Skip to content
Thanksgiving 82 episode artwork

Nov 29, 2024 5 min

Thanksgiving 82

from Quick and Dirty History Hosted by Patrick Brooks

Who decided a bird gets presidential pass? Is it justice, or just plain fowl play? This turkey has better legal representation than you do! This is what Thanksgiving during the Civil War sounds like.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Thanksgiving 82

0:00 5:26
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

We have a liftoff. You're listening to Quick and Dirty History, the show about American history on the go. This episode of Quick and Dirty History is brought to you by Awkward Holiday Dinners. If you've ever had a heated debate about politics over turkey and taters, just remember, Abraham Lincoln declared Thanksgiving a national holiday during a huge war with half of the country trying to leave the Union. Talk about table tension. So, let's dig in. Pun very much intended. Thanksgiving is the perfect time to reflect on gratitude and history. But let's be real, it's not all gravy, baby. Some parts are mashed with a whole lot of awkward stuffing. First, some history on Thanksgiving.

The story you probably learned in school goes something like this. Pilgrims and Native Americans held hands and sang kumbaya over turkey and cranberry sauce in 1621, kicking off a tradition of gratitude and feasting. Nice story, right? Too bad it's mostly a feel-good myth. What actually happened was a little bit more complicated. The Wampanoag helped the struggling pilgrims survive their first brutal winter, but the so-called first Thanksgiving was likely a three-day harvest festival, not an annual tradition at all. And let's not forget, within a generation, many Native Americans who had been the pilgrims' allies were dead or displaced, thanks to European colonization and a shit-ton of disease.

Fast forward a couple centuries, and Thanksgiving was still just a loose concept, celebrated at different times in different places. It wasn't until the mid-1800s that a woman named Sarah Josepha Hale, writer, editor, and author of Mary Had a Little Lamb, started lobbying for a national Thanksgiving holiday. She wanted the country to have a unified day of gratitude, and partly because she thought it might help cool the simmering tensions between the North and the South. But it didn't. So enter Abraham Lincoln. In 1863, the United States was a hot mess. Democrats are slave-holding racists, the Civil War is raging on, the country's fractured, and Abraham Lincoln is under immense pressure to hold the Union together.

Amid all this chaos, he got a letter from Sarah Hale, who had been pushing presidents for years to make Thanksgiving a thing. Lincoln, desperate for a way to foster unity and morale, decided to go for it. He issued a proclamation declaring the last Thursday of November a national day of Thanksgiving. Lincoln even spared a turkey intended for dinner at the behest of his son Tad, who had grown fond of the bird as a pet. This wasn't just about turkey and pie. It was a very calculated move. Lincoln's proclamation wasn't just a feel-good gesture. It was full of Civil War-era subtext. He called for Americans to give thanks for blessings like fruitful fields and healthful skies.

even while acknowledging the lamentable civil strife, tearing the nation apart. Lincoln wanted people to focus on what they could still be grateful for, even during a literal war. But there's an elephant, or maybe a turkey, in the room that we need to talk about. Thanksgiving also symbolizes a history that's been sanitized to make colonization seem less brutal than it was. By the time Lincoln made Thanksgiving a national holiday, the U.S. government had spent decades enacting policies that displaced, marginalized, and outright destroyed Native American communities. Manifest Destiny. The belief that white settlers were destined to take over the continent.

had driven westward expansion, forcing Native Americans off their lands and into treaties that were frequently broken. You can go back a few episodes to learn more about that. Lincoln himself, while a progressive figure in many ways, wasn't immune to the contradictions of his time. During his presidency, he approved policies like the Homestead Act, which encouraged settlers to claim land that had been occupied by Native Americans for centuries or longer. Meanwhile, Native communities were suffering from violence, starvation, and forced removals. So, why does Thanksgiving matter today? For one, it really is a time to reflect. Not just on gratitude, but on history.

Thanksgiving can remind us to acknowledge the resilience of Native American cultures, despite centuries of oppression, oppression that's still going on today. It's also a chance to rethink what it means to come together as a community, especially in a time when polarization is still very much a thing. Lincoln's Thanksgiving proclamation wasn't perfect, and it came from a deeply imperfect time. But the idea of setting aside a day to be thankful, to pause, to appreciate what we have, and to connect with each other still resonates. So whether you're feasting with friends, awkwardly dodging political debates with relatives, or just saying, fuck it, work sucks, and I'm going to enjoy a long weekend, take a moment to think about the complicated, messy.

and sometimes inspiring history behind this uniquely American tradition. And maybe pass the mashed potatoes and brandy while you're at it.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Quick and Dirty History?

This episode is 5 minutes long.

When was this Quick and Dirty History episode published?

This episode was published on November 29, 2024.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Quick and Dirty History episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.