutely. Just be like, okay. Yeah. Like I, it would just be so much more sci-fi and so, so awesome. Especially if that was like, if you're just a casual watcher and you don't actually know who the doctor is and just disappears. I'm like, wait, what was that? Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Like it'd be awesome. Yeah. Cause I mean, he never does it. Cause if you don

hologram you wouldn't know that he's a hologram no no like at all especially in these later episodes now like they just you know they treat him like a person yeah but so much so like i'm saying like he just walks out of the room with everybody else like come on man showing you got yeah you got like superpowers to disappear and reappear on will right like use it um but then the last thing wasn't necessarily about this episode in particular either it was just something i've noticed more and more as we go along anytime whoever we're talking about in the episode today i believe yeah it was it was jacote they were referencing we always get some line That's if we don't do this, whatever this is, whatever the episode is about, you will die. And it's always you will die. It's never you will be incapacitated. You will be handicapped for the rest of your life. You will be, you know, severely maimed or something like, no, you will die. No matter what the injury or trauma is, you will die. Right. Like it's always, always, always life or death. There's never anything in the middle. And I don't know. Maybe it's just we've had a couple of these back to back that it's it's sitting there in my face right now. But it feels like they do that a lot.

Really? Every week is life or death? I don't know. So little things that just... kind of hit me this week and i'm guessing none of those were what you wanted to talk about though now the well the one moment i wanted to point out was like i like at the very beginning of the episode when kaplan and chakotay are in the shuttle which by the way i know you haven't seen them all this is the third shuttlecraft that voyager has now lost really because they've crashed or they've sent them off or whatever yeah they lost a shuttle here yeah just but yeah now it's the third one they're gonna replicate a new one i guess i don't know oh okay i suppose yes replicate the parts i don't know seems like they're on replicator rations well this is why they need the gala site so they can go you know do stuff anyway yeah um you know they're like oh we're flying in circles oh look there's that star again and he goes engage optical scanners and i'm sitting there being like Like, you mean your eyes?

or the video camera outside is that engage the optical scanner you mean the camera like like what's an optical scanner well they were definitely you know going more old school too so it's like yeah that i engage optical cameras look over and look out the window i want to know whoever wrote that line in particular like what they were thinking if that was a little joke to them because you know no one is going to well i was back then wasn't going to question it well because it goes by so fast you know like exactly exactly you just you just don't you know you've got it though so there was i sent you this picture the other day like like star trek does a little things like this all the time where they just they slip stuff in and just move on um like the akuta grams that they had especially on the enterprise d where like because the camera is never going to focus on it you're never going to see it they just got to fill up words like they're putting in song lyrics you know to recognizable songs or yeah i think the ones you sent me were the the words to gilgan's island yeah that's it right there that's it right there just just because nobody's ever going to see it or uh back in the original series they're the pipes like when they open up the wall the pipes would have uh um like g in d in and then some number sequence after and it's the gnd was goes nowhere and does nothing you know

Cause she's a fake pipe, right? Um, I just, I love a little, just sort of engage optical scanners. I see it engaged anyway. Um, well, Matt, let's, I'm not sure where you're wanting to go with all this. Let's talk about the B plot then. Um, and I don't even have a summary for these different, just to be, but it's what happened on Voyager. They find a, uh, they find stuff and they go find a dead board cube and they bring a board back and they do something to them and it sort of reactivates and everybody freaks out and they have to go over to the board cube to do stuff. Yeah. So, I mean, my notes for, for the quote unquote B plot are very short. Cause.

