Train Dreams (2025)

In this episode of Cinema Callback, Andy and Michael take a deep dive into Clint Bentley’s Netflix film Train Dreams (2025), starring Joel Edgerton. Through the show’s signature voice note conversation format, the hosts exchange contrasting reactions to a beautifully photographed, deeply melancholic story about working-class life, grief, isolation, and the passage of time. Set against the changing American frontier of the early twentieth century, Train Dreams follows Robert Grainier, a railroad worker and logger whose life unfolds through moments of love, tragedy, and quiet reflection. Andy and Michael explore the film’s portrayal of physically demanding labour, male loneliness, psychological trauma, and the devastating consequences of loss, while considering how its story reflects humanity’s evolving relationship with nature, industry, and time itself. The conversation also explores the film’s place within a particular tradition of spiritual and philosophical art-house cinema, drawing comparisons with Terrence Malick’s The Tree of Life and David Lowery’s A Ghost Story. Does Train Dreams achieve the same sense of emotional transcendence through its meditative imagery and deliberately sparse storytelling, or does its restrained approach leave the audience feeling slightly detached? The hosts debate whether a film in which seemingly very little happens can nevertheless communicate something profound about the human experience. Andy and Michael also find themselves questioning the boundaries of the Western genre. With its historical frontier setting, rugged landscapes, isolated workers, and changing American identity, does Train Dreams qualify as a genuine Western, or is it better understood as a character drama with distinctly Western DNA? The discussion opens up a broader examination of what actually defines a genre beyond its familiar imagery and setting. Across their voice note exchanges, the hosts share contrasting family reactions to the film, including the wonderfully contradictory assessment that it is "brilliant despite nothing happening." There is also room for the usual Cinema Callback tangents, including a brief discussion of the genre surprises in Sinners and the different expectations audiences bring to films that challenge conventional storytelling. As ever, the conversation extends beyond cinema itself, with personal updates covering an engagement, the search for wedding rings, the realities of parenthood on the go, and holiday travels back to Ireland. These moments of everyday life provide a fitting contrast to a film so deeply concerned with the passage of time and the experiences that ultimately define us. Join Andy and Michael for a deep dive into grief, PTSD, the American frontier, Terrence Malick, the meaning of the Western, and whether a film in which almost nothing happens can somehow say everything about being alive. Enjoying the conversation? Support Cinema Callback on Patreon for bonus content, exclusive extras, and to help us continue making in depth film discussions through our unique voice note format. Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/CinemaCallback