The Hanging Tree & The Lady in Blue: Hauntings at Captain Tony’s Saloon

Send us Fan MailIn this episode of the You Two Scare Me Podcast, Andi and Feliz take you inside one of the most legendary and haunted bars in Key West: Captain Tony’s Saloon. Located at 428 Greene Street, this building has a history as colorful and dark as the island itself. From its days as the city’s ice house and morgue to its infamous reputation as the site of the Hanging Tree, we explore why this bar is a hotspot for paranormal activity.We dive into the chilling legend of the Lady in Blue, a restless spirit said to haunt the ladies' room, and the mysterious skeletal remains discovered beneath the floorboards. Plus, we discuss the two gravestones found inside the bar—Reba Sawyer and Elvira Drew—and the "bad juju" that still lingers around the tree that grows right through the roof.Grab a drink, pull up a stool, and join us as we toast to the ghosts of Captain Tony’s.Do you have a spooky story that you’d like included in the You Two Scare Me Podcast? Check out our website at: www.youtwoscaremepodcast.com and go fill out the “Somebody Told Me…” form. We might include your tale in an upcoming episode!The You Two Scare Me Podcast is hosted by Andi Zyvith and Feliz AndrewsOriginal Music by Stefan TatkaDisclaimer: The You Two Scare Me Podcast is intended for entertainment purposes only. The views, opinions, and discussions presented in this show are those of the hosts and guests, and should not be considered factual statements, professional advice, or verified accounts. Our content often includes folklore, paranormal stories, urban legends, and speculative material, which may not be historically accurate. Listener discretion is advised, as some episodes may include sensitive themes such as death, violence, or trauma. All stories are shared with respect for the cultures and communities connected to them, and no harm or offense is intended.Support the showVisit our Socials!Instagram:  @youtwoscareme_podcastFacebook:  You Two Scare Me PodcastTikTok: @youtwoscaremepodcast