I mean, I split things up in my notes because I don't know how it's going to pan out in the end already. But I do have actually two major points I want to bring to light here. First, I love that Janeway was gung ho to go find out everything they can about Borg tech. Like there's an abandoned cube. Yes. Hell yes. Let's check this out. See what's out there. And when are you ever going to get this opportunity again? Right now, we have discussed recently that the origins of the Borg are in the Delta Quadrant. Yes. Would Janeway have known that? I believe so. And the reason why I say that is.

because and people are going to crucify me for this, whatever. Way back in TNG season two, when we very first met the board, when Q threw us across the galaxy and we're like, oh, look, there's the board. He threw them to the Delta Quadrant, I believe. OK, I think that's what it is. So I think that as Starfleet, we've known for a while that they're coming from the Delta Quadrant. And that's why we know that. I believe. Don't kill me if I'm wrong, folks. But in my head, that's what that that's what that is. That would make sense. OK, because I guess I was a little bit more surprised other than, you know, at the end of the last episode, we don't even know who she and Chakotay told. I mean, right. We hear, you know, information spreads very quickly on the ship, but.

Otherwise, how many people actually know that they found a Borg? And it was just one single Borg. What does that mean? It doesn't mean anything. So it was a little bit surprising to me that she didn't make more of a deal out of it, I guess. She wasn't surprised that there was a Borg cube out here, but I guess maybe she had more knowledge of them being in the Delta Quadrant than I give her credit for.

Well, don't, I mean, don't forget they did see that Borg, you know, just last week, you know, when they found the Borg. But she didn't reference it at all though, right? It's true. Like she didn't say, oh, maybe that's where that came from or, you know, something more sophisticated than that. But in any case, I'm just glad that she took this opportunity. And like, that's the one thing I love is like, they never like lose sight of their mission. Like they're always, they're explorers at heart. Yeah. Always, always, always. And we see this most, I feel, with Janeway and Chakotay in various episodes, but actually in this episode, a lot, we see that from them.

Like, no, we got to keep exploring, got to keep learning. So that's cool. But then they brought a Borg on board the ship. Yes. And now, I mean, I got caught up in the rest of the episode and kind of forgot about it. I'm a little bit mad that that didn't have more of a consequence. Oh, bringing the dead Borg on the ship? Yeah. Dead Borg. Yeah. Because like, as soon as they said, hey, we brought one back.

just telling the captain not, they never asked her. Right. It's like, it's okay if we bring a board and got back onto your ship. I mean, generally be like, uh, what are you doing? Exactly. Like from what we know of the board, like experiment with them over on the cube. Sure. Right. But you don't bring them back onto your ship. I don't care if they, how did they look like, I think there should have been a bigger consequence there. And like, they just gave us comedy out of it. Right. I mean, even, even if it wasn't a consequence in January, it was just like, Hey, I appreciate why you did what you did. Uh, clear this with me next time. Sure. Like, even if it was just that simple, like just acknowledge, like you didn't ask permission, you just did, you know? Um, yeah, I could see that. I could see that. Yeah.

Because I like I was expecting something like I guess I was expecting the plot to head more in that direction. It's like, oh, now the board is alive on the ship. And they did kind of give us like start reactivating things and blah, blah, blah. But even that didn't really come to be in that in that way. Like there are other things that happened that caused more more damage than them reactivating that dead board on Voyager. Even if it was like a second board showed up or I don't know, just something I felt should have been there should have been something bigger that happened because of that. Like they reactivate the board and he calls all his board friends.

Yeah, I don't know. I don't know. Maybe they couldn't think of something, but I don't know. It felt like a dead end. Looking back on it now, I'm liking it less and less. But I did like the thought that because we've been talking about recently that we don't really have a big bad right now. Like we kind of thought maybe the board was going to be it, or at least I did. Right. Right. And then they give us this idea. It's like, why is there a dead board cube? Have they been defeated? Is there something more powerful than the board out there? And I liked that idea. I did like that idea that we're sitting here thinking, yeah, the board are the most powerful thing in the universe. And all of a sudden, oh, there's something there's a board killer out there.

Pardon me, Matt, while I look over here and take a drink. Because as far as this episode goes, they blamed it on like a natural phenomenon. Their ship got zapped and lost power. And yep. At least they think. Yep. I mean, they're in the middle of this expanse. Who knows? But I.

