The Witch of Pungo - Lunatic Soup

What this episode covers

The Witch of Pungo takes center stage in this week’s Lunatic Soup as we dive into the life, legend, and lingering mystery of Grace Sherwood—the Virginia woman accused of bewitching neighbors, ruining crops, shapeshifting into a cat, and conjuring storms before being subjected to a trial by ducking in 1706. We explore who Sherwood really was beneath the folklore, how a tangle of superstition and community grudges fueled her reputation, and why her story still echoes through the marshes of Pungo today, where locals claim her spirit hasn’t entirely settled.

Share this episode

Similar Episodes

House of the Dragon Season 3 Review (Episode 2)

Jun 29, 2026 ·26m

Wrestling Legal Talk LIVE w_ Jeff Lippman _ Janel Grant vs Vince McMahon Update_ AEW Lawsuits (1)

Jun 27, 2026 ·92m

Smackdown Soup Du Jour Episode 19_ T_was the night before Night of Champions 2026

Jun 27, 2026 ·111m

A Special Donversation with TBW's Hottest Rising Star, the IT Factor, Jay Kolsch

Jun 27, 2026 ·101m

The Evolve Effect EP 66_WWE Evolve Succession 3 Review

Jun 26, 2026 ·61m

Chapter 19 Part 1 - Gene Wolfe's Return to the Whorl

Jun 26, 2026 ·60m

Similar Podcasts

The Lunatic Fringe Podcast The Pilot Step into the void with The Pilot from Blue Skies Magazine as he talks to some of the worlds premiere as well as lesser known extreme air sports athletes to get their take on living life to the fullest, their paths along the “Lunatic Fringe” and how they fit into the mainstream world while living life on the dark side. Explicit The Nerd Soup Podcast Nerd Soup It's good soup. New episodes every week! Explicit Girl on Guy with Aisha Tyler Aisha Tyler join aisha tyler (archer, friends, talk soup) and her guests as they rant about stuff guys love: video games, action movies, comic books, sex, drinking, bar fights, and blowing sh*t up. plus the weekly installments of self-inflicted wounds and 'the apologia'. girl on guy: stuff. guys. love. Explicit Horror Soup: A Horror Movie Podcast Caleb Soup Do expect: discussions about strange and amusing occurrences in horror moviesDo not expect: intelligent reviewsWe're hardly ever right… unless we’re talking Amityville. We know everything about every Amityville ever made and we've never been wrong about anything that has even the slightest association to the house, story, or lore of Amityville. Explicit

Frequently Asked Questions

How long is this episode of Lunatic Soup?

This episode is 1 hour and 7 minutes long.

When was this Lunatic Soup episode published?

This episode was published on May 21, 2026.

What is this episode about?

The Witch of Pungo takes center stage in this week’s Lunatic Soup as we dive into the life, legend, and lingering mystery of Grace Sherwood—the Virginia woman accused of bewitching neighbors, ruining crops, shapeshifting into a cat, and conjuring...

Can I download this Lunatic Soup episode?

Yes, you can download this episode by clicking the download button on the episode player, or subscribe to the podcast in your preferred podcast app for automatic downloads.