EPISODE · Apr 23, 2026 · 56 MIN
The Sheriff Who Built His Own Gallows
from Unlocking the Unknown · host Atlas Gray
Henry Plummer was the elected sheriff of Bannack who was summarily hanged in 1864 by the Montana Vigilantes on unproven charges of secretly leading a murderous "road agent" gang known as the "Innocents".While early accounts portrayed the vigilantes as heroic civilizers, modern historians have challenged this narrative, suggesting the executions were potentially motivated by Republican elites seeking to eliminate a charismatic Democratic political rival.The definitive truth of Plummer's guilt remains irretrievable, yet his story persists through ghost stories and historical reenactments at Bannack State Park, where the jail he commissioned still stands today.Would you like me to create a tailored report summarizing the historiographical shift in how the Montana Vigilantes have been portrayed over the last 150 years?
Embed this episode
Ready to play
The Sheriff Who Built His Own Gallows
No transcript for this episode yet
Similar Episodes
No similar episodes found.
Similar Podcasts
No similar podcasts found.