I mean, I don't know. I don't know. We should probably just move on and talk about the main plot. We should move on and talk about the main plot. The main plot, Chakotay, crash lands on a planet where he is captured slash rescued by some ex-Borg drones. And turns out they are still somewhat connected with some Borg parts, even though they've started to become normal again, sort of, kind of. And they form their own little collective cooperative thingamajig. And they want Chakotay's help in reactivating that dead Borg cube that Voyager just found hanging out there in space so they can control everybody because, you know, they're all fighting each other and they want to bring each other back and have their collective again, which seems like a bad idea.

Unless you've been in it and you think that it actually could be a really good idea because there are, it turns out, some benefits, at least we learn, from being in the collective. And Chakotay kind of agrees with them and then he doesn't until they force their way back into Chakotay's brain and make him go do it against his will, sort of. At least they tell us that they did it against his will. Maybe he really didn't. They're just taking the fall. Who knows, Matt? For sure. Who knows, Matt? That's the way I've always heard. I'm like, you really wanted to go help them. They're just taking the fall. Anyway, Matt, talk to us about the A-plot here, buddy. So we got into a battle right away and it was basically just so we could get our fairly standard sci-fi bit. It's like, yeah, jump into the middle of unknown territory.

get attacked by the bad guys, get saved by the good guys. Okay, let's go figure out what's going on now. Looking back on my notes again, I forgot that they mentioned right at the beginning when they're scanning the planet that they found 80,000 humanoids. That's a lot. Like even when they're talking later, they don't seem to imply that there's that many people down there. And like, I don't get that impression because she's like, yeah, we have, I think she says maybe a couple hundred or something in the collective. I mean, I guess she means on their side of things that are working together. But are you telling me the other 80,000, are they, are they all former Borg as well? That's the implication. Yes.

Yes. Because they all have that node or whatever. What I'm starting to piece together more is that it's not that there were only a few hundred survivors from the board cube. There were tens of thousands of survivors. It's just we don't all agree. And I mean, later we find out there are like 1,100 corpses on the cube. So they did lose a few. Right.

the vast majority of them survived. Yeah. That's kind of scary now, especially when we get to the very end and she's like, we are the new cooperative. Yeah. Yeah. That's not just a few hundred people anymore. Huh? So this, so this, this wasn't the board queen got defeated and.

they all deactivated and kind of went on their merry way. Like you, you shouldn't pick, pick up on that. Like, I don't know if that's a connection because that's what some people were thinking back then was because they just saw the board queen defeated in first contact. Right. Sure. And like, Oh, well she got defeated. So now every sort of freed all the drones or something like that. Like, no, no, no. They told you like there is, it's something we don't know what sort of spatial Eddie or whatever it is. Um,

you know, something did it to them. And it, this is really just the drones from this one cube or this, this one collection of cubes, right? That's what I, that's all I read into it. Yep. Yeah. I, I'm not trying to make a connection with the movie at all. Yeah. Yeah. And I just, I wanted to make sure you weren't thinking along those lines either. Cause we don't have a bunch of X drones hopping over the galaxy now or anything like that. Um, but yeah, yeah, that's, that's why now I just, I did look it up prior to the show. Cause I was curious, um, how many board drones are on a ship or a cube. Yeah. And it's anywhere between like,

5,000 and like 180,000 per cube. So if you're talking to 80,000 right here, you know, 1,000 are left back on the ship, 1,500 are left back on the ship, 80,000 get out. You know, that's a pretty populated cube there. Yeah, but I mean, you think about it, like those cubes are huge. 27 cubic kilometers.

That's ridiculous. But I mean, just compared to the size of the starships, Federation starships, which are huge in, you know, of themselves and hold, you know, thousands of people. Right. So the cubes are much bigger and the cubes aren't like, they don't have functional space. They're just walls and walls, hallways of bodies. Yeah. That's all the drones don't need space. No, they need their, their alcove to do whatever. Yeah. It's like their cubicle, but yeah, smaller. Right. So yeah, I mean, it totally makes sense. They can have that many people in there, but once again, man, looking back at my notes, how, how she words everything, Riley.

words, everything she says. It makes so much sense. Like, it just fits. And like, why didn't I see this sooner? Her ship was attacked. They were put in some form of stasis and then woke up in the Delta Quadrant. Huh. Okay. That's one way of putting it, I guess. Explaining becoming a Borg. Turns out your ship got attacked, you became a Borg, and then you didn't become a Borg. Yeah. But that's how you explain it to a stranger who you don't want to tell. Yeah, I'm a Borg or part Borg. Now, I will say, as soon as she started saying, like, she had three other humans from her crew, dozens of other Klingons, Cardassians, Romulans.

and a bunch of other species, I did start thinking along the lines of, okay, did the Borg do this? Right. And so like my mind at that point was very much, maybe we don't fully understand how the Borg work, even though we've kind of seen it with Picard. Like, I mean, I always feel Picard was an exception to how they treat people. But it's like, maybe they do kind of grab some people.

dump them on this planet and, you know, run experiments on them or let them live and see, just learn from their experience on that planet. You know, that's how they learn about everything they know or something. I don't know. I was trying to come up with some weird theory that they might be writing into this. Obviously, that's had nothing to do with anything. I was just wrong on that. But I was at this point trying to write the Borg into this story, but still way off base. Now, the next part of it makes a lot more sense after you explain the whole, you know, maybe communism was better type of thing.

Yeah, because the whole Chakotay is like, hey, you can come with us. It's like, no, no, you got it wrong. I actually want to stay here. Yeah. Like, OK, a little bit odd, but sure. Right. And I mean, I think they made it a little bit too obvious when before Chakotay knows that the border involved down here, like he offers to help them. It's like, no, no, like.

gives that such an abrupt like no no you don't you you need to stay here you need to stay here you can't come over here behind closed doors no looking behind the curtain like i feel like it made that more subtle and made us wonder a little bit longer maybe maybe they're running on time i don't know but it just it was one of those situations that felt like that was way too obvious sure so i like i guess that's just matt the director saying i would have liked to see that play out differently were you were you shocked when you realized that they were all on board like did you see it coming like did you pick up on it before they did the reveal like did they drop enough breadcrumbs or were you like oh my god old Borg. So even that, even when Chakotay walks into the room or out of the room, I guess it looked like that was more outside. Um, I just started typing my notes seriously. I'm like, okay, no one seems to be paying attention to him. It's kind of weird, which actually makes sense. If they're Borg, they never paid attention to anybody. Right. Um, there's a lot of work being done. They're building people. Are they androids? Are the Borg evolving? Did they get Edgar suits? They were conceived of as insects first. I mean, like.

That's where my mind went. I'm like, oh my, like the Borg are trying a new tactic. They're trying to fit in now. They're trying to look more human. Yeah. Matt, have you ever, you've never watched, I know you've never watched Stargate. Have you ever watched the new Battlestar Galactica? No. Matt, buddy, we got so much work to do. Okay. So in, in both of those shows, they both have, and it's, it's said from fairly on, that's not a big spoiler. They both have artificial life forms that have grown and learned how to perfectly mimic an organic human being.

Okay. And like, it's like, you look around and like, you don't know who's who, like anybody could be one of these things, you know? And sometimes they don't even know themselves. Like they don't even know. Like it's, that's, that's how good it is. So yeah. Edgar suits. It's one of my favorite quotables.

but seriously like that that's that's where my mind went i like i i still didn't fully have in my head what was going on that oh they were bored yeah it's like until it was actually explained to me i'm like oh yeah okay let's talk about some of the things we learned about the board here yeah they get so collective neural energy has healing properties that's special medical powers it's like yeah that's totally a plot device that they just contrived for this episode but that's absolutely But I mean, I like the way that they explained it. It's like, yeah, if you need blood, like you're not just going to get it from one donor. You're going to get it from thousands of donors. Yeah. Everybody donate one drop of blood. There you go. Got enough. Like it's like I have no problem with that happening. Sure. Sure. So healing power. So that was cool. The just the efficiency of being able to communicate. Sure. Right. They talk about that. And was it in this episode? Oh, I might be combining episodes now. What else did they say? Do you remember? Did they talk about the loneliness factor or the quietness factor? I don't remember those specific words. No. OK. Yeah. OK. I'll save that one. All right.

So yeah, it's pretty, pretty cool stuff, man. Like, and I, to me, like, I think that's where the most intriguing part of this episode goes because, because after this you get, you know, Chakotay obviously doesn't want to have anything to do with it. And then he kind of like, it's either die or do it. And so he's like, okay, fine. Yeah. And then everything's cool. Two seconds away from death. It's like, fine, you can do it. Right. It hasn't showed up yet. Right. And they have that, like that cool flipping sequence of, of images from several of the drones life and images that we've seen before. We have seen before some of them, some of them we've seen from previous episodes. Like I was thinking maybe some of the battle scenes maybe looks a little bit familiar, but like I did have that question. Like, am I supposed to recognize any of these?

some of them and then some of them like they shot new for riley's past as a kid like when they catch only the flowers and then her run to her grandfather because chakotay brought those things up later yeah yeah and they flipped through all that real fast so you know you had that and you know and then chakotay goes back and he's like you know it wasn't that bad like it's kind of neat for a moment like i just knew they residual energy where they're like touching each other and whatever you know but then okay okay so so two two things about that yeah um first of all i was a little bit worried when he let him go in and join with his mind okay This could be useful because Chakotay could end up learning a lot about the Borg from joining with them. But they could learn a lot about him and the Federation, which I don't know if that's a good idea. I mean, like I said, I don't know if he really had much choice at that point. It was life or death. But that's something that, you know, could play out more in the future for them. And then number two, the residual effects thing. Like they kind of faded out as Chakotay and Riley were.

getting close sure and so like I'm not entirely sure what happened or what they did but all I could think about the entire time was um can't everybody else who uh was just connected with you feel and hear just the same as Riley is right now so when you're like caressing each other's face like the nine other people in the room or however many there were like wait why is my face being rubbed right like what's going on here and so that's kind of why I question it's like wait how much did happen there how much how much of a connection is there like I don't think it's just between Riley and Chakotay it's kind of weird there kind of weird But it turns out they were still either they left something in or they were utilizing this. Whatever. I'm curious. What's your interpretation? In my head. Did they actually disconnect it? I don't think so. And then just use their power to like amplify it, as they said later, or you think they left it turned on? I think they left it turned on. I really. And she tried to explain it away as, oh, yeah, there's this residual effect. Yep. I think they absolutely left it turned on. I think they did that on purpose. It was there. Yep. Like if they realized they didn't need it, because I think they were trying to get Janeway.

to agree. I don't think they wanted to force you to do it. Yeah. But that was their like, just in case we have to, this is plan B. Um, and of course they didn't, so they had to activate them and make him go do it. And they're like, Oh, but now he's, he's disconnected. I'm like, yeah, how can we believe you? Is he, is he really? Cause I mean that, that I, I, I agree with you on that. Like, I don't think they actually disconnected it, um, as much as they said they would and all that type of stuff. Like, and I think that's just, that just plays into.

They are Borg. They're still Borg. No matter how good or individual they seem, they're still Borg. They're still going to force themselves upon you to get what they want. And that's what Janeway was worried about. And even Chakotay says the last line of the episode, right? I wonder how long their ideals will last in the face of that kind of power. Like now that they're able to do that basically to anyone again, it's like they say they're going to be good about it, but absolute power corrupts. Absolutely, man. We just saw them force it on him. And Chakotay even kind of admits that it's like, yeah, we just saw them use it.

forcefully yeah i mean last week we were talking about you know the mind meld being forced on people and now the borg forcing their way into people's minds their own mind meld type of thing yeah yeah yeah yeah you take somebody who's in a vulnerable situation like chakotay was you graft them in altruistically but still you graft them in and then you take advantage of it when you have to you can't respect their individuality and their wishes and this is something that star trek does really good you have to you you can't do that like you have to respect an individual's wishes right um and this is where i still go back to say that janeway was 100 completely wrong about tuvix she had the man sitting right there telling her no he didn't want it but anyway yeah i digress um This was actually the thing I wanted to talk about, Matt, because it kind of leads into the Star Trek message. And I'm not really sure that this is a message as much as Brent just has a personal experience that kind of feels Borgish like this. And I've never really talked about this time before. Maybe you and I've talked about it a little bit. I don't know how much of this you know about me. So I was a part of an organization for probably about 10 years. It was pretty nifty. It was not a cult. OK, however, it was very oriented around a single person. And the rest of us who were in this large organization, the rest of us really existed to serve and further.

that person's vision for the organization. Right. And in many ways, like we became this monolith that was all driving towards this one vision of, you know, we had a leader who was pointing us towards like, this is where we're going to go. And I got to tell you, it was awesome. I loved being a part of this group. We all knew why we were working. We knew what we were working for. We knew who we were working for. We all had skills and talents, talents that we were able to put to use in service of that mission. And most of us, myself included, got to discover and learn brand new talents and skills that we never would have thought of before. In fact, I would tell you this podcast would not exist. I would not be podcasting if it had not been for my time there and learning what I learned.

there and getting things drawn out in me fair enough and we got to do some really really cool stuff like we got to put our hands to do just like cool stuff man like it was a lot of fun and we genuinely loved each other we genuinely loved being together as people we fiercely protected like all were welcome but for those who were in we fiercely protected each other you know um And and I know it sounds very cultish and it wasn't at all. But I can see why people might like on the outside look at it and be like, oh, that seems weird. That seems even you guys listening. That seems a little cultish. I see where people draw that. I will say right now, from what you've described so far, that's probably the assumption I would. And you probably could find some textbook definition like, oh, here's where it lines up to all these textbooks. You probably could do that. But it wasn't a cult. OK, now also, I want to say that in the beginning, this whole thing was very altruistic. It was very noble and it was very honorable.

As time went on, though, power did its thing and power corrupted to the people that were in charge. And it did its thing. And things internally for a few years really began to deteriorate. mostly we couldn't even see it. You're like, you knew something was off. Something wasn't right, but you couldn't figure out what it was because we were, we, again, we were doing some, a lot of cool stuff that we really loved and we really loved being together and we really loved each other. And that I've masked a lot of that, you know, and as a result, some unhealthy things really crept in that really took us, I think to the brink of cultism. And eventually that corruption was exposed and we all sort of looked up and went, what are we doing? This is dumb. And why are we looking? You know what I mean? Like it was, it was just a lot of that. And so I've got to tell you, there was a real sense of relief when that all kind of got exposed, but there was also a real and true grief over what we knew we were losing because of this.

Like I said, we loved being together and we really got to do some fun things. I can tell you working in that kind of a system is a dream and it's easy, but that's that I can also. really 100% understand the Borg's desire to not give up the benefits that actually come from being in that system, even though overall it's unhealthy and it's not a good thing to be in. There's still some bit like you can see that. And I've never thought about this in terms of the communist states because growing up here in America, it's all you can't be communist. The communist, you can't do it. Like, that's just the way we grew up here, right? And oh, you can't do that. That's bad. And that's evil. And that just leads to nowhere. And maybe it does. You know, I don't know of any communist state that has survived and prospered long term. And there's lots of other things to say that. But I do know there's a big wave even now here in America where people kind of want to go that direction. They want to move towards more of that socialist, communist guy.

idea because it seems better than even what we've experienced here. But regardless, I can understand the nostalgia and as gross as it may seem to those who are on the outside, in our case, those from over here, looking at the Soviet Union, those who come out there really, I think, could be a great sense of loss. Like I could see what the Borg, ex-Borg in this situation, like, you know, we used to be able to move with such efficiency and heal and just all these benefits. And we didn't have the fighting and we didn't have the wars because we were all moving towards one goal. There's a real draw to wanting to find the balance between not living in bondage, not living with your brain turned off and being able to still have all of these benefits and utilize them.

without having somebody go all board queen on you, you know? Um, and I, I don't know how that works. I don't know where that goes, but I, I definitely can understand like that idea of like, man, when we were there, there were so many good things and it's really easy to look back on the good stuff and forget about the hard stuff. It's also equally to always look back on that and only think about the negative stuff. You know what I mean? Like there's a lot of people that really got hurt and they look back on it and it's only negative. It colors the whole experience. And you're like, yeah, but kind of like we were talking earlier again, you know, we met each other through this and you know what we got to do through this. Like there is some good that comes out of this. And it's just weird to think about even with a board experience, even for these drones, that as bad as it can be, that there is,

some sort of goodness in the middle of that, which is weird. Again, I don't know that this is a message as much as Brent's just having a relational moment he's never thought of before. Fair enough. That's all. That's all I have to say about that. Matt, you have anything else about this episode you want to talk about? I don't think so. Okay, let me ask you this. Now I want you to prognosticate. We've had the Necrot expanse. You had blood fever. You've had this episode. We're coming towards the end of season three. Any ideas on...

What, how do you think Voyager is going to handle this? Like, is this a one-off episode? Are we, what do you think they're doing? What are, are they laying the groundwork for something like the Dominion or, you know, where do you think they're going with all of this idea? Let me ask you this. What do you want them to do with it? Let's just, let's just say that because I know there's no way you know what they're going to do. I know what they're going to do. What do you want them to do? I mean, honestly, at this point, I was just gonna say, I don't think they necessarily have any idea where they're going with it just yet.

No, because they only they only created that. Obviously, they wrote that little board piece into the end of the last episode to prep for this episode. Like they knew where they were going. This episode was created for sweeps week. Yeah. They wanted to do a board episode. Yeah. But having just sort of reactivated the board and created a new collective or new cooperative or whatever they call it, you have to imagine we see them at least once more. I mean.

Do I think they are going to be the big bad or the big bad of the series? Like, I currently still believe, like, the Dominion is, like, going to be the end of DS9, right? I don't see that happening as much. Like, I feel they were, even though, I mean, you keep telling me there weren't actually that many Borg episodes back in TNG, but I feel with, like, Locutus, like, how can you beat that? Right. Like, you don't, like, I don't think Janeway's going to become a Borg. I mean, people would just call him out for...

repeating it and i don't i don't see them taking an old villain bringing them back even even if it is kind of in a new vein and saying hey yeah this is our big bad no like i i don't think this is the last we see the borg in voyager okay i think we see more of them but i don't think they're the big bad that that we're building towards whatever that may be and i don't even think that like i think they're gonna disappear for a while okay i don't think we're gonna see them for a while Okay. I will neither confirm nor deny any of that. I didn't expect it, but I would love it. Um, just, just a couple of notes. Um, one, the board costumes for this episode. Absolutely. They went and pulled off the rack from the movie. Right. Um, Robert Duncan McNeil found that his biggest challenge in doing this episode as a board episode was the fact they didn't really have board in it. Like they only actually had board for like what he said was two and a half pages, which if you figure like an episode, like 80 pages, it's not a lot of pages, you know? I, I mean, yeah, they had the cube and they were on it, but as for actual like board, like people drones, it was all the people like they had like two, two pictures of corpses. Yeah. Yeah. But that was about it. Yeah.

Yeah. And so now between first contact with the idea and the introduction of the idea of a queen and this with the fact that there can be life outside of being assimilated, which we already knew from Locutus. But, you know, here's another look at what happens. You know, Picard was only Locutus for a couple of days, maybe a couple of weeks. This is for, you know, these people were there for years, you know. So they really are. They're kind of the idea that their conscience, their conscience while being Borg, you know.

they're kind of rewriting this, this idea of the board now. So yeah. Um, with this episode, they say that they, this is the episode where they began to really embrace CGI and their visual effects department. Okay. And like, I like, apparently they did like some wireframe shot of Voyager going out instead of using one of the models and a lot of the board stuff. Uh, they said that 90% of their, yeah, go ahead. That's what I'm saying. If they want to mess around with CGI, make the doctor disappear. There you go. They said 90% of their visual effects in this episode were CGI and the rest was a.

mix of practical and reused footage that already existed. So, uh, anyway, just three, three little notes there. All right, Matt. Well, I guess we'll bring it down. I'll ask you the question you've already told us, but we'll officially do it. Did you like this episode? Would you want to watch it again? Yes. And do you understand why it's part of a run? Say not yet. Not yet. Okay. There you go. I mean, you will one day, my friend. You will one day. Yeah. Yes. There's gotta be, I mean.

with just how, how big of a change this is for the Borg. I feel it's hard not to, to, to view it, even if we don't really see the board again. Yeah. But like I said, I think we're in. Remember, remember there, you know, Star Trek Voyager is happening in the same Star Trek universe that all the other Star Treks are. They're very aware of that. At the same time, they're trying, they're striving to not just redo and rehash what was done in the next generation, Deep Space Nine, which is why they wanted to, you know, they struggled with bringing Q over.

And they struggled with the Ferengi and they like, well, they keep tying these things back in. They're still like the, the, the Voyager people are being very smart about it. I think, uh, same thing with the board thing. They, they wanted the board again, but they had to figure out a new way to do it. Um, what was it? Oh, put the pond fart just last week. We had that conversation. We can't just do another Vulcan pond fart. You got to find something new. So the, I think the Voyager people are doing a pretty good job on that. All right, Matt, well, let's talk about next week real quick. Would you like to know what we're doing next week? That would be useful. All right, well, we are going to jump back over to deep space nine and check in with them over there. We're going to pick up a true double episode this time, Matt. So this is a double episode, but they have two very different names. There's no part one in part two. Those names are the first episode is in purgatory shadow. And the second episode is by Inferno's light. And this is just a mid season cliffhanger, uh, probably actually is what I would assume it is. It was a sweeps week type thing.

But definitely something we need to watch. So this is a proper two-part. We'll be covering both of those episodes in next week. And I don't have any extra viewings for you here this week on Voyager to handle. So we'll have to pick from those extra viewings here later. Folks out there, that's going to do it for us this week on Beam Me Up, a Star Trek podcast. What did you guys think of Unity? Do you like this new direction of the Borg? Do you like where this is headed in Voyager? Is it headed anywhere? I don't know. Email us, beammeuppod at gmail.com. Matt, where can they find you out there on the internet?

You can find me personally on both Instagram and Twitter at as a matter of Matt. And if you guys would like to get in touch with me, you can find me at Brent Allen live across all the social medias. I'd love to connect with you there as well, too. Until next time, folks, live long and prosper.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Beam Me Up: A Star Trek Podcast?

This episode is 55 minutes long.

When was this Beam Me Up: A Star Trek Podcast episode published?

This episode was published on November 16, 2021.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Beam Me Up: A Star Trek Podcast episